Cane toads in Australia
The cane toad in Australia is regarded as an exemplary case of a "feral species"—others being rabbits, foxes, cats and dogs. Australia's relative isolation prior to European Colonisation and the industrial revolution—both of which dramatically increased traffic and importation of novel species—allowed development of a complex, interdepending system of ecology, but one which provided no natural predators for many of the species subsequently introduced. The recent, sudden inundation of foreign species has led to severe breakdowns in Australian ecology, after overwhelming proliferation of a number of introduced species for which the continent has no efficient natural predators or parasites, and which displace native species—in some cases these species are physically destructive to habitat as well. Cane toads have been very successful as an invasive species, having become established in more than 15 countries within the past 150 years. In the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, the Australian Government listed the impacts of the cane toad as a "key threatening process".
Introduction and spread
Native to South and mainland Middle America, cane toads were introduced to Australia from Hawaii in June 1935 by the Bureau of Sugar Experiment Stations, now the Sugar Research Australia, in an attempt to control the native grey-backed cane beetle (Dermolepida albohirtum) and French's beetle (Lepidiota frenchi). These beetles are native to Australia and they are detrimental to sugar cane crops, which are a major source of income for Australia. Adult cane beetles eat the crop's leaves, but the main problem is the larvae, which feed on the roots. Adult cane beetles have a heavy exoskeleton and their eggs and larva are often buried deep underground, making them difficult to exterminate. Furthermore, conventional methods of pest control, such as pesticide use, would eradicate harmless species of insects as well, making it an unsatisfactory method. Cane toads were to replace the use of pesticides like arsenic, pitch, copper and drugs. The success of using the moth Cactoblastis cactorum in controlling prickly pears in Australia also contributed to hopes for the cane toad.
In June 1935 102 cane toads (Bufo marinus) were imported to Gordonvale from Hawaii (with one dying in transit due to dehydration). By March 1937 some 62,000 toadlets were bred in captivity and then released in areas around Cairns, Gordonvale and Innisfail in northern Queensland. More toads were released around Ingham, Ayr, Mackay and Bundaberg. Releases were temporarily limited because of environmental concerns but resumed in other areas after September 1936. Since their release, toads have rapidly multiplied in population and now number over 200 million and have been known to spread diseases affecting local biodiversity. Unfortunately, the introduction of the toads has not only caused large environmental detriment, but there is no evidence that they have affected the cane beetles that they were introduced to prey upon.
The spread of cane toads was slow at first but by 1959 they had colonised most of Queensland’s east coast. In 1964 they appeared in the Gulf of Carpentaria. By 1978 they had reached the border with New South Wales. By 1984 they had reached the Queensland/Northern Territory border. In March 2001 the invasion front entered the wetlands of heritage-listed Kakadu National Park and by 2009 the toads were within reach of the Northern Territory/Western Australian border. They have also spread south into northern New South Wales, with one isolated community in Port Macquarie and are now found in Sydney at Tarren Point in the south of the city. By 2019 they had become a pest in the Torres Strait Islands, probably carried there by boat.
The toads on the western frontier of their advance have evolved larger legs; this is thought to be related to their ability to travel farther. As a consequence of their longer legs, larger bodies, and faster movement, about 10% of the leading edge cane toads have also developed arthritis. It was estimated that cane toads migrate at an average of 40 kilometres (25 miles) per year as of 1994, but new research in 2014 indicated that the migration rate had increased to 60 km (37 miles) per year on the western front.
The long-term effects of toads on the Australian environment are difficult to determine, however some effects include "the depletion of native species that die eating cane toads; the poisoning of pets and humans; depletion of native fauna preyed on by cane toads; and reduced prey populations for native insectivores, such as skinks."
Precipitous declines in populations of the northern quoll (Dasyurus hallucatus) have been observed after toads have invaded an area. There are a number of reports of declines in goanna and snake populations after the arrival of toads. For example, local populations of Varanus panoptes dropped by up to 90% when their habitat was invaded by cane toads. The preliminary risk assessment of cane toads in Kakadu National Park stated that the predation of the cane toad by native wildlife is the greatest risk to biodiversity. Other factors, such as competition with native wildlife for resources, and the predation of the cane toad on native wildlife, were considered much lower risk factors but requiring further study. In the Northern Territory, goanna predation on cane toads has been linked to a rise in the amount of undamaged saltwater crocodile eggs. Cane toads were present within a few days of the crocodiles hatching in April 2007.
