Battle of Bannockburn

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Coordinates: 56°05′31″N 3°54′54″W / 56.092°N 3.915°W / 56.092; -3.915

Battle of Bannockburn
Part of the First War of Scottish Independence
Battle of Bannockburn.jpg
This depiction from the Scotichronicon (c.1440) is the earliest known image of the battle. King Robert wielding an axe and Edward II fleeing toward Stirling feature prominently, conflating incidents from the two days of battle.
Corpus Christi College, Cambridge.
Date23–24 June 1314
Location
Result Decisive Scottish victory
Belligerents
Royal Arms of the Kingdom of Scotland.svg Kingdom of Scotland Royal Arms of England.svg Kingdom of England
Commanders and leaders
Strength
5,000[1]–8,000 men[2] 20,000[3]–25,000 men[4]
Casualties and losses
Light[5][6]
  • 700 knights and men-at-arms killed[7][8]
  • 500 knights and men-at-arms captured[9][10]
  • 4,000[11]–11,000 infantry killed[12]
Designated21 March 2011
Reference no.BTL4

The Battle of Bannockburn (Scottish Gaelic: Blàr Allt nam Bànag or Blàr Allt a' Bhonnaich) on 23 and 24 June 1314 was a victory of the army of King of Scots Robert the Bruce over the army of King Edward II of England in the First War of Scottish Independence. Although it did not bring an end to the war, as victory would only be secured 14 years later, Bannockburn is still a landmark in Scottish history.[13]

King Edward II invaded Scotland after Bruce demanded in 1313 that all supporters still loyal to ousted Scottish king John Balliol acknowledge Bruce as their king or lose their lands. Stirling Castle, a Scots royal fortress occupied by the English, was under siege by the Scottish army. King Edward assembled a formidable force of soldiers from England, Ireland and Wales to relieve it – the largest army ever to invade Scotland. This attempt failed when he found his path blocked by a smaller army commanded by Bruce.[13]

The Scottish army was divided into three divisions of schiltrons commanded by Bruce, his brother Edward Bruce, and his nephew, the Earl of Moray. After Robert Bruce killed Sir Henry de Bohun on the first day of the battle, the English were forced to withdraw for the night. Sir Alexander Seton, a Scottish noble serving in Edward's army, defected to the Scottish side and informed them of the English camp's position and low morale. Robert Bruce decided to launch a full-scale attack on the English forces and to use his schiltrons again as offensive units, a strategy his predecessor William Wallace had not used. The English army was defeated in a pitched battle which resulted in the deaths of several prominent commanders, including the Earl of Gloucester and Sir Robert Clifford, and capture of many others.[13]

The victory against the English at Bannockburn is the most celebrated in Scottish history, and for centuries the battle has been commemorated in verse and art. The National Trust for Scotland operates the Bannockburn Visitor Centre (previously known as the Bannockburn Heritage Centre). Though the exact location for the battle is uncertain, a modern monument was erected in a field above a possible site of the battlefield, where the warring parties are believed to have camped, alongside a statue of Robert Bruce designed by Pilkington Jackson. The monument, along with the associated visitor centre, is one of the most popular tourist attractions in the area.

Background[edit]

The Wars of Scottish Independence between England and Scotland began in 1296 and initially the English were successful under the command of Edward I, having won victories at the Battle of Dunbar (1296) and at the Capture of Berwick (1296).[14] The removal of John Balliol from the Scottish throne also contributed to the English success.[14] The Scots had been victorious in defeating the English at the Battle of Stirling Bridge in 1297. This was countered, however, by Edward I's victory at the Battle of Falkirk (1298).[14] By 1304, Scotland had been conquered, but in 1306 Robert the Bruce seized the Scottish throne and the war was reopened.[14]

After the death of Edward I, his son Edward II of England came to the throne in 1307 but was incapable of providing the determined leadership his father had shown, and the English position soon became more difficult.[14]

In 1313, Bruce demanded the allegiance of all remaining Balliol supporters, under threat of losing their lands, as well as the surrender of the English garrison at Stirling Castle.[13] The castle was one of the most important castles held by the English, as it commanded the route north into the Scottish Highlands.[14] It was besieged in 1314 by Robert the Bruce's younger brother, Edward Bruce, and an agreement was made that if the castle was not relieved by mid-summer it would be surrendered to the Scots.[14]

