Page semi-protected

Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act, also known as the Caesar Act, is a United States legislation that sanctions the Syrian government, including Syrian president Bashar al-Assad, for war crimes against the Syrian population. The bill has not been passed into law. Instead, parts of it were incorporated in the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2020, making it unlikely that the original bill will be revisited.[1]

A number of Syrian operated industries, including those related to infrastructure, military maintenance and energy production, are targeted. The bill also targets individuals and businesses who provide funding or assistance to the president of Syria. Iranian and Russian entities are addressed for their governments' support of Assad in the Syrian Civil War. The legislation imposes fresh sanctions on entities conducting business with the Syrian government and its military and intelligence agencies. It also aims to encourage negotiations by allowing the President of the United States to waive sanctions if the parties are engaged in meaningful negotiations and the violence against civilians has ceased.

The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019 has become a part of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2020 (S1790) as House of Representatives report 116–333.[2][3] The House Committee Report, including Caesar has passed the Senate on December 17, 2019 with bipartisan support from both chambers of United States Congress.[4][5][6] A few days later, U.S. President Donald Trump signed this bill containing this version of the Caesar provision to become law.[7]

This bill is named after an individual known as Caesar, who documented torture against civilians by Assad's government, which was verified to become known as the 2014 Syrian detainee report or Caesar Report. Human Rights Watch (HRW) further investigated this report, and produced an additional report titled If the Dead Could Speak. Photographic evidence from the 2014 Syrian detainee report has been on display at the United States Holocaust Museum and at the United Nations.

Overview and origin[edit]

A spokesperson for Americans for a Free Syria claimed tens of hospitals in Syria have been bombed by Russia since April 2019. Caesar sanctions are intended to address crimes by the Syrian regime and its allies Russia and Iran. Sanctions are also to discourage foreign investors from doing business with Assad's regime, in an effort to not reward war crimes.[6]

Caesar sanctions will financially punish Assad and his associates as long as his regime is committing atrocities. Hence, the sanctions would mainly target providing goods, services, technology, information, or any support that would expand local production in the field of natural gas, oil and its derivatives. The sanctions also aim to deter foreign investors from signing contracts for reconstruction following the civil war.[8][9]

The legislation was introduced by Representative Eliot Engel as House Resolution 31 of 2020.[10] It was incorporated into the National Defense Authorization Act which was enacted and then signed by President Trump.[11] [12]

Implementation, requirements and exemptions[edit]

The sanctions would be implemented six months after its signature into a law, starting from 17 June 2020.[13] The requirements of the legislation would expire after five years, i.e. 2024.[11] However, Section 401 of the Caesar Bill outlines six requirements to lift U.S. sanctions on Syria:[12][14]

  1. End to Syrian and Russian aircraft bombing civilians.
  2. Iranian, Syrian and Russian forces, as well as entities connected to them, no longer restrict humanitarian access to besieged areas, and allow for civilians to leave freely.
  3. All political prisoners are released, and the appropriate international human rights organizations are given full access to Syria’s prisons and detention facilities.
  4. Bombing of “medical facilities, schools, residential areas, and community gathering places, including markets” by Syrian, Russian, Iranian forces, as well as entities connected to them, ceases.
  5. The possibility for the “safe, voluntary, and dignified return of Syrians displaced by the conflict” is achieved.
  6. Accountability for “perpetrators of war crimes in Syria and justice for victims of war crimes committed by the Assad regime, including by participation in a credible and independent truth and reconciliation process.”

American envoy to the northeast Syria, William Robak, mentioned that the sanctions will exclude the areas of the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria.[15]

Debate over measure[edit]

Regional ramifications[edit]

In May 2020, the Syrian authorities imposed heavy taxes on president's cousin, Rami Makhlouf, and seized his assets in order to find resources prior to the implementation of Caesar Act.[16]

In early June, the Syrian pound underwent a dramatic collapse. The US Government stated via US Envoy James Jeffrey that the collapse would be exacerbated due to sanctions, and offered to help President Bashar al-Assad if he agreed to meet certain conditions for political reform.[17]

On June 10, hundreds of protesters returned to the streets of As-Suwayda for the fourth consecutive day, rallying against the collapse of the country’s economy, as the Syrian pound plummeted to 3,000 to the dollar within the past week.[18]

