Countdown with Keith Olbermann
|Countdown with Keith Olbermann|
|Presented by||Keith Olbermann|
|Country of origin||United States|
|No. of episodes||1,400+|
|Location(s)||Secaucus, New Jersey
(April 3, 2003 – October 19, 2007)
New York City
(October 22, 2007 – January 21, 2011; June 20, 2011 – March 29, 2012)
|Running time||60 minutes (March 2003 – January 2011; June 2011 – March 2012)
63 minutes (some episodes in June 2011)
|Original network||MSNBC (2003 – 2011)
Current TV (2011 – 2012)
|Picture format||480i (SDTV)|
|Original release||March 31, 2003
– January 21, 2011 ;|
June 20, 2011 – March 29, 2012
Countdown with Keith Olbermann is an hour-long weeknight news and political commentary program hosted by Keith Olbermann that aired on MSNBC from 2003-2011 and Current TV from 2011-2012. The show presented five selected news stories of the day, with commentary by Olbermann and interviews of guests. At the start of Countdown, Olbermann told television columnist Lisa de Moraes:
"Our charge for the immediate future is to stay out of the way of the news.... News is the news. We will not be screwing around with it.... As times improve and the war [in Iraq] ends we will begin to introduce more and more elements familiar to my style."
The show was known for Olbermann's fast-paced rhetoric, historical and pop culture references, and liberal commentary. Olbermann melded news stories, both serious and light, with commentary, much of it critical of Republicans and conservative politics. The show has been the source of controversy due to these criticisms, as well as the host's ongoing commentary against Fox News and his feud with its leading primetime personality, Bill O'Reilly.
During the January 21, 2011, edition of Countdown, Olbermann announced that it would be his last appearance on the show, but gave no explanation why. The New York Times reported the following day that Olbermann had negotiated his exit from MSNBC, with a secret deal. After being hired by Current TV, Olbermann announced on April 26, 2011, that his nightly news program on the new network would begin June 20, 2011, and would also be called Countdown with Keith Olbermann. On March 30, 2012, Current TV terminated its relationship with Olbermann and replaced his show with a program hosted by Eliot Spitzer.
- 1 History
- 2 About the show
- 3 Criticism and response
- 4 Guests
- 5 Notes
- 6 External links
Countdown with Keith Olbermann debuted as Countdown: Iraq on March 31, 2003, hosted by NBC anchor Lester Holt; the program featured live updates on the then-unfolding War in Iraq. Countdown was broadcast at 8:00 p.m. on weekday nights, having replaced a cancelled talk show hosted by Phil Donahue. Olbermann—who left MSNBC in the late 1990s—returned to the network around this time and replaced Holt, becoming the permanent host for the renamed Countdown with Keith Olbermann. The show did not feature political commentary in its first few years, simply recapping the news of the day in a "5-4-3-2-1" format as the title suggested.
Countdown began to attract liberal and progressive viewers in 2005, when Olbermann began critiquing and satirizing conservative media commentators, specifically Fox News and its main primetime anchor, Bill O'Reilly. He criticized Fox and O'Reilly for purportedly deceiving their viewers in service to their alleged right-wing biases, frequently including the latter in Countdown's "Worst Person in the World" segment. O'Reilly, while not directly mentioning Olbermann, launched an online petition implicitly asking MSNBC to fire him, and, in conjunction with a call-in campaign organized by Mike Stark, threatened Stark for mentioning Olbermann by name after phoning in to O'Reilly's radio show. O'Reilly and other Fox personalities accused MSNBC of facilitating a liberal media bias, in what Olbermann described as a war of attrition intended to force him into silence.
In 2006, Olbermann started delivering occasional "Special Comments" in which he has expressed sharp criticisms of members of the George W. Bush administration, including then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Vice President Dick Cheney and President George W. Bush. While further Special Comments were directed at members of the Republican Party, Olbermann occasionally targeted Democrats as well. Issues addressed in the Special Comments dealt with the Bush Administration's foreign and domestic policies, mainly the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. One of the Special Comments spoke out against the passage of Proposition 8 in California on November 4, 2008, for which he was awarded the 2009 GLAAD Media Award for "Outstanding TV Journalism Segment". Olbermann's Special Comments were compared to Edward R. Murrow's signature essays.