The English could not ignore this challenge and prepared and equipped a substantial campaign. It is known that Edward II requested 2,000 heavily armoured cavalry and 25,000 infantry, many of whom were likely armed with longbows, from England, Wales and Ireland; it is estimated no more than half the infantry actually arrived, but the English army was still by far the largest ever to invade Scotland. The Scottish army probably numbered around 6,000 men,[13] including no more than 500 mounted forces.[14] Unlike the English, the Scottish cavalry was probably unequipped for charging enemy lines and suitable only for skirmishing and reconnaissance. The Scottish infantry was likely armed with axes, swords and pikes, and included only a few bowmen.[14]

The precise numerical advantage of the English forces relative to the Scottish forces is unknown, but modern researchers estimate that the Scottish faced English forces one-and-a-half to two or three times their size.[15]

Prelude[edit]

Holkham Bible, c. 1330: Depiction of a biblical battle, giving an impression of how soldiers were equipped at Bannockburn.

Edward II and his advisors were aware of the places the Scots were likely to challenge them and sent orders for their troops to prepare for an enemy established in boggy ground near the River Forth, near Stirling.[14] The English appear to have advanced in four divisions, known as 'schiltrons', which were strong defensive squares of men with pikes.[16][14] Thomas Randolph, 1st Earl of Moray, commanded the Scottish vanguard, which was stationed about a mile south of Stirling, near the church of St. Ninian, while the king commanded the rearguard at the entrance to the New Park. His brother Edward led the third division. The fourth division was nominally under the youthful Walter the Steward, but actually under the command of Sir James Douglas.[17] The Scottish archers used yew-stave longbows and, though these were not weaker than or inferior to English longbows, there were fewer Scottish archers,[18] possibly only 500. These archers played little part in the battle.[19] There is first-hand evidence in a poem, written just after the battle by the captured Carmelite friar Robert Baston, that one or both sides employed slingers and crossbowmen.[20]

Battle[edit]

Location of the battlefield[edit]

The exact site of the Battle of Bannockburn has been debated for many years,[21] but most modern historians agree that the traditional site,[22] where a visitor centre and statue have been erected, is not correct.[23]

A large number of alternative locations have been considered but modern researchers believe only two merit serious consideration:[24]

  • An area of peaty ground outside the village of Balquhiderock known as the Dryfield, about .75 miles (1.21 km) east of the traditional site.[25]
  • The Carse of Balquhiderock, about 1.5 miles (2.4 km) northeast of the traditional site. This location is accepted by the National Trust as the most likely site.[26]

First day of battle[edit]

An interpretation of the battle of Bannockburn—first day

Most medieval battles were short-lived, lasting only a few hours, so the Battle of Bannockburn is unusual in that it lasted two days.[14] On 23 June 1314 two English cavalry formations advanced. The first was commanded by the Earl of Gloucester and by the Earl of Hereford.[14]

They encountered a body of Scots led by Robert the Bruce.[14] Bruce and Henry de Bohun, nephew of the Earl of Hereford, faced off in what became a celebrated instance of single combat.[14] Bohun charged at Bruce and, when the two passed side by side, Bruce split Bohun's head with his axe.[14][27] The Scots then rushed the English forces under Gloucester's and Hereford's command, who retreated, struggling back over the Bannockburn.[28]

The second English cavalry force was commanded by Robert Clifford and Henry de Beaumont. Their forces included Sir Thomas de Grey of Heaton, father of the chronicler Thomas Grey. The younger Grey described the battle:

Robert Lord de Clifford and Henry de Beaumont, with three hundred men-at-arms, made a circuit upon the other side of the wood towards the castle, keeping the open ground. Thomas Randolph, 1st Earl of Moray, Robert de Brus's nephew, who was leader of the Scottish advanced guard, hearing that his uncle had repulsed the advanced guard of the English on the other side of the wood, thought that he must have his share, and issuing from the wood with his division marched across the open ground towards the two afore-named lords.

