|Part of a series on|
|History of religions|
|Part of a series on|
Christianization or Christianisation is to make Christian; to imbue with Christian principles; to become Christian. It can apply to the conversion of an individual, a practice, a place or a whole society. It began in the Roman Empire, continued through the Middle Ages in Europe, and in the twenty-first century has spread around the globe.
Historically, there are observable stages in the process of Christianization beginning with 1) the mission period and individual conversion, followed by 2) consolidation and community building, and 3) the exchange of beliefs and sacred spaces sometimes referred to as syncretism. Having observable stages does not indicate Christianization has maintained one consistent approach to conversion throughout its long history. Different periods and places have produced a variety of methods, motives and means.
The first countries to make Christianity their state religion were Armenia, Georgia, Ethiopia and Eritrea in the fourth century. By the end of the fifth and beginning of the sixth century, the majority of the Roman Empire had been converted. Christian empire was finally created under the Eastern Emperor Justinian the first, when Ancient Christianity begins its end, and Christianity transforms into its eclectic medieval forms by the 800's.
Medieval Christianization began in Europe in the 8th and 9th centuries. A new region of Europe that later became known as Eastern Central Europe was formed, though not without some bloodshed, since throughout central and eastern Europe, Christianization and political centralization went hand in hand. The rulers of Bulgaria, Bohemia (which became Czechoslovakia), the Serbs and the Croats, along with Hungary, and Poland, voluntarily joined the Western, Latin church, sometimes pressuring their people to follow. The Christianization of the Kievan Rus', the ancestors of Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine, began in the tenth century following the path of Byzantine Christianity and becoming a true state church with state control of religion and some coercion.
The two centuries around the turn of the first millennium brought Europe's most significant Christianization of the Middle Ages. What had been two dangerous and aggressive enemies, (the Scandinavian Vikings on the northern borders, and the Hungarians in the east), voluntarily adopted Christianity and founded kingdoms that sought a place among the European states. The Northern Crusades, from 1147 to 1316, form a unique chapter in Christianization. They were not for the reclamation of lost territory, nor were they a defense against invasive Muslims; instead, they were largely political, led by local princes against their own enemies, for their own gain, and conversion by these princes was almost always a result of armed conquest. Colonialism was both supported and opposed by missionaries. Modern Christianization has become a global phenomenon.
The first stage of Christianization begins when personal conversions take place. For nations, this has historically been associated with missions and missionaries, and is therefore called the mission period.
The second stage is consolidation. The convert's way of life begins to transform. Their world out-look changes and former customs, such as burial customs, are changed to reflect Christian practices. On a societal basis, Christian communities form; the first dedicated church structures are built; monasteries and dioceses are established; and the first parishes are created. During this stage, Christianization establishes schools and spreads education, translates Christian writings to local languages, often developing a script to do so, thereby creating the first literature of what had been a pre-literate culture.
The third step in the process of Christianization involves the interchange that occurs when two cultural systems interconnect. Christianization has never been a one-way process.[note 1] In some cases the survival of local custom was encouraged by Christian missionaries, while other aspects of traditional religion survived despite the opposition of the missionaries.
According to archaeologist Anna Collar, when groups of people with different ways of life come into contact with each other, they naturally exchange ideas and practices. This is sometimes referred to as syncretism, but syncretism is a controversial concept, so instead, many scholars use the terms inculturation and acculturation instead. Anthropologist Aylward Shorter defines inculturation as the "ongoing dialogue" between Christian teachings and local culture. The church adapts itself to a particular local cultural context just as local culture and places are also adapted to the church. This has at times involved appropriation, removal and/or redesignation of aspects of native religion and former sacred spaces allowing them to find a place in the new religious system.
Variations in the results, according to Clark, are based largely on local ethnic composition, political structure and the local locus of power. Ancient Germanic societies tended to be communal by nature rather than oriented around individuality, and loyalty to the king meant the conversion of the ruler was generally followed by the mass conversion of his subjects. Clark has also written that different methods were used by different individual missionaries contributing to differing results.
Anthropologist Jerry E. Clark writes: "Acculturation has been defined as the changes that occur in one or both cultures when two different cultures come in contact. In the case of missionaries and the American Indians, the process of acculturation was purposely one-sided." Recent anthropological work on acculturation has led contemporary scholars to write that its traditional definition can only be used when both societies involved in exchange have some autonomy. In the case of a loss of political autonomy, as happened with native Americans, directed or forced acculturation produces an alternative definition. Robert F. Berkhofer references E. A. Hobble's definition as saying that acculturation under directed contact is "the process of interaction between two societies by which the culture of the society in subordinate position is drastically modified to conform to the culture of the dominant society."
History connects Christianization with colonialism, especially but not limited to the New World and other regions subject to settler colonialism. History also connects Christianization with opposition to colonialism. African historian Lamin Sanneh writes that there is an equal amount of evidence of both missionary support and missionary opposition to colonialism through "protest and resistance both in the church and in politics".
"Despite their role as allies of the empire, missions also developed the vernacular that inspired sentiments of national identity and thus undercut Christianity's identification with colonial rule".
Integration happened when an individual engaged both their heritage culture and the larger society; assimilation or separation occurred when an individual became oriented exclusively to one or the other culture. Orientation to neither culture is marginalization. In the Late Middle Ages, and later colonialism, the mixture of religion with politics led to some instances of forced conversion by the sword, racialism and the marginalization of entire groups.
Ancient (Ante-Nicaean) Christianity (1st to 3rd centuries)
Christianization began in the Roman Empire in Jerusalem around 30–40 AD, spreading outward quickly. The Church in Rome was founded by Peter and Paul in the 1st century. There is agreement among twenty-first century scholars that Christianization of the Roman Empire in its first three centuries did not happen by imposition. Christianization of this period was the cumulative result of multiple individual decisions and behaviors.
While enduring three centuries of on again - off again persecution, from differing levels of government ranging from local to imperial, Christianity had remained 'self-organized' and without central authority. In this manner, it reached an important threshold of success between 150 and 250, when it moved from less than 50,000 adherents to over a million, and became self-sustaining and able to generate enough further growth that there was no longer a viable means of stopping it. Scholars agree there was a significant rise in the absolute number of Christians in the third century.
Early Christian communities were highly inclusive in terms of social stratification and other social categories. Many scholars have seen this inclusivity as the primary reason for Christianization's early success. The Apostolic Decree helped to establish Ancient Christianity as unhindered by either ethnic or geographical ties.[note 2] Christianity was experienced as a new start, and was open to both men and women, rich and poor. Baptism was free. There were no fees, and it was intellectually egalitarian, making philosophy and ethics available to ordinary people including those who might have lacked literacy. Heterogeneity characterized the groups formed by Paul the Apostle, and the role of women was much greater than in any of the forms of Judaism or paganism in existence at the time.
Ante-Nicaean Christianity was also highly exclusive. Believing was the crucial and defining characteristic that set a "high boundary" that strongly excluded the "unbeliever". Keith Hopkins asserts: "It is this exclusivism, idealized or practiced, which marks Christianity off from most other religious groups in the ancient world". The early Christian had exacting moral standards that included avoiding contact with those that were seen as still "in bondage to the Evil One": (2 Corinthians 6:1-18; 1 John 2: 15-18; Revelation 18: 4; II Clement 6; Epistle of Barnabas, 1920). In Daniel Praet's view, the exclusivity of Christian monotheism formed an important part of its success, enabling it to maintain its independence in a society that syncretized religion.
Christian monasticism emerged in the third century, and monks soon became crucial to the process of Christianization. Their numbers grew such that, "by the fifth century, monasticism had become a dominant force impacting all areas of society".
Armenia, Georgia, Ethiopia and Eritrea
In 301, Armenia became the first kingdom in history to adopt Christianity as an official state religion. The transformations taking place in these centuries of the Roman Empire had been slower to catch on in Caucasia. Indigenous writing did not begin until the fifth century, there was an absence of large cities, and many institutions such as monasticism did not exist in Caucasia until the seventh century. Scholarly consensus places the Christianization of the Armenian and Georgian elites in the first half of the fourth century, although Armenian tradition says Christianization began in the first century through the Apostles Thaddeus and Bartholomew. This is said to have eventually led to the conversion of the Arsacid family, (the royal house of Armenia), through St. Gregory the Illuminator in the early fourth century.
Christianization took many generations and was not a uniform process. Robert Thomson writes that it was not the officially established hierarchy of the church that spread Christianity in Armenia. "It was the unorganized activity of wandering holy men that brought about the Christianization of the populace at large". The most significant stage in this process was the development of a script for the native tongue.
Scholars do not agree on the exact date of Christianization of Georgia, but most assert the early 4th century when Mirian III of the Kingdom of Iberia (known locally as Kartli) adopted Christianity. According to medieval Georgian Chronicles, Christianization began with Andrew the Apostle and culminated in the evangelization of Iberia through the efforts of a captive woman known in Iberian tradition as Saint Nino in the fourth century. Fifth, 8th, and 12th century accounts of the conversion of Georgia reveal how pre-Christian practices were taken up and reinterpreted by Christian narrators.
In 325, the Kingdom of Aksum (Modern Ethiopia and Eritrea) became the second country to declare Christianity as its official state religion.
Late antiquity (4th–5th centuries)
Peter Brown has written that, "it would be profoundly misleading" to claim that the cultural and social changes that took place in Late Antiquity reflected "in any way" a process of Christianization. Instead, the "flowering of a vigorous public culture that polytheists, Jews and Christians alike could share... [that] could be described as Christian "only in the narrowest sense" developed. It is true that Christianity made sure blood sacrifice played no part in that culture, but the sheer success and unusual stability of the Constantinian and post-Constantinian state also ensured that "the edges of potential conflict were blurred... It would be wrong to look for further signs of Christianization at this time. It is impossible to speak of a Christian empire as existing before Justinian". 
Favoritism and hostility
The Christianization of the Roman Empire is frequently divided by scholars into the two phases of before and after the conversion of Constantine in 312.[note 3] According to Harold A. Drake, Constantine's official imperial religious policies did not stem from faith as much as they stemmed from his duty as Emperor to maintain peace in the empire. Drake asserts that, since Constantine's reign followed Diocletian's failure to enforce a particular religious view, Constantine was able to observe that coercion had not produced peace.
Contemporary scholars are in general agreement that Constantine did not support the suppression of paganism by force. He never engaged in a purge, there were no pagan martyrs during his reign. Pagans remained in important positions at his court. Constantine ruled for 31 years and never outlawed paganism. A few authors suggest that "true Christian sentiment" might have motivated Constantine, since he held the conviction that, in the realm of faith, only freedom mattered.[note 4]
Making the adoption of Christianity beneficial was Constantine's primary approach to religion, and imperial favor was important to successful Christianization over the next century. However, Constantine must have written the laws that threatened and menaced pagans who continued to practice sacrifice. There is no evidence of any of the horrific punishments ever being enacted. There is no record of anyone being executed for violating religious laws before Tiberius II Constantine at the end of the sixth century (574–582). Still, classicist Scott Bradbury notes that the complete disappearance of public sacrifice by the mid-fourth century "in many towns and cities must be attributed to the atmosphere created by imperial and episcopal hostility".[note 5]
Paganism did not end when public sacrifice did. Brown explains that polytheists were accustomed to offering prayers to the gods in many ways and places that did not include sacrifice, that pollution was only associated with sacrifice, and that the ban on sacrifice had fixed boundaries and limits. Paganism thus remained widespread into the early fifth century continuing in parts of the empire into the seventh and beyond.
Late Antiquity from the third to the sixth centuries was the era of the development of the great Christian narrative, an interpretatio Christiana of the history of humankind. In this reconstruction of the past, Christian writers built on preceding tradition, creating competing chronologies and alternative histories.
In the early fourth century, Eusebius wrote Chronici canones. In it, he developed an elaborate synchronistic chronology reinterpreting the Greco-Roman past to reflect a Christian perspective.
In the early fifth century Orosius wrote Historiae adversus paganos in response to the charge that the Roman Empire was in misery and ruins because it had converted to Christianity and neglected the old gods. Maijastina Kahlos explains that, "In order to refute these claims, Orosius reviewed the entire history of Rome, demonstrating that the alleged glorious past of the Romans in fact consisted of war, despair and suffering".
Theodosius I and orthodoxy
In the centuries following his death, Theodosius I gained a reputation as the emperor who crushed paganism in order to establish Nicene Christianity as the one official religion of the empire. Modern historians no longer see this as actual history, but instead, see it as a later interpretation of history – a rewriting of history - by Christian writers.
Nearly all the sources available on Theodosius are ecclesiastical histories that are highly colored and carefully curated for public reading. Beginning with contemporaries like the bishop Ambrose, and followed in the next century by church historians such as Theodoret, these histories focus on Theodosius' impact on the church as uniformly positive, orthodox and anti-pagan, frequently going beyond admiration into panegyric and hagiography. Cameron explains that, since Theodosius's predecessors Constantine, Constantius, and Valens had all been semi-Arians, it fell to the orthodox Theodosius to receive from Christian literary tradition most of the credit for the final triumph of Christianity. [note 6]
Theodosius did champion Christian orthodoxy, and the majority of the laws he wrote were intended to eliminate heresies and promote unity within Christianity. Scholars say there is little, if any, evidence that Theodosius I ever pursued an active policy against the traditional cults.
In 380, he issued the Edict of Thessalonica to the people of Constantinople. It was addressed to Arian Christians, granted Christians no favors or advantages over other religions, and it is clear from mandates issued in the years after 380, that Theodosius had not intended it as a requirement for pagans or Jews to convert to Christianity. Hungarian legal scholar Pál Sáry explains that, "In 393, the emperor was gravely disturbed that the Jewish assemblies had been forbidden in certain places. For this reason, he stated with emphasis that the sect of the Jews was forbidden by no law".[note 7]
It has long been an accepted axiom that a universal ban on paganism, and the establishment of Christianity as the singular religion of the empire, can be implied from Theodosius' later laws such as that issued in November 392.[note 8] This law was only sent to Rufinus in the East; it describes and bans all types of private domestic sacrifice, which were thought to have "slipped out from under public control"; it bans magic used for divining the future from such sacrifices, and any idolatry associated with those sacrifices. It makes no mention of Christianity at all. Sozomen, the Constantinopolitan lawyer, wrote a history of the church around 443 where he evaluates the law of 392 as having had only minor significance at the time it was issued.[note 9]
During the reign of Theodosius, pagans were continuously appointed to prominent positions and pagan aristocrats remained in high offices. Theodosius allowed pagan practices that did not involve sacrifice to be performed publicly and temples to remain open.[note 10] In his 2020 biography of Theodosius, Mark Hebblewhite concludes that Theodosius never saw himself, or advertised himself, as a destroyer of the old cults. The emperor's efforts at Christianization were "targeted, tactical, and nuanced".
According to H. A. Drake, Christians worried about the validity of coerced faith and resisted such aggressive actions for centuries. Tertullian held that 'the free exercise of religious choice was a tenet of both man made and natural law', and that religion was 'something to be taken up voluntarily, not under duress". In Peter Garnsey's view, "Christians were the only group in antiquity to enunciate conditions for practicing religious toleration as a principle, rather than as an expedient".
In the fourth century, a council of Spanish Bishops meeting in Elvira on the coast of Spain, determined that Christians who died in attacks on idol temples should not be received as martyrs. The bishops wrote that they took this stand of disapproval because "such actions cannot be found in the Gospels, nor were they ever undertaken by the Apostles".
Drake suggests this stands as testimony to the tradition established in early Christianity which favored and operated toward peace, moderation, and conciliation. "It was a tradition that held true belief could not be compelled for the simple reason that God could tell the difference between voluntary and coerced worship". Peter Brown has written that,
It would be a full two centuries before Justinian would envisage the compulsory baptism of remaining polytheists, and a further century until Heraclius and the Visigothic kings of Spain would attempt to baptize the Jews. In the fourth century, such ambitious schemes were impossible.
There is no evidence to indicate that conversion of pagans through force was an accepted method of Christianization at any point in Late Antiquity; all uses of imperial force concerning religion were aimed at Christian heretics such as the Donatists and the Manichaeans.[note 11] Augustine, who advocated coercion for heretics, did not do so for the pagans or the Jews of his era, and the distinction between heretical Christians and non-believers continued to be made up to and through Aquinas in the thirteenth century.
Before the fifth century, there were isolated local incidents of anti-Jewish violence, and there were legislative pressures against specific pagan practices, but according to historians of forced conversion Mercedes García-Arenal and Yonatan Glazer-Eytan, it is only with the legislation introduced during the seventh century Visigothic period that a different view of the use of coercion or force began to develop in Spain.[note 12]
The earliest references to the Christianization of the Germanic peoples are in the writings of Irenaeus (130–202 ), Origen (185-253), and Tertullian (Adv. Jud. VII) (155–220). Athanasius omits Germany from his list of Christianized peoples, but that is possibly because, by the 4th century, many from the Eastern Germanic tribes, notably the Goths, had adopted Arianism. Yet Eusebius who supported Bishop Arian also omits them without saying why. Noel Lenski writes that the emperor Valens offered encouragement rather than active sponsorship of Christianization beyond Roman borders.
Tacitus is an important early source describing the nature of German religion, and their understanding of the function of a king, as facilitating Christianization. Conversion of the West and East Germanic tribes sometimes took place "top to bottom" in the sense that missionaries aimed at converting Germanic nobility first. A king had divine lineage as a descendent of Woden. Ties of fealty between German kings and their followers often rested on the agreement of loyalty for reward; the concerns of these early societies were communal, not individual; this combination produced mass conversions of entire tribes following their king, trusting him to share the rewards of conversion with them accordingly. Afterwards, their societies began a gradual process of Christianization that took centuries, with some traces of earlier beliefs remaining.
- In 341, Romanian born Ulfila (Wulfilas, 311–383) became a bishop and was sent to instruct the Gothic Christians living in Gothia in the province of Dacia. Ulfilas is traditionally credited with the voluntary conversion of the Goths between 369 and 372.
- The Vandals converted to Arian Christianity shortly before they left Spain for northern Africa in 429.
- Clovis I converted to Catholicism sometime around 498, extending his kingdom into most of Gaul (France) and large parts of what is now modern Germany.
- The Ostrogothic kingdom, which included all of Italy and parts of the Balkans, began in 493 with the killing of Odoacer by Theodoric. They converted to Arianism.
- Christianization of the central Balkans is documented at the end of the 4th century, where Nicetas the Bishop of Remesiana brought the gospel to "those mountain wolves", the Bessi.
- The Langobardic kingdom, which covered most of Italy, began in 568, becoming Arian shortly after the conversion of Agilulf in 607. Most scholars assert that the Lombards, who had lived in Pannonia and along the Elbe river, converted to Christianity when they moved to Italy in 568, since it was thought they had little to do with the empire before then. According to the Greek scholar Procopius (500-565), the Lombards had "occupied a Roman province for 40 years before moving into Italy". It is now thought that the Lombards first adopted Christianity while still in Pannonia. Procopius writes that, by the time the Lombards moved into Italy, "they appear to have had some familiarity already with both Christianity and some elements of Roman administrative culture".[note 13]
In all these cases, Christianization meant "the Germanic conquerors lost their native languages. In the remaining parts of the Germanic world, that is, to the North and East of France, the Germanic languages were maintained, but the syntax, the conceptual framework underlying the lexicon, and most of the literary forms were thoroughly latinized".
St. Boniface led the effort in the mid-eighth century to organize churches in the region that would become modern Germany. As ecclesiastical organization increased, so did the political unity of the Germanic Christians. By the year 962, when Pope John XII anoints King Otto I as Holy Roman Emperor, "Germany and Christendom had become one". This union lasted until dissolved by Napoleon in 1806.
Pope Celestine I (422-430) sent Palladius to be the first bishop to the Irish in 431, and in 432, St Patrick began his mission there. Scholars cite many questions (and scarce sources) concerning the next two hundred years. Relying largely on recent archaeological developments, Lorcan Harney has reported to the Royal Academy that the missionaries and traders who came to Ireland in the fifth to sixth centuries were not backed by any military force.
