Cornell literary societies
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)(Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Cornell literary societies were a group of 19th century student organizations at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, formed for the purpose of promoting language skills and oratory. The U.S. Bureau of Education described three of them as a "purely literary society" following the "traditions of the old literary societies of Eastern universities." At their peak, the literary societies met in a room called "Society Hall," located within North University (now White Hall).
- 1 Cornell’s Literary Societies, 1868–1888
- 2 Society Hall
- 3 Decline
- 4 Irving Literary Society
- 5 The Philaletheian Society
- 6 The Samuel Johnson or Johnsonian Society
- 7 The Adelphi or Adelphia Society
- 8 The James Russell Lowell or Lowell Society
- 9 The George William Curtis or Curtis Society
- 10 The Philolexian Society
- 11 See also
- 12 References
Cornell’s Literary Societies, 1868–1888
In 1877, the four literary societies were ranked according to seniority in the Cornell Register: the Irving (founded in 1868), the Philaletheian (also founded in 1868), the Adelphi (founded in 1870) and the Curtis (founded in 1872). Competition was an early trait of literary society life at Cornell. Beginning in February 1870, the Irving and the Philaletheian held their annual contest against one another. That event has been noted as one reason why the quality of debate was so high between 1869 and 1884.
Other associations formed after the Irving. The Young Men’s Catholic Literary Association held a meeting in November 1869 at Deming Hall on Ithaca’s State Street. The subject of debate was "Resolved, That the French Revolution exerted a beneficial effect on the civilization of Europe." Besides the Irving and Philaletheian, other smaller societies met to provide opportunities for those not competitive within the two larger societies, whether for lack of opportunity or fear of the Irving and Philaletheian’s larger audiences. The Irving and Philaletheian were regarded as the foremost of Cornell undergraduate institutions; the smaller societies were the training leagues for the elevated two. In 1870, the second year of the University's operation, the Johnsonian and the Adelphi societies were founded, but the Johnsonian only lasted until 1872. Even more short-lived were the Grove, Lowell, and Philolexian societies which were founded in 1871 and ceased operations shortly thereafter. Lowell used its membership fees to support a reading room in the old Cornell Public Library in downtown Ithaca for the use of patrons. As the Cornell Era supposed midway through the University’s second year,
We are glad to note the organization of two or three small literary societies among the students, one of which holds its meetings in one of the University lecture rooms. These do in a humbler way, although perhaps as effectually, the work of the large societies and interest those who are not confident enough to appear before large audiences.
The three societies, the Irving, Curtis and Philaletheian, combined efforts to produce their own publication, the Cornell Review, in December 1873. The Review was a repository of original articles, essays, stories, Woodford orations, elaborate discussions, and poems. It was published first by representatives of the literary societies. After 1880, an editor from the debating club replaced the candidate from the defunct Philaletheian. The Curtis died out a few years later. The Curtis’ possessions were routed over to the American History Section Room, provided to Professor Tyler. After 1883, the Cornell Review drew its editors from the Irving and the debating club. Three editors, a sophomore, junior, and senior, were appointed by the retiring Review board. Issued first as a quarterly in 1873, it became a monthly in 1874–1875. And throughout the 1880s, the surviving literary societies competed against new student interests, such as the Cornell Congress and the emerging Cornell Athletics. Literary exercises were also conducted within social fraternities, which undercut the need for separate societies that drew members from multiple fraternities or independents.
The creation of a "Society Hall" was proposed by Andrew Dickson White with a $1,000 gift in January to be matched by $300 from the members of all the societies that would use the facilities. As for the site, Room M, North University (later called White 10) was chosen. During the spring of 1870, Andrew Dickson White allocated a large room inside the center door of what is now called Andrew Dickson White Hall, for the use of the literary societies. The room is now called the Dean's Seminar Room. At the time, White Hall was called North University and housed the engineering department as well as the office of Professor Goldwin Smith. Society Hall became one the standard stops on the Cornell campus tour and was described in the Cornell Era of June 29, 1870:
This is a large and beautifully furnished room used for meetings of the two chief literary societies and the Students’ Christian Association. It is carpeted, and its walls are partly wainscoted in two woods, partly tinted. On them, supported by bronze brackets, are placed nine full-length bronze statuettes executed in Paris and representing the following historic characters: Washington, Franklin, Shakespeare, Newton, Moliere, Goethe, Cervantes, Dante and Michelangelo. Interspersed between these are twenty large engravings, many of them proof impressions, depicting important scenes in the history of America and other countries. A half-hour may well be devoted to their examination, since some of the imported ones are exceedingly rare in this country. Nor should the handsome desk on the president’s rostrum be neglected, noteworthy as it is for the elegance of its design and the thoroughness of its execution. All the fittings of this hall are of the most substantial kind.”
