Braddock, photographed in the 1960s
|Member of Parliament
for Liverpool Exchange
|Born||Elizabeth Margaret Bamber
24 September 1899
Liverpool, Lancashire, England
|Died||13 November 1970
Liverpool, Lancashire, England
|Spouse(s)||John "Jack" Braddock|
Elizabeth Margaret "Bessie" Braddock (née Bamber; 24 September 1899 – 13 November 1970) was a British Labour Party politician who served as Member of Parliament (MP) for the Liverpool Exchange division from 1945 to 1970. She was a member of Liverpool County Borough Council from 1930 to 1961. Although she never held ministerial office, she won a national reputation for her forthright campaigns in connection with housing, health and other social issues.
Braddock inherited much of her campaigning spirit from her mother, Mary Bamber, an early socialist and trade union activist. After some years in the Independent Labour Party (ILP), Braddock joined the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB) on its foundation in 1920, but quickly became disillusioned with the party's dictatorial tendencies. She left the CPGB in 1924 and later joined the Labour Party. Before the Second World War, alongside her husband Jack Braddock, she established a reputation as a crusading left-wing councillor, frequently at odds with her party while pursuing an agenda of social reform. During the war she worked in Liverpool's ambulance service, before winning the Exchange division for Labour in the 1945 general election.
With her formidable physique and outspoken manner Braddock was a pugnacious presence in parliament, and a keen supporter of the 1945–51 Attlee ministry's reform agenda, particularly the establishment of the National Health Service in 1948. She served on Labour's National Executive Committee between 1947 and 1969. Her combative style led to a brief suspension from parliament in 1952. For most of her parliamentary career she remained a member of Liverpool's council, and was a central figure in the controversy that arose in the 1950s over the city's decision to acquire and flood the Tryweryn Valley in Wales for the construction of a reservoir.
Between 1953 and 1957 Braddock served on the Royal Commission for Mental Health which led to the Mental Health Act 1959. From the early 1950s she moved steadily to the right wing of her party, and was increasingly acerbic in her judgements of her former colleagues on the left. When Labour won the 1964 general election she refused office on the grounds of age and health; thereafter her parliamentary contributions dwindled as her health worsened. Towards the end of her life she became Liverpool's first woman freeman. After her death in 1970 her Guardian obituarist hailed her as "one of the most distinctive political personalities of the century".
- 1 Life
- 2 Assessment
- 3 Notes and references
- 4 External links
Elizabeth Bamber was born on 24 September 1899 at 23 Zante Street, Liverpool, the eldest daughter of Hugh Bamber, a bookbinder, and his wife Mary, née Little. Mary had come to Liverpool as a child when her father, a well-to-do Edinburgh lawyer, abandoned his family after his descent into alcoholism and poverty. Liverpool in the late 19th century suffered extremes of social deprivation, and had the highest infant mortality rate in the country. Mary became a trade union organiser and campaigner against poverty, and established a reputation as an outstanding platform speaker. She was the dominant early influence on her daughter Elizabeth, who formed a lifelong determination to represent and fight for the disadvantaged.
In 1902 the Bamber family relocated to Smollett Street in nearby Bootle, one of several moves that caused Elizabeth's formal education to be divided among several schools. Alongside her normal schooling her political education began at the Marmaduke Street Socialist Sunday School, and through the medium of her mother's campaigning activities. One of Elizabeth's early memories was of the soup kitchen for the destitute which Mary helped to run on St George's Plateau: "I remember the faces of the unemployed when the soup ran out ... I remember blank, hopeless stares, day after day, week after week, all through the hard winter of 1906–07".
At the age of 11 Elizabeth left the Sunday School and joined the youth section of the Independent Labour Party (ILP), where she studied socialism alongside a busy programme of social activities. She later described herself at this time as "strong, agile, fond of walking and eating". By this time Mary Bamber was working as an organiser for the Warehouse Workers' Union; Elizabeth assisted her mother, sometimes acting as a steward at meetings. Mother and daughter were both present at St George's Plateau on 13 August 1911, when a baton charge by police and troops broke up a rally in support of Liverpool's striking transport workers. Hundreds were injured, and in the disturbances that followed, two demonstrators were shot dead. The day became enshrined in Liverpool's working-class history as "Bloody Sunday".
Elizabeth left school in 1913, and began work filling seed packets for five shillings a week. The job was too monotonous to engage her for long, and after a few months she found a post in the drapery department of the Walton Road Co-operative store. At her mother's insistence she became a member of the Shopworkers' Union. Meanwhile, she attended classes run by the Workers' Educational Association and the Plebs' League: "They told me how the capitalists controlled money, business and the land, and how they hung on to them".
