Book talk:Economics

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject Wikipedia-Books (Rated Book-class)
WikiProject icon This is a Wikipedia Book, a collection of articles which can be downloaded electronically or ordered in print. Wikipedia Books are maintained by the Wikipedia community, particularly WikiProject Wikipedia-Books. Wikipedia Books can also be tagged by the banners of any relevant Wikiprojects (with |class=book).
Wikipedia Book Book  This book does not require a rating on the quality scale.
WikiProject Economics (Rated Book-class)
WikiProject icon This book is within the scope of WikiProject Economics, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Economics on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.
Wikipedia Book Book  This book does not require a rating on the project's quality scale.
Featured article FA  Featured list FL  A-Class article A   GA  B-Class article B  C-Class article C  Start-Class article Start  Stub-Class article Stub   List   ???   NA 
0 0 0 2 8 24 25 2 0 2 0
Book reports are automatically updated by Cyberbot I (last run: 12 hours ago). Report bugs and suggestions for improvements to cyberpower678. For bugs and suggestions concerning Citation bot, report them to Smith609.

A Good Idea[edit]

The idea of writing and presenting all the Wikipedia data on economics in a book is a good one. However such a project must be approached with care. It will mean that when the material is separated and collected together, a lot of logical arranging will be necessary so that the book is more than a mere collection of various enclyclopedican items (incidentally many of which are still needing improvement). These improvments are both in themselves and in relationship to the rest of the items. In other words, the creation of the book is useful to all the various items as well as the reverse (of course).

This is a large project due to the amount of material. For that reason the approach I favor is initially to forget about the various existing items and to prepare a list of various aspects of the subject in logical order and with developing significance (easiest first), so that the subject is developed as the subjects unfold. Then the various items hopefully can be fitted into this framework with possible additions and merging as needed.

The trouble with economics is that there are as many opinions as economists (and a few!). This means that some of the available material contradicts and in a book this would be unacceptable, even when an alternative view is expressed in Wikipedia. Terminology is another problem for which Wikipedia is still struggling. It would be excellent if this aspect of the improvements to articles be tackled soon and not decided later during the book preparations. I am writing these lines as a person who has attempted outside of Wikipedia to write a book on Macroeconomics, taking a fresh approach. Believe me it is very difficult to choose the right words for each subject, and then to bring life to what is otherwise boring as dust!