Candace Tiara Elmore
November 19, 1989
|Died||April 18, 2000 (aged 10)|
Evergreen, Colorado, USA
|Cause of death||Suffocation|
Candace Elizabeth Newmaker (born Candace Tiara Elmore, November 19, 1989 – April 18, 2000) was a child who was killed during a 70-minute attachment therapy session purported to treat reactive attachment disorder. The treatment, during which Candace was suffocated, included a rebirthing script.
Candace was born in Lincolnton, North Carolina, to Angela and Todd Elmore. At a young age, she and her younger brother Michael and sister Chelsea were removed from the home for neglect and separated by social services. When she was five, her parents' parental rights were terminated. Two years later she was adopted by Jeane Elizabeth Newmaker, a single woman and pediatric nurse practitioner in Durham, North Carolina.
Within months of the adoption, Jeane began taking Candace to a psychiatrist, complaining about her behavior and attitude at home. Though Candace was treated with medications, Jeane reported that Candace's behavior got worse during the ensuing two years, a period supposedly including her playing with matches and also killing goldfish.
Attachment therapy and Candace's death
Candace and Jeane Newmaker traveled to Evergreen, Colorado, in April 2000, for a $7,000 two-week "intensive" session of attachment therapy with Connell Watkins (who was without license) upon a referral from William Goble, a licensed psychologist in North Carolina.
Candace died during the second week of the intensive sessions with Watkins during what has been called a "rebirthing" session. Participating in the fatal session as therapists were Watkins and Julie Ponder, also without a license, along with Candace's "therapeutic foster parents", Brita St. Clair, Jack McDaniel, and Jeane Newmaker.
Following the script for that day's treatment, Candace was wrapped in a flannel sheet and covered with pillows to simulate a womb or birth canal and was told to fight her way out of it, with the apparent expectation that the experience would help her "attach" to her adoptive mother. Four of the adults (weighing a combined total of 673 pounds) used their hands and feet to push on Candace's head, chest, and 70-pound body to resist her attempts to free herself, while she complained, pleaded, and even screamed for help and air, unable to escape from the sheet. Candace stated eleven times during the session that she was dying, to which Ponder responded, "Go ahead. Die right now, for real. For real". Twenty minutes into the session, Candace had vomited and excreted inside of the sheet; she was nonetheless kept restrained within.
Forty minutes into the session, Candace was asked if she wanted to be reborn. She faintly responded "no"; this would ultimately be her last word. To this, Ponder replied, "Quitter, quitter, quitter, quitter! Quit, quit, quit, quit. She's a quitter!" Jeane Newmaker, who said later she felt rejected by Candace's inability to be reborn, was asked by Watkins to leave the room, in order for Candace not to "pick up on (Jeane's) sorrow". Soon thereafter, Watkins requested the same of McDaniel and Brita St. Clair, leaving only herself and Ponder in the room with Candace. After talking for five minutes, the two unwrapped Candace and found that she was motionless, blue on the fingertips and lips, and not breathing. Upon seeing this, Watkins declared, "Oh there she is; she's sleeping in her vomit", whereupon Newmaker, who had been watching on a monitor in another room, rushed into the room, remarked on Candace's color, and began CPR while Watkins called 9-1-1. When paramedics arrived ten minutes later, McDaniel told them that Candace had been left alone for five minutes during a rebirthing session and was not breathing. The paramedics surmised that Candace had been unconscious and possibly not breathing for some time. Paramedics were able to restore the girl's pulse and she was flown by helicopter to a hospital in Denver; however, she was declared brain-dead the next day as a consequence of asphyxia.
The entire fatal session, as well as ten hours of other sessions from the preceding days, had been videotaped as a matter of course with Watkins's treatment. All the videos were shown at the trial of Watkins and Ponder.
