Bruno Bettelheim

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Bruno Bettelheim
Born(1904-08-28)August 28, 1904
DiedMarch 13, 1990(1990-03-13) (aged 86)
NationalityAustrian, American (since 1944)
CitizenshipUnited States
Alma materUniversity of Vienna
Known forAutism research
The Uses of Enchantment
Spouse(s)Gina Alstadt (1930–?; divorced)
Gertrude Weinfeld (1941–1984; her death; 3 children)[1]
Scientific career
FieldsChild psychology
InstitutionsUniversity of Chicago
Sonia Shankman Orthogenic School
Stanford University
Doctoral studentsBenjamin Drake Wright

Bruno Bettelheim (August 28, 1903 – March 13, 1990) was an Austrian-born psychologist, scholar, public intellectual and writer who spent most of his academic and clinical career in the United States. An early writer on autism, Bettelheim's work focused on the education of emotionally disturbed children, as well as Freudian psychology more generally. In the U.S., he later gained a position as professor at the University of Chicago and director of the Sonia Shankman Orthogenic School for Disturbed Children, and after 1973 taught at Stanford University.[2]

Bettelheim's ideas, which grew out of those of Sigmund Freud, theorized that children with behavioral and emotional disorders were not born that way, and could be treated through extended psychoanalytic therapy, treatment that rejected the use of psychotropic drugs and shock therapy.[3] During the 1960s and 1970s he had an international reputation in such fields as autism, child psychiatry, and psychoanalysis.[4][5]

Much of his work was discredited after his death due to fraudulent academic credentials, allegations of patient abuse, accusations of plagiarism, and lack of oversight by institutions and the psychological community.

Background in Austria[edit]

Bruno Bettelheim was born in Vienna, Austria-Hungary, on August 28, 1903. When his father died, Bettelheim left his studies at the University of Vienna to look after his family's sawmill. Having discharged his obligations to his family's business, Bettelheim returned as a mature student in his thirties to the University of Vienna.[citation needed] Sources disagree about his education (see Misrepresented credentials section).

Bettelheim's first wife, Gina, took care of a troubled American child, Patsy, who lived in their home in Vienna for seven years, and who may have been on the autism spectrum.[6][7][8]

In the Austrian academic culture of Bettelheim's time, one could not study the history of art without mastering aspects of psychology.[citation needed] Candidates for the doctoral dissertation in the History of Art in 1938 at Vienna University had to fulfill prerequisites in the formal study of the role of Jungian archetypes in art, and in art as an expression of the unconscious.

Though Jewish by birth, Bettelheim grew up in a secular family. After the Anschluss (political annexation) of Austria on March 13, 1938, the National Socialist (Nazi) authorities sent Austrian Jews and political opponents to the Dachau and Buchenwald concentration camps where many were brutally treated, and tortured or killed. Bettelheim was arrested some two months later on May 28, 1938, and was imprisoned in both these camps for ten and half months before being released on April 14, 1939.[9][10] While at the Buchenwald camp, he met and befriended the social psychologist Ernst Federn. As a result of an amnesty declared for Adolf Hitler's birthday (which occurred slightly later on April 20, 1939), Bettelheim and hundreds of other prisoners were released.[citation needed] Bettelheim drew on the experience of the concentration camps for some of his later work.

Life and career in the United States[edit]

Bettelheim arrived by ship as a refugee in New York City in late 1939 to join his wife Gina, who had already emigrated. They divorced because she had become involved with someone else during their separation.[citation needed] He soon moved to Chicago, became a naturalized U.S. citizen in 1944, and married an Austrian woman, Gertrude ('Trudi') Weinfeld, also an emigrant from Vienna.

Psychology[edit]

The Rockefeller Foundation sponsored a wartime project to help resettle European scholars by circulating their resumes to American universities. Through this process, Ralph Tyler hired Bettelheim to be his research assistant at the University of Chicago from 1939 to 1941 with funding from the Progressive Education Association to evaluate how high schools taught art. Once this funding ran out, Bettelheim found a job at Rockford College, Illinois, where he taught from 1942 to 1944.[2][5][11]

In 1943, he published the paper "Individual and Mass Behavior in Extreme Situations" about his experiences in the concentration camps, a paper which was highly regarded by Dwight Eisenhower among others.[4] Bettelheim claimed he had interviewed 1,500 fellow prisoners, although this was unlikely.[4][12] He stated that the Viennese psychoanalyst Richard Sterba had analyzed him, as well as implying in several of his writings that he had written a PhD dissertation in the philosophy of education. His actual PhD was in art history, and he had only taken three introductory courses in psychology.[13]

Through Ralph Tyler's recommendation, the University of Chicago appointed Bettelheim as a professor of psychology, as well as director of the Sonia Shankman Orthogenic School for emotionally disturbed children.[5] He held both positions from 1944 until his retirement in 1973. He wrote a number of books on psychology and, for a time, had an international reputation for his work on Sigmund Freud, psychoanalysis, and emotionally disturbed children.

At the Orthogenic School, Bettelheim made changes and set up an environment for milieu therapy, in which children could form strong attachments with adults within a structured but caring environment. He claimed considerable success in treating some of the emotionally disturbed children. He wrote books on both normal and abnormal child psychology, and became a major influence in the field, widely respected during his lifetime. He was noted for his study of feral children, who revert to the animal stage without experiencing the benefits of belonging to a community.[14] He discussed this phenomenon in the book The Informed Heart.[14] Even critics agree that, in his practice, Bettelheim was dedicated to helping these children using methods and practices that would enable them to lead happy lives.[15] It is based on his position that psychotherapy could change humans and that they can adapt to their environment provided they are given proper care and attention.[15]

Bettelheim was elected a Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1971.[16] After retiring in 1973, he and his wife moved to Portola Valley, California, where he continued to write and taught at Stanford University. His wife died in 1984.[17]

The Uses of Enchantment[edit]