Patrick and Palladius and other British and Gaulish missionaries aimed first at converting royal households. Patrick indicates in his Confessio that safety depended upon it. Communities often followed their king en masse. It is likely most natives were willing to embrace the new religion, and that most religious communities were willing to integrate themselves into the surrounding culture. Conversion and consolidation were long complex processes that took centuries.
Christianization of the Irish landscape was a complex process that varied considerably depending on local conditions. Ancient sites were viewed with veneration, and were excluded or included for Christian use based largely on diverse local feeling about their nature, character, ethos and even location.
The Irish monks developed a concept of peregrinatio where a monk would leave the monastery to preach among the 'heathens'. From 590, Irish missionaries were active in Gaul, Scotland, Wales and Britain.
The most likely date for Christianity getting its first foothold in Britain is sometime around 200. Recent archaeology indicates that it had become an established minority faith by the fourth century. It was largely mainstream, and in certain areas, had been continuous.
The conversion of the Anglo-Saxons was begun at about the same time in both the north and south of the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms in two unconnected initiatives. Irish missionaries led by Saint Columba, based in Iona (from 563), converted many Picts. The court of Anglo-Saxon Northumbria, and the Gregorian mission, who landed in 596, did the same to the Kingdom of Kent. They had been sent by Pope Gregory I and were led by Augustine of Canterbury with a mission team from Italy. In both cases, as in other kingdoms of this period, conversion generally began with the royal family and the nobility adopting the new religion first.
In early Anglo-Saxon England, non-stop religious development meant paganism and Christianity were never completely separate. Lorcan Harney has reported that Anglo-Saxon churches were not built by pagan barrows before the 11th century.
The Franks first appear in the historical record in the 3rd century as a confederation of Germanic tribes living on the east bank of the lower Rhine River. Clovis I was the first king of the Franks to unite all of the Frankish tribes under one ruler. According to legend, Clovis had prayed to the Christian god before his battle against one of the kings of the Alemanni, and had consequently attributed his victory to Jesus. The most likely date of his conversion to Catholicism is Christmas Day, 508, following that Battle of Tolbiac. He was baptized in Rheims. The Frankish Kingdom became Christian over the next two centuries.[note 14]
The conversion of the northern Saxons began with their forced incorporation into the Frankish kingdom in 776 by Charlemagne (r. 768–814). Thereafter, the Saxon's Christian conversion slowly progressed into the eleventh century. Saxons had gone back and forth between rebellion and submission to the Franks for decades. Charlemagne placed missionaries and courts across Saxony in hopes of pacifying the region, but Saxons rebelled again in 782 with disastrous losses for the Franks. In response, the Frankish King "enacted a variety of draconian measures" beginning with the massacre at Verden in 782 when he ordered the decapitation of 4500 Saxon prisoners offering them baptism as an alternative to death. These events were followed by the severe legislation of the Capitulatio de partibus Saxoniae in 785 which prescribes death to those that are disloyal to the king, harm Christian churches or its ministers, or practice pagan burial rites. His harsh methods of Christianization raised objections from his friends Alcuin and Paulinus of Aquileia. Charlemagne abolished the death penalty for paganism in 797.
Christianization throughout Italy in Late Antiquity allowed for an amount of religious competition, negotiation, toleration and cooperation; it included syncretism both to and from pagans and Christians; and it allowed for a great deal of secularism. Public sacrifice had largely disappeared by the mid-fourth century, but paganism in a broader sense did not end. Paganism continued, transforming itself over the next two centuries in ways that often included the appropriation and redesignation of Christian practices and ideas while remaining pagan.
In 529, Benedict of Nursia established his first monastery in the Abbey of Monte Cassino, Italy. He wrote the Rule of Saint Benedict based on "pray and work". This "Rule" provided the foundation of the majority of the thousands of monasteries that spread across what is modern day Europe thereby becoming a major factor in the Christianization of Europe.
Monasteries were models of productivity and economic resourcefulness teaching their local communities animal husbandry, cheese making, wine making, and various other skills. They were havens for the poor, hospitals, hospices for the dying, and schools. Medical practice was highly important, and monasteries are best known for their contributions to medical tradition. They also made advances in sciences such as astronomy. For centuries, nearly all secular leaders were trained by monks because, excepting private tutors who were still, often, monks, it was the only education available.
The formation of these organized bodies of believers gradually carved out a series of uniquely distinct social spaces with some amount of independence from other types of authority such as political and familial authority. This revolutionized social history for everyone, but especially for women who could become leaders of communities with great influence of their own.
Benedict's biographer Cuthbert Butler writes that "...certainly there will be no demur in recognizing that St. Benedict's Rule has been one of the great facts in the history of western Europe, and that its influence and effects are with us to this day."
Christianization was slower in Greece than in most other parts of the Roman empire. There are multiple theories of why, but there is no consensus. What is agreed upon is that, for a variety of reasons, Christianization did not take hold in Greece until the fourth and fifth centuries. Christians and pagans maintained a self imposed segregation throughout the period. In Athens, for example, pagans retained the old civic center with its temples and public buildings as their sphere of activity, while Christians restricted themselves to the suburban areas. There was little direct contact between them. J. M. Speiser has argued that this was the situation throughout the country, and that "rarely was there any significant contact, hostile or otherwise" between Christians and pagans in Greece. This would have slowed the process of Christianization. By the time Christianization showed up in Greece, many of the fundamental aspects of the two religious traditions had already become similar. Accommodations had been made in both directions allowing points of view acceptable to those who had previously been pagan.
Timothy Gregory says, "it is admirably clear that organized paganism survived well into the sixth century throughout the empire and in parts of Greece (at least in the Mani) until the ninth century or later". Gregory adds that pagan ideas and forms persisted most in practices related to healing, death, and the family. These are "first-order" concerns - those connected with the basics of life – which were not generally subjected to objections from theologians and bishops.
The Parthenon, the Erechtheion, and the Theseion were turned into churches, but Alison Frantz has won consensus support of her view that, aside from a few rare instances, temple conversions took place only after Late Antiquity, especially in the seventh century, after the displacements caused by the Slavic invasions.
Sept. 22nd, 529 has been regarded by some scholars as the symbolic marking [of] the end of antiquity in the Eastern Roman Empire: the date corresponds to Justinian’s closing of the philosophical school at Athens, a fact whose historicity is beyond doubt, and whose effects on the cultural life of the Greek East have been variously assessed.
Hispania had become part of the Roman Empire in the third century BC. In his Epistle to the Romans, the Apostle Paul speaks of his intent to travel there, but when, how, and even if this happened, is uncertain. Paul may have begun the Christianization of Spain, but it may have been begun by soldiers returning from Mauritania. However Christianization began, Christian communities can be found dating to the third century, and bishoprics had been created in León, Mérida and Zeragosa by that same period. In AD 300 an ecclesiastical council held in Elvira was attended by 20 bishops. With the end of persecution in 312, churches, baptistries, hospitals and episcopal palaces were erected in most major towns, and many landed aristocracy embraced the faith and converted sections of their villas into chapels.
In 416, the Germanic Visigoths crossed into Hispania as Roman allies. They converted to Arian Christianity shortly before 429. The Visigothic King Sisebut came to the throne in 612 when the Roman emperor Heraclius surrendered his Spanish holdings. The emperor had received a prophecy that the empire would be destroyed by a circumcised people; lacking awareness of Islam, he applied this to the Jews. Heraclius is said to have called upon Sisebut to banish all Jews who would not submit to baptism. Bouchier says 90,000 Hebrews were baptized while others fled to France or North Africa.
Despite early Christian testimonies and institutional organization, Christianization of the Basques was slow. Muslim accounts from the period of the Umayyad conquest of Hispania (711 – 718) up to the 9th century, indicate the Basques were not considered Christianized by the Muslims who called them magi or 'pagan wizards', rather than 'People of the Book' as Christians or Jews were.
Colonialization and secularization
Christianity and the various pagan religions co-existed and largely tolerated each other in most of the empire throughout the majority of the fourth and fifth centuries. The structure and ideals of both Church and State were transformed through this long period of symbiosis. By the time a fifth-century pope attempted to denounce the Lupercalia as 'pagan superstition', religion scholar Elizabeth Clark says "it fell on deaf ears". In Historian R. A. Markus's reading of events, this marked a colonialization by Christians of pagan values and practices. For Alan Cameron, the mixed culture that included the continuation of the circuses, amphitheaters and games – sans sacrifice – on into the sixth century involved the secularization of paganism rather than appropriation by Christianity.
Up to the time of Justin I and Justinian I (527 to 565), there was some toleration for all religions; there were anti-sacrifice laws, but they were not enforced. Thus, up into the sixth century, there still existed centers of paganism in Athens, Gaza, Alexandria, and elsewhere.
Christianization of Europe (6th–9th centuries)
Change in method
A shift in Christianization took place in 612 when the Visigothic King Sisebut declared the obligatory conversion of all Jews in Spain, contradicting Pope Gregory who had reiterated the traditional ban against forced conversion of the Jews in 591. Scholars refer to this shift as a "seismic moment" in Christianization.
Constantine had granted, through the Edict of Milan, the right to all people to follow whatever religion they wished. Also in the West, Emperor Gratian surrendered the title of Pontifex Maximus, the position of head priest of the empire. The religious policy of the Eastern emperor Justinian I (527 to 565) reflected his conviction that a unified Empire presupposed unity of faith.
Herrin asserts that, under Justinian, this involved considerable destruction. The decree of 528 had already barred pagans from state office when, decades later, Justinian ordered a "persecution of surviving Hellenes, accompanied by the burning of pagan books, pictures and statues" which took place at the Kynêgion. Herrin says it is difficult to assess the degree to which Christians are responsible for the losses of ancient documents in many cases, but in the mid-sixth century, active persecution in Constantinople destroyed many ancient texts.
According to Anthony Kaldellis, Justinian is often seen as a tyrant and despot. Unlike Constantine, Justinian did purge the bureaucracy of those who disagreed with him. He sought to centralize imperial government, became increasingly autocratic, and "nothing could be done", not even in the Church, that was contrary to the emperor's will and command. In Kaldellis' estimation, "Few emperors had started so many wars or tried to enforce cultural and religious uniformity with such zeal".
In the first half of the sixth century, Justinian came to Rome to liberate it from barbarians leading to a guerrilla war that lasted nearly 20 years. After fighting ended, Justinian used what is known as a Pragmatic Sanction to assert control over Italy. The Sanction effectively removed the supports that had allowed the senatorial aristocracy to retain power. The political and social influence of the Senate's aristocratic members thereafter disappeared, and by 630, the Senate ceased to exist, and its building was converted into a church. Bishops stepped into civic leadership in the Senator's places. The position and influence of the pope rose.
End of the Ancient world
Before the 800s, the Pope, as the 'Bishop of Rome,' had no special influence over bishops outside Rome and had not yet manifested as the central ecclesiastical power. From the late seventh to the middle of the eighth century, eleven of the thirteen men who held the position of Roman Pope were the sons of families from the East. Before they could be installed, these Popes had to be approved by the head of State, the Byzantine emperor. This is called the Byzantine papacy, and along with losses to Islam, and changes within Christianity itself, it helped put an end to Ancient Christianity. Most scholars agree the 7th and 8th centuries are when the 'end of the ancient world' is most conclusive and well documented. Christianity transformed into its eclectic medieval forms as exemplified by the creation of the Papal state, and the alliance between the papacy and the militant Frankish king Charlemagne.
Christianity had taken root in the Balkans when it was part of the Roman Empire. When the Slavs entered the area and conquered it in the fifth century, they adopted the religion of those they had subdued. In 680, Khan Aspuruk, the leader of an ethnically mixed pagan tribe led an army of Proto-Bulgars across the Danube, conquering the Slavs. They settled, and the First Bulgarian Empire was founded in 680/1 with the capitol at Pliska. Over the next two centuries, they fought on and off to protect their borders from various tribes and Byzantium.
Omurtag became Khan in 814. He persecuted Christians, but war with Byzantium, and other wars to acquire territory, brought many Christian prisoners of war into the state. The histories say their faith in the face of extreme misery impressed some of their captors including one of Omurtag's sons who converted. Under Omurtag, Bulgaria and Byzantium maintained a 30-year peace treaty that allowed for more contact, and this increased Christian missionary activities. Christianity spread, while the nobility who were largely Proto-Bulgarians, remained steadfastly pagan.
Official Christianization began in 864/5 under Khan Boris I (852– 889) who had been baptized in 864 in the capital city, Pliska, by Byzantine priests. The need to secure the country's borders, at least from Byzantium, was compounded by the need for internal peace between the different ethnic groups. Boris I determined that imposing Christianity was the answer. The decision was partly military, partly domestic, and partly to diminish the power of the Proto-Bulgarian nobility. A number of nobles reacted violently; 52 were executed. After prolonged negotiations with both Rome and Constantinople, an autocephalous Bulgarian Orthodox Church was formed that used the newly created Cyrillic script to make the Bulgarian language the language of the Church.
Boris' eldest son, Vladimir, also called Rasate, probably ruled from 889 – 893. He was deposed in 893 amidst accusations he was planning to abandon the Christian faith. Scholars remain uncertain as to the veracity of the accusation. His younger brother Symeon, Boris' third son, replaced him, ruling from 893 to 927. He intensified the translation of Greek literature and theology into Bulgarian, and enabled the establishment of an intellectual circle called the school of Preslav. Symeon also led a series of wars against the Byzantines to gain official recognition of his Imperial title and the full independence of the Bulgarian Church. As a result of his victories in 927, the Byzantines finally recognized the Bulgarian Patriarchate.
Serbs migrated to the Balkan Peninsula between the fifth and seventh centuries. Christianity had been introduced there under Roman rule, but the region had largely returned to paganism by then. Serbian tribes adopted Christianity very slowly. The first instance of mass baptism happened during the reign of Heraclius (610–641) by "elders of Rome" according to Constantine Porphyrogenitus in his annals (r. 913–959).
The full conversion of the Slavs dates to the time of Eastern Orthodox missionaries Saints Cyril and Methodius during the reign of the Byzantine emperor Basil I (r. 867–886). The Serbian prince Vlastimir (c. 830 until c. 851) was probably pagan as all his sons had pagan names. In the next generation of Serbian monarchs and nobles there are Petar Gojniković, Stefan Mutimirović, and Pavle Branović. Serbs were baptized sometime before Basil sent imperial admiral Nikita Orifas to Knez Mutimir for aid in the war against the Saracens in 869, after acknowledging the suzerainty of the Byzantine Empire. The fleets and land forces of Zahumlje, Travunia and Konavli (Serbian Pomorje) were sent to fight the Saracens who attacked the town of Ragusa (Dubrovnik) in 869, on the immediate request of Basil I, who was asked by the Ragusians for help.
The first diocese of Serbia, the Diocese of Ras, is mentioned in the ninth century. It's provenance is uncertain, but it was probably founded about 871. Serbia can certainly be seen as a Christian nation by 870.
Serbia was annexed by Bulgaria, becoming a Bulgarian province under Samuel of Bulgaria (997-1014), bringing with it the Cyrillic alphabet and Slav texts. The full Byzantine conquest that followed Samuel's rule did not alter that use of Slavic language and liturgy within the Serbian church.
The medieval Serbian state was created in the second half of the twelfth century.
According to Constantine VII, Christianization of Croats began in the 7th century. Viseslav (r. 785–802), one of the first dukes of Croatia, left behind a special baptismal font, which symbolizes the acceptance of the church, and thereby Western culture, by the Croats. The conversion of Croatia is said to have been completed by the time of Duke Trpimir's death in 864. In 879, under duke Branimir, Croatia received papal recognition as a state from Pope John VIII.
The Narentine pirates, based on the Croatian coast, remained pagans until the late ninth century.
Hungarian historian László Veszprémy writes: "By the end of the 11th century, Hungarian expansion had secured Croatia, a country that was coveted by both the Venetian and Byzantine empires and had already adopted the Latin Christian faith. The Croatian crown was held by the Hungarian kings up to 1918, but Croatia retained its territorial integrity throughout. It is not unrelated that the borders of Latin Christendom in the Balkans have remained coincident with the borders of Croatia into present times".
What was Bohemia forms much of the Czech Republic, comprising the central and western portions of the country.
Evidence of Christianity in this region north of the Danube can be found dating from the time of Roman occupation in the second century. Christianity was developing organically until the arrival of the Huns in 433 which Christianity survived only to a small extent. From the 7th century, in the territory of contemporary Slovakia, (Great Moravia and its successor state Duchy of Bohemia), Christianization was sustained by the intervention of various missions from the Frankish Empire and Byzantine enclaves in Italy and Dalmatia.
Significant missionary activity only took place after Charlemagne defeated the Avar Khaganate several times at the end of the 8th century and beginning of the ninth centuries. A key event with significant influence on the Christianization of Slavs was the elevation of the Salzburg diocese to archdiocese by Charlemagne with permission from the Pope in 798.
The first Christian church of the Western and Eastern Slavs (known to written sources) was built in 828 by Pribina (c. 800–861) ruler and Prince of the Principality of Nitra. His career is recorded in the Conversion of the Bavarians and the Carantanians (a historical work written in 870). Pribina was driven out by Mojmír I in 833. Mojmír was baptized in 831 by Reginhar, Bishop of Passau. Despite formal endorsement by the elites, Great Moravian Christianity was described as containing many pagan elements as late as in 852.
Church organization was supervised by the Franks. Prince Rastislav's request for missionaries had been sent to Byzantine Emperor Michael III (842–867) in hopes of establishing a local church organization independent of Frankish clergy.
In the Christianization process of Bohemia, Moravia and Slovakia territories, the two Byzantine missionary brothers Saints Constantine-Cyril and Methodius played the key roles beginning in 863. They spent approximately 40 months in Great Moravia continuously translating texts and teaching students. Cyril developed the first Slavic alphabet and translated the Gospel into the Old Church Slavonic language. Old Church Slavonic became the first literary language of the Slavs and, eventually, the educational foundation for all Slavic nations.
In 869 Methodius was consecrated as (arch)bishop of Pannonia and the Great Moravia regions. In 880, Pope John VIII issued the bull Industriae Tuae, by which he set up the independent ecclesiastical province that Rastislav had hoped for, with Archbishop Methodius as its head. The independent archdiocese managed by Methodius was established only for a short time, but relics of this church organization withstood the fall of Great Moravia.
Christianization of Europe (10th - 14th centuries)
The intense and rapid changes which occurred during the eleventh and twelfth centuries, including a "profound revolution in religious sentiment", are considered some of the most significant changes in the history of Christianization.
New monk new Christianization
The church of this era had immense authority, but the key to its power was a reformation movement that swept through Europe in the 900's. The reform movement created two images of the Benedictine ideal: the traditional contemplative, and the new monks, from new communities like the Dominicans, who saw their calling in terms of actively working to reform the world. This influenced the next 400 years of European history. The church's stated purpose had long been to change the heart of individual persons, not the social order, and ancient Christians had not thought of their movement in terms of social reform.
Dominicans came to dominate the new universities, traveled about preaching against heresy, and eventually became notorious for their participation in the Medieval Inquisition, the Albigensian Crusade and the Northern crusades. Christian policy denying the existence of witches and witchcraft would later be challenged by the Dominicans allowing them to participate in witch trials. The monk's new focus on reforming the world created a new form of Christianization evident in the conversion of East Central Europe. Throughout central and eastern Europe, Christianization and political centralization went hand in hand.
Christianization and political centralization
By 1150, a watershed period in European history had begun. Western culture became more secular. Kings began centralizing power into themselves and their nations. They accomplished this by taking legal, military, and social powers away from the aristocrats who had traditionally held those powers, turning them into powers belonging only to the king as the representative of the state. Centralization of power led all of Europe of the High Middle Ages to become a persecuting culture. 