A year later, Watkins and Ponder were tried and convicted of reckless child abuse resulting in death and received 16-year prison sentences. Brita St. Clair and Jack McDaniel, the therapeutic foster parents, pleaded guilty to criminally negligent child abuse and were given ten years' probation and 1,000 hours of community service in a plea bargain. The adoptive mother, Jeane Newmaker, a nurse practitioner, pleaded guilty to neglect and abuse charges and was given a four-year suspended sentence, after which the charges were expunged from her record. An appeal by Watkins against conviction and sentence failed. Watkins was paroled in June 2008, under "intense supervision" with restrictions on contact with children or counseling work, having served approximately seven years of her 16-year sentence.
The story of Candace's death was a national one in the United States of America. Contemporaneous reports about her death and the subsequent trial of her therapists appeared in newspapers and news magazines all across the country, and internationally.
The case was the motivation behind "Candace's Law" in Colorado and North Carolina, which outlawed dangerous re-enactments of the birth experience. The U.S. House of Representatives and Senate have separately passed resolutions urging similar actions in other states.
In popular culture
The 2017 web series Petscop alludes to Newmaker, with references including the name of the "Newmaker Plane", the setting of the titular web series, and several mentions of a character named "Tiara" as well as an exploration of the theme of "rebirthing", and also the "Quitter's Room" in Petscop which references how Candace Newmaker's therapists tormented her during the procedure calling her a quitter. The connection was initially mere speculation. The creator of Petscop later confirmed the reference to Newmaker.
- Attachment disorder
- Attachment therapy
- Advocates for Children in Therapy
- Michael and Sharen Gravelle
- Reactive attachment disorder
- Siegel, Barry (February 4, 2001). "Seeking child's love, a child's life is lost". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. pp. A1, A22–A24.
- Crowder, Carla; Lowe, Peggy (October 29, 2000). "Her name was Candace". Rocky Mountain News. Archived from the original on June 16, 2009.
- Auge, Karen (June 17, 2000). "Alternative therapies not new in Evergreen". The Denver Post. Retrieved March 13, 2019.
- Gillan, Audrey (June 20, 2001). "The therapy that killed". The Guardian. Archived from the original on September 25, 2006.
- Caldwell, C. (May 28, 2001). "Colorado rebirths convicted". The Weekly Standard. 6 (35). p. 20ff.
- Mercer, Jean; Sarner, Larry; Rosa, Linda (May 2003). Attachment Therapy on Trial: The Torture and Death of Candace Newmaker. Child Psychology and Mental Health. Chapter by Costa G. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers. ISBN 0-275-97675-0. ISSN 1538-8883. OCLC 51242100.
- Sink, Mindy (October 5, 2001). "Rockies: Colorado: Probation In Suffocation Death". The New York Times. Retrieved September 30, 2019.
- Nicholson, Kieran (August 2, 2001). "Rebirthing aides to plead to lesser charges in death". The Denver Post.
- "Affirmation of judgment and sentence on appeal by Watkins" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on September 7, 2008. Retrieved April 18, 2008.
- "Therapist In 'Rebirthing' Death In Halfway House". KCNC-TV. Associated Press. August 3, 2008. Archived from the original on August 6, 2008.
- Sarner, Larry (June 19, 2001). ""Rebirthers" Who Killed Child Receive 16-Year Prison Terms". Quackwatch. Retrieved March 13, 2019.
- "§ 14-401.21. Practicing "rebirthing technique"; penalty". North Carolina General Assembly. Retrieved March 13, 2019.
- "Senate Condemns Rebirthing Techniques". The Source on Women's Issues in Congress. 10 (68). October 21, 2005. ISSN 1526-8713. Archived from the original on January 28, 2006. Retrieved January 28, 2006.
- Hernandez, Patricia (April 21, 2017). "People Are Trying To Find The Truth About A Creepy 'Unfinished' PlayStation Game". Kotaku. Retrieved November 24, 2017.
- @pressedyes (November 20, 2019). "Regarding Newmaker references. Most of you know that this was intentional but I wanted to confirm it. It was extremely stupid of me" (Tweet) – via Twitter.