On June 11, Prime Minister Imad Khamis was dismissed by President Bashar al-Assad, amid anti-government protests over deteriorating economic conditions.[19] The new lows for the Syrian currency, and the dramatic increase in sanctions, began to appear to raise new threats to the survival of the Assad government.[20][21][22]

Analysts noted that a resolution to the current banking crisis in Lebanon might be crucial to restoring stability in Syria.[23]

Some analysts began to raise concerns that Assad might be on the verge of losing power; but that any such collapse in the regime might cause conditions to worsen, as the result might be mass chaos, rather than an improvement in political or economic conditions.[24][25][26] Russia continued to expand its influence and military role in the areas of Syria where the main military conflict was occurring.[27]

On June 17, the United States imposed sanctions on 39 members of the Bashar al-Assad regime, including Assad and his wife. Former Deputy Secretary of Defence Mick Mulroy told Kurdistan 24 and ABC News that the Assad regime "has to be held accountable for what they have done to the Syrian people that resulted in over 700,000 people being killed and over 10 million being displaced”, that the international community also needs to "increase humanitarian aid and stabilization funding to the areas liberated from this despotic regime” and “do everything we can to help the Syrian people and everything we can to end the Syrian regime. They are one and the same.” [28][29]

On June 23, Syrian Foreign Minister, Walid Muallem, held a press conference and mentioned that the United States seek to "starve the people" and the sanctions would open the door for "terrorism" to return; in addition, he insisted that the Syrian government will cope with the sanctions with the assistance from friends and allies.[30]

International debate[edit]

Analysts noted that the upcoming implementation of new heavy sanctions under the US Caesar Act could devastate the Syrian economy, ruin any chances of recovery, destroy regional stability, and do nothing but destabilize the entire region.[31]

A leading analyst, Julien Barnes-Dacey, director of the Middle East and North Africa Programme at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said:

“Assad is absolutely the prime driver of Syria’s ongoing collapse. [But] the US position now appears to be fundamentally driven by great power politics and the goal of ensuring that Russia and Iran can’t claim a win. My fear is that Caesar will achieve the exact opposite of its stated goals, fuelling the worst impulses of the Syrian regime and wider conflict. The US self-declared maximum pressure campaign aims to bring the regime to its knees and force its backers to concede defeat but the regime knows how to brutally hold onto power and it’s clear that its key backers aren’t for moving.

“The Syrian people have been brutalised for a decade now and the country is devastated by conflict but we appear to be staring into the precipice of a dangerous new stage of the conflict … which risks a devastating new unravelling.”[31]

Russia and the United States continuously argued publicly over the role played by each country in Syrian politics. Russia noted that its military presence had the approval of Syria's government.[32] The Syrian government news agency, Syrian Arab News Agency (SANA), reported that Russian Ambassador, Alexander Yevimov, said that Russia would seek to help Syria to recover and to develop its economy positively.[33]

Some analysts said that Assad would need support from major Sunni countries to stay in power, and that he would need the US to facilitate such support.[34]

In Spain, according to SANA, the Director-General of Cooperation and Human Rights of the Regional Government of La Rioja, Mayra Moro-Coco said that Caesar act would massively increase the suffering of the Syrian population, and would not improve conditions or human rights at all.[35]

Past versions[edit]

Past versions of the bill included surveying the proposal of instituting no-fly zones over Syria.

The neighboring countries might have been affected from sanctions such as Jordan.[36]

S52/HR31 and related amendments of 116th Congress[edit]

Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019 (HR31) has passed the House on January 22, 2019, and is currently awaiting in the Senate.[37] S52 is the Senate drafted version of this bill.

This version did not include investigating military means of protecting civilians. HR 31 was amended by the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations on June 3, 2019 to include congressional briefings by the President of military means meant to protect civilians, and obtaining data from organizations and countries in relation to Syria.

HR1677 of 115th Congress[edit]

HR5732 was reintroduced into the 115th Congress as HR1677. This bill passed the House, but stalled in the Senate. It was reintroduced into the next Congress as HR31.

HR5732 of 114th Congress[edit]

The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2016 was a long-waited act drafted by the United States Congress by both Democrats and Republicans during a lame duck session sanctioning the Syrian government.[38] On November 15, 2016, it passed the House unanimously as The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act (HR 5732).[39] This bipartisan legislation would have imposed new sanctions upon the Syrian government.