Bettelheim analyzed fairy tales in terms of Freudian psychology in The Uses of Enchantment (1976). He discussed the emotional and symbolic importance of fairy tales for children, including traditional tales once considered too dark, such as those collected and published by the Brothers Grimm. Bettelheim suggested that traditional fairy tales, with the darkness of abandonment, death, witches, and injuries, allowed children to grapple with their fears in remote, symbolic terms. If they could read and interpret these fairy tales in their own way, he believed, they would get a greater sense of meaning and purpose. Bettelheim thought that by engaging with these socially evolved stories, children would go through emotional growth that would better prepare them for their own futures. In the United States, Bettelheim won two major awards for The Uses of Enchantment: the National Book Critics Circle Award for Criticism[18] and the National Book Award in the category of Contemporary Thought.[19]

However, in 1991, well-supported charges of plagiarism were brought against Bettelheim's The Uses of Enchantment, primarily that he had copied from Julian Herscher's 1963 A Psychiatric Study of Fairy Tales (revised ed. 1974).[20][21][22]

Death[edit]

At the end of his life, Bettelheim had depression. He appeared to have had difficulties with depression for much of his life.[23] In 1990, widowed, in failing physical health, and experiencing the effects of a stroke which impaired his mental abilities and paralyzed part of his body, he killed himself as a result of self-induced asphyxiation by placing a plastic bag over his head.[tone][24][25] He died on March 13, 1990, in Maryland.[26]

In popular culture[edit]

Bettelheim was a public intellectual, whose writing and many public appearances in popular media paralleled a growing post WWII interest in psychoanalysis.[27] For instance, he appeared multiple times on The Dick Cavett Show in the 70s to discuss theories of autism and psychoanalysis.[28] Pollak's biography argues that such popular appearances shielded Bettelheim's unethical behavior from scrutiny.[29]

Bettelheim appeared as himself in the 1983 Woody Allen mockumentary Zelig.

A BBC Horizon documentary about Bettelheim was televised in 1987.[30]

Controversies and scientific fraud accusations[edit]

Bettelheim's life and work have come under increasing scrutiny since his death.

Misrepresented credentials[edit]

Though he spent most of his life working in psychology and psychiatry, Bettelheim's educational background in those fields is murky at best. Sources disagree whether Bettelheim's PhD was in art history[31][32] or in philosophy (aesthetics).[33][34] When he was hired at the University of Chicago, Ralph W. Tyler assumed that he had two PhDs, one in art history and the other in psychology.[5] He also believed, falsely, that Bettelheim was certified to conduct psychoanalysis though Bettelheim never received such certification.[11] A posthumous review of his transcript showed that Bettelheim had only taken three introductory classes in psychology.[13] Bertram Cohler and Jacquelyn Sanders at the Orthogenic School believed Bettelheim had a PhD in art history.[5] In some of his own writings, Bettelheim implied that he had written a dissertation on the philosophy of education.[citation needed]

Determining Bettelheim's education is complicated by the fact that he routinely embellished or inflated aspects of his own biography. As an example, Bettelheim's first wife, Gina, took care of a troubled American child, Patsy, who lived in their home in Vienna for seven years. Although Bettelheim later claimed he himself had taken care of the child, there is general agreement that his wife actually provided most of the child care.[33][35] However sources disagree on whether Patsy was autistic.[7][8] Bettelheim later claimed that it was Patsy who inspired him to study autism[7] and embellished her into two or even several autistic children in his home.[4][33][36]

Additionally, when he applied for a position at Rockford College in Illinois, he claimed in a résumé that he had earned summa cum laude doctorates in philosophy, art history, and psychology, and he made such claims that he had run the art department at Lower Austria's library, that he had published two books on art, that he had excavated Roman antiquities, and that he had engaged in music studies with Arnold Schoenberg. When he applied at the University of Chicago for a professorship and as director of the Orthogenic School, he further claimed that he had training in psychology, experience raising autistic children, and personal encouragement from Sigmund Freud.[37] The University of Chicago biographical sketch of Bettelheim listed a single PhD but no subject area.[5] Posthumous biographies of Bettelheim have investigated these claims and have come to no clear conclusions about his credentials.[38][39] A review in The Independent (UK) of Sutton's book stated that Bettelheim "despite claims to the contrary, possessed no psychology qualifications of any sort".[40] Another review in The New York Times by a different reviewer stated that Bettelheim "began inventing degrees he never earned".[4] A review in the Chicago Tribune stated "as Pollak demonstrates, Bettelheim was a snake-oil salesman of the first magnitude."[33]

In a 1997 Weekly Standard article Peter Kramer, clinical professor of psychiatry at Brown University, summarized: "There were snatches of truth in the tall tale, but not many. Bettelheim had earned a non-honors degree in philosophy, he had made acquaintances in the psychoanalytic community, and his first wife had helped raise a troubled child. But, from 1926 to 1938, —the bulk of the '14 years' at university—Bettelheim had worked as a lumber dealer in the family business."[8]

In his 1997 review of Pollak's book in the Baltimore Sun, Paul R. McHugh, then director of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at Johns Hopkins, stated "Bettelheim—with boldness, energy and luck—exploited American deference to Freudo-Nietzschean mind-sets and interpretation, especially when intoned in accents Viennese."[32]

Richard Pollak's 1997 biography of Bettelheim[edit]

In the New York Review of Books, Robert Gottlieb describes Pollak as a "relentlessly negative biographer," but Gottlieb still writes: "The accusations against Bettelheim fall into several categories. First, he lied; that is, he both exaggerated his successes at the school and falsified aspects of his background, claiming a more elaborate academic and psychoanalytic history in Vienna than he had actually had. There is conclusive evidence to support both charges." Gottlieb goes on to say that Bettelheim arrived in the United States as a Holocaust survivor and refugee without a job nor even a profession, and writes: "I suspect he said what he thought it was necessary to say, and was then stuck with these claims later on, when he could neither confirm them (since they were false) nor, given his pride, acknowledge that he had lied."[23]

Richard Pollak's biography begins with a personal account, for his brother died in an accident while home from Bettelheim's school on holiday. While playing hide-and-go-seek in a hay loft, the brother fell through a chute covered with hay and hit the concrete floor on the level below. Years later, Pollak hoped to get some information about his brother's life and sought out Bettelheim. As Pollak recounts, "Bettelheim immediately launched into an attack. The boys' father, he said, was a simple-minded 'schlemiel.' Their mother, he insisted, had rejected Stephen at birth forcing him to develop 'pseudo-feeble-mindedness' to cope." He went on to angrily ask: "What is it about these Jewish mothers, Mr. Pollak?" Bettelheim furthermore insisted the brother had committed suicide and made it look like an accident. Pollak did not believe this.[4][33][41]

