Brenton Butler case
|Brenton Butler case|
|Court||Duval County Courthouse|
|Full case name||State of Florida v. Brenton Leonard Butler|
|Decided||November 21, 2000|
|Judge(s) sitting||Waddell Wallace|
The Brenton Butler case (officially State of Florida v. Brenton Leonard Butler) was a murder case in Jacksonville, Florida. During the investigation of a shooting death outside a motel in 2000, police arrested 15-year-old Brenton Butler and charged him with the murder. Butler subsequently confessed to the crime, and the case went to trial. However, during the trial he testified that he had been brutalized into his confession, and he was acquitted. The case gained significant notice in the media, and became the subject of an award-winning documentary, Murder on a Sunday Morning.
In May 2000, two tourists from Florida were accosted outside the Ramada Inn on University Boulevard. Mary Ann Stephens was shot in the head in front of her husband and the killer fled. During the subsequent investigation, police picked up Butler, a 15-year-old student at Englewood High School who was on his way to submit a job application to a local Blockbuster Video. Butler was brought to the victim's husband, who identified him as the killer.
Police brought Butler in for questioning without a parent or attorney present or informing his parents of his whereabouts, and coerced him into confessing to the murder by signing a timeline of events written by Detective Williams. State Attorney Harry Shorstein decided to prosecute the case. During the trial, Butler went on to testify that two detectives involved in the investigation, including Michael Glover, son of the then current Sheriff Nat Glover, had physically abused him and intimidated him into confessing.
Butler was represented by Patrick McGuinness and Ann Finnell, two attorneys from the Public defenders office. They supplied a photograph of Butler with bruises on his face, which they claimed was the result of the interrogation. The jury deliberated for less than an hour before finding Butler not guilty; one juror later cited the testimony about the interrogation as one of the key factors in their decision. State Attorney Shorstein and Jacksonville Sheriff Glover took the unusual steps of apologizing to Butler and re-opening the case of two unrelated suspects. However, Michael Glover denied the allegations against him, and Shorstein said there was no evidence that Butler had been physically abused during the interrogation.
After the case, the State Attorney's Office launched a grand jury investigation into the conduct of the officers and prosecutors, while the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office began an internal affairs investigation. The grand jury investigation criticized the prosecutor and police for their handling of the case but found no evidence of criminal wrongdoing. The police disciplinary board sought the suspension of three officers and other penalties for two more, but these measures were later largely overturned. Michael Glover retired from JSO and became a private investigator, while Dwayne Darnell was transferred from the homicide division.
The Butler case opened up discussion about the video taping of police interrogations. At the time of the investigation, the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office was in discussions over implementing video recording during interrogations. The office had purchased the equipment and was prepared to start taping interrogations, but held off at the request of the State Attorney's Office. After the grand jury investigation, the Sheriff's office began taping interrogations of juvenile suspects, and implemented other procedural changes recommended by the jury.
The Butler case was the subject of the French documentary film Murder on a Sunday Morning, which won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature at the 74th Academy Awards in 2001. The documentary follows Butler's defense team as they build their case for his innocence. In 2004, Butler wrote a book about his experience, entitled They Said It Was Murder.
After Butler's acquittal, his attorneys tipped the Sheriff's Office to two other suspects, Juan Curtis and Jermel Williams. Williams pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and testified against his co-defendant at the trial; he was sentenced to ten years in prison. Curtis' fingerprints were found on the victim's purse, which had been recovered after the crime but had never been tested. The Butler case figured into the new trial; the judge allowed Curtis' lawyers to discuss the eye-witness identification, but ruled that Florida's evidence laws forbade them from using Butler's confession. Curtis was subsequently found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison. However, in 2004 appeals court found that the exclusion of the confession denied Curtis' constitutional right to a fair trial, and granted a retrial. At this second trial Curtis was found guilty and sentenced to two consecutive life terms.
In late February 2001, lawyers for the Butler family announced that they were moving forward with a civil lawsuit seeking $2.5 million in damages against the City, the Sheriff's Department and individual officers involved. Eight months later, the lawsuit was refiled, seeking $8.5 million. Finally, on April 29, 2002, the Butler family accepted a $775,000 settlement from the city. According to their attorney, the family decided to settle for various reasons, including concerns about how long the case would drag on and the difficulty in proving the case under federal civil rights law.
- Pinkham, Paul (February 23, 2001). "Butler case spotlights interrogations". The Florida Times-Union. Retrieved July 7, 2009.
- "Court strikes conviction in murder case". St. Petersburg Times. Associated Press. May 21, 2004. Retrieved July 18, 2009.
- "Brenton Butler Arrested For Misdemeanor". news4jax.com. May 12, 2003. Archived from the original on June 4, 2009. Retrieved July 7, 2009.
- Schoettler, Jim (February 18, 2004). "Teen's book details ordeal of his arrest". The Florida Times-Union. Retrieved July 7, 2009.
- "Murder on a Sunday Morning". The New York Times: Movies. Retrieved 2008-11-23.
- "Man Gets Two Life Sentences in Ga. Tourist Murder". news4jax.com. October 29, 2004. Archived from the original on March 1, 2005. Retrieved July 20, 2009.
- "Butler Family Plans $2.5 Million Civil Lawsuit" Archived June 3, 2009, at the Wayback Machine. (February 22, 2001). From news4jax.com. Retrieved July 7, 2009.
- "Falsely Accused Teen Sues For $8.5 Million" Archived June 3, 2009, at the Wayback Machine. (October 18, 2001). From news4jax.com. Retrieved July 7, 2009.
- "Butler Family Settles Lawsuit With City" Archived June 4, 2009, at the Wayback Machine. (April 29, 2002). From news4jax.com. Retrieved July 7, 2009.