Braniff Flight 352
Lockheed L-188 Electra similar to accident aircraft
|Date||May 3, 1968|
|Summary||Pilot error, thunderstorm|
|Site||Navarro County, near Dawson, Texas|
|Aircraft type||Lockheed L-188A Electra|
|Operator||Braniff International Airways|
|Flight origin||William P. Hobby Airport, Houston, Texas|
|Destination||Dallas Love Field, Dallas, Texas|
Braniff International Airways Flight 352 was a scheduled domestic flight from William P. Hobby Airport in Houston, Texas, United States to Dallas Love Field in Dallas; on May 3, 1968 a Lockheed L-188A Electra flying on the route, registration N9707C, broke up in mid air and crashed near Dawson, Texas, after flying into a severe thunderstorm. It was carrying 5 crew and 80 passengers; there were no survivors. Investigation revealed that the accident was caused by the captain's decision to penetrate an area of heavy weather followed by a structural over-stress and failure of the airframe while attempting recovery from loss of control during a steep 180 degree turn executed in an attempt to escape the weather.
Earlier in the day, at 12:40 local time, the crew of the accident flight flew from Dallas to Houston through the same area they were scheduled to fly later on. On that previous flight, a few hours before, they encountered no significant weather along the route. Once they arrived in Houston, there was no record of the crew being briefed about the updated weather by any Weather Bureau or FAA personnel, or by any Braniff dispatcher or weather office. They did, however, receive hardcopy information about all relevant en route and terminal weather reports and forecasts.
At 16:11, the crew departed William P. Hobby Airport as Braniff Flight 352, a Lockheed L-188A Electra four-engine turboprop, en route to Dallas-Love Field. After about 25 minutes into the flight, while cruising at FL200 (about 20,000 feet above mean sea level), the aircraft approached an area of severe thunderstorm activity. The crew requested to descend to 15,000 feet and deviate to the west. ATC informed the crew that other flights in the area were deviating to the east and suggested they also deviate east, but the Electra crew insisted that the west seemed OK to them on their onboard weather radar:
"Three fifty two does it look good (better). On our scope here it looks like to the uh a little just a little bit to the west would do us real fine."
ATC then cleared the flight to descend to 14,000 feet and deviate to the west as they requested. (The westerly deviation would have been shorter and quicker than an easterly one.)
At 16:44 the crew requested and ATC cleared the flight to descend to 5,000 feet. The crew asked ATC if there were any reports of hail in the area, to which ATC replied:
"No, you're the closest one that's ever come to it yet . . . I haven't been able to, anybody to, well I haven't tried really to get anybody to go through it, they've all deviated around to the east."
At 16:47 the flight encountered an area of severe weather including hail and requested a 180 degree right turn, which ATC immediately approved. While turning to the right in severe turbulence the bank angle was increased to over 90 degrees, and the nose pitched down to approximately 40 degrees. As the crew attempted to recover from the ensuing steep diving turn, the aircraft experienced acceleration forces of over 4 g, which caused the right wing to fail. The aircraft then broke up at an altitude of 6,750 feet and crashed in flames into the ground at about 16:48, killing all 85 persons on board.
Witnesses said the four-engine turboprop Electra - a modified version of the trouble-plagued Lockheed aircraft that had experienced two wing failure accidents in 1959 and 1960 - had blown up before it hit the ground and pieces "fishtailed" down through sheets of rain. The FBI, however, did not suspect foul play. Cloyce Floyd, postmaster of the little town of Dawson, about a mile from the crash scene, said he was driving along in the rain when he saw an "orange flash." He continued, "I looked over to the left and I could see this red ball of fire hanging back there about the size of the sun. From the glare of the fire I could see the fuselage sort of fishtailing down. Then it hit and exploded."
Rex Owen, a fireman from Mexia, Texas, was among nearly 100 volunteer rescue workers who went to the scene. "The wreckage was scattered all over the place," he said. Rescue worked clogged the muddy roads for hours carrying bodies and parts of bodies from the eerie scene lit by several klieg lights.
The NTSB investigated the accident. The flight data recorder (FDR) and cockpit voice recorder (CVR) were recovered from the wreckage with their data mostly intact, and the cockpit audio was reconstructed and transcribed.
The NTSB correlated the cockpit conversations with the ATC communications transcript and noted that it was the first officer, at the captain's request, who asked ATC about hail in the area and received the response from ATC that "no ... they've all deviated around to the east." At that point, according to the CVR transcript, the captain advised the first officer:
Shortly thereafter, the first officer stated: ". . . it looks worse to me over there." The crew then requested and received clearance from ATC for the 180 degree turn. The turn became extremely steep, with a bank of over 90 degrees and a nose pitch down of 40 degrees. As they were trying to recover from the turn, the FDR indicated a peak acceleration of 4.3 g, which the NTSB concluded caused a structural overstress and inflight breakup.
On June 19, 1969 the NTSB issued its final report, which included the following Probable Cause statement:
Probable Cause: The stressing of the aircraft structure beyond its ultimate strength during an attempted recovery from an unusual attitude induced by turbulence associated with a thunderstorm. The operation in the turbulence resulted from a decision to penetrate an area of known severe weather.
