Headless men

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Blemmyes (legendary creatures))
Jump to: navigation, search
For the non-legendary tribe, see Blemmyes.
A blemmyes, a from a map by Guillaume Le Testu

Various species of mythical headless men were rumored, in antiquity and later, to inhabit remote parts of the world. They are variously known as akephaloi (Greek ἀκέφαλοι, "headless ones") or Blemmyes (Latin: Blemmyae; Greek: βλέμμυες) and described as lacking a head, with their facial features — the eyes and the mouth — on their chest. These were at first described as inhabitants of the Nile system (Aethiopia): later traditions confined to their habitat to a particular island in the Brisone River[a], or even shifted it to India.

Blemmyes are said to occur in two types: with eyes on the chest or with the eyes on the shoulders. Epiphagi, a variant name for the headless people of the Brisone, is sometimes used as a term referring strictly to the eyes-on-the-shoulders type.

Etymology[edit]

As for the origins of the name Blemmys, various etymologies had been proposed, and the question has long been considered unsettled.[1]

In antiquity, Blemmyes was said to be named epyonmously after King Blemys (Βλέμυς), according to Nonnus's 5th century epic Dionysiaca, but no lore about headlessness is attached to the people in this work.[2][3] Samuel Bochart of the 17th century derived the word Blemmyes from the Hebrew bly (בלי) "without" and moach (מוח) "brain", implying that the Blemmyes were people without brains.[4][5] A Greek derivation from blemma (Greek: βλέμμα) "look, glance" and muō (Greek: μύω) "close the eyes" has also been suggested.[6] Wolfgang Helck claimed a Coptic word "blind" for its etymology.[7]

Leo Reinisch (de) in 1895 proposed that it derived from bálami "desert people" in the Bedauye tongue (Beja language). Although this theory had long been neglected,[8] this etymology has come into acceptance, alongside the identification of the Beja people as true descendants of the Blemmyes of yore.[9][10][11]

In antiquity[edit]

The first indirect reference to the blemmyes occurs in Herodotus, Histories, where he calls them the akephaloi (Greek: ἀκέφαλοι "without a head").[12] The headless akephaloi, the dog-headed cynocephali, "and the wild men and women, besides many other creatures not fabulous" dwelled in the eastern edge of ancient Libya, according to Heodotus's Libyan sources.[13]

Mela was the first to name the "Blemyae" of Africa as being headless with their face buried in their chest.[14] In a similar vein, Pliny the Elder in the Natural History reports the Blemmyae tribe of North Africa as "[having] no heads, their mouths and eyes being seated in their breasts".[15] Pliny situates the Blemmyae somewhere in Aethiopia (in, or in the neighboring lands to Nubia).[b][15][16][17] Modern commentators on Pliny have suggested the notion of headlessness among Blemmyes may be due to their combat tactic of keeping their heads pressed close to the head, while half-squatting with one knee to the ground.[c][5][18] Solinus, adds they are believed to be born with their head part dismembered, their mouth and eyes deposited on the breast.[19]

The term acephalous (akephaloi) was applied to people without heads whose facial parts such as eyes and mouth have relocated to other parts of the body, and the blemmyes as described by Pliny or Solinus conform with this appellation.[20]

Middle Ages[edit]

By the 7th or 8th century there had been composed a Letter of Pharasmenes to Hadrian,[d] whose accounts of marvels such as bearded women (and headless men) became incorporated into later texts. This included De Rebus in Oriente mirabilibus (also known as Mirabilia), its Anglo-Saxon translation, Gervase of Tilbury's treatise, and the Alexander legend attributed to Leo Archipresbyter (it).[21]

The Latin text in the recension knonwn as the Fermes Letter[e] was translated verbatim in Gervase of Tilbury's Otia Imperialia (ca. 1211) which describes a "people without heads" ("Des hommes sanz testes") of a golden color, measuring 12 feet tall and 7 feet wide, living on an isle in the River Brison (in Ethiopia).[f][24][25]

The catalogue of strange peoples from Letter occur in the Anglo-Saxon Wonders of the East (translation of Mirabilia) and the Liber Monstrorum; recensions of both these works are bound in the Beowulf manuscript.[26][22] The transmission is imperfectNo name is given to the headless islanders, eight feet tall in the Wonders of the East.[g][27][28] Epiphagi ("epifugi") is the name of the headless in Liber Monstrorum[h][29] This form derives from "epiphagos" in a modified recension of the Letter of Pharasmenes known as the Letter of Premonis to Trajan (Epistola Premonis Regis ad Trajanum).[i][31]

Alexander romances[edit]

Alexander encounters the headless people
Hisotria de preliis in French, BL Royal MS 15 E vi, c. 1445.

