Constantinople massacre of 1821
The Constantinople massacre of 1821 was orchestrated by the authorities of the Ottoman Empire against the Greek community of Constantinople (modern Istanbul) in retaliation for the outbreak of the Greek War of Independence (1821–1830). As soon as the first news of the Greek uprising reached the Ottoman capital, there occurred mass executions, pogrom-type attacks, destruction of churches, and looting of the properties of the city's Greek population. The events culminated with the hanging of the Ecumenical Patriarch, Gregory V and the beheading of the Grand Dragoman, Konstantinos Mourouzis.
In early March 1821, Alexandros Ypsilantis crossed the Prut river and marched into Moldavia, an event that marked the beginning of the Greek War of Independence. Immediately in response of rumors that Turkish citizens had been massacred by Greeks in the Danubian Principalities, particularly in Iași and Galați,[full citation needed] the Grand Vizier ordered the arrest of seven Greek bishops in Constantinople. In addition, on the evening of April 2, the first news of the Greek Revolt in southern Greece reached Constantinople.
Leading personalities of the Greek community, in particular the Ecumenical Patriarch, Gregory V, and the Grand Dragoman, Konstantinos Mourouzis, were accused of having knowledge of the revolt by the Sultan, Mahmud II, but both pleaded innocence. Nevertheless, the Sultan requested a fatwa allowing a general massacre against all Greeks living in the Empire from the Shaykh al-Islām, Haci Halil Efendi. The Shaykh obliged, however the Patriarch managed to convince him that only a few Greeks were involved in the uprising, and the Shaykh recalled the fatwa. Haci Halil Efendi was later exiled and executed by the Sultan for this.
The Ecumenical Patriarch was forced by the Ottoman authorities to excommunicate the revolutionaries, which he did on Palm Sunday, April, 15 [O.S. April, 3] 1821. Although he was unrelated to the insurgents, the Ottoman authorities still considered him guilty of treason because he was unable, as representative of the Orthodox population of the Ottoman Empire, to prevent the uprising.
Executions of the Patriarch and the Grand Dragoman
Although the Patriarch found himself forced to excommunicate the revolutionaries, he still failed to appease the Ottoman rulers. Later, on the same day as the excommunication, the Sultan ordered the execution of the Grand Dragoman, Konstantinos Mourouzis. He was arrested at the house of the Reis Effendi and beheaded, while his body was displayed in public. Moreover, his brother and various other leading members of the Phanariote families were also executed, although in fact only a few Phanariotes were connected with the revolutionaries.
Despite the efforts of the Orthodox Patriarch to profess his loyalty to the Sultan, the latter remained unconvinced. One week after the excommunication, on Easter Sunday, April, 22 [O.S. April, 10] 1821, he was grabbed by Ottoman soldiers during the liturgy and hanged at the central gate of the Patriarchate. Thus, although he was completely uninvolved with the Revolution, his death was ordered as an act of revenge. His body remained suspended at the gate for three days, and was then handed to a Jewish mob (there had been animosity between the Greek and Jewish communities of Constantinople at the time), dragged through the streets before being thrown into the Golden Horn. The body was eventually picked up by the Greek crew of a Russian ship, brought to Odessa, and fifty years later was brought to Greece, where, on the one hundredth anniversary of his death, Gregory V was formally proclaimed a saint by the Greek Orthodox Church. Gregory's execution caused outrage throughout Greece and the rest of Europe, and resulted in an upsurge of sympathy and support for the rebels in Europe. The gate from which he was hung remains closed to this day.
Spread of the massacres (April–July 1821)
On the day of the hanging of Gregory V, three bishops and a dozens of other Greeks, high officials in the Ottoman administration, were quickly executed in various parts of the Ottoman capital. Among them were the metropolitan bishops, Dionysios of Ephesus, Athanasios of Nicomedia, Gregory of Derkoi, and Eugenios of Anchialos.
Moreover, the execution of the Patriarch signaled a reign of terror against the Greeks living in Constantinople the following weeks, while fanatical Muslims were encouraged to attack Greek communities throughout the Ottoman Empire. Thus, groups of fanatical Turks, including janissaries, roamed the streets of the city, as well as the nearby villages. They looted Greek churches and property, initiating a large scale pogrom. Around 14 Christian Churches suffered heavy damage, while some of them were completely destroyed. The Patriarchal complex also became one of the targets. Eugenius II, the newly elected Patriarch, saved himself at the last moment, by escaping to the roof. During this period, the Ottoman authorities sought prominent Greeks from all over Constantinople: in government service, in the Orthodox Church, or members of prominent families and put them to death by hanging or beheading. In addition, several hundred Greek merchants in the city were also massacred.
