Criticism of Mother Teresa

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Mother Teresa at a pro-life meeting in 1986 in Bonn, West Germany

The work of Roman Catholic nun, missionary, and saint Mother Teresa received mixed reactions from prominent people, governments and organizations. Her practices and those of the Missionaries of Charity, the order she founded, were subject to numerous controversies. These include objections to the quality of medical care they provided, suggestions that some deathbed baptisms constituted forced conversion, and alleged links to colonialism and racism. Teresa received extensive media coverage, and some critics suggest that the Church used her image to promote Catholicism and to distract from ecclesiastical scandals.

Media criticisms[edit]

Indian author and physician Aroup Chatterjee, who briefly worked in one of Mother Teresa's homes, later investigated the financial and other practices of Teresa's order. In 1994, two British journalists, Christopher Hitchens and Tariq Ali, produced a critical British Channel 4 documentary, Hell's Angel, based on Chatterjee's work. The next year, Hitchens published The Missionary Position: Mother Teresa in Theory and Practice, a book that repeated many of the accusations in the documentary. Chatterjee published The Final Verdict in 2003, a less polemic work than those of Hitchens and Ali, but equally critical of Teresa's operations.[1] Chatterjee and Hitchens were called by the Vatican to present evidence against Teresa during her canonisation process.[2] In 2016, American sociologist, activist, and president of the Catholic League Bill Donohue wrote a book-length response to criticism of Mother Teresa.[3]

Quality of medical care[edit]

In 1991, Robin Fox, editor of the British medical journal The Lancet visited the Home for Dying Destitutes in Calcutta (now Kolkata) and described the medical care the patients received as "haphazard".[4] He observed that sisters and volunteers, some of whom had no medical knowledge, had to make decisions about patient care, because of the lack of doctors in the hospice. Fox specifically held Teresa responsible for conditions in this home, and observed that her order did not distinguish between curable and incurable patients, so that people who could otherwise survive would be at risk of dying from infections and lack of treatment.

Fox conceded that the regimen he observed included cleanliness, the tending of wounds and sores, and kindness, but he noted that the sisters' approach to managing pain was "disturbingly lacking". The formulary at the facility Fox visited lacked strong analgesics which he felt clearly separated Mother Teresa's approach from the hospice movement. Fox also wrote that needles were rinsed with warm water, which left them inadequately sterilised, and that the facility did not isolate patients with tuberculosis. There have been a series of other reports documenting inattention to medical care in the order's facilities. Similar points of view have also been expressed by some former volunteers who worked for Teresa's order. Mother Teresa herself referred to the facilities as "Houses of the Dying".[5]

In 2013, in a comprehensive review[6] covering 96% of the literature on Mother Teresa, a group of Université de Montréal academics reinforced the foregoing criticism, detailing, among other issues, the missionary's practice of "caring for the sick by glorifying their suffering instead of relieving it, … her questionable political contacts, her suspicious management of the enormous sums of money she received, and her overly dogmatic views regarding, in particular, abortion, contraception, and divorce". Questioning the Vatican's motivations for ignoring the mass of criticism, the study concluded that Mother Teresa's "hallowed image—which does not stand up to analysis of the facts—was constructed, and that her beatification was orchestrated by an effective media relations campaign" engineered by the Catholic convert and anti-abortion BBC journalist Malcolm Muggeridge.[7]

Baptisms of the dying[edit]

According to Christopher Hitchens, Mother Teresa encouraged members of her order to secretly baptise dying patients, without regard to the individual's religion. Susan Shields, a former member of the Missionaries of Charity, writes that "Sisters were to ask each person in danger of death if he wanted a 'ticket to heaven'. An affirmative reply was to mean consent to baptism. The sister was then to pretend that she was just cooling the patient’s head with a wet cloth, while in fact she was baptising him, saying quietly the necessary words. Secrecy was important so that it would not come to be known that Mother Teresa's sisters were baptising Hindus and Muslims."[8]

Murray Kempton has argued that patients were not provided sufficient information to make an informed decision about whether they wanted to be baptised and the theological significance of a Christian baptism.[9] Simon Leys, defending the practice in a letter to the New York Review of Books, argued that forced conversion is either benevolent or morally neutral.[10]

Relationships to controversial public figures[edit]

In Hell's Angel and The Missionary Position, Hitchens leveled criticism at what he perceived to be Mother Teresa's endorsement of the regime of Enver Hoxha in Socialist Albania. She had visited Albania in August 1989, where she was received by Hoxha's widow, Nexhmije, Foreign Minister Reis Malile, Minister of Health, Ahmet Kamberi, the Chairman of the People's Assembly Petro Dode, and other state and party officials. She subsequently laid a bouquet on Hoxha's grave, and placed a wreath on the statue of Mother Albania.[11]