The Letter material was incorporated into the Alexander legend by Leo Archipresbyter, known as Historia de Preliis (version J2),[32] which was translated into Old French as Roman d'Alexandre en prose. In the prose Alexandre the golden-colored headless encountered by Alexandre measured just 6 feet tall, and had beards reaching their knees.[33][19] In the French version, Alexander captures 30 of the headless to show the rest of the world, an element lacking in the Latin original.[34]

Other Alexander books that contain the headless people episode are Thomas de Kent's romance and Jean Wauquelin's chronicle.[35][36]

Medieval maps[edit]

The blemmyes or the headless people have also been illustrated and described on medieval maps. The Hereford Mappa Mundi (ca. 1300) places the "Blemee" in Ethiopia (upper Nile system), deriving its information from Solinus, perhaps via Isidore of Seville.

The Blemee have their face on their on chest.
1) Blemee with face on chest
People with face at shoulders.
2) People with eyes at the shoulders.
—Hereford Map (c. 1300)

One Blemee standing has his face on their chest, and another below him has "eyes and mouth at their shoulders". Both varieties of Blemmyae occur according to Isidore,[j][37][38] who reported that in Libya, besides the Blemmyae born with a face on the chest, there were reputedly "others, born without necks, [and] have their eyes on their shoulders".[39] Some modern commentators believe the two different types represent the male and female blemmyes, with their genitals explicitly drawn.[40][41] Another example is the Ranulf Higden map (ca. 1363), which bears an inscription regarding the headless in Ethiopia, although unaccompanied by any picture of the people.[k][42]

Headless placed in India.
—Andrea Bianco map (1436)

By the Late Middle Ages, world maps began to appear that located the headless people further east, in Asia, such as the Andrea Bianco map (1436) that depicted people who "all do not have heads (omines qui non abent capites)" in India, on the same peninsula as the Terrestrial paradise.[l] But other maps of the period such as the Andreas Walsperger's map (ca. 1448) did continue to locate the headless in Ethiopia.[m][44][45] The post-medieval map of Guillaume Le Testu (pictured above) illustrates the headless and the dog-headed cynocephali north beyond the Himalayan mountains.[46]

Late Middle Ages[edit]

The Travels of Sir John Mandeville writes of "ugly folk without heads, who have eyes in each shoulder" with their mouths "round like a horseshoe, in the middle of their chest" living among the populace in the big island of Dundeya (Andaman Islands) between India and Myanmar. In other parts of the island are headless men with eyes and mouth on their backs.[47] This has been noted as an example of blemmyes by commentators,[48][49] though Mandeville does not use the term.

A Blemmyae from Schedel's Nuremberg Chronicle (1493).

Examples of chapters on monstrous races (including the headless), taken from earlier sources, occur in the Buch der Natur or the Nuremberg Chronicle[50]

The Buch der Natur (ca. 1349), written by Conrad of Megenberg, described the "people without heads (läut an haupt)"[n] as shaggy all over the body, with "coarse hair like wild animals",[o] but when the printed book versions appeared, their woodcut illustrations depicted them as smooth-bodied, in contradiction to the text.[51] Conrad lumped peoples of various geography under "wundermenschen", and condemned such wondrous people as earning physical deformities due to the sins of their ancestors.[52][53]

Age of Discovery[edit]

Headless in Ewaipanoma (1599 engraving)

During the Age of Discovery, a rumor of headless men called the Ewaipanoma was reported by Sir Walter Raleigh in his Discovery of Guiana, to have been living on the banks of the Caura River. Of the story, Raleigh was "resolved it is true, because every child in the provinces of Aromaia and Canuri affirm the same". He also cited an anonymous Spaniard's sighting of the Ewaipanoma.[54] Joannes de Laet, a somewhat later contemporary dismissed the story, writing that these natives' heads were set so close to the shoulders, that some were led to believe their eyes were attached to the shoulders and the mouth to their breasts.[20]

Modern rational explanations[edit]