Jews and homosexuals were among the first minorities to lose rights and be persecuted by law. A new rhetoric of exclusion based on stereotyping, stigmatization and even demonization of the accused were seen to legitimize and justify these attacks. Attitudes of the church toward the Jews changed in the 1200s, and the church no longer protected them. In 1215, the Fourth Lateran Council, known as the Great Council, met and accepted 70 canons (church laws). The last three canons required Jews to distinguish themselves from Christians in their dress, prohibited them from holding public office, and prohibited Jewish converts from continuing to practice Jewish rituals. As Berger has articulated it: "The other side of the coin of unique toleration was unique persecution."
In the eleventh century, the kingdom of Jerusalem had spread a legal code ordaining death for "sodomites". From the 1250s onwards, a series of similar legal codes in the nation-states of Spain, France, Italy and Germany followed this example. Sociologist R. I. Moore writes that "By 1300, places where male sodomy was not a capitol offense had become the exception rather than the rule."
They were followed in the next few centuries by Gypsies, beggars, spendthrifts, prostitutes, and idle former soldiers. The church did not have the leading role in this persecution, but church leaders supported the kings through Christian rhetoric and new canon law.
By the 1300's, kings in France and England had been so successful at centralizing power by taking it from others that many governments wanted to imitate them, including the church's government. The popes of the fourteenth century worked to amass power into the papal position, building what is often called the papal monarchy. This was accomplished partly through the reorganization of the ecclesiastical financial system. The poor had previously been allowed to offer their tithes in goods and services, but these popes revamped the system to only accept money. A steady cash flow brought with it the power of great wealth. The papal states were thereafter governed by the pope in the same manner the secular powers governed. The pope became a pseudo-monarch.
These fourteenth century popes were greedy and politically corrupt, so that pious Christians of the period became disgusted, leading to the loss of papal prestige. Devoted and virtuous nuns and monks became increasingly rare. Monastic reform had been a major force in the High Middle Ages but is largely unknown in the Late Middle Ages. Christian missions are almost non-existent everywhere but Asia (Eastern Europe).
In Asia, the combination of Christianization and political centralization created what Peter Brown describes as, "specific micro-Christendoms". It did not only create new states, László Veszprémy says it also created "a new region which later became known as East Central Europe". Conversion began with local elites who wanted to convert because they gained prestige and power through matrimonial alliances and participation in imperial rituals.[note 15] Christianity then spread from the center to the edges of society.
Historian Ivo Štefan writes that, "Although Christian authors often depicted the conversion of rulers as the triumph of the new faith, the reality was much more complex. Christianization of everyday life took centuries, with many non-Christian elements surviving in rural communities until the beginning of the modern era".[note 16]
According to historians Franciszek Longchamps de Bérier and Rafael Domingo: "A pre-Christian Poland never existed. Poland entered history suddenly when some western lands inhabited by the Slavs embraced Christianity. Christianity was brought to the region by Dobrawa of Bohemia, the daughter of Boleslaus I the Cruel, Duke of Bohemia, when Duke Mieszko I was baptized and married her in 966."  The dynastic interests of the Piasts produced the establishment of both church and state in Great Poland (Greater Poland, often known by its Polish name "Wielkopolska" is a historical region of west-central Poland. Its chief and largest city is Poznań.). That seems to have been a planned strategic decision.
The "Baptism of Poland" (Polish: Chrzest Polski) in 966, refers to the baptism of Mieszko I, the first ruler. "The young Christian state acquired its own Slavic martyr, Wojciech (known as Adalbert), in 1000, plus the archbishopric in Gniezno and four bishoprics (Poznań, Kraków, Wrocław and Kołobrzeg). This Christian state, the earliest attempt at Christianization in this region of Europe, lasted for roughly 70 years". Mieszko's baptism was followed by the building of churches and the establishment of an ecclesiastical hierarchy. Mieszko saw baptism as a way of strengthening his hold on power, with the active support he could expect from the bishops, as well as a unifying force for the Polish people.
Christianity existed in what would become present day Hungary from the time of Roman rule. At the end of the ninth century, the Magyars occupied said territory finding widespread traces of Christianity amongst the Avar tribes, the Bulgars and the Slavs who had previously settled there; there is also historical evidence the Magyar people brought with them a prior knowledge of Christianity.
Around 952, the tribal chief Gyula II of Transylvania, visited Constantinople and was baptized, bringing home with him Hierotheus who was designated bishop of Turkia (Hungary). Medieval historian Phyllis G. Jestice writes that Gyula's son-in-law "Géza of Hungary became Duke of the Hungarians [around 970] and began a new open door policy to the west that made mission in that region possible for the first time". Some scholars say Géza used forced conversion, and ruthlessly removed pagan idols and cultic places, but there is little support as Géza is largely excluded from the historical record of Hungary's conversion. The conversion of Gyula at Constantinople and the missionary work of Bishop Hierotheus are depicted as leading directly to the court of St. Stephen, the first Hungarian king, a Christian in a still mostly pagan country.
While there is historiographical dispute over who actually converted the Hungarian people, King Stephen or the German Emperor Henry II, there is agreement that the realm King Stephen inherited had no established church system, and that monarchy was a break from the "old law". Stephen suppressed rebellion, organized both the Hungarian State (establishing strong royal authority), and the church, by inviting missionaries, and suppressing paganism by making laws requiring the people to attend church every Sunday. Soon the Hungarian Kingdom had two archbishops and 8 bishops, and a defined state structure with province governors that answered to the King. Stephen opened the frontiers of his Kingdom in 1016 to the pilgrims that traveled by land to the Holy Land, and soon this route became extremely popular, being used later in the Crusades. Stephen often personally met pilgrims and invited them to stay in Hungary. Saint Stephen was the first Hungarian monarch elevated to sainthood for his Christian characteristics and not because he suffered a martyr's death.
The beginning of the 11th century marks the end of the first stage of the founding of church and state in Hungary. Hungarian Christianity and the kingdom's ecclesiastical and temporal administrations consolidated towards the end of the 11th century, especially under Ladislas I and Coloman when the feudal order was finally established, the first saints were canonized, and new dioceses were founded.
In 945, Igor, the duke of the Rus', entered a trade agreement with Byzantium in exchange for soldiers, and when those mercenaries returned, they brought Christianity with them. Duchess Olga was the first member of the ruling family to accept baptism, ca. 950 in Constantinople, but it did not spread immediately.
Around 978, Vladimir (978–1015), the son of Sviatoslav, seized power in Kiev. Slavic historian Ivo Štefan writes that, Vladimir examined monotheism for himself, and "Around that same time, Vladimir conquered Cherson in the Crimea, where, according to the Tale of Bygone Years, he was baptized". After returning to Kiev, the same text describes Vladimir as unleashing "a systematic destruction of pagan idols and the construction of Christian churches in their place".
Bohemia, Poland, and Hungary had become part of western Latin Christianity, while the Rus' adopted Christianity from Byzantium, leading them down a different path. A specific form of Rus' Christianity formed quickly. The Rus' dukes maintained exclusive control of the church which was financially dependent upon them. The prince appointed the clergy to positions in government service; satisfied their material needs; determined who would fill the higher ecclesiastical positions; and directed the synods of bishops in the Kievan metropolitanate. This new Christian religious structure was imposed upon the socio-political and economic fabric of the land by the authority of the state's rulers. According to Andrzej Poppe, Slavic historian, it is fully justifiable to call the Church of Rus' a state church. The Church strengthened the authority of the Prince, and helped to justifiy the expansion of Kievan empire into new territories through missionary activity.
Clergy formed a new layer in the hierarchy of society. They taught Christian values, a Christian world view, the intellectual traditions of Antiquity, and translated religious texts into local vernacular language which introduced literacy to all members of the princely dynasty, including women, as well as the populace. Monasteries of the twelfth century became key spiritual, intellectual, art, and craft centers. Under Vladimir’s son Yaroslav I the Wise (1016–1018, 1019–1054), a building and cultural boom took place. The Church of Rus' gradually developed into an independent political force in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.
Before Christianity arrived, there was a common Scandinavian culture with only regional differences. Early Scandinavian loyalties, of the Viking Age (793–1066 AD) and the early medieval period (6th to 10th century), were determined by warfare, temporary treaties, marriage alliances and wealth. Having nothing equivalent to modern borders, kings rose and fell based primarily on their ability to gain wealth for their people.
Christianization of Scandinavia is divided into two stages by Professor of medieval archaeology Alexandra Sanmark. Stage 1 involves missionaries who arrive in pagan territory, on their own, without secular support. This began during the Carolingian era (800s). However, early Scandinavians had been in contact with the Christian world as far back as the Migration Period (AD 375 (possibly as early as 300) to 568), and later during the Viking Age, long before the first documented missions.
Florence Harmer writes that "Between A.D. 960 and 1008 three Scandinavian kings were converted to Christianity". The Danish King Harald Gormsen (Bluetooth) was baptized c. 960. The conversion of Norway was begun by Hákon Aðalsteinsfostri between 935 and 961, but the wide-scale conversion of this kingdom was undertaken by King Olav Tryggvason in c. 995. In Sweden, King Olof Erikson Skötkonung accepted Christianity around 1000.
According to Peter Brown, Scandinavians adopted Christianity of their own accord c.1000. Anders Winroth accepts this view, explaining that Iceland became the model for the institutional conversion of the rest of Scandinavia after the farmers voted to adopt Christian law at the Assembly at Thingvellir in AD 1000. Winroth demonstrates that Scandinavians were not passive recipients of the new religion, but were instead converted to Christianity because it was in individual chieftains' political, economic, and cultural interests to do so.
Women were important and influential early converts. Scandinavian women might have found Christianity more appealing than Norse religion for a variety of reasons: Valhalla was unavailable to the majority of women; infanticide of female infants was a common practice, and it was forbidden within Christianity; Christianity had a generally less violent message, and it inserted "gender equality into marriage and sexual relations".
Although Scandinavians became nominally Christian, it would take considerably longer for actual Christian beliefs to establish themselves among the people. Archaeological excavations of burial sites on the island of Lovön near modern-day Stockholm have shown that the actual Christianization of the people was very slow and took at least 150–200 years. Thirteenth-century runic inscriptions from the bustling merchant town of Bergen in Norway show little Christian influence, and one of them appeals to a Valkyrie.
Stage 2 begins when a secular ruler takes charge of Christianization in their territory, and ends when a defined and organized ecclesiastical network is established. For Scandinavia, the emergence of a stable ecclesiastical organization is also marked by closer links with the papacy. Archbishoprics were founded in Lund (1103/04), Nidaros (1153), and Uppsala (1164), and in 1152/3, Cardinal Nicholas Breakspear was sent as a papal legate to Norway and Sweden. By 1350, Scandinavia was an integral part of Western Christendom.
From the days of Charlemagne (747-814), the people around the Baltic Sea had raided – stealing crucial resources, killing, and enslaving captives – from the countries that surrounded them including Denmark, Prussia, Germany and Poland. In the eleventh century, German and Danish nobles united to put a stop to the raiding, in an attempt to force peace through military action, but it didn't last.
When the Pope (Blessed) Eugenius III (1145–1153) called for a Second Crusade in response to the fall of Edessa in 1144, Saxon nobles refused to go. They wanted to go back to subduing Baltic Tribes instead. These rulers did not see crusading as a moral, faith based duty as western crusaders did. They saw holy war as a tool for territorial expansion, alliance building, and the empowerment of their own young church and state. Succession struggles would have left them vulnerable at home while they were gone, and the longer pilgrimage could not benefit them with those things that crusading at home would. In 1147, Eugenius' Divini dispensatione, gave the eastern nobles full crusade indulgences to go to the Baltic area instead of the Levant. The Northern, (or Baltic), Crusades followed, taking place, off and on, with and without papal support, from 1147 to 1316.
Law professor Eric Christiansen indicates the primary motivation for these wars was the noble's desire for territorial expansion and wealth in the form of land, furs, amber, slaves, and tribute.[note 17] Taking the time for peaceful conversion did not fit in with these plans. Conversion by these princes was almost always a result of conquest, either by the direct use of force, or indirectly, when a leader converted and required it of his followers.
Monks and priests had to work with the secular rulers on the ruler's terms. According to Fonnesberg-Schmidt, "While the theologians maintained that conversion should be voluntary, there was a widespread pragmatic acceptance of conversion obtained through political pressure or military coercion". Acceptance led some commentators to endorse and approve coerced conversions, something that had not been done in the church before this time. Dominican friars helped with this ideological justification by offering a portrayal of the pagans as possessed by evil spirits. In this manner, they could assert that pagans were in need of conquest in order to free them from their terrible circumstance; then they could be peacefully converted. There were often severe consequences for populations that chose to resist.
Between 711 and 718, the Iberian peninsula had been conquered by Muslims in the Umayyad conquest. Spain and Sicily are the only European regions to have experienced Islamic conquest. The blended Muslim, Christian and Jewish cultures that resulted from the eighth century onward left a profound imprint on Spain.
The centuries long military struggle to reclaim the peninsula from Muslim rule, called the Reconquista, took place until the Christian Kingdoms, that would later become Spain and Portugal, reconquered the Moorish states of Al-Ándalus in 1492 (see: Battle of Covadonga in 722 and the Conquest of Granada in 1492).
Isabel and Ferdinand united the country with themselves as its first royalty quickly establishing the Spanish Inquisition in order to consolidate state interest. The Spanish inquisition was originally authorized by the Pope, yet the initial inquisitors proved so severe that the Pope almost immediately opposed it; to no avail. Ferdinand is said to have pressured the Pope, and in October 1483, a papal bull conceded control of the inquisition to the Spanish crown. According to Spanish historian José Casanova, the Spanish inquisition became the first truly national, unified and centralized state institution. After the 1400s, few Spanish inquisitors were from the religious orders.
Romania became Christian in a gradual manner beginning when Rome conquered the province of Dacia (106-107). The Romans brought Latinization through intense and massive colonization. Rome withdrew in the third century, then the Slavs reached Dacia in the 6th to 7th centuries and were eventually assimilated. By the 8th to 9th centuries, Romanians existed in a "frontier" on the other side of the Carpathian mountains between Latin, Catholic Europe and the Byzantine, Orthodox East. During most of this period, being Christian allowed its relative observance in parallel with the continued observance of some pagan customs.
Missionaries from south of the Danube moved north spreading their western faith and their Latin language. In the last two decades of the 9th century, missionaries Clement and Naum, (who were disciples of the brothers Cyril and Methodius who had converted the Old Slavic language to a written form in 863), had arrived in the region spreading the Cyrillic alphabet. By the 10th century when the Bulgarian Tsars extended their territory to include Transylvania, they were able to impose the Bulgarian church model and its Slavic language without opposition. Nearly all Romanian words concerning Christian faith have Latin roots, while words regarding the organization of the church are Slavonic.
Romanian historian Ioan-Aurel Pop writes that "Christian fervor and the massive conversion to Christianity among the Slavs may have led to the canonic conversion of the last heathen, or ecclesiastically unorganized, Romanian islands". For Romanians, the church model was "overwhelming, omnipresent, putting pressure on the Romanians and often accompanied by a political element". This ecclesiastical and political tradition continued until the 19th century.
Albanian historian Robert Elsie writes that, "In a book published in 1994, German professor Gottfried Schramm (b. 1929) linked the Albanians to the ancient Bessi or Bessoi (Gk. Βέσσοι or Βῆσσοι), a Thracian tribe living around ancient Remesiana (Bela Palanka) in the current Serbian-Bulgarian-Macedonian border region. According to Schramm, these Bessi were converted to Christianity very early" by Nicetas the Bishop of Remesiana, "and were later pushed westward into Albania in the early ninth century" bringing their religion with them. The history of Albania by Movses Daskhurantsi or Kaghankatvatsi insists on the apostolic origin of Albanian Christianity through St. Elisaeus (Eghishe). However, most scholars agree that Christianity was officially adopted in AD 313 or AD 315 when Gregory the Illuminator baptized the Albanian king and ordained the first bishop Tovmas, the founder of the Albanian church. It is highly probable that Christianization covered the whole of antique Albania by the late fourth century.
According to Elsie,
Albania found itself on the cultural border that separated Latin influence to the north from Greek influence to the south. The dividing line between the two, known to historians as the Jireček Line, ran through Albania from around Laç (between Tirana and Lezha) in an easterly, slightly north-easterly direction. North of this line one encounters inscriptions primarily in Latin, whereas south of the line, and more overwhelmingly south of the Shkumbin valley, one encounters inscriptions in Greek. As a cultural divide, the Jireček Line still finds its reflection in Albania today. Christian Albanians to the north of it are Catholic in their vast majority, whereas Christian Albanians to the south of it are almost all Orthodox.
The last of the Baltic crusades was the conflict between the mostly German Teutonic Order and Lithuania in the far northeastern reaches of Europe. Lithuania is sometimes described as "the last pagan nation in medieval Europe".
The Teutonic Order was a crusading organization for the Christian Holy Land founded by members of the Knights Hospitaller. Medieval historian Aiden Lilienfeld says "In 1226, however, the Duke of Mazovia (in modern-day Poland) granted the Order territory in eastern Prussia in exchange for help in subjugating pagan Baltic peoples".
Lilienfeld says "their status as a crusading “monastic” order meant that they could only claim autonomy and legitimacy so long as they could convince the other European Catholic states, from whom they received recruits and financial support, that the Order had a job to do: to convert pagan populations that Catholic rulers perceived to be a threat to Christendom. The greatest of these perceived threats was the Grand Duchy of Lithuania."
Over the course of the next 200 years, the Order expanded its territory to cover much of the eastern Baltic coast.
In 1384, the ten year old daughter of Louis the Great, King of Hungary and Poland, and his wife, Elizabeth of Bosnia, named Jadwiga, was crowned king of Poland. One year later, a marriage was arranged between her and the Grand Duke Jogaila of Lithuania. Jogaila was baptized, married, and crowned king in 1386 beginning the 400 year shared history of Poland and Lithuania. This would seem to obviate the need for the Order's crusade, yet activity against local populations, particularly the Samogition peoples of the eastern Baltic, continued in a frequently brutal manner.
The Teutonic Order eventually fell to Poland-Lithuania in 1525. Lilienfeld says that "After this, the Order’s territory was divided between Poland-Lithuania and the Hohenzollern dynasty of Brandenburg, putting an end to the monastic state and the formal Northern Crusade. All of the Order’s most powerful cities–Danzig (Gdansk), Elbing (Elblag), Marienburg (Malbork), and Braunsberg (Braniewo)–now fall within Poland in the 21st century, except for Koenigsburg (Kaliningrad) in Russia."
Early colonialism (1500s -1700s)
Following the geographic discoveries of the 1400's and 1500's, increasing population and inflation led the emerging nation-states of Portugal, Spain, and France, the Dutch Republic, and England to explore, conquer, colonize and exploit the newly discovered territories. While colonialism was primarily economic and political, it opened the door for Christian missionaries who soon followed. These missionaries were not officially sent out as agents of colonial governments, and there were differing levels of missionary support and opposition to colonialism within different states, yet there is enough evidence of support and cooperation with colonialist ideas, for Christianization to be seen as an aspect of colonialism.
There is also evidence of missionary opposition to colonialism. Missions, in Sanneh's view, were "colonialism's Achilles heel, not its shield". According to historical theologian Justo Gonzales, colonialism and missions each sometimes aided and sometimes impeded the other.
Different state actors created colonies that varied widely. Some colonies had institutions that allowed native populations to reap some benefits. Others became extractive colonies with predatory rule that produced an autocracy with a dismal record.
Portugal and Spain
Under Spanish and Portuguese rule, creating a Christian Commonwealth was the goal of missions. This included a significant role, from the beginning of colonial rule, played by Catholic missionaries.
Portugal practiced extractive colonialism. Early attempts at Christianization were not very successful, and those who had been converted were not well instructed. In the church's view, this led them into "errors and misunderstandings". In December 1560, the Portuguese Inquisition arrived in Goa, India. This was largely the result of the crown's fear that converted Jews were becoming dominant in Goa and might ally with Ottoman Jews to threaten Portuguese control of the spice trade. After 1561 the Inquisition had a practical monopoly over heresy, and its "policy of terror ... was reflected in the approximately 15,000 trials which took place between 1561 and 1812, involving more than 200 death sentences."
