|Based on||Cruel Doubt|
by Joe McGinniss
|Screenplay by||John Gay|
|Story by||Joe McGinniss|
|Directed by||Yves Simoneau|
|Theme music composer||George S. Clinton|
|Country of origin||United States|
|Running time||187 min.|
|Original release||May 17, 1992|
|Preceded by||Blind Faith (1990)|
Cruel Doubt is a 1992 miniseries starring Blythe Danner and Matt McGrath, as well as Danner's daughter, Gwyneth Paltrow. The film was broadcast in two parts on NBC in the United States and on CTV in Canada on May 17 and May 19, 1992.
The miniseries is based on the 1991 true crime book Cruel Doubt by Joe McGinniss, which documents the 1988 murder of Lieth Von Stein by his stepson, Chris Pritchard, and two friends, James Upchurch and Gerald Neal Henderson.
In their bedroom asleep one night, Bonnie and Leith Von Stein are violently attacked