On two occasions, guest hosts for Countdown proved popular enough to be given their own MSNBC shows, contributing to a widespread perception of MSNBC being a left-leaning network. In 2008, Air America Radio personality Rachel Maddow hosted Countdown in Olbermann's absence, leading to the debut of her own program, The Rachel Maddow Show. In 2009, left-wing political analyst Lawrence O'Donnell hosted Countdown for an extended period, leading to the eventual launch of his show The Last Word. Subsequent guest hosts included progressive radio hosts Cenk Uygur and Sam Seder, Obama biographer Richard Wolffe, journalist Chris Hayes, and DNC chairman Howard Dean.
Hiatus and first cancellation
On October 28, 2010, five days before the 2010 U.S. elections, Olbermann donated $2,400 each to three Democratic candidates for Congress: Kentucky Senate candidate Jack Conway, and Arizona Democratic Representatives Raul Grijalva and Gabrielle Giffords. In response, MSNBC President Phil Griffin suspended Olbermann indefinitely without pay on November 5, for violating a network policy regarding political contributions which required prior approval from management. An online petition calling for his reinstatement received over 250,000 signatures, and two days after the suspension began, Griffin announced that Olbermann would return to the air starting with the November 9 program.
On the January 21, 2011, episode of Countdown, Olbermann abruptly announced that the show would be his final MSNBC broadcast. Olbermann thanked viewers, producers, and technical staff for his show's eight-year success. However, he did not thank Griffin or NBC News president Steve Capus. Neither Olbermann nor MSNBC divulged the reason for the cancellation. Many liberal bloggers and commentators blamed the cable operator Comcast for Olbermann's departure, accusing the company of silencing the host for political purposes just days after acquiring NBC Universal on January 18. Statements from MSNBC and Comcast denied this allegation. Media critic Howard Kurtz, former MSNBC anchor David Shuster, and an anonymous NBC executive said that Olbermann's 2010 suspension was a more likely precipitating factor in Countdown's cancellation.
In subsequent interviews, Olbermann went into greater detail about the circumstances surrounding his exit from MSNBC. In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter published on June 7, 2011, Olbermann said he had faced increasing opposition from network management after Tim Russert died in 2008, because the Meet the Press moderator had been his ally and a peacemaker at the network. He further stated that "there were lots of people who were forced to choose sides" over his presence at MSNBC, including Maddow. Olbermann further stated that he didn't know he had been released from his MSNBC contract until less than a half-hour before his on-air farewell.
However, Olbermann's 2012 breach-of-contract lawsuit against Current TV indicated that Olbermann had been moved to leave MSNBC by Current founders Al Gore and Joel Hyatt. The lawsuit alleged that Gore and Hyatt had attempted to court Olbermann despite being informed that he had two years remaining on his MSNBC contract, and reached an agreement for him to join the network the same month as his departure from MSNBC, according to court documents acquired by TMZ.
Current TV period
On February 8, Olbermann announced that he had been hired as the host of a new primetime show on Current TV, the cable television network founded by former vice president Al Gore and businessman Joel Hyatt; in April, it was announced that the show would retain the Countdown title. Olbermann also became Current TV's "Chief News Officer" and bought an equity stake in the network. On May 11, Olbermann announced that Daily Kos founder Markos Moulitsas, filmmakers Michael Moore and Ken Burns, and comedian Richard Lewis would become contributors to the new Countdown. During a June 16 interview on NBC's Late Night with Jimmy Fallon, Olbermann further announced that journalists Matt Taibbi and Jeremy Scahill, former Nixon administration official and author John Dean, actor Donald Sutherland, and astronomer Derrick Pitts would also be contributors.
On June 20, Countdown aired its first episode on Current TV, concluding with an abbreviated "Special Comment" in which Olbermann outlined his mission statement, quoting Harriet Beecher Stowe. The program drew 179,000 viewers, a significant increase from Current TV's normal 30,000 viewership; it drew more viewers than CNN in the key 25-54 audience demographic. Countdown continued to beat CNN in the 25-54 demo throughout its first week on Current TV. Countdown saw a drop in ratings in its second week, but sustained an audience of 310,000 total viewers by September. The show was filmed at NEP Studio 33.
