Children's Healthcare is a Legal Duty
|Rita Swan, President|
Children's Healthcare Is a Legal Duty (CHILD) is an American nonprofit membership organization that works to stop child abuse and neglect based on religious beliefs, cultural traditions, and quackery. CHILD opposes religious exemptions from child health and safety laws. These exemptions have been used as a defense in criminal cases when parents have withheld lifesaving medical care on religious grounds. These exemptions also have discouraged reporting and investigation of religion-based medical neglect of children and spawned many outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases and deaths. CHILD publicizes the ideological abuse and neglect of children, lobbies for equal protection laws for children, and files lawsuits and amicus curiae briefs in related cases.
CHILD was founded in 1983 by Rita and Douglas Swan after the death of their son, Matthew. When Matthew developed a high fever in 1977, several Christian Science practitioners, who claimed they were healing Matthew, persuaded the Swans not to seek medical treatment for him. After he had been ill for 12 days, the Swans did take Matthew to the hospital, but his illness had progressed too far and he died of meningitis.
According to the National Association of Counsel for Children, which gave an award to Rita Swan for her efforts, "Due in large part to CHILD's efforts, Colorado, Massachusetts, Maryland, South Dakota, Hawaii, and Oregon have removed laws which provided exemptions from prosecution to parents who fail to provide medical care for their sick children based on religion".
Rita and Douglas Swan founded CHILD as a legacy to their son, Matthew. In 1977 he became ill with bacterial meningitis. The Swans, Christian Scientists at the time, were persuaded by Christian Scientist practitioners – the religion's name for its spiritual healers – not to seek medical treatment for their son. When one of the practitioners said Matthew might have a broken bone, which Christian Scientists are allowed to go to a doctor for, the Swans took their baby to a hospital after he had been ill for 12 days, but his illness had progressed too far, and he died. Motivated by this tragedy, CHILD works to eliminate religious exemptions in child health and safety laws. Parents belonging to various religions, in particular Christian Science, have used these exemptions as legal defenses in criminal cases for failing to provide medical care for children who then died.
Following the death of their son, the Swans left the Christian Science Church, and in 1983, Rita Swan founded the nonprofit organization, Children's Healthcare is a Legal Duty (CHILD), and has worked "relentlessly" to publicize cases of religion-related child abuse and neglect. In 1998, Rita Swan and Seth Asser published a benchmark study in Pediatrics that analyzed 140 child deaths in which medical treatment was withheld. This study showed that 90% of these children would have survived with routine medical care.
In 1996 Congress added to the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act a provision that nothing in the act can "be construed as establishing a Federal requirement that a parent or legal guardian provide any medical service or treatment that is against the religious beliefs of the parent or legal guardian". CHILD has opposed this provision on several fronts. CHILD's work has led to the repeal of some or all religious exemptions to child neglect laws in Colorado, Massachusetts, Maryland, South Dakota, Hawaii, Oregon, Minnesota, Ohio, and Rhode Island. In 2009, CHILD lobbied successfully to remove provisions from the federal Affordable Care Act that would have provided government funding and mandated insurance coverage for faith healing that did not also include medical care.
Mission and activities
CHILD'S mission is to end child abuse and religious-based medical neglect, cultural practices, or pseudoscience through public education, research, and a limited amount of lobbying to support laws that protect children against maltreatment. The organization also files lawsuits and amicus curiae briefs in related court cases.
- Laws requiring medical care of children, including preventive and diagnostic measures, without exception for religious belief
- Reporting of child abuse and child neglect without religious exemption
- Licensing of child care facility, including those run by churches
- Ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
The Swans filed a wrongful death suit against the Christian Science Church in 1980, but it was dismissed on First Amendment grounds, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear their case on appeal. In 2000, CHILD sued the director of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (Children's Healthcare Is a Legal Duty, Inc. v. Min De Parle), over federal healthcare monies being directed to Christian Science facilities and others that provide no medical treatment. The suit, alleging a violation of the establishment clause, was dismissed with summary judgment; on appeal, the judgment was upheld, and the Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal.
