Carol Whittier Chessman
May 27, 1921
St. Joseph, Michigan, U.S.
|Died||May 2, 1960 (aged 38)|
|Cause of death||Execution by gas chamber|
|Criminal charge||Robbery, kidnapping, and rape (17 counts)|
|January 23, 1948|
|Imprisoned at||San Quentin State Prison|
Caryl Whittier Chessman (May 27, 1921 – May 2, 1960) was a convicted robber, kidnapper and rapist who was sentenced to death for a series of crimes committed in January 1948 in the Los Angeles area. Chessman was convicted under a loosely interpreted "Little Lindbergh law" – later repealed, but not retroactively – that defined kidnapping as a capital offense under certain circumstances. His case attracted worldwide attention, and helped propel the movement to end the use of capital punishment in the state of California.
Chessman was born Carol Whittier Chessman in St. Joseph, Michigan, the only child of Hallie Lillian (née Cottle) and Serl Whittier Chessman, both devout Baptists. (Carol was, at the time, a popular name for boys of Danish descent; but Chessman later changed the spelling himself to Caryl.) In 1922, the family relocated to Glendale, California. Chessman's father became despondent after failing at each of a series of jobs, and attempted suicide twice. In 1929 Chessman's mother was paralyzed as the result of a car accident. As a child, Chessman battled asthma, which left him weak, and he also contracted encephalitis, which he later claimed changed his personality. After recovering he began to rebel against his parents' strict Baptist upbringing by committing petty crimes. The family was hit hard by the Depression, and Chessman later recalled that he stole food and other items as an adolescent to help his parents. During his teen years—as the stealing continued—he changed the spelling of his first name from "Carol" to "Caryl."
In July 1937 Chessman was caught stealing a car and sent to Preston School of Industry (also known as Preston Castle), a reform school in Northern California. He was released in April 1938, only to return a month later after stealing another car. In October 1939 Chessman was sent to the Los Angeles County Road Camp after yet another car theft. It was there that he met a group of young criminals known as the "Boy Bandit Gang." After his release from the road camp he joined the gang and, in April 1941, was arrested in connection with a number of gang-related robberies and shootouts with police. As the gang's leader, Chessman was convicted of robbery and sent to San Quentin State Prison, then transferred to the California Institution for Men in Chino. He escaped in October 1943 but was arrested a month later. Convicted on another robbery charge, Chessman was sentenced to five years to life and served the minimum, mostly at Folsom State Prison. He was released in December 1947 and returned to Glendale.
Crimes and conviction
In the first three weeks of January 1948, a number of robberies and thefts were reported throughout the Greater Los Angeles Area. On January 3, two men robbed a haberdashery in Pasadena with a .45 caliber semi-automatic pistol. On January 13, a 1946 Ford Coupe was stolen from a Pasadena street. On January 18, a man driving a car described as a 1947 Ford coupe used a red light to stop a vehicle near Malibu Beach, then used a .45 caliber pistol to rob the vehicle's occupants. Later that day a second couple was robbed in the same manner near the Rose Bowl. Police quickly began to suspect a common perpetrator, and Los Angeles newspapers dubbed the suspect "The Red Light Bandit." On January 19, a third couple was robbed as they sat parked on a hill in West Pasadena, and the woman, Regina Johnson, was forced to perform oral sex on her assailant. On January 22, a fourth couple returning home from a church dance was pulled over on Mulholland Drive. The assailant dragged the woman, 17-year-old Mary Alice Meza, a short distance to his vehicle. Her boyfriend then drove away and was pursued by the assailant. After an unsuccessful attempt to force the male victim off the road, the perpetrator drove Meza to a secluded area where he forced her to engage in oral and anal sex, threatening to kill her boyfriend if she did not comply.