As a review in the Baltimore Sun states, "The stance of infallibility over matters Pollak knew to be untrue prompted him to wonder about the foundation of Bettelheim's commanding reputation."[32]

In a 1997 book review in the New York Times, Sarah Boxer wrote: "Mr. Pollak gives a damning passage-for-passage comparison of the two [Bettelheim's book and Heuscher's earlier book]."[4]

Richard Pollak's biography, The Creation of Dr. B, portrays Bettelheim as an anti-Semite even though he was raised in a secular Jewish household, and asserts that Bettelheim criticized in others the same cowardice he himself had displayed in the concentration camps.[42]

Pollak's biography also states that two women reported that Bettelheim had fondled their breasts and those of other female students at the school while he was ostensibly apologizing to each for beating her.[42][8]

A number of reviewers criticized Pollak's writing style, commenting that his book was motivated by "Vengeance, not malice"[33] or that his book was "curiously unnuanced",[4] but they still largely agreed with his conclusions.[4][42]

Plagiarism in Bettelheim's Uses of Enchantment[edit]

In 1991, Alan Dundes published an article in the Journal of American Folklore in which he claimed Bettelheim had engaged in plagiarism in his 1976 The Uses of Enchantment.[20] He argued that Bettelheim had copied from a variety of sources, including Dundes' own 1967 paper on Cinderella, but most of all from Dr. Julius E. Heuscher's 1963 book A Psychiatric Study of Fairy Tales (revised edition 1974).[4][21][22][43][44]

On the other hand, Jacquelyn Sanders, who worked with Bettelheim and later became director of the Orthogenic School, stated that she had read Dundes' article but disagreed with its conclusions: "I would not call that plagiarism. I think the article is a reasonable scholarly endeavor, and calling it scholarly etiquette is appropriate. It is appropriate that this man deserved to be acknowledged and Bettelheim didn't… But I would not fail a student for doing that, and I don't know anybody who would".[22]

Abusive treatment of students[edit]

Many students and staff at the school have argued that Bettelheim was abusive, violent, and cruel to them and to others. There are multiple newspaper accounts of abuse, in letters,[45][46][47][48][49] editorials[50] articles,[51][52] and memoirs.[53][54][55] A November 1990 Chicago Tribune article states: "Of the 19 alumni of the Orthogenic School interviewed for this story, some are still bitterly angry at Bettelheim, 20 or 30 years after leaving the institution due to the trauma they had suffered under him. Others say their stays did them good, and they express gratitude for having had the opportunity to be at the school. All agree that Bettelheim frequently struck his young and vulnerable patients."[5]

A particularly evocative example came from Alida Jatich, who lived at the school from 1966 to 1972 from ages twelve to eighteen. She wrote an initially anonymous April 1990 letter to the Chicago Reader in which she stated that she "lived in fear of Bettelheim's unpredictable temper tantrums, public beatings, hair pulling, wild accusations and threats and abuse in front of classmates and staff. One minute he could be smiling and joking, the next minute he could be exploding." She added, "In person, he was an evil man who set up his school as a private empire and himself as a demi-god or cultleader." Jatich said Bettelheim had "bullied, awed, and terrorized" the children at his school, their parents, school staff members, his graduate students, and anyone else who came into contact with him.[56][page needed]

Jacquelyn Sanders, who later became director of the Orthogenic School, said she thought it was a case of Bettelheim getting too much success too quickly. "Dr. B got worse once he started getting acclaim," she said. "He was less able to have any insight into his effect on these kids."[5]

Conversely, some staff who worked at the Orthogenic School have stated that they saw Bettelheim's behavior as being corporal punishment, in line with the standards of the time, and not abuse.[5][49][48][52] As an example, David Zwerdling, who was a counselor at the school for one year in 1969–70, wrote a Sept. 1990 response to The Washington Post in which he stated, "I witnessed one occasion when an adolescent boy cursed at a female counselor. Incensed upon learning of this, Dr. Bettelheim proceeded to slap the boy two or three times across the face, while telling him sternly never to speak that way to a woman again. This was the only such incident I observed or heard of during my year at the school… until fairly recently, the near-consensus against corporal punishment in schools did not obtain." However, Zwerdling also noted, "He also was a man who, for whatever reasons, was capable of intense anger on occasion."[48]

Published books, memoirs, and biographies of Bettelheim have also taken up the question of his treatment of students.[57][58][41]

Institutional and professional non-responses[edit]

Perhaps in part because of Bettelheim's professional and public stature, there was little effort during his lifetime to curtail his behavior or intervene on behalf of his victims. His work at the University of Chicago seems to have been given less formal oversight by the university than other research entities under their purview.[7]

A Newsweek article reported that Chicago-area psychiatrists had privately given him the nickname "Brutalheim," but did nothing to effectively intervene on behalf of students at the school.[59]

Professionals in the psychiatric and psychological communities likely knew there were allegations of abuse and maltreatment at the Orthogenic School.[60][49] Howard Gardner, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, wrote that many professionals knew of Bettelheim's behavior but did not confront him for various reasons including "fear about Bettelheim's legendary capacity for retribution to the solidarity needed among the guild of healers to a feeling that, on balance, Bettelheim's positive attributes predominated and an unmasking would fuel more malevolent forces."[42]

Autism controversy[edit]

Behavioral psychology and conditions in children and adolescents was little understood in the mid-twentieth century. The concept of "autism" was first used as a term for schizophrenia.[61] In the 1950s into the 1960s what may be understood as autism in children was regularly also referred to as "childhood psychosis and childhood schizophrenia". "Psychogenesis", the theory that childhood disorders had origins in early childhood events or trauma acting on the child from the outside was a prominent theory, and Bettelheim was a prominent proponent of a psychogenic basis for autism. For Bettelheim, the idea that outside forces cause individual behavior issues can be traced back to his earliest prominent article on the psychology of imprisoned persons.[62] Beginning in the 1960s and into the 1970s, "biogenesis", the idea that such conditions had an inner-organic or biological basis overtook psychogenesis.[63]

