|R-30 (RSM-56) Bulava |
|Place of origin||Russia|
|In service||10 January 2013|
|Used by||Russian Navy|
|Designer||Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology|
|Manufacturer||Votkinsk Plant State Production Association|
|Weight||36.8 t (36.2 long tons; 40.6 short tons)|
|Length||11.5 m (38 ft) (without warhead)
12.1 m (40 ft) (launch container)
|Diameter||2 m (6 ft 7 in) (missile)
2.1 m (6 ft 11 in) (launch container)
|Warhead||6 (can carry 10 to 4,000 km) re-entry vehicles with a yield of 150 kt each.|
|Engine||three stage, Solid-fuel rocket and Liquid-propellant rocket|
|Propellant||solid propellant and liquid fuel|
|inertial guidance, possibly Astro-inertial guidance with and/or GLONASS update|
Typhoon-class submarine Dmitri Donskoi
The Bulava (Russian: Булава, lit. "mace"; designation RSM-56, NATO reporting name SS-NX-30 or SS-N-32 , GRAU index 3M30) is a submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) developed for the Russian Navy and deployed in 2013 on the new Borei class of ballistic missile nuclear submarines. It is intended as the future cornerstone of Russia's nuclear triad, and is the most expensive weapons project in the country. The weapon takes its name from bulava, a Russian word for mace. Bulava has slightly greater range but a 30%+ lower throw-weight than the 1979 American Trident C4 missile.
Designed by Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology, development of the missile was launched in the late 1990s as a replacement for the R-39 Rif solid-fuel SLBM. It is expected that the first three Borei-class submarines will carry 16 missiles, while the following five vessels will carry 20 missiles. Development and deployment of the Bulava missile within the Russian Navy is not affected by the enforcement of the new START treaty.
The missile's flight test programme was problematic. Until 2009, there were 6 failures in 13 flight tests and one failure during ground test, blamed mostly on substandard components. After a failure in December 2009, further tests were put on hold and a probe was conducted to find out the reasons for the failures. Testing was resumed on 7 October 2010 with a launch from the Typhoon-class submarine Dmitri Donskoi in the White Sea; the warheads successfully hit their targets at the Kura Test Range in the Russian Far East. Seven launches have been conducted since the probe, all successful. On 28 June 2011, the missile was launched for the first time from its standard carrier, Borei-class submarine Yury Dolgorukiy, and on 27 August 2011 the first full-range (over 9,000 km (5,600 mi)) flight test was conducted. After this successful launch, the start of serial production of Bulava missiles in the same configuration was announced on 28 June 2011. A successful salvo launch on 23 December 2011 concluded the flight test programme. The missile was officially approved for service on 27 December 2011, and was reported to be commissioned aboard the Yuri Dolgorukiy on 10 January 2013. The missile did however continue to fail in the summer of 2013 and was not operational as of November 2013. The Bulava is finally operational aboard Yury Dolgorukiy as of October 2015. However, recent developments put this in question. In November 2015, the Vladimir Monomakh sub fired two missiles while submerged. One of the missiles self-destructed during the boost phase and the other failed to deliver its warheads to the specified target. After being sent back to the manufacturer, it was determined that the missiles failed due to manufacturing defects.
|Bulava||Trident C4||Trident D5|
|Number of stages||3||3||3|
|Length of assembled missile without front section, m||11.5||10.3||n/a|
|Maximum diameter of missile airframe (without stabilizers, raceways, protruding elements), m||2||1.88||2.11|
|Launch weight, tonnes||36.8||32.3||58.5|
|Total length of missile as a unit with launch canister (with front section), m||12.1||n/a||13.58|
|Throw weight, kg||1150||1500||2800|
|Accuracy, CEP (meters)||350||380||90|
- 1 Description
- 2 Development history
- 3 Timetable
- 4 Service
- 5 See also
- 6 References
- 7 External links
The Bulava missile was developed by Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology under the leadership of chief designer Yury Solomonov. Although it utilizes some engineering solutions used for the recent Topol-M ICBM, the new missile has been developed virtually from scratch. Bulava is both lighter and more sophisticated than the Topol-M. The two missiles are expected to have comparable ranges, and similar CEP and warhead configurations. Bulava has a declared START throw weight of 1150 kg to 9,500 kilometers.
The missile has three stages; the first and second stages use solid fuel propellant, while the third stage uses a liquid fuel to allow high maneuverability during warhead separation. The missile can be launched from an inclined position, allowing a submarine to fire them while moving. It has a low flight trajectory, and due to this could be classified as a quasi-ballistic missile. The missile possesses advanced defense capabilities making it resistant to missile-defense systems.
