Clutterbuck played two seasons in his major league career; 1986 and 1989. He was sent down to the Minor Leagues after his performance in 1986, but returned to the Major Leagues in 1989 pitching another mediocre year. He never played again after 1989. His career statistics include a 2–6 win/loss record, a 4.21 Earned Run Average, and 67 strikeouts.
Clutterbuck played college baseball at Eastern Michigan University for Coach Ron Oestrike. He died on August 23, 2016, from colon cancer.