Currently, many of Bettelheim's theories in which he attributes autism spectrum conditions to parenting style are considered to be discredited, not least because of the controversies relating to his academic and professional qualifications.[64][65][66]

Autism spectrum conditions are now currently regarded as perhaps having multiple forms with a variety of genetic, epigenetic, and brain development causes influenced by such environmental factors as complications during pregnancy, viral infections, and perhaps even air pollution.[64][67][65][66][7][68][69]

The two biographies by Sutton (1995) and Pollak (1997) awakened interest and focus on Bettelheim's actual methods as distinct from his public persona.[7][68][4] Bettelheim's theories on the causes of autism have been largely discredited, and his reporting rates of cure have been questioned, with critics stating that his patients were not actually autistic.[33][7][70] In a favorable review of Pollak's biography, Christopher Lehmann-Haupt of The New York Times wrote, "What scanty evidence remains suggests that his patients were not even autistic in the first place."[68]

In 1997 the psychiatrist Peter Kramer wrote, "The Ford Foundation was willing to underwrite innovative treatments for autistic children, so Bettelheim labeled his children autistic. Few actually met the definition of the newly minted syndrome."[8]

Bettelheim believed that autism did not have an organic basis, but resulted when mothers withheld appropriate affection from their children and failed to make a good connection with them. Bettelheim also blamed absent or weak fathers. One of his most famous books, The Empty Fortress (1967), contains a complex and detailed explanation of this dynamic in psychoanalytical and psychological terms. These views were disputed at the time by mothers of autistic children and by researchers.[71] He derived his thinking from the qualitative investigation of clinical cases.[citation needed] He also related the world of autistic children to conditions in concentration camps.

It appears that Leo Kanner first came up with the term "refrigerator mother," although Bettelheim did a lot to popularize the term. "Although it now seems beyond comprehension that anyone would believe that autism is caused by deep-seated issues arising in early childhood relationships, virtually every psychiatric condition was attributed to parent-child relationships in the 1940s and 1950s, when Freudian psychoanalytic theory was in its heyday."[72]

In A Good Enough Parent, published in 1987, he had come to the view that children had considerable resilience and that most parents could be "good enough" to help their children make a good start.[73][unreliable source?]

Prior to this, Bettelheim subscribed to and became an early prominent proponent of the "refrigerator mother" theory of autism: the theory that autistic behaviors stem from the emotional frigidity of the children's mothers. He adapted and transformed the Orthogenic School at the University of Chicago as a residential treatment milieu for such children, who he felt would benefit from a "parentectomy". This marked the apex of autism viewed as a disorder of parenting.[69][74]

A 2002 book on autism spectrum stated, "At the time, few people knew that Bettelheim had faked his credentials and was using fictional data to support his research."[75] Michael Rutter has observed, "Many people made a mistake in going from a statement which is undoubtedly true—that there is no evidence that autism has been caused by poor parenting—to the statement that it has been disproven. It has not actually been disproven. It has faded away simply because, on the one hand, of a lack of convincing evidence and on the other hand, an awareness that autism was a neurodevelopmental disorder of some kind."[76]

In a 1997 review of two books on Bettelheim, Molly Finn wrote "I am the mother of an autistic daughter, and have considered Bettelheim a charlatan since The Empty Fortress, his celebrated study of autism, came out in 1967. I have nothing personal against Bettelheim, if it is not personal to resent being compared to a devouring witch, an infanticidal king, and an SS guard in a concentration camp, or to wonder what could be the basis of Bettelheim's statement that 'the precipitating factor in infantile autism is the parent's wish that his child should not exist.'"[7]

Although Bettelheim foreshadowed the modern interest in the causal influence of genetics in the section Parental Background, he consistently emphasised nurture over nature. For example: "When at last the once totally frozen affects begin to emerge, and a much richer human personality to evolve, then convictions about the psychogenic nature of the disturbance become stronger still."; On Treatability, p. 412. The rates of recovery claimed for the Orthogenic School are set out in Follow-up Data, with a recovery good enough to be considered a 'cure' of 43%, pp. 414–15.

Subsequently, medical research has provided greater understanding of the biological basis of autism and other illnesses. Scientists such as Bernard Rimland challenged Bettelheim's view of autism by arguing that autism is a neurodevelopmental issue. As late as 2009, the "refrigerator mother" theory retained some prominent supporters,[24][77] including the prominent Irish psychologist Tony Humphreys.[78] His theory still enjoys widespread support in France.[79][dubious ]

In his book Unstrange Minds (2007), Roy Richard Grinker wrote:

Two other books on autism, published at about the same time [as Bettelheim's Empty Fortress (1967)], got little mention in the press: Bernard Rimland's Autism: The Syndrome and Its Implications for a Neural Theory of Behavior (1964), which outlined the biological and neurological aspects of autism, and Clara Clairborne Park's The Siege (1967), a beautifully written memoir of raising an autistic child. Though they were more accurate depictions of autism, they couldn't compete with Bettelheim. He was simply too good a writer, and with his Viennese accent—the sign of an authentic expert in psychology—too good a self promoter.[80]

Jordynn Jack writes that Bettelheim's ideas gained currency and became popular in large part because society already tended to blame a mother first and foremost for her child's difficulties.[81]

Remarks about Jews and the Holocaust[edit]

Bettelheim's experiences during the Holocaust shaped his personal and professional life for years after. His first publication was "Individual and Mass Behavior in Extreme Situations" derived from his experiences at Dachau and Buchenwald.[82] His later work frequently compared emotionally disturbed childhood to prison or confinement, and according to Sutton, his professional work attempted to operationalize the lessons about human nature he learned during his confinement.[83]

Bettelheim became one of the most prominent defenders of Hannah Arendt's book Eichmann in Jerusalem. He wrote a positive review for The New Republic.[84] This review prompted a letter from a writer, Harry Golden, who alleged that both Bettelheim and Arendt suffered from "an essentially Jewish phenomenon… self-hatred".[85][86]