The Spanish military was known for its ill-treatment of Amerindians. Spanish missionaries are generally credited with championing efforts to initiate protective laws for the Indians and for working against their enslavement. This led to debate on the nature of human rights. In 16th-century Spain the issue resulted in a crisis of conscience and the birth of modern international law.
In words of outrage similar to those earlier missionaries, Junipero Serra wrote of the depredations of the soldiers against Indian women in California in 1770. Following through on missionary complaints, Viceroy Bucareli drew up the first regulatory code of California, the Echeveste Regulations.  Missionary opposition and military prosecution failed to protect the Amerindian women. On the one hand, California missionaries sought to protect the Amerindians from exploitation by the conquistadores, soldiers and colonists. On the other hand, Jesuits, Fransiscans and other orders relied on corporal punishment and an institutionalized racialism for training the "untamed savages".
A catastrophe was wrought upon the Amerindians by contact with Europeans. Old World diseases like smallpox, measles, malaria and many others spread through Indian populations. "In most of the New World 90 percent or more of the native population was destroyed by wave after wave of previously unknown afflictions. Explorers and colonists did not enter an empty land but rather an emptied one".
In the seventeenth century, the French used assimilation as a means of establishing colonies controlled by the state rather than private companies. Within the context of western geocentrism, assimilation (integration of a small group into a larger one) has been used to legitimize European colonization morally and politically for centuries. It advocated multiple aspects of European culture such as "civility, social organization, law, economic development, civil status," dress, bodily description, religion and more to the exclusion of local culture.
Their goal was a political and religious community representative of an ideal society as articulated through the progressive theory of history. This common theory of the time asserts that history shows the normal progression of society is toward constant betterment; that humans could therefore eventually be perfected; that primitive nations could be forced to become modern states wherein that would happen.
This was linked with the emergence of the modern state and was instrumental in the development of racialism as an explanation of the failure of Christianization.
The Dutch Republic
The Dutch Reformed church was not a dominant influence in the Dutch colonies. However, the Dutch East Indies Trading Company used assimilation in its Asian port towns, encouraging intermarriage and cultural uniformity, to establish colonies.
Great Britain's colonial expansion was for the most part driven by commercial ambitions and competition with France. Investors saw converting the natives as a secondary concern. Laura Stevens writes that British missions were more talk than walk. From the beginning, the British talked (and wrote) a great deal about converting native populations, but actual efforts were few and feeble. These missions were universally Protestant, were based on belief in the traditional duty to "teach all nations", the sense of obligation to extend the benefits of Christianity to heathen lands just as Europe itself had been "civilized" centuries before, and a fervent pity for those who had never heard the gospel. Historian Jacob Schacter says "ambivalent benevolence" was at the heart of most British and American attitudes toward native Americans. The British did not create widespread conversion.
New imperialism (19th and 20th centuries)
Beginning in the mid-nineteenth century, New Imperialism was a second wave of colonialism that lasted until World War II. Economists Jan Henryk Pierskalla and Alexander de Juan write that "Early colonial encounters in the Americas of the fifteenth century had little in common with colonization in Africa during the age of the “New Imperialism".” During this time, colonial powers gained territory at almost three times the rate of the earlier period.
By 1914, these empires extended over 85% of the globe. The two largest and most powerful empires were the British empire and the Japanese empire. "In addition to colonial rule, other means of domination were exercised in the form of spheres of influence, special commercial treaties, and the subordination that lenders often impose on debtor nations".
The sixteenth century had been the "great age of Catholic expansion" whereas the nineteenth century was that for Protestantism.
As a latecomer to the Scramble for Africa, Germany’s main interest was in making its colonies secure rather than to maximize extraction. Germany largely focused on the idea that disturbances could be interpreted as a sign of weakness by its international rivals.
Colonies in the Americas, Africa, Asia and the Pacific
Settler colonialism is a distinct type of colonialism that replaces indigenous populations with a settler society. Settler colonial states include Canada, the United States, Australia, and South Africa.
The beginning of American Protestant missions abroad followed the sailing of William Carey from England to India in 1793 after the Great awakening. An even greater effort was made to evangelize America itself. However, Christianization was often mingled with Americanization creating ambiguity and other problems.
For example, a peace treaty with the Cherokee in 1794 stimulated a cultural revival and the welcoming of white missionaries. Mark Noll has written that "what followed was a slow but steady acceptance of the Christian faith". Both Christianization and the Cherokee people received a fatal blow after the discovery of gold in north Georgia in 1828. Cherokee land was seized by the government, sold to white settlers and the Cherokee people were transported in what became known as the Trail of tears.
Missionaries played a crucial role in the acculturation of the Cherokee and other American Indians. Historian William Gerald McLoughlin has written that, humanitarians who saw the decline of indigenous people with regret, advocated education and assimilation as the native's only hope for survival.
The history of boarding schools for the indigenous populations in Canada and the US is not generally good. While the majority of native children did not attend boarding school at all, of those that did, recent studies indicate some found happiness and refuge while others found suffering and abuse.
Over time, many missionaries came to respect the virtues of native culture. "After 1828, most missionaries found it difficult to defend the policies of their government" writes McLoughlin.
Mark Boyle writes that:
Christianity's historical alignment with the Western project and [the overlapping] histories of colonialism and imperialism raises questions about its capacity to serve as a progressive force in global affairs today. Placing Christianity under postcolonial scrutiny, ... Christianity offers a variety of complex, contradictory, and competing approaches to peace building that variously defend the hegemonic ambitions of the West on the one hand, and support critical practices that usurp and decenter the sovereign supremacy assumed by the West on the other.
Impact of colonialism
Sociologists have identified the key role of Christian missionaries, in particular Protestant missionaries, in generating a democratic legacy for many former colonies, through the spread of literacy, mass printing, and voluntary organizations.
Although contact with Christian missionaries might have had beneficial long-term effects for human capital, political participation, and eventually democratization, contact with the colonial slave trade has had pernicious effects.
Some of the different colonial practices, along with the pre-existing conditions in the colonial states, have had long-term negative impact on modern post-colonial countries in their economic development, their democracy, and the ability of their government to accomplish policy goals. The political legacies of colonialism include political instability, violence, and ethnic exclusion which is also linked to civil strife and civil war.
Just as Christianization had a role in colonialism, it has also played a central role in decolonization moving former colonies toward independence. Shifting beliefs about Christianity's role in empire began in France in the 1930's and 40's. Christians were rethinking the relationship between religion and politics. From the 1960's onward, this new understanding of theology combined with Christian activism, was instrumental in motivating indigenous people, such as the Algerians, to work toward and fight for independence from foreign governments. This in turn, influenced global trends. In many colonial societies, Christian missionaries played a transformative role in the development of decolonization and post-colonial Christianity.
In the post-colonial world, it has become necessary for Christianization to break free of its colonial moorings, says Sanneh.
Third wave Christianization
In the early twenty-first century, Christianity is declining in the West and growing in former colonial lands. In 1900 under colonial rule there were just under 9 million Christians in Africa. By 1960, and the end of colonialism there were about 60 million. By 2005, African Christians had increased to 393 million, about half of the continent's total population at that time. Population in Africa has continued to grow with the percentage of Christians remaining at about half in 2022. Christianity has become the most diverse, pluralist, fastest growing religion in the world.
The Bible and other Christian writings have been translated into more than 3000 of the world's 7000 languages. Approximately 90% of those languages have a written grammar and a dictionary only because of missionaries working with indigenous people to create them while doing those translations. Tracing the impact of this on local native cultures shows it has produced "the movements of indigenization and cultural liberation". "The translated scripture ... has become the benchmark of awakening and renewal".
According to Sanneh, this means that western missionaries pioneered the "largest, most diverse and most vigorous movement of cultural renewal in history".
Christianization is now being practiced by Third World countries sending missionaries in an effort to re-evangelize the secular West.
In Late Antique Roman Empire, sites already consecrated as pagan temples or mithraea began being converted into Christian churches. Scholarship has been divided over whether this represents Christianization as a general effort to demolish the pagan past, was instead simple pragmatism, or perhaps an attempt to preserve the past's art and architecture, or some combination.
Sulpicius Severus, in his Vita describes Martin of Tours as a dedicated destroyer of temples and sacred trees, saying "wherever he destroyed heathen temples, there he used immediately to build either churches or monasteries". There is a discrepancy between the written text and archaeology, however, as none of the churches attributed to Martin can be shown to have existed in Gaul in the fourth century.
R. P. C. Hanson says the direct conversion of temples into churches did not begin until the mid fifth century in any but a few isolated incidents. It is likely this timing stems from the fact that these buildings and places remained officially in public use, ownership could only be transferred by the emperor, and temples remained protected by law.
According to modern archaeology, 120 pagan temples were converted to churches in the whole of the empire, out of the thousands of temples that existed, with the majority of those conversions dated after the fifth century. In the fourth century, there were no conversions of temples in the city of Rome itself. It is only with the formation of the Papal State in the eighth century, (when the emperor’s properties in the West came into the possession of the bishop of Rome), that the conversions of temples in Rome took off in earnest. According to Dutch historian Feyo L. Schuddeboom, individual temples and temple sites in the city were converted to churches primarily to preserve their exceptional architecture. They were also used pragmatically because of the importance of their location at the center of town.
When Benedict moved to Monte Cassino about 530, a small temple with a sacred grove and a separate altar to Apollo stood on the hill. The population was still mostly pagan. The land was most likely granted as a gift to Benedict from one of his supporters. This would explain the authoritative way he immediately cut down the groves, removed the altar, and built an oratory before the locals were converted.
Christianizing native religious, cultural activities and beliefs became official in the sixth century. This argument (in favor of what in modern terms is syncretism), is preserved in the Venerable Bede's Historia ecclesiastica gentis Anglorum in the form of a letter from Pope Gregory to Mellitus (d.604). L. C. Jane has translated Bede's text:
Tell Augustine that he should by no means destroy the temples of the gods but rather the idols within those temples. Let him, after he has purified them with holy water, place altars and relics of the saints in them. For, if those temples are well built, they should be converted from the worship of demons to the service of the true God. Thus, seeing that their places of worship are not destroyed, the people will banish error from their hearts and come to places familiar and dear to them in acknowledgement and worship of the true God. Bede, Historia ecclesiastica gentis Anglorum (1.30)
Richard A. Fletcher suggests that Holy wells developed out of a like adaptation. The British Isles and other areas of northern Europe that were formerly druidic are still densely punctuated by holy wells and holy springs that are now attributed to a saint, often a highly local saint unknown elsewhere. In earlier times many of these were seen as guarded by supernatural forces such as the melusina, and many such pre-Christian holy wells appear to survive as baptistries.
By 771, Charlemagne had inherited the three-century long conflict with the Saxons who regularly specifically targeted churches and monasteries in brutal raids into Frankish territory. In January 772, Charlemagne retaliated with an attack on the Saxon's most important holy site, a sacred grove in southern Engria. "It was dominated by the Irminsul (‘Great Pillar’), which was either a (wooden) pillar or an ancient tree and presumably symbolized Germanic religion’s ‘Universal Tree’. The Franks cut down the Irminsul, looted the accumulated sacrificial treasures (which the King distributed among his men), and torched the entire grove... Charlemagne ordered a Frankish fortress to be erected at the Eresburg".
The practice of replacing pagan beliefs and motifs with Christian, and purposefully not recording the pagan history (such as the names of pagan gods, or details of pagan religious practices), has been compared to the practice of damnatio memoriae.
During the Reconquista and the Crusades, the cross served the symbolic function of possession that a flag would occupy today. In an account written by Osbernus at the siege of Lisbon in 1147, he recorded that a mixed group of Christians took the city: "What great joy and what a great abundance there was of pious tears when, to the praise and honor of God and of the most Holy Virgin Mary the saving cross was placed atop the highest tower to be seen by all as a symbol of the city's subjection."
The cross is currently the most common symbol of Christianity, and has been for many centuries. It came to prominence during the 4th century (301 to 400 AD), and is the most familiar and widely recognized symbol of Christianity today.
Ancient pagan funeral rituals often remained within Christian culture as aspects of custom and community with very little alteration. Pagan rituals symbolized grief through wailing and loud lamentation. Gregory of Nyssa modified this practice into antiphonal singing of psalms and hymns.
Pagans and Jews decorated their burial chambers, so Christians did as well, thereby creating the first Christian art in the catacombs beneath Rome. This art is symbolic, rising out of a reinterpretation of Jewish and pagan symbolism.
While many new subjects appear for the first time in the Christian catacombs - i.e. the Good Shepherd, Baptism, and the Eucharistic meal - the Orant figures (women praying with upraised hands) probably came directly from pagan art.
The Ichthys, Christian Fish, also known colloquially as the Jesus Fish, was an early Christian secret symbol. Early Christians used the Ichthys symbol to identify themselves as followers of Jesus Christ and to proclaim their commitment to Christianity. Ichthys is the Ancient Greek word for "fish," which explains why the sign resembles a fish; the Greek word ιχθυς is an acronym for the phrase transliterated as "Iesous Christos Theou Yios Soter", that is, "Jesus Christ, God's Son, the Savior". There are several other possible connections with Christian tradition relating to this symbol: that it was a reference to the feeding of the multitude; that it referred to some of the apostles having previously been fishermen; or that the word Christ was pronounced by Jews in a similar way to the Hebrew word for fish (though Nuna is the normal Aramaic word for fish, making this seem unlikely).
- ^ Michelle Salzman has shown that in the process of converting the Roman Empire's aristocracy, Christianity absorbed the values of that aristocracy. Several early Christian writers, including Justin (2nd century), Tertullian, and Origen (3rd century) wrote of Mithraists copying Christian beliefs. Christianity adopted aspects of Platonic thought, names for months and days of the week - even the concept of a seven-day week - from Roman paganism.
- ^ The Council of Jerusalem (around 50 AD) agreed the lack of circumcision could not be a basis for excluding Gentile believers from membership in the Jesus community. They instructed converts to avoid "pollution of idols, fornication, things strangled, and blood" (KJV, Acts 15:20–21). These were put into writing, distributed (KJV Acts 16:4–5) by messengers present at the council, and were received as an encouragement.
- ^ There have, historically, been many different scholarly views on Constantine's religious policies. For example Jacob Burckhardt has characterized Constantine as being "essentially unreligious" and as using the Church solely to support his power and ambition. Drake asserts that "critical reaction against Burckhardt's anachronistic reading has been decisive." According to Burckhardt, being Christian automatically meant being intolerant, while Drake says that assumes a uniformity of belief within Christianity that does not exist in the historical record.
Brown calls Constantine's conversion a "very Roman conversion." "He had risen to power in a series of deathly civil wars, destroyed the system of divided empire, believed the Christian God had brought him victory, and therefore regarded that god as the proper recipient of religio". Brown says Constantine was over 40, had most likely been a traditional polytheist, and was a savvy and ruthless politician when he declared himself a Christian.
- ^ During his long reign, Constantine destroyed a few temples, plundered more, and generally neglected the rest. In Eusebius' church history, there is a bold claim of a Constantinian campaign against the temples, however, there are discrepancies in the evidence. Temple destruction is attested to in 43 cases in the written sources, but only four have been confirmed by archaeological evidence. Trombley and MacMullen explain that discrepancies between literary sources and archaeological evidence exist because it is common for details in the literary sources to be ambiguous and unclear. For example, Malalas claimed Constantine destroyed all the temples, then he said Theodisius destroyed them all, then he said Constantine converted them all to churches. At the sacred oak and spring at Mamre, a site venerated and occupied by Jews, Christians, and pagans alike, the literature says Constantine ordered the burning of the idols, the destruction of the altar, and erection of a church on the spot of the temple. The archaeology of the site shows that Constantine’s church, along with its attendant buildings, only occupied a peripheral sector of the precinct, leaving the rest unhindered. A number of elements coincided to end the temples, but none of them were strictly religious. Earthquakes caused much of the destruction of this era. Civil conflict and external invasions also destroyed many temples and shrines. Economics was also a factor. The Roman economy of the third and fourth centuries struggled, and traditional polytheism was expensive and dependent upon donations from the state and private elites. Roger S. Bagnall reports that imperial financial support declined markedly after Augustus. Lower budgets meant the physical decline of urban structures of all types. This progressive decay was accompanied by an increased trade in salvaged building materials, as the practice of recycling became common in Late Antiquity. Economic struggles meant that necessity drove much of the destruction and conversion of pagan religious monuments. In many instances, such as in Tripolitania, this happened before Constantine the Great became emperor. Constantine "confiscated temple funds to help finance his own building projects", and he confiscated temple hoards of gold and silver to establish a stable currency; on a few occasions, he confiscated temple land; he refused to personally support pagan beliefs and practices while also speaking out against them. He forbade pagan sacrifices and closed temples that continued to offer them; he wrote laws that favored Christianity; he granted to Christians those governmental privileges, such as tax exemptions and the right to hold property, that had previously been available only to pagan priests; he personally endowed Christians with gifts of money, land and government positions. Yet Constantine never stopped the established state support of the traditional religious institutions.
- ^ Constantine did not destroy large numbers of temples, but he did destroy a few. In the previous 300 years, Roman authority had periodically confiscated various church properties, some of which were associated with Christian holy places. For example, Christian historians alleged that Hadrian (2nd century) had, in the military colony of Aelia Capitolina (Jerusalem), constructed a temple to Aphrodite on the site of the crucifixion of Jesus on Golgotha hill in order to suppress Jewish Christian veneration there. Constantine was vigorous in reclaiming confiscated properties whenever these issues were brought to his attention, and he used reclamation to justify the destruction of Aphrodite's temple in Jerusalem. Using the vocabulary of reclamation, Constantine acquired several more sites of Christian significance in the Holy Land.
Calculated acts of desecration - removing the hands and feet of statues of the divine, mutilating heads and genitals, tearing down altars and "purging sacred precincts with fire" - were acts committed by the people during the early centuries. While seen as 'proving' the impotence of the gods, pagan icons were also seen as having been “polluted” by the practice of sacrifice. They were, therefore, in need of "desacralization" or "deconsecration" (a practice not limited to Christians). Brown says that, while it was in some ways studiously vindictive, it was not indiscriminate or extensive. Once these objects were detached from 'the contagion' of sacrifice, they were seen as having returned to innocence. Many statues and temples were then preserved as art. Professor of Byzantine history Helen Saradi-Mendelovici writes that this process implies appreciation of antique art and a conscious desire to find a way to include it in Christian culture.
According to Alan Cameron, this violence was unofficial and without support from Christian clergy or state magistrates. There are only a few examples (i.e. Martin of Tours) of Christian officials having any involvement in the violent destruction of pagan shrines. In the 380s, one eastern official (generally identified as the praetorian prefect Cynegius), used the army under his control and bands of monks to destroy temples in the eastern provinces.
- ^ Numerous literary sources, both Christian and pagan, falsely attributed to Theodosius multiple anti-pagan initiatives such as the withdrawal of state funding to pagan cults (this measure belongs to Gratian) and the demolition of temples (for which there is no primary evidence). Theodosius was also associated with the ending of the Vestal virgins, but twenty-first century scholarship asserts the Virgins continued until 415 and suffered no more under Theodosius than they had since Gratian restricted their finances. Theodosius did turn pagan holidays into workdays, but the festivals associated with them continued. Theodosius was associated with ending the ancient Olympic Games, which he also probably did not do. Sofie Remijsen says there are several reasons to conclude the Olympic games continued after Theodosius I, and that they came to an end under Theodosius the second, by accident, instead. Two extant scholia on Lucian connect the end of the games with a fire that burned down the temple of the Olympian Zeus during Theodosius the second's reign.
- ^ The Edict of Thessalonica declared those Christians who refused the Nicene faith to be infames, and prohibited them from using Christian churches. Sáry uses this example: "After his arrival in Constantinople, Theodosius offered to confirm the Arian bishop Demophilus in his see, if he would accept the Nicene Creed. After Demophilus refused the offer, the emperor immediately directed him to surrender all his churches to the Catholics."