Numerous native species have been reported as successfully preying on toads. Some birds, such as the black kite (Milvus migrans), have learned to attack the toad's belly, avoiding the poison-producing glands on the back of the head. Anecdotal reports in the Northern Territory suggest that a native frog, Dahl's aquatic frog (Litoria dahlii), is able to eat the tadpoles and live young of the toad without being affected by the poison that often kills other predators. This may account for slower than expected infestations of toads in certain areas of the Northern Territory, although later research carried out jointly by several Australian Universities casts doubt on these reports. Some snake species have been reported to have adapted smaller jaws so that they are unable to swallow large cane toads which have large quantities of poison.
Another study, however, notes that the cane toad is adapting to a wider environmental range and may in the future be spreading into habitats currently not available.
In 2009 it was found that the native meat ant is immune to the toad's poison and can successfully prey upon young cane toads. Whereas native frogs and toads have natural reflexes to avoid the meat ants, the cane toads do not tend to try to escape the ants, rather standing still when attacked waiting for the toxin to kill the attacker.
New research has indicated that cane toads prey on dung beetles by nestling in cowpats and waiting for the beetles, eating up to 150 in one meal. In areas where cane toads have free access to water in dams, there are 9.6 times fewer dung beetles. This indicates that the cane toad has the potential to economically affect the cattle industry through increased disease in cattle.
Predators in Australia are not adapted to their toxin, which is the toad's main defense mechanism. Because of this, toads do not tend to hide and are usually targeted by predators, who then expose themselves to the toxic effects. One study suggests Australian reptiles are greatly threatened by invasion of the cane toad, more so than any other group. Seventy-five species of crocodiles and freshwater turtles were found to be at risk of invasion, and all species studied were found capable of eating a toad large enough to kill them. All freshwater turtles and crocodiles are predicted to share part of their future distribution with the invasive species by 2030. Australia's varanids and agamids are also at a great risk.
It is reported that one native freshwater turtle species, Myuchelys latisternum (saw-shelled turtle), which ranges along rivers and streams from Cape York Peninsula to northern New South Wales, is one of the few native animals which is a successful predator of cane toads. The larger the animal, or predator, is the better chance they have of survival, as their body weight effectively dilutes the concentration of the toxin in their body. One native species, the Torresian crow, has learned how to kill and eat cane toads without ingesting the poison by flipping it onto its back and using its powerful bill to deliver a lethal blow to the throat where the toad's skin is thinner, giving the crow access to the toad's non-toxic innards. In 2014 researchers found evidence that the Australian Freshwater Crocodile (Crocodylus johnstoni) had learned to eat just the hind legs of cane toads. One research study concluded that in less than 75 years the red-bellied black snake had evolved in toad-inhabited regions of Australia to have increased resistance to toad toxin and decreased preference for toads as prey.
There is evidence for native predator species adapting to the presence of the cane toad, through learning or evolutionary selection. However, the initial drop in population is often steep and can reduce biodiversity on a population level. One proposed solution is to use "teacher toads", or smaller toads which are less likely to kill predators. These toads would allow predators to learn not to eat the toads while mitigating mortality. Some have even proposed adding some chemical to make the toads distasteful to further discourage predation. These efforts have shown some promising results so far.
A study to be published in the Ecology journal states that the invasion of cane toads in a case study area caused a trophic cascade over a period of five years. The resident predators, the monitor lizards, ate the cane toads and died, which resulted in a boom in the population of the lizards' typical prey, the crimson finches.
In 2019, it was found that the native rakali or Australian water rats (Hydromys chrysogaster) have learned to make an incision to eat the cane toads' hearts and livers, while avoiding their lethal skin and glands. According to Parrott, Doody, & Clulow's research article, the water rats were able to adapt the hunting strategies within two years of the cane toads introducing into their territory.
Methods to control invasion in Australia
Currently, most attempts to curtail the invasion of cane toads have been unsuccessful. Many of these strategies involve the physical trapping of toads, but these methods also capture unintended native species. Since the largest selective pressure on cane toads currently is intraspecies competition, these physical removals often only improve the conditions for untrapped toads. Also, since migration is high, any area purged of toads would most likely be reinvaded quickly.
Many new ideas have been proposed to control the cane toad population. Some have suggested introducing a native viral or bacterial pest of the toads, but this has potential to once again invade native species. Two similar strategies have been proposed, both of which focus on fecundity. One involves the release of sterile males into the population. These males would compete for resources with other males, while themselves not being able to reproduce. A second strategy would be to insert a gene in female toads which would allow them to only create male offspring. In theory, this would limit the reproductive rates and control the population. It is difficult to determine the efficacy and dangers of these approaches, as these methods have never been attempted, especially on a large scale.
