Censorship in Cuba
|Part of a series on|
|Censorship by country|
Censorship in Cuba is the most intense in the western hemisphere. It has been reported on extensively and resulted in European Union sanctions from 2003 to 2008 as well as statements of protest from groups, governments, and noted individuals.
Cuba has ranked low on the Press Freedom Index from Reporters Without Borders from 2002 when the index was established (134th out of 139) to the present (169th out of 180 in 2015). In 2006 the Inter American Press Association reported that "repression against independent journalists, mistreatment of jailed reporters, and very strict government surveillance limiting the people’s access to alternative sources of information are continuing".
Books, newspapers, radio channels, television channels, movies and music are heavily censored. Clandestine printing is also highly restricted. The special permits that are required to use the Internet are only available to selected Cubans and use of the Internet is limited for the vast majority of Cubans. Mobile phones are quite rare, with most citizens not having been allowed to use them until quite recently. Foreign journalists who can work in the country are selected by the government.
Laws and government institutions
|Part of a series on|
|Life in Cuba|
The Cuban Constitution guaranties religious freedom and freedom of conscience (articles 8 and 55), freedom and full dignity of man (article 9), freedom of speech and the press (article 53), and the rights of assembly, demonstration, and association (article 54). However, freedom of speech and the press must be exercised in accordance with the aims of socialist society and none of the freedoms granted to citizens can be exercised against the provisions of the Constitution and laws, nor against the existence and objectives of the socialist state, or against the decision of the Cuban people to build socialism and communism (article 62).
Civilian courts exist at the municipal, provincial, and Supreme Court levels. The constitution recognizes the independence of the judiciary, but the judiciary is directly subordinate to the National Assembly, which can remove or appoint judges at any time and in practice the judiciary is dominated by political considerations. Special tribunals are convened for political (“counterrevolutionary”) and other cases deemed sensitive to “state security” and held behind closed doors.
Laws related to censorship include:
- A provision regarding contempt for authority (desacato) penalizes anyone who "threatens, libels or slanders, defames, affronts (injuria) or in any other way insults (ultraje) or offends, with the spoken word or in writing, the dignity or decorum of an authority, public functionary, or his agents or auxiliaries." Penalties are from three months to one year in prison, plus a fine. If the person demonstrates contempt for the President of the Council of the State, the President of the National Assembly of Popular Power, the members of the Council of the State or the Council of Ministers, or the Deputies of the National Assembly of the Popular Power, the penalty is from one to three years in prison.
- Anyone who "publicly defames, denigrates, or scorns the Republic's institutions, the political, mass, or social organizations of the country, or the heroes or martyrs of the nation" is subject to from three months to one year in prison. This sweeping provision potentially outlaws mere expressions of dissatisfaction or disagreement with government policies or practices.
- Clandestine printing is a crime against public order and anyone who "produces, disseminates, or directs the circulation of publications without indicating the printer or the place where it was printed, or without following the established rules for the identification of the author or origin, or reproduces, stores, or transports" such publications, can be sentenced to from three months to one year in prison.
The Interior Ministry has principal responsibility for monitoring the Cuban population for signs of dissent. The ministry employs two central offices for this purpose: the General Directorate of Counter-Intelligence, which supervises the Department of State Security, also known as the Political Police, and the General Directorate of Internal Order, which supervises two police units with internal surveillance responsibilities, the National Revolutionary Police and the Technical Department of Investigation (Departamento Técnico de Investigaciones, DTI).
The Singular Systems of Vigilance and Protection (Sistema Unico de Vigilancia y Protección, SUVP) reach across several state institutions, including the Communist Party, the police, the CDRs, the state-controlled labor union, student groups, and members of mass organizations. The government calls on SUVPs to carry out surveillance and to intimidate opposition activists. Rapid Action Brigades (Brigadas de Acción Rapida, also referred to as Rapid Response Brigades, or Brigadas de Respuesta Rápida) are groups of government organized civilians that observe and control dissidents.