Sir Henry de Beaumont called to his men: "Let us wait a little; let them come on; give them room".

"Sir," said Sir Thomas Gray, "I doubt that whatever you give them now, they will have all too soon".

"Very well" exclaimed the said Henry, "if you are afraid, be off".

"Sir," answered the said Thomas, "it is not from fear that I shall fly this day."

So saying, he spurred in between Beaumont and Sir William Deyncourt and charged into the thick of the enemy. William was killed, Thomas was taken prisoner, his horse being killed on the pikes, and he himself carried off with the Scots on foot when they marched off, having utterly routed the squadron of the said two lords. Some of the English fled to the castle, others to the king's army, which having already left the road through the wood had debouched upon a plain near the water of Forth beyond Bannockburn, an evil, deep, wet marsh, where the said English army unharnessed and remained all night, having sadly lost confidence and being too much disaffected by the events of the day.

— Sir Thomas Grey, Scalacronica, translated by Herbert Maxwell[29]


Second day of battle[edit]

An interpretation of the battle of Bannockburn—second day.

During the night the English forces crossed the stream known as the Bannockburn, establishing their position on the plain beyond it.[14] A Scottish knight, Alexander Seton, who was fighting in the service of Edward II of England, deserted the English camp and told Bruce that English morale was low and encouraged him to attack.[14]

In the morning the Scots advanced from New Park.[14] Not long after daybreak, Edward was surprised to see the Scottish pikemen emerge from the cover of the woods and advance towards his position. As Bruce's army drew nearer, they paused and knelt in prayer. Edward reportedly said in surprise, "They pray for mercy!" "For mercy, yes," one of his attendants replied, "but from God, not you. These men will conquer or die."[30]

The Earl of Gloucester had argued with the Earl of Hereford over who should lead the vanguard into battle. He had also tried to persuade the king that the battle should be postponed. This led the king to accuse him of cowardice. Goaded by the accusation, the Earl of Gloucester advanced to meet the Scots.[14] Few accompanied Gloucester and, when he reached the Scottish lines, he was quickly surrounded and killed.[14]

The English were gradually pushed back and ground down by the Scots' schiltrons.[14] The English longbowmen attempted to support the advance of the knights but were ordered to stop shooting, as they were causing casualties among their own. The English then attempted to deploy their English and Welsh longbowmen to flank the advancing Scots, but they were dispersed by 500 Scottish cavalry under the Marischal Sir Robert Keith.[31] (Although the Scottish cavalry is sometimes described as light cavalry, this appears to be a misinterpretation of Barbour's statement that these were men-at-arms on lighter horses than those of their English counterparts.[32])

The English cavalry was hemmed in against the Bannockburn, making it difficult for them to manoeuvre.[14] Unable to hold their formations, they broke rank.[14] It soon became clear to Aymer de Valence and Giles d'Argentan (reputedly the third-best knight in Europe) that the English had lost the battle and Edward II needed at all costs to be led to safety. Seizing the reins of the king's horse, they dragged him away, closely followed by 500 knights of the royal bodyguard.[33]

Once they were clear of the battle d'Argentan turned to the king and said: "Sire, your protection was committed to me, but since you are safely on your way, I will bid you farewell for never yet have I fled from a battle, nor will I now." He turned his horse to charge back into the ranks of Scottish, where he was overborne and slain.[34]

English retreat[edit]

Edward fled with his personal bodyguard and panic spread among the remaining troops, turning their defeat into a rout. King Edward with about 500 men first fled for Stirling Castle where Sir Philip de Moubray, commander of the castle, turned him away as the castle would shortly be surrendered to the Scots.[35] Then, pursued by James Douglas and a small troop of horsemen, Edward fled to Dunbar Castle, from which he took a ship to Berwick. From the carnage of Bannockburn, the rest of the army tried to escape to the safety of the English border, 90 miles (140 km) south. Many were killed by the pursuing Scottish army or by the inhabitants of the countryside they passed through.