She accepted money from the British publisher Robert Maxwell,[12][13] who, as was later revealed, embezzled UK£450 million from his employees' pension funds. There is no suggestion that she was aware of any theft before accepting the donation in either case. Criticism does focus on Teresa's character statement produced in the Charles Keating case, where Keating was charged with fraud following high-profile business failures. Keating had donated millions of dollars to Mother Teresa and had lent her his private jet when she visited the United States.[14] Keating's convictions were thrown out on appeal, as was a summary judgement.[15][16][17] Keating later pled guilty to four counts of wire and bankruptcy fraud and was sentenced to time served.[18]

After Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi's suspension of civil liberties in 1975 (The Emergency), Mother Teresa said: "People are happier. There are more jobs. There are no strikes." These approving comments were seen as a result of the friendship between Teresa and the Congress Party. Mother Teresa's comments were even criticised outside India within the Catholic media.[19]

She supported Licio Gelli's nomination for the Nobel Prize in Literature.[20] Gelli was known for being the head of the Propaganda Due masonic lodge, which was implicated in various murders and high-profile corruption cases in Italy, as well as having close connections with the neo-fascist Italian Social Movement and the Argentine Military Junta.

In 2017, investigative journalist Gianluigi Nuzzi, in a book titled Original Sin published accounting documents from the controversial Vatican Bank – officially known as the Institute for the Works of Religion, which revealed that the funds held in Mother Theresa's name on behalf of her charity had made her the Bank's biggest client, and amounted to billions. Had she made substantial withdrawals, the Bank would have risked default.[21][22][23][24]

Motivation of charitable activities[edit]

Chatterjee stated that the public image of Mother Teresa as a "helper of the poor" was misleading, and that only a few hundred people are served by even the largest of the homes. In 1998, among the 200 charitable assistance organisations reported to operate in Calcutta, Missionaries of Charity was not ranked among the largest charity organisations–with the Assembly of God charity notably serving a greater number of the poor at 18,000 meals daily.[25]

Chatterjee alleged that many operations of the order engage in no charitable activity at all but instead use their funds for missionary work. He stated, for example, that none of the eight facilities that the Missionaries of Charity run in Papua New Guinea have any residents in them, being purely for the purpose of converting local people to Catholicism.

She was sometimes accused by Hindus in her adopted country of trying to convert the poor to Catholicism by "stealth".[26] Christopher Hitchens described Mother Teresa's organisation as a cult that promoted suffering and did not help those in need. He said that Mother Teresa's own words on poverty proved that her intention was not to help people, quoting her words at a 1981 press conference in which she was asked: "Do you teach the poor to endure their lot?" She replied: "I think it is very beautiful for the poor to accept their lot, to share it with the passion of Christ. I think the world is being much helped by the suffering of the poor people."[11]

Relation to colonialism and racism[edit]

In an essay in the collection White Women in Racialized Spaces, historian Vijay Prashad said of Mother Teresa:

Mother Teresa is the quintessential image of the white woman in the colonies, working to save the dark bodies from their own temptations and failures. [...] The Euro-American-dominated international media continue to harbor the colonial notion that white peoples are somehow especially endowed with the capacity to create social change. When nonwhite people labor in this direction, the media typically search for white benefactors or teachers, or else, for white people who stand in the wings to direct the nonwhite actors. Dark bodies cannot act of their own volition to stretch their own capacity, for they must wait, the media seem to imply, for some colonial administrator, some technocrat from IBM or the IMF to tell them how to do things. When it comes to saving the poor, the dark bodies are again invisible, for the media seem to celebrate only the worn out platitudes of such as Mother Teresa and ignore the struggles of those bodies for their own liberation. To open the life of someone like Mother Teresa to scrutiny, therefore, is always difficult. [...] Mother Teresa's work was part of a global enterprise for the alleviation of bourgeois guilt, rather than a genuine challenge to those forces that produce and maintain poverty.[27]

Posthumous criticisms[edit]

Mother Teresa died in 1997. Despite her request that all writing and correspondence be destroyed, a collection was posthumously released to the public in book form.[28][page needed] Her writings revealed that she struggled with feelings of disconnectedness,[29] that were in contrast to the strong feelings she had experienced as a young novice.[30] In her letters Mother Teresa describes a decades long sense of feeling disconnected from God[31] and lacking the earlier zeal that had characterized her efforts to start the Missionaries of Charity. As a result of this, she was judged by some to have "ceased to believe" and was posthumously criticized for hypocrisy.[32][33][not in citation given] Thomas C. Reeves suggests such criticism displays a basic unfamiliarity with the concept of the "dark night of the soul".[34]