Migration and housing officials threaten activists with forced exile, the loss of their homes, or by imposing fines. Political fidelity is monitored at workplaces and in schools: academic and labor files (expedientes escolares y laborales) that record actions or statements that may bear on a person's loyalty are maintained for each citizen and an individual's record must be deemed acceptable before they can advance to a new school or position.
Cuba had 21 journalists in prison in 2008, placing it second only to the People's Republic of China, according to The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), an international NGO. By December 2011 this number had dropped to zero, although many prisoners were forced into exile in exchange for their freedom. However, journalists continue to be at risk of imprisonment or other severe sanctions if they engage in independent reporting or commentary. The Cuban government still uses arbitrary arrests and short-term detentions to restrict freedom of assembly and expression.
Media and culture
Cubans cannot watch or listen to independent, private, or foreign broadcasts. In 1963, using Soviet-supplied equipment, Cuba became the first nation in the Western Hemisphere to jam radio broadcasts, the apparent targets being the anti-Castro stations in the US. In 2006, Cuba jammed Radio Republica, a clandestine broadcast to Cuba on 7205 kHz. The output of the Television Network teleSUR in Cuba is subject to various restrictions.
Before the Communist regime, Havana boasted 135 cinemas — more than New York City or Paris. Today less than 20 remain open, although the city’s population has doubled. The Communist regime established a control of Cuba's film industry, and it was made compulsory for all movies to be censored by the Instituto Cubano de Arte y Industria Cinematográfico before broadcast or release.
In October 1994, five "counterrevolutionaries" were convicted of rebellion and sentenced to ten years each. The judges characterized the group's actions as nonviolent, but found they had prepared and distributed calls for changes in the country's social, political, and economic systems, citing the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The court characterized the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and denunciations of Cuban human rights violations as counterrevolutionary propaganda.
An article published on 19 November 1999 by Maria Elena Rodriguez, a journalist for the Cuba-Verdad Press, described the burning and burying of hundreds of books donated to Cuba by the government of Spain. Unexplained at the time was why all of the books in the Spanish-donated shipment, even those on seemingly non-controversial topics such as children's literature and medical textbooks were destroyed. It was later revealed that some 8,000 pamphlets containing the text of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights were discovered in the shipment. Rather than risking overlooking any pamphlets that may have been inserted in the pages of even the "safe" books in the shipment, the Cuban authorities apparently thought the wisest course was to destroy every one of the books sent from Spain.
In 2002, “Following the Hip Hop Festival held in Havana in August, the Casa de Cultura in Alamar received an order from the Ministry of Culture to review the lyrics of rap songs before the start of any concert.” Cuban rappers responded by altering their music/lyric styles. “Underground’s beat slowed down its tempo and rappers started changing their lyrics. The strident notes coming from the barrios and caseríos that scared the State so much when they first came out started softening themselves to take advantage of the promotional opportunities offered by those same people who initiated the hunting spree.”
In April 2003 a Cuban court convicted dissident Julio Valdés of committing "crimes against the national sovereignty and economy of Cuba" and him sentenced to 20 years in prison. One of the accusations made against Valdés was the founding of a "self-proclaimed Independent Library" to "ideologically subvert the reader with the clear purpose, by means of inducing confusion, to recruit persons for the counter-revolution...". The judges also condemned Valdes' library materials as "lacking in usefulness" and ordered them burned.
In August 2006, the Cuban government announced a warning to owners of illegal television satellite dishes, citing as a concern that the United States could use the dishes to transmit programming with "destabilizing, subversive content."
Starting in 2010 and 2011, religious groups reported greater latitude to voice their opinions during sermons and at religious gatherings than in the past, although most members of the clergy continued to exercise self-censorship. Religious leaders in some cases criticized the government, its policies, and even the country’s leadership without reprisals. In September the Catholic Church opened a cultural center in Havana that hosted debates featuring participants voicing different opinions about the country’s future at which well-known dissidents were allowed to participate. The Catholic Church published two periodicals that sometimes included criticism of official social and economic policies.
