Bingham Canyon Mine
Mine in 2003
|Location||Salt Lake County|
Bingham Canyon Open Pit Copper Mine
|NRHP Reference #||66000736|
|Added to NRHP||November 13, 1966|
|Designated NHL||November 13, 1966|
The Bingham Canyon Mine, more commonly known as Kennecott Copper Mine among locals, is an open-pit mining operation extracting a large porphyry copper deposit southwest of Salt Lake City, Utah, USA, in the Oquirrh Mountains. The mine is the largest man-made excavation in the world. The mine is owned by Rio Tinto Group, an international mining and exploration company headquartered in the United Kingdom. The copper operations at Bingham Canyon Mine are managed through Kennecott Utah Copper Corporation which operates the mine, a concentrator plant, a smelter, and a refinery. The mine has been in production since 1906, and has resulted in the creation of a pit over 0.6 miles (970 m) deep, 2.5 miles (4 km) wide, and covering 1,900 acres (770 ha). It was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1966 under the name Bingham Canyon Open Pit Copper Mine. The mine experienced a massive landslide in April 2013 and a smaller slide in September 2013.
Minerals, in the form of copper ore, were first discovered in Bingham Canyon in 1848 by two brothers, Sanford and Thomas Bingham, sons of Erastus Bingham, Mormon pioneers of September 1847, who grazed their cattle there. They reported their find to their leader, Brigham Young, who advised against pursuing mining operations because the survival and establishment of settlements was of paramount importance at that time. The brothers applied themselves to that purpose as directed and did not stake a claim. In 1850, the Bingham family went to settle what is now Weber County, leaving the canyon still today known by their name.
It was not until 17 Sept. 1863 that extraction of ore began and the potential of the canyon's mineral resources began to be widely recognized. That was when George B. Ogilvie and 23 others "located the West Jordan claim", soon followed by the Vidette claim. At first, mining was confined to placer gold, lead-silver and copper-gold. Porphyry copper required processing and a railroad, which reached the canyon in 1873.:61–62
Enos Andrew Wall started working claims in 1887. His extensive tunnels and test pits, on his 200 acres, indicated ore containing 2% copper.:38,64–65
The canyon's 19th Century mines were relatively small, but it wasn't until the end of the century that very large-scale exploitation of the canyon's ore bodies began to develop with open-pit mining. In 1896, Samuel Newhouse and Thomas Weir acquired the Highland Boy Mine, which was rich in copper, silver and gold. Together they formed the Utah Consolidated Gold Mines, Ltd. with English investors. They then formed the Boston Consolidated Gold and Copper Co., Ltd., for development of low-grade copper ore adjacent to the Utah Copper Company site.:93–94
Another significant development took place in 1903, when Daniel C. Jackling and Enos A. Wall organized the Utah Copper Company. Utah Copper immediately began construction of a pilot mill at Copperton, just beyond the mouth of the canyon, and the company actually started mining in 1906.
The success of Utah Copper in mining the huge but low-grade porphyry copper type ore body at Bingham Canyon was based on Jacklin's 1904 decision to use open-pit mining, steam shovels and the railroad. The mine became a showplace for "railroad-pit operations" and the industrial complex defined by the mine and the ASARCO smelting operation made it the "largest industrial mining complex in the world" by 1912.:168–170
Utah Copper and Boston Consolidated merged after their separate surface operations approached each other in 1906. The Kennecott Copper Corporation, established to operate mines in Kennecott, Alaska, purchased a 25 percent financial interest in Utah Copper in 1915, which they increased to 75 percent in 1923.:82,151
Bingham's Canyon mine expanded rapidly, and by the 1920s the region was a beehive of activity. Some 15,000 people of widely varying ethnicity lived in the canyon, in large residential communities constructed on the steep canyon walls. The population declined rapidly as mining techniques improved, and several of the mining camps were swallowed up by the ever-expanding mine. By 1980, when Lark was dismantled, only Copperton, at the mouth of Bingham Canyon and with a population of 800, remained.
The 21 separate mining operations in existence by 1911 were consolidated into two in 1970: Kennecott and The Anaconda Minerals Company. In 1985 open-pit mining operations were halted by Kennecott's Utah Copper. In 1986, Kennecott discovered gold in nearby Barney's Canyon.
