This article may require copy editing for grammar, style, cohesion, tone, or spelling. (September 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
A black legend (Spanish: leyenda negra) is a historiographical phenomenon where a sustained trend in historical writing of biased reporting and introduction of fabricated, exaggerated and/or decontextualized facts is directed against particular persons, nations or institutions with the intention of creating a distorted and uniquely inhuman image of them while hiding their positive contributions to history.
The term was first used by Arthur Lévy in his work Napoléon Intime, in contrast to the expression "Golden Legend" that had been in circulation around Europe since the publication of the book of that name in the Middle Ages. Lévy writes: "However, if we study the life of the emperor properly, we will soon get rid of the legends, both the golden legend, and the legend that we may call the Napoleonic black legend. This is the truth: Napoleon was not a God, nor was he a monster." (Napoleon Intime) This description clearly summarizes the essence of a black legend, which is often associated with a golden legend.
Historian Alfredo Alvar defined a black legend as:
"The careful distortion of the history of a nation, perpetrated by its enemies, in order to better fight it. And a distortion as monstrous as possible, with the goal of achieving a specific aim: the moral disqualification of the nation, whose supremacy must be fought in every way possible."— Alfredo Alvar, La Leyenda Negra (1997:5)
Even though black legends are not just a Spanish phenomenon, the term "The Black Legend" has come to refer specifically to "The Spanish Black Legend" (Spanish: La leyenda negra), a hypothesis according to which political propaganda from the 16th century or earlier about Spain, the Spanish Empire, and Hispanic America, was "absorbed and converted into broadly held stereotypes" that assumed that Spain was "uniquely evil.".
According to this hypothesis, the absorption of political propaganda and fabrications into mainstream academia, along with their use to cover up inconvenient facts about other nations, resulted in a systematic repetition of such bias and distortion of Spanish history as perceived both in and out of the country. A common example of this would be the Spanish inquisition.
- 1 The Spanish Black Legend
- 2 Unique aspects
- 3 About
- 4 Distribution
- 5 Core elements
- 6 Origins
- 7 Development
- 8 Others
- 9 Reception and criticism
- 10 Modern manifestations
- 11 White Legend
- 12 See also
- 13 Notes
- 14 Further reading
The Spanish Black Legend
The expression "black legend" was borrowed by Spanish historians and intellectuals for a long time to refer to specific aspects of their history. Antonio Soler used it regarding the portrayal of some Castilian monarchs within Spanish history, for example. However, it was Emilia Pardo Bazán at a conference in Paris on April 18, 1899, who used it for the first time to refer to a generalized view of Spain as a whole. She declared:
Abroad our miseries are known and often exaggerated without balance: take as an example the book by M. Yves Guyot, which we can consider as the perfect model of a black legend, the opposite of a golden legend. The Spanish black legend is a straw man for those who seek convenient examples to support certain political theses (...) The black legend replaces our contemporary history in favour of a novel, genre Ponson du Terrail, with mines and countermines, that doesn't even deserve the honor of analysis [at the conference].
This conference had a great impact inside and outside of Spain. In Spain the torch was passed to various historians making reference to the Spanish Black Legend (Spanish: La leyenda negra española, or simply La leyenda negra), among them Julián Juderías. He was the first historian to describe and denounce this phenomenon in an organized way, providing the first definition of "a black legend" as well as the first description of "The (Spanish) Black Legend". His book The Black Legend and the Historical Truth (Spanish: La Leyenda Negra y la Verdad Histórica), a critique published in 1914, claimed that this type of biased historiography had presented Spanish history in a deeply negative light, purposely ignoring positive achievements or advances. In his book, Juderías defines The (Spanish) Black Legend as:
the environment created by the fantastic stories about our homeland that have been published in all countries, the grotesque descriptions that have always been made of the character of Spaniards as individuals and collectively, the denial or at least the systematic ignorance of all that is favorable and beautiful in the various manifestations of culture and art, the accusations that in every era have been flung against Spain.
Later writers have supported and developed Juderías's critique. In 1958, Charles Gibson wrote that "Spain and the Spanish Empire were historically presented as cruel, bigoted, exploitative and self-righteous in excess of reality."
An image of Spain circulated through late sixteenth-century Europe, borne by means of political and religious propaganda that blackened the characters of Spaniards and their ruler to such an extent that Spain became the symbol of all forces of repression, brutality, religious and political intolerance, and intellectual and artistic backwardness for the next four centuries. Spaniards ... have termed this process and the image that resulted from it as ‘The Black Legend,’ la leyenda negra.
He also provided various examples of how it was still active in modern history:
Spaniards who came to the new world seeking opportunities beyond the prospects of their European environment are contemptuously called cruel and greedy "goldseekers," or other opprobrious epithets virtually synonymous with Devils; but Englishmen who sought New World opportunities are more respectfully called "colonists," or "homebuilders," or "seekers after liberty." (...) When Spaniards expelled or punished religious dissidents that was called "bigotry," "intolerance," "fanaticism" ... When Englishmen, Dutchmen, or Frenchmen did the same thing, it is known as "unifying the nation,"...
The hypothesis of a Spanish black legend assimilating anti-Hispanic propaganda from the 16th and 17th centuries has a high level of acceptance among specialists, but the extent of its reach and the data it affected, and what happened instead, is still debated, especially regarding the Spanish Conquest of America, where few written sources have been proven reliable. Historians are now exploring genetic as well as new scientific and statistical investigative techniques.
There is also debate regarding whether it is still in effect today. While some authors like Powell consider that the black legend keeps determining modern day policies and international relationships, other authors, like Richard Kamen, believe it has been left behind.
According to historian Elvira Roca Barea the formation of a Black Legend and its assimilation by the nation that suffers it is a phenomenon observed in all multicultural empires, not just on the Spanish Empire. The black legend of empires would be the result of the following combined factors:
- The combined propaganda attacks and efforts of most smaller powers of the time, as well as defeated rivals.