Within the group of young socialists who gathered regularly at the ILP's local headquarters there were three Elizabeths. To avoid confusion, lots were drawn to decide who should be known respectively as Elizabeth, Betty, or Bessie. By this means Elizabeth Bamber took the name Bessie, which she retained for the rest of her life. Among the other ILP activists at Kensington was Sydney Silverman, four years older than Bessie, the son of a poor draper. Silverman was a considerable influence on the youthful Bessie; he would be her future colleague, both in the Liverpool council chamber and the House of Commons. When the First World War began in August 1914, the ILP opposed it as "an appalling crime upon the nations" who had been "stampeded by fear and panic". On the introduction of conscription in 1916, Silverman and others adopted positions of uncompromising pacifism, and were imprisoned. The ILP welcomed news of the Russian Revolution of 1917, and vigorously opposed allied intervention in the civil war that followed it. Bessie played a leading role in a TUC "Hands Off Russia" rally in Liverpool's Sheil Park, where she and others resisted the efforts of the British Empire Union to capture the ILP's red flag.
At the end of the war in 1918, Bessie left the Co-op and took a clerical post with the Warehouse Workers' Union. In the course of her ILP activities she met and befriended John "Jack" Braddock, a wagon builder and union activist with a reputation as a firebrand. He had arrived in Liverpool from Dewsbury in 1915, hoping to emigrate to Canada, but had stayed in the port and immersed himself in left-wing politics and the fight to improve working conditions. He and Bessie became very close; in 1919 they helped Mary Bamber to fight for a Liverpool council seat, as the ILP's candidate in the Everton district. The election campaign was bitter and at times violent, but resulted in Bamber's victory by the slim margin of 13 votes.
By 1920 Mary Bamber, Bessie and Jack Braddock had become disillusioned with the ILP, which seemed to them to lack the necessary radicalism to march with the times. At the time, Sylvia Pankhurst's Workers' Socialist Federation, the British Socialist Party and other socialist organisations were increasingly coordinating their activities, and in 1920 merged to form the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB). Under Mary Bamber's influence, both Bessie and Jack Braddock left the ILP to become members of the new party. Within the CPGB the young couple became acquainted with Wal Hannington, leader of the National Unemployed Workers Committee Movement. They joined his "work or maintenance" campaign which aimed to raise the levels of Poor Law relief to what they considered a proper subsistence level. The couple did not endear themselves to the CPGB hierarchy when, on egalitarian grounds, they opposed the levels of salary which the party wanted to pay to its full-time officials.
In the joint autobiography written with Jack, The Braddocks (1963), Bessie cites the formative experience of police violence on "Bloody Sunday" in 1911 as a motivating factor for her CPGB activities. On 12 September 1921, again at St George's Plateau, she attended a rally for the city's jobless, organised by the Liverpool Unemployed Workers' Committee. Again there was police intervention; Jack and Mary Bamber were charged with unlawful assembly and received a token one day's imprisonment. In 1922 Bessie and other party members provided comfort and shelter to Hannington's hunger marchers, as the columns of unemployed passed through Lancashire on their way to London. Bessie combined her party roles—she was treasurer of the Liverpool branch—with her full-time union post; Jack, meanwhile, was only intermittently in work, as his incendiary reputation meant that employers were reluctant to give him a job. He had been living for some time at the Bambers' home when, in February 1922, the couple were married at Brougham Terrace registry office, during the course of a working day. After a brief reception they returned to their respective duties—Bessie to her union job and Jack to his volunteer work for the CPGB.
The Braddocks were not comfortable as CPGB members. They objected to the lack of autonomy afforded to local branches by the party's central "Political Bureau", and to what they perceived as the leadership's unquestioning subservience to the Soviet Union. Mary Bamber, after a visit to Russia, opined that there were as many true communists in Liverpool as in Moscow. In 1924, increasingly convinced that communist rule would lead to the enslavement rather than the liberation of workers, the entire leadership of the Liverpool CPGB branch, including both Braddocks, resigned from the party.
After leaving the CPGB, the Braddocks continued their socialist activism in Liverpool. Jack's role in the Merseyside Council of Action during the 1926 General Strike made employers even less willing to engage him. He was rescued by the action of Sir Benjamin Johnson, a liberal-minded industrialist, who lent him the money to purchase a Co-operative Insurance Society agency. He and Bessie were now determined to pursue their political aims by democratic methods, and in 1926 they joined the Fairfeld ward of the Liverpool Labour Party.[n 1] In the 1929 Liverpool council elections, Jack was returned unopposed as the Labour councillor for the Everton ward. A year later Bessie joined him, elected in the St Anne's ward.