KCC was purchased by Sohio in 1981 and the mine reopened in 1987 after BP Minerals purchased the assets. In 1989 the Rio Tinto Group acquired the asset, who modernized the mine, mill and smelter.:9
The open-pit owners replaced an antiquated 1000-car railroad with conveyor belts and pipelines for transporting the ore and waste, which reduced costs by nearly 30% and returned the operation to profitability.
At 9:30 pm on April 10, 2013, a landslide occurred at the mine. It was the largest non-volcanic landslide in the history of North America. Around 65–70 million cubic meters (2.3×109–2.5×109 cu ft) of dirt and rock thundered down the side of the pit. Understanding that the mine's steep walls made it a high risk for landslides, an interferometric radar system had been installed to monitor the ground's stability. As a result of warnings produced by this system, mining operations were shut down the previous day in anticipation of the slide. There were no injuries. The massive slide is expected to cut production of mined copper by 100,000 tonnes (110,000 short tons). A second slide caused an evacuation of 100 workers on September 11, 2013.
According to environmental specialists, the mine has had adverse environmental effects on the habitats of fish and wild animals as well as air and water pollution, creating health hazards to the surrounding public. Different federal agencies concerned with environmental conservation have used strict legal rules to pressure the subsidiary of Kennecott copper mine to comply with environmental regulations. Since the early 1990s, Kennecott has spent more than $400 million on clean up efforts on the affected areas to avoid regulatory laws that would have placed them on the Superfund National Priorities List (NPL).
The Bingham Canyon ore deposits occur in the Bingham nappe. They are a porphyry copper deposit, formed by a quartz monzonite porphyry intruded into sedimentary rocks. They exhibit a concentric alteration pattern and mineralogic zonation around the Bingham stock. These zones include a central core containing magnetite, followed by "a molybdenite zone low in copper, a bornite-chalcopyrite-gold higher grade copper zone, a pyrite-chalcopyrite zone, a pyrite zone, and an outermost lead-zinc zone.":E1,E8
Structurally, Late Paleozoic rocks were thrust faulted over the Precambrian craton during the Cretaceous Sevier orogeny. These rocks were later intruded and altered in the Tertiary by granitoid rocks. This igneous event was the source of deposition of gold, silver and other base metals.:E4
Copper and molybdenum sulfide minerals are dispersed in the intruded stock and in the adjoining carbonate sedimentary skarns. The main stratigraphic rocks in Bingham Canyon are Upper Pennsylvanian sandstones, quartzites, and limestones known as the Bingham Mine Formation in the Oquirrh Group. The central porphyry ores formed from mantle hydrothermal circulation while the outer vein and deposits in the sedimentary rocks formed at lower temperature when magmatic and meteoric waters mixed.
The extracted ore is treated at the Kennecott smelter at nearby Magna, Utah. The ore is run through a concentrator, where huge grinding mills reduce it to the consistency of face powder. Flotation then separates the gangue from the metalliferous particles, which float off as a 28-percent concentrate of copper along with lesser amounts of silver, gold, lead, molybdenum, platinum and palladium. A selective flotation step separates the molybdenite (molybdenum disulfide) from the chalcopyrite.
The filtered concentrate slurry is piped 17 miles (27 km) to the smelter, where it is dried, and then injected along with oxygen into a flash smelting furnace to oxidize the iron and sulfur. The oxidized iron is skimmed off, while the sulfur dioxide gas is captured and sent to an on-site acid plant for conversion to valuable sulfuric acid - a million tons of it each year.
Left behind is a molten copper sulfide called matte. The 70-percent-copper matte is water-quenched to form a sand-like solid, then injected, with oxygen, into a flash-converting furnace that produces molten, 98.6-percent-pure copper. This copper is then cast into 700-pound (320 kg) anode plates and shipped by rail to the refinery.
At the refinery, the anode plates are pressed flat and interleaved with stainless steel cathode blanks. Automated robotic vehicles place the prepared anodes in cells containing an acidic electrolyte. When the cells are electrified, the anodes slowly dissolve, freeing copper ions that are deposited on the cathode as 99.99-percent-pure copper.