The Society Hall room marked the first recognition that University-supplied space should be devoted to student activities and organizations. This further evolved with the parlor rooms in the Sage College for women in 1872, with the construction of Barnes Hall to house the Students’ Christian Association in 1888, and finally with the construction of Willard Straight Hall as the student union in 1925.
By the 1890s, many literary societies across the United States were declining, with the serious survivors turning into debating clubs. Cornell's controversial transition from literary societies to amusing extracurricular activities occurred in the 1880s. When the literary societies proposed, through the Cornell Era, the substitution of charades or mock trials for traditional literary activities, more conservative editors at the University of Virginia refused. The literary societies were starting to entertain activities of a less intellectual and more social nature. The transition from purely literary to amusing activities was noted by President Andrew Dickson White. His professional opinion was that the decline of Cornell’s undergraduate literary societies followed from the growth of Cornell's Greek System, the decline of oratory as a valued skill in late 19th century America, and Charles Kendall Adams' reforms which brought the "seminary"or seminar system to the University.
The last of the original Cornell literary societies, the Irving, ceased public operations by 1888. According to the Cornell Magazine, the Irving held its last meeting at Society Hall on May 27, 1887. The Cornell Debate Association performs a similar function to the literary societies at present.
The initial decline of the literary societies was followed by a period of inactivity for about five or six years after which there was a revived interest in student debates. The revival would not place the literary societies back in their position at the forefront of Cornell institutions, but it did provide a lasting place for oral debate on the Hill. The source of the 1890s revival of intercollegiate competitions has been generally attributed to Western colleges and their challenges to the Eastern elite institutions. At Cornell, this challenge occurred as the University was establishing a professorship in elocution, and competitions followed.
In 1900, the United States Bureau of Education cited the experience of the Irving, Philalatheian, and Curtis as evidence that the East Coast's traditional literary culture did not take root at the new Cornell University in the same manner as at Harvard, Yale, Pennsylvania, and other "seaboard" schools. The Land Grant college undergraduate culture was increasing in organized athletics. But during their preeminence, the Irving and its peers produced literature at a higher rate than the campus average for the next generation, leading commentators at the turn of the 20th century to question whether academic standards had fallen since Cornell University’s founding. The 1900 report observed that all of the Cornell literary societies had "disappeared."
Irving Literary Society
Cornell's first literary society was the Irving Literary Association, later the Irving Literary Society. It held its first business meeting in Room No. 4, Cascadilla Place, on October 20, 1868, some thirteen days after Cornell University opened its doors. It was named after the New York-born writer and historian Washington Irving. In 1884, three years before its final demise, the Ithaca Daily Democrat lamented its decline under mechanical and engineering students pursuing technical interests in the mid-1880s.
The Philaletheian Society
|This section requires expansion. (October 2010)|
The Philaletheian was founded on November 1, 1868 with Dudley W. Rhodes as its first president. Rhodes went on to become the valedictorian of Cornell's first graduating class. Unlike the Irving and Curtis societies, the Philaletheian limited its membership to men. On December 18, 1868, it conducted Cornell's first public exhibition at the Aurora Street Methodist Episcopal Church, where they debated, "Resolved, that a two-thirds majority of the Supreme Court should be necessary to annul an Act of Congress."
In the autumn of 1878, the Philaletheian changed its name (derived from the Greek word meaning "lover of truth") to the Cornell Debating Club. Its members decided that as its activities were exclusively concentrated on debate, a classical name was no longer appropriate. The society ceased to exist in 1885.
The Samuel Johnson or Johnsonian Society
|This section requires expansion. (April 2011)|
Named in honor of Samuel Johnson, it was founded in 1870 and lasted until 1872.
The Adelphi or Adelphia Society
|This section requires expansion. (October 2010)|
Adelphi was a secret literary society founded on January 16, 1870 and noted for bringing George Francis Train to Ithaca, New York, for a presentation. It was active from 1870 to 1877 with members that included the banker Joseph C. Hendrix and historian Emilius O. Randall.
The James Russell Lowell or Lowell Society
|This section requires expansion. (April 2011)|
Founded in 1871 and named in honor of James Russell Lowell.
The George William Curtis or Curtis Society
The Curtis Literary Society, named for the transcendentalist writer and orator George William Curtis, was founded on October 10, 1872. The Curtis was the first of the Cornell literary societies to admit women. The Curtis census during the fall of 1880 was about the same as the Cornell Club, the new debate forum. Each mustered about 15 students. An example of Curtis’ debate would be the November 1880 exercise: "Resolved, that suffrage be extended to women." The next month, Hidesabro Saze lectured on Japan. The following term, the Curtis provided new formats, such as the presentation of papers on a common topic like "The Contrast between Germany and Italy." When conducting these exercises, the members would also perform music from the cultures featured. The members also conducted mock trials. The society died out in October 1881. Among its members was the jurist Wilmot Moses Smith, who co-wrote the lyrics to Far Above Cayuga's Waters, Cornell's alma mater. On December 7, 1893 the name (but not the society itself) was resurrected when a group of undergraduates formed the Curtis Debating Club with separate organizations for sophomores, juniors and seniors, and a combined membership of 75 men. Eventually, an overall Cornell Union was established to coordinate all of the debating clubs.