Explanations similar to de Laet's were repeated in later years. In the Age of Enlightenment, Joseph-François Lafitau asserted that while "acephalous" races were actually present in North America, they were no more than a local trait of having the head set deep in the shoulders. He argued that reports of "headless" traits in the "East Indies" by writers of antiquity is evidence that people of the same genetic pool migrated from Asia to North America.[55] Contemporary literature say certain writers attribute Blemmyes' physique as an ability to raise both shoulders to an extraordinary height, and ensconcing their head in-between.[4]

Other explanations have been offered for the legend of their unusual physique. As noted earlier, native warriors perhaps employed the tactic of keeping head tucked close to the breast while marching with one knee on the ground.[18] Or perhaps had the custom of carrying with shields ornamented with faces.[56]

In art[edit]

Blemyah, Ripon Cathedral

Likenesses of blemmyes are used as supports for misericords at Norwich Cathedral and Ripon Cathedral, from earlier local folklore.[57] Writer Lewis Caroll is said to have invented characters based on objects in the Ripon church where his father served as canon, and in particular, the blemmys here inspired his Humpty Dumpty character.[58]

In literature[edit]

And of the Cannibals that each other eat, The Anthropophagi, and men whose heads Do grow beneath their shoulders. ---Shakespeare, Othello (circa 1603).

In Umberto Eco's Baudolino, the protagonist meets Blemmyes along with Sciapods and a number of monsters from the medieval bestiary in his quest to find Prester John.[59]

In his 2006 book La Torre della Solitudine, Valerio Massimo Manfredi features the Blemmyes as fierce, sand-dwelling creatures located in the southeastern Sahara, and suggests that they are the manifestation of the evil face of mankind. Othello makes reference to them as "men whose heads | Do grow beneath their shoulders" [I.iii.143-144].

Science fiction author Bruce Sterling wrote a short story entitled "The Blemmye's Stratagem", included in his collection "Visionary in Residence". The story describes a Blemmye during the Crusades, who turns out to be an extraterrestrial. Sterling later stated that the idea for his story was taken from a children's story by Waleed Ali.

The Oz stories by L. Frank Baum describe the Hammerhead Men, who are ferocious, fearsome misanthropes who jealously guard their mountain against any who enter. The Hammerhead Men are very short, and they can detach their heads from their bodies and thus give them a headless appearance. They attack Dorothy and her friends on the way to the South.

Gene Wolfe writes of a man with his face on his chest, located in his short story collection "Endangered Species".

Blemmyes appear in the 2000 novel The Amazing Voyage of Azzam by K Godel as cannibalistic tribesmen who guard a lost treasure of King Solomon. They use clubs, spears, and blow darts as weapons.

Gallery[edit]

See also[edit]

Explanatory notes[edit]

  1. ^ Also "Brixonte[s]", etc.
  2. ^ From the geographical desciption this was a desert area south and east of Egypt, between tributaries of the Nile, in Nubian-Egyptian border zone in the Eastern Desert.
  3. ^ Comment by Louis Marcus (1829), taking hint from a passage in Heliodorus of Emesa Aethiopica Book V.
  4. ^ Particularly the F-group of text known as Fermes Letter, represented in Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, nouv. acq. lat. 1065.
  5. ^ Fermes Letter: "Est namque et alia insula in Brisone flumine, ubi nascuntur homines sine capite, habentes oculos et os in pectore; longi sunt pedes XII, lati et vasti pedes VII, colore et corpus auro simile".[22]
  6. ^ River Brison was a fictious distributary of the Nile. Commentators (Gervase, Gerner & Pignatelli tr 2006, pp. 298, 536) localize the Brison as being in Ethiopia.
  7. ^ Wonders says they live on "another island south of the Brixontes.." (Orchard tr.) presumably meaning another island in Brixontes River, but further south than the island where the donkey-eared, sheep-wooled, bird-footed animals called lertices dwell.
  8. ^ Liber Monstrorum, I. 24: Epifugi, as the Greeks called them, are "eight feet tall and have all the functions of the head in their chests, except they are said to have eyes in their shoulders" (Orchard tr.); Latin text reads '..'quos Epifugos Graeci vocant et VIII pedum altitudinis sunt et tota in pectore capitis officia gerunt, nisi quod oculos in humeris habere dicuntur".
  9. ^ XVII, 5 : est etiam in Brixonte insula in homines sine qua nascuntur captibus, quia in pectore et oculos habent in time, altitude novem pedum latitude et octo: hos epifagos vocamus.[30]
  10. ^ Although Kline (2001) thinks the second type with eyes and mouth at shoulder should be identified as a "Epiphagi"
  11. ^ Inscription reads "Gens ista habet caput et os in pectore" and can be read above the spine of the Atlas, to the far right on the image Ranulf Higden map
  12. ^ Bianco locates the headless in the Orient, but the dog-heads still in Ethiopia.[43]
  13. ^ Labeled "Hy haben vultum in pectore"
  14. ^ Husband & Gilmore-House 1980, p. 47 refers to them as the "acephalous" but original German is followed here
  15. ^ And having (sint über al rauch mit hertem hâr, sam diu wilden tier)"