This version of legislation would also have required the U.S president to report to Congress on the prospects for a no-fly zone in Syria. The bill would have authorized the Secretary of State to support entities that are collecting and preserving evidence for the eventual prosecution of those who committed war crimes and crimes against humanity in Syria from March 2011 to the present, and would have required the President to report to Congress on the names of those who are responsible for or complicit in gross violations of human rights of the Syrian people.[40]

Related bills[edit]

Stop UN Support for Assad Act and No Assistance for Assad Act are related U.S. congressional bills that have not passed into law.

Stop UN Support for Assad Act[edit]

Stop UN Support for Assad Act (HR4868 of 116th Congress) seeks to prevent the UN from misdirecting US funds to Assad, which funds his war effort against Syrian civilians.[41] The UN mandates that humanitarian aid to Syria, even by non-governmental organizations (NGO's) be provided through the Syrian government, led by Assad, who they allege misuses it.

No Assistance for Assad Act[edit]

No Assistance for Assad Act has been introduced into the House of Representatives twice. HR4681 of 115th Congress has passed the House, but action hasn't been taken on it in the Senate. This bill has been reintroduced into the 116th Congress as HR1706, and this version is still in the House of Representatives. This bill would prevent funding reconstruction of Syrian regime held areas until war crimes were verified as halted.[42]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019 (S. 52)". GovTrack.us.
  2. ^ Josh Rogin (December 11, 2019). "The United States is about to sanction Assad, Russia and Iran for Syrian war crimes". Washington Post.
  3. ^ "NATIONAL DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2020: CONFERENCE REPORT TO ACCOMPANY S. 1790". congress.gov. December 2019. Retrieved December 11, 2019.
  4. ^ "S.1790 - National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2020: Actions". congress.gov. December 2019. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  5. ^ Simon, Mallory; Boulduan, Kate (December 17, 2019). "He smuggled war crimes evidence and begged the US for help. Now Congress is finally acting and set to sanction Syria". CNN.
  6. ^ a b Amos, Deborah (December 17, 2019). "Congress Authorizes Sanctions On Syria, Iran And Russia". NPR.
  7. ^ "Trump signs Caesar Act sanctioning Syrian regime". aa.com.tr. December 21, 2019.
  8. ^ "Congress Prepares to Hit Assad With New Sanctions for War Crimes". The New York Times. December 16, 2019.
  9. ^ "The Caesar Act: The beginning or end of US Syria Policy?". Syria direct. January 5, 2020.
  10. ^ H.R.31 - Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019, 116th Congress (2019-2020), congress.gov.
  11. ^ a b "H.R. 31, Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019" (PDF). Congressional Budget Office. June 6, 2019.
  12. ^ a b "The Caesar Act: Impacts and Implementation". Syria Justice and Accountability Centre. February 20, 2020.
  13. ^ "Congress Authorizes Sanctions On Syria, Iran And Russia". npr.org. December 17, 2019.
  14. ^ "H.R.31 — 116th Congress (2019-2020)". congress.gov. June 3, 2019.
  15. ^ "William Robak: Caesar's Act to exclude Autonomous Administration areas". Hawar News Agency. May 23, 2020.
  16. ^ "Syria: New US sanctions set to make Assad squirm". DW. June 9, 2020.
  17. ^ Jared Szuba (June 9, 2020). "Sanctions on Syrian government also threaten Washington's Kurdish allies". Al-Monitor. While US and international sanctions aren't specifically targeted at Kurdish-ruled northeast Syria, the area is impacted all the same with trade practically halted and because of the sudden plunge of the Syrian pound.
  18. ^ "Protests hit Druze city in Syria for fourth day". Reuters. June 11, 2020.
  19. ^ "Syria war: Assad sacks PM as economic crisis sparks protests". BBC. June 11, 2020.
  20. ^ "Syrian pound hits record low ahead of new U.S. sanctions: dealers". Reuters. June 8, 2020.. The Syrian pound sank to a new record low on Monday as investors scrambled for dollars ahead of new U.S. sanctions later this month, which many fear will tighten the noose around President Bashar al Assad’s government, dealers and bankers said.
  21. ^ Seth J. Frantzman (June 8, 2020). "Syrian currency collapse throws country into uncertainty". The Jerusalem Post. The Syrian regime thought it was finally out of the woods in its almost decade-long civil war.
  22. ^ "Syrian currency loses more value as sanctions hit". Associated Press. June 11, 2020.