In March 2012 Cuban police beat and then arrested at least 50 female members of the Ladies in White, a prominent dissident group, who were holding demonstrations just days before the visit of Pope Benedict XVI. All but two of demonstrators were released within a day or two. The move was seen as a warning from the government not to interfere with the papal trip, the first to the island since John Paul II's 1998 visit.
On 24 July 2012 dozens of anti-government activists were arrested as they made their way to the funeral of Oswaldo Paya Sardiñas, a prominent critic of Cuba's government.
The Cuban internet is among the most tightly controlled in the world. A special permit is required to use the Internet and all e-mails are intricately monitored. Cuba has been listed as an "Internet Enemy" by Reporters Without Borders since the list was created in 2006. The level of Internet filtering in Cuba is not categorized by the OpenNet Initiative due to lack of data.
Two kinds of online connections are offered in Cuban Internet cafes: a 'national' one that is restricted to a simple e-mail service operated by the government, and an 'international' one that gives access to the entire Internet. The population is restricted to the first one, which costs €1.20 an hour. Foreign visitors who allow Cubans to use their computers are harassed and persecuted.
Cuban ambassador Miguel Ramirez has argued that Cuba has the right to "regulate access to [the] Internet and avoid hackers, stealing passwords, [and] access to pornographic, satanic cults, terrorist or other negative sites".
Authorities claim that 1,600,000 or about twelve percent of the population have access to Internet, and there were 630,000 computers available on the island in 2008, a 23% increase over 2007. But it is also seen as essential for Cuba’s economic development.
In recent times, censorship of the Internet has slowly relaxed. For example in 2007, it became possible for members of the public to legally buy a computer.
In order to get around the government's control of the Internet, citizens have developed numerous techniques. Some get online through embassies and coffee shops or purchase accounts through the black market. The black market consists of professional or former government officials who have been cleared to have Internet access. These individuals sell or rent their usernames and passwords to citizens who want to have access.
Prior to March 2008 mobile phones were banned. However, they could be used by those who needed them as part of their work. In March 2008 Raul Castro lifted the ban on mobile phones along with other consumerist goods. The state-run telecommunications company, ETECSA, says the revenues will be used to fund telecommunications development in Cuba. In February 2009, ETECSA said that its subscriber base had surged by 60% to reach nearly half a million customers. Nearly 8,000 new connections were purchased in the first ten days after the restrictions were lifted. The government also halved the cost of the sign-up fee. The local newspaper, Juventud Rebelde reported that around 480,000 cellular lines are now in use, compared with 300,000 before the change.
Between 2009 and 2012 the U.S. secretly created and funded a Twitter-like service for Cubans called ZunZuneo, initially based on mobile phone text message service and later with an internet interface. The service was funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development through its Office of Transition Initiatives, who utiliized contractors and front companies in the Cayman Islands, Spain and Ireland. A longer term objective was to organize "smart mobs" that might "renegotiate the balance of power between the state and society." A database about the subscribers was created, including gender, age, and "political tendencies". At its peak ZunZuneo had 40,000 Cuban users, but the service closed as financially unsustainable when U.S. funding was stopped.
Sanctions, imposed by the European Union in 2003 as a response to a crackdown against dissidents (Black Spring), were lifted in 2008, in spite of a finding by the EU council that "the state of human rights had deteriorated" since sanctions were initially imposed.
In 2001 and 2003 the International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions and its Committee of Free Access to Information and Freedom of Expression expressed their deep concern about the continuing violations of the basic human right to freedom of access to information and freedom of expression in Cuba.
In November 2006 the U.S. State Department's Office for Cuban Affairs issued a statement praising the Global Coordinating Committee of Press Freedom Organizations for their efforts to bring attention to the “unjust jailing of journalists” in Cuba.