St Anne's, one of the most deprived areas of the city, contained the closed Brownlow Hill Workhouse which the Conservative-controlled council had decided to sell to the Roman Catholic Church, as the potential site for a cathedral. This decision split the minority Labour group on religious lines. Labour's official policy was to delay the sale for several years so that the empty workhouse buildings could be used as temporary housing during slum clearance and rebuilding. However, nearly all the Catholic members of the Labour group defied party policy and voted for an immediate sale. Among the rebels was the sitting St Anne's councillor, Olive Hughes. She was thereupon deselected by the St Anne's ward, which chose Bessie as their candidate for the 1930 election. Bessie faced a difficult task, since Hughes chose to stand against her as an Independent Socialist, with the support of leading local Catholics in a ward where the electorate was 85 per cent Catholic. An intense campaign, during which Bessie claimed to have visited every street in the ward, brought her success.
This victory did not delay the workhouse's fate; the site was duly sold to the Catholic Church for £110,000, and demolition began in January 1931. Nevertheless, Bessie, who had been appalled by the housing conditions in the ward, helped to instigate a slum clearance campaign which slowly brought improvements. Through her membership of the council's Port Sanitary and Hospitals Committee, which controlled all the city's hospitals and residential homes for the elderly, Bessie was deeply involved in the reorganisation and modernisation of many of the city's health facilities. Bessie found the hospitals generally verminous, drably decorated and poorly ventilated, with inadequate cooking facilities. Patients' record-keeping systems were rudimentary, with little or no communication between hospitals. The programme of gradual reform that she helped to introduce was such that, years later, a visiting expert described the city's medical provision as a "National Health Service in miniature".
The Labour group on the council remained divided. The group's leader was Luke Hogan (1885–1954), of Irish stock and closely identified with the Catholic caucus. He enjoyed the strong support of around two-thirds of the Labour councillors; the Braddocks, and from 1932 Sydney Silverman, were part of the smaller leftist wing of the group. Clashes between the two sides were frequent, the main contention being the supposed attempts by Hogan and his followers to "catholicise" the local party. In 1936, when Hogan tried to block the renewal of a grant to a local birth control clinic, Bessie led a cross-party rebellion of councillors to ensure that the grant was maintained. She argued that most of the 87 women who had died in childbirth the previous year might have survived with access to contraception.
Mostly, Bessie was uncompromising in her attitude towards the council's ruling Conservatives; on one occasion she was ejected from the council chamber by the police, after she had called the Housing Committee chairman a liar and refused the mayor's order to withdraw the remark. She justified this behaviour on the grounds that "if you didn't do something outrageous, nobody would take any notice of you". She had earlier resorted to using a two-foot megaphone in a council meeting, to demand action over housing conditions and slums.
Inspired by her colleague Silverman, who in the 1935 general election became MP for Nelson and Colne, Bessie determined to seek a parliamentary career of her own. This ambition contrasted with that of Jack, who turned down the chance to be Labour's candidate in the Everton constituency to concentrate on his local government role.[n 2] In 1936 Bessie was selected as Labour candidate for Liverpool Exchange. This inner-city division had long been held by the Conservatives, mainly because of a substantial "business vote" which, before the abolition of plural voting in 1948, gave owners of businesses an extra vote in the constituency where their business operated. In the recent election the seat had been held by the Conservative, Sir John Shute, with a majority of 4,412. Bessie was then 36 years old; she would have to wait for nearly 10 years before she could fight her seat, as the general election that would normally have been held in 1939 or 1940 was postponed by the Second World War.
In the years immediately before the war Bessie was concerned at the extent of recruitment in the city by the British Union of Fascists. She was outspoken in her attacks on fascist groups, and in her defence of those who attacked their parades. The death of her mother Mary Bamber in June 1938, at the age of 63, was a considerable personal blow to Bessie, and was widely mourned within Liverpool's socialist community.
Second World War
On the outbreak of war in September 1939, Bessie left her union post and joined G Division of the Liverpool Ambulance Service, as a driver. Initially her main job was to train other drivers, mostly young women. She became a section leader and then a deputy leader of G Division, an administrative post that should have kept her at headquarters. However, she records that she drove her ambulance through all the 68 major air raids that struck Liverpool during the war years. It was dangerous work; on a single day, 3 May 1941, 14 drivers lost their lives.
Bessie remained with the ambulance service almost until the end of the war in 1945. In 1942 she and Jack moved to what would be their home for the remainder of their lives, a suburban semi-detached house in ZigZag Road, in Liverpool's West Derby district. They remained active members of Liverpool council, and in 1943 Jack became deputy leader of the Labour group. Two years later the Braddocks healed the rift with Hogan by proposing and seconding his appointment as the city's Lord Mayor for the year 1945–46; Jack succeeded him as leader of the Labour group on the council, a post he held until his death in 1963. Bessie became honorary president of the Liverpool Trades Council and Labour Party (LTCLP), the body that had been formed in 1921 when the Liverpool Trades Council merged with the newly formed local Labour Party to form a united labour front.[n 3]
Labour government 1945–51
Despite some opinion polls indicating a Labour lead, most commentators expected that Winston Churchill's prestige would ensure a comfortable Conservative victory in the July 1945 general election. Before polling day, the Manchester Guardian surmised that "the chances of Labour sweeping the country and obtaining a clear majority ... are pretty remote". The News of the World predicted a working Conservative majority, while in Glasgow a pundit forecast the result as Conservatives 360, Labour 220, Others 60. The expectations of a Labour victory in Liverpool Exchange were not high, but Bessie's chances were boosted by the poor local record of the sitting member, Colonel Shute, and she herself was confident. Defying most forecasts, across the country Labour won 393 seats, and with an overall majority of 146, Clement Attlee formed the first majority Labour government. Bessie won Liverpool Exchange with a majority of 665 from 16,000 votes cast.
