|33rd Florida Attorney General|
January 3, 1987 – November 4, 2002
|Preceded by||James C. Smith|
|Succeeded by||Richard E. Doran|
August 20, 1942 |
Passaic, New Jersey, U.S.
|Alma mater||University of Florida (B.A.)
University of Miami (J.D.)
Early life and career
Butterworth was born in Passaic, New Jersey, and moved to Florida with his family as a child. He received a degree in business administration from the University of Florida in 1965, and a Juris Doctor degree from the University of Miami in 1969. He is a member of Tau Kappa Epsilon and previously served on its international board of directors.
Butterworth was a judge in the county and circuit courts of Broward County from 1974 to 1978, when he was appointed sheriff of Broward County. He was appointed to head up Florida's Department of Motor Vehicles in 1982, and mayor of Sunrise, Florida in 1984.
In 1986, on the eve of his election as attorney general, Butterworth's ex-wife, Saundra, fatally shot their 16-year-old son, Robert A. Butterworth III, and then killed herself on a northeast Miami street. Police said she was mentally ill and had used a gun Butterworth had given her for protection before their divorce in 1976.
Butterworth currently has two children, a daughter, BreAnne and her brother, Brandon.
Florida Attorney General
A Democrat, Butterworth served as the 33rd Attorney General of Florida, for four consecutive terms, under three governors: Bob Martinez, Lawton Chiles, and Jeb Bush. He was first elected in 1986 and reelected in 1990, 1994, and 1998. His popularity among voters in the state has led to frequent mention of his name as a potential candidate for Governor of Florida or for the U.S. Senate.
Butterworth was attorney general during the final years of use of the electric chair in executing death row prisoners. It was notorious for frequent malfunctions in the 1990s, namely in the cases of Jesse Tafero (executed May 4, 1990), Pedro Medina (executed March 25, 1997) and Allen Lee Davis (executed July 8, 1999). Reportedly, six-inch flames shot out of Tafero's head and 12-inch flames shot out of Medina's head, raising the question whether use of the electric chair was cruel and unusual punishment. After the Medina execution, Butterworth commented, "People who wish to commit murder, they'd better not do it in the state of Florida because we may have a problem with the electric chair."
One of Butterworth's key activities during his time in office was the initiation and execution of Florida's lawsuit against the tobacco industry, which was one of the early contributions to what eventually became a nationwide effort. As a result of this suit, tobacco companies agreed to pay $11 billion to the state of Florida. Based on his participation in this effort, Butterworth was voted the nation's top state attorney general by attorneys-general from other states.
Involvement in the 2000 election
Butterworth was the Florida chair of Al Gore's 2000 presidential campaign and chose to not use his capacities as Attorney-General to influence court decisions on whether all the votes would be counted, so as not to have a conflict of interest. (Butterworth did argue in favor of a statewide recount in the media).
Butterworth's Republican counterpart, Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris, was the Florida chair of George W. Bush's presidential campaign. She was criticized by Democrats when she chose to certify the heavily-contested ballot count, despite the conflict of interest.
In 2002, Butterworth ran for Seat 25 in the Florida Senate, in hopes of representing portions of Palm Beach and Broward Counties. He resigned as Attorney General because of Florida's "resign-to-run laws. However, he was beaten by Republican Jeffrey Atwater.
On December 19, 2006, governor-elect Charlie Crist named Butterworth as the new secretary of the Florida Department of Children and Families.
On July 29, 2008 Secretary Butterworth resigned his post as Secretary of The Department of Children and Families, saying in his resignation letter to Governor Charlie Crist: “It is time to pass the torch to a new secretary,” says the letter, which was delivered to the Governor Tuesday morning. “It’s not that all the problems are solved. This agency will never be able to say, ‘Mission Accomplished.’ We only look at the accomplishments these past 19 months and say, ‘Keep it going.’
After his resignation from DCF, Butterworth joined the Fort Lauderdale law firm Atkinson Diner et al.
- candidate's ex-wife, son shot dead
- Word, Ron. "Flawed execution prompts Florida to study method". Associated Press, South Coast Today, March 26, 1997. Retrieved on November 19, 2014.