For the first two weeks of its Current TV run, Countdown ran slightly longer than an hour at sixty-three minutes, in a covert effort to erode MSNBC's viewership. However, Olbermann changed his mind and reverted the running time to the usual sixty minutes, realizing the move "would only serve to annoy fans of" both Countdown and Rachel Maddow's MSNBC show while not benefiting his own program's ratings. By the fall of 2011, Olbermann came into conflict with Current TV management over production values and creative control, and nearly left the network.
On March 30, 2012, Current TV terminated its relationship with Olbermann, thereby cancelling Countdown for a second time. In its statement, Current TV cited Olbermann's implied lack of "respect, openness, collegiality, and loyalty to our viewers." Internal sources reported that Olbermann's repeated absences, his failure to promote Current TV, and disparaging public comments he had made about the network contributed to the decision to fire him. Olbermann called Current TV's claims "untrue" and sued the network for breach-of-contract, demanding $50 million in damages. A counter-suit by Current TV cited Olbermann's work absences, as well as his allegedly abusive treatment of executives and staff. In March 2013, Olbermann and Current TV reached a settlement, with Olbermann receiving an undisclosed amount.
On his April 3, 2012 appearance on CBS's Late Show with David Letterman, Olbermann showed concern for his viewers and the production crew on Countdown, stating that "I screwed up. I screwed up really big on this." Olbermann referred to production issues, in-fighting and key absences during political events as the primary reasons that ended with Current TV's decision to pull Countdown from the network lineup.
About the show
The show's theme music was the opening bars of the second movement of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, a nod to NBC's Huntley-Brinkley Report and NBC Nightly News themes from the 1960s and 1970s. During the opening sequence of each nightly episode, Olbermann, in voice-over, previewed upcoming stories after asking, "Which of these stories will you be talking about tomorrow?" On MSNBC, the stories featured in the show's "countdown" was introduced by a "5-4-3-2-1" format; this format, however, was downplayed after Countdown's move to Current TV.
"Worst Person in the World" segment
The "Worst Person in the World" segment was a nightly feature in which Olbermann recounts three news stories involving people saying or doing things that offended Olbermann. "Nominees" for the dubious "Worst Person in the World" award are declared "worse", "worser", and "worst", which Olbermann refers to as bronze, silver, and gold levels, respectively. While many of his targets are not political, the overwhelming majority are conservatives, Fox News personalities, Tea Party activists, and, at the time, Bush Administration officials. The segment is introduced by Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D Minor. On a few occasions, during the show's MSNBC run, the segment was either briefly suspended or renamed in response to concerns that it contributed to an atmosphere of political divisiveness.
Based on this segment of the show, a book titled The Worst Person in the World was published in September 2006. It includes transcripts of segments that aired from this feature's inception on July 1, 2005, through May 31, 2006, as well as some original material. Another such book, Pitchforks and Torches — named after Olbermann's catchphrase in introducing the segment — was released in 2010.
"Time Marches On" segment
The "Time Marches On" segment was another nightly feature, in which Olbermann shows footage of strange news stories from around the world. The segment was originally called "Oddball", as a reference to the MSNBC program Hardball with Chris Matthews.
The "Keith number"
During the 2008 U.S. Presidential Primary season, Olbermann began using the term "Keith number" in reference to the sum of a pre-election opinion poll's margin of error and the percentage of respondents who are undecided. Olbermann believes this value tends to be predictive of the extent to which a poll may vary from actual election results, and also of the volatility of the electorate's leanings.
- The greater the poll's margin of error, the farther the results may be from the current views of the voters.
- The more undecided voters, the more likely voters are to change their views in the future.
On the January 11, 2008, episode of Countdown, Olbermann described the number as follows:
|“||What, you ask, is the ‘Keith number‘? This is the margin of error plus the percentage of undecided — in this case, four-and-a-half margin of error plus five percent undecided. I thought of it, so I named it after myself. You think of a better caveat for polls from now on and we‘ll name it after you.||”|
Olbermann's "Keith number" is unrelated (mathematically or otherwise) to the more traditional use of the term.