The following day, police in North Hollywood attempted to stop a 1946 Ford coupe matching the description given by Meza and her boyfriend, and also by witnesses to a robbery at a clothing store in Redondo Beach earlier that day. After a high-speed chase the vehicle's occupants, Chessman and David Knowles, were captured and arrested. After a 72-hour interrogation, during which Chessman later claimed he was beaten and tortured, Chessman confessed to the "Red Light Bandit" crimes. He was also positively identified by the rape victims, Johnson and Meza. In late January 1948 Chessman was indicted on 18 counts of robbery, kidnapping, and rape. After a three-week trial in May, he was convicted on 17 of the 18 counts, and was sentenced to death. Chessman's accomplice, Knowles, was tried and convicted as an accessory in the store robberies, but his conviction was reversed on appeal in 1950 due to an absence of direct incriminating evidence and "impermissible abuse of the law."
Appeals and controversy
Part of the controversy surrounding the Chessman case stemmed from the state's unusual application of the death penalty. At the time, under California's version of the "Little Lindbergh Law," a crime that involved kidnapping with bodily harm could be considered a capital offense. Two of the counts against Chessman alleged that he dragged Johnson 22 feet from her car before demanding oral sex, and that he abducted Meza against her will, driving her a considerable distance before raping her. The court ruled that both actions fit the law's definition of kidnapping with bodily harm, thus making Chessman eligible for the death penalty under the law. The law was repealed by the time his trial began but was in effect at the time of the crimes; the repeal was not applied retroactively.
Chessman asserted his innocence from the outset, arguing throughout the trial and the appeals process that he was alternately the victim of mistaken identity, or of a conspiracy to frame him. (He claimed to know the identity of the real perpetrator, but refused to reveal it.) He further alleged that the confession he signed during his initial police interrogation was coerced through force and intimidation.
Over the course of nearly twelve years on death row Chessman filed dozens of appeals, acting as his own attorney, and successfully avoided eight execution deadlines, often by a few hours. Most appeals were based on assertions that he was forced to go to trial unprepared; that the trial itself was unfair; that confessions obtained by force and intimidation and promises of partial immunity were used in evidence against him; that California's "Little Lindbergh Law" was unconstitutional; and that the transcript of record forwarded upon appeal to the state supreme court was incomplete, and important parts of the proceedings were missing or incorrectly recorded. In 1957 the U.S. Supreme Court ordered the State of California to conduct a full review of the transcripts. The review concluded that the transcripts were substantially accurate.
Chessman also took his case to the public through letters, essays and books. His four books, Cell 2455, Death Row, Trial by Ordeal, The Face of Justice, and The Kid Was a Killer, became bestsellers. He sold the rights to Cell 2455, Death Row to Columbia Pictures, which made a 1955 film of the same name, directed by Fred F. Sears, with William Campbell as Chessman. Chessman's middle name, Whittier, was used as the surname of his alter ego protagonist in the film. The manuscript of his fourth book, The Kid Was a Killer, was seized by San Quentin warden Harley O. Teets in 1954 as a product of “prison labor." It was eventually returned to Chessman in late 1957, and published in 1960.
Chessman's books and public campaign ignited a worldwide movement to spare his life, while focusing attention on the larger question of the death penalty in the United States, at a time when most Western countries had abandoned it, or were in the process of doing so. The office of California Governor Pat Brown was flooded with appeals for clemency from noted authors and intellectuals from around the world, including Aldous Huxley, Ray Bradbury, Norman Mailer, Dwight MacDonald, and Robert Frost, and from such other public figures as former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt and Christian evangelist Billy Graham.
The Chessman affair put Brown, an opponent of the death penalty, in a difficult position. He was unable to grant Chessman executive clemency as the California Constitution required the commutation of a two-time felon's death sentence to be ratified by the California Supreme Court, which declined ratification by a vote of 4-3. After a long period of inaction Brown finally issued a 60-day stay a few hours before the February 19, 1960 scheduled execution. He issued the stay, he said, out of concern that the execution could threaten the safety of President Dwight D. Eisenhower during an official visit to South America, where the Chessman case had inflamed anti-American sentiment.