In an assessment of the new MPs, the Daily Express described Bessie as "a character among the Labour women. Very forthright in her speech, strong in her Labour faith ... never hesitates to call a spade a spade". Physically imposing—she admitted to weighing 15 stone (210 pounds, 95 kg)—she made an impact with her maiden speech, on 17 October 1945, during a debate on the national housing shortage. After taunting the Conservative opposition for having "filched" the Exchange seat—"the prize Division of the [Liverpool] Tory Party"—she made an impassioned plea to the new Minister of Health, Aneurin Bevan, for immediate measures to improve the slum housing conditions in Liverpool, and throughout the country: "Particularly in industrial areas, people are living in flea-ridden, bug-ridden, rat-ridden, lousy hell-holes". She ended her speech with a promise that she and other Labour back-benchers would continue to agitate until the conditions in which many were forced to live, "as a result of having been represented for so long by the Conservative Party", were removed.
Bessie's aggressive anti-Toryism was frequently in evidence during her first years in parliament, especially when she could attribute to them the economic miseries of her Liverpool constituents. In a Commons debate on 28 March 1946 she welcomed the government's decision to close the Liverpool Cotton Association, which she denounced as "the bulwark of the Tory administration in Liverpool", nothing more than a group of financiers who gambled with the industry in order to make profits for themselves. On 1 May 1947 the Manchester Guardian, reporting the chaotic Commons scenes during the divisions following a debate on the nationalisation of the railways, recorded that "Mrs E.M. Braddock ... danced a jig as she moved over to the Opposition benches where she occupied the seat usually used by Mr Churchill." When the Bolton Evening News called her performance "nauseating, a sorry degradation of democratic discussion" she sued the newspaper for defamation. She lost the case, and a subsequent appeal was unsuccessful.
In 1947 Bessie was elected to the Labour Party's National Executive Committee (NEC). She was generally identified with the left wing of the party, and was for a time associated with a grouping known as the "Socialist Fellowship", which espoused a programme of colonial freedom, workers' control and reduced arms expenditure. She resigned from the Fellowship in 1950, along with fellow-MPs Fenner Brockway and Ellis Smith, when it condemned the United Nations intervention in the Korean War. She continued her wholehearted campaigning on behalf of the poorest in the country, pleading with parliament to "remember the queues outside the Poor Relief offices", and castigating the "New Look" fashion of 1948 as wasteful, "the ridiculous whim of idle people". Bessie's fiery reputation did not harm her electorally; in the February 1950 general election, with the Exchange constituency greatly increased by boundary changes, her majority rose to 5,344. Nationally Labour lost 76 seats, and its parliamentary majority was reduced to five. Attlee's second government was short-lived; in the October 1951 general election Bessie increased her personal majority again, to 6,834, but nationally Labour was defeated by the Conservatives and went into opposition.
Outside her political duties Bessie, a keen fan of boxing, accepted the honorary presidency of the Professional Boxers' Association, and was a passionate defender of the sport. Her enthusiasm arose in part from her experiences as a juvenile court magistrate; she believed that the sport fostered character and mutual respect. She was frequently at odds with her parliamentary colleague Edith Summerskill, a medical doctor who wrote the anti-boxing tract The Ignoble Art, and campaigned for the sport's abolition.
1950s: Rightward shift
After leaving Socialist Fellowship, Bessie moved steadily towards the centre and right of her party, distancing herself from colleagues with whom she had earlier found common cause. She did not support Aneurin Bevan when he resigned from the government in April 1951 over the introduction of National Health Service charges, and later asserted that, by making dissidence fashionable, Bevan had "weakened the [Labour] National Executive to the point where it could no longer deal effectively with infiltrating Trotskyists and Communists". In 1955 her opposition to the Bevanite faction was such that she supported efforts by Hugh Gaitskell and Herbert Morrison to have Bevan expelled from the party. She regularly attacked the Labour left at party conferences, and in 1952 was involved in scuffles with other delegates after the unexpected success of Bevanite candidates in the NEC elections.