By May 1821, restrictions on the local Greeks increased, while churches continued to be assaulted. On May 24, Patriarch Eugenius presented a memorandum to the Ottoman authorities, begging them to be merciful towards the Greek people and church, claiming that only a few Greeks revolted and not the entire nation. Eugenius also repeated the excommunication of Gregory toward the revolutionaries. Nevertheless, public executions of Greeks were still a daily occurrence in Constantinople. On June 15, five archbishops and three bishops were executed. Additionally, in early July, seventy shared the same fate. Additionally, 450 shopkeepers and traders were rounded up and sent to work in mines.
Anti-Greek massacres in other parts of the Ottoman Empire (May–July 1821)
The same state of affairs also spread to other major cities of the Ottoman Empire with significant Greek populations. In Adrianople, on May 3, the former Patriarch, Cyril VI, nine priests and twenty merchants were hanged in front of the local Cathedral. Other Greeks of lower social status were executed, sent to exile or imprisoned.
In Smyrna, numerous Ottoman troops were staged, waiting orders to march against the rebels in Greece. They entered the city and together with local Turks embarked on a general massacre against the Christian population of the city which amounted to hundreds of deaths. During another massacre in the predominantly Greek town of Ayvalik, the town was burned to the ground, for fear that the inhabitants might rebel and join the revolution in Greece. As a result of the Ayvalik massacres, hundreds of Greeks were killed and many of the survivors were sold as slaves.
Similar massacres against the Greek population during these months occurred also in the Aegean islands of Kos and Rhodes. Part of the Greek population in Cyprus was also massacred. Among the victims was the archbishop Kyprianos, as well as five other local bishops.
The British and Russian ambassadors made strong protests to the Ottoman Empire as reaction of the execution of the Patriarch. The Russian ambassador in particular, Baron Stroganov protested against this kind of treatment towards the Orthodox Christians, while his protest climaxed after the death of the Patriarch. In July 1821, Stroganov proclaimed that if the massacres against the Greeks continued, this would be an act of war by the Porte to all Christian states. The public opinion in the European countries was also affected, especially in Russia.
The events in Constantinople were one of the reasons that triggered massacres against Turkish communities in regions where the uprising was in full swing. On the other hand, part of the jurisdiction of the Ecumenical Patriarch, secured in 1453, was revoked. The Patriarchate had until then been vested by the Ottoman Empire as the sole representative of the Orthodox communities of the Empire. Apart from leader of the Greek Orthodox millet, the Orthodox Patriarch was also responsible for legal, administrative, educational rights of his flock. The Patriarchate never recovered from the atrocities that occurred in the city in 1821.
The massacres were undertaken by the Ottoman authorities, purely as a political reaction to the outbreak of the Greek Revolution, centered in southern Greece. The victims of these actions were hardly related to the Revolution, while no serious investigations were conducted by the Ottoman side in order to prove that there was any kind of involvement by the people put to death.
The French newspaper Le Constitutionnel reported on May 21, 1821 that it had been formally decided by the Ottoman authorities to "slaughter all Christian subjects of the Empire." The same newspaper also stated that it was the Ottoman government's intention to "wipe Christianity from the face of the earth."
- Moltke, Helmuth (1984). Unter dem Halbmond: Erlebnisse in der alten Türkei 1835-1839. Thienemann Edition Erdmann. p. 17. ISBN 9783522603102.
- Seewald, Berthold (1994). Karl Wilhelm v. Heideck: ein bayerischer General im befreiten Griechenland (1826-1835). Oldenbourg Verlag. p. 40. ISBN 9783486560589.
- Kluge, Alexander (2006). Tur an Tur mit einem anderen Leben. Suhrkamp. p. 321.
- Schröder Felix , Bernath Mathias (1979). Biographisches Lexikon zur Geschichte Südosteuropas. München: Oldenburg. p. 72. ISBN 9783486489910.
- Gábor Ágoston, Bruce Alan Masters (2009). Encyclopedia of the Ottoman Empire. Infobase Publishing. p. 240. ISBN 9781438110257.
