The house was built in stone up against the ruins of Cloghane Castle in two storeys with a 7-bay frontage, of which the middle three were pedimented. In the 19th century a tower house was attached at the rear based on the ruins of the castle keep. The house was burnt down in 1922, probably by Sinn Féin. It now stands as a derelict ruin with the gardens and estate land used for farming.
Henry Otway (1768–1815) came to own the castle. He married Sarah Cave of Stanford Hall, Leicestershire, who became Baroness Braye in her own right. After Henry's death both the Baroness and their son Robert adopted the surname Otway-Cave and the property passed to Robert. He died young in 1844 with no children and the house was inherited by a cousin, Vice-Admiral Robert Jocelyn Otway. On the latter's death in 1884 it passed to his Galway-born son-in-law William Clifford Bermingham Ruthven, who adopted the surname Otway-Ruthven. The castle at one time housed the Otway Harp, an ornate late 16th-century instrument which is now the property of Trinity College, Dublin.
- "Landed Estates Database- House: Castle Otway". NUI Galway. Retrieved 11 October 2013.
- "Castle Otway, Tipperary". Abandoned Ireland. Retrieved 11 October 2013.
- Burke, Bernard (1912). Genealogical and Heraldic history of the landed families of Ireland.
- "Castle Otway Ruins, Co. Tipperary". Travelmania Ireland. Retrieved 11 October 2013.
- "Image Gallery: The Castle Otway Harp". HarpSpectrum. Retrieved 11 October 2013.