- The propaganda created by the many rival power factions within the Empire itself against each other as part of their struggle to win more power.
- The self-criticism of the intellectual elite, which tends to be larger in larger Empires.
- The need of the new powers consolidated during the Empire´s life or after its dissolution to justify their new prevalence and the new order.
Said black legend tends to fade once the next great power is established or that enough time has gone by.
However, the factors that would set the Spanish Black Legend apart from others, would be its abnormal permeation and outreach across nations,its racialized component, and its abnormal persistence through time. The causes of this would be:
- The overlap of the period of splendour of the Spanish Empire with the introduction of the printing press in England and Germany, that allowed the propaganda of such colonial and religious rivals to spread faster and wider than never before, and persist in time way after the disappearance of said Empire.
- Permanence after the dissolution of the empire due to religious factors.
- The dismantling and substitution of the Spanish intellectual class by another favorable to former rival-France- after the War of the Spanish Succession, which established the French narrative in the country.
- The unique characteristics of the colonial wars of the early contemporary period and the need of new colonial powers to legitimate claims in now independent Spanish colonies, as well as the unique and new characteristics of the Empire that succeeded it, the British Empire.
Edward Peters, states in his work "Inquisition":
The inquisition was regarded outside of Spain as a necessary cleansing, since all Spaniards were accused of having Moorish and Jewish ancestry. (...) First condemned by the impurity of their beliefs, the Spanish then came under fire for excess of zeal in defending Catholicism. Influenced by the political and religious policies of Spain, a common type of ethnic invective became an eloquent form of description by character assassination. So, when Bartolomé de las Casas wrote his criticism of certain governmental policies in the New World, his limited, persuasive, specific purpose was ignored.— Edward Peters, Inquisition
William S.Maltby, regarding Spain in the Netherlands.
As part of an Elizabethan campaign against Spain and the Catholic Church ...Literary hundreds of anti-Spanish publications appeared in English, Dutch, French, and German in the sisteenth century. New editions and New works restating old acusations would appear in the Thirty Years War and in other ocasons when it seemed useful to excite anti Spanish sentiment. Given the pervasiveness of such material it is not surprising that the authors of scholarly histories absorved anti-hispanism and transmitted it to later generations.— William S.Maltby, The Rise and Fall of the Spanish Empire
Richard Kagan regarding the Black Legend in the United States:
Compounding that perspective of Spain as an inferior ´other´ was the black legend, the centuries-old set of beliefs that the United States inherited from the British and, to a certain extent, from the Dutch...Such reading of Spanish history was overly simplistic but promoters of American excepcionalism found it useful.— Richard Kagan, Spain in America: The Origins of Hispanism in the United States
The Black Legend is said[by whom?] to affect most of Europe, especially Protestant and Anglican Europe, and France, as well as the Americas. There is, however, no significant trace of it in the Muslim world or Turkey despite the almost nine centuries of sustained war that Spain and the Islamic world were engaged into. This seems to reinforce the idea of a European origin.
As seen in the quotes of "about" there are no other core elements to the accusations of the black legend than those of being "the immoral other", whatever that might mean at the time. The accusations of mixed blood and loose religiosity of the 15th century were turned into accusations of religious fanaticism and Judaism in the 16th century, and of antisemitism in the 20th century. The only stable element is an element of "otherness" marked by interaction with the Eastern and African worlds, pf "complete others", cruelty and lack of moral character, in which the same narratives are re-imagined and reshaped, as Margaret R. Greer and Walter D. Mignolo indicate in their work "Reading the Black Legend. Discourses of Religion and Racial Difference".
Anti-Spanish sentiment appeared in many parts of Europe as the power of the Spanish empire grew. With the Habsburg realm, Spain dominated much of Western Europe (including present-day Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg and most of the Italian Peninsula). In 1555, Pope Paul IV described Spaniards as "heretics, schismatics, accursed of God, the offspring of Jews and Marranos, the very scum of the earth". During the Eighty Years' War, English and Dutch propaganda depicted Spaniards as bloodthirsty barbarians. In the following centuries anti-Spanish stereotypes circulated widely, especially in English, Dutch and German-speaking parts of Europe. This propaganda would depict exaggerated versions of the evils of Spanish colonial practices and the Spanish Inquisition. Various reasonable origins have been suggested for the Spanish Black legend.
Sverker Arnoldsson, from the University of Gothenburg, supports Juderías hypothesis of the existence of a Spanish Black Legend in European historiography, locates the origins of the Black Legend in medieval Italy, unlike previous authors who locate it in the 16th century. In his book The Black Legend. A Study of its Origins, Arnoldsson cites studies by Benedetto Croce and Arturo Farinelli to affirm that Italy in the 14th, 15th, and 16th centuries was extremely hostile to Spain, and considers that the texts produced and distributed there were later used as a base to build on by Protestant nations.
Arnoldsson's theory on the origins of The Black legend has been disputed as confusing the process of Black Legend generation with simply a negative view or a critique of a foreign power. In general, they raise the following objections:
- Just because the earliest writings against Spaniards were written in Italy, that is not sufficient reason to describe Italy as the origin of the Black Legend. It is a normal reaction in any society dominated by a foreign power.
- The phrase "black legend" suggests a certain "tradition", which did not exist in Italian writings based primarily on a reaction to the recent presence of Spanish troops, that faded quickly.
- In 15th- and 16th-century Italy there coexisted critics as well as Italian intellectuals that greatly admired Spain, specially Ferdinand II of Aragon.
William S. Maltby further argues that the Italian satyre lacks the "conducting theme", the common topic and narrative that would later form of the black legend in the Netherlands and England. Roca Barea also protests this idea and, even though she does not deny that Italian writings may have been used by German rivals, the Italian writings "lack the viciousness and blind deformation of black legend writings", and are just satyric reactions to an occupation. In general, the Italian origin hypothesis is a good field to explore and read about the difference between a black legend and a simply negative view.