Borei-class submarines carrying Bulava missiles are expected to be an integral part of the Russian nuclear triad until 2040.
Bulava can be loaded on TEL road mobile launchers, on railway BZhRK trains, other various displacement ground sea sub.
In the 1990s, Russia had two submarine-launched ICBMs, the solid-fuel R-39 and the liquid-fuel R-29 Vysota family, both developed by the Makeyev Design Bureau. A new missile, designated R-39UTTH Bark was under development to replace the R-39. The Bark was planned to become the only submarine-launched ballistic missile of the Russian nuclear arsenal. However, its development was plagued with problems, and after three test failures the Bark programme was canceled in 1998. Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology was now tasked with developing a new advanced missile. The institute promised that it would able to quickly develop a new naval missile based on its recent Topol-M land-based ICBM.
The new missile would be deployed per 16 missiles on the Borei I- and per 20 missiles on Borei II-class submarines. As the new submarines would not be ready in time for flight tests, the Typhoon-class submarine Dmitry Donskoy was upgraded to carry Bulavas.
Key people involved in the decision to develop Bulava included the institute director and Bulava's chief designer Yury Solomonov; director of the Defense Ministry's Fourth Central Research Institute, Major-General Vladimir Dvorkin; Navy Commander, Fleet Admiral Vladimir Kuroyedov; Defense Minister, Marshal Igor Sergeyev; Economics Minister Yakov Urinson and Prime Minister Viktor Chernomyrdin.
The missile completed the first stage launch-tests at the end of 2004. Although it was initially planned to base the Bulava design on the Topol-M, the first tests showed that the new missile was completely different in terms of appearance, dimensions and warhead lay-out. It was later acknowledged that the Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology had developed Bulava virtually from scratch, reusing only a few engineering solutions from the Topol-M.
By 2009, the missile had experienced 5 failures in 11 tests. This led to the missile's chief designer, Yury Solomonov resigning from his post in July 2009. Aleksandr Sukhodolskiy was appointed as the new general designer of sea-based ballistic missiles at the Moscow Institute of Thermal Technology; Solomonov however retained his post of general designer of land-based missiles.
Explanations for the failures
Chief designer Solomonov has blamed the failures on the poor state of the Russian defense industry and problems in the design-technology-production chain.
- "Sometimes [the problem] is poor-quality materials, sometimes it is the lack of necessary equipment to exclude the 'human' factor in production, sometimes it is inefficient quality control"
According to Solomonov, the industry is unable to manufacture 50 of the necessary components for the missile, forcing designers to improvise and look for alternative solutions, which seriously complicates the testing process. Solomonov further said that despite the failures, there was no need for changes in the design.
Sergei Kovalyov, the designer of three generations of Russian strategic submarines said that due to lack of funding, the developers had been unable to conduct test launches from a floating pad to test the underwater segment of the missile's trajectory. He also said that there were insufficient funds to conduct ground-based test launches. Both types of testing had been standard procedure during Soviet times. Kovalyov also criticised the poor quality of missile components provided by a large number of sub-contractors and the absence of military representatives at manufacturing plants.
The 2009 Norwegian spiral anomalies, a temporary strange light phenomenon over vast areas of northern Norway have been explained with a failed stage of a Bulava missile test. According to a spokesman, "The missile's first two stages worked as normal, but there was a technical malfunction at the next, third, stage of the trajectory".
Effects on the military
Due to the delays in Bulava's development, the launch of the fourth Borei-class submarine, Svyatitel Nikolay, has been pushed back. Russia was planning to build eight of Borei-class submarines by 2015.
Only one Typhoon-class submarine, Dmitry Donskoy, has been modified to launch Bulavas. The Bulava program is the most expensive weapons project in Russia.
Debate about the program
Despite continued test failures, the Russian defense minister, Anatoly Serdyukov, has stated that the project will not be abandoned. "We will certainly not give up the Bulava. I think that despite all the failures, the missile will fly," he said in an interview in late December 2009. The Russian military has been adamant that there is no alternative to Bulava.
There has been discussion among analysts about the possibility of re-equipping the Borei-class submarines with the more reliable liquid-propellant R-29RMU Sineva missiles. The Sineva is an upgrade of the R-29RM Shtil and entered service in 2007. According to RIA Novosti military analyst Ilya Kramnik, this would have been an attractive option, given that the less advanced Sineva missiles already have "virtually the same impressive specifications as the Trident II (D5) SLBMs wielded by the U.S. Navy and the Royal Navy." However, the work needed to redesign and modify the Borei-class submarines to carry Sinevas is regarded as too expensive.