Other legal cases include CHILD Inc. and Brown v. Deters challenging Ohio's religious defense to child endangerment and manslaughter (ORC 2919.22a) and CHILD Inc. v. Vladeck against the federal government's use of medicare and medicaid funds for Christian Science nursing.
Testimony before legislatures
- Oregon Senate Judiciary Committee, 26 April 2011
- Oregon House Judiciary Committee, 21 February 2011
- Wisconsin Assembly Committee on Children and Families, 17 March 2010
- Nebraska State Legislature, Health and Human Services Committee, 25 January 2007
- Iowa House Education Subcommittee, January 2006
- Maine Joint Standing Committee on Health and Human Services, May 2005
- Nebraska State Legislature, Education Committee, February 2005
- Rhode Island House Health, Education, and Welfare Committee, February 2004
- Missouri House Judiciary Committee, April 2003
- Colorado Senate Health, Environment, Children, and Families Committee, April 2001
- Maryland House Judiciary Committee, March 2001
- Colorado House Criminal Justice Committee, February 2001
- Oregon House Criminal Law Committee, March 1999
- South Dakota House and Senate Health and Human Services Committees, February 1998
- Michigan House Judiciary Committee, February 1997
- U. S. Senate Labor and Human Resources staff briefing, June 1995
- Minnesota House Judiciary Committee, March 1994
- Minnesota House Judiciary Committee, December 1991
- Minnesota Senate Judiciary Committee, March 1991
- South Dakota House State Affairs Committee, January 1990
- California Assembly Committee on Public Safety, October 1989
- Ohio House Children and Youth Committee, March 1989
- Ohio House Children and Youth Subcommittee, March 1985
- North Dakota House of Representatives, January 1979
- Swan, Rita (Winter 2009–2010), "Matthew, you cannot be sick", The Dublin Review, Dublin, Ireland: Brendan Barrington, no. 37, pp. 43–69, ISSN 1393-998X, archived from the original on 2013-08-01, retrieved 2013-05-07
- Swan, Rita (2010). The Last Strawberry. Dublin: Hag's Head Press. ISBN 9780955126468.
- Swan, Rita (2010). "Prayer-fee mandates removed from federal health care bills". ICSA Today. International Cultic Studies Association. 1 (2): 18–21. ISSN 2154-820X. Archived from the original on 2013-06-29.
- Swan, Rita (2011). "Chapter 63: Religion and Child Neglect". In Jenny, Carole (ed.). Child Abuse and Neglect: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Evidence (1st ed.). St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Health Sciences. pp. 599–604. ISBN 978-1-4160-6393-3.
- Swan, Rita (2007). "Medical Neglect Related to Religion and Culture". In Jackson, Nicky Ali (ed.). Encyclopedia of Domestic Violence. New York: Routledge Press. pp. 475–483. ISBN 9780203942215.
- Swan, Rita. "Religious Attitudes Toward Corporal Punishment". Ibid. pp. 205–208.
- Swan, Rita (November–December 2000). "Religion-based neglect: Pervasive, deadly...and legal?". The Humanist. American Humanist Association: 11–16. ISSN 0018-7399. Archived from the original on 2013-10-26. Retrieved 2013-05-07.
- Swan, R. (1998), "On statutes depriving a class of children of rights to medical care: Can this discrimination be litigated?", Quinnipiac Health Law Journal, Quinnipiac University, School of Law, 2 (1): 73–95, OCLC 36163682
- Swan, R. (Winter 1998–1999). "Letting children die for the faith". Free Inquiry. Council for Secular Humanism. 19 (1): 6–7. ISSN 0272-0701. PMID 11657679.
- "Religion-based medical neglect and corporal punishment must not be tolerated". The APSAC Advisor. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. 11: 2–3. Spring 1998. ISSN 1088-3819.
- Swan, R. (1997). "Children, medicine, religion, and the law". Advances in Pediatrics. Mosby: Elsevier. 44: 491–543. ISSN 0065-3101. PMID 9265980.