Arnoldsson offered a second alternative to the Italian origin in its polar opposite, the German Renaissance. German humanism was deeply nationalistic and longed to create a German identity in opposition to the Roman invaders. However, both Ulrich of Hutten and Martin Luther, the main authors of the movement, combine the "Roman" in a wider concept of the "Latino, or "Welsche." This Latin world includes Spain, Portugal, France, and Italy, and is perceived as "foreign, immoral, chaotic and fake, in opposition to the moral, ordered and German."
In addition to the identification of Spaniards with Jews, heretics, and "Africans" (see "anti-Semitic origin") there was a clear increase in anti-Spanish propaganda among the detractors of Emperor Charles V. The propaganda against Charles V was deeply nationalistic and identified him with Spain and Rome, even though he was Flemish-born and -raised, with origins in a German dynasty, and spoke little Spanish and no Italian at the time, and was often at odds with the Papacy.
To further the appeal of their cause, rulers opposed to Charles focused on identifying Charles with the Pope, a view that Charles himself had started as a way to force the Spanish troops to accept involvement in his personal German wars, which they very much resisted as being none of their concern. The fact that the troops and supporters of Charles included German and Protestant princes and soldiers was an extra reason to focus attention on the rejection of the Spanish elements attached to them. It was necessary to create fear of Spanish rule, and to do so a certain image had to be created. At this point, the printing press would come into full action. Among the points most often highlighted was the identification of Spaniards with Moors and Jews due to the high level of intermarriage and the number of "conversos"(Jews or Muslims who had adopted Christianity) in their society, and with the "natural cruelty of those two."  The actual level of intermarriage probably varied by region, being effected by length under Andalucian rule and Iberian Christian stigmas such as Limpieza de sangre. Additionally, the Reconquista which played a major role in creating Castile, benefited substantially from contributions both in soldiers and settlers from all over western Europe, including, but not limited to adventurers of German origin.
Some authors maintain that various incidents with the troops of Charles V in Germany during the war contributed to development of the Black Legend, while others point out that although the majority of Charles's troops were German, atrocities were attributed exclusively to Spaniards, suggesting that the Black legend already existed prior to these events.
By the end of the 16th century the Black Legend had acquired clear race-based elements under the influence of Flemish and French writers. By this time the power of Spain had also grown enough to threaten France´s security, and the Flemish nobles had given up all hope of extending their influence in the Castilian and Aragonese courts as they had initially tried to do (see the Revolt of the Comuneros). This created fear in France and discontent in the Flemish nobility, who saw their comparative power diminished and were repeatedly denied their desire to participate in the conquest of America (see following point).
Anti-Islamic and Anti-Semitic origin
This origin combines elements of the German origin with the proofs of the anti-Hispanic narrative existing prior to the 16th century, and with the large number of parallelisms between anti-Spanish and anti-Semitic narratives in modern Europe, and it is among the ones that are gathering most support.
Roca Barea, among others, argues that The Black Legend is founded on a spin-off, a reused version of the anti-Semitic narratives forged and circulated through England and most of Central Europe from the 13th century on.
According to this view the Spanish Black Legend was created by transferring the already created "character" of the "cruel, gold lusty Jew" onto the Spanish nations. Since the narrative was familiar, the stereotype accepted, and the identification of Spaniards and Jews was already mainstream in Europe due to the long history of coexistence between both in Iberia, at a time in which the Jews had been expulsed from most of Europe, the Black legend was proptly believed and asimilated in central Europe.
This case has three main sources of proof, the texts of German Renaiscence Intellectuals, the existence of black legend narrative in Europe prior to the conquest of America, and the similarity of the stereotypes associated to judaism by anti-semitic Europe and those that the black legend attributed to the Spaniards.
Texts identifying Spaniards with "heretics" and "Jews" can be found in Germany from the 14th century, and various pieces of 15th- and 16th-century anti-Spanish propaganda are almost line by line copies of prior anti-semitic works. For example, the famous account of the mistreated Native Americans killing their oppressors by pouring melted gold on their heads is an exact copy of the same scene in the anti-semitic poem the Siege of Jerusalem. It also suggests that the deep anti-semitism in Luther´s works may have served a double function, nationalistic and anti Spanish as well as religious, if that identification between both was already in circulation.
Luther creates a particularly explicit correlation between "the Jew", already detested in Germany at the time, and "the Spanish", which had a growing power in the area. He describes both as "thieves, false, proud and lusty". It is hard to believe that the words of such an influentian thinker would go unnoticed. This animosity of Luther towards Spain, even though it still was not the power it would later become, is explained by Arnoldsson as follows:
- An identification of Italy and Spain with the papacy, even though the Papacy and Spain were bitter enemies at the time.
- His own antisemitism and the long history coexistence-and intermarriage-of Christians and Jews in Iberia -the Spanish royal line was known to have Jewish blood in it. Luther characterized Spaniards as «sunt plerunque Marani, Mamalucken»; Jews, sons of Jews".
- Identification of Spain and Turkey, and fear to an invasion by both.
Ideo prophetatum est Hispanos velle subigere Germaniam aut per se aut per alios, scilicet Turcam [...] Et ita Germania vexabitur et viribus ac bonis suis exhausta Hispanico regno subiugabitur. Eo tendit Sathan, quod Germaniam liberam perturbare tentat.— Luther
In 1566 Luther´s conversations are published. Among many other similar affirmations, he is quoted as writing:
[...] Spaniern [...], die essen gern weiss Brot vnd küssen gern weisse Meidlein, vnd sind sie stiffelbraun vnd Pechschwartz wie König Balthasar mit seinem Affen. (The Spanish eat white bread and kiss blonde women with all pleasure, but they are as brown and black as King Balthasar and his monkey".)— Johann Fischart, Geschichtklitterung (1575).