The Showtime program Penn & Teller: Bullshit! has an episode titled "Holier than Thou" that was released in 2005, which criticises Mother Teresa, as well as Mahatma Gandhi and the 14th Dalai Lama. The show criticises Mother Teresa's relationships with Charles Keating and the Duvalier family, as well as the quality of medical care in her home for the dying. Christopher Hitchens appears on, and narrates, some of the episode.[35] According to Navin B. Chawla, the Missionaries of Charity set up a small mission in Port-au-Prince. A day after Mother Teresa visited and left, Duvalier’s daughter-in-law went to Mother Teresa’s mission and donated 1,000 dollars, not one million as reported.[36]

In 2003, after Teresa was beatified by John Paul II, Hitchens continued his criticism, calling her "a fanatic, a fundamentalist, and a fraud." He further criticized the Catholic Church for ignoring the testimony of Dr. Ranjan Mustafi who attributed the recovery of his patient to modern medicine, rather than a miracle associated with Mother Teresa.[37] In 2016, when she was canonized, Dan Savage drew attention to the conflicting evidence and accused NPR of describing alleged miracles in a way that favoured the church's interpretation.[38]

Responses to criticism[edit]

An article in the conservative religious journal First Things criticises Christopher Hitchens' methods and findings of the Université de Montréal review.[39] A more detailed response to criticism of Mother Teresa's critics came from William A. Donohue.[40]

Melanie McDonagh believes that Mother Teresa is in large part "criticized for not being what she never set out to be, for not doing things which she never saw as her job." Mother Teresa was not a social worker. She did not address the fundamental causes of poverty; "she wasn't trying to do anything except treat people at the margins of society as if they were Christ himself."[41]

Mari Marcel Thekaekara points out that after the Bengladesh War, a few million refugees poured into Calcutta from the former East Pakistan. "No one had ever before done anything remotely like Mother Teresa's order, namely picking up destitute and dying people off the pavements and giving them a clean place to die in dignity."[42]