On 13 June 2012 news reports cited a new research breakthrough regarding cane toad control. Research has confirmed that cane toad tadpoles are attracted to the toxin produced by adults and spawn. Tadpoles are believed to cannibalize toad spawn as a food source. Researchers used cane toad toxin to successfully lure cane toad tadpoles, implying that in controlled areas tadpoles could be captured and eradicated.
New research has indicated that in semi-arid areas where water is scarce the construction of toad proof fences around dams can severely affect toad survival rates by denying their access to water.
The RSPCA has guidelines for the humane culling of cane toads. Inhumane ways include spraying with Dettol, Phenyl and using a large hammer with a flat, metal head to bludgeon them to death, but these are illegal in most states and territories (for NT, QLD and NSW there are no laws against inhumane ways just recommendations). Due to concerns over potential harm to other Australian wildlife species, the use of Dettol as pest control was banned in Western Australia by the Department of Environment and Conservation in 2011.
Large predators like the yellow-spotted monitors and sand goannas are being fed young, small, cane toads by researchers to create a "food poisoning"-like experience for the predators, in the hope that they will avoid eating adult toads which might kill them.
Poisonous sausages containing toad meat are being trialed in the Kimberley (Western Australia) to try to protect native animals from cane toads' deadly impact. The Western Australian Department of Environment and Conservation has been working with the University of Sydney to develop baits to train native animals not to eat the toads. By blending bits of toad with a nausea-inducing chemical, the baits train the animals to stay away from the amphibians. Researcher David Pearson says trials run in laboratories and in remote parts of the Kimberley region of WA are looking promising, although the baits will not solve the cane toad problem altogether.
Attempts have been made to make use of dead cane toads, which can number in the thousands and cause hygiene problems. This includes processing the carcasses into liquid fertilisers.
Their skin can be made into leather, and novelty cane-toad purses made of the fore-body and abdomen have been made.
In the Torres Strait Islands, where the toads arrived in about 2014, one entrepreneur is tanning the hides to create a durable leather, and creating luxury fashion handbags from the skins.
In popular culture
The cane toad has been listed by the National Trust of Queensland as a state icon of Queensland, alongside the Great Barrier Reef, and past icons, the Royal Flying Doctor Service and the backyard mango tree (also an introduced species).
In Australian states where the cane toad is common, some "sports" have developed, such as cane toad golf and cane toad cricket, where cane toads are used as balls. In April 2005, Dave Tollner, a Northern Territory Member of Parliament, called for legalisation of attacks on cane toads. This was criticised by many animal and conservation groups who claim freezing is a more humane way to kill cane toads than hitting them with cricket bats. Townsville holds an annual "Toad Day Out" where the community learn about and catch cane toads, with prizes for the largest toad caught, and the heaviest weight of toads caught. In 2015, 143.6 kilograms (317 lb) of toads were caught. In 2016, a drier year, 92 kilograms (203 lb) of toads were caught. Cane toad races are popular in some towns and pubs. Toads are given humorous names and punters can bid or buy a toad or bet on them like horse racing. It is common for entrants or the winner to have to kiss their toad.
The introduction and subsequent migration of the cane toad in Australia was popularised by the film Cane Toads: An Unnatural History (1988), which tells the tale with a humorous edge and is often shown in Environmental Science courses. Don Spencer, a popular children's entertainer, sang the song "Warts 'n' All", which was used in the documentary. A longer sequel, Cane Toads: The Conquest, by the same filmmaker, was made in 2010.
A controversial commercial for Tooheys beer company showed people from New South Wales standing at the New South Wales-Queensland Border with golf clubs and lights, attracting cane toads just so they could hit them back across the border with the golf clubs.
The Cane Toad Times was a satirical humour magazine based in Brisbane, Queensland.
The invasive nature of cane toads was referenced in The Simpsons episode "Bart vs. Australia". It was also parodied in the episode "Bart the Mother" in which an invasive lizard is dealt with by introducing other species.
In the video game Ty the Tasmanian Tiger 2: Bush Rescue, cane toads appear as enemies. They wear spiked collars, have poisonous tongues (in contrast to real world cane toads), are about the size of medium-sized dogs, and will chase Ty down upon seeing him.
In Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn video game, there's a quest titled "You Call That a Toad", the player has to kill a group of enemies called "Cane Toad" after local wheat farmers brought these toads from foreign continent to devour the locusts but the cane toads have no natural predators on the new land and have taken over the region, leaving the farmers with no choice but to slay them all.
- "Archived copy". ProQuest 862947521. Cite journal requires
- "Australian Government policy on cane toads". Department of the Environment and Energy. 26 November 2007.
- Clarke, G. M., Gross, S., Matthews, M., Catling, P. C., Baker, B., Hewitt, C. L., Crowther, D., & Saddler, S. R. 2000, Environmental Pest Species in Australia, Australia: State of the Environment, Second Technical Paper Series (Biodiversity), Department of the Environment and Heritage, Canberra.
- "Cane Toad". Australian Museum.
- Turvey, Nigel. "Everyone agreed: cane toads would be a winner for Australia". The Conversation. Retrieved 26 October 2016.
- "Introducing the cane toad". Queensland Historical Atlas. University of Queensland. Archived from the original on 6 December 2020. Retrieved 6 December 2020.
- "Institute for Molecular Bioscience, Killing off the cane toad". Archived from the original on 2 October 2006. Retrieved 6 December 2006.
- Thompson, Jesse (31 January 2020). "On a tiny island invaded by cane toads, this handbag has become an unlikely solution". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 1 February 2020.
- "Toxic Toads Evolve Longer Legs, Study Says. 15 February 2006. National Geographic News". Retrieved 19 May 2006.
- Henry Fountain (16 October 2007). "Arthritis Fails to Slow Invading Toads in Australian Fields". NY Times. Retrieved 27 October 2007.
- Tyler, M. J. (1994). Australian Frogs A Natural History. Reed Books. p. 112. ISBN 0-7301-0468-0.
- "Cane toads evolving into straight, fast hoppers". ABC News. 9 October 2014.
- "Cane Toad Bufo marinus". National Geographic.
- Mayes, P.J.; Thompson, G. G.; Withers, P. C. (2005). "Diet and foraging behaviour of the semi-aquatic Varanus mertensi (Reptilia: Varanidae)". Wildlife Research. 32: 67–74. doi:10.1071/WR04040.
- J. S. Doody et al (2007): A Preliminary Assessment of the Impacts of Invasive Cane Toads (Bufo marinus) on Three Species of Varanid Lizards in Australia. Mertensiella 16 (Advances in Monitor Research III), S. 218–227
- "SSR164 – A preliminary risk assessment of cane toads in Kakadu National Park". Retrieved 22 May 2006.
- Boland, C. R. J. (2004). "Introduced cane toads Bufo marinus are active nest predators and competitors of rainbow bee-eaters Merops ornatus: observational and experimental evidence". Biological Conservation. 120 (1): 53–62. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2004.01.025.
- "Cane toad impact will boost croc hatchling numbers, researchers say". ABC News. Archived from the original on 11 October 2007. Retrieved 15 October 2006.
- "Cane Toads Present for Croc Hatching".[permanent dead link]
- Mitchell, D.; Jones, A.; Hero, J.M. (1995). "Predation on the Cane Toad (Bufo marinus) by the black kite (Milvus migrans)". Memoirs of the Queensland Museum. 38: 512–531.
- "NT frog 'eats' Cane Toad". ABC News. 15 December 2004. Archived from the original on 16 December 2004. Retrieved 9 May 2006.
- ."Team Bufo: About Us".
- Phillips, Ben L.; Shine, Richard (December 2004). "Adapting to an invasive species: Toxic cane toads induce morphological change in Australian snakes". PNAS. 101 (49): 17150–17155. Bibcode:2004PNAS..10117150P. doi:10.1073/pnas.0406440101. PMC 535375. PMID 15569943.
- Urban, Mark C.; Ben L. Phillips; David K. Skelly; Richard Shine (2007). "The cane toad's (Chaunus Bufo marinus) increasing ability to invade Australia is revealed by a dynamically updated range model". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 274 (1616): 1413–9. doi:10.1098/rspb.2007.0114. PMC 2176198. PMID 17389221.
- Sweeney, Claire (31 March 2009). "Killer ants are weapons of mass toad destruction". The Times. London. Retrieved 31 March 2009.
- "Cane toad threatens valuable dung beetle, scientists say". ABC News. 14 April 2015.
- "Cane Toads in Oz". canetoadsinoz.com.