Kennecott’s Bingham Canyon Mine is the largest man-made excavation in the world, and some[who?] claim that it is the only manmade feature visible to the naked eye from an orbiting space shuttle. Employing 1,800 employees and hundreds of contractors[when?], 450,000 short tons (400,000 long tons; 410,000 t) of material are removed from the mine daily. Electric shovels can carry up to 56 cubic yards (43 m3) or 98 short tons (88 long tons; 89 t) of ore in a single scoop. Ore is loaded into a fleet of 64 large dump trucks which each carry 255 short tons (228 long tons; 231 t) of ore at a time; the trucks themselves cost about $3 million each. There is a five-mile (8 km) series of conveyors that take ore to the Copperton concentrator and flotation plant. The longest conveyor is 3 miles (4.8 km) long.
As of 2010, Kennecott Utah Copper was the second largest copper producer in the US, and provided about 13-18% percent of the U.S.'s copper needs. It is one of the top producing copper mines in the world with production at more than 18.7 million short tons (16.7 million long tons; 17.0 Mt). Every year, Kennecott produces approximately 300 thousand short tons (272 kt or 268 thousand long tons) of copper, along with 400 thousand troy ounces (13.7 short tons 12.4 tonnes, or 12.2 long tons) of gold, 4 million troy ounces (124 tonnes, 137 short tons or 122 long tons) of silver, about 10 thousand short tons (9,100 tonnes or 8,900 long tons) of molybdenum, and about a million short tons (910 kt or 890 thousand long tons) of sulfuric acid, a by-product of the smelting process. Rio Tinto purchased Kennecott Utah Copper in 1989 and has invested about $2 billion in the modernization of KUC’s operations.
The current mine plan will expire in 2019. Rio Tinto has been studying a plan to extend the open pit 1,000 feet (305 m) southward, which would extend the life of the mine into the mid-2030s. The plan has been contingent on approval by the Rio Tinto board of directors and approximately 25 required environmental permits.
Bingham Canyon has proven to be one of the world's most productive mines. As of 2004, its ore yielded more than 17 million tons (15.4 Mt) of copper, 23 million ounces (715 t) of gold, 190 million ounces (5,900 t) of silver, and 850 million pounds (386 kt) of molybdenum. The value of the resources extracted from the Bingham Canyon Mine is greater than the Comstock Lode, Klondike, and California gold rush mining regions combined. Mines in Chile, Indonesia, Arizona, and New Mexico now[when?] exceed Bingham Canyon's annual production rate. High molybdenum prices in 2005 made the molybdenum produced at Bingham Canyon in that year worth more than the copper. The value of metals produced in 2006 at Bingham Canyon was US$1.8 billion.
In 1990, homes that had been built on former flood plains were discovered to be contaminated with high levels of lead and arsenic. Activities to clean up 100 years of accumulated impacts began in the 1990s, under state Utah Department of Environmental Quality and federal oversight and are ongoing.
The EPA lists "Kennecott South Zone/Bingham" on its superfund webpage, because it was proposed to be listed as a superfund site in 1994. The South Zone includes the Bingham Mining District in the Oquirrh Mountains, about 25 miles southwest of Salt Lake City, the open pit, waste rock dumps, Copperton Mill and other historic sites. The company avoided regulatory issues of being on the NPL by voluntarily cleaning up the contaminated lands, the so-called Superfund Alternative Approach. The listing proposal was withdrawn in 2008. More than 25 million tons of mining wastes have been removed, sludge with elevated sulfate concentrations was consolidated and capped on site.
By 1904, there were three large copper smelters and one lead smelter in the Salt Lake valley. The sulfur dioxide gas emissions from the smokestacks caused significant crop damage to neighboring crops. During the 1904-1905 winter, the farmers gathered together and decided to file suit against the smelters in the United States District Court of Utah. In 1906, Federal Court Judge Marshall ruled that the smelters could not smelt ores containing more than 10% sulfur, effectively closing all of the aforementioned smelters.
Kennecott Copper Mines was formed in 1910 after a merger of Utah Copper and Kennecott copper mining companies. By 1912, environmental protection organizations were complaining about high levels of asbestos being used in the organization. Kennecott Corporation was using asbestos for preventing fires since copper processing requires very high temperatures. Copper has a very high boiling point and also requires use of other chemicals to separate it from other metals and impurities present in the ore. Asbestos has microscopic particles that dispersed into the atmosphere and contributed to illnesses among workers and individuals living near the mines. Asbestos is responsible for illnesses such as pleural fibrosis, skin warts and lung cancer.