In 2006 the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) named Cuba one of the ten most censored countries in the world. In 2009 CPJ ranked Cuba as the world's fourth worst place for bloggers, stating that "only government officials and people with links to the Communist Party have Web access" and "only pro-government bloggers can post their material on domestic sites that can be easily accessed".
In June 2007 the Inter American Press Association, a nonprofit organization devoted to defending freedom of speech and freedom of the press in the Americas, stated how disgraceful it is that "Not only are these individuals being denied their right to free speech, but their very lives are being endangered by denying them adequate health care." For example, imprisoned journalist Omar Ruiz Hernández had tuberculosis and a chronic parasitic infection, and weighed only 45 kilograms (about 100 pounds).
- "European Union to lift sanctions on Cuba", Robin Oakley, CNN World, 19 June 2008. Retrieved 6 August 2012
- "Cuban Women's Group Awarded European Parliament's Sakharov Prize Prize", Eric Green, Washington File, 27 October 2005, Bureau of International Information Programs, U.S. Department of State. Retrieved 7 August 2005. “In an October 26 statement, the European Parliament, which awards the prize annually, said the group of Cuban women has been protesting peacefully every Sunday since 2004 against the continued detention of their husbands and sons, who are political dissidents in Cuba. The women wear white as a symbol of peace and the innocence of those imprisoned.”
- "Press Freedom Index 2002", Reporters Without Borders. Retrieved 6 August 2012
- "Press Freedom Index 2015", Reporters Without Borders. Retrieved 12 November 2015
- "62nd General Assembly Reports: Cuba". Inter American Press Association. 3 October 2006. Retrieved 6 August 2012.
- "Impediments to Human rights in Cuban Law (Part III)". Cuba's Repressive Machinery: Human Rights Forty Years After the Revolution. Human Rights Watch. June 1999. ISBN 1-56432-234-3. Retrieved 7 August 2012.
- Claire Voeux and Julien Pain (October 2006). "Going online in Cuba: Internet under surveillance" (PDF). Reporters Without Borders.
- Michael C. Moynihan (22 February 2008). "Still Stuck on Castro - How the press handled a tyrant's farewell".
- "10 most censored countries". The Committee to Protect Journalists. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "CPJ-2006" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- Constitución de la Republica de Cuba (Constitution of the Republic of Cuba)" (Spanish), (English translation)
- "Cuba", Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2011, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, U.S. Department of State, 2011
- "Routine Repression (Part VIII)". Cuba's Repressive Machinery: Human Rights Forty Years After the Revolution. Human Rights Watch. June 1999. ISBN 1-56432-234-3. Retrieved 7 August 2012.
- "CPJ's 2008 prison census: Online and in jail". Committee to Protect Journalists. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 7 August 2012.
- "Attacks on the Press in 2011: Cuba", Committee to Protect Journalists. Retrieved 6 August 2012
- "Cuba", Freedom of the Press 2011, Freedom House
- "Human Rights in Cuba", Human Rights Watch. Retrieved 8 August 2012
- "Cuba facts, issue 42". Cuba Transition Project, Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies (ICCAS), University of Miami. August 2008. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- "Timetable History of Cuba: After The Revolution", Jerry A. Sierra, historyofcuba.com. Retrieved 5 August 2012
- "Radio Republica, Jammed by Cuba", Cobalt Pet Shortwave / Mediumwave Radio Weblog, 8 April 2006
- "Por qué Fidel Castro censura a Telesur" ("Why Fidel Castro censors Telesur") (Spanish) (English translation), Carlos Manuel Estefania, HarryMagazine.com, August 2005. Retrieved 8 January 2009
- "Radikal tv-kanal får kritik" ("Radical TV station has come under criticism") (Swedish) (English translation), Nathan Shachar, DN.se, 5 August 2005. Retrieved 4 March 2009
- "The Cuban revolution at 50: Heroic myth and prosaic failure". The Economist. 30 December 2008. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- Theodore Dalrymple (5 January 2009). "Cuba: A Cemetery of Hopes". Front Page Magazine. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- William Luis (2001). Culture and customs of Cuba. Greenwood Press. p. 229. ISBN 0-313-30433-5. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- "Library books burned, buried, dumped". New York: Friends of Cuban Libraries. 10 December 1999. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- "Library books burned, buried, dumped: Mystery solved?". New York: Friends of Cuban Libraries. 9 March 2000. Retrieved 21 April 2015.
