Chillul Hashem

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

In Judaism, a Chillul Hashem (Hebrew: חילול השם‎) is an act that violates the prohibition in the Torah of desecrating (chillul) the name (Hashem) of God. A Chillul Hashem occurs when a Jew acts immorally while in the presence of others, either Jews or Gentiles. Since Judaism believes that Jews are representatives of God and His moral code, when a Jew acts in a shameful manner, s/he has represented God poorly, thus desecrating His name. Chillul Hashem is the opposite of a Kiddush Hashem ("sanctification of God's name") — the act of bringing honor, respect, and glory to God's name. Kiddush Hashem is often used to mean religious martyrdom. The concept of Chillul Hashem is prevalent in the Bible, and is often referenced by modern-day Jews as a reason to uphold the highest moral standard, especially as it pertains to the State of Israel.

Biblical source of the prohibition[edit]

There are four references to Chillul Hashem in the Torah (Lev. 18:21, ibid. 19:12, ibid. 22:2, ibid. 22:32). The general prohibition of desecrating God’s name is stated most explicitly in Leviticus: “And you shall not desecrate My Holy name; and I shall be sanctified in the midst of the Children of Israel. I am the Lord who sanctifies you (Lev. 22:32).” In addition to the references in the Torah, Chillul Hashem is mentioned extensively in Prophets and Writings, especially in the Book Ezekiel.[1] The fact that it appears so frequently throughout the Hebrew Bible demonstrates its centrality and severity. A notable example is Ezekiel 36:20–24 in which the prophet laments the Jewish Exile to Babylonia and claims that the reality of exile — specifically, the Jewish people living outside their ancestral homeland — is itself a desecration of God’s name. The obligation to refrain from desecration of Hashem is one of the 613 commandments in rabbinical enumeration.[2]

Severity of the prohibition[edit]

In general, if a Jew is faced with the decision to violate a law in the Torah or to lose their life, the Torah mandates that s/he violate the prohibition rather than give up his/her life.[3] There are three major exceptions to this rule:

  1. If the prohibition is particularly severe (e.g. murder, idolatry, adultery), then the person must give up his/her life rather than violate the prohibition. The most famous example of this in the Talmud is the story of the woman with seven sons.
  2. If the person is being forced to violate a prohibition in front of ten other people, the Talmud states that even the smallest commandment may not be violated.
  3. If the person is faced with the choice of violating a prohibition — even a less severe one — that is currently outlawed by the foreign power, then s/he must give up his life.[4]

The explanation of the latter two exceptions is that a public sin or a sin done in reverence to a governmental decree constitutes a Chillul Hashem. The prohibition of desecrating God’s Name is so severe that a Jew is required to die rather than violate the sin.[5] Some Rishonim (medieval commentaries) maintain that the requirement to give up one’s life under these circumstances only applies when the individual is being called upon to actively commit a sin. Thus, if one would remain still and allow himself to be used as a projectile to kill another person rather than give up his own life, it would be permissible.[6]

A Chillul Hashem can also occur even if a technical prohibition has not been violated. For example, if a Jewish leader, or someone perceived to be righteous is seen acting improperly, his/her actions constitute a Chillul Hashem.[2] Maimonides says that if a scholarly, righteous Jew gets drunk in front of a less learned Jew, it constitutes a Chillul Hashem. Thus, any time a Torah scholar or Rabbi acts improperly in front of others, they have committed a Chillul Hashem.[7]

Contemporary examples[edit]

By acting as an upstanding and righteous people, and by following the commandments of the Torah, Jews seek to sanctify God’s name and fulfill the mandate of being an “Ohr La’goyim” — a light unto the nations (Isaiah 43:10). As such, the concepts of Kiddush Hashem and avoiding Chillul Hashem are often invoked by Orthodox Jews as a reminder to act in an upstanding manner.[8]

The goal of sanctifying God’s name is commonly mentioned with reference to the State of Israel.[9] Because Ezekiel calls the Jewish exile a desecration of God’s name, Religious Zionists believe that one of the main purposes of the State of Israel is to reverse that state of exile, and thereby bring about a sanctification of God’s name. To accomplish this, they believe that Israel, and particularly the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), ought to lead the world by example by acting in the most humanitarian way possible.[9]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Online Bible - Search". Retrieved 2017-04-28. 
  2. ^ a b The Book of Education (Sefer HaChinuch) Mitzvah 295. 
  3. ^ Talmud Bavli: Tractate Sanhedrin folio 74a. 
  4. ^ Talmud Bavli: Tractate Sanhedrin folio 74b. 
  5. ^ Rashi ibid.; Mishneh Torah: Yesodei Hatorah 5:1. 
  6. ^ Tosafot tractate Sanhedrin ibid.; Rosh ibid. 
  7. ^ Mishneh Torah: Deot 5:13. 
  8. ^ "Defining a Chilul Hashem". 
  9. ^ a b "Kiddush Hashem: Israel's Mission" (PDF).