Kennecott Corporation was also cited as contributing to emissions of heavy metals such as arsenic and mercury. By 1940, arsenic and mercury were also some of the concerns that were raised by environmental protection agencies against Kennecott Corporation. Both mercury and arsenic are dangerous to health in large quantities.
|1989||100,000,000 gal (est)||Process water containing arsenic||Unknown|
Investigations in the 1980s revealed contamination in the groundwater caused by mining operations the release of hazardous materials. The State of Utah proceeded with legal action against Kennecott and filed a damage claim against the mine in October, 1986, for the loss and destruction of the natural resources, specifically the groundwater.
There was also a threat due to the tailings dam. An engineering report in March, 1988, gave information that the tailings dam overshadowing the town of Magna had threat of collapse due to an earthquake and that the billion-ton tailings pond would bury the homes nearby if the tailing pond’s embankment failed. The mine responded by proposing various potential strategies including buying up entire subdivisions near the tailings pond, calculating the company’s liability if the embankment failed, investing $500 million to reinforce the embankment, and colluding with state regulators to keep the engineering report out of the public eye.
|1999||100,000,000 gal (est)||Process water containing arsenic||Unknown|
|1998||unknown||Acid rock drainage||Clogged pipe|
|1997||unknown||Copper sulphate||Clogged outlet valve|
|1997||unknown||Process water with pH 2.5-4.0||Ruptured pipeline|
|1993||45,000 gal||Wastewater||Transfer line rupture|
|1991||30,000 gal||Industrial wastewater||Line break|
Starting in the beginning of 1990s, dust emissions from mining began polluting surrounding areas, caused by an area near the mine where PM10 levels (particulate matter larger than 10 µg/m³) began to rise from 28μg/m³ to 50μg/m³, posing a severe health concerns for residents. The first report of PM10 rising was proposed by Schwartz and Dockery in 1992. Then, in 1997, Carter (a professor at Brigham Young University) put forward that the mine discharge of PM10 has caused lung damage to neighboring residents.
As a result of mine discharge sewage containing large amounts of arsenic and selenium – selenium being particularly toxic to birds, fish and amphibians – about 30% of the fish population were killed in the early 1990s. In 1995 Kennecott, EPA and the State of Utah signed an agreement saying that Kennecott will continue to clean up the discharge sewage.
|2011||145,424 gal||Copper tailings||Equipment malfunction|
|2011||100,000-290,000 gal||Copper tailings||Unknown|
|2010||4,000-5,000 gal||Sulfuric acid||Unknown|
|2007||1,240,000 gal||Process water containing arsenic||Cold temperatures|
|2006||270,000 gal||Process water||Pump failure|
|2006||660,000 gal||Process water containing arsenic||Cracked pipe|
|2006||1,000,000 gal||Process water||Failed indicator|
|2004||4,000,000 gal||Process water containing arsenic||Cracked pipe|
|2004||2,000,000 gal||Process water containing arsenic||Ruptured process water line|
|2004||202,000 gal||Process water||Pipeline failure|
|2003||70 tons||Copper concentrate||Unknown|
|2003||10.27 tons||Copper concentrate containing arsenic, copper and lead||Pipeline rupture|
|2003||240,681 tons||Copper, arsenic and lead||Copper concentrate pipeline rupture|
|2002||5,800 gal||Process water from slag pot||Plugged drain line|
|2001||19 lbs||Arsenic, chromium and lead||Tailings pipeline failure|
|2000||110 tons||Ore slurry||Leak in ore line|
|2000||18,000 tons||Sulfuric acid||Flange failure|
The EPA has estimated a 72-mile plume of contaminated groundwater has been created over the course of the mine due to multiple spills and runoff. Long-term effects of the underground water supply contamination may include an increased demand for surface water solutions as the population of the Salt Lake valley grows since the county will not be able to tap into the groundwater supply.