Also in 1952, Bessie's volatile temperament caused her to become the first woman member to be suspended from the House of Commons, after she repeatedly protested to the Deputy Speaker for failing to call her during a debate on the textile industry, a matter of great concern to her constituents. In general, her forthright attitude won her cross-party respect, and in 1953 she was appointed by Churchill (who had returned as prime minister in 1951) to the Royal Commission on Mental Health, otherwise known as the Percy Commission, whose work led to the Mental Health Act 1959.
Bessie's increasingly right-wing stance troubled party members in Liverpool Exchange, where the Bevanite faction was generally popular. In 1954 the local party passed a motion requesting that she step down before the next general election. This was rejected by the NEC, who believed that Bessie was a national electoral asset. Shortly before the May 1955 general election the Exchange party tried again, and voted by 40 to 39 to deselect her. Bessie, convinced that this vote had been rigged, appealed to the NEC, who set the decision aside and imposed her on the constituency. These party machinations had no effect on Bessie's popularity with the voters; in the election on 26 May, despite the intervention of a left-wing Independent Socialist candidate, she increased her majority to 7,186. Nevertheless, the Conservatives retained power with an increased parliamentary majority. In the municipal elections held that same month, Labour won control of Liverpool's council for the first time; Jack Braddock became council leader. Bessie gave up her St Anne's ward seat, after 25 years, but remained on the council as a co-opted alderman.
Campaigns and controversies, 1956–59
In May 1956 Bessie's concerns about the treatment of prisoners in Walton Prison led to an investigation by Sir Godfrey Russell Vick, which revealed numerous instances of violence by members of the prison staff, and brought about reforms. In July that year, during a home affairs debate, Bessie demanded tougher regulations on the supply and licensing of air pistols, which under the existing law were readily available to juveniles. She alarmed the house by brandishing two such pistols which, she explained, she had confiscated in the course of her duties as a juvenile court magistrate. When rebuked by the Deputy Speaker, she replied that she had deliberately used shock tactics, reprising her earlier council chamber argument that "no one takes any notice unless someone does something which is out of order, or is unusual". She also campaigned for the rights of larger women to obtain fashionable clothes; using her substantial 50" – 40" – 50" measurements to advantage, she took part in a fashion show aimed at the larger-than-average woman.
In 1956, as part of a Liverpool council delegation, the Braddocks visited the Soviet Union at the invitation of the mayor of Odessa, a city with which Liverpool had informal fraternal links. Her overall impression of the country was of drabness and oppression, with welfare provision generally well below British levels, although she conceded that medical facilities were excellent. Before returning home she informed the mayor of Odessa that "after forty years of socialism ... you haven't achieved half of what we have in Britain".
In the later 1950s an issue arose which tarnished the reputations of both Braddocks in the eyes of much of Liverpool's Welsh community and the people of Wales. In 1955 Liverpool council applied for the compulsory purchase of land in the Tryweryn Valley, Merionethshire, North Wales, for the construction of a reservoir to serve Liverpool's increasing needs for water—some 65 million gallons a day. The proposal would mean the flooding of the small village of Llyn Celyn, and several farms. On 7 November a deputation led by the Plaid Cymru president Gwynfor Evans sought to address the council in a plea for a change in policy. According to Bessie's biographer Ben Rees, while Evans was speaking, Bessie banged on the table and joined other councillors in insulting Evans and demanding that he "go back to Wales". In July 1957, when the enabling legislation reached its second House of Commons reading, Bessie described the scheme as regional rather than local, and claimed that some parts of Wales would benefit from it. The land to be flooded in the Tryweryn Valley was not, she said, of high agricultural value, and "nothing was done that was not agreed to by the tenants in the area". The bill became law, and construction began in 1959, but protests and demonstrations continued until the reservoir's opening in 1965. The slogan Cofia Dryerwyn ("Remember Tryweryn") was coined by nationalists, says Rees, as "a reminder of Liverpool's greed and lack of sensitivity".
In the October 1959 general election the Conservatives, now led by Harold Macmillan, increased their majority in parliament to 100 seats. In Liverpool Exchange Bessie defied the national swing, and increased her proportion of the vote. On a reduced turnout her personal majority fell slightly, to 6,971.
Later career, 1960–68
In 1961 Bessie's aldermanic term on Liverpool's council expired. That year, the Conservatives briefly took control of the council, and used their majority to block her reappointment. This ended 31 years' service on the council. In 1963, when Labour regained control, she did not seek re-instatement. The year 1963 saw the publication of The Braddocks, in which Bessie made a sustained attack on communism and Trotskyism: "The purpose of this book is to bring home to the rank and file how wide that influence is ... unless positive steps are taken by the workers themselves ... democracy will be dead". Reviewing the book for the Socialist Standard, Lawrence Weidberg thought it gave a useful picture of early 20th century working-class life in Liverpool, but concluded that "from the evidence of this book the Braddocks qualified fully for the role of blind leaders of the blind".