- "Censorship against young poets and rap artists", Jorge Alberto Aguiar Diaz, Cuba News, 13 December 2002. Retrieved 5 August 2012
- "From Hip-hop to Reggaeton: Is There Only a Step?" in Reggaeton, Welmo Romero Joseph, pp. 312-323, Duke University Press, 2009, ISBN 978-0-8223-4360-8
- "Library books burned by court order". New York: Friends of Cuban Libraries. 28 September 2003. Retrieved 5 August 2012.
- "Sentencing Document for Cause 5 of 2003 before the Popular Provincial Court of Santiago of Cuba of the Crimes Against the Security of the State, defendant Julio Antonio Valdes Guevara", 4 April 2003, English translation, Rule of Law and Cuba, Center for the Advancement of Human Rights, Florida State University in Tallahassee, Florida USA. Retrieved 5 August 2012
- Thompson, Ginger (10 August 2006). "Cuba: Warning On TV Dishes". New York Times. Retrieved 7 December 2006.
- "Cuba", Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2010, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, U.S. Department of State, 2010
- "Cuba Holds Dissidents Ahead of Papal Visit ", Stacy Meichtry, Wall Street Journal, 19 March 2012
- "Dozens reported arrested on way to Cuban dissident's funeral", Patrick Oppmann, CNN, 25 July 2012
- "Internet Enemies: Cuba", Reporters Without Borders, March 2011
- "ONI Country Profile: Cuba", OpenNet Initiative, May 2007
- Luxner, Larry (February 2004). "Cuba delays crackdown against illegal access to Internet". Cuba News.
- Juventud Rebelde (6 February 2009), Internet es vital para el desarrollo de Cuba (Internet is vital for the development of Cuba) (in Spanish), Cuban Youth Daily (English translation)
- "Changes in Cuba: From Fidel to Raul Castro", Perceptions of Cuba: Canadian and American policies in comparative perspective, Lana Wylie, University of Toronto Press Incorporated, 2010, p. 114, ISBN 978-1-4426-4061-0
- "Guillermo Fariñas ends seven-month-old hunger strike for Internet access". Reporters Without Borders. 1 September 2006.
- "Havana Internet cafes". Havana Guide. Retrieved 7 November 2011.
- "Cuba lifts curbs on mobile phones". BBC. 28 March 2008. Retrieved 16 June 2009.
- "Mobile Phone Usage Surges in Cuba". 9 February 2009. Retrieved 16 June 2009.
- Alberto Arce, Desmond Butler, Jack Gillum (3 April 2014). "U'S' secretly created 'Cuban Twitter' to stir unrest". Washington Post. Associated Press. Retrieved 6 April 2014.
- Parmy Olson (4 April 2014). "Why The U'S' Government's Fake 'Cuban Twitter' Service Failed". Forbes. Retrieved 6 April 2014.
- "Dismay at the European Union’s decision not to re-impose Cuba sanctions". Reporters Without Borders. 14 June 2006. Retrieved 7 December 2006.
- Access to Information and Intellectual Freedom in Cuba, American Library Association. Retrieved 10 August 2012
- Green, Eric (28 November 2006). "U.S. Lauds Press Freedom Advocates’ Criticism of Cuba". News From Washington (United States Government). Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- "10 Worst Countries to be a Blogger", Committee to Protect Journalists, 30 April 2009. Retrieved 10 August 2012
- "IAPA condemns inadequate health care for independent journalists jailed in Cuba". Inter American Press Association. 29 June 2007.