In 2007, Kennecott Utah Copper LLC was considering expanding its land holdings to Rose Canyon Ranch in the southern Oquirrh mountains and Yellow Fork Canyon land in Salt Lake County. Kennecott claims rights to file a mining claim in accordance with the Stock-Raising Homestead Act of 1916.
In 2008, the United States Department of Interior Fish and Wildlife Service sued Kennecott after the release of hazardous substances including selenium, copper, arsenic, zinc, lead, and cadmium. A federal biologist claimed that these chemicals have caused great damage to the ecosystems and resources that support the migrant bird populations, as well as other fish and wildlife habitats.
In the northern zone near Magna, Utah, the extensive southern tailings pond has been collecting the tailings since the mine first started mining production. Kennecott Utah Copper LLC has requested permission for a Tailings Expansion Project (TEP) to expand the tailings pond impoundment in Magna, which is already at 1.8 billion ton capacity, and to expand on 721 new acres of wetlands south of the Great Salt Lake. The company has come under scrutiny for the instability of the structure. The Salt Lake Tribune published a report in 2007 revealing that the company failed to disclose information on possible damages that could occur if the tailings pond collapsed in the event of a major earthquake. From 2001 through 2009 there have been six earthquakes ranging from 2.3 to 3.4 in magnitude with an average epicenter only 3 miles away from Magna.
In popular culture
Bingham Canyon Mine was featured in the 1973 made-for-TV movie Birds of Prey, with protagonist helicopter pilot Harry Walker (played by David Janssen) piloting his Hughes 500 into the crater to track down three bank robbers and their female hostage in an Aérospatiale SA 315B Lama, which was hiding behind heavy mining machinery.
- National Park Service (2007-01-23). "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service.
- "Bingham Canyon Open Pit Copper Mine". National Historic Landmark summary listing. National Park Service. Retrieved 2008-07-12.
- Mcfarland, Sheena. "Kennecott Copper Mine recovering faster than predicted". The Salt Lake Tribune. The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 28 April 2015.
- Lee, Jasen. "Kennecott laying off 200 workers". DeseretNews.com. Retrieved 2016-03-06.
- Second landslide hits Rio's Bingham Canyon mine, 100 workers evacuated 16 September 2013
- Crump, Scott (1994), "Bingham Canyon", in Powell, Allan Kent, Utah History Encyclopedia, Salt Lake City, Utah: University of Utah Press, ISBN 0874804256, OCLC 30473917
- The Descendants of Erastus Bingham and Lucinda Gates, Ogden, Utah: Bingham Family Corp, 1970. pp. 3-4.
- Charles Caldwell Hawley (2014). A Kennecott Story. The University of Utah Press. pp. 37–40.
- Edwin W. Tooker (1990). Gold in Bingham District, Utah in USGS Bulletin 1857 Gold in Copper Porphyry Copper Systems. United States Government Printing Office. p. E2.
- Tasa, Frederick K. Lutgens, Edward J. Tarbuck ; illustrated by Dennis (2012). Essentials of geology (11th ed.). Boston: Prentice Hall. p. 57. ISBN 978-0321714725.
- "Sizing up the Landslide at Bingham Canyon Mine". Earth Observatory. NASA.
- Romero, McKenzie; Adams, Andrew (April 11, 2013). "Massive landslide stops production at Bingham Canyon Mine". Deseret News.
- "Bingham slide could cut output by 110,000 ST". Mining Engineering. April 17, 2013.
- Bell and Laurance J. Donnelly., Fred G. (2006). Mining and its Impact on the Environment. CRC Press.
- "Kennecott Utah Copper's South End Removed from the National Priorities List" (PDF). www.kennecott.com. Kennecott. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- Bingham Mining: crushing and conveying the ore. Mining World Company. 1911-01-01.
- "Kennecott Utah Copper's Bingham Canyon Mine". Utah.com. Retrieved July 11, 2010.
- "Bingham Canyon". Global InfoMine. Retrieved July 11, 2010.
- Voynick, Steve. "Bingham Canyon Copper: Finding Chalcopyrite at "The Richest Hole on Earth"". Retrieved July 11, 2010.
- "National Energy Foundation's Out of The Rock" (PDF (2.1MB)). Rio Tinto. p. 22. Retrieved 6 May 2010.