References to Spanish as "bad Christians", "Jews", "Moors" or racialized references associating said ancestry with lack of moral or general inferiority can be found uninterruptedly in black legend sources and political propaganda since the Middle Ages until well into the contemporary period.
This section does not cite any sources. (August 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
England is sometimes pointed at in relation to The Spanish Black Legend. England had a crucial role in its spread and use during colonial times, but it is also agreed that, no matter how much they added to it, the origin of the narrative was not here and actually reached the islands quite late in the game.
This element has been highlighted by American Hispanist Philip Wayne Powell. He stated that the criticisms spread by the Jews expelled by the Catholic Monarchs of Spain have been considered an important part in the spread of anti Hispanic sentiment, especially when it comes to religious stereotypes. Those accounts tend to characterize Spain as godless, heathen and idolactric, as opposed to fanatically catholic like other German sources, but as usual those two things were not seen as mutually exclusive.
Even though Jewish communities had already been expelled by almost all parts of Europe, including some of those who re-admitted them as a result of their feud with Spain, the level of criticism that the Sephardic Jews displayed was not seen regarding any other nation. Some of the explanations offered for this are that the Jewish community had never enjoyed such a golden period as they did in Spain, nor been so integrated, which made the expulsion more traumatic; that in other cases they were not so integrated in academic life; or that similar criticisms may have existed regarding other nations but found no amplifying mechanism in other parts of Europe and faded away, while the Sephardic Jews got enthusiastic listeners in Holland and the Netherlands.
The active involvement of expelled Sephardic Jews, particularly of former intellectuals, in spreading a distorted image of Spanish religious practices has been supported by the studies of Yosef Kaplan, Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi and Jaime Contreras.
The conquest of the Americas
In the process of European colonization of the Americas that lasted over three centuries, atrocities were committed by all nations, according to both contemporary opinion and modern moral standards. It is historically established fact that Spain's colonization involved murder, slavery (including sexual slavery) and genocide of Native peoples, and that these atrocities began during the Columbian voyages in the Caribbean. However, Spain did pass some laws for the protection of Native Americans. As early as 1512, the Laws of Burgos regulated the behavior of Europeans in the New World forbidding the ill-treatment of indigenous people and limiting the power of encomenderos—those who received royal grants of authority to impose forced labor on specific groups of natives. In 1542 the New Laws expanded and corrected the previous body of laws in order to improve their application. Although these laws were not always followed across all American territories — resulting in documented cruelty by slave owners and little ground for redress by the natives — they at least reflect the will of the Spanish colonial government of the time to protect the rights of the native population.
Testimonies of the time accuse Columbus of brutality against the natives and forced labor, and direct reports by members of his journey tell of murder, rape and enslavement in the words of the perpetrators. These atrocities led to debate within Spain itself about the treatment and rights of indigenous peoples in the Americas. In 1552, the Dominican friar Bartolomé de las Casas published the Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias (A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies), an account of atrocities committed by landowners and some officials during the early period of colonization of New Spain, particularly in Hispaniola (today Haiti and the Dominican Republic). Las Casas, son of the merchant Pedro de las Casas who accompanied Columbus on his second voyage, described Columbus's treatment of the natives in his History of the Indies. Their description of Spanish savagery was used by writers of Spain's rivals as a convenient basis for attacks on Spain which would later be referred to as The Black Legend. They were already used in Flemish anti-Spanish propaganda during the Eighty Years' War. Today the degree to which Las Casas's descriptions of Spanish colonization represent a reasonable or wildly exaggerated picture is still debated among some scholars. For example, historian Lewis Hanke considers Las Casas to have exaggerated the atrocities in his accounts and thereby contributed to Black Legend propaganda. Historian Benjamin Keen on the other hand found them likely to be more or less accurate. In Charles Gibson's 1964 monograph The Aztecs under Spanish Rule, the first comprehensive study of the documentary sources of relations between Indians and Spaniards in New Spain (colonial Mexico), he concludes that the Black Legend "builds upon the record of deliberate sadism. It flourishes in an atmosphere of indignation which removes the issue from the category of objective understanding. It is insufficient in its understanding of institutions of colonial history."
This historical ill-treatment of Amerindians, also occurring in other European colonies in the Americas, was used as propaganda in works of competing European powers to create animosity against the Spanish Empire. The work of Las Casas was first cited in English with the 1583 publication The Spanish Colonie, or Brief Chronicle of the Actes and Gestes of the Spaniards in the West Indies, at a time when England was preparing for war against Spain in the Netherlands. The biased use of such works, including the distortion or exaggeration of their contents, is part of the anti-Spanish historical propaganda or Black Legend.
From the perspective of history and the colonization of the Americas, all European powers that colonized the Americas, such as England, Portugal, the Netherlands and others, were guilty of the ill-treatment of indigenous peoples. Colonial powers have been also accused of genocide in Canada, the United States, and Australia. These issues have received greater scholarly attention over recent years and have led to and evolution in historiographical evaluations of the effects of colonialism. "At least three generations of scholarship have produced a more balanced appreciation of Spanish conduct in both the Old World and the New, while the dismal records of other imperial powers have received a more objective appraisal."
Spain's war with the United Provinces and in particular the victories and atrocities of the Duke of Alba contributed to the anti-Spanish propaganda. Sent in August 1567 to counter political unrest in a part of Europe where printing presses were a source of heterodox opinion, especially against the Roman Catholic Church, Alba took control of the book industry. Several printers were banished and at least one was executed. Book sellers and printers were prosecuted and arrested for publishing banned books, many of which were added to the Index Librorum Prohibitorum.