  23. ^ Hugo Goodridge (June 4, 2020). "Charting the dramatic collapse of Syria's national currency". Despite fears of a spillover from Syria affecting neighbouring Lebanon, it was conversely the collapse of the Lebanese pound that plunged Syria deeper into its economic quagmire. Rising Lebanese debts and a lack of financial ability to pay off these debts, with a seeming absence of political will to find a solution, led to capital controls being imposed. Throughout the war in Syria, Lebanon had been used by Syrians as a reliable place to withdraw dollars. "Syrians, who bought a lot of their dollars in Lebanon, suddenly couldn't access dollars, the value of the Syrian pound started to collapse."
  24. ^ Charles Lister (June 11, 2020). "Is Assad About to Fall?". Politico. While the world wasn’t watching, Syria has edged toward collapse, and the dictator is in his weakest position ever. The U.S. now has a narrow chance to prevent a catastrophe.
  25. ^ Gareth Browne (June 8, 2020). "Assad faces backlash in Syria as economy crashes". The Telegraph. Hundreds of protesters gather in the restive south of the country as the prices of everyday essentials sky-rocket
  26. ^ "Syria Insight: Syria's collapsing economy threatens Assad's rule], Syria has been hit by further economic instability". alaraby.co.uk. June 7, 2020.
  27. ^ "Warm waters at last: Russia's expanding military footprint in the Middle East". alaraby.co.uk. June 9, 2020. Russia is increasing its presence in the wider Middle East and North Africa region through the deployment of its armed forces, the sale of arms and the establishment of new military bases. In recent weeks, it began negotiating the establishment of new concessions from the Syrian regime on its indefinite military presence in that country and has also become more directly involved in the civil war tearing Libya apart.
  28. ^ News, A. B. C. "US sanctions Assad, his wife, others in bid to shut down foreign investment for Syrian regime". ABC News.
  29. ^ Mylroie, Laurie. "New US sanctions against Syria include families of Bashar, Maher al-Assad". www.kurdistan24.net. Retrieved June 18, 2020.
  30. ^ "Syrian FM Says US Sanctions Seek to 'Starve the People'". The New York Times. June 23, 2020.
  31. ^ a b Martin Chulov (June 12, 2020). "US 'Caesar Act' sanctions could devastate Syria's flatlining economy". The Guardian. Critics say legislation is being used for US strategy and could cause further problems for country and wider region.
  32. ^ Vusala Abbasova (June 8, 2020). "Russian Embassy In Washington Dismisses US Accusations Over Role In Syria". Caspian News. The rivalry between Russia and the United States in the Middle East continues to escalate as the countries exchange tense remarks over military presence in the region. In a statement posted on its official Facebook page on Friday, the Russian embassy in Washington, DC. criticized the remarks of David Schenker, the State Department's top diplomat for the Middle East, who had said that Russia should leave Syria and described its role there as "destructive". "In response to Assistant Secretary of State David Schenker’s blatant call for Russia to 'go out of the Middle East' we would like to remind: Russian military is stationed in Syria at the invitation of its government," the Russian diplomatic mission said in its statement.
  33. ^ Gh.A.Hassoun (June 13, 2020). "Yevimov: Syria and Russia will not be defeated by economic terrorism". SANA.
  34. ^ Murat Sofuoglu (June 14, 2020). "How new protests in Syria are pushing Assad to the brink". TRT World.
  35. ^ Manar / Bushra / Hazem Sabbagh (June 14, 2020). "Spanish province of La Rioja condemns Caesar Act and the Western sanctions against Syria". SANA.
  36. ^ "U.S. punishes Syria with sanctions — but allies like Jordan also pay a price". Los Angeles Times. September 10, 2019. Retrieved September 10, 2019.
  37. ^ "H.R.31 - Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019". 2019. Retrieved June 5, 2019.
  38. ^ Rogin, Josh (July 14, 2016). "Congress launches Syria sanctions drive". The Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved July 14, 2016.
  39. ^ "Engel & Royce Syria Sanctions Bill Passes House - Committee on Foreign Affairs".
  40. ^ "Congress Introduces Bipartisan Bill Increasing Sanctions on Syria". Retrieved July 15, 2016.
  41. ^ Harris, Bryant (November 1, 2019). "Congress sounds alarm on weaponization of Syrian aid". AL Monitor.
  42. ^ Cupp, SE; Meriden, Suzanne; Kinzinger, Adam; Boyle, Brendan (September 18, 2018). "In Syria, is the worst yet to come?". CNN.

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]