- Ryan, Michelle, General Editor. (2000). Wildlife of Tropical North Queensland: Cooktown to Mackay. Queensland Museum. ISBN 0-7242-9349-3. p. 198.
- Katrina Bolton (15 September 2007). "Toads fall victim to crows in NT – ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)". ABC News. Retrieved 12 November 2011.
- "Miniature crocodiles fighting back against cane toad menace". ABC News. 17 November 2014.
- Phillips BL, Shine R (2006). "An invasive species induces rapid adaptive change in a native predator: cane toads and black snakes in Australia". Proc. Biol. Sci. 273 (1593): 1545–50. doi:10.1098/rspb.2006.3479. PMC 1560325. PMID 16777750.
- Doody, J. Sean; Soanes, Rebekah; Castellano, Christina M.; Rhind, David; Green, Brian; McHenry, Colin R.; Clulow, Simon (2015). "Invasive toads shift predator–prey densities in animal communities by removing top predators". Ecology. 96 (9): 2544–2554. doi:10.1890/14-1332.1. PMID 26594710.
- "Meet Richard Shine, who is saving our native animals from cane toads".
- "Eat your heart out: choice and handling of novel toxic prey by predatory water rats". Australian Mammalogy. 2019.
- Sarah Zielinski (15 June 2012). "The Reluctant Toad Killer". Science. 336 (6087): 1375–7. Bibcode:2012Sci...336.1375Z. doi:10.1126/science.336.6087.1375. PMID 22700900.
- Phillips, Nicky (4 February 2015). "Fences could halt cane toad invasion of arid Australia, study". The Sydney Morning Herald.
- "What is the most humane way to kill a cane toad?". RSPCA Australia.
- "Methods for the field euthanasia of cane toads". Australian Government, Department of the Environment and Energy. 2011.
- Narelle Towie (23 May 2009). "Cane toad poison banned". Perth Now. Retrieved 2 February 2013.
- "'Food poisoning' helps goannas survive invading cane-toad". ABC News. 6 January 2016.
- Parke, Erin (14 November 2016). "Cane toad sausages on the menu for Kimberley wildlife in taste aversion project". ABC News.
- "Toads as Fertilizer – DirtDoctor.com – Howard Garrett". Archived from the original on 19 June 2006. Retrieved 7 June 2006.
- "National Trust Queensland National Icons". Archived from the original on 19 September 2006. Retrieved 17 October 2006.
- "Australian slang terms – Koalanet.com.au". Retrieved 2 April 2010.
- "Cane toad clubbing sparks controversy". ABC News. Archived from the original on 1 March 2006. Retrieved 20 June 2006.
- "Townsville kids kick cane toads out of town". ABC News. 30 March 2015.
- "Townsville's annual cane toad hunt sees lowest yield ever". ABC News. 22 March 2016.
- "Cane toad races in Australia – cane toad racing in Queensland Australia". amazingaustralia.com.au.
- "Cane toad racing – Iron Bar, Port Douglas Traveller Reviews – TripAdvisor". tripadvisor.com.au.
- "Vulgar, Violent Ads". Retrieved 20 July 2009.
- Squires, Nick (8 June 2007). "Cane Toad Golf Out of Bounds". The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 20 July 2009.
- Mirkin, David (2005). The Simpsons season 6 DVD commentary for the episode "Bart vs. Australia" (DVD). 20th Century Fox.
- Cohen, David S. (2007). The Simpsons The Complete Tenth Season DVD commentary for the episode "Bart the Mother" (DVD). 20th Century Fox.
- Tyler, M. J. (1994). Australian Frogs A Natural History. Reed Books. ISBN 0-7301-0468-0.
- Barker, J.; Grigg, G.C.; Tyler, M.J. (1995). A Field Guide to Australian Frogs. Surrey Beatty & Sons. ISBN 0-949324-61-2.
- Lawson, Walter J. (1987). The Cane Toad, Bufo marinus: A Bibliography (AES working paper). School of Australian Environmental Studies, Griffith University. ISBN 0-86857-247-0.
- Cane Toads: An Unnatural History at IMDb
- Cane Toads: The Conquest at IMDb
- Summary of cane toad research in Australia
- Cane toad factsheet —Australian Museum (2003)
- The Cane Toad – Australia's Amphibian Plague at h2g2
- "Cane Toad – What Happened To Baz?" —the prize-winning Australian animated short, hosted on a German site
- Kimberley Toad Busters
- The Cane Toad (Bufo Marinus) —Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts (2010)