- ^ The English translation reads: "16.10.12 (8th November 392): Emperors Theodosius, Arcadius and Honorius to Rufinus, praetorian prefect: nobody, of whatsoever condition and class, who was appointed for an office or some privilege, should he be powerful for his origin or born in humble conditions, absolutely nowhere, in no city, shall offer an innocent victim to the meaningless idols, nor, as a worse sacrilege, worship the Lares with fire, the Genius with wine, the Penates with perfumes, nor shall light lamps or put incense after them, nor hang wreaths. If someone dares to sacrifice a victim or consult its still warm intrails, he’ll be charged for high treason and subject to the prescribed penalty, even though he didn’t try to divine anything in favour or against the prince’s health. For the crime to be grave it’s enough the will of going against the laws of nature, to investigate illicit things, to discover the hidden, to try the forbidden, to want to put an end to everyone else’s health, to hope in someone’s death. If someone adores, by putting incense after them, images made by human hands and therefore suffering the passing of time, or suddenly fears in a ridicule manner what himself made, or, after putting ribbons on a tree or constructing an altar out of clumps, tries to honor the vane idols with an even modest gift, but completely despising religion, he will be charged of religion violation and will be punished with confiscation of the house or land in which the superstition of gentiles will be proven to have survived. Therefore, all places in which will be proven that the smoke of incense raised, if they’re property of the person who burnt the incense, will be attributed to the imperial revenue. If the guilty tries some form of sacrifice in a public temple or sanctuary or in a place belonging to another person and if this latter is recognized unaware of what happened, the guilty will pay 25 pounds of gold and the same amount will be paid by every accomplice. We wish judges, defender and curial officers in every city to implement what we said, so that on one hand they refer violations to the court, on the other they punish the referred facts. But if they conceal something for benevolence or let it unpunished for negligence, they’ll underwent the trial; if they have been warned of the crime but omitted to implement the provided punishment, they would pay a fine of 30 pounds and so their staff."
- ^ The Theodosian Law Code has long been one of the principal historical sources for the study of Late Antiquity. Gibbon described the Theodosian decrees, in his Memoires, as a work of history rather than jurisprudence. Brown says the language of these laws is uniformly vehement, and penalties are harsh and frequently horrifying, leading some historians, such as Ramsay MacMullen, to see them as a 'declaration of war' on traditional religious practices.
It has been a common axiom among historians that the laws marked a turning point in the decline of paganism. Yet, many contemporary scholars such as Lepelley, Brown and Cameron, and others question using a legal document as a record of history. They say no legal code has the ability to tell how, or if, its policies were actually carried out. There is no record of anyone in Constantine's era being executed for sacrificing, nor is there evidence of any of the horrific punishments ever being enacted. Archaeologists Luke Lavan and Michael Mulryan have written that the Code can be seen to document "Christian ambition" but not historic reality.
The overtly violent fourth century that one would expect to find from taking the laws at face value is simply not supported by archaeological evidence from around the Mediterranean. Cameron concludes there is no solid evidence for a universal ban on paganism in the Roman empire.
- ^ During his first official tour of Italy (389–391), the emperor won over the influential pagan lobby in the Roman Senate by appointing its foremost members to important administrative posts. Theodosius also nominated the last pair of pagan consuls in Roman history (Tatianus and Symmachus) in 391. He also voiced his support for the preservation of temple buildings, but nonetheless failed to prevent the damaging of several holy sites in the eastern provinces. Following the death in 388 of Cynegius, the praetorian prefect thought to be responsible for that vandalization, Theodosius replaced him with a moderate pagan who subsequently moved to protect the temples. There is no evidence of any desire on the part of the emperor to institute a systematic destruction of temples anywhere in the Theodosian Code, and no evidence in the archaeological record that extensive temple destruction took place. According to Bayliss, "There is no single law of the Theodosian Code containing a specific order for the destruction of temples that does not include the pretext of sacrifice or idolatry. Even Theodosius’ law of 435, seen by most scholars as the coup de grace of surviving temples only applies to the temples of pagans who had committed illegal acts of sacrifice. It is quite possible that the significance of this law has been overemphasized by scholars".
- ^ In his 1984 book, Christianizing the Roman Empire: (A.D. 100–400), and again in 1997, Ramsay MacMullen argues that widespread Christian anti–pagan violence, as well as persecution from a "bloodthirsty" and violent Constantine (and his successors), caused the Christianization of the Roman Empire in the fourth century.
Award winning historian Michelle Renee Salzman describes MacMullen's book as "controversial".
In a review, T. D. Barnes has written that MacMullen's book treats "non-Christian evidence as better and more reliable than Christian evidence", generalizes from pagan polemics as if they were unchallenged fact, misses important facts entirely, and shows an important selectivity in his choices of what ancient and modern works he discusses.
David Bentley Hart also gives a detailed discussion of MacMullen's "careless misuse of textual evidence".
Schwarz says MacMullen is an example of a modern minimalist. Schwarz suggests that minimalism is beginning to show signs of decline because it tends to understate the significance of some human actions, and so makes assumptions that are hard to support. As a result, "MacMullen's account of Christianization as basically an aggregation of accidents and contingencies" is not broadly supported.
In Gaul, some of the most influential textual sources on pagan-Christian violence concerns Martin, Bishop of Tours (c. 371–397), the Pannonian ex-soldier who is "solely credited in the historical record as the militant converter of Gaul".
These texts have been criticized for lacking historical veracity, even by ancient critics, but they are still useful for illuminating views of violence held in late fourth century Gaul.
The portion of the sources devoted to attacks on pagans is limited, and they all revolve around Martin using his miraculous powers to overturn pagan shrines and idols, but not to ever threaten or harm people.
Salzman concludes that "None of Martin's interventions led to the deaths of any Gauls, pagan or Christian. Even if one doubts the exact veracity of these incidents, the assertion that Martin preferred non-violent conversion techniques says much about the norms for conversion in Gaul" at the time Martin's biography was written.
Archaeologist David Riggs writes that evidence from North Africa reveals a tolerance of religious pluralism and a vitality of traditional paganism much more than it shows any form of religious violence or coercion: "persuasion, such as the propagation of Christian apologetics, appears to have played a more critical role in the eventual "triumph of Christianity" than was previously assumed".
Archaeologists Luke Lavan and Michael Mulryan of the Centre for Late Antique Archaeology indicate that archaeology does not show evidence of widespread conflict.
In the twenty first century, the conflict model of Christianization has become marginalized. According to Raymond Van Dam, "an approach which emphasizes conflict flounders as a means for explaining both the initial attractions of a new cult like Christianity, as well as, more importantly, its persistence".
- ^ Constantine's sons banned pagan state religious sacrifices in 341. The content and intent of this law is much debated. In English, it says "Superstition shall cease; the madness of sacrifices shall be abolished. For if any man in violation of the law of the sainted Emperor, Our father, and in violation of this command of Our Clemency, should dare to perform sacrifices, he shall suffer the infliction of a suitable punishment and the effect of an immediate sentence." Interpretation depends entirely on what was meant by the term superstitio. In fact, independent testimony from the period 340-363 indicates that paganism and sacrifice continued in Rome despite the law.
- ^ St Barbatus, bishop of Benevento in the 670s, describes the Lombards in the city of Benevento as worshipping a simulacrum of a viper and swearing oaths as they galloped past a hide hung on a tree. When St. Barbatus converted the Beneventine Lombards to Christianity, he caused the tree to be cut down but some centuries afterwards, in 1526, Judge Paolo Grillandi wrote of witches in Benevento who worship a goddess at the site of an old walnut tree. The laws issued for the Lombards by King Liutprand in 727 condemned, along with divination, the practice of 'sorcery' and incantation, any Lombard "who like a rustic prays to a tree as sacred or adores springs".
- ^ Grave goods, which of course are not a Christian practice, have been found until that time; see: Padberg (1998), p. 59
- ^ Historian Ivo Štefan asserts that, in general, adoption of Christianity in Bohemia, Poland and Hungary was not forced either by pressure from outside or by violence.
- ^ People living during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries experienced Plague, famine and war that ravaged most of the continent, social unrest, urban riots, peasant revolts and renegade feudal armies, and the religious changes often forced upon them by their new monarchies. They did so with a church unable to provide much moral leadership as a result of its own internal conflict and corruption. The church reached its nadir from 1309 to 1377 when there were three different men claiming to be the rightful Pope. Ullmann writes: "What the observer of the papacy witnessed in [these] centuries was a gradual, though clearly perceptible, decomposition of Europe as a single ecclesiastical unit, and the fragmentation of Europe into independent, autonomous entities which were soon to be called national monarchies or states. This fragmentation heralded the withering away of the papacy as a governing institution operating on a universal scale." ...The [later] Reformation only administered the coup de grâce."
- ^ Between 1147 when Pope Eugene called for crusade, and 1347 when bubonic plague arrived in Europe, the intervening 200 years saw the greatest territorial expansion of medieval German history: 2,214 towns on the southern shores of the Baltic Sea were chartered, "903 were chartered within regions across the Elbe river, along the Baltic coast northwest of the old heartland of the German kingdom." Aiden Lilienfeld has written that, "These Northern Crusades are largely unknown to all but the more dedicated students of medieval Europe, but they hold such an enduring weight in German history that the rhetoric and culture surrounding them still had a key role in Nazi expansion into Slavic lands 800 years later".
- Anti-paganism policies of the early Byzantine Empire
- Christianity and other religions
- Christianity and violence
- Forcible conversion to Christianity
- History of Christianity
- History of Christian thought on persecution and tolerance
- Role of Christianity in civilization
- Spread of Christianity
- European colonization of the Americas
- Goa Inquisition
- Taiping Rebellion
- Christianization of Anglo-Saxon England
- Christianization of England
- Christianization of Ireland
- Christianization of the Celtic peoples
- Christianization of Roman (Southern) France
- Christianization of Bavaria
- Christianization of the Netherlands
- Christianization of the Swiss
- Christianization of Lithuania
- Christianization of the Faroe Islands
- Christianization of the Basque people
- Christianization of Iceland
- Christianization of Scandinavia
- Christianization of Finland
- Christianization of Kievan Rus'
- Christianization of the Rus' Khaganate
- Christianization of Poland
- Christianization of Bulgaria
- Christianization of Armenia
- Christianization of Goa
- Christianization of Tonga
- In other religions
- ^ a b c d e f Štefan 2022, p. 101.
- ^ a b Klaniczay 2004, p. 99.
- ^ Leighton 2021, pp. 393–408.
- ^ Ščavinskas 2017, p. 57.
- ^ a b c Ščavinskas 2017, p. 59.
- ^ Puspitasari 2013, pp. 87–88.
- ^ Scourfield 2007, p. 2.
- ^ Salzman 2002, pp. 200–219.
- ^ Abruzzi 2018, p. 24.
- ^ Rausing 1995, p. 229.
- ^ Scourfield 2007, pp. 18, 20–22.
- ^ a b c Gregory 1986, p. 234.
- ^ Collar 2013, pp. 1–10.
- ^ Ščavinskas 2017, p. 61.
- ^ Shorter 2006, p. 11.
- ^ a b Clark 1979, p. 377.
- ^ a b Cusack 1998, p. 35.
- ^ Clark 1979, p. 394.
- ^ a b Berkhofer 2014, pp. x–xi.
- ^ Berkhofer 2014, p. xi.
- ^ Clark 1979, pp. 377–380.
- ^ a b Sanneh 2007, p. 134-137.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, p. 271.
- ^ a b Sam & Berry 2010, p. abstract.
- ^ Burton 2018, p. 129.
- ^ Runciman 2004, p. 6.
- ^ Collar 2013, p. 6.
- ^ Collar 2013, pp. 6, 36, 39.
- ^ Collar 2013, p. 325.
- ^ Harnett 2017, pp. 200, 217.
- ^ Hopkins 1998, p. 193.
- ^ Runciman 2004, p. 3.
- ^ Runciman 2004, p. 4.
- ^ Meeks 2003, p. 79.
- ^ Praet 1992, p. 49.
- ^ Fahy 1963, p. 249.
- ^ Fahy 1963, p. 257.
- ^ Praet 1992, p. 45–48.
- ^ Meeks 2003, p. 81.
- ^ a b Trebilco 2017, pp. 85, 218.
- ^ Hopkins 1998, p. 187.
- ^ Green 2010, pp. 126–127.
- ^ Praet 1992, p. 68;108.
- ^ Crislip 2005, p. 1-3.
- ^ Gibbon 1776, Chapter 38.
- ^ Cohan 2005, p. 333.
- ^ Aleksidze 2018, p. 138.
- ^ a b Aleksidze 2018, p. 135.
- ^ Thomson 1988, p. 35.
- ^ a b Thomson 1988, p. 45.
- ^ Rapp 2007, p. 138.
- ^ Aleksidze 2018, pp. 135–136.
- ^ Horn 1998, p. 262.
- ^ Brita 2020, p. 252.
- ^ Brown 1998, p. 652.
- ^ Brown 1998, pp. 652–653.
- ^ Siecienski 2017, p. 3.
- ^ Drake 1995, pp. 2, 15.
- ^ Drake 1995, pp. 1, 2.
- ^ Drake 1995, p. 3.
- ^ a b Brown 2012, p. 61.
- ^ Brown 2012, pp. 60–61.
- ^ a b Siecienski 2017, p. 4.
- ^ a b c Leithart 2010, p. 302.
- ^ a b Wiemer 1994, p. 523.
- ^ Drake 1995, p. 7–9.
- ^ Bradbury 1994, pp. 122–126.
- ^ Leithart 2010, p. 304.
- ^ a b c Brown 2003, p. 74.
- ^ Thompson 2005, p. 87,93.
- ^ Drake 1995, pp. 3, 7.
- ^ Digeser 2000, p. 169.
- ^ Bradbury 1994, p. 123.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, pp. xxvii, xxiv.
- ^ Trombley 1995a, pp. 166–168, 335–336.
- ^ Trombley 2001, pp. 246–282.
- ^ Bayliss 2004, p. 110.
- ^ Bradbury 1994, p. 131.
- ^ Bayliss 2004, p. 31.
- ^ a b c Leone 2013, p. 82.
- ^ Leone 2013, p. 28.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. xxvi.
- ^ a b Bradbury 1995, p. 353.
- ^ a b Brown 2003, p. 60.
- ^ Jones 1986, pp. 8–10, 13, 735.
- ^ Bagnall 2021, pp. 261–269.
- ^ Leone 2013, p. 2.
- ^ Leone 2013, p. 29.
- ^ Bradbury 1995.
- ^ a b Boyd 2005, p. 16.
- ^ a b Southern 2015, p. 455–457.
- ^ Gerberding & Moran Cruz 2004, p. 55–56.
- ^ a b Bayliss 2004, p. 243.
- ^ a b Digeser 2000, pp. 168–169.
- ^ a b Thompson 2005, p. 93.
- ^ Bradbury 1995, p. 345-356.
- ^ Loosley 2012, p. 3.
- ^ Bayliss 2004, p. 30.
- ^ Bradbury 1994, p. 132.
- ^ Brown 1998, pp. 649–652.
- ^ a b Brown 1998, p. 650.
- ^ Bayliss 2004, pp. 39, 40.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. 303.
- ^ Cameron 2011, p. 799.
- ^ Salzman 2006, pp. 284–285.
- ^ Haas 2002, pp. 160–162.
- ^ a b c Constantelos 1964, p. 372.
- ^ Brown 1998, pp. 641, 645.
- ^ a b Brown 1998, p. 645.
- ^ Salzman 2002, p. 182.
- ^ Kahlos 2015, p. 12.
- ^ Kahlos 2015, pp. 11, 28.
- ^ Brown 1993, pp. 90–91, 640.
- ^ a b Kahlos 2015, p. 28.
- ^ a b Hebblewhite 2020, p. 3.
- ^ Hebblewhite 2020, p. 3-5.
- ^ Cameron 1993, p. 74 (note 177).
- ^ Cameron 1993, pp. 46–47, 72.
- ^ Testa 2007, p. 260.
- ^ Graf, pp. 229–232.
- ^ Perrottet 2004, pp. 190–.
- ^ Hamlet 2004, pp. 53–75.
- ^ Remijsen 2015, p. 49.
- ^ a b Hebblewhite 2020, chapter 8; 82.
- ^ Sáry 2019, pp. 72–74, 77.
- ^ Sáry 2019, pp. 72–74, fn. 32, 33, 34, 77.
- ^ Sáry 2019, pp. 73, 77.
- ^ Sáry 2019, p. 79.
- ^ Errington 2006, chapter 8; 248–249, 251.
- ^ Errington 1997, pp. 410–415.
- ^ Simioni, Manuela. "THEODOSIAN CODE (CODEX THEODOSIANUS) 16.10: TEXT". European Pagan Memory Day. Retrieved February 14, 2023.
- ^ Cameron 2011, pp. 61.
- ^ Bilias & Grigolo 2019, p. 82.
- ^ Kahlos 2019, p. 146.
- ^ Roux 2018.
- ^ Simeoni n.d.
- ^ Errington 1997, p. 431.
- ^ Cameron 2011, pp. 60, 63, 68.
- ^ a b c Lepelley 1992, pp. 50–76.
- ^ Quinault & McKitterick 2002, p. 25.
- ^ MacMullen 1981, p. 100.
- ^ Brown 1998, p. 638.
- ^ Trombley 2001, p. 12.
- ^ Stachura 2018, p. 246.
- ^ Salzman 1993, p. 378.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. xxii.
- ^ Mulryan 2011, p. 41.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, pp. xxi, 138.
- ^ Errington 1997, p. 398.
- ^ Cameron 2011, pp. 61, 99.
- ^ Sáry 2019, p. 73.
- ^ Kahlos 2019, p. 35 (and note 45).
- ^ Errington 2006, pp. 245, 251.
- ^ a b Woods, Religious Policy.
- ^ Cameron 2011, pp. 56, 64.
- ^ Bagnall et al 1987, p. 317.
- ^ Errington 2006, p. 249.
- ^ MacMullen 1984, p. 90.
- ^ Trombley 2001, p. 53.
- ^ a b Hebblewhite 2020, chapter 8.
- ^ Cameron 2011, p. 57.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. xxx.
- ^ Fowden 1978, p. 63.
- ^ Bayliss 2004, p. 41.
- ^ Errington 2006, p. 251.
- ^ Cameron 2011, p. 71.
- ^ Drake 2011, p. 196.
- ^ a b Drake 1996, p. 10.
- ^ a b Drake 2011, p. 203.
- ^ Brown 1998, p. 640.
- ^ Salzman 2006, pp. 268–269.
- ^ Marcos 2013, pp. 1–16.
- ^ MacMullen 1984, p. 46–50.
- ^ a b Salzman 2006, p. 265.
- ^ Barnes 1985, p. 496.
- ^ Hart 2009, p. 148-152.
- ^ Schwartz 2005, p. 150–151.
- ^ Schwartz 2005, p. 152.
- ^ Schwartz 2005, p. 150–152.
- ^ Salzman 2006, p. 278–279.
- ^ Salzman 2006, p. 279.
- ^ Salzman 2006, p. 280.
- ^ Salzman 2006, p. 282.
- ^ Riggs 2006, p. 297; 308.
- ^ Salzman, Sághy & Testa 2016, p. 2.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. 155.
- ^ Scourfield 2007, p. 2–4.
- ^ Van Dam 1985, p. 2.
- ^ Stocking 2000, p. 135 fn. 68.
- ^ García-Arenal & Glazer-Eytan 2019, p. 19.
- ^ García-Arenal & Glazer-Eytan 2019, p. 4.
- ^ Bradbury 1994, p. 126.
- ^ Salzman 1987, p. 179.
- ^ Salzman 1987, p. 180.
- ^ Salzman 1987, p. 181.
- ^ Cusack 1998, p. 56 fn.50.
- ^ Cusack 1998, p. 56; 39.
- ^ Lenski 1995, p. 80.
- ^ Cusack 1998, p. 37.