Brown's stay of execution, along with Chessman's last appeals, ran out in April 1960, and Chessman finally went to the gas chamber at San Quentin Prison on May 2, twenty-five days before his 39th birthday. According to some sources, a last-minute attempt by a California Supreme Court justice to implement a new stay pending a habeas corpus motion failed when a court secretary misdialed the prison switchboard's phone number. By the time the call was received and routed to the execution chamber, the execution had already begun and could not be halted. During the execution Chessman vigorously nodded his head, a pre‑arranged signal to reporters that he was experiencing pain. Chessman's body was cremated, as per his wishes, at the Mount Tamalpais Mortuary and Cemetery in San Rafael, California. He requested that his ashes be interred with his parents' at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Glendale, but Forest Lawn refused the request on "moral grounds." His ashes were buried at the Mount Tamalpais Cemetery, then disinterred in 1974 by Chessman's attorney Rosalie Asher and scattered off the coast of Santa Cruz Island.
Chessman was dubbed "the first modern American executed for a non-lethal kidnapping." His time on death row – eleven years and ten months – was then the longest ever in the United States, a record that was broken in the post-Furman v. Georgia era on March 15, 1988, when Willie Darden, Jr. was executed in Florida's electric chair. Several months after Chessman's execution, Billy Monk was executed on November 21, 1961 for kidnapping two women, attempting to rape the first and raping the second, and was the last to be executed for a non-lethal kidnapping in the United States.
In popular culture
The author Dominique Lapierre visited Chessman several times during his incarceration. Lapierre was then a young reporter working for a French newspaper. His account of Chessman appears in the book A Thousand Suns.
Chessman's execution is referenced in Lucio Fulci's 1969 giallo One on Top of the Other, in which the character of George Dumurrier (Jean Sorel) is prepared to be executed in San Quentin's gas chamber. Not only were these sequences shot on location in San Quentin, but several of the prison personnel who were responsible for Chessman's death acted in them; a fact that was especially highlighted in the film's trailer.
The song "The Ballad of Caryl Chessman," written by the hit songwriting team of Al Hoffman and Dick Manning, and which includes the chorus "let him live, let him live, let him live," was a minor hit single for Ronnie Hawkins two months before Chessman's execution.
Country music star Merle Haggard stated in an interview in 1995 that many years earlier, when he was a prison inmate, observing Chessman's preparations for his execution helped to set him on the straight and narrow.
"Chessman," a 2016 play by Joe Rodota, tells the story of the execution from the viewpoint of Governor Pat Brown.
The song "Broadway Melody of 1974" by the rock group Genesis, off their album The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, contains the following lyrics: "Caryl Chessman sniffs the air and leads the parade, he knows, in a scent, you can bottle all you made."
- Howard, C. The True Story of Caryl Chessman. The Crime Library. Retrieved February 25, 2015.
- Hamm, Theodore (2001). Rebel and a Cause: Caryl Chessman and the Politics of the Death Penalty in Postwar California, 1948–1979. University of California Press. p. 3. ISBN 0-520-92523-8.
- Starr, Kevin (2003). Embattled Dreams: California in War and Peace, 1940–1950. Oxford University Press. p. 223. ISBN 0-195-16897-6.
- James, Bill (2012). Popular Crime: Reflections on the Celebration of Violence. Scribner. p. 186. ISBN 1-416-55274-X.
- Ulin, David L. (September 19, 2006). "Caryl Chessman's infamous death row case is revisited". latimes.com. Retrieved December 22, 2014.
- James 2012 p.187
- Hamm 2001 p.4
- James 2012 p.188
- "A Strange Meeting In Prison". Life. Time Inc. 48 (7): 30. February 22, 1960. ISSN 0024-3019.
- People v. Chessman, 38 Cal. 2d 166 (1951).
- People v. Chessman, 52 Cal. 2d 467 (1959).
- Chessman v. People, et. al., 205 F.2d 128 (9th Cir. 1953).