After years of unrest in the Low Countries, the summer of 1567 saw renewed violent outbursts of iconoclasm, in which Dutch 'Beeldenstorm' Calvinists defaced statues and decorations of Catholic monasteries and churches. The Battle of Oosterweel in March 1567 was the first Spanish military response to the many riots, and a prelude to or the start of the Eighty Years' War. The 80 Years' War can be seen to have started on 13 March 1567 with the defeat of the rebels at Oosterweel. In 1568 Alba had prominent Dutch nobles executed on the Grote Markt in Brussels, sparking strong anti-Spanish sentiment. In October 1572, after the Orange forces captured the city of Mechelen, its lieutenant attempted to surrender when he was informed that a larger Spanish army was approaching. They tried to welcome the Duke's forces by the singing of psalms, but Fadrique Álvarez de Toledo, son of the Governor of the Netherlands, and commander of the Duke's troops, allowed his men three days of pillage of the archbishopric city. Alba reported to his king that "not a nail was left in the wall". A year later, magistrates still attempted to retrieve precious church belongings that Spanish soldiers had sold in other cities. This sack of Mechelen was the first of the Spanish Furies; several events remembered by that name occurred in the four or five years to come. In November and December of the same year, with permission by the Duke, Fadrique had many people of Zutphen and of Naarden locked and burnt in their church.
In July 1573, after half a year of siege, the city of Haarlem surrendered. Then the garrison's men (except for the German soldiers) were drowned or had their throats cut by the duke's troops, and eminent citizens were executed. In 1576, Spanish troops attacked and pillaged Antwerp. The soldiers rampaged through the city, killing and looting; they demanded money from citizens and burned the homes of those who refused to (or could not) pay. Christophe Plantin's printing establishment was threatened with destruction three times, but was saved each time when a ransom was paid. Antwerp was economically devastated by the attack. A thousand buildings were torched and as many as 18,000 men, women and children murdered. Maastricht was besieged, sacked and destroyed twice in succession (in 1576 and 1579) by the Tercios de Flandes (Flemish regiments). The siege of 1579 ended with the destruction and sacking of the city known as the 'Spanish Fury'. During the assault they killed not only many of the town's defenders but also many women and children. The Spanish soldiers deliberately drowned hundreds of civilians by throwing them off the bridge leading over the river Maas. Of the city's 30,000 population, only 400 survived.
The propaganda created by the Dutch Revolt during the struggle against the Spanish Crown can also be seen as part of the Black Legend. The depredations against the Indians that De las Casas had described, were compared to the depredations of Alba and his successors in the Netherlands. The Brevissima relacion was reprinted no less than 33 times between 1578 and 1648 in the Netherlands (more than in all other European countries combined).
The Articles and Resolutions of the Spanish Inquisition to Invade and Impede the Netherlands imputed a conspiracy to the Holy Office to starve the Dutch population and exterminate its leading nobles, "as the Spanish had done in the Indies." Marnix of Sint-Aldegonde, a prominent propagandist for the cause of the rebels, regularly used references to alleged intentions on the part of Spain to "colonize" the Netherlands, for instance in his 1578 address to the German Diet.
King Philip, at the time also king of Portugal, was accused of cruelty for his hanging of supporters of António, Prior of Crato, the rival contender for the throne of Portugal, on yardarms on the Azores islands, following the Battle of Ponta Delgada.
Reception in England
Other critics of Spain included Antonio Pérez, the fallen secretary of King Philip, who fled to France and England, where he published attacks on the Spanish monarchy under the title Relaciones (1594). The English referred to these books to justify privateering and wars against the Spanish.
In the 18th century, despite the fact that he never visited Spain, philosopher Immanuel Kant stated that "The Spaniard's bad side is that he does not learn from foreigners; that he does not travel in order to get acquainted with other nations; that he is centuries behind in the sciences. He resists any reform; he is proud of not having to work; he is of a romantic quality of spirit, as the bullfight shows; he is cruel, as the former auto-da-fé shows; and he displays in his taste an origin that is partly non-European." Historian Walter Mignolo has argued that the Black Legend was closely tied to ideologies of race, both in the way that it used the Moorish history of Spain to depict Spaniards as racially tainted, and in the way that the treatment of Africans and Native Americans during Spanish colonial projects came to symbolize their moral character.
Reception and criticism
In general, the idea of the existence of the Spanish Black Legend is majoritarely accepted by academics, even though there are some criticism to the idea and the consensus is not universal.
Ricardo Garcia Carcel directly denies the existence of the Black Legend in his book The Black Legend (1991), arguing: "It is neither a legend, insofar as the negative opinions of Spain have genuine historical foundations, nor is it black, as the tone was never consistent nor uniform. Gray abounds, but the color of these opinions was always viewed in contrast [to what] we have called the white legend."
Among the historians that actively support or have found proof in their work for the Spanish Black Legend we can name: Philip Wayne Powell, Edward Peters, William S.Maltby, Richard Kagan, Margaret R. Greer, Helen Rawlings, Ronnie Hsia, Lu Ann Homza, Stanley G. Payne, Andrea Donofrio, Irene Silverblatt, Christopher Schmidt-Nowara, Charles Gibson (historian), María Elvira Roca Barea, Ronald Hilton, Joseph Pérez, Bartolomé Bennasar and Sverker Arnoldsson, who specialized himself in the study of the subject.
The perdurance, or not, of the Black Legend is a debated issue. In recent years a group of historians including Alfredo Alvar and Lourdes Mateo Bretos have argued that the Black Legend does not currently exist, the Black Legend instead being merely the Spanish perception of how the world views Spain's legacy.
Carmen Iglesias has argued that the black legend would consist in those negative traits, that would be objectively the most repeated ones, that the Spanish consciousness sees in itself. Nonetheless she admits that the black legend also responds to highly manipulated propaganda driven by political interests.
Henry Kamen considers that the black legend existed during the XVI century but is a thing of the past in England, other authors consider that it continues affecting Spanish and Latin America diplomatic and economic present and world status.