After a launch failure in December 2009 caused by a defective engine nozzle and which led to the 2009 Norwegian spiral anomaly, further tests were put on hold and a review of the missile program was initiated. The results of the probe were delivered to the Russian government in May 2010.
Testing was resumed for the first time after the probe on 7 October 2010. The missile was launched from the submerged Dmitry Donskoy, in the White Sea, and the warheads successfully hit their targets at the Kura testing range, 380 kilometres (240 mi) to the north of Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky in the Russian Far East. The launch reportedly took place at 07:15 UTC. The missile travelled over 6,000 kilometres (3,700 mi), and the rocket's trajectory was within the normal parameters, according to a Navy official.
The next test to be performed from Yuriy Dolgorukiy was initially planned to December 2010, but was postponed to mid-summer 2011 due to ice conditions in White Sea.
Each of following new test missiles needed to be built under nearly identical conditions, in order to determine the cause of potential failures.
2011 tests and deployment
Russian defense sources have stated that the Bulava missile will not enter service until it is 98-99% reliable. According to the Russian Vice Premier Sergei Ivanov another six successful launches (one planned in 2010, other five in 2011) will be required before the missile could be commissioned. After a successful test salvo launch in December 2011, Russian president Dmitry Medvedev announced that the Bulava missile was ready and it would now be adopted for service with the Russian Navy.
2012 tests and deployment
On August 2012 a high-ranking official of Russia's United Shipbuilding Corporation said in 2012 Russia will test fire its Bulava missile only once, in November, specifically from the nuclear-powered submarine Alexander Nevsky.
Bulava was finally commissioned with its lead carrier Yuri Dolgorukiy on 10 January 2013. The official ceremony of raising the Russian Navy colors on the submarine was led by Russian Defense Minister Sergey Shoigu. After another failed launch in September, Shoigu announced a pause in the state trials of the next two submarines and five more test launches. The entire production run of the missiles was then recalled for factory inspections. Russian Deputy Defense Minister Yury Borisov told reporters on Wednesday 20 November 2013: "The commission has completed its work. The causes have been determined. They are technological and are related to the production of the nozzle," Borisov told a roundtable meeting on state defense contracts. The cause of the failure does not call into question "the correctness of the production of the product in general," he said. The flaw that has been revealed has been corrected on the three remaining missiles in this batch, Borisov said. Borisov said Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu has made a decision to hold another five Bulava launches. "These launches will be planned next year," Borisov said. The intercontinental ballistic missile Bulava was launched at the Kura testing ground in Kamchatka during the state testing of the strategic nuclear submarine Alexander Nevsky in the White Sea on September 6. "The missile left the launch container, but the its board system failed three minutes into the launch," the Russian Defense Ministry earlier said.
|24 June 2004||Failure||Ground||Solid propellant engine exploded during the test.|
|01||23 September 2004||Success||Surfaced||Dmitri Donskoi||Pop-up test.|
|02||27 September 2005||Success||Surfaced||Dmitry Donskoi||First flight test.|
|03||21 December 2005||Success||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||First launch from a submerged submarine.|
|04||7 September 2006||Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||The first stage failed shortly after launch.|
|05||25 October 2006||Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||Failure of the first stage.|
|06||24 December 2006||Failure||Surfaced||Dmitry Donskoi||Problems with the third stage.|
|07||29 June 2007||Partial Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||Warheads hit targets at the Kura testing range, but one of the warheads didn't.|
|08||18 September 2008||Success||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||Launch at 18:45, warheads hit target at 19:05.|
|09||28 November 2008||Success||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||The first statements suggests that the test was a success.|
|10||23 December 2008||Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||The missile malfunctioned during firing of its third stage and self-destructed on command.|
|11||15 July 2009||Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||The missile malfunctioned during firing of its first stage and self-destructed.|
|12||9 December 2009||Failure||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||The missile malfunctioned during firing of its third stage.|
|13||7 October 2010||Success||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||Targets at the Kura Test Range in the Russian Far East were successfully hit.|
|14||29 October 2010||Success||Submerged||Dmitry Donskoi||Launch from the White Sea. Targets at the Kura Test Range were hit successfully.|
|15||28 June 2011||Success||Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||First launch from standard missile carrier from the White Sea. Targets at the Kura Test Range were hit successfully.|
|16||27 August 2011||Failure||Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||Launch from the White Sea. Targets at the Pacific Ocean were hit unsuccessfully at a range, self-destruction of 120 km (75 mi). First full-range test.|