On 12 November 1963 Jack Braddock died of a heart attack, at the age of 71, while attending an official function in Liverpool. The October 1964 general election brought Labour a narrow victory under Harold Wilson, while in Liverpool Exchange, Bessie achieved her best personal majority to date, 9,746. She did not take a post in the new government; according to the Guardian she was offered a job, but declined on the grounds of health and age. Although she fought the next election, in March 1966, and held Liverpool Exchange easily, for the final six years of her parliamentary life she was relatively inactive and often absent through illness. She served as chairman of the Commons Kitchen Committee until the end of 1966, but thereafter rarely participated in parliamentary debates. Her last contribution in the House was on 27 January 1969, a question regarding facilities for disabled drivers.
Final years and death
In 1968 Bessie became vice chairman (and therefore chairman-elect) of the Labour Party. However, in February 1969 she collapsed with exhaustion and was hospitalised. In August she resigned from the NEC on health grounds, thus forgoing her succession to the party chairmanship. In September she announced that she did not intend to contest the next general election, and would retire from politics, a decision which shocked and disappointed her constituents. In April 1970 she was awarded the freedom of the City of Liverpool, the first woman thus honoured. Bessie formally left parliament at the dissolution before the June 1970 general election; on 13 November 1970 she died in Liverpool's Rathbone Hospital, at the age of 71. At her funeral service held a few days later at Anfield Crematorium, in the course of his tribute, Harold Wilson summed her up thus: "She was born to fight for the people of the docks, of the slums, of the factories and in every part of the city where people needed help".
At the time of her death, commentators described Bessie as one of the most notable political personalities of her time, and perhaps the best-known woman in Britain after the Queen. She was especially appreciated on Merseyside, where much of her campaigning zeal for better housing and healthcare was concentrated. Widely known and remembered as "Battling Bessie", thirty years after her death she was placed eighth in a BBC poll of "great Merseysiders".
Bessie was renowned for the sharpness of her tongue, either in pursuit of her campaigns or in denouncing her enemies. She frequently used inflammatory, colourful language, once describing an opposing councillor as a "blasted rat", and another time telling the Tory majority that she was willing "to take a machine gun to the lot of you". In contrast to this aggressive public, Bessie's private life was unostentatious. She did not smoke or drink, dressed conventionally and holidayed modestly in Scarborough. Nevertheless, she enjoyed the company of many glamorous friends from the worlds of show business and boxing.
Towards perceived adversaries, Bessie showed neither patience nor respect, especially those with whom she had once shared common ground on the far left. Apart from her attacks on Bevan, she displayed particular scorn for the future Labour Party leader Michael Foot, whose practice in the 1950s of writing articles attacking the Labour leadership for right-wing newspapers was, she thought, disloyal. A much reported exchange between her and Churchill has her accusing him of being drunk, and him concurring but adding: "My dear you are ugly, but tomorrow I shall be sober and you will still be ugly"—or similar words. There is no reliable evidence that any such exchange took place; despite its popularity, commentators are generally sceptical. According to the columnist Simon Hoggart, similar stories involving other figures had been circulating for years; he concluded: "If it sounds true, if it echoes something we feel about the politician, then it will cling to him or her as if bonded with superglue".
Bessie Braddock is commemorated in Liverpool by a statue in Lime Street Station, and by a blue plaque erected at her modest home in ZigZag Road. In a 2014 Fabian Society essay the Labour MP Lisa Nandy wrote that Bessie "brought her experiences of life in the slums of Liverpool right into the heart of Westminster. Now, more than ever, we need the voices of working women to be heard in parliament".
Notes and references
- Until 1918, membership of the Labour Party was only through one of the affiliated organisations, e.g. the ILP, the Fabian Society, trade unions, etc. The 1918 constitution provided for direct membership of the Labour Party, via local constituency parties. The ILP continued as an affiliated body, with its own membership, but was greatly weakened.
- The Everton constituency was won by Labour in 1935, and held by the party until its abolition in 1950. Thus, Jack Braddock could easily have enjoyed a lengthy parliamentary career, eventually alongside his wife.
- The two components remained united, despite considerable tension, until 1969, when they separated into a Trades Council and a District Labour Party.
- The Guardian obituary 1970.
- Ingham 2005.
- Law 2000, pp. 20–21.
- Hartley 2003, p. 61.
- Rees 2011, pp. 4, 11.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 7.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 1–3.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 8.
- Rees 2011, pp. 11–12.
- Wright 2011.
- Rees 2011, p. 12.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 10.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 14.
- Rees 2011, p. 13.
- Boulton 1967, pp. 44–45.
- McCabe 2004.
- Carsten 1982, pp. 101–04.
- Lane 1995, p. 128.
- Davies 2004.
- Rees 2011, pp. 14–15.
- Klugmann 1960, pp. 1–11.
- Rees 2011, p. 15.
- TUC Timeline.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 34–40.
- Rees 2011, pp. 18–19.