Other authors, however, like Roca Barea, Philip Wayne Powell, and consider that it still affects the way in which Spain is perceived and that it is brought up strategically during diplomatic conflicts of interest, as well as in popular culture to hide the negative actions of other nations. Among those who consider that The Black Legend is still around, Roberto Fernandez Retamar, Benjamin Keen, Patricia Shaw, David J. Weber, and Eric Griffin, have devoted work specifically to study the cause of such an uncanny persistence.
Those who consider that the Black legend still affects Spain and the Latin American world point out events like:
- Creation and use of special categories: The use in English of the word "conquistador" instead of "conqueror" (the literal translation of conquistador), as well as of "conquista" instead of "conquest" (also, the literal translation of conquista) in order to create a new, unique category of connotation that separates both Spaniards from other Europeans, and the actions of the Spanish in the new world from the conquerors in Europe, even though both actions were not seen as different, nor were carried out differently at the time.
- Trade disputes: Direct references to constructs from the times of the black legend were made in British and Canadian press during the "Fletan War" of 1992 between both countries. This conflict was "solved" by diplomatic pressures partially generated by those black legend elements and never made it to international court.
- References to black legend constructs are currently used in Argentina to argue in favor of protectionist policies against Spanish companies.
- Usa-Latin America relationships: Powell considered it the root of current diplomatic problems and anti-Latino sentiment in the United States, and he shows so in his work The Tree of Hate: Propaganda and Prejudices Affecting Relations with the Hispanic World (1971). The view of the black legend affecting modern day USA´s immigration policy has gained supporters in the current political climate. The narrative of the "degenerated race" is argued to be at the root of the racist discrimination suffered by Latinos in America.
- The Spanish past ownership of about half of the United Estates land is unknown by most Americans, affecting the way in which Latin American population and culture are treated, as well as the linguistic debate there.
- Spanish foreign minister Josep Borrell explained that he sees a re-emergence of the black legend across Europe in the way the Catalonian issue has been covered, especially by English speaking press, regarding the unquestioning acceptance of unchecked numbers of injured that turned out to be false.
Education and popular culture
- Cinema: Spanish proponents of the prevalence of the black legend point out that the black legend view Spain and Spanish history, as well as to its anti-catholic elements are common in popular culture, such as in movies like Elizabeth, popular culture references to similar deeds by other colonial powers are scarce or idealized in movies such as Victoria & Abdul. In his essay Why Spaniards Make Good Bad Guys? Samuel Amago analizes the persistence of the black legend in contemporary European cinema through a long list of titles, actors and directors.
- In 2012 the British TV show Lonely Planet broadcast an episode about the age of discovery, in which Spanish, Portuguese, English, Dutch, and Turk explorers were depicted. Only in the case of the Spaniards was any violent or negative action showed, devoting most of the time of the segment to how they killed and looted, while no mention of any such thing by English or Dutch, to Portuguese slave trade, or anything of the sort was ever showed. By contrast, none of the main exploration or scientific trips by Spain were shown. There was also no mention to the percentage of Native Population in each of the former colonies that could balance the lack of violence shown regarding central European nations.
- In 1944, the American Council of Education elaborated a report on anti-Hispanism in school and highschool textbooks, identifying a large number of basic errors, inexactitudes and biased portrayals, concluding that "The abolition of the black legend and its effects in our interpretation of Latin American life is one of our main problems in the educational and intelectual aspect, as well as in the political sphere" and urges to fix textbook bias and errors. However, according to Powell, in 1971 all the core errors were sill in the majority of school material.
The black legend and its counterpart the British golden legend are, allegedly, a main contributor to the construct of white supremacism since it erases both the ethical and intellectual contributions of Southern Europeans and reduce the power and competence achieved by Native American Empires prior and during the Spanish conquest.
The label "White Legend" is used by some historians to describe a historiographic approach that they consider to go too far in trying to counter the Black Legend, and which consequently ends up painting an uncritical or idealized image of Spanish colonial practices. Such an approach has been described as characteristic of Nationalist Spanish historiography during the regime of Francisco Franco, which associated itself with the imperial past couched in positive terms. Some, such as Benjamin Keen, have criticized the works of John Fiske and Lewis Hanke as going too far towards idealizing Spanish history.
White legend may also refer to the propaganda spread within Spain by Phillip II and his descendants, to present his actions to preserve his own patrimony in the Netherlands and America as religiously motivated. This propaganda would create the view of a prudent and pious monarch within Spain, helping to control the unrest that his aggressive policies and wars in the Netherlands were generating.
- New Laws
- Atrocity propaganda
- Black armband view of history, a similar concept in Australia
- Black Legend of the Spanish Inquisition
- Blood libel
- Colonial mentality
- Cultural depictions of Philip II of Spain
- Population history of indigenous peoples of the Americas
- Historical revisionism
- Historiography of Colonial Spanish America
- History of the west coast of North America
- History wars
- Information warfare
- Laws of Burgos
- New Laws
- Spanish colonization of the Americas
- Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire
- Spanish conquest of the Inca Empire
- Spanish conquest of Yucatán
- Spanish Empire
- Valladolid debate
- ...cuidadosa distorsión de la historia de un pueblo, realizada por sus enemigos, para mejor combatirle. Y una distorsión lo más monstruosa posible, a fin de lograr el objetivo marcado: la descalificación moral de ese pueblo, cuya supremacía hay que combatir por todos los mediossine die.»
- Maltby, William B. "The Black Legend" in Encyclopedia of Latin American History and Culture, vol. 1, pp. 346-348. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons 1996.
- http://www.fgbueno.es. "Emilia Pardo Bazán, La España de ayer y la de hoy (La muerte de una leyenda), 18 de Abril de 1899". filosofia.org. Retrieved 2016-07-05.
- Juderías, Julián, La Leyenda Negra (2003; first Edition of 1914) ISBN 84-9718-225-1
- "el ambiente creado por los relatos fantásticos que acerca de nuestra patria han visto la luz pública en todos los países, las descripciones grotescas que se han hecho siempre del carácter de los españoles como individuos y colectividad, la negación o por lo menos la ignorancia sistemática de cuanto es favorable y hermoso en las diversas manifestaciones de la cultura y del arte, las acusaciones que en todo tiempo se han lanzado sobre España..."