|17||28 October 2011||Success||Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||Successful launch from the White Sea. Warheads hit target at the Kura test range in Kamchatka.|
|18,19||23 December 2011||Success||Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||A salvo launch involving two missiles. Warheads hit designated targets at the Kura test range in Kamchatka.|
|20||6 September 2013||Failure||Submerged||Alexander Nevsky||A malfunction in one of its systems on the second minute of the flight.|
|21||9 September 2014||Success||Submerged||Vladimir Monomakh||Hit the designated target at the Kura test range|
|22||29 October 2014||Success||Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||Successfully completed the launch of an intercontinental ballistic "Bulava" missile.|
|23||28 November 2014||Success||Submerged||Alexander Nevsky||Alexander Nevsky fired the missile from under water in the Barents Sea and it landed on a military training ground in Russia's far eastern peninsula of Kamchatka, as planned.|
|24||15 November 2015||Failure
|Submerged||Vladimir Monomakh||In November of 2015, the Vladimir Monomakh sub fired two missiles while submerged. One of the missiles self-destructed during the boost phase and the other failed to deliver its warheads to the specified target. After being sent back to the manufacturer, it was determined that the missiles failed due to manufacturing defects.|
|Submerged||Monomakh Dolgorukiy||At least two launches are planned in 2016.|
|26||27 September 2016||Success
|Submerged||Yury Dolgorukiy||Two missiles were launched, one successfully struck a designated target at the Kura range, another one was self-destroyed. |
In October 2010 it was reported that 150-170 operational missiles would be built (124 active + reserve for training and tests). |- After the successful launch on 28 June 2011, the Russian government announced the start of serial production of Bulava missiles. On 10 January 2013, Bulava was adopted into service with its lead carrier submarine Yuri Dolgorukiy.
- Submarine-launched ballistic missile
- Nuclear torpedo
- Status-6 - Russian heavy nuclear stealth torpedo
- Comparison of ICBMs
- M51 SLBM - French submarine-launched intercontinental ballistic missile
- Trident II SLBM - US submarine-launched intercontinental ballistic missile
- JL-2 SLBM – Chinese submarine-launched intercontinental ballistic missile
- Pukkuksong-1 – North Korean submarine-launched ballistic missile
- R-29RMU2 Layner - Russian submarine-launched intercontinental ballistic missile based on R-29RMU Sineva
- RS-26 Rubezh - Russian Intercontinental Ballistic Missile based on the RS-24 Yars
- RS-28 Sarmat - Russian heavy intercontinental ballistic missile, replacement for R-36M SS-18
- RT-2PM2 Topol-M
- RS-24 Yars
- R-39 Rif
- RT-23 Molodets
- "Finally flying colors: Yury Dolgoruky nuclear sub joins Russian Navy". RT. 10 January 2013. Retrieved 13 January 2013.
- "Названа дата 14-го запуска "Булавы"". Flot.com. 26 October 2010. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Russian military successfully tests new missile". Fox News. 2010-10-07. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "SS-27 Topol-M / SS-NX-30 Bulava ("Mace")". warfare.ru. 2007. Retrieved 2010-04-07.
- "New Start won't keep Russia from developing Bulava missiles - deputy PM | Defense | RIA Novosti". RIA Novosti. 5 February 2011. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Russia's Bulava missile hits target in test". RIA Novosti. 2010-10-07. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Bulava missile completes flight tests, ready to deploy". RIA Novosti. 2011-12-27. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russian Navy's Newest Missile Subs Not Operational – Source". Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- "TASS: Russia - Bulava missile launched from nuclear sub in Russia". TASS. Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- Kramnik, Ilya (2010-09-20). "Bulava missile: is there any alternative?". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 20121-11-05. Check date values in:
- "Bulava - the lightest ballistic missile of its type". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Bulava missile: 13th time lucky". Russia Today. 2010-10-07. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Status of Russia's SLBM programs". russianforces.org. 2005. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "The Bulava missile saga". RIA Novosti. 2009-12-10. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "SSBN Yury Dolgoruky completed sea trials". rusnavy.com. 28 September 2010. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Bulava trials are postponed". rusnavy.com. 2009-12-09. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Russian Bulava missile designer quits after failed tests". RIA Novosti. 22 July 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- ""Булава" сносит головы". Российская газета. 2010-09-20. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Bulava missile designer blames industry for test failures". news.az. 2010-04-14. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russian submarine designer certain of Bulava missile success". RIA Novosti. 14 August 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Strange 'Norway spiral' likely an out-of-control missile". New Scientist. 10 December 2009. Archived from the original on 13 December 2009.
- "Norway spiral: A rocket scientist explains the mystery". Christian Science Monitor. 10 December 2009. Archived from the original on 13 December 2009. Retrieved 11 December 2009.