- Rees 2011, pp. 16–17.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 60–63.
- Davies 1999, pp. 10–11.
- Taylor 1970, pp. 129–31.
- Guy 2012.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 68–69.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 71–72.
- The Workhouse Site.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 73–74.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 130–39.
- Rees 2011, pp. 22–23.
- Baldwin et al (eds) 2012, p. 122.
- Worley 2005, p. 200.
- BBC History 2004.
- Rees 2011, pp. 24–25.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 86.
- Rees 2011, p. 29.
- Rees 2011, p. 27.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 87.
- Liverpool Ambulance Service.
- Davies 1999, p. 7.
- Davies 1999, p. 17.
- Kynaston 2008, pp. 70–71.
- The Manchester Guardian 4 July 1945.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 442.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 238.
- Rees 2011, pp. 29–30.
- Hansard 17 October 1945.
- Hansard 28 March 1946.
- The Manchester Guardian 11 November 1948.
- The Manchester Guardian 12 November 1948.
- The Manchester Guardian 23 June 1949.
- Rees 2011, p. 35.
- Pröbsting 2013.
- Kynaston 2008, p. 149.
- Kynaston 2008, p. 257.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 236.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 452.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 453.
- London School of Economics 2010.
- Spokesman-Review 3 December 1950, p. 5.
- Rees 2011, p. 38.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 203.
- Rees 2011, p. 40.
- Wheen 1990, p. 321.
- Kynaston 2009, pp. 249–50.
- Hansard 26 March 1952.
- The Guardian 24 May 1968.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 109.
- Percy Commission Report 1957.
- Rees 2011, p. 39.
- Taaffe and Mulhearn 1988, p. 345.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 91–92.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 470.
- Davies 1999, p. 16.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 98–101.
- Hansard 2 July 1956.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 151–53.
- BBC iWonder 2015.
- Rees 2011, pp. 41–43.
- Hansard 3 July 1957.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 479.
- The Guardian 24 May 1961.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, p. 237.
- Weidberg 1964.
- Rees 2011, p. 53.
- Pearce and Stewart 1992, p. 485.
- The Guardian 16 October 1964.
- The Guardian 22 October 1964.
- The Guardian 1 April 1966.
- Hansard 21 December 1964.
- Hansard 27 January 1969.
- The Guardian 3 October 1968.
- The Observer 16 February 1969.
- The Guardian 15 August 1969.
- The Observer 7 September 1969.
- Rees 2011, p. 54.
- Rees 2011, p. 55.
- Coslett 2009.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 173–81.
- Braddock and Braddock 1963, pp. 182–83.
- Williams 2013.
- Hoggart 2007.
- heraldscotland 2000.
- Nandy 2014.
- Baldwin, Anne; et al., eds. (2012). Class, Culture and Community: New Perspectives in Nineteenth and Twentieth Century British Labour History. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4438-4064-4.
- Boulton, David (1967). Objection Overruled. London: MacGibbon and Kie. OCLC 956913.
- Braddock, Bessie; Braddock, John (1963). The Braddocks. London: Macdonald. OCLC 4716477.
- Carsten, Francis Ludwig (1982). War Against War: British and German Radical Movements in the First World War. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-04581-1.
- Hartley, Cathy (2003). A Historical Dictionary of British Women. London: Europa Publications. ISBN 978-1-85743-228-2.
- Kynaston, David (2008). Austerity Britain 1945–51. London: Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-0-7475-9923-4.
- Kynaston, David (2009). Family Britain 1951–57. London: Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-0-7475-8385-1.
- Lane, A. Thomas, ed. (1995). Biographical Dictionary of European Labor Leaders, Volume 1. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press. ISBN 978-0-313-29899-8.
- Law, Cheryl (2000). Women, A Modern Political Dictionary. London: I.B. Taurus. ISBN 978-1-86064-502-0.
- Pearce, Malcolm; Stewart, Geoffrey (1992). British Political History 1867–1990. London: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-07247-2.
- Rees, D. Ben (2011). A Portrait of Battling Bessie. Nottingham: Spokesman Books (Leen Editions). ISBN 978-0-9570631-0-5.
- Taaffe, Peter; Mulhearn, Tony (1988). Liverpool: A City that Dared to Fight. London: Fortress Books. ISBN 978-1-870958-00-4.
- Taylor, A.J.P. (1970). English History 1914–1945. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0-14-021181-8.
- Wheen, Francis (1990). The Soul of Indiscretion. London: Fourth Estate. ISBN 978-1-84115-575-3.
- Worley, Matthew (2005). Labour Inside the Gate: A History of the British Labour Party Between the Wars. London: I.B. Tauris. ISBN 978-1-85043-798-7.
Newspapers and journals
- "Bessie Braddock". The Observer. 16 February 1969. p. 1.
- "Bessie Braddock shock". The Observer. 7 September 1969. p. 1.