Historian Peter Reese wrote that "only one sizeable group of men – all foot soldiers – made good their escape to England."[12] These were a force of Welsh spearmen who were kept together by their commander, Sir Maurice de Berkeley. The majority of them reached Carlisle.[12] Weighing the available evidence, Reese concludes that "it seems doubtful if even a third of the foot soldiers returned to England."[12] If his estimate is accurate, of 16,000 English infantrymen, about 11,000 were killed. The English chronicler Thomas Walsingham gave the number of English men-at-arms who were killed as 700,[7] while 500 more men-at-arms were spared for ransom.[36] The Scottish losses appear to have been comparatively light, with only two knights among those killed.[37]

Aftermath[edit]

The immediate aftermath was the surrender of Stirling Castle, one of Scotland's most important fortresses, to King Robert. He then slighted it to prevent it from being retaken. Nearly as important was the surrender of Bothwell Castle where a sizeable party of English nobles, including the Earl of Hereford, had taken refuge. [38] In exchange for the captured nobles, Edward II released Robert's wife Elizabeth de Burgh, sisters Christina Bruce, Mary Bruce and daughter Marjorie Bruce, and Robert Wishart, Bishop of Glasgow, ending their 8-year imprisonment in England.

The defeat of the English opened up the north of England to Scottish raids[14] and allowed the Scottish invasion of Ireland.[31] These finally led, after the failure of the Declaration of Arbroath to secure diplomatic recognition of Scotland's independence by the Pope, to the Treaty of Edinburgh–Northampton in 1328.[31] Under the treaty the English crown recognised the full independence of the Kingdom of Scotland, and acknowledged Robert the Bruce, and his heirs and successors, as the rightful rulers.

Notable casualties[edit]

The following are the notable casualties and captives of the battle.[39]

Deaths[edit]

Captives[edit]

Legacy[edit]

Bannockburn Visitor Centre[edit]

The hemicircle of the modern Bannockburn monument

In 1932 the Bannockburn Preservation Committee, under Edward Bruce, 10th Earl of Elgin and Kincardine, presented lands to the National Trust for Scotland. Further lands were purchased in 1960 and 1965 to facilitate visitor access. A modern monument was erected in a field above the possible site of the battle, where the warring parties are believed to have camped on the night before the battle. The monument consists of two hemicircular walls depicting the opposing parties. Nearby stands the 1960s statue of Bruce by Pilkington Jackson. Although the statue was conceived by Pilkington Jackson he commissioned Thomas Taylor Bowie of the Ontario College of Art in Toronto to create the statue. The monument, and the associated visitor centre, is one of the most popular tourist attractions in the area. The battlefield has been included in the Inventory of Historic Battlefields in Scotland and protected by Historic Scotland under the Historic Environment (Amendment) Act 2011.[40]

The National Trust for Scotland operates the Bannockburn Visitor Centre (previously known as the Bannockburn Heritage Centre), which is open daily from March through October. On 31 October 2012 the original building was closed[41] for demolition and replacement by a new design, inspired by traditional Scottish buildings, by Reiach and Hall Architects. The project is a partnership between the National Trust for Scotland and Historic Environment Scotland, funded by the Scottish Government and the Heritage Lottery Fund.[42] The battlefield's new visitor centre – now rebranded as the Bannockburn Visitor Centre – opened in March 2014. One of the attractions created by a £9m redevelopment of the centre and the nearby battlefield memorial is a computerised multiplayer game.[43]

On 11 June 2020, during the George Floyd protests in the United Kingdom, the statue was defaced with graffiti.[44]

Arts[edit]

Bruce addresses his troops, from Cassell's History of England.[45]

"Scots Wha Hae" is the title of a patriotic poem by Robert Burns.[46] The chorus of Scotland's unofficial national anthem Flower of Scotland refers to Scotland's victory over Edward and the English at Bannockburn. Many artworks depict the battle. John Duncan[47] and Eric Harald Macbeth Robertson[48] both painted Bruce's encounter with de Bohun. John Phillip painted Bruce receiving the sacrament on the eve of the battle.[49] John Hassall painted a similar theme.[50]

A painting by William Findlay depicts Bruce at the battle.[51]

The aftermath of the battle is the setting of the Space: 1999 episode Journey to Where.[citation needed]

The closing scene of the 1995 film Braveheart shows the moments before the Battle of Bannockburn. Departing from history, in the film King Robert decides to do battle spontaneously.[52]

The Last Stand album by Sabaton features the song "Blood of Bannockburn".