- ^ Cusack 1998, p. 78; 101.
- ^ Fletcher 1999, pp. 236–238.
- ^ Lenski 1995, p. 55.
- ^ Russell 1996, p. 138.
- ^ Cusack 1998, p. 58.
- ^ Lenski 1995, p. 51.
- ^ a b c d e f Ghosh 2016, p. 116.
- ^ a b c Padberg 1998, p. 48.
- ^ Schramm 1994.
- ^ Kelly 1989, p. 8.
- ^ Grimassi 2000, p. 454.
- ^ Dunn 2013, p. 107.
- ^ Roe 1980, p. 101.
- ^ a b c d e Lund 2022, p. 113.
- ^ a b c Harney 2017, p. 103.
- ^ Haley 2002, p. 96.
- ^ a b Harney 2017, p. 117.
- ^ Harney 2017, p. 119.
- ^ Harney 2017, p. 104.
- ^ Harney 2017, p. 120,121.
- ^ Padberg 1998, p. 67.
- ^ Thomas 1981, p. 34.
- ^ Thomas 1997, p. 506–507.
- ^ Sharpe 1995, pp. 30–33.
- ^ Wood 2007, pp. 20–22.
- ^ Wood 2007, p. 34.
- ^ Harney 2017, p. 107.
- ^ Brown 2003, p. 137.
- ^ Danuta 1998, pp. 29–57.
- ^ Padberg 1998, pp. 45–48, 53.
- ^ Riché 1993, p. 87.
- ^ Riché 1993, pp. 105, 161.
- ^ Barbero 2004, p. 46.
- ^ Riché 1993, p. 299.
- ^ Paul 2016, p. 60.
- ^ Scourfield 2007, p. 4.
- ^ Brown 1998, p. 641.
- ^ Dunn 2016, p. 60.
- ^ Koenig, King & Carson 2012, pp. 22–24.
- ^ Monroe 1909, p. 253.
- ^ Haight 2004, p. 273.
- ^ Butler 1919, pp. 3–8.
- ^ Gregory 1986, p. 235-236.
- ^ a b c d Gregory 1986, p. 233.
- ^ Gregory 1986, pp. 233–236.
- ^ Gregory 1986, p. 242.
- ^ Saradi 2011, pp. 261–309.
- ^ Gregory 1986, p. 241.
- ^ Pontani 2015, p. 398.
- ^ Barton 2009, p. 6,7.
- ^ a b c Barton 2009, p. 11.
- ^ a b Barton 2009, p. 12.
- ^ Barton 2009, p. 13-14.
- ^ Bouchier 1914, p. 58.
- ^ Bouchier 1914, pp. 58–59.
- ^ Jimeno Jurío 1995, p. 47.
- ^ Leone 2013, pp. 13, 42.
- ^ Cameron 1993, p. 392–393.
- ^ Brown 1963, p. 284.
- ^ Clark 1992, pp. 543–546.
- ^ Markus 1990, pp. 141–142.
- ^ Cameron 2011, pp. 8–10.
- ^ García-Arenal & Glazer-Eytan 2019, pp. 5–6.
- ^ García-Arenal & Glazer-Eytan 2019, pp. 5–6, 15.
- ^ Irmscher 1988, p. 165.
- ^ Anastos 1967, pp. 13–41.
- ^ a b c Herrin 2009, p. 213.
- ^ Kaldellis 2012, pp. 1–3.
- ^ Kaldellis 2012, p. 2.
- ^ Stern 1998, p. 151.
- ^ Mansi 1762, p. 970B.
- ^ Kaldellis 2012, p. 3.
- ^ Irmscher 1988, p. 166.
- ^ Lichtenberger & Raja 2018, pp. 85–98.
- ^ Ekonomou 2007, p. 1, 3.
- ^ Salzman 2021, p. 298.
- ^ a b c Salzman 2021, p. 335.
- ^ Salzman 2021, p. 299.
- ^ a b Sanmark 2004, p. 15.
- ^ Ekonomou 2007, pp. 245–247.
- ^ Gregory 1986, p. 232.
- ^ Brown 1961, p. 85.
- ^ Miller 1974, p. 79–81.
- ^ Salzman 2021, pp. 335–336.
- ^ Ekonomou 2007, pp. 63–64.
- ^ a b Crampton 2005, p. 13.
- ^ Osenova 2010, p. 644.
- ^ Crampton 2005, p. 8.
- ^ Ziemann 2021, pp. 329–330.
- ^ Ziemann 2021, p. 331.
- ^ Ziemann 2021, pp. 331–332.
- ^ Crampton 2005, pp. 9–10.
- ^ Crampton 2005, p. 11.
- ^ Crampton 2005, pp. 13–14.
- ^ Crampton 2005, pp. 14–16.
- ^ a b c Ziemann 2021, p. 332.
- ^ a b c d Radić 2010, p. 232.
- ^ a b Vlasto 1970, p. 208.
- ^ Rastko n.d.
- ^ Vlasto 1970, pp. 208–209.
- ^ a b Vlasto 1970, p. 209.
- ^ Vlasto 1970, p. 210.
- ^ Popovski 2017, p. none available.
- ^ Antoljak 1994, p. 43.
- ^ Evans 2007, p. 363.
- ^ Veszprémy 2001, p. 83.
- ^ Friese 2017.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, p. 123.
- ^ Poulik 1978, pp. 158–171.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, p. 125.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, pp. 124–125.
- ^ a b Ivanič 2016, p. 124.
- ^ Goldberg 2006, pp. 16, 83–84.
- ^ Barford 2001, p. 218.
- ^ Sommer, Trestik & Zemlicka 2007, pp. 214–262.
- ^ a b Barford 2001, p. 219.
- ^ a b Schaff n.d., pp. 161–162.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, pp. 126, 129.
- ^ a b c Ivanič 2016, p. 127.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, p. 128.
- ^ Ivanič 2016, p. 129.
- ^ a b Constable 1998, pp. 4–5.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 215.
- ^ Constable 1998, p. 4.
- ^ Jestice 1997, p. 1; 5-6.
- ^ Fox 1987, p. 298.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 219.
- ^ Duni 2016, pp. 204–205.
- ^ Champion 2011, p. 183.
- ^ a b Jestice 1997, p. 57.
- ^ a b c Štefan 2022, p. 112.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 219; 221.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, pp. 209–210.
- ^ Moore 2007, pp. 4, 5, 132.
- ^ Moore 2007, p. 4.
- ^ a b c d e Schacter 2011, p. 2.
- ^ Shatzmiller 1974, p. 339.
- ^ Schacter 2011, p. 58.
- ^ Moore 2007, p. 7.
- ^ Moore 2007, p. 87.
- ^ Moore 2007, pp. vi, 154.
- ^ Waugh & Diehl 2002, p. 224.
- ^ Cotts 2012, pp. 8–10.
- ^ Moore 2007, pp. 146–154.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 247.
- ^ a b c d e Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 248.
- ^ Schrader 1936, pp. 259–282.
- ^ a b Ullmann 2005, p. xv.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 248–250.
- ^ Veszprémy 2001, p. 87.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 243.
- ^ Olson 1999, p. 348.
- ^ Ullmann 2005, p. 176.
- ^ de Bérier & Domingo 2022, p. 3.
- ^ a b c Bukowska 2012, p. 467.
- ^ Moravcsik 1947, p. 134.
- ^ Moravcsik 1947, pp. 134–135.
- ^ Berend, Urbańczyk & Wiszewski 2013, p. 130.
- ^ Stephenson 2000, p. 40.
- ^ Jestice 1997, pp. 1–2, fn.1.
- ^ Veszprémy 2001, p. 75.
- ^ a b c d Sedlar 1995, pp. 1119–1120.
- ^ Moravcsik 1947, p. 141.
- ^ Veszprémy 2001, p. 79.
- ^ Sisa 1995, p. 169-170.
- ^ Veszprémy 2001, pp. 86–87.
- ^ Štefan 2022, pp. 110–111.
- ^ a b c d e Štefan 2022, p. 111.
- ^ Štefan 2022, p. 103.
- ^ Štefan 2022, p. 101; 112.
- ^ a b Poppe 1991, p. 15.
- ^ Poppe 1991, p. 12.
- ^ Štefan 2022, p. 113.
- ^ Poppe 1991, p. 14.
- ^ Sanmark 2004, pp. 19–20.
- ^ Brown 2012, p. 464.
- ^ Sanmark 2004, pp. 14, 15.
- ^ Sanmark 2004, p. 21.
- ^ a b Sanmark 2004, p. 22.
- ^ Harmer 1946, p. 122.
- ^ Brown 2012, p. 473.
- ^ Murphy 2014, p. 542.
- ^ Winroth 2012, p. abstract.
- ^ Wicker 2012, p. 260-262.
- ^ Wicker 2012, p. 261.
- ^ Schön 2004, p. 170.
- ^ Schön 2004, p. 172.
- ^ Schön 2004, p. 173.
- ^ Sanmark 2004, p. 14.
- ^ Brink 2004, p. xvi.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, p. 23.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, p. 12.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, pp. 23–25.
- ^ a b Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, p. 65.
- ^ Firlej 2021–2022, p. 121.
- ^ Firlej 2021–2022, pp. 120, 133.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, p. 71.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2009, p. 119.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, p. 287.
- ^ Hunyadi & Laszlovszky 2001, p. 606.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, pp. 65, 75–77.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, pp. 10–15.
- ^ Dragnea 2020, pp. 5–6.
- ^ a b c d e f g Lilienfeld 2022.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, pp. 23–24, 29.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, pp. 23, 24.
- ^ Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, p. 76.
- ^ a b Fonnesberg-Schmidt 2007, p. 24.
- ^ Haverkamp 1988, pp. 157–158.
- ^ Boockmann 1975, p. 58.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, p. 57.
- ^ Tyerman 2011, pp. 23–44.
- ^ Dollinger 1999, p. 34.
- ^ Forstreuter 1938, p. 9.
- ^ Christiansen 1997, pp. 14–15.
- ^ a b Barton 2009, p. xvii.
- ^ Rawlings 2006, pp. 1–2.
- ^ Mathew 2018, pp. 52–53.
- ^ Casanova 1994, p. 75.
- ^ Rawlings 2006, p. 2.
- ^ a b Pop 2009, p. 249.
- ^ a b c d Pop 2009, p. 252.
- ^ Pop 2009, p. 246.
- ^ Pop 2009, p. 250.
- ^ Pop 2009, pp. 245, 249.
- ^ Pop 2009, p. 251.
- ^ Pop 2009, p. 253.
- ^ Elsie 2015, p. 7.
- ^ Plontke-Lüning 2017, abstract.
- ^ Hakobyan 2021, p. abstract.
- ^ Seibt 2002, p. abstract.
- ^ Elsie 2015, p. 5.
- ^ Wyrwińska 2022, pp. 48–63.
- ^ Wyrwińska 2022, pp. 3–4.
- ^ Matthews & Platt 1992, p. 304.
- ^ Nowell, Magdoff & Webster 2022.
- ^ Robinson 1952, p. 152.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, pp. 131–132.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, p. 135.
- ^ Gonzalez 2010, p. 418.
- ^ a b de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, p. Conditions at Times of Colonial Intervention.
- ^ de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, p. Colonial Legacies and Economic Development.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, p. 218.
- ^ Cheng 1999, p. 205.
- ^ Paiva 2017, pp. 568, 585.
- ^ Paiva 2017, p. 566.
- ^ Paiva 2017, pp. 567–568.
- ^ Paiva 2017, pp. 588, 591.
- ^ Woods 2012, p. 135.
- ^ Spliesgart 2007, p. 287.
- ^ Woods 2012, p. 137.
- ^ Johansen 2005, pp. 109–110.
- ^ Castañeda 1993, p. 15.
- ^ Castañeda 1993, p. 19.
- ^ Castañeda 1993, pp. 23–26.
- ^ Castañeda 1993, pp. 28–29.
- ^ Strauss et al. 2005, pp. 230, 454.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, p. 6.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, p. 1.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, pp. 1–2.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, pp. 2–5.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, pp. 6–7.
- ^ Berkhofer 2014, p. ix–xii.
- ^ Oostindie 2008, p. 8.
- ^ Belmessous 2013, p. 7.
- ^ Britannica & British Empire 2023.
- ^ Robinson 1952, pp. 152–168.
- ^ Schacter 2011, p. 5.
- ^ Schacter 2011, p. 3.
- ^ Headrick 2012, p. 2.
- ^ de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, p. introduction/Conditions at Times of Colonial Intervention.
- ^ a b c Magdoff & McDougall 2020.
- ^ Gonzalez 2010, p. 302.
- ^ Barker & Lowman n.d.
- ^ Noll 1992, p. 185.
- ^ a b Noll 1992, p. 188.
- ^ Noll 1992, pp. 188–190.
- ^ a b McLoughlin 1984, p. abstract.
- ^ Eder & Reyhner 2017, p. 3.
- ^ Eder & Reyhner 2017, p. 6.
- ^ Boyle 2010, p. abstract.
- ^ de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, p. 161.
- ^ de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, pp. 159–162.
- ^ de Juan & Pierskalla 2017, pp. 161–162.
- ^ Fontaine 2016, p. 6.
- ^ Fontaine 2016, p. 6-7.
- ^ Fontaine 2016, pp. 7–8.
- ^ Fontaine 2016, p. 8.
- ^ a b Sanneh 2007, p. 285.
- ^ a b c d Sanneh 2007, p. xx.
- ^ "Religion in Africa 2022". Find Easy population & more. PEW Research Center. Retrieved February 4, 2023.
- ^ Sanneh & McClymond 2016, p. 265.
- ^ Sanneh & McClymond 2016, p. 279.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, pp. xx–xxii.
- ^ Sanneh 2007, p. xxi.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. xxxix.
- ^ Markus 1990, p. 142.
- ^ Schuddeboom 2017, pp. 166–167, 177.
- ^ Severus - Vita.
- ^ Lavan & Mulryan 2011, p. 178.
- ^ Hanson 1978, p. 257.
- ^ Schuddeboom 2017, p. 181-182.
- ^ Schuddeboom 2017, pp. 169.
- ^ Schuddeboom 2017, p. 179.
- ^ Schuddeboom 2017, pp. 181–182.
- ^ Farmer 1995, p. 26.
- ^ Bede 2007, p. 53.
- ^ Fletcher 1999, p. 254.
- ^ Weston 1942, p. 26.
- ^ Harney 2017, pp. 119–121.
- ^ Dean 2015, pp. 15–16.
- ^ Dean 2015, p. 16.
- ^ Dean 2015, pp. 16–17.
- ^ Strzelczyk 1987, p. 60.
- ^ De expugnatione Lyxbonensi 1147.
- ^ a b c Fairchild 2021.
- ^ Testa 1998, p. 78.
- ^ Alexiou & Yatromanolakis 2002, p. 13.
- ^ Testa 1998, p. 80.
- ^ Goodenough 1962, p. 138.
- ^ Testa 1998, p. 82.
- ^ Goodenough 1962, p. 125.
- Abruzzi, William (2018). Mithraism and Christianity. doi:10.13140/RG.2.2.36486.52804.
- Aleksidze, Nikoloz (2018). "7: Caucasia: Albania, Armenia and Georgia". In Lössl, Josef; Baker-Brian, Nicholas J. (eds.). A Companion to Religion in Late Antiquity. John Wiley and Sons. ISBN 9781118968109.
- Alexiou, Margaret; Yatromanolakis, Dimitrios (2002). The ritual lament in Greek tradition. Rowman & Littlefield.
- Anastos, Milton (1967). "The Edict of Milan (313): A Defence of Its Traditional Authorship and Designation". Revue des études byzantines. 25 (1): 13–41. doi:10.3406/rebyz.1967.1383.
- Antoljak, Stjepan (1994). Pregled hrvatske povijesti (2. dopunjeno izd ed.). Split: Orbis. ISBN 953-6044-01-3.
- Bagnall, Roger S.; Alan Cameron; Seth R. Schwartz & Klaas A. Worp (1987). Consuls of the Later Roman Empire. Oxford University Press. ISBN 1-55540-099-X.
- Bagnall, Roger S. (2021). Egypt in Late Antiquity (illustrated, reprint ed.). Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-1-4008-2116-7.
- Barbero, Alessandro (2004). Charlemagne: Father of a Continent. University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-23943-2.
- Barford, P. M. (2001). The early Slavs : culture and society in early medieval Eastern Europe. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
- Barker, Adam; Lowman, Emma Battell (n.d.). "Settler colonialism". Global Social Theory. Retrieved January 22, 2023.
- Barnes, T.D. (1985). "Review of Christianizing the Roman Empire A.D. 100–400 by R. Macmullen". Echos du Monde Classique: Classical Views. 29 (3): 495–496.
- Barton, Simon (2009). A History of Spain (2nd, revised ed.). Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9781137013477.
- Bayliss, Richard (2004). Provincial Cilicia and the Archaeology of Temple Conversion. Oxford: Archaeopress. ISBN 978-1-84171-634-3.
- Bede (2007) . The Ecclesiastical History of the English Nation. Translated by Jane, L. C. New York: Cosimo Classics. ISBN 9781602068322. Retrieved September 16, 2017.
- Belmessous, Saliha (2013). Assimilation and Empire: Uniformity in French and British Colonies, 1541-1954. OUP. ISBN 9780199579167.
- Berend, Nora; Urbańczyk, Przemysław; Wiszewski, Przemysław (2013). Central Europe in the High Middle Ages: Bohemia, Hungary and Poland, c. 900-c. 1300. New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521781565.
- Berkhofer, Robert F., Jr. (2014). Salvation and the Savage: An Analysis of Protestant Missions and American Indian Response, 1787–1862. University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 9780813162102.
- Bilias, Konstantinos; Grigolo, Francesca (2019). "04 Lares and lararia: The domestic religion brought out to the sidewalk". public private. An exhibition of the Q-Kolleg at the Winckelmann-Institut Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin in cooperation with the Dipartimento Scienza dell` Antichitá of the Sapienza-Università di Roma (19/06/2019 – 31/12/2019). Berlin, Germany: Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. pp. 79–101. doi:10.18452/20022.
- Boockmann, Hartmut (1975). Johannes Falkenberg, der Deutsche Orden und die polnische Politik. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. ISBN 9783525353547.
- Bouchier, Edmund Spenser (1914). Spain Under the Roman Empire. B. H. Blackwell.
- Boyd, William Kenneth (2005). The Ecclesiastical Edicts of the Theodosian Code (reprint ed.). The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd. ISBN 9781584775317.
- Boyle, Mark (2010). "Beyond the 'Sigh of the Oppressed Creature': A Critical Geographical Enquiry into Christianity's Contributions to the Making of a Peaceable West". Annals of the Association of American Geographers. 100 (3): 678–94. doi:10.1080/00045601003795095. JSTOR 40863555. S2CID 55367128.
- Bradbury, Scott (1995). "Julian's Pagan Revival and the Decline of Blood Sacrifice". Phoenix. 49 (4): 331–56. doi:10.2307/1088885. JSTOR 1088885.
- Bradbury, Scott (1994). "Constantine and the Problem of Anti-Pagan Legislation in the Fourth Century". Classical Philology. 89 (2): 120–139. doi:10.1086/367402. S2CID 159997492.
- Brink, Stefan (2004). "New Perspectives on the Christianization of Scandinavia and the Organization of the Early Church". Scandinavia and Europe 800-1350: Contact, Conflict, and Coexistence. ISD. pp. 163–175. ISBN 9782503510859.
- Brita, Antonella (2020). "Genres of Ethiopian-Eritrean Christian Literature with a Focus on Hagiography". In Kelly, Samantha (ed.). A Companion to Medieval Ethiopia and Eritrea. Brill. pp. 252–281. ISBN 978-90-04-41943-8.
- "British Empire". British Empire | History, Countries, Map, Size, & Facts | Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica. January 5, 2023. Retrieved January 23, 2023.
- Brown, P. R. L. (1961). "Religious dissent in the later Roman empire: the case of North Africa". History. 46 (157): 83–101. doi:10.1111/j.1468-229X.1961.tb02436.x. ISSN 0018-2648. JSTOR 24405338.
