JTF-GTMO image of Bensayah Belkacem
|Status||still in captivity|
Bensayah Belkacem is a citizen of Bosnia, currently held in the United States Guantanamo Bay detainment camps, in Cuba. Born in Algeria, he was arrested in his home in Bosnia, on October 8, 2001, shortly after the attacks of September 11, 2001.
Bensayah Belkacem arrived at the Guantanamo detention camps on January 21, 2002, and has been held there for 12 years, 1 month and 17 days. He has been held since. In October 2008 his case was heard by the US District Court for the District of Columbia, which recommended his continued detention. This was overturned on appeal (see below.)
Belkacem and five other men, native-born Algerians who were charity workers and colleagues of his, were arrested on suspicion of plotting to bomb the American embassy in Bosnia. They are known as the Algerian Six. The other five men were released in 2009. This followed the Supreme Court decision in Boumediene v. Bush (2008) that said the military commissions were unconstitutional and provided for detainees to have their habeas corpus petitions heard by the US federal civilian court. After reviewing their cases, US District Court Judge Richard J. Leon ruled each of the five was being held illegally, but he ordered the continued detention of Belkacem.
His decision was appealed to the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. On June 28, 2010, a three-judge panel reversed Leon's ruling, holding that Belkacem could not be considered a member of al-Qaeda. The Justice Department said it would respond, and Belkacem is still being detained.
American intelligence officials had grown alarmed by an increase in the "chatter" in terrorist networks. After Belkacem's extrajudicial capture, news media reported that a search of his home turned up pro-jihadist material.
He was eventually "accused of helping people who wanted to travel to Afghanistan and join Al Qaeda". He was transported January 21, 2002 to the Guantanamo detention camp and has been held there since.
Detention in Cuba
Bensayah was one of the first Guantanamo detainees to get a letter out describing the conditions there. In a letter his wife received in June 2002, he said that the detainees no longer had to defecate and urinate into plastic bags. The camp authorities had finally provided them with toilets.
Writ of habeas corpus
A writ of habeas corpus was submitted on behalf of the Algerian Six, including Bensayah Belkacem. On 12 October 2004, the Department of Defense released 40 pages of unclassified documents related to Belkacem's Combatant Status Review Tribunal.
On 21 October 2008 US District Court Judge Richard J. Leon ordered the release of five of the Algerians held at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, following the US Supreme Court ruling in Boumediene v. Bush (2008) and based on his review of their cases. He ordered the continued detention of Belkacem.
Appeal of Judge Leon's ruling
On September 15, 2009 a three-judge panel from the DC Circuit Court of Appeals started to review Leon's ruling on Belkacem. The panel ruled that their hearings would be held entirely in-camera.
According to The Blog of Legal Times, a partially declassified brief to the appeal court by Marc Fleming, one of Belkacem's lawyers, of Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr, had challenged Leon's reasoning because he had relied on “unfinished, conclusory intelligence reports and uncorroborated assertions from anonymous sources.” Fleming's brief had challenged Leon's ruling because he had not required the government to search for exculpatory evidence related to Belkacem. Fleming asserted that when the government had conducted its search, the classified evidence it provided to him in April 2009 eroded the government's allegations.
On June 28, 2010, the panel reversed Leon's ruling, holding that Belkacem could not be considered a member of al-Qaeda. Judge Douglas H. Ginsburg, writing for the panel, said that the U.S. Government had presented "no direct evidence of actual communication between Bensayah and any al Qaeda member". Ginsburg noted that attorneys for the Obama administration had backed away from several arguments the Bush administration had previously made to Leon, including claims that Belkacem had communicated with Abu Zubaydah (The latter has been found to be a low-level person of little importance anyway).
According to the New York Times, "Still, Judge Ginsburg’s opinion suggested that the appeals court ruling turned less on the recategorization of Mr. Bensayah’s alleged ties to Al Qaeda than on skepticism about the basic credibility of the evidence the government presented against him." As a result, the panel ordered the release of Belkacem. The Justice Department said it would respond.
- OARDEC (2006-05-15). "List of Individuals Detained by the Department of Defense at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba from January 2002 through May 15, 2006". United States Department of Defense. Retrieved 2007-09-29.
- Man linked to Bin Laden arrested in Bosnia, The Guardian, October 8, 2001
- JTF-GTMO (2007-03-16). "Measurements of Heights and Weights of Individuals Detained by the Department of Defense at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba". Department of Defense. Retrieved 2008-12-22. mirror
- "Measurements of Heights and Weights of Individuals Detained by the Department of Defense at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba (ordered and consolidated version)". Center for the Study of Human Rights in the Americas, from DoD data. Archived from the original on 2009-12-21.
- Margot Williams (2008-11-03). "Guantanamo Docket: Bensayah Belkacem". New York Times. Retrieved 2010-03-30.
- "Bosnia: Algerian Trial Jeopardised", Institute for War and Peace Reporting, December 7, 2001
- "Terrorist material found in Sarajevo charity raid", The Guardian, February 23, 2002
- Savage, Charlie. "Appeals court sides with detainee", The New York Times, 2010-07-04
- Michael Elliott (June 16, 2002). "The Next Wave: Dirty-bomb, car-bomb, boat-bomb, bomb plots—meet the new al-Qaeda men, less polished than the 9/11 crew, but any less lethal?". Time magazine. Retrieved 2007-12-19.
- "Lakhdar Boumediene et al. v. George W. Bush: 04-1166 (RJL)". United States Department of Defense. pp. 101 ff. Retrieved 2007-12-24.
- Richard J. Leon. "Bensayah v. USA". United States Department of Justice. Archived from Judge Leon's order the original on 2009-09-21.
- William Glaberson (2009-11-20). "Judge Declares Five Detainees Held Illegally". New York Times. Archived from the original on 2009-09-21.
- "US judge orders Algerians freed". BBC News. 2008-11-20. Retrieved 2009-09-21.
- Mike Scarcella (2009-09-15). "D.C. Circuit Orders Guantanamo Hearing Closed to Public". The Blog of Legal Times.
- "Bensayah v. Obama". United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. 2010-06-28. Retrieved 2012-01-09.
- Andy Worthington, "Guantánamo and Habeas Corpus: Prisoners Win 3 out of 4 Cases, But Lose 5 out of 6 in Court of Appeals" (Part Two), Andy Worthington website, 27 July 2010
- Judge Ginsburg ruling from June 28, 2010
- "Habeas Works: Federal Courts’ Proven Capacity to Handle Guantánamo Cases" (2010), Human Rights First
- "Bin Laden suspect held in Bosnia". CNN. Fall 2001. Retrieved 2007-10-10.
- Ian Fisher (January 28, 2002). "Qaeda Suspect's Bosnian Wife Says He's No Terrorist". New York Times. Retrieved 2007-10-10.
- "German troops 'posed' as media". United Press International. December 22, 2005. Retrieved 2007-12-24.