References[edit]

  1. ^ Nusbacher, Aryeh (2000). The Battle of Bannockburn 1314. Stroud: Tempus. p. 85. ISBN 0-7524-1783-5.
  2. ^ Tucker, Spencer (2011). Battles that Changed History: An Encyclopedia of World Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 126. ISBN 978-1-59884-429-0.
  3. ^ Tucker, Spencer (2011). Battles that Changed History: An Encyclopedia of World Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 126. ISBN 978-1-59884-429-0.
  4. ^ Grant, R.G. (2008), Battle: A visual journey through 5,000 years of combat, DK Publishing, p.118.
  5. ^ Sadler, John, Scottish Battles, (Biddles Ltd., 1998), 52–54.
  6. ^ Tucker, Spencer (2011). Battles that Changed History: An Encyclopedia of World Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 127. ISBN 978-1-59884-429-0.
  7. ^ a b Mackenzie, p.88 referencing Walsingham, p.141
  8. ^ Tucker, Spencer (2011). Battles that Changed History: An Encyclopedia of World Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 127. ISBN 978-1-59884-429-0.
  9. ^ Mackenzie, p.90
  10. ^ Tucker, Spencer (2011). Battles that Changed History: An Encyclopedia of World Conflict. ABC-CLIO. p. 127. ISBN 978-1-59884-429-0.
  11. ^ Sadler, 52.
  12. ^ a b c d Reese, p.174
  13. ^ a b c d e "BBC – Scotland's History – The Battle of Bannockburn". BBC. Retrieved 2 December 2018.
  14. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y Black, Jeremy. (2005). The Seventy Great Battles of All Time. pp. 71–73. Thames & Hudson Ltd. ISBN 0-500-25125-8.
  15. ^ Watson, F., "In Our Time: The Battle of Bannockburn", BBC Radio, 3 February 2011
  16. ^ Barrow, Geoffrey W. S. (1988). Robert Bruce and the Community of Realm of Scotland. Edinburgh University Press. p. 225-229.
  17. ^ Nicholson, Later Middle Ages pp.87–89
  18. ^ Strickland, Matthew; Hardy,Robert (2005). The Great Warbow. Stroud: Sutton. p. 162. ISBN 0-7509-3167-1.
  19. ^ The Chronicle of Lanercost says that, on the second day of the battle, "the English archers were thrown forward before the line, and the Scottish archers engaged them, a few being killed and wounded on either side; but the King of England's archers quickly put the others to flight." The Chronicle of Lanercost, 1272–1346: Translated, with notes by Sir Herbert Maxwell. p. 206
  20. ^ Walter Bower, Scotichronicon,Book XII, p. 371
  21. ^ Historic Environment Scotland. "Battle of Bannockburn (47243)". Canmore. Retrieved 2 April 2009.
  22. ^ "OS 25 inch map 1892–1949, with Bing opacity slider". National Library of Scotland. Ordnance Survey. Retrieved 12 October 2017.
  23. ^ Mackenzie, W. M. (1913). The Battle of Bannockburn: a Study in Mediaeval Warfare, Publisher: James MacLehose; Glasgow.
  24. ^ Barrow, Geoffrey W.S. (1998). Robert Bruce & The Community of The Realm of Scotland. ISBN 0-85224-604-8
  25. ^ Barron, E.M., The Scottish War of Independence: a Critical Study, 1934
  26. ^ Christison, Philip, Bannockburn: The Story of the Battle, 1960, Edinburgh: The National Trust for Scotland.
  27. ^ Hyland, Ann. The Warhorse 1250–1600, UK: Sutton Publishing, 1998, p 38
  28. ^ The Battle of Bannockburn britishbattles.com. Retrieved 14 June 2014.
  29. ^ Maxwell 1907
  30. ^ Scott 1982, p. 158
  31. ^ a b c Scott 1982
  32. ^ (Brown, C. (2008) pp 129–130)
  33. ^ Scott 1982, p. 159
  34. ^ Scott 1982, p. 160
  35. ^ Barrow, Geoffrey W.S. (1988). Robert Bruce and the Community of the Realm of Scotland. Edinburgh University Press. p. 230.
  36. ^ Mackenzie, p.90
  37. ^ Reese, p.176
  38. ^ Barrow, Geoffrey W.S. (1988). Robert Bruce and the Community of the Realm of Scotland. Edinburgh University Press. p. 231.
  39. ^ Cornell 2009, p. 262.
  40. ^ "Inventory battlefields". Historic Scotland. Retrieved 12 April 2012.
  41. ^ "Bannockburn Heritage Centre closes before demolition". BBC News. 31 October 2012. Retrieved 31 October 2012.
  42. ^ "Battle of Bannockburn: Bannockburn : About the project". Archived from the original on 23 June 2013. Retrieved 24 September 2012.
  43. ^ "Battle of Bannockburn: : The Battle of Bannockburn Visitor Centre Opens". Archived from the original on 8 February 2015. Retrieved 1 December 2014.
  44. ^ "Robert the Bruce statue at Bannockburn daubed with Black Lives Matter graffiti". www.scotsman.com. Retrieved 12 June 2020.
  45. ^ Arnold-Foster, Hugh Oakley (1907). "Bannockburn". A History of England from the Landing of Julius Caesar to the Present Day. London, Paris, New York & Melbourne: Cassell and Company. p. 207. Retrieved 19 June 2009.
  46. ^ The Complete Works of Robert Burns at Project Gutenberg.
  47. ^ "Bruce and De Bohun". ArtUK. The Stirling Smith Art Gallery & Museum. Retrieved 5 November 2017.
  48. ^ "Robert the Bruce and de Bohun". ArtUK. The Fleming Collection. Retrieved 5 November 2017.
  49. ^ "Robert the Bruce on the Eve of Bannockburn Receiving the Sacrament from the Abbot of Inchaffre". ArtUK. Brechin Mechanics' Institute. Retrieved 5 November 2017.
  50. ^ "Bannockburn". ArtUK. Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum. Retrieved 5 November 2017.
  51. ^ "The Liberation of Scotland (The Battle of Bannockburn)". ArtUK. Glasgow Museums Resource Centre (GMRC). Retrieved 5 November 2017.
  52. ^ Gibson, Mel (1995). Braveheart (Motion picture). Paramount Pictures.