The Philolexian Society
|This section requires expansion. (April 2011)|
Founded in 1872.
- "Cornell University," The People's Cyclopedia of Universal Knowledge (W.H. De Puy ed.1897) at 687.
- The Cornell University Register (3d.)(1874–5) at 77.
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine (8:4)(Jan. 1895) at 187–194.
- The Cornell Era (Nov. 17, 1869) at 76.
- Hewett, Waterman Thomas, et al., Cornell University, a History, The University Publishing Society, 1905, p. 6
- Hewett, Waterman Thomas, et al., Cornell University, a History, The University Publishing Society, 1905. See also Guide to the Mitchell and Barnes Families Papers,1791-1933
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine(8:4)(Jan. 1895) at 187–194.
- The Cornell Era (Feb. 2, 1870) at 133.
- E.g.,H. William Fogle. "The Deke House at Cornell A Concise History of the Delta Chi Chapter of Delta Kappa Epsilon, 1870-1930" (PDF). pp. 11–12. Retrieved 2010-12-02.
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine (8:4)(Jan. 1895) at 187–194; see also Cornell University, The Register 1879-1880 at 5.; "A Historical Sketch of Our Association," The Association Bulletin (1:)(Apr. 1886) at 1.
- The Cornell Era(Sept. 16, 1870) at 5.
- The Cornell Era (June 29, 1870) p. 275.
- "Sage Hall - facilities information". Cornell University. Retrieved 2010-10-26.
- "Barnes Hall - facilities information". Cornell University. Retrieved 2010-10-26.
- The Sage Handbook of Rhetorical Studies, "Intercollegiate Debate and Speech Communications" (Lunsford, Wilson & Eberly, eds.) at 319.
- See "Exchanges", The Virginia University Magazine (12:2)(Nov. 1873) p. 266.
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine (8:4)(Jan. 1895) at 187–194
- Moyer, Fayette E.. at 192. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "Moyer.2C_Fayette_E.._at_192" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine (8:4) (Jan. 1895) at 187–194
- U.S. Bureau of Education, supra, at 393.
- R.W., “The infancy of Cornell Journalism,” The Era (1900) at 74.
- Morris Bishop, A history of Cornell (1963) at 138.
- F.E. Moyer, ”Cornell Student Activities,” Cornell Magazine(8:4)(Jan. 1895) at 194.
- Daily Democrat 2 (Sept. 27, 1884)("The Irving literary society met last evening, but was poorly attended. This institution should be one of the most prosperous student societies in the college, but strange to say, it has deteriorated in point of numbers, and its management has fallen into the hands of technical instead of literary students.").
- Moyer, Fayette E. (Jan 1895). "Cornell Student Activities". Cornell Magazine. 8. p. 189.
- However, Selkreg reports that Philaletheian was founded before Irving. Selkreg, John H. (1894). "X". Landmarks of Tompkins County, New York. D. Mason & Co. Retrieved 2010-10-26.
- Cornell Alumni News, "Dudley W. Rhodes '69", Vol. XXVII, No. 40, August 1925, p. 500
- Fayette E. Moyer, "Literary Societies," Cornell Magazine (January 1895) at 7:187 (“Following the example of the Curtis, the Irving also admitted women to membership, but the Philaletheian, believing that there ought to be one society which devoted itself purely to debate, remained an organization for men only.”). See also Carol Kammen, Cornell: glorious to view (2003) at 39.
- Moyer, F.E. "Cornell Student Activities". Cornell Magazine. 8. pp. 191–92.
- The Cornell Magazine, Volume 8, 1896, p. 191
- Cornell Alumni News, "Prominent Cornellians: Joseph C. Hendrix", Vol. I, No. 5, May 3, 1899, pp. 31-32
- Cornell Alumni News, "Emilus O. Randall '74", Vol. XXII, No. 14, January 1, 1920, p. 160
- Moyer, Fayette E.. at 191.
- Editorial, The Cornell Daily Sun (10:2)(Oct. 1, 1880) at 18.
- Cornelliana, The Cornell Daily Sun (13.9)(Nov. 19, 1880) at 108.
- Personalia, The Cornell Era (13:11)(Dec. 3, 1880) at 132.
- Cornelliana The Cornell Era (13:16)(Jan. 28, 1881) at 19.
- Cornelliana, The Cornell Era (13:19)(Feb. 18, 1881) at 224.
- Cornell Alumni News, "Wilmot M. Smith '74", Vol. II., No. 10. November 29, 1899, p. 1
- Moyer, Fayette E.. at 193.