- Gibson, Charles. 1958. "The Colonial Period in Latin American History", pages 13-14, defines the black legend as "The accumulated tradition of propaganda and hispanophobia according to which Spanish imperialism is regarded as cruel, bigoted, exploitative and self-righteous in excess of reality"
- Powell, Philip Wayne, 1971, "Tree of Hate" (first Ed.) ISBN 9780465087501
- MALTBY, W. S. The Black Legend in England (Maltby, 1971). Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press
- John L. Robinson, «The anti-hispanic bias in British historiography», Hispania Sacra, 1992, XLIV
- Roca Barea, María Elvira (2016). Imperiofobia y leyenda negra. Roma, Rusia, Estados Unidos y el Imperio español. Madrid: Siruela. ISBN 978-84-16854233.
- Marías, Julián (2006; primera edición 1985). España Inteligible. Razón Histórica de las Españas. Alianza Editorial. ISBN 84-206-7725-6.
- Swart, K. W. (1975). "The Black Legend During the Eighty Years War." In Britain and the Netherlands (pp. 36-57). Springer Netherlands.
- Alvar, p.7
- Maltby, p.7
- Arnoldsson, pp. 104 ss
- Arnoldsson, pp. 117 ss.
- Arnoldsson, pp. 123 ss.; Kamen, pp. 305 ss.
- Elvira, Roca Barea María, and Arcadi Espada. Imperiofobia Y Leyenda Negra: Roma, Rusia, Estados Unidos Y El Imperio Español. Madrid: Siruela, 201
- Luther op. cit., Tischr., III, p. 382, N° 3533 a (14-31 de enero de 1537); V, p. 284, N° 5635 a (12 de mayo de 1544): op. cit. Arnoldsson (1960).
- "Mirror of the Cruel and Horrible Spanish Tyranny Perpetrated in the Netherlands, by the Tyrant, the Duke of Alba, and Other Commanders of King Philip II". World Digital Library. 1620. Retrieved 2013-08-25.
- Stannard, David E. (1993). American Holocaust: The Conquest of the New World. Oxford University Press, USA. p. 74. ISBN 978-0-19-508557-0.
- Hanke, Lewis, "A Modest Proposal for a Moratorium on Grand Generalizations: Some Thoughts on the Black Legend", The Hispanic American Historical Review 51, No. 1 (Feb., 1971), pp. 112-127
- Keen, Benjamin (1969). "The Black Legend Revisited: Assumptions and Realities". The Hispanic American Historical Review. 49 (4): 703–19. doi:10.2307/2511162. JSTOR 2511162.
- The Aztecs Under Spanish Rule: A History of the Indians of the Valley of Mexico, 1519-1810. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1964. p. 403
- Arnade, Peter J. Beggars, iconoclasts, and civic patriots: the political culture of the Dutch Revolt. Cornell University Press, 2008 (Limited online by Google books). pp. 226–229. ISBN 978-0-8014-7496-5. Retrieved 31 July 2011.
- Elsen, Jean (February 2007). "De nood-en belegeringsmunten van de Nederlandse opstand tegen Filips II - Historisch kader" (PDF). Collection J.R. Lasser (New York). Nood- en belegeringsmunten, Deel II (in Dutch). Jean Elsen & ses Fils s.a., Brussels, Belgium. p. 4; 15. Archived from the original (PDF) on 18 January 2012. Retrieved 1 August 2011. External link in
- GDB (7 September 2004). "'Spaanse furie' terug thuis". journal Het Nieuwsblad, Belgium. Retrieved 31 July 2011.
- pagan-live-style (2009–2011). "Catherine church Mechelen 3". deviantArt. Retrieved 3 August 2011. External link in
- "Sold Items provided for Reference and Research Purposes — OHN Bellingham - Assassin, St Petersburg, Russia, 3 December 1806 - ALS". Berryhill & Sturgeon, Ltd. Retrieved 3 August 2011. External link in
- "History - South-Limburg". Parkstad.com, Limburg, Netherlands. Archived from the original on 28 September 2011. Retrieved 3 August 2011. External link in
- Burg, David F. "1567 Revolt of the Netherlands". A World History of Tax Rebellions - An Encyclopedia of Tax Rebels, Revolts, and Riots from Antiquity to the Present. Taylor and Francis, London, UK, 2003, 2005; Routledge, 2004 (Online by BookRags, Inc). ISBN 978-0-203-50089-7. ISBN 978-0-415-92498-6. Archived from the original on 4 August 2011. Retrieved 4 August 2011.
in Madrid, Alba was accused of following his own whims rather than Philip’s wishes. According to Henry Kamen, Medinaceli reported to the king that “Excessive rigour, the misconduct of some officers and soldiers, and the Tenth Penny, are the cause of all the ills, and not heresy or rebellion.” —[...]— One of the governor’s officers reported that in the Netherlands “the name of the house of Alba” was held in abhorrenceExternal link in
- Lamers, Jaqueline. "Gemeente Naarden – Keverdijk, diverse straten". Municipality of Naarden, Netherlands. Archived from the original on 27 September 2011. Retrieved 31 July 2011.
- Schmidt, p. 97
- Schmidt, p 112
- Mignolo, W. D. (2007). "What does the Black Legend Have to do with Race?" Rereading the Black Legend: The Discourses of Religious and Racial Difference in the Renaissance Empires, 312-24.
- Jail and Matthew Garcia Bretos, The Black Legend (1991) & Matthew Garcia Carcel, Bretos, p.84
- Etzion, Judith (1998). «Spanish music as percieved in western music historiography: a case of the black legend ?». International Review of the Aesthetics and Sociology of Music 2 (29).