References[edit]

  1. ^ Zaborski (1989).
  2. ^ Nonnus, Dionysiaca, XVII, 385–397
  3. ^ Derrett (2002), p. 468.
  4. ^ a b Chambers, Ephraim, ed. (1728). "Blemmyes". Cyclopædia, or an Universal Dictionary of Arts and Sciences. 1 (first ed.). James and John Knapton, et al. p. 107. 
  5. ^ a b Pliny (1829), Histoire naturelle, III, Ajasson, M. (tr.); Marcus, Louis (notes), C. L. F. Panckoucke, pp. 190–1 
  6. ^ Morié, Louis J. (1904), Les civilisations africaines: La Nubie (Éthiopie ancienne), 1, A. Challamel, p. 65 
  7. ^ Der Kleine Pauly I, 913, cited in Derrett 2002, p. 468
  8. ^ Zaborski (1989), pp. 172–173.
  9. ^ Mukarovsky, Hans G. (1987), "Reinisch and Some Problems of he Study of Beja Today", Leo Reinisch: Werk und Erbe, Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, p. 130 (125–139) 
  10. ^ Updegraff, Robert T. (1988) [1972], László Török, "The Blemmyes I: The Rise of the Blemmyes and the Roman Withdrawal from Nubia under Diocletian", ANRW, II (10.1), p. 55 (44–106) 
  11. ^ Fleming, Harold C. (1988), Ongota: A Decisive Language in African Prehistory, p. 149 
  12. ^ Derrett (2002), p. 467.
  13. ^ Herodotus. The Histories. Trans. A. D. Godley. 4.191. 
  14. ^ Derrett (2002), p. 469.
  15. ^ a b Pliny the Elder (1893). The Natural History. 1. Trans. John Bostock and H. T. Riley. George Bell & Sons. p. 405.  (Book 5.8)
  16. ^ Pliny, Bostock & Riley (tr.) 1893, p. 405, note 1 (Book 5.8, note 9)
  17. ^ Török, László (2009), Between Two Worlds: The Frontier Region Between Ancient Nubia and Egypt, BRILL, pp. 9–10, ISBN 9789004171978 
  18. ^ a b Pliny, Bostock & Riley (tr.) 1893, p.406, note 3 (Book 5.8, note 17)
  19. ^ a b Druce (1915), pp. 137–139.
  20. ^ a b "Acephaous". Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1. 1823. pp. 130–131. 
  21. ^ Ford (2015), pp. 12–15; notes 23, 32.
  22. ^ a b Stella (2012), p. 75.
  23. ^ Ford (2015), p. 13, note 32.
  24. ^ Gervase, in his autograph manuscript (Rome, Vat. Lat. 933) admits to using the Letter as his source.[23]
  25. ^ Gervase of Tilbury (2006), Gerner, Dominique; Pignatelli, Cinzia, eds., Les traductions françaises des Otia imperialia de Gervais de Tilbury, Droz, LXXV (p. 301) 
  26. ^ Oswald, Dana (2010), Monsters, Gender and Sexuality in Medieval English Literature, Boydell & Brewer 
  27. ^ Orchard, Andy (2003b). A Critical Companion to Beowulf. Boydell & Brewer Ltd. p. 24. ISBN 9781843840299. 
  28. ^ Orchard 2003a, Wonders of the East, §15 (pp. 192–193)
  29. ^ Orchard 2003a, Liber Monstrorum, I. 24 (p. 273)
  30. ^ Stella (2012), p. 62, note 55.
  31. ^ Stella (2012), pp. 62–63.
  32. ^ Ford (2015), p. 12, note 23.
  33. ^ Hilka, Alfons (1920), "Comment Alixandres trouva gens sans testes qui avoient couleur d'or et orent les iols on pis", Der Altfranzösische Prosa-Alexander-roman nach der Berliner Bilderhandschrift, nebst dem lateinischen Original der Historia de preliis, Max Niemeyer, p. 236 
  34. ^ Pérez-Simon, Maud (2014), Conquête du monde, enquête sur l'autre et quête de soi. Alexandre le Grand au Moyen Âge, Éditions de la Maison des sciences de l'homme, p. 204  (Open edition)