Bettelheim would later speak critically of Jewish people who were killed during the Holocaust. He has been criticized for promoting the myth that Jews went "like sheep to the slaughter" and for blaming Anne Frank and her family for their own deaths due to not owning firearms, fleeing, or hiding more effectively.[87][88] In an introduction he wrote to an account by Miklos Nyiszli, Bettelheim stated, discussing Frank that "Everybody who recognized the obvious knew that the hardest way to go underground was to do it as a family; that to hide as a family made detection by the SS most likely. The Franks, with their excellent connections among gentile Dutch families should have had an easy time hiding out singly, each with a different family. But instead of planning for this, the main principle of their planning was to continue as much as possible with the kind of family life they were accustomed to."[89]

Bibliography[edit]

Major works by Bettelheim[edit]

  • 1943 "Individual and Mass Behavior in Extreme Situations", Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 38: 417–452.
  • 1950 Bettleheim, Bruno and Janowitz, Morris, Dynamics of Prejudice: A Psychological & Sociological Study of Veterans, Harper & Bros.
  • 1950 Love Is Not Enough: The Treatment of Emotionally Disturbed Children, Free Press, Glencoe, Ill.
  • 1954 Symbolic Wounds: Puberty Rites and the Envious Male, Free Press, Glencoe, Ill.
  • 1955 Truants From Life: The Rehabilitation of Emotionally Disturbed Children, Free Press, Glencoe, Ill.
  • 1959 "Joey: A 'Mechanical Boy'", Scientific American, 200, March 1959: 117–126. (About a boy who believes himself to be a robot.)
  • 1960 The Informed Heart: Autonomy in a Mass Age, The Free Press, Glencoe, Ill.
  • 1962 Dialogues with Mothers, The Free Press, Glencoe, Ill.
  • 1967 The Empty Fortress: Infantile Autism and the Birth of the Self, The Free Press, New York
  • 1969 The Children of the Dream, Macmillan, London & New York (About the raising of children in a kibbutz environment.)
  • 1974 A Home for the Heart, Knopf, New York. (About Bettelheim's Orthogenic School at the University of Chicago for schizophrenic and autistic children.)
  • 1976 The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales, Knopf, New York. ISBN 0-394-49771-6
  • 1979 Surviving and Other Essays, Knopf, New York (Includes the essay "The Ignored Lesson of Anne Frank".)
  • 1982 On Learning to Read: The Child's Fascination with Meaning (with Karen Zelan), Knopf, New York
  • 1982 Freud and Man's Soul, Knopf, 1983, ISBN 0-394-52481-0
  • 1987 A Good Enough Parent: A Book on Child-Rearing, Knopf, New York
  • 1990 Freud's Vienna and Other Essays, Knopf, New York
  • 1993, Bettelheim, Bruno and Rosenfeld, Alvin A, "The Art of the Obvious" Knopf.
  • 1994 Bettelheim, Bruno & Ekstein, Rudolf: "Grenzgänge zwischen den Kulturen. Das letzte Gespräch zwischen Bruno Bettelheim und Rudolf Ekstein [de]". In: Kaufhold, Roland (ed.) (1994): Annäherung an Bruno Bettelheim. Mainz (Grünewald): 49–60.

Critical reviews of Bettelheim (works and person)[edit]

  • Angres, Ronald: "Who, Really, Was Bruno Bettelheim?", personal essay, Commentary, 90, (4), October 1990: 26–30.
  • Bernstein, Richard: "Accusations of Abuse Haunt the Legacy of Dr. Bruno Bettelheim", The New York Times, November 4, 1990: "The Week in Review" section.
  • Bersihand, Geneviève (1977). Bettelheim [Bettelheim]. Champigny-sur-Marne: R. Jauze. p. 199. ISBN 2-86214-001-5.
  • Dundes, Alan: "Bruno Bettelheim's Uses of Enchantment and Abuses of Scholarship". The Journal of American Folklore, Vol. 104, N0. 411. (Winter, 1991): 74–83.
  • Ekstein, Rudolf (1994): "Mein Freund Bruno (1903–1990). Wie ich mich an ihn erinnere". In: Kaufhold, Roland (ed.) (1994): Annäherung an Bruno Bettelheim. Mainz (Grünewald), S. 87–94.
  • Eliot, Stephen: Not the Thing I Was: Thirteen Years at Bruno Bettelheim's Orthogenic School, St. Martin's Press, 2003.
  • Federn, Ernst (1994): "Bruno Bettelheim und das Überleben im Konzentrationslager". In: Kaufhold, Roland (ed.) (1999): Ernst Federn: Versuche zur Psychologie des Terrors. Gießen (Psychosozial-Verlag): 105–108.
  • Finn M (1997). "In the case of Bruno Bettelheim". First Things (74): 44–8.
  • Fisher, David James: Psychoanalytische Kulturkritik und die Seele des Menschen. Essays über Bruno Bettelheim (co-editor: Roland Kaufhold), Gießen (Psychosozial-Verlag)
  • Fisher, David James: Bettelheim: Living and Dying, Contemporary Psychoanalytic Studies, Amsterdam, New York: Brill/Rodopi, 2008.
  • Frattaroli, Elio: "Bruno Bettelheim's Unrecognized Contribution to Psychoanalytic Thought", Psychoanalytic Review, 81:379–409, 1994.
  • Heisig, James W.: "Bruno Bettelheim and the Fairy Tales", Children's Literature, 6, 1977: 93–115.
  • Kaufhold, Roland (ed.): Pioniere der psychoanalytischen Pädagogik: Bruno Bettelheim, Rudolf Ekstein, Ernst Federn und Siegfried Bernfeld, psychosozial Nr. 53 (1/1993)
  • Kaufhold, Roland (Ed.): Annäherung an Bruno Bettelheim. Mainz, 1994 (Grünewald)
  • Kaufhold, Roland (1999): "Falsche Fabeln vom Guru?" Der "Spiegel" und sein Märchen vom bösen Juden Bruno Bettelheim", Behindertenpädagogik, 38. Jhg., Heft 2/1999, S. 160–187.
  • Kaufhold, Roland: Bettelheim, Ekstein, Federn: Impulse für die psychoanalytisch-pädagogische Bewegung. Gießen, 2001 (Psychosozial-Verlag).
  • Kaufhold, Roland/Löffelholz, Michael (Ed.) (2003): "'So können sie nicht leben' – Bruno Bettelheim (1903–1990)". Zeitschrift für Politische Psychologie 1-3/2003.
  • Lyons, Tom W. (1983), The Pelican and After: A Novel about Emotional Disturbance, Richmond, Virginia: Prescott, Durrell, and Company. This is a roman à clef novel in which the author lived at the Orthogenic School for almost twelve years. The novel's head of the institution is a "Dr. V."
  • Marcus, Paul: Autonomy in the Extreme Situation. Bruno Bettelheim, the Nazi Concentration Camps and the Mass Society, Praeger, Westport, Conn., 1999.
  • Pollak, Richard: The Creation of Dr. B: A Biography of Bruno Bettelheim, Simon & Schuster, New York, 1997.
  • Raines, Theron (2002). Rising to the light : a portrait of Bruno Bettelheim (1 ed.). New York: Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 0-679-40196-2.
  • Redford, Roberta Carly (2010) Crazy: My Seven Years At Bruno Bettelheim's Orthogenic School, Trafford Publishing, 364 pages.
  • Sutton, Nina: Bruno Bettelheim: The Other Side of Madness, Duckworth Press, London, 1995. (Translated from the French by David Sharp in collaboration with the author. Subsequently, published with the title Bruno Bettelheim, a Life and a Legacy.)
  • Zipes, Jack: "On the Use and Abuse of Folk and Fairy Tales with Children: Bruno Bettelheim's Moralistic Magic Wand", in Zipes, Jack: Breaking the Magic Spell: Radical Theories of Folk and Fairy Tales, University of Texas Press, Austin, 1979.