Criticism and response
The Media Research Center, a conservative media watchdog group, was critical of Olbermann and his coverage, issuing a press release describing Olbermann's November 1, 2006 Special Comment as "preaching hate speech", and describing Olbermann as "a brown-shirted left-winger spew[ing] hate from an NBC-owned podium." In response, Olbermann named MRC founder Brent Bozell – whom he has described variously as "Redbeard the pirate", and "humorist", – the "worst person in the world" for various comments he has made about Countdown and other topics. Olbermann, in an interview with the Hartford Courant, claimed that the MRC desires "an institutionalized, pro-Republican slant" in the media.
Olbermann has addressed the assertions of liberal bias by stating that he would be equally critical of a Democratic president who had invited criticism by his actions:
"I mean, no one in 1998, no one accused me of being a liberal in 1998 because I was covering the Lewinsky scandal. And whatever I had to do about it, I tried to be fair and honest and as accurate and as informed as possible, and allow my viewer to be the same way. And nowadays it's the same thing. And now all of a sudden I’m a screaming liberal."
However, Howard Kurtz has written that Olbermann departed MSNBC the first time as a result of the Clinton-Lewinsky coverage, which he did not personally agree with. Elsewhere, Los Angeles Times TV critic Howard Rosenberg commented on the show's absence of guests who challenged Olbermann's views, writing "'Countdown' is more or less an echo chamber in which Olbermann and like-minded bobbleheads nod at each other."
On November 25, 2006, Fox News Watch panelist Cal Thomas named Olbermann as his choice for 2006's "Media Turkey Award" for what Thomas alleged were Olbermann's "inaccuracies" and "hot air". Olbermann in turn gave the show the Bronze for "Worst Person in the World", not for naming him "Turkey of the Year", but for misspelling his last name as "Olberman" on the onscreen graphic.
Regular contributors featured on the show in its Current TV run included:
- David Shuster, former MSNBC anchor and "primary substitute anchor" since June 7, 2011
- Matt Taibbi, Rolling Stone journalist
- Michael Moore, filmmaker
- Ken Burns, documentarian
- Richard Lewis, comedian and actor
- Sam Seder, host of The Majority Report and occasional substitute anchor.
- Markos Moulitsas, creator of Daily Kos
- John Dean, former White House Counsel to Richard Nixon—political
- Heather McGhee, Director of the Washington office of Demos
- Jonathan Turley, law professor at The George Washington University School of Law
- Maysoon Zayid, comedian and activist
- Kate Sheppard, Mother Jones energy and environmental reporter
- Jeremy Scahill, investigative journalist and author
- Donald Sutherland, actor
- Mark Ruffalo, actor
- Derrick Pitts, astronomer
- Nicole Lamoureux, the executive director of the National Association of Free Clinics
- Jonathan Alter, senior editor for Newsweek magazine—political
- Margaret Carlson, TIME Magazine columnist and author of Anyone Can Grow Up: How George Bush and I Made it to the White House
- Chris Cillizza, blogger for The Washington Post
- Howard Fineman, Newsweek contributor—political
- Christian Finnegan, comedian—tabloid/entertainment
- Christopher Hayes, Washington, D.C. editor for The Nation
- Chris Kofinis, Democratic political strategist
- Howard Dean, former Democratic National Committee chairman
- Eugene Robinson, newspaper columnist for The Washington Post
- Paul F. Tompkins, comedian—tabloid/entertainment
- Richard Wolffe, Newsweek—politicalHouse—journalistic, political
- Lynn Woolsey, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus
- Melissa Harris-Perry, professor of politics and African-American studies, Princeton University—political
- Jason Bateman, actor—pop culture
- Shannyn Moore, contributor to Huffington Post
- Wesley Clark, retired four-star general—military analyst for MSNBC
- E. J. Dionne, columnist for The Washington Post
- John Harwood, New York Times writer and CNBC contributing reporter—political
- Richard Justice, Sports Writer for the Houston Chronicle
- Rachel Maddow, who also served as a substitute anchor from April through August in 2008 before getting her own MSNBC show.