  35. ^ Harf-Lancner, Laurence (2012), Maddox, Donald; Sturm-Maddox, Sara, eds., "From Alexander to Marco Polo, from Text to Image: The Marvels of India", Medieval French Alexander, SUNY Press, p. 238 
  36. ^ Hériché, Sandrine (2008), Alexandre le Bourguignon: étude du roman Les faicts et les conquestes d'Alexandre le Grand de Jehan Wauquelin, Droz, pp. cxlvi, 233–234 
  37. ^ Kline, Naomi Reed (2001), Maps of Medieval Thought: The Hereford Paradigm, Boydell Press, pp. 143, 148–151 
  38. ^ Bevan, William Latham; Phillott, Henry Wright (1873), Mediæval Geography: An Essay in Illustration of the Hereford Mappa Mundi, E. Stanford, p. 103 
  39. ^ Isidore of Seville (2005), Throop, Priscilla, ed., Isidore of Seville's Etymologies: Complete English Translation, Lulu.com, XI. 3. 17 
  40. ^ Westrem ed., Hereford Mappa Mundi, p. 381, item 971, 973; cited in Derrett 2002, p. 470
  41. ^ Baumgärtner, Ingrid (2006), "Biblical, Mythical, and Foreign Women in the Texts and Pictures on Medieval World Maps" (PDF), The Hereford World Map: Medieval World Maps and their Context, British Library, p. 305 
  42. ^ Miller (1895), III, p. 105.
  43. ^ Hoogvliet, Margriet (2007), Mappae mundi, Brepols, p. 211, ISBN 2503520650 
  44. ^ Miller (1895), III, p. 148.
  45. ^ Hallberg, Ivar (1907), L'extrême orient dans la littérature et la cartographie de l'occident des XIIIe, XIVe, et XVe siècles : étude sur l'histoire de la géographie, Göteborg: Wald. Zachrisson, Blemmyis (pp. 78–79), archived from the original on 2009 
  46. ^ White, David Gordon (1991), Myths of the Dog-Man, University of Chicago Press, p. 86 
  47. ^ Moseley, C. W. R. D. (tr.) (2005) [1983], The Travels of Sir John Mandeville, Penguin, p. 29; 137, ISBN 978-0141902814 
  48. ^ Moseley 2005, p. 29
  49. ^ Strickland, Debra Higgs (2003), Saracens, Demons, & Jews: Making Monsters in Medieval Art, Princeton University Press, p. 203 
  50. ^ Husband, Timothy; Gilmore-House, Gloria (1980), The Wild Man: Medieval Myth and Symbolism, Susan E. Tholl, Metropolitan Museum of Art, p. 6 
  51. ^ a b Husband & Gilmore-House (1980), p. 47.
  52. ^ Thomas of Cantimpré, who was Conrad's primary source also associated the headless with sin, but allegorically. To Thomas the headless represented unscrupulous lawyers.[51]
  53. ^ Metzler, Irina (2016), Fools and idiots?: Intellectual disability in the Middle Ages, Oxford University Press, p. 75 
  54. ^ Walter Raleigh (2006). The Discovery of Guiana. Project Gutenberg. 
  55. ^ Delon, Michel (2013), Encyclopedia of the Enlightenment, London and New York: Routledge, Monster (p. 849), ISBN 9781135959982 
  56. ^ Friedman, John (2000) [1981], The Monstrous Races In Medieval Art and Though, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, pp. 12, 15, 25, 146, 178–179, ISBN 9780802071736 
  57. ^ Tasker, Edward G. (1993), Encyclopedia of Medieval Church Art, B.T. Batsford, blemya (p. 24) 
  58. ^ Derrett (2002), p. 466.
  59. ^ Stella (2012), p. 39.

Bibliography[edit]