References[edit]

  1. ^ Andrews, Deborah; Turner, Roland (1990). The Annual Obituary. ISBN 978-1-55862092-6.
  2. ^ a b John F. Ohles ed., 1978, Biographical Dictionary of American Educators, Vol. 1, London, England and Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
  3. ^ Fountain, John W. (March 14, 1990). "Dr. Bruno Bettleheim, child psychology expert". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved May 12, 2019.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Boxer, Sarah (January 26, 1997). "The Man He Always Wanted to Be". The New York Times. Retrieved December 2, 2016. Bruno Bettelheim's new biographer lays his cards on the table right away: he thinks Bettelheim was a pathological liar.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i Ron Grossman, November 11, 1990 Solving The Puzzle That Was Bruno Bettelheim, Chicago Tribune. "Yet the [University of Chicago]'s official biographical sketch credits Bettelheim with only one Ph.D., and doesn't specify a field."
  6. ^ Winn 1997 "He was familiar with this disease because his first wife, Gina, had cared for an autistic child in their home for several years.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h Finn 1997.
  8. ^ a b c d e Peter D. Kramer, April 7, 1997 The battle over Bettelheim, Weekly Standard.
  9. ^ Silberman 2015, pp. 202–3.
  10. ^ Samuel Totten, Paul R. Bartrop, 2008, Dictionary of Genocide, Volume 1: A–L, "Bettelheim, Bruno (1903–1990)," with contributions by Steven Leonard Jacobs, Westport, CT, U.S. and London, UK: Greenwood.
  11. ^ a b Morris Finder, 2004, Educating America: How Ralph W. Tyler Taught America to Teach, forew. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Westport, CT, London: Praeger, p. 41.
  12. ^ Silberman 2015, pp. 199–208: "The closest he ever came to meeting Freud was walking past his house."
  13. ^ a b Ron Grossman, January 23, 1997, Genius or Fraud? Bettelheim's Biographers Can't Seem To Decide, Chicago Tribune, "…he evidently gambled that because of the war no one would be able to check on his credentials…"
  14. ^ a b Poplau, Ronald W. (2018). A Living Classroom: Ideas for Student Creativity and Community Service. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 74. ISBN 978-1-4758-4854-0.
  15. ^ a b Zipes, Jack (2002). Breaking the Magic Spell: Radical Theories of Folk and Fairy Tales. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky. p. 179. ISBN 0-8131-9030-4.
  16. ^ "B" (PDF), Book of Members, 1780–2010, American Academy of Arts and Sciences, retrieved June 24, 2011
  17. ^ Merkin, Daphne (September 2, 2014). The Fame Lunches: On Wounded Icons, Money, Sex, the Brontës, and the Importance of Handbags. Macmillan. p. 38. ISBN 978-0-37414037-3.
  18. ^ "All Past National Book Critics Circle Award Winners and Finalists" Archived June 4, 2019, at the Wayback Machine. National Book Critics Circle. Retrieved 2019-05-09.
  19. ^ "National Book Awards – 1977". National Book Foundation. Retrieved 2019-05-09.
    There was a "Contemporary" or "Current" award category from 1972 to 1980.
  20. ^ a b Dundes, Alan: "Bruno Bettelheim's Uses of Enchantment and Abuses of Scholarship". The Journal of American Folklore, Vol. 104, No. 411. (Winter, 1991): pp. 74–83.
  21. ^ a b Bettelheim Plagiarized Book Ideas, Scholar Says : Authors: The late child psychologist is accused of 'wholesale borrowing' for study of fairy tales, Los Angeles Times, Anne C. Roark, Feb. 7, 1991. The article includes a contrast-and-compare between Bettelheim and a passage from Julius Heuscher's book.
  22. ^ a b c Bettelheim Accused of Plagiarizing Book, Chicago Tribune, Sharman Stein, February 7, 1991.
  23. ^ a b Robert Gottlieb, Feb 27, 2003, "The Strange Case of Dr. B.", The New York Review.
  24. ^ a b Severson, Katherine De Maria; Aune, James Arnt; Jodlowski, Denise (2007). "Bruno Bettelheim, Autism, and the Rhetoric of Scientific Authority". In Osteen, Mark (ed.). Autism and Representation. Routledge research in cultural and media studies. Routledge. pp. 65–77. ISBN 978-0-415-95644-4. Retrieved August 28, 2009.
  25. ^ Osgood, Nancy J. (July 1992). Suicide in later life. Lexington Books (published 1992). p. 4. ISBN 978-0-669-21214-3. Retrieved January 29, 2010.
  26. ^ John W. Fountain, March 14, 1990, Dr. Bruno Bettelheim, Child Psychology Expert, Chicago Tribune.
  27. ^ Silverman, Chloe. "From Disorders of Affect to Mindblindness: Framing the History of Autism Spectrum Disorders". The Society for Critical Exchange. Retrieved May 8, 2019.
  28. ^ "The Dick Cavett Show - Guests". dickcavettshow.com. Retrieved May 8, 2019.
  29. ^ In Print: the abominable Dr. Bettelheim, Chicago Reader, Cara Jepsen, Jan. 16, 1997.
  30. ^ "Horizon - BBC Two England - 2 February 1987". BBC Genome. Retrieved July 16, 2018.
  31. ^ Beck, Joan (1997). "Setting the record straight about a 'fallen guru'". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved May 7, 2019.
  32. ^ a b c McHugh, Paul R. (January 19, 1997). "Bruno Bettelheim: a cautionary life". Baltimore Sun. Archived from the original on January 19, 1997. Retrieved May 7, 2019.
  33. ^ a b c d e f g Winn 1997.
  34. ^ Lehmann-Haupt, Christopher (January 13, 1997). "An Icon of Psychology Falls From His Pedestal". The New York Times. Retrieved May 7, 2019.
  35. ^ Silberman 2015, p. 201.
  36. ^ Silberman 2015, p. 203, last ¶.
  37. ^ Beck 1997.