- Brown, Peter (1963). "Religious Coercion in the Later Roman Empire: The Case of North Africa". History. Wiley. 48 (164): 283–305. doi:10.1111/j.1468-229X.1963.tb02320.x. JSTOR 24405550.
- Brown, Peter (1998). "Christianization and religious conflict". In Averil Cameron; Peter Garnsey (eds.). The Cambridge Ancient History XIII: The Late Empire, A.D. 337–425. Cambridge University Press. pp. 632–664. ISBN 978-0-521-30200-5.
- Brown, Peter (1993). "The Problem of Christianization" (PDF). Proceedings of the British Academy. Oxford University Press. 84: 89–106.
- Brown, Peter (2003). The rise of Western Christendom : triumph and diversity, A.D. 200-1000 (2nd ed.). Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers. ISBN 978-0-631-22137-1.
- Brown, Peter (2012). Through the Eye of a Needle: Wealth, the Fall of Rome, and the Making of Christianity in the West, 350–550 AD. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0-691-15290-5.
- Bukowska, Aneta (2012). "The Origins of Christianity in Poland. Actual Research on the Church Archaeology". Christianisierung Europas: Entstehung, Entwicklung und Konsolidierung im archäologischen Befund. Schnell & Steiner. pp. 449–468.
- Burton, Edward (January 19, 2018). "Chapter IV: "Paul is sent to Rome"". History of the Christian Church in the 1st Century. Ozymandias Press. ISBN 978-1-5312-8668-2.
- Butler, Cuthbert (1919). Benedictine Monachism: Studies in Benedictine Life and Rule. New York: Longmans, Green and Company.
- Cameron, Averil (1993). The Later Roman Empire, AD 284-430 (illustrated ed.). Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-51194-1.
- Cameron, Alan (2011). The Last Pagans of Rome. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-974727-6.
- Casanova, José (1994). Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0-226-09535-5.
- Castañeda, Antonia I. (1993). "Two: Sexual violence in the politics and policies of Conquest". In de la Torre, Adela; Pesquera, Beatriz M. (eds.). Building with Our Hands: New Directions in Chicana Studies. University of California Press. ISBN 9780520070905.
- Champion, Matthew (2011). "Crushing the Canon: Nicolas Jacquier's Response to the Canon Episcopi in the Flagellum haereticorum fascinariorum" (PDF). Magic, Ritual, and Witchcraft. 6 (2): 183–211. doi:10.1353/mrw.2011.0022. S2CID 73545212.
- Cheng, Christina Miu Bing (1999). Macau A Cultural Janus. Hong Kong University Press. ISBN 9789622094864.
- Christiansen, Eric (1997). The Northern Crusades. London: Penguin books. ISBN 978-0140266535.
- Clark, Elizabeth A. (1992). "The End of Ancient Christianity". Ancient Philosophy. 12 (2): 543–546. doi:10.5840/ancientphil199212240.
- Clark, Jerry E. (1979). "Jesuit Impact on Potawatomi Acculturation: A Comparison of Two Villages in the Mid-Plains". Ethnohistory. 26 (4): 377–95. doi:10.2307/481367. JSTOR 481367.
- Cohan, Sara (2005). "A brief history of the Armenian Genocide" (PDF). Social Education. 69 (6): 333–337.
- Collar, Anna (2013). Religious Networks in the Roman Empire (illustrated, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107043442.
- Constable, Giles (1998). The Reformation of the Twelfth Century (illustrated, revised, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521638715.
- Constantelos, Demetrios J. (1964). "Paganism and the State in the Age of Justinian". The Catholic Historical Review. 50 (3): 372–80. JSTOR 25017472.
- Cotts, John (2012). Europe's Long Twelfth Century: Order, Anxiety and Adaptation, 1095-1229. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-1-137-29608-5.
- Crampton, R. J (2005). A concise history of Bulgaria (second ed.). Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521850858.
- Crislip, Andrew T. (2005). From Monastery to Hospital: Christian Monasticism & the Transformation of Health Care in Late Antiquity. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. ISBN 978-0-472-11474-0.
- Cusack, Carole M. (1998). Conversion Among the Germanic Peoples (reprint ed.). A&C Black. ISBN 9780304701551.
- Danuta, Shanzer (March 1998). "Dating the Baptism of Clovis: The bishop of Vienna vs the bishop of Tours". Early Medieval Europe. 7 (1): 29–57. doi:10.1111/1468-0254.00017. S2CID 161819012.
- Dean, Sidney E. (2015). "Felling the Irminsul: Charlemagne's Saxon Wars". Medieval Warfare. 5 (2): 15–20. JSTOR 48578430.
- de Bérier, Franciszek Longchamps; Domingo, Rafael (2022). "Introduction". In de Bérier, Franciszek Longchamps; Domingo, Rafael (eds.). Law and Christianity in Poland. Routledge. pp. 1–6. ISBN 978-1032019727.
- "Osbernus: De expugnatione Lyxbonensi, 1147". Internet History Sourcebooks Project.
- de Juan, Alexander; Pierskalla, Jan Henryk (2017). "The Comparative Politics of Colonialism and Its Legacies: An Introduction". Politics & Society. 45 (2 Special Issue).
- Digeser, Elizabeth DePalma (2000). The Making of a Christian Empire: Lactantius & Rome. Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-0-8014-3594-2.
- Dollinger, Philippe (1999). The German Hansa. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-19073-2.
- Dragnea, Mihai (2020). The Wendish Crusade, 1147: The Development of Crusading Ideology in the Twelfth Century. NY: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-367-36696-4.
- Drake, H. A. (1995). "Constantine and Consensus". Church History. 64 (1): 1–15. doi:10.2307/3168653. JSTOR 3168653. S2CID 163129848.
- Drake, H.A., ed. (2006). Violence in Late Antiquity: Perceptions and Practices. Aldershot: Ashgate. ISBN 978-0-7546-5498-8.
- Drake, H. A. (2011). "Intolerance, Religious Violence, and Political Legitimacy in Late Antiquity". Journal of the American Academy of Religion. Oxford University Press. 79 (1): 193–235. doi:10.1093/jaarel/lfq064. JSTOR 23020391.
- Drake, H. A. (1996). "Lambs into Lions: Explaining Early Christian Intolerance". Past & Present. 153 (153): 3–36. doi:10.1093/past/153.1.3. JSTOR 651134.
- Duni, Matteo (June 2016). "Doubting Witchcraft: Theologians, Jurists, Inquisitors during the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries". Studies in Church History. 52: 203–231. doi:10.1017/stc.2015.12. S2CID 164173947.
- Dunn, Marilyn (2013). Belief and Religion in Barbarian Europe c. 350-700. A&C Black. ISBN 978-1-4411-2382-4.
- Dunn, Dennis J. (2016). A History of Orthodox, Islamic, and Western Christian Political Values. Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-3-319-32566-8.
- Eder, Jeanne; Reyhner, Jon (2017). American Indian Education: A History (2nd ed.). University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 9780806159911.
- Ekonomou, Andrew J. (2007). Byzantine Rome and the Greek popes: Eastern influences on Rome and the papacy from Gregory the Great to Zacharias, AD 590-752. Lexington Books. ISBN 9780739133866.
- Elsie, Robert (2015). "The Early History of Albania" (PDF). Retrieved December 12, 2022.
- Errington, R. Malcolm (1997). "Christian Accounts of the Religious Legislation of Theodosius I". Klio. 79 (2): 398–443. doi:10.1524/klio.1922.214.171.1248. S2CID 159619838.
- Errington, R. Malcolm (2006). Roman Imperial Policy from Julian to Theodosius. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 978-0-8078-3038-3.
- Evans, Arthur (2007) . Through Bosnia and the Herzegovina on Foot During the Insurrection, August and September 1875. New York: Cosimo. ISBN 978-1602062702.
- Fahy, T. (1963). "The Council of Jerusalem". Irish Theological Quarterly. 30 (3): 232–261. doi:10.1177/002114006303000303. S2CID 170396423.
- Fairchild, Mary (2021). "Take an Illustrated Tour of Christian Symbols". Learn Religions. Interdenominational Christian Training Center. Retrieved October 27, 2021.
- Farmer, David Hugh, ed. (1995). Benedict's Disciples. Gracewing. ISBN 9780852442746.
- Firlej, Dominik (2021–2022). "Why did Polish Kings not go on Crusade in the Levant?" (PDF). The Cupola. 16: 120–135.
- Fletcher, Richard (1999). The Barbarian Conversion: From Paganism to Christianity. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 0-520-21859-0.
- Fonnesberg-Schmidt, Iben (2007). The popes and the Baltic crusades, 1147–1254. Brill. ISBN 9789004155022.
- Fonnesberg-Schmidt, Iben (2009). "Pope Honorius III and Mission and Crusades in the Baltic Region". In Murray, Alan V. (ed.). The Clash of Cultures on the Medieval Baltic Frontier. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. pp. 103–122. ISBN 978-0-7546-6483-3.
- Fontaine, Darcie (2016). Decolonizing Christianity: Religion and the End of Empire in France and Algeria. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107118171.
- Forstreuter, Kurt (1938). Deutschland und Litauen. Studien zum Detuschtum im Osten. Vol. 1. Königsberg: Ost-europa.
- Fowden, Garth (1978). "Bishops and Temples in the Eastern Roman Empire A.D. 320–435". The Journal of Theological Studies. Oxford University Press. 29 (1): 53–78. doi:10.1093/jts/XXIX.1.53. JSTOR 23960254.
- Fox, Robin Lane (1987). Pagans and Christians. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 978-0-394-55495-2.
- Friese, Thomas (March 22, 2017). "In Deep: A Brief History of Bohemia". Butterfield & Robinson. Retrieved October 17, 2022.
- García-Arenal, Mercedes; Glazer-Eytan, Yonatan (2019). Forced conversion in Christianity, Judaism and Islam: coercion and faith in premodern Iberia and beyond. Brill. ISBN 9789004416826.
- Gerberding, R.; Moran Cruz, J. H. (2004). Medieval Worlds. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company. pp. 55–56.
- Ghosh, Shami (2016). "Paul the Deacon and the Ancient History of the Lombards". Writing the Barbarian Past: Studies in Early Medieval Historical Narrative. Brill. pp. 115–152. ISBN 978-90-04-30522-9.
- Gibbon, Edward (1776). The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Vol. I: The Decline And Fall In The West.
- Goldberg, Eric J. (2006). Struggle for Empire: Kingship and Conflict under Louis the German, 817–876. Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-0-8014-7529-0.
- Gonzalez, Justo L. (2010). The Story of Christianity. Vol. 2: The Reformation to the Present Day. HarperCollins. ISBN 978-0-06-185589-4.
- Goodenough, Erwin R. (1962). "Catacomb Art". Journal of Biblical Literature. 81 (2): 113–142. doi:10.2307/3264749. JSTOR 3264749.
- Graf, Fritz (2014). "Laying Down the Law in Ferragosto: The Roman Visit of Theodosius in Summer 389". Journal of Early Christian Studies. 22 (2): 219–242. doi:10.1353/earl.2014.0022. S2CID 159641057.
- Green, Bernard (2010). Christianity in ancient Rome : the first three centuries. London: A&C Black. pp. 126–127. ISBN 978-0-5670-3250-8.
- Gregory, Timothy E. (1986). "The Survival of Paganism in Christian Greece: A Critical Essay". The American Journal of Philology. 107 (2): 229–242. doi:10.2307/294605. ISSN 0002-9475. JSTOR 294605.
- Grimassi, Raven (2000). Encyclopedia of Wicca & Witchcraft. Llewellyn Worldwide. ISBN 978-1-56718-257-6.
- Haas, Christopher (2002). Alexandria in Late Antiquity Topography and Social Conflict. Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 9780801870330.
- Haight, Roger D. (2004). Christian Community in History Volume 1: Historical Ecclesiology. New York: The Continuum International Publishing Group. ISBN 0-8264-1630-6.
- Hakobyan, Aleksan H. (2021). "About the Dating of the Christianization of Caucasian Albania". Afro-Aziatskie Obshchestva: Istoriia I Sovremennost. 5 (5): 71–81. doi:10.31857/S086919080014885-0. S2CID 240239868.
- Haley, Gene C. (2002). "Tamlachta: The Map of Plague Burials and Some Implications for Early Irish History". Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium. 22: 96–140. JSTOR 40285165.
- Hamlet, Ingomar (2004). "Theodosius I. And The Olympic Games". Nikephoros. 17: 53–75.
- Hanson, R. P. C. (1978). "The transformation of pagan temples into churches in the early Christian centuries". Journal of Semitic Studies. 23 (2): 257–267. doi:10.1093/jss/23.2.257.
- Harmer, Florence E. (1946). "The english contribution to the epistolary usages of early scandinavian kings". Saga-Book. 13: 115–155. ISSN 0305-9219. JSTOR 48611990.
- Harnett, Benjamin (2017). "The Diffusion of the Codex". Classical Antiquity. University of California Press. 36 (2): 183–235. doi:10.1525/ca.2017.36.2.183. JSTOR 26362608.
- Harney, Lorcan (2017). "Christianising Pagan Worlds in Conversion-Era Ireland: Archaeological Evidence for the Origins of Irish Ecclesiastical Sites". Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy: Archaeology, Culture, History, Literature. 117C: 103–30. doi:10.3318/priac.2017.117.07. S2CID 165970409.
- Hart, David Bentley (2009). Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies (unabridged ed.). Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-15564-8.
- Haverkamp, Alfred (1988). Medieval Germany, 1056-1273. Translated by Helga Braun; Richard Mortimer. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-822132-6.
- Headrick, Daniel R. (2012). Power Over Peoples Technology, Environments, and Western Imperialism, 1400 to the Present. Princeton University Press. ISBN 9781400833597.
- Hebblewhite, Mark (2020). Theodosius and the Limits of Empire. London: Routledge. doi:10.4324/9781315103334. ISBN 978-1-138-10298-9. S2CID 213344890.
- Herrin, Judith (2009). "Book Burning as purification". In Rousseau, Philip; Papoutsakis, Emmanuel (eds.). Transformations of Late Antiquity: Essays for Peter Brown, Volume 2 (illustrated, reprint ed.). Ashgate Publishing, Ltd. ISBN 9780754665533.
- Hopkins, Keith (1998). "Christian Number and Its Implications". Journal of Early Christian Studies. 6 (2): 185–226. doi:10.1353/earl.1998.0035. S2CID 170769034.
- Horn, Cornelia B. (1998). "St. Nino and the Christianization of pagan Georgia". Medieval Encounters. 4 (3): 242–264. doi:10.1163/157006798X00151.
- Hunyadi, Zsolt; Laszlovszky, József (2001). The Crusades and the Military Orders: Expanding the Frontiers of Medieval Latin Christianity. Budapest: Central European University Press. ISBN 978-963-9241-42-8.
- Irmscher, Johannes (1988). "Non-christians and sectarians under Justinian: the fate of the inculpated". Collection de l'Institut des Sciences et Techniques de l'Antiquité. 367 (1): 165–167.
- Ivanič, Peter (2016). "The origins of Christianity in the territory of Czech and Slovak republics within the contexts of written sources". European Journal of Science and Theology. 12 (6): 123–130.
- Jestice, Phyllis G. (1997). Wayward Monks and the Religious Revolution of the Eleventh Century. BRILL. ISBN 9789004107229.
- Jimeno Jurío, José María (1995). Historia de Pamplona y de sus lenguas. Tafalla: Txalaparta. ISBN 978-8481360172.
- Johansen, Bruce Elliott (2005). The Native Peoples of North America A History · Volume 1. Praeger Publishers. ISBN 978-0275987206.
In the Americas, the Catholic priest Bartolome de las Casas avidly encouraged enquiries into the Spanish conquest's many cruelties. Las Casas chronicled Spanish brutality against the Native peoples in excruciating detail.
- Jones, Arnold Hugh Martin (1986). The Later Roman Empire, 284-602: A Social Economic and Administrative Survey. Vol. 1 (reprint ed.). JHU Press. ISBN 978-0-8018-3353-3.
- Kahlos, Maijastina (2015). Seizing History: Christianising the Past in Late Antique Historiography.
- Kahlos, Maijastina (2019). Religious Dissent in Late Antiquity, 350–450. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-006725-0.
- Kaldellis, Anthony (2012). Procopius of Caesarea: Tyranny, History, and Philosophy at the End of Antiquity. University of Pennsylvania Press. ISBN 978-0-8122-0241-0.
- Kelly, Thomas Forrest (1989). The Beneventan Chant. CUP Archive. ISBN 978-0-521-34310-7.
- Klaniczay, Gábor (2004). "The birth of a new Europe about 1000 CE: conversion, transfer of institutional models, new dynamics". Medieval Encounters. 10 (1–3): 99–129. doi:10.1163/1570067043077823. S2CID 162367005.
- Koenig, Harold G.; King, Dana E.; Carson, Verna Benner, eds. (2012). Handbook of Religion and Health (second ed.). New Yorkc: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-533595-8.
- Lavan, Luke; Mulryan, Michael, eds. (2011). The Archaeology of Late Antique 'Paganism'. Leiden: Brill. ISBN 978-90-04-19237-9.
- Leighton, Gregory (November 29, 2021). "Chapter 22 "The Baltic Crusades (1147-1300)"". In Curta, Florin (ed.). The Routledge Handbook of East Central and Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 500-1300. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-000-47624-8.
- Leithart, Peter J. (2010). Defending Constantine The Twilight of an Empire and the Dawn of Christendom. InterVarsity Press. ISBN 978-0-8308-2722-0.
- Lenski, Noel (1995). "The Date of the Gothic Civil War and the Date of the Gothic Conversion" (PDF). Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies. 36 (1).
- Lepelley, C. (1992). "The survival and fall of the classical city in Late Roman Africa". In Rich, John (ed.). The City in Late Antiquity. London and New York: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-06855-0.
- Leone, Anna (2013). The End of the Pagan City: Religion, Economy, and Urbanism in Late Antique North Africa (illustrated ed.). OUP. ISBN 978-0-19-957092-8.
- Lichtenberger, Achim; Raja, Rubina (2018). "From synagogue to church: The Appropriation of the Synagogue of Gerasa/Jerash under Justinian". Jahrbuch für Antike und Christentum. 61.
- Lilienfeld, Aidan (2022). "Baltic Frontiers". Colombia Journal of History. Colombia University. Retrieved December 20, 2022.
- Loosley, Emma (2012). The Architecture and Liturgy of the Bema in Fourth- To-Sixth-Century Syrian Churches (illustrated ed.). Brill. ISBN 9789004231825.
- Lund, James (2022). "Religion and Thought". In Johnson, Wendell G.; Barbe, Katharina (eds.). Modern Germany. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-1-4408-6454-4.
- McLoughlin, William Gerald (1984). Cherokees and Missionaries, 1789-1839. Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300030754.
- MacMullen, Ramsay (1981). Paganism in the Roman Empire (unabridged ed.). Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-02984-0.
- MacMullen, Ramsay (1984). Christianizing the Roman Empire : (A.D. 100-400). New Haven. ISBN 978-0-300-03216-1.
- Magdoff, Harry; McDougall, Walter A. (2020). "New Imperialism". Brittanica. Britannica. Retrieved January 25, 2023.
- Mansi, Giovanni Domenico (1762). Concilia. Vol. VIII.
- Marcos, M. (2013). "The Debate on Religious Coercion in Ancient Christianity". Chaos e Kosmos. 13: 1–16.
- Markus, Robert Austin (1990). The End of Ancient Christianity (illustrated, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-33949-0.
- Mathew, Arnold Harris (2018). The Life and Times of Rodrigo Borgia, Pope Alexander VI. Creative Media Partners, LLC. ISBN 978-0-342-68601-8.
- Matthews, Roy T.; Platt, F. DeWitt (1992). The Western Humanities. Mayfield Pub. Co. ISBN 0-87484-785-0.
- Meeks, Wayne A. (2003). The First Urban Christians (second ed.). Yale University. ISBN 0-300-09861-8.