- "Discrimination de jure: Religious exemptions for medical neglect". The APSAC Advisor. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. 7: 35–8. Winter 1994. ISSN 1088-3819.
- "Public policy: Religious exemptions". The Brown University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter. John Wiley & Sons: 2–3. January 1993. ISSN 1058-1073.
- Swan, Rita (Spring 1987). "The law should protect all children". Journal of Christian Nursing. Wolters Kluwer: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins. 4 (2): 40. doi:10.1097/00005217-198704020-00016. ISSN 0743-2550. PMID 3644911.
- Swan, Rita (29 December 1983). "Faith healing, Christian Science, and the medical care of children". New England Journal of Medicine. Massachusetts Medical Society. 309 (26): 1639–41. doi:10.1056/NEJM198312293092610. ISSN 0028-4793. PMID 6358892.
- American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP): 2012 President's Certificate for Outstanding Service awarded to Rita Swan, MA, PhD for efforts in children's rights to medical care and decades of work with the AAP on these issues.
- Iowa Chapter of the Methodist Federation for Social Action: 6 June 2010 Outstanding Social Justice Work Award.
- Omicron Delta Kappa chapter at Morningside College: 27 April 2003 Honoris Causa Award.
- National Association of Counsel for Children (NACC): 2001 Outstanding Legal Advocacy Award received by Rita Swan, MA, PhD for working to protect children from religious-based medical neglect through policy advocacy and amicus curiae work.
- Oregon Pediatric Society: 17 June 2000 Child Advocacy Service Award.
- Oregon Peace Officers Association Child Abuse and Sex Crimes Investigators: 2 November 1999 Award for Child Advocacy.
- The Giraffe Heroes Project: 12 January 1993 Award for Risk-Taking and Service.
- Sioux City Human Rights Commission: 2 May 1991 Human Rights Service Award.
- South Dakota Chapter of the AAP: 14 September 1990 Child Advocacy Service Award.
- "Some Outbreaks of Vaccine-preventable Disease in Groups with Religious or Philosophical Exemptions to Vaccination", CHILD website, CHILD, retrieved 30 April 2013.
- Tilkin, Dan (KATU News); Murad, Mike (KBOI News, Idaho) (20 May 2011). "Man speaks out about child deaths in NW faith-healing church" (TV news broadcast). Portland, OR: Fisher Communications, Inc. KATU. Retrieved 30 April 2013.
- Bell, Bonnie (31 March 1980), "Their baby's death provokes Doug and Rita Swan to a holy war on Christian Science", People, ISSN 0093-7673
- Castle, Marie Alena, "No legal protection for kids in faith-healing families: Why most states sanction religion-based child sacrifice", Atheists for Human Rights, archived from the original on 31 January 2013, retrieved 30 January 2013
- "Children's Law News" (PDF). The Guardian. National Association of Counsel for Children. 23 (3): 15. 2001. Retrieved 4 April 2013.
- Munns, Roger (2 June 1996). "Mom fights prayer that excludes medicine". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 22 April 2013.
- Fraser, Caroline (1999), God's Perfect Child: Living and Dying in the Christian Science Church, New York: Henry Holt and Company, pp. 295–298, ISBN 0805044302, OCLC 473250863
- Fraser, 1999, pp. 278–291.
- Larabee, Mark (30 November 1998), "Parents turn grief into a mission: Change the laws", The Oregonian, Advance Publications, ISSN 8750-1317
- Fraser, Caroline (April 1995), "Suffering children and the Christian Science Church", The Atlantic, ISSN 1072-7825, retrieved 18 April 2013
- Asser, S.M.; Swan, R. (April 1998). "Child fatalities from religion-motivated medical neglect". Pediatrics. American Academy of Pediatrics. 101 (4 Pt 1): 625–9. doi:10.1542/peds.101.4.625. ISSN 0031-4005. PMID 9521945. S2CID 169037.
- Gallegos, Alicia (19 September 2011). "Miracle vs. medicine: When faith puts care at risk". American Medical News. American Medical Association. ISSN 0098-7484. Retrieved 17 April 2013.