Sources[edit]

Primary[edit]

Secondary[edit]

  • Armstrong, Pete (illustrated by Graham Turner), Bannockburn 1314: Robert Bruce's Great Victory, Osprey Publishing, 2002 ISBN 1-85532-609-4
  • Barrow, G. W. S., Robert Bruce and the Community of the Realm of Scotland, 1988,ISBN 0-85224-604-8
  • Brown, C.A., "Bannockburn 1314",History Press,Stroud, 2008, ISBN 978-0-7524-4600-4.
  • Brown, C.A., Robert the Bruce. A life Chronicled.
  • Brown, Michael (2008). Bannockburn. The Scottish War and the British Isles 1307–1323. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
  • Brown, M., Wars of Scotland
  • Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Bannockburn" . Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • Cornell, David. Bannockburn: The Triumph of Robert the Bruce. Yale University Press, 2009. ISBN 9780300145687
  • Mackenzie, W. M., Bannockburn: A Study in Medieval Warfare, The Strong Oak Press, Stevenage 1989 (first published 1913), ISBN 1-871048-03-6
  • MacNamee, C., The Wars of the Bruces
  • Nicholson, R., Scotland-the Later Middle Ages, 1974.
  • Prestwich, M., The Three Edwards: War and State in England, 1272–1377, 1980
  • Ramsay, J. H., The Genesis of Lancaster, 1307–99, 1913.
  • Reese, P., Bannockburn, Canongate, Edinburgh, 2003, ISBN 1-84195-465-9
  • Scott, Ronald McNair (1982). Robert the Bruce King of Scots. London: Hutchinson & Co.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

External links[edit]