- Styron, William (1 de febrero de 1963). «Slave and Citizen: The Negro in the Americas. (review)». The New York Review of Books
- Vaca de Osma, p.208
- Daniel Cecchini y Jorge Cicolillo, «Los Nuevos Conquistadores. Cómo las Empresas Españolas expoliaron Argentina
- Opinion | Immigration - and the Curse of the Black Legend, Tony Horwitz
- Powell, Philip Wayne, 1971, "Tree of Hate" (first Ed.)
- Borrell, el CIP y la Leyenda Negra Luis Oz - El Mundo
- La reina Victoria y Abdul: ¡viva el Imperialismo!. Noticias de Cine, Alejandro Alegré
- Tree of Hate pp180
- Powell, Philip Wayne, 1971, Tree of Hate (first Ed.)
- Keen, Benjamin. 1969. "The Black Legend Revisited: Assumptions and realities". The Hispanic American Historical Review. volume 49. no. 4. pp.703-719
- Molina Martínez, Miguel. 2012. "La Leyenda Negra revisitada: la polémica continúa", Revista Hispanoamericana. Revista Digital de la Real Academia Hispano Americana de Ciencias, Artes y Letras. 2012, nº2: http://revista.raha.es/ ISSN 2174-0445
- Walsh, Anne L. (2007). Arturo Pérez-Reverte: narrative tricks and narrative strategies. Colección Támesis: Monografías (Volume 246). London: Tamesis Books. p. 117. ISBN 1-85566-150-0.
- Ardolino, Frank. Apocalypse and Armada in Kyd's Spanish Tragedy (Kirksville, Missouri: Sixteenth Century Studies, 1995).
- Arnoldsson, Sverker. "La Leyenda Negra: Estudios Sobre Sus Orígines," Göteborgs Universitets Årsskrift, 66:3, 1960
- Díaz, María Elena (2004). "Beyond Tannenbaum". Law and History Review. 22 (2): 371–376. doi:10.2307/4141650.
- Edelmayer, Friedrich (2011). "The "Leyenda Negra" and the Circulation of Anti-Catholic and Anti-Spanish Prejudices". European History Online.
- Español Bouché, Luis, "Leyendas Negras: Vida y Obra de Julian Juderías", Junta de Castilla y Leon, 2007.
- Gibson, Charles. The Black Legend: Anti-Spanish Attitudes in the Old World and the New. 1971.
- Gledhill, John (1996). "Review: From "Others" to Actors: New Perspectives on Popular Political Cultures and National State Formation in Latin America". American Anthropologist. New Series. 98 (3): 630–633. doi:10.1525/aa.1996.98.3.02a00210.
- Griffin, Eric. "Ethos to Ethnos: Hispanizing 'the Spaniard' in the Old World and the New," The New Centennial Review, 2:1, 2002.
- Hadfield, Andrew. "Late Elizabethan Protestantism, Colonialism and the Fear of the Apocalypse," Reformation, 3, 1998.
- Hanke Lewis. The Spanish Struggle for Justice in the Conquest of America. 1949.
- Hanke, Lewis. Bartolomé de Las Casas: Bookman, Scholar and Propagandist. 1952.
- Hauben, Paul J. (1977). "White Legend against Black: Nationalism and Enlightenment in a Spanish Context". The Americas. 34 (1): 1–19. doi:10.2307/980809.
- Hillgarth, J. N. (1985). "Spanish Historiography and Iberian Reality". History and Theory. 24 (1): 23–43. doi:10.2307/2504941.
- Kamen, Henry, Empire: How Spain Became a World Power, 1492-1763. New York: HarperCollins. 2003. ISBN 0-06-093264-3
- Keen, Benjamin, "The Black Legend Revisited: Assumptions and Realities", Hispanic American Historical Review 49, no. 4 (November 1969): 703–19.
- Keen, Benjamin, "The White Legend Revisited: A Reply to Professor Hanke's 'Modest Proposal,'" Hispanic American Historical Review 51, no. 2 (May 1971): 336–55.
- LaRosa, Michael (1992–1993). "Religion in a Changing Latin America: A Review". Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs. 34 (4): 245–255. doi:10.2307/165811.
- Lock, Julian. "'How Many Tercios Has the Pope?' The Spanish War and the Sublimation of Elizabethan Anti-Popery," History, 81, 1996.
- Maltby, William S., The Black Legend in England. Duke University Press, Durham, 1971, ISBN 0-8223-0250-0.
- Maura, Juan Francisco. "La hispanofobia a través de algunos textos de la conquista de América: de la propaganda política a la frivolidad académica". Bulletin of Spanish Studies 83. 2 (2006): 213-240.
- Maura, Juan Francisco. "Cobardía, crueldad y oportunismo español: algunas consideraciones sobre la 'verdadera' historia de la conquista de la Nueva España". Lemir (Revista de literatura medieval y del Renacimiento) 7 (2003): 1-29.
- Mignolo, W. D. (2007). "What does the Black Legend Have to do with Race?" Rereading the Black Legend: The Discourses of Religious and Racial Difference in the Renaissance Empires, 312-24.
- Powell, Philip Wayne, Tree of Hate: Propaganda and Prejudices Affecting United States Relations with the Hispanic World. Basic Books, New York, 1971, ISBN 0-465-08750-7.
- Rabasa, José (1993). "Aesthetics of Colonial Violence: The Massacre of Acoma in Gaspar de Villagrá's "Historia de la Nueva México"". College Literature. 20 (3): 96–114.
- Sanchez, M.G., Anti-Spanish Sentiment in English Literary and Political Writing, 1553-1603 (Phd Diss; University of Leeds, 2004)
- Schmidt, Benjamin, Innocence Abroad. The Dutch Imagination and the New World, 1570-1670, Cambridge U.P. 2001, ISBN 978-0-521-02455-6
- Vigil, Ralph H. (1994). "Review: Inequality and Ideology in Borderlands Historiography". Latin American Research Review. 29 (1): 155–171.