- "Bingham Canyon extension could extend life of mine to mid-2030s by moving south wall," Mining Engineering, October 2010, p.10.
- Bon, R.L.; Krahulec, K.A. (May 2006). Utah, Mining Engineering. p. 117.
- Bon, R.L.; Krahulec, K.A. (May 2007). Utah, Mining Engineering. p. 120.
- "Kennecott South Zone / Bingham". EPA. Retrieved 8 May 2014.
- Butler, Kaitlin (11 April 2014). "When the copper is gone, our children will get the pit". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 8 May 2014.
- "EPA withdraws proposal to list Kennecott South Zone as Superfund site". Region 8 superfund. EPA. 3 September 2008. Retrieved 8 May 2014.
- EPA Superfund Program: Kennecott South Zone, Copperton, UT EPA, 26 April 2016
- Arrington and Gary B. Hansen, Leonard J. (1963). "The richest hole on earth: a history of the Bingham copper mine." (PDF). Utah State Univ Pr. 11 (1).
- "United States Investor". Volume 17, Part 2 (27-52).
- Richards, Deanna J. (1997). The Industrial Green Game:: Implications for Environmental Design and Management. National Academies Press.
- Miller and Scott Spoolman, George (2011). Living in the environment: principles, connections, and solutions. Cengage Learning.
- "Miglietta v. Kennecott Copper Corporation.". Appellate Division of Supreme Court of the State of New York. 25 A.D.2d 57, 266 N.Y.S.2d 936. 1966. Retrieved June 10, 2014.
- Frosch & Gallopoulos, N, Robert (1992). "Towards an industrial ecology." The treatment and handling of wastes. Chapman & Hall. pp. 269–292.
- Eppinger, Robert (2000). "Environmental Geochemical studies of selected Mineral Deposits". US Geological survey professional paper.
- "Kennecott Copper Mine". he Mesothelioma Cancer Alliance at Mesothelioma.com. he Mesothelioma Cancer Alliance at Mesothelioma.com. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- "EPA Superfund Record of Decision" (PDF). EPA.gov. EPA. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- "Kennecott Utah Copper Company: Natural Resource Damage Claim and Settlement". Southern Utah University; Michael O. Leavitt Center for Politics and Public Service. Southern Utah University. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- "Problems with Bingham Canyon Mine" (PDF). Earthworksaction.org. EARTHWORKS. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- Fahys, Judy (March 24, 2008). "Special Report: How Kennecott concealed warnings of a possible disaster from the people of Magna". Salt Lake Tribune. Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- Archer, Victor E. (1990). "Air pollution and fatal lung disease in three Utah counties." (PDF). Archives of Environmental Health. 45 (6): 325–334. doi:10.1080/00039896.1990.10118751.
- "THE TRACK RECORD OF WATER QUALITY IMPACTS RESULTING FROM PIPELINE SPILLS, TAILINGS FAILURES AND WATER COLLECTION AND TREATMENT FAILURES" (PDF). http://www.patagoniaalliance.org/. EARTHWORKS. Retrieved 23 June 2014. External link in
- Dethman, Leigh (Sep 19, 2008). "Kennecott eyes land in canyon". Deseret News. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- "Scoping Summary Report: Kennecott Utah Copper LLC Tailings Expansion Project" (PDF). United States Department of the Army Corp of Engineers. August 2011. Retrieved 23 June 2014.
- Charles Caldwell Hawley. (September 15, 2014) A Kennecott Story: Three Mines, Four Men, and One Hundred Years, 1887-1997. University of Utah Press, ISBN 1607813696, 336 pages
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Bingham Canyon Mine.|
- Kennecott's Home Page
- Kennecott Copper Mine. Utah Teacher Guide
- John Hollenhorst Kennecott Begins Major Expansion Project, 17 Nov, 2005, ksl.com
- To Move A Mountain: A History of Mining and Railroads in Bingham Canyon
- Photo gallery
- Visiting the mine utahoutdooractivities.com
- Panoramic View of the Bingham Canyon Mine 3d-exposure.com
- Photos of the 2013 landslide ksl.com
- Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) No. UT-21, "Utah Copper Company, Bingham Canyon Mine, State Route 48, Copperton, Salt Lake County, UT", 26 photos, 4 measured drawings, 2 photo caption pages