The passengers included:
- Several doctors and their wives, returning home to Dallas from a conference in Houston.
- Joseph E. Lockridge, one of the first African Americans to be elected to the Texas House of Representatives since Reconstruction.
- A number of federal government workers.
- Oilmen with Mobil, Continental and General American Oil.
- Four other Braniff employees.
- Half a dozen soldiers with the U.S. Air Force and U.S. Army.
- The office manager for the Great National Life Insurance Company of Dallas.
- The office manager for the Great National Life Insurance Company of Fort Worth.
- Unbeknownst to the passengers, the cargo bay contained one corpse, that of Mildred Wilkinson.
- Crew 
- Capt. John Ralph Phillips (46)
- First Officer John W. "Jack" Foster
- Second Officer Steve W. Crossland
- Hostess Jo Carol Brand, originally of Taylor, North Dakota
- Hostess Suzanne Renz, originally of South Orange, New Jersey
- Passenger names
- Dr. L. E. Adin, Dallas
- William F. Alexander, Jr., Dallas
- Mrs. B. Antich, Houston
- Dr. Joe B. Barnett, Dallas (37)
- James E. Doell, Dallas
- Karney Brent, Dallas
- Mrs. Elaine Brown, Galveston, Tex
- William R. Burton, Ohio (40)
- Thomas Keener Cambre, Dallas
- Mrs. Lou Cherry, Edna, Texas (72)
- Theodore Floyd Clark Sr, Dallas
- Wayne Collins, Dallas
- Lawrence Rene Cordet, Dallas
- Everett W. Corl, Houston
- Kenneth Cornella, Middletown, Ohio (32)
- Lou Ellen Currier, Garland, Tex
- Edward L. Davis, Dallas
- Molly Ann Deware; Braniff Cargo Secretary (25)
- Howard Dinwiddie, Houston
- Dr. Paul Roscoe Ellis Jr, Dallas
- George G. Elwood, Fort Worth
- John R. Ford, no town given
- James Calvin Grant, Dallas
- Robert Paul Gravesmill, Dallas
- Victor Campbell Hayes, Dallas
- Charles Wilson Harshaw, Fort Worth
- Mrs. Lanora Lavelle Hawkins, Corpus Christi, Tex
- Mrs. Neva Hawkins, Corpus Christi, Tex
- Fred Louis Herrmann, New York City
- John Daniel Haverstock Jr, Dallas
- Henry Stephen Hollis, Houston (21) U.S. Air Force
- Jackie Dean Hurley, Rosenberg, Tex
- John Ray Kubitz, San Antonio
- John Thomas Llewellyn, Denver, Colo (43)
- Joseph Edwin Lockridge, Dallas
- Louis Ira Masquelier, Dallas
- Robert James Maxwell, Middletown, Ohio
- Thoms L. Maxwell, JR., Irving, Tex (45)
- Mrs. Lulu Beth McBee, Poteau, Okla (51)
- Herbert William McCormick, Midland, Mich
- Allen N. McDowell, Richardson, Tex
- Edward Calvin "Eddie" McDuff, Hurst, Tex
- Hugh Herron McGaughy Jr, no address
- William "Bill" McPherson, Irving
- William Wade Meeker, Fort Worth
- Lewis Dean Messersmith, Irving
- Mrs. Carol Ann Murray, no address
- Lorentz Peter "Larry" Myhr, Dallas (42)
- Robert Roy "Bob" Neal, Tulsa, Okla.
- Miss D. O'Neal, Houston
- Edward Lee Pitts, Michigan (32)
- Dr. James Knox Pittard Jr, Anson, Tex
- Ruth Clark Pittard, Anson
- William Walter Reagan, no address
- John Walter Rogers, Tulsa, Oklahoma
- John Roberts, Dallas, Braniff employee
- Fred Albert Ryser III, Houston, Texas
- Miss Diane Jackie Schnell, Dallas (18)
- Robert Dale "Bob" Spencer, Dallas
- James Norton Shepperd, Dallas
- Jimmy Dan Thompson, Fort Worth (38)
- William R. Trotter, Tulsa, Okla
- William S. Tucker, Richardson, Tex
- Norman L Vagneur, Aspen, Colorado U.S. Army
- Robert Odes Whiddon Jr, Dallas
- Robert Andrew Whitburn, Galveston, Texas (19) U.S. Air Force
- William Robert "Bob" Wilcox, Dallas
- MRS. Willey Wright, Dallas
- Clyde Ray Williams (37)
- Laverne B. "Pete" Yochim, Erie, PA
- Accident description at the Aviation Safety Network. Retrieved on 2006-10-14.
- "NTSB Report" (PDF).
- Finding #15 in the NTSB report
- Finding #26 in the NTSB report
- "New York Times", May 4, 1968
- Other possible interpretations for the parenthesized words which were garbled in the audio: "we'd made the" or "we made a"
- Airliners.net Photos of Electra N9707C, in Dallas Love Field
- Corsicana Daily Sun "Dawson Plane Crash Remembered"
- 84 Die in Worst Texas Air Disaster May 1968
- Passenger List of Flight 352