Category talk:German musical groups
|WikiProject Germany||(Rated Category-class)|
- i'm a bit confused by the titel of this category. i'm a german user and as far as i know the english word "musical" refers to the german word "Musical". So i think this category should have the titel "German music groups". Or just a few bands are just categorized wrong.
This category is full of irrelevant entries with no encyclopedic value. Lots of bands are listed here which are between amateur and semi-pro level or known at most in local subcultural context and not notable at all, especially not in an internationl context. It seems this category is being abused to by these bands or relatives to create an artificial significance. Since this is Wikipedia and not MySpace, many of the entries here should be deleted, I suggest throwing out all articles that lack sources and citations and clear indices of cultural relevance. 188.8.131.52 (talk) 07:16, 14 November 2008 (UTC)
Whoever made this forgot Die Toten Hosen and The Scorpions. Is this all German bands or just the newer ones or ones that sing in German? They should specify if it is not all German bands. --184.108.40.206 (talk) 00:38, 30 May 2009 (UTC)