- History of the Balkans, Barbara Jelavich, page 212, 1983
- Frazee, 1969: 27
- Clair, William St. (2008). That Greece might still be free (New ed., rev., corr., and with additional ill. and updated bibliography. ed.). Cambridge: Open Book Publ. p. 3. ISBN 9781906924003.
- Weithmann, Michael W. (1994). Griechenland : vom Frühmittelalter bis zur Gegenwart. Regensburg: Pustet. p. 167. ISBN 9783791714257.
- Binns, John (2002). An introduction to the Christian Orthodox churches (1. publ. ed.). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. p. 12. ISBN 9780521667388.
- Frazee, 1969: 29
- Runciman, 1985: 405-406
- Frazee, 1969: 28
- Binns, John (2002-07-04). An Introduction to the Christian Orthodox Churches. pp. 12–13. ISBN 9780521667388.
- Angold, Michael (2006). The Cambridge history of Christianity (1. publ. ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press. p. 230. ISBN 9780521811132.
- Weithmann, Michael W. (1994). Griechenland : vom Frühmittelalter bis zur Gegenwart. Regensburg: Pustet. p. 167. ISBN 9783791714257.
- Richard Clogg (20 June 2002). A Concise History of Greece. Cambridge University Press. p. 36. ISBN 978-0-521-00479-4. Retrieved 4 March 2013.
- Gazette de Lausanne, digital archive available online
- editor, Alexander Mikaberidze, (2011-07-31). Conflict and Conquest in the Islamic World a Historical Encyclopedia. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO. p. 349. ISBN 9781598843378.
- Arndt, Helmuth v. Moltke ; herausgegeben von Helmut (1984). Unter dem Halbmond : Erlebnisse in der alten Türkei 1835-1839 (3. Aufl. ed.). Stuttgart: Thienimann. p. 17. ISBN 9783522603102.
- Frazee, 1969: 33
- Clair, 2008: 4
- Kossok, Manfred (1989). In tyrannos : Revolutionen der Weltgeschichte : von den Hussiten bis zur Commune (1. Aufl. ed.). [Leipzig]: Edition Leipzig. p. 7240. ISBN 9783361002067.
- Eichheim, Hubert (2006). Griechenland (Orig.-Ausg., 2., aktualisierte und erg. Aufl. ed.). München: Beck. p. 116. ISBN 9783406398773.
- Rodogn, Davide (2011-11-21). Against Massacre : Humanitarian Interventions in the Ottoman Empire, 1815-1914 (1. publ. ed.). Oxford: Princeton Univ. Press. p. 67. ISBN 9780691151335.
- Clair, 2008: 5
- Frazee, 1969: 32
- Frazee, 1969: 36
- Webster, Daniel (2006). Great speeches. Teddington, U.K.: Echo Library. p. 54. ISBN 9781846375798.
- Cycon, Dieter (1991). Die glücklichen Jahre : Deutschland und Russland. Herford: Busse Seewald. p. 373. ISBN 9783512030376.
- Breuilly, John (1993). Nationalism and the state (2. ed.). Manchester: Manchester Univ. Press. pp. 141–142. ISBN 9780719038006.
- Wheatcroft, Andrew (2004). Infidels a history of the conflict between Christendom and Islam (1st U.S. ed.). New York: Random House. ISBN 9781588363909.
On May 27, 1821, Le Constitutionnel reported that it had been officially decided in Constantinople to 'slaughter all Christian subjects of the Ottoman empire'
- Athanassoglou-Kallmyer, Nina (1989). French images from the Greek War of Independence (1821-1830) : art and politics under the Restoration (illustrated ed.). New Haven: Yale University Press. p. 17. ISBN 9780300045321. Retrieved 5 March 2013.
- Clair, William St. (2008). That Greece might still be free (New ed., rev., corr., and with additional ill. and updated bibliography. ed.). Cambridge: Open Book Publ. ISBN 9781906924003.
- Frazee, Charles A. (1969). The Orthodox church and independent Greece: 1821-1852. Campridge University Press.
- Runciman, Steven (1985). The Great Church in captivity : a study of the Patriarchate of Constantinople from the eve of the Turkish conquest to the Greek War of Independence (1st pbk. ed.). Cambridge [Cambridgeshire]: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521313100.
- C. Prousis, Theophilus (2008). "Eastern Orthodoxy Under Siege in the Ottoman Levant: A View from Constantinople in 1821". History Faculty Publications. (University of North Florida) (13). Retrieved 23 June 2013.