- Clara Moskowitz, 'Russia admits missile caused UFO lights'. MSNBC News, 10 December 2009.
- Oberg, James (January 2010). "Russia's Ailing ICBM Program: Spiral over Norway latest in string of failures". IEEE Spectrum. Retrieved 2010-04-07.
- "Russia to start construction of 4th Borey-class sub in early 2010". RIA Novosti. 2009-12-21. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russia's newest nuclear sub completes sea trials". RIA Novosti. 2010-09-28. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russian defense minister insists on Bulava missile development". RIA Novosti. 24 December 2009. Retrieved 2010-01-01.
- Kramnik, Ilya (2010-09-20). "Bulava missile: is there any alternative?". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Bulava probe results ready for Russian government review - source". RIA Novosti. 2010-05-25. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- Podvig, Pavel. "Bulava launch reported success". russianforces.org. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russia successfully tests troubled Bulava missile". Reuters AlertNet. 2010-10-07. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russia carries out another successful test launch of Bulava missile". RIA Novosti. 2010-10-29. Retrieved 2016-10-22.
- "Названа новая дата испытаний "Булавы"". flot.com. 15 December 2010. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Russia to test Bulava missile in 3rd quarter - top general". RIA Novosti. 2010-06-14. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russia's ballistic missile to enter service after clean sheet (Update 1)". RIA Novosti. 2010-10-26. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "To commission Bulava, six effective launches are required – Ivanov". rusnavy.com. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Bulava missile ready to deploy | Defense |". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Borei super-subs trials may be postponed after Bulava 'failure'". Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- http://www.rg.ru/2013/09/16/bulava-anons.html. Retrieved 23 December 2014. Missing or empty
- Bulava launch failure was caused by violations of nozzle production technologies-Russian Defense Ministry Voice of Russia, 20 November 2013
- "Bulava missile: test-launch history". RIA Novosti. 25 November 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Булава" не раскалывается. Kommersant (in Russian). 22 September 2008. Retrieved 2012-11-16.
- "Russia successfully test launches Bulava missile from submarine". RIA Novosti. 18 September 2008. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Russia test launches ICBM from White Sea, hits Kamchatka target". RIA Novosti. 28 November 2008. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- С АПЛ "Дмитрий Донской" произведен неудачный запуск "Булавы". lenta.ru (in Russian). 23 December 2008. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Q+A-Russia delays test of troubled Bulava missile". Reuters. 24 November 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Russia's latest Bulava missile test unsuccessful". RIA Novosti. 10 December 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "New Russian missile fails again in test: reports". Agence France-Presse. 10 December 2009. Retrieved 2009-12-29.
- "Russia successfully test-fires new ballistic missile". RT. 2011-06-28. Retrieved 2016-10-22.
- "First Borey class nuclear sub to be assigned to Pacific Fleet in 2011 | Defense |". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Yuri Dolgoruky nuclear submarine successfully conducts Bulava missile launch". RIA Novosti. 27 August 2011. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- тНРН: "пц". ""Чпхи Днкцнпсйхи" Бшонкмхк Сяоеьмши Осяй Пюйерш "Аскюбю" — Пняяхияйюъ Цюгерю". rg.ru. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- "Russia successfully test fires Bulava missiles". RIA Novosti. 23 December 2011. Retrieved 2012-11-05.
- "Russian Navy to get three nuclear submarines in 2013". Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- "Russia Puts Submarine Trials on Hold After Bulava Failure". RIA Novosti. 7 September 2013. Retrieved 2013-09-07.
- "Russia Successfully Test-Fires Bulava SLBM". Retrieved 23 December 2014.
- "Ракетоносец "Юрий Долгорукий" выполнил пуск "Булавы" по полигону Кура.". Rusplt. 2014-10-29. Retrieved 2014-10-29.
- "Russian submarine test-launches Bulava intercontinental missile". Reuters. Retrieved 28 November 2014.
- "Russian nuclear submarine to launch Bulava ICBMs to Far East range in June.". Russian News Agency TASS. 2016-03-11.
- "A two "Bulava" missile salvo has been successful only partially". Vzglyad (newspaper). 2016-09-27.
- "Russia Successfully Tests Sea-Based Bulava Ballistic Missile.". Sputnik (news agency). 2016-09-27.
- "Объем серийного выпуска ракет "Булава" может превысить 150 единиц". flot.com. 25 October 2010. Retrieved 2011-12-29.
- ""Булаву" можно запускать в серийное производство, заявил Сердюков". flotprom.ru. Retrieved 2011-12-29.