Christianity Is Stupid

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
"Christianity Is Stupid"
Song by Negativland from the album Escape from Noise
Released 1987 (1987)
Length 3:54
Label SST Records

"Christianity Is Stupid" is a song from Negativland's 1987 concept album, Escape from Noise.[1] In the song, Negativland rearranges words and phrases to form a different meaning. They sampled phrases from a sermon by Rev. Estus Pirkle (from his 1968 LP, If Footmen Tire You, What Will Horses Do?,[2] itself later adapted into a film of the same name).[3] Pirkle's narrative included an imagined visit to the U.S. under Communism where public loudspeakers constantly proclaim "Christianity is stupid! Communism is good! Give up!" These phrases were taken out of context and mixed with appropriately march-like heavy metal music and various other sound effects.

In 2004, the song was made into a video entitled "The Mashin' of the Christ" that sampled many Jesus Christ-topic films and footage from Marxist-Leninist countries.[4]

Fake press release[edit]

When their 1987 album, Escape From Noise, proved to be more successful than they expected, Negativland were expected to do a national tour. However, their record company, SST, could not provide sufficient funds.[citation needed] To explain the cancelled tour, Negativland issued a fake press release saying that the song "Christianity Is Stupid" had played a role in the David Brom murders.[5] The press release implied that Brom had listened to Negativland's song "Christianity Is Stupid" before the fatal quarrel with his religious parents.[6] The group claimed they were "advised by Federal Official Dick Jordan not to leave town pending an investigation into the Brom murders".[3] Brom, 16 at the time, had killed his family with an axe. Negativland's press release was picked up by San Francisco Bay Area media, including CBS News. Negativland recorded much of the news about their supposed influence on Brom, and in 1989 worked this material into another album called Helter Stupid.[7] Eventually, Negativland exposed their own hoax during an NPR interview on the subject.

In reality, there was no official named "Dick Jordan", and Brom did not possess any Negativland music. Nevertheless, pundits and journalists took the press release at face value, and the hoax received widespread media coverage.[8] Negativland encouraged the spread of the story by steadfastly refusing further comment, supposedly on the advice of their attorney "Hal Stakke", another fictional person invented by the band. Much of this media coverage was negative, and band member Richard Lyons' home in Oakland, California was pelted with rocks by an unknown vandal.[6] The resulting media craze, stemming from journalists neglecting to fact-check, is lampooned in the title track of their 1989 album, Helter Stupid, whose insert also includes background information behind the band's prank.[9][10]


  1. ^ Buckley, Peter (2003). The Rough Guide To Rock (3 ed.). Rough Guides. p. 713. ISBN 1-84353-105-4. 
  2. ^
  3. ^ a b Eric Dregni; Mark Moran; Mark Sceurman (2006). Weird Minnesota. Sterling. p. 24. ISBN 1-4027-3908-7. 
  4. ^ "Negativland—Our Favorite Things". CMJ New Music Monthly: 51. December 2007. ISSN 1074-6978. 
  5. ^ Bogdanov, Vladimir (2001). All music guide to electronica: the definitive guide to electronic music (4 ed.). Backbeat Books. ISBN 0-87930-628-9. 
  6. ^ a b PRANKS! – Pullout – Music Quarterly – The Stranger, Seattle's Only Newspaper
  7. ^ McLeod, Kembrew (2005). Freedom of expression®: resistance and repression in the age of intellectual property. University of Minnesota Press. pp. 117–118. ISBN 0-8166-5031-4. 
  8. ^ Reviews – Escape From Noise
  9. ^ Thomas Bey William Bailey, MicroBionic: Radical Electronic Music and Sound Art in the 21st Century, p. 153-180.
  10. ^ Guerrilla culture-jam (Metro Times Detroit)