  38. ^ Sutton, Nina (1997). Bettelheim, a life and a legacy (pbk ed.). WestView Press. ISBN 0-81339099-0.
  39. ^ Pollak, Richard (1997). The creation of Dr. B: A biography of Bruno Bettelheim. New York: Simon & Schuster. p. 478. ISBN 0-684-80938-9.
  40. ^ Nicholas Tucker, 8 December 1995 Turbulent dreams of a damaged saint, The Independent UK (review of Bruno Bettelheim: A Life and a Legacy by Nina Sutton).
  41. ^ a b Setting The Record Straight About A 'Fallen Guru', Chicago Tribune, Joan Beck, Editorial, April 3, 1997. '…claimed he had summa cum laude degrees in three disciplines…'
  42. ^ a b c d Howard Gardner, Jan. 19, 1997 The Confidence Man : The creation of dr. B.: A Biography of Bruno Bettelheim. By Richard Pollak. Simon & Schuster: 478 pp., Los Angeles Times review. "…indicts those of his time who knew the man but kept their reservations to themselves."
  43. ^ A Psychiatric Study of Fairy Tales: Their Origin, Meaning and Usefulness, Julius E. Heuscher, illus. Melba Bennett, Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1963, 224 pp.
  44. ^ A Psychiatric Study of Fairy Tales: Their Origin, Meaning and Usefulness; enlarged, thoroughly rev. 2nd ed., Julius E. Heuscher, Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas, April 1974, 422 pp.
  45. ^ Alida Jatich, Oct. 29, 1990. A Personal View Of Bruno Bettelheim, Chicago Tribune 'Whenever Bettelheim called a young person "autistic" or "psychotic" or "homicidal" or "suicidal" or anything else, the staff believed him regardless of all evidence to the contrary. To them, the truth was whatever Bettelheim said it was, and their job was to get me and the other youngsters to accept it.'
  46. ^ Chicago Reader, Letters to the Editor, The Cult of Bettelheim, "By WB A former counselor," July 5, 1990.
  47. ^ Roberta Redford, Nov. 20, 1990 Letter to the Editor, The New York Times, 'Bettelheim Became the Very Evil He Loathed,' written Nov. 9. "I would like to believe that at the beginning his motives were pure. By the time I knew him, he was a megalomaniac, twisted and out of control. We were terrified of him, and lived for those days when he was out of town."
  48. ^ a b c Charles Pekow, Aug. 26, 1990, The Other Dr. Bettelheim, The Washington Post editorial. "…we could never tell when he would attack us for any arbitrary reason…" See 'The Other Dr. Bettelheim', Sept. 6, 1990, and The Bettelheim We Know (Cont'd.), Oct. 6, 1990, for the contrasting views of some counselors.
  49. ^ a b c Alida Jatich April 5, 1990 Chicago Reader, Letters to the Editor, Brutal Bettelheim, name withheld. Alida Jatich, April 4, 1991 The Monster of the Midway. The author lived at the "Orthogenic School" from 1966–72, and in her second letter acknowledges authorship of the first.
  50. ^ Joan Beck, Oct. 1, 1990, Bettelheim Led Us Cruelly Down Wrong Road for Children, Chicago Tribune editorial. "But autism is almost certainly caused by a genetic defect, not a cold style of mothering. (Even a quick look at children who are abused or neglected by parents should make it obvious that autism is a completely different kind of problem.)"
  51. ^ Bernstein, Richard: "Accusations of Abuse Haunt the Legacy of Dr. Bruno Bettelheim", The New York Times, November 4, 1990: "The Week in Review" section. "…not only of a tyrant but of a hypocrite as well."
  52. ^ a b Angres, Ronald: "Who, Really, Was Bruno Bettelheim?", personal essay, Commentary, 90, (4), October 1, 1990: 26–30.
  53. ^ Kenneth A. Kavale, Mark P. Mostert, 2004, The Positive Side of Special Education: Minimizing Its Fads, Fancies, and Follies, ScareCrow Education (imprint of The Rowman & Littlefield), p. 132.
  54. ^ Stephen Eliot, 2003 Not The Thing I Was: Thirteen Years at Bruno Bettelheim's Orthogenic School, New York: St. Martin's Press, as listed for Toronto Public Library.
  55. ^ Roberta Carly Redford, 2010, Crazy: My Seven Years at Bruno Bettelheim's Orthogenic School, Trafford Publishing, 364 pp. The author was a student at the school from 1967 to 1974, ages 16 to 23.
  56. ^ New York Times, November 4, 1990
  57. ^ Adam Feinstein, A History of Autism Conversations, Wiley Blackwell, p. 71
  58. ^ And They Call it Help: The Psychiatric Policing of America's Children, Louise Armstrong, Addison-Wesley, 1993, Chapter 3 "Bart Simpson Meets Bruno Bettelheim." See pages 75 and following for Alida Jatich's reports of abuse at the school. See pages 77 and following for the overall nonresponse from the Chicago psychiatric community. See pages 80 and following for more of Jatich's recounts of her experiences and her thoughts regarding why more people didn't speak up.
  59. ^ Newsweek, "'Beno Brutalheim'?," Nina Darnton, Sept. 10, 1990.
  60. ^ Late-Talking Children: A Symptom of a Stage?, Stephen M. Camarata, MIT Press, 2014. From "Ch. 4: Lessons from Autism: Charlatans, False Cures, and Questionable Cures", page 81 quotes a paragraph from Newsweek magazine.
  61. ^ Herman, Ellen. "Childhood Psychosis or Schizophrenia". The Autism History Project. University of Oregon. Retrieved February 29, 2020.
  62. ^ Herman, Ellen. "Bruno Bettelheim, "Schizophrenia as a Reaction to Extreme Situations," 1956". The Autism History Project. University of Oregon. Retrieved February 29, 2020.
  63. ^ Herman, Ellen. "Psychogenesis". The Autism History Project. University of Oregon. Retrieved February 29, 2020.
