Bumfights

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Bumfights: A Cause for Concern is a film produced by Indecline Films. The video features primarily high school fights caught on tape and homeless men (most notably Rufus Hannah and Donnie Brennan) in the San Diego, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Las Vegas metropolitan areas attempting amateur stunts in a style inspired by the popular MTV series Jackass. Bumfights: A Cause for Concern (2002), was produced by Ryan McPherson, with friends Zachary Bubeck, Daniel J. Tanner, and Michael Slyman, as Indecline Films. Contrary to its title, the video does not depict homeless men actually fighting, but instead a compilation of street fights caught on tape and homeless men performing in skits and stunts.

The video immediately gained criticism. The US-based National Coalition for the Homeless (NCH) has stated that the Bumfights videos disseminate hate against the homeless and dehumanize them.[1] In April 2006, the four original filmmakers agreed not to produce any more "Bumfights" videos or distribute videos already made, and to pay three homeless men depicted in the videos, under a settlement announced shortly before a lawsuit was due to go to trial.[2]

Controversies[edit]

The videos have been banned in several countries, including the United Kingdom, Canada,[3] and New Zealand. The internet auction site eBay routinely cancels listings which contain copies of the video, citing their policy which prohibits the sale of materials which promote or glorify violence.[4] In the state of California, both felony and misdemeanor charges were filed against the producers, as well as civil lawsuits. They pled guilty to staging an illegal fight but subsequently in 2005[5] the producers were sentenced to six months in prison for having failed to complete the community service to which they had previously been sentenced. The filmmakers maintain that the production of the video was a mutually beneficial arrangement and that the homeless people depicted freely chose to participate.

A group of suburban Nevada teenagers, who called themselves "311 Boyz," also faced criminal charges, including attempted murder, after filming several violent exploits inspired by Bumfights. The suspects attempted to make a profitable video by instigating fights around their neighborhoods, in some instances imposing on unwilling participants.

Indecline: Vol. 1—"It's Worse Than You Think"[edit]

Ryan McPherson moved on to produce a similar reality video called Indecline: Vol. 1—It's Worse Than You Think. Though controversial for its fight footage and acts of elaborate graffiti art, legal troubles did not hinder the sales of this video, although the website went offline in June 2008. The Indecline web site went back online in November 2008.[6] As of May 2016, the Indecline Films website is still down and has been down for over five years. In 2017, Indecline returned with a brand new site (www.thisisindecline.com).

Popular culture[edit]

  • In 2005, The Daily Show with Jon Stewart, had a segment featuring Bumvertising, in which they made a comparison to Bumfights, showing a video clip of two bums fighting. The episode of The Daily Show was titled 'Face For Rent'.
  • In one episode of the 2003 remake of Dragnet, the case investigated is strongly based on the Bumfights videos (called "Bum Wars" in the episode).
  • In the episode of American Dad!, "Threat Levels," Stan begins a Bumfights Federation for himself, staging Bumfights on his own street, in a wrestling ring and giving the competitors professional wrestling-style personas and nicknames.
  • In the episode of Arrested Development, "Making a Stand," George Sr.'s Boyfights series of videos bears resemblances to the documentary series, both in the name and in the nature of capturing footage of unwilling subjects.
  • The December 12, 2006 episode of Dr. Phil featured Bumfights producer Ty Beeson. Beeson arrived for the taping with a haircut and outfit that matched show host Dr. Phil McGraw's distinct styling. McGraw had stopped the tape and demanded that the producer leave the set (Beeson was ultimately escorted off the set by uniformed Paramount Studios security guards), stating he refused to "publicize" the subject because he claimed the short video was despicable.
  • The episode "Return of the Kane" of Veronica Mars features the character Logan Echolls staging Bumfights. His sister Trina refers to Logan calls Logan's act "bumfights" by name later in the season.
  • In episode 2 of the TV series Nathan Barley, Nathan finds a web site parody of Bumfights called Tramp Racing.
  • In the mockumentary LolliLove, about giving lollipops to the homeless, James Gunn writes in his diary about wanting to see Bumfights.
  • In the film Hobo with a Shotgun, a minor character is a young man filming homeless persons hurting each other in return for money, a reference to Bumfights.
  • In episode 17 of Workaholics, Adam says "I've been watching a lot of Bumfights lately..."
  • In episode 5 ("Honeypot") of the animated series Archer, Sterling asks Dr. Krieger if he still tapes Bumfights to which the latter replies: "No, now I'm into something...darker." [7]

Bumfights videos[edit]

  • Bumfights Vol. 1: A Cause for Concern (2002)
  • Bumfights Vol. 2: Bumlife (2003)
  • Bumfights Vol. 3: The Felony Footage (2004)
  • Bumfights Vol. 4: Return Of Ruckus (2006)

References[edit]

  1. ^ "National Coalition for the Homeless The National Coalition for the Homeless » National Coalition for the Homeless". Nationalhomeless.org. Retrieved 2014-03-06. 
  2. ^ "Homeless men in 'Bumfights' get settlements over video". SignOnSanDiego.com. 2006-04-06. Retrieved 2014-03-06. 
  3. ^ "Décisions - Régie du cinéma". Rcq.gouv.qc.ca. Retrieved 2014-03-06. 
  4. ^ "Offensive material policy". Pages.ebay.com. Retrieved 2014-03-06. 
  5. ^ "Exploitative Videos: Bumfights & Girls Gone Wild". Businessethicsblog.com. Retrieved 2015-09-02. 
  6. ^ "Ryen McPherson Q&A Part 2 [Bumfights / Indecline / King of the Jews ] - Polly Staffle - Movie & DVD Reviews". Polly Staffle. Archived from the original on 2007-01-08. Retrieved 2014-03-06. 
  7. ^ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rvOjTj3jXA

External links[edit]