- "Dame Irene bows to exile". The Guardian. 24 May 1968. p. 1.
- "Disabled Drivers' Vehicles". Hansard 776. 27 January 1969. p. cc929–31. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "Disarmament job still vacant". The Guardian. 22 October 1964. p. 22.
- "English women in word fight". The Spokesman-Review. 3 December 1950.
- "First results in General Election". The Guardian. 16 October 1964. p. 4.
- "For the sixth time". The Guardian. 1 April 1966. p. 1.
- Guy, Peter (16 April 2012). "Bessie Braddock: People of Liverpool". The Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 20 October 2015.
- Hoggart, Simon (1 July 2007). "Hague's baseball cap, Mandelson's mushy peas: True tales or just great political myths?". MailOnline. Retrieved 2 November 2015.
- "Home Office". Hansard 555. 2 July 1956. p. c1060. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "House of Commons Catering". Hansard 704. 21 December 1964. p. c166. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "Housing Shortage". Hansard 414. 17 October 1945. p. c1257–60. Retrieved 25 October 2015.
- Klugmann, James (January 1960). "The Foundation of the Communist Party of Great Britain". Marxism Today 4 (1).
- "Liverpool Cotton Market". Hansard 421. 28 March 1946. p. c626. Retrieved 25 October 2015.
- "Mode of Operation". Hansard 572. 3 July 1957. p. cc1218–22. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "Mrs Braddock loses her case". The Manchester Guardian. 12 November 1948. p. 3. (subscription required)
- "Mrs Braddock may leave executive". The Guardian. 15 August 1969. p. 16.
- "Mrs Braddock's appeal fails". The Manchester Guardian. 23 June 1949. p. 3. (subscription required)
- "Mrs Braddock's libel action". The Manchester Guardian. 11 November 1948. p. 6. (subscription required)
- "Not so safe on the aldermanic bench". The Guardian. 24 May 1961. p. 14.
- "Obituary: Mrs Bessie Braddock". The Guardian. 14 November 1970.
- "Rhodesia Resolution Banned". The Guardian. 3 October 1968. p. 18.
- "Textile Industry". Hansard 498. 26 March 1952. p. cc726–30. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "The Liberals". The Manchester Guardian. 4 July 1945. p. 4. (subscription required)
- Weidberg, Lawrence (April 1964). "A Labour leader looks back (1964)". Social Standard.
- Williams, Rob (14 October 2013). "My dear you are ugly, but tomorrow I shall be sober and you will still be ugly: Winston Churchill tops poll of history's funniest insults". The Independent. Retrieved 1 November 2015.
- Wright, Jade (11 June 2011). "100 hundred years on, Jade Wright looks back at Liverpool general transport strike". The Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
- "A blue plaque for Bessie Braddock". heraldscotland. 2000. Retrieved 1 November 2015.
- Coslett, Paul (2009). "The people: Bessie Braddock". BBC Liverpool. Retrieved 1 November 2015.
- Davies, Sam (1999). "Liverpool Labour Party and Trades Council" (PDF). Microform Academic Publishers. Retrieved 20 October 2015.
- Davies, Sam (2004). "Braddock, John". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edition. Retrieved 22 October 2015. (subscription required)
- Ingham, Robert (2005). "Braddock [née Bamber], Elizabeth Margaret". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edition. Retrieved 22 October 2015. (subscription required)
- "Local Legends: "Battling Bessie"". BBC History. 16 January 2004. Retrieved 18 October 2015.
- McCabe, Sarah (2004). "Silverman, (Samuel) Sydney". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edition. Retrieved 22 October 2015. (subscription required)
- Nandy, Lisa (15 October 2014). "Rising Voices: How feminism can open up politics". The Fabian Society. Retrieved 11 November 2015.
- Pröbsting, Michael (October 2013). "Healy’s Pupils Fail to Break with their Master". Revolutionary Communist International Tendency. Retrieved 25 October 2015.
- "Royal Commission on the Law Relating to Mental Illness and Mental Deficiency (Percy Commission)". The National Archives. 1957. Retrieved 28 October 2015.
- "Summerskill, Edith Clara (1901–1980)". LSE Library Services. 2010. Retrieved 28 October 2015.
- "The Blitz: Dark Days". Liverpool Ambulance Service. Retrieved 22 October 2015.
- "The Workhouse Site". The Metropolitan Cathedral of Christ the King, Liverpool. Retrieved 18 October 2015.
- "Tryweryn: The Drowning of a Village". BBC iWonder. 2015. Retrieved 29 October 2015.
- "TUC Timeline: The Union Makes Us Strong". London Metropolitan University. Retrieved 17 October 2015.
- Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by Bessie Braddock
- Watch Anglia News from 1962 with Braddock speech recorded in Norfolk
|Parliament of the United Kingdom|
John Joseph Shute
|Member of Parliament for Liverpool Exchange