Navin B. Chawla points out that Mother Teresa never intended to build hospitals, but to provide a place where those who had been refused admittance "could at least die being comforted and with some dignity." He also counters that her periodic hospitalizations were instigated by staff members against her wishes and disputes surreptitious baptisms. "...those who are quick to criticise Mother Teresa and her mission, are unable or unwilling to do anything to help with their own hands."[36]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Dutta, Krishna (16 May 2003). "Saint of the gutters with friends in high places". Times Higher Education. Retrieved 4 March 2011. 
  2. ^ Crawley, William (26 Aug 2010). "Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict?". BBC. Retrieved 18 Dec 2015. 
  3. ^ "Bill Donohue: Mother Teresa Scared Atheists, Socialists". Newsmax. 2016-08-31. Retrieved 2017-11-23. 
  4. ^ Fox, Robin (1994). "Mother Teresa's care for the dying". The Lancet. 344 (8925): 807–808. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(94)92353-1. 
  5. ^ Robin Fox. "Mother Theresa's care for the dying". The Lancet. 344 (8925): 807–808. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(94)92353-1. ; cf. "Mother Teresa's care for the dying," letters from David Jeffrey, Joseph O'Neill and Gilly Burns, The Lancet 344 (8929): 1098
  6. ^ Larivée, Serge; Carole Sénéchal; Geneviève Chénard (2013). "Les côtés ténébreux de Mère Teresa". Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses. 42 (3): 319–345. doi:10.1177/0008429812469894. 
  7. ^ "Mother Teresa: Anything but a Saint…". U de M Nouvelles. 1 March 2013. Archived from the original on 2016-04-01. 
  8. ^ Christopher Hitchens (24 April 2012). The Missionary Position: Mother Theresa in Theory and Practice. McClelland & Stewart. pp. 51–. ISBN 978-0-7710-3919-5. 
  9. ^ Kempton, Murray. "The Shadow Saint". www.nybooks.com. The New York Review of Books. Retrieved 18 December 2015. 
  10. ^ Leys, Simon. "In Defense of Mother Teresa". The New York Review of Books. Retrieved 18 December 2015. 
  11. ^ a b Hitchens, Christopher (1995). The Missionary Position: Mother Teresa in Theory and Practice. London: Verso. p. 82. ISBN 978-1-85984-054-2. Retrieved 22 August 2014. 
  12. ^ Squires, Nick. "Mother Teresa's legacy under cloud as sainthood nears". The Telegraph. Retrieved 20 January 2017. 
  13. ^ Woods, Mark. "Mother Teresa and her critics: Should she really be made a saint?". Christian Today. Christian Media Corporation. Retrieved 20 January 2017. 
  14. ^ "Charles Keating – obituary". The Telegraph. 2 April 2014. 
  15. ^ "U.S. Judge Overturns State Conviction of Keating". The New York Times. Associated Press. 1996-04-04. 
  16. ^ Sterngold, James (1996-12-03). "Judge Throws Out Keating's Verdict". The New York Times. 
  17. ^ "Appeals Court Rules In Favor of Keating". The New York Times. 1999-08-07. 
  18. ^ Mrozek, Thom (April 6, 1999). "Charles Keating pleads guilty to federal fraud charges; four criminal convictions resolve 10-year-old case" (Press release). United States Attorney for the Central District of California. Archived from the original on 1999-09-21. 
  19. ^ Chatterjee, Aroup (2002). Mother Teresa: The Final Verdict. Meteor Books. p. 276. ISBN 9788188248001. 
  20. ^ Fertilio, Dario (17 February 2006). ""Licio Gelli si merita la vittoria": parola di Madre Teresa e Mahfuz" (in Italian). Corriere della Sera. 
  21. ^ Gianluigi Nuzzi "Peccato Originale" Chiarelettere, 2017
  22. ^ Nadeau, Barbie Latza "Mother Teresa’s Secret Billions and a Vatican Seminary Rampant with Sex Abuse—a New Book Tells All", The Daily Beast, 11 November 2017 [1]
  23. ^ "l libro di Nuzzi: “Madre Teresa aveva un maxi-conto allo Ior", La Stampa, 9 November 2017, [2]
  24. ^ Curridori, Francesco "Madre Teresa aveva un maxi-conto allo Ior", il Giornale, 9 November 2017, [3]
  25. ^ Wüllenweber, Walter (10 September 1998). "Mutter Teresa – wo sind ihre Millionen?" [Mother Teresa – Where are her millions?] (PDF). Stern (in German). Gruner + Jahr. p. 214. Archived (PDF) from the original on 13 November 2004. Retrieved 15 September 2016. Das Essen bekommt Samity jedoch nicht vom Order der Mutter Teresa sondern von der "Assembly of God", einer amerikanischen Hilfsorganisation, die hier täglich 18 000 Mahlzeiten ausgibt.  - translated source
  26. ^ "1997: Mother Teresa dies", BBC On This Day, 5 September 2008
  27. ^ Prashad, Vijay (2012). "Mother Teresa as the Mirror of Bourgeois Guilt". In Najmi, Samina; Srikanth, Rajini. White Women in Racialized Spaces: Imaginative Transformation and Ethical Action in Literature (illustrated ed.). State University of New York Press. pp. 67–68. ISBN 978-0-7914-8808-9. Retrieved 8 March 2015. 
  28. ^ Kolodiejchuk, Brian (ed.). Mother Teresa: Come Be My Light: The Private Writings of the Saint of Calcutta. ISBN 978-0-307-58923-1. 
  29. ^ Van Biema, David (23 August 2007). "Mother Teresa's Crisis of Faith". Time. 
  30. ^ "New Book Reveals Mother Teresa's Struggle with Faith". Beliefnet. 
  31. ^ Moore, Malcolm (24 August 2007). "Mother Teresa's 40 year faith crisis". Telegraph. 
  32. ^ Mannion, Francis (18 September 2014). "Mother Teresa of Calcutta's Dark Night of the Soul". Catholic News Agency. 
  33. ^ "CNN iReport: 'Crisis of Faith: Mother Teresa's letters'". CNN. 1 June 2009. Archived from the original on 22 December 2015. Retrieved 18 December 2015. 
  34. ^ Reeves, Thomas C., "Mother Teresa's Critics Undone", The Catholic League, September 20 2016
  35. ^ "Holier Than Thou". Penn & Teller: Bullshit!. Season 3. Episode 5. 23 May 2005. Showtime. 
  36. ^ a b Chawla, Navin B., "The Mother Teresa her critics choose to ignore", the Hindu, August 26, 2013
  37. ^ Hitchens, Christopher (2003-10-20). "Mommie Dearest". Slate. Retrieved 2018-03-23. 
  38. ^ Savage, Dan (2016-08-31). "NPR Believes in Miracles". The Stranger. Retrieved 2018-03-23. 
  39. ^ Doino, William Jr (1 April 2013). "Mother Teresa and Her Critics". First Things. Retrieved 22 December 2015. 
  40. ^ Donohue, William A. (2016). Unmasking Mother Teresa’s Critics. Sophia Institute Press. pp. 21–33. ISBN 9781622823758. 
  41. ^ McDonagh, Melanie. "Why is Mother Teresa criticized for not doing things that weren't her job?", The Spectator, 4 September 2016
  42. ^ Thekaekara, Mari Marcel. "Reflections on the harsh criticism of Mother Teresa", The New Internationalist, 14 September 2016

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]