- Miller, David Harry (January 1974). "The Roman Revolution of the Eighth Century: A Study of the Ideological Background of die Papal Separation from Byzantium and Alliance with the Franks". Mediaeval Studies. 36: 79–133. doi:10.1484/J.MS.2.306158.
- Monroe, Paul (1909). A Text-book in the History of Education. London: The Macmillan Company.
- Moore, R. I. (2007). The Formation of a Persecuting Society (second ed.). Malden, Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4051-2964-0.
- Moravcsik, Gyula (December 1947). "The Role of the Byzantine Church in Medieval Hungary". American Slavic and East European Review. 6 (3/4): 134–151. doi:10.2307/2491705. JSTOR 2491705.
- Mulryan, Michael (2011). "'Paganism' In Late Antiquity: Regional Studies And Material Culture". Brill: 41–86. ISBN 9789004210394.
- Murphy, G. Ronald (September 2014). "Book Review: The Conversion of Scandinavia: Vikings, Merchants, and Missionaries in the Remaking of Northern Europe". Christianity & Literature. 63 (4): 542–545. doi:10.1177/014833311406300419. ISSN 0148-3331.
- Noll, Mark A. (1992). A History of Christianity in the United States and Canada. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802806512.
- Nowell, Charles E.; Magdoff, Harry; Webster, Richard A. (November 13, 2022). "Western colonialism". Western colonialism | Definition, History, Examples, & Effects | Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved January 15, 2023.
- Olson, Roger E. (1999). The Story of Christian Theology: Twenty Centuries of Tradition and Reform. Downer's Grove, In.: InterVarsity Press. p. 172. ISBN 978-0-8308-1505-0.
- Oostindie, Geert, ed. (2008). Dutch Colonialism, Migration and Cultural Heritage Past and Present. Brill. ISBN 9789004253889.
- Osenova, Petya (2010). "Bulgarian". Revue belge de philologie et d'histoire. 88 (3): 643–666. doi:10.3406/rbph.2010.7798.
- Padberg, Lutz von (1998). Die Christianisierung Europas im Mittelalter (in German). Stuttgart: Reclam. ISBN 9783150170151. OCLC 493859593.
- Paiva, José Pedro (2017). "The Inquisition Tribunal in Goa: Why and for What Purpose?". Journal of Early Modern History. 21 (6): 565–593. doi:10.1163/15700658-12342575.
- Paul, Marcus (2016). The Evil That Men Do: Faith, Injustice and the Church. Sacristy Press. ISBN 9781908381972.
- Poulik, Josef (1978). "The Origins of Christianity in Slavonic Countries North of the Middle Danube Basin". World Archaeology. 10 (2): 158–171. doi:10.1080/00438243.1978.9979728.
- Perrottet, Tony (2004). The Naked Olympics: The True Story of the Ancient Games. Random House Digital, Inc. ISBN 978-1-58836-382-4. Retrieved April 1, 2013.
- Plontke-Lüning, A. (2017). "Early Christian Churches in Caucasian Albania". Early Christian Churches in Caucasian Albania ; Raně křesťanské kostely v kavkazské Albánii. Convivium Supplementum. Vol. 1. Brepols Publishers. pp. 160–175. doi:10.1484/M.CONVISUP-EB.5.131088. ISBN 9788021083226. Retrieved December 11, 2022.
- Pontani, Filippomaria (2015). "Scholarship in the Byzantine Empire (529–1453)". In Montanari, Franco; Matthaios, Stefanos; Rengakos, Antonios (eds.). Brill's Companion to Ancient Greek Scholarship (2 Vols.). BRILL. pp. 297–455. ISBN 978-90-04-28192-9.
- Pop, Ioan-Aurel (2009). "Romania and Romanians in Europe: A Historical Perspective". In Boari, Vasile; Gherghina, Sergiu (eds.). Weighting Differences: Romanian Identity in the Wider European Context. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. ISBN 9781443812153.
- Popovski, Ivan (2017). "Medieval Croatian states". A Short History of South East Europe. Lulu Press, Inc. ISBN 978-1-365-95394-1.
- Poppe, Andrzej (1991). "Christianity and Ideological change in Kievan Rus': The First Hundred Years". Canadian-American Slavic Studies. 25 (1–4): 3–26. doi:10.1163/221023991X00038.
- Praet, Danny (1992). "Explaining the Christianization of the Roman Empire. Older theories and recent developments". Sacris Erudiri. Jaarboek voor Godsdienstgeschiedenis. A Journal on the Inheritance of Early and Medieval Christianity. 23: 5–119.
- Puspitasari, Ni Wayan Radita Novi (2013). "The history of Christianization: education as the first step of spreading the religion in Batavia in the 17th century". Historia: International Journal of History Education. XIV (1).
- Quinault, Roland; McKitterick, Rosamond (2002). Edward Gibbon and empire. Cambridge. ISBN 978-0-521-52505-3.
- Rapp, Stephen H., Jr (2007). "Chapter 7 – Georgian Christianity". The Blackwell companion to Eastern Christianity. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1-4443-3361-9.
- "Vladimir Corovic: Istorija srpskog naroda". Rastko.rs. n.d. Retrieved January 12, 2012.
- Rausing, Gad (1995). "The days of the week and Dark Age politics". Fornvännen. 90 (4).
- Radić, Radmilla (2010). "11:Serbian Christianity". In Parry, Ken (ed.). The Blackwell Companion to Eastern Christianity. Wiley. ISBN 9781444333619.
- Rawlings, Helen (2006). The Spanish Inquisition. Malden, Mass.: Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 0-631-20599-3.
- Remijsen, Sofie (2015). The End of Greek Athletics in Late Antiquity. Cambridge University Press.
- Riché, Pierre (1993). The Carolingians : a family who forged Europe. University of Pennsylvania Press. ISBN 0-8122-3062-0.
- Riggs, David. "Christianizing the Rural Communities of Late Roman Africa: A Process of Coercion or Persuasion?". In Drake (2006), pp. 297–308.
- Robinson, W. Stitt (May 1952). "Indian Education and Missions in Colonial Virginia". The Journal of Southern History. 18 (2): 152–168. doi:10.2307/2954270. JSTOR 2954270.
- Roe, H. (1980). "Rome and the Early Germans: Some Sociolinguistic Observations". Florilegium. 2 (1): 101–120. doi:10.3138/flor.2.006.
- Roux, Marie (2018). "Codex Theodosianus XVI.10.12 (8th November 392 CE)". Judaism and Rome. European Research Council. Retrieved June 20, 2022.
- Runciman, W. G. (2004). "The Diffusion of Christianity in the Third Century AD as a Case-Study in the Theory of Cultural Selection". European Journal of Sociology. 45 (1): 3–21. doi:10.1017/S0003975604001365. S2CID 146353096.
- Russell, James C. (1996). The Germanization of Early Medieval Christianity: A Sociohistorical Approach to Religious Transformation (reprint ed.). OUP. ISBN 9780195104660.
- Salzman, Michele Renee (1993). "The Evidence for the Conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity in Book 16 of the 'Theodosian Code". Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte. Franz Steiner Verlag. 42 (3): 362–78. JSTOR 4436297.
- Salzman, Michele R. (1987). "'Superstitio' in the Codex Theodosianus and the Persecution of Pagans". Vigiliae Christianae. 41 (2): 172–188.
- Salzman, Michele Renee. "Rethinking Pagan-Christian Violence". In Drake (2006), pp. 265–286.
- Salzman, Michele Renee (2002). The Making of a Christian Aristocracy: Social and Religious Change in the Western Roman Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. doi:10.2307/j.ctvk12r62. ISBN 978-0-674-00641-6. JSTOR j.ctvk12r62.
- Salzman, Michele Renee; Sághy, Marianne; Testa, Rita Lizzi, eds. (2016). Pagans and Christians in late antique Rome : conflict, competition, and coexistence in the fourth century. New York, NY. ISBN 978-1-107-11030-4.
- Salzman, Michelle Renee (2021). The Falls of Rome: Crises, Resilience, and Resurgence in Late Antiquity. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1107111424.
- Sam, David L.; Berry, John W. (2010). "Acculturation: When individuals and groups of different cultural backgrounds meet". Perspectives on Psychological Science. 5 (4): 472–481. doi:10.1177/1745691610373075. PMID 26162193. S2CID 220262608.
- Sanmark, Alexandra (2004). "1". Power and Conversion. A Comparative Study of Christianization in Scandinavia. The University of Uppsala. ISBN 9789150617399.
- Sanneh, Lamin O. (2007). Disciples of all nations: Pillars of world Christianity. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-1980-4084-2.
- Sanneh, Lamin; McClymond, Michael, eds. (2016). The Wiley Blackwell Companion to World Christianity. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 978-1118556047.
- Saradi, Helen G. (2011). "Late Paganism and Christianisation in Greece". Late Antique Archaeology. 7 (1): 261–309. doi:10.1163/22134522-90000160.
- Sáry, Pál (2019). "Remarks on the Edict of Thessalonica of 380". In Vojtech Vladár (ed.). Perpauca Terrena Blande Honori dedicata pocta Petrovi Blahovi K Nedožitým 80. Narodeninám. Trnavská univerzity. pp. 67–80. ISBN 978-80-568-0313-4.
- Sedlar, Jean W. (1995). "King Saint Stephen of Hungary. By György Györffy. Trans. Peter Doherty". Slavic Review. 54 (4): 1119–1120. doi:10.2307/2501480. JSTOR 2501480. S2CID 165113730.
- Ščavinskas, Marius (2017). "A Few Remarks on the so Called First Stage of Christianization of the Eastern Coast of the Baltic Region". Tabularium Historiae. II: 57–76.
- Schacter, Jacob J. (2011). Carlebach, Elisheva; Schacter, Jacob J. (eds.). New Perspectives on Jewish-Christian Relations: In Honor of David Berger. Netherlands: Brill. ISBN 978-9-00422-118-5.
- Schaff, Philip (n.d.). History of the Christian Church, Volume IV: Mediaeval Christianity. A.D. 590–1073. CCEL. pp. 161–162. ISBN 978-1-61025-043-6. Retrieved June 15, 2013.
- Schön, Ebbe (2004). Asa-Tors hammare : gudar och jättar i tro och tradition (in Swedish) (1. uppl ed.). Stockholm: Hjalmarson & Högberg. ISBN 91-89660-41-2.
- Schrader, Charles E. (1936). "The Historical Development of the Papal Monarchy". The Catholic Historical Review. 22 (3): 259–282. JSTOR 25013503.
- Schramm, Gottfried (1994). "A New Approach to Albanian History". albanianhistory.net. Translated by Robert Elsie.
- Schwartz, Seth (2005). "Chapter 8: Roman Historians and the Rise of Christianity: The School of Edward Gibbon". In Harris, William Vernon (ed.). The Spread of Christianity in the First Four Centuries: Essays in Explanation. BRILL. ISBN 978-90-04-14717-1.
- Schuddeboom, Feyo L. (2017). "The Conversion of Temples in Rome". Journal of Late Antiquity. Johns Hopkins University Press. 10 (1): 166–186. doi:10.1353/jla.2017.0005. S2CID 165142999.
- Scourfield, J. H. D. (2007). Texts and Culture in Late Antiquity: Inheritance, Authority, and Change. ISD LLC. ISBN 978-1-910589-45-8.
- Seibt, Werner (2002). "Die Christianisierung des Kaukasus. The Christianization of Caucasus (Armenia, Georgia, Albania)". Referate des internationalen Symposions. austriaca.at. ISBN 978-3-7001-3016-1.
- "Sulpitius Severus on the life of St. Martin - Vita, ch xiii". Archived from the original on September 9, 2006. Retrieved July 4, 2005.
- Sharpe, Richard (1995). Life of St Columba. Penguin UK.
- Shatzmiller, Joseph (1974). "Review of 'Medieval Jewry in Northern France: A Political and Social History', by Robert Chazan". Jewish Social Studies. 36 (3): 339.
- Shorter, Aylward (2006). Toward a Theology of Inculturation. Wipf & Stock. ISBN 9781597525473.
- Siecienski, A. Edward (2017). Constantine: Religious Faith and Imperial Policy (illustrated ed.). Routledge. ISBN 9781351976114.
- Simeoni, Manuel (n.d.). "THEODOSIAN CODE (CODEX THEODOSIANUS) 16.10: TEXT". European Pagan Memory Day. Retrieved April 19, 2022.
- Sisa, Stephen (1995). The spirit of Hungary : a panorama of Hungarian history and culture (3rd ed.). Morristown, N.J.: Vista Books. ISBN 978-0962842221.
- Sommer, Petr; Trestik, Dusan; Zemlicka, Josef (2007), "Bohemia and Moravia", in Berend, Nora (ed.), Christianization and the rise of Christian monarchy : Scandinavia, Central Europe and Rus' c. 900–1200, Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press
- Southern, Patricia (2015). The Roman Empire from Severus to Constantine (second, revised ed.). Routledge. ISBN 978-1-317-49694-6.
- Spliesgart, Roland (2007). Koschorke, Klaus; Ludwig, Frieder; Delgado, Mariano; Spliesgart, Roland (eds.). A History of Christianity in Asia, Africa, and Latin America, 1450-1990. Eerdmans Publishing Company. ISBN 9780802828897.
- Stachura, Michał (2018). Enemies of the Later Roman Order: A Study of the Phenomenon of Language Aggression in the Theodosian Code, Post-Theodosian Novels, and the Sirmondian Constitutions. Krakow: Jagiellonian University Press. ISBN 978-83-233-4505-3.
- Štefan, Ivo (2022). "6". In Curta, Florin (ed.). The Routledge handbook of east central and eastern europe in the middle ages, 500–1300. Routledge. pp. 101–120. ISBN 978-0-367-22655-8.
- Stephenson, Paul (2000). Byzantium's Balkan Frontier: A Political Study of the Northern Balkans, 900-1204. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521770170.
- Stern, Craig A. (1998). "Justinian: Lieutenant of Christ, Legislator for Christendom". Regent University Law Review. 11 (1). SSRN 2642313.
- Stocking, Rachel L. (2000). Bishops, councils, and consensus in the Visigothic Kingdom, 589-633. University of Michigan Press.
- Strauss, Barry S.; Noble, Thomas F. X.; Cohen, William B.; Osheim, Duane; Neuschel, Kristen B.; Accampo, Elinore A.; Roberts, David D. (2005). Western Civilization The Continuing Experiment · Volume 1. Houghton Mifflin Company. ISBN 9780618561902.
- Strzelczyk, Jerzy (1987). Od Prasłowian do Polaków (in Polish). Krajowa Agencja Wydawnicza. ISBN 978-83-03-02015-4.
- Testa, Judith Anne (1998). "10, The Christian Catacombs". Rome is Love Spelled Backward (Roma Amor): Enjoying Art and Architecture in the Eternal City. Northern Illinois University Press. ISBN 9780875805764.
- Testa, Rita Lizzi (2007). "Christian emperor, vestal virgins and priestly colleges: Reconsidering the end of roman paganism". Antiquité tardive. 15: 251–262. doi:10.1484/J.AT.2.303121.
- Thomas, Charles (1981). Christianity in Roman Britain to AD 500 (illustrated ed.). University of California Press. ISBN 9780520043923.
- Thomas, Charles (1997). "Evidence for Christianity in Roman Britain. The Small Finds. By CF Mawer. BAR British Series 243. Tempus Reparatum, Oxford, 1995. Pp. vi+ 178, illus. ISBN 0-8605-4789-2". Britannia. 28.
- Thompson, Glen L. (2005). "Constantius II and the First Removal of the Altar of Victory". In Jean-Jacques Aubert; Zsuzsanna Varhelyi (eds.). A Tall Order: Writing the Social History of the Ancient World – Essays in honor of William V. Harris. Munich: K.G. Saur. pp. 85–106. doi:10.1515/9783110931419. ISBN 978-3-598-77828-5.
- Thomson, Robert W. (1988). "Mission, Conversion, and Christianization: The Armenian Example". Harvard Ukrainian Studies. 12/13: 28–45. JSTOR 41036303.
- Trombley, F. R. (1995a). Hellenic Religion and Christianization, c. 370-529. Vol. I. New York: Brill.
- Trombley, Frank R. (2001). Hellenic Religion and Christianization, c. 370–529. Netherlands: Brill Academic Publishers.
- Trebilco, Paul Raymond (2017). Outsider Designations and Boundary Construction in the New Testament: Early Christian Communities and the Formation of Group Identity. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-31132-8.
- Tyerman, Christopher (2011). "Henry of Livonia and the Ideology of Crusading". In Tamm, Marek; Kaljundi, Linda; Jensen, Carsten Selch (eds.). Crusading and Chronicle Writing on the Medieval Baltic Frontier: A Companion to the Chronicle of Henry of Livonia. Burlington: Ashgate Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4094-3396-5.
- Ullmann, Walter (2005). A Short History of the Papacy in the Middle Ages (2nd ed.). New York: Routledge. ISBN 0-203-34952-0.
- Van Dam, Raymond (1985). "From Paganism to Christianity at Late Antique Gaza". Viator. 16: 1–20. doi:10.1484/J.VIATOR.2.301417.
- Veszprémy, László (2001). "Hungary's Conversion to Christianity. The Establishment of Hungarian Statehood and its Consequences to the Thirteenth Century". Hungarian Studies Review. 28 (1–2): 73–92.
- Vlasto, A. P. (1970). The entry of the Slavs into Christendom: an introduction to the medieval. ISBN 9780521074599. Retrieved January 12, 2012.
- Waugh, Scott L.; Diehl, Peter (2002). Christendom and Its Discontents: Exclusion, Persecution, and Rebellion, 1000-1500. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-52509-1.
- Weston, Arthur Harold (1942). "December 25th, Christmas Day". The Classical Outlook. 20 (3): 26. JSTOR 44006370.
- Wiemer, Hans-Ulrich (1994). "Libanius on Constantine". The Classical Quarterly. 44 (2): 511–524. doi:10.1017/S0009838800043962. JSTOR 639654. S2CID 170876695.
- Wicker, Nancy L. (2012). "Christianization, Female Infanticide, and the Abundance of Female Burials at Viking Age Birka in Sweden". Journal of the History of Sexuality. 21 (2): 245–62. doi:10.1353/sex.2012.0043. JSTOR 41475079. PMID 22606749. S2CID 44682045.
- Winroth, Anders (2012). The Conversion of Scandinavia: Vikings, Merchants, and Missionaries in the Remaking of Northern Europe. Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300205534.
- Wood, Ian N. (2007). "Some historical re-identifications and the Christianization of Kent". Christianizing Peoples and Converting Individuals. pp. 27–35.
- Woods, David. "Theodosius I (379–395 A.D.)". De Imperatoribus Romanis.
- Woods, Thomas Jr. (2012). How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization. Regnery Publishing. ISBN 9781596983281.
- Wyrwińska, Karolina (2022). "3 Jadwiga of Anjou (1374–1399)". In de Bérier, Franciszek Longchamps; Domingo, Rafael (eds.). Law and Christianity in Poland. Routledge. pp. 48–63. ISBN 978-1032019727.
- Ziemann, Daniel (2021). "Goodness and Cruelty: The Image of the Ruler of the First Bulgarian Empire in the Period of Christianisation (Ninth Century)". In Philip Michael Forness; Alexandra Hasse-Ungeheuer; Hartmut Leppin (eds.). The Good Christian Ruler in the First Millennium : Views from the Wider Mediterranean World in Conversation. Millennium-Studien / Millennium Studies. Vol. 92. Berlin: De Gruyter. pp. 327–360. ISBN 9783110725612.
- Jorge Quiroga and Monica R. Lovelle, "Ciudades atlánticas en transición: La "ciudad" tardo-antigua y alto-medieval en el noroeste de la Península Ibérica (s.V-XI)" from Archeologia Medievale vol xxvii (1999), pp 257–268 Christianizing Late Antique Roman sites from the 6th century onwards.
- Unilineal Descent Groups and Deep Christianization: A Cross-Cultural Comparison