- General Barry McCaffrey, Ret. — military
- Joel McHale, host of the E! show The Soup - pop culture
- Maria Milito, New York disc jockey — American Idol
- Michael Musto, editor of The Village Voice— tabloid/entertainment
- Lawrence O'Donnell, MSNBC political analyst and host of The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell
- Tom O'Neil, editor of Entertainment Weekly—entertainment
- Clarence Page, columnist and member of the editorial board of the Chicago Tribune
- Nate Silver, founder of FiveThirtyEight.com - for 2008 presidential election prediction
- Jon Soltz, Iraq War Veteran, Co-Founder and Chairman of VoteVets.org
- Chuck Todd, political director for NBC News
- Clint Van Zandt, former FBI profiler—abductions/murders
- Robin Wright, diplomatic correspondent for The Washington Post —terrorism and international events
- "Countdown with Keith Olbermann for April 3, 2008". Countdown with Keith Olbermann. MSNBC. 2008-04-03.
- Barnhart, Aaron (2008-01-06). "Keith Olbermann enjoys big success and very little wisdom". Kansas City Star.
Is this a straight newscast at this point?" Olbermann said. "Probably not. It is, however, entirely news-driven. If there is no daily controversy about the Iraq war, we’re not going to start the show with one.
- Shafer, Jack (2006-04-18). "The Olbermann-O'Reilly feud.". Slate Magazine.
- Carter, Bill (January 21, 2011). "Olbermann Leaves ‘Countdown' on MSNBC". The New York Times.
- Carter, Bill (January 22, 2011). "Olbermann's MSNBC Exit Was Weeks in the Making". The New York Times.
- "Olbermann out, Spitzer in on Current TV". Politico. 30 March 2012. Retrieved 30 March 2012.
- Time: Bill O'Reilly vs. Keith Olbermann, Top 10 TV Feuds. March 12, 2009.
- CallingAllWingnuts.com: Awwww... You Got Me, Bill at the Wayback Machine (archived April 4, 2006). Archive accessed February 12, 2013.
- The Radio Factor, Bill O'Reilly, March 2, 2006.
- Olbermann Blasts O'Reilly For Attacking GE: "You Are More Personally Responsible For The 4,000 Dead Americans In Iraq Than All of America's Corporations Put Together.", The Huffington Post, 23 April 2008.
- Landau, Erica (November 11, 2008). "Olbermann on Prop 8: 'It's About the Human Heart'". The Nation.
- Bryant, Adam (November 11, 2008). "Keith Olbermann Inks New Deal, Lets Loose on California Gay Marriage Ban". TV Guide.
- "Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation - Media Award recipients". Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation. Retrieved 2009-04-02. Archived April 1, 2009, at the Wayback Machine.
- Kitman, Marvin. "Olbermann Rules!". The Nation.com. Retrieved 2007-12-24.
- Nevius, C.W. (November 12, 2006). "Olbermann taps a well of discontent as the anti-O'Reilly". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved 2008-02-13.
- Boyer, Peter J., One Angry Man: Is Keith Olbermann changing TV news? In the New Yorker, June 23, 2008.
- Barnhart, Aaron (2008-06-14). "MSNBC’s Chuck Todd and Rachel Maddow are young, geeky and hot". Kansas City Star.
- Simmi Aujla (November 5, 2010). "Keith Olbermann suspended after donating to Democrats". Politico.
- Danny Shea (November 5, 2010). "Keith Olbermann Suspended From MSNBC Indefinitely Without Pay". Huffington Post.
- "NBC: Olbermann suspension ending Tuesday". MSNBC.com. 7 November 2010. Retrieved 7 November 2010.
- Keith Olbermann signs off from MSNBC, CNN.com, 22 January 2011
- Critics see Comcast's hand in Olbermann departure from MSNBC, The Hill, 22 January 2011
- Olbermann Fired Because of Comcast via TMZ - Stance on Net Neutrality To Blame?, The Daily Kos, 21 January 2011
- Olbermann and MSNBC: a failing relationship, Associated Press, 22 January 2011
- Keith Olbermann Breaks Silence On MSNBC Exit; Could Earn $100M at Current TV, The Hollywood Reporter, 7 June 2011
- For Current TV, Adding Olbermann Is Way to Gain an Identity, The New York Times, 8 February 2011
- Michael Moore, Ken Burns Tapped as Contributors for Keith Olbermann’s Current TV Show, TVNewser, 11 May 2011
- Keith Olbermann Adds Contributors to ‘Countdown’ on Current, Talks Rachel Maddow on NBC, TVNewser, 17 June 2011
- Keith Olbermann's 'Countdown' Beats CNN in Target Demo, The Hollywood Reporter, 21 June 2011
- In First Week on Current, Keith Olbermann Beats CNN in Target Demo, The Hollywood Reporter, 28 June 2011
- ‘Countdown’ on Current TV Drops in Week Two, TVNewser, 6 June 2011
- Keith Olbermann’s ‘Countdown’ Gets Highest Ratings Since Current TV Debut, TVNewser, 1 September 2011
- "Company Town". Los Angeles Times. June 30, 2011.