- Chessman v. Teets, 354 U.S. 156 (1957).
- "Caryl Chessman". November 26, 2007.
- Caryl Chessman, The Red-Light Bandit Archived May 25, 2008, at the Wayback Machine
- "California Constitution: Article 5". leginfo.ca.gov. Archived from the original on January 8, 2011.
- "Caryl Chessman: Biography". biography.com.
- Obituary: R. Richard Rubottom, New York Times, December 20, 2010; accessed June 2, 2014.
- "Chessman's Execution a 'Breath of Fresh Air,' Times Says (Clippings of 1960s coverage)". LATimes. Retrieved December 14, 2014.
- The Encyclopedia of American Prisons by Carl Sifakis page 85; Retrieved January 22, 2016
- Gruesome Spectacles: Botched Executions and America's Death Penalty by Austin Sarat page 196 Retrieved January 19, 2016
- Debates in Criminal Justice: Key Themes and Issues edited by Tom Ellis, Stephen P. Savage page 214 Retrieved January 19, 2016
- Stevens, Shane (2007). By Reason of Insanity. Chicago Review Press. p. 39. ISBN 1-556-52662-8.
- Mitford, Jessica (2011). The American Way of Death Revisited. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. p. 102. ISBN 0-307-80939-0.
- "Ashes of Chessman Scattered At Sea". The Milwaukee Journal. March 11, 1974. p. 6. Retrieved December 22, 2014.
- New York Daily News archive. Retrieved April 13, 2015.
- Nordheimer, J. (March 13, 1988). Florida Inmate Faces His Seventh Date With Executioner. The New York Times Retrieved November 30, 2014.
- People v. Monk, 56 Cal. 2d. 288 (Cal. 2d July 20, 1961).
- "Tragedy in Curtain Call for Sad Mother". Mirror News. April 27, 1960. Retrieved November 8, 2013.
- Dominique Lapierre: Bestselling Writer Turns Philanthropist. cityofjoyaid.org archive Archived March 7, 2014, at the Wayback Machine. Retrieved November 30, 2014.
- "Bruce Conner. CHILD. 1959-60 - MoMA". The Museum of Modern Art.
- Art, Archives of American. "Oral history interview with Bruce Conner, 1974 March 29 - Oral Histories | Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution". www.aaa.si.edu. Retrieved December 18, 2016.
- Stephen Thrower (2018). One on Top of the Other (Interview with Stephen Thrower) (Blu-ray Disc). Seattle: Mondo Macabro.
- Morales, T. (January 4, 2005). Alan Alda Shows Off His Dark Side. CBS News archive. Retrieved November 30, 2014.
- "Could be I love you (to the bank, to the bank, to the bank) English lyrics by Al Hoffman & Dick Manning, original Spanish lyric & music by Haroldo Barboza & Lucio Alves". www.copyrightencyclopedia.com.
- It peaked at number 32 on the CHUM Chart in Toronto in March 1960. The CHUM Chart Book: 1957–1983, Ron Hall, p. 81.
- 1:33 PM ET (April 8, 2016). "Fresh Air Remembers Country Music Legend Merle Haggard". NPR. Retrieved October 29, 2016.
- Crowder, Marcus (October 17, 2016). "Life or death at B Street Theatre in 'Chessman'". Sacramento Bee. Retrieved February 14, 2017.
- "Lyrics to the Genesis song "Broadway Melody Of 1974"". Genius. Retrieved May 23, 2019.
|Wikiquote has quotations related to: Caryl Chessman|
- Caryl Chessman online
- Newsreel footage about Caryl Chessman
- An in depth article on Chessman
- FBI files on Chessman
- Chessman on Crime Library at the Wayback Machine (archived March 29, 2001)
- Kill Me If You Can on IMDb
- Caryl Chessman at Find a Grave
- Cell 2455, Death Row on IMDb
- Cell 2455, Death Row at the TCM Movie Database