- Title 42-The Public Health And Welfare, Chapter 67-Child Abuse Prevention And Treatment And Adoption Reform, Subchapter I-General Program, Sec. 5106i-Rule Of Construction 42 U.S.C. § 5106i
- "Policy & Legal". CHILD website. CHILD. Retrieved 30 April 2013.
- The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub.L. 111–148
- "Victory! Christian Science provision not in merged health care reform bill." (News Release), Freedom From Religion Foundation, 20 November 2009,
Faith-healing mandate nixed from Senate health care reform bill
- "CHILD About", CHILD website, CHILD, retrieved 4 April 2013
- Brown v. Laitner, 435 N.W.2d 1, 432 Mich. 861 (1989).
- CHILD Inc. v. Min De Parle Archived 2010-05-17 at the Wayback Machine 212 F.3d 1084 (8th Cir. 2000); No. 98-3521 U. S. Court Of Appeals for the 8th Circuit Submitted: 18 October 1999. Filed: 1 May 2000. Retrieved from Public.Resource.Org 17 April 2013.
- Harris, B. (2010). "Veiled in textual neutrality: Is that enough? A candid reexamination of the constitutionality of section 4454 of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997" (PDF). Alabama Law Review. 61 (2): 401–402. Retrieved 4 April 2013.
- CHILD Inc. and Brown v. Deters Archived 2010-05-17 at the Wayback Machine 92 F.3d 1412. No. 95-3850. U. S. Court Of Appeals, 6th Circuit. Argued 4 March 1996. Decided 5 August 1996. Rehearing And Suggestion For Rehearing En Banc Denied 20 September 1996. Retrieved from Public.Resource.Org 17 April 2013.
- CHILD Inc. v. Vladeck 938 F.Supp. 1466 (1996) No. 3-96-63. U. S. Dist. Court, D. MN, 3rd Div. 7 August 1996. Retrieved from Google Scholar 17 April 2013.
- Oregon Senate Committee on the Judiciary Minutes 26 April 2011. 2. Retrieved 18 April 2013
- Oregon House Committee on the Judiciary Minutes 21 February 2011. 2. Retrieved 18 April 2013
- Nebraska State Legislature, Health and Human Services Committee 25 January 2007 transcript. Archived 9 June 2015 at the Wayback Machine 11-13. Retrieved 18 April 2013
- Legislative Research Council, South Dakota Legislature. "Minutes 13 February 1998, Senate Health and Human Services Committee". Retrieved 22 April 2013
- Legislative Research Council, South Dakota Legislature. "Minutes 6 February 1998, House Health and Human Services Committee". Retrieved 22 April 2013
- "Rita Swan, PhD Fellow Board of Directors", Institute for Science in Medicine website, Institute for Science in Medicine, retrieved 23 April 2013
- "AAP President recognizes Dr. Swan for work on children's equal rights to health care", AAP News, American Academy of Pediatrics, 33 (5), May 2012
- "2010 Social action award recipients" (PDF). Social Questions Bulletin. Iowa Chapter Methodist Federation for Social Action. June 2010. p. 3. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 January 2011. Retrieved 17 April 2013.
- "The Giraffe Heroes Database: Swan, Rita". The Giraffe Heroes Project. Archived from the original on 26 February 2014. Retrieved 17 April 2013.
- Stamm, Dan (22 April 2013). "Second child death for convicted faith-healing couple". NBC10 Television News Website. NBCUniversal Media, LLC.
- Anderson, Madeline (25 March 2013). "Marathon Co. faith healing case: 5 years after Kara Neumann's death". WSAW TV 7 News website. Gray Television, Inc.
- "Rita Swan and protecting children from religious exemptions" (blog). Free Thinking. Center for Inquiry. 9 March 2012.
- Atwood, Kimball (16 October 2009). "Health care bills: More mischief in Washington" (blog). Science Based Medicine.
- Vanegeren, Jessica (17 November 2009). "Dueling bills take aim at religious exemption". The Capital Times. Madison, Wisconsin.
- Margolick, David (6 August 1990). "In child deaths, a test for Christian Science". The New York Times.