- Al Gore's Desperate Bid to Keep Keith Olbermann—and Save Current TV, The Daily Beast, 6 February 2012
- Current TV Fires Keith Olbermann, Replaces Him With Spitzer Immediately, Olbermann to Sue, ThinkProgress, 30 March 2012
- Acid-tongued broadcaster Keith Olbermann gets the boot from Al Gore's Current TV, The Christian Science Monitor, 31 March 2012
- Current TV Counter-Sues Keith Olbermann, TVNewser.com, 6 April 2012
- Keith Olbermann Settles $50 Million Lawsuit Against Current TV and Al Gore, Forbes, 13 March 2013
- USA Today. April 3, 2012 http://content.usatoday.com/communities/entertainment/post/2012/04/keith-olbermann-admits-i-screwed-up-/1#.T3v3ntUXheR. Missing or empty
- http://insidetv.ew.com/2012/04/03/keith-olbermann-on-letterman-i-screwed-up-really-big/?iid=rcfooter-tv-keith+olbermann+has+his+say. Missing or empty
- "The "Worst" of MSNBC's Keith Olbermann". Media Research Center. 2006-06-26. Retrieved 2006-09-02.
- "About Toccata and Fugue in D Minor". TripAtlas.com. Retrieved 2010-07-13.
- Keith Olbermann’s ‘Worst Person’ Suspension Over? According to his Twitter It is, TVNewser, 17 November 2010
- "A note on 'Worst Persons in the World' (VIDEO)". MSNBC. January 10, 2010. Retrieved 2010-01-10.
- Olbermann, Keith (September 15, 2006). "The Worst Person in the World". MSNBC. Retrieved 2008-03-11.
- Blumenthal, Mark (February 14, 2008). "The Keith number". Mystery Pollster. National Journal. Retrieved 2008-04-05.
- "Countdown with Keith Olbermann for January 11, 2008". Countdown with Keith Olbermann. MSNBC. 2008-01-14.
- "MSNBC’s Keith Olbermann Preaches Hate Speech And Liberal Media Are Silent" (Press release). Media Research Center. November 2, 2006. Retrieved 2008-09-11.
- "Countdown with Keith Olbermann for October 25, 2005". Countdown with Keith Olbermann. MSNBC. 2005-10-25.
- "Countdown with Keith Olbermann for July 13, 2006". Countdown with Keith Olbermann. MSNBC. 2006-07-13.
- "'Countdown with Keith Olbermann' for July 13". MSNBC. July 13, 2006. Retrieved 2013-02-23.
- Hartford Courant: Making Sport Of It All. at the Wayback Machine (archived March 23, 2005) March 15, 2005.
- "Q & A." March 12, 2006. C-SPAN. Uncorrected transcript provided by Morningside Partners. Retrieved on January 24, 2009.
- "Howard Kurtz - The Anti-Bush Anchor - washingtonpost.com". Washingtonpost.com. April 3, 2006. Retrieved 2008-11-08.
- Rosenberg, Howard (June 7, 2008). "Is Olbermann's snide act on MSNBC the future of TV news? - Los Angeles Times". Latimes.com. Retrieved 2008-11-08.
- Fox News: Fox News Watch. November 25, 2006.
- "Countdown with Keith Olbermann for November 28, 2006". Countdown with Keith Olbermann. MSNBC. 2006-11-28.
- Marisa Guthrie (11:01 AM 6/7/2011). "The Confessions of Keith Olbermann". The Hollywood Reporter. Check date values in:
- "Olbermann.org: An Unofficial Keith Olbermann Archive and Fan Site". Olbermann.org. Retrieved 2008-11-08.
- "Melissa Harris-Lacewell (official site)". www.melissaharrislacewell.com. Retrieved 2010-07-16.