  64. ^ a b Workshop on U.S. Data to Evaluate Changes in the Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASDs), US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), February 1, 2011, Background: What Do We Know About ASD Prevalence?, M. Yeargin-Allsopp, p. 7, 'There are likely multiple forms of ASDs with multiple causes that are poorly understood.'
  65. ^ a b Why are the French still blaming mothers for autism?, Philly. Michael Yudell: Tuesday, January 31, 2012.
  66. ^ a b Address to Florida Autism Task Force on World Autism Day, Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN), Ari Ne'eman, April 2, 2008. '…the past few decades have resulted in a decrease in the stigmatization of parents of autistic children, as a result of the medical community moving away from the odious and damaging inaccuracy that autism is the result of "refrigerator mothers."'
  67. ^ Autism spectrum disorder, Cause, Mayo Clinic Staff, June 3, 2014. 'Genetic problems. Several different genes appear to be involved… Environmental factors. Researchers are currently exploring whether such factors as viral infections, complications during pregnancy or air pollutants play a role in triggering autism spectrum disorder.'
  68. ^ a b c Christopher Lehmann-Haupt, Jan. 13, 1997 An Icon of Psychology Falls From His Pedestal, The New York Times, Books, review of The Creation of Dr. B by Richard Pollak.
  69. ^ a b Separating Fact from Fiction in the Etiology and Treatment of Autism, Scientific Review of Mental Health Practice, James Herbert, Ian Sharp, Brandon Gaudiano (all three authors from Hahnemann University in Philadelphia, Penn.), Vol. 1: No. 1, Spring-Summer 2002. "…no controlled research has been produced to support the refrigerator mother theory of autism. For example, Allen, DeMeyer, Norton, Pontus, and Yang (1971) did not find differences between parents of autistic and mentally retarded children and matched comparison children on personality measures."
  70. ^ Ann Hulbert, 2003, Raising America: Experts, Parents, and a Century of Advice about Children, Random House. "An evocative case history approach like his allowed for fudging of samples, methods, and final results, and Bettelheim did so quite brazenly."
  71. ^ Lehmann-Haupt, Christopher 13 Jan. 1997, "An Icon of Psychology Falls From His Pedestal," The New York Times.
  72. ^ Lisa D. Benaron, 2009, Autism, Greenwood Press, p. 4.
  73. ^ Amazon reviews
  74. ^ Millon, Theodore; Krueger, mRobert F.; Simonsen, Erik, eds. (2011). Contemporary Directions in Psychopathology. Scientific Foundations of the DSM-V and ICD-11. New York City: Guilford Press. p. 555. ISBN 978-1-60623-533-1.
  75. ^ Valerie Paradiz, 2002, Elijah's Cup: A Family's Journey into the Community and Culture of High-Functioning Autism and Asperger's Syndrome, rev. ed., Free Press; UK: Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2005, pp. 72–73: "At the time, few people knew that Bettelheim had faked his credentials and was using fictional data to support his research. In 1944, with a forged resumé that suggested a stellar academic career in psychoanalysis in Austria, Bettelheim had made his way into a post as the director of the Orthgenic School for Disturbed Children at the University of Chicago."
  76. ^ Feinstein, Adam (2010). A History of Autism: Conversations with the Pioneers. Oxford, UK: Blackwell's. p. 68.
  77. ^ Feinstein, Adam. "'Refrigerator mother' tosh must go into cold storage". Autism connect. Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved July 29, 2007.
  78. ^ Humphreys, Tony (February 3, 2012). "Core connection: A diagnosis of Asperger's syndrome does little to help a child troubled by unhappy relationships". Irish Examiner. p. 7.
  79. ^ Heurtevent, David (January 2, 2012). "Introduction to Autism in France: A Really Silly Psychiatric System !". Support The Wall – Autism. Archived from the original on December 20, 2012. Retrieved February 25, 2012.
  80. ^ Roy Richard Grinker, 2007, Unstrange Minds: Remapping the World of Autism: A Father, a Daughter, and a Search for New Answers, New York: Basic Books (Perseus Books).
  81. ^ Jordynn Jack, 2014, Autism and Gender: From Refrigerator Mothers to Computer Geeks, University of Illinois Press.
  82. ^ Bettelheim, Bruno (1943). "Individual and Mass Behavior in Extreme Situations". Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 38 (4): 417–52. doi:10.1037/h0061208.
  83. ^ Sutton, Nina (1997). Bettelheim: A Life and a Legacy. Westview Press. ISBN 978-0-81339099-4.
  84. ^ The New Republic, June 15, 1963
  85. ^ The New Republic, July 20, 1963
  86. ^ Ezra, Michael (2007). "The Eichmann Polemics: Hannah Arendt and Her Critics". Democratiya (book review). London. Archived from the original on January 20, 2009. Retrieved February 20, 2009.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  87. ^ Tec, Nechama (Winter 2013). "Did Jews Go Like Sheep to the Slaughter?". Reform Judaism Magazine. Retrieved December 5, 2018.
  88. ^ Middleton-Kaplan, Richard (2014). "The Myth of Jewish Passivity". In Henry, Patrick (ed.). Jewish Resistance Against the Nazis. Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press. p. 10. ISBN 978-0-81322589-0.
  89. ^ Nyiszli, Miklos (2011) [1960]. Auschwitz: A Doctor's Eyewitness Account. Arcade. p. xiii. ISBN 978-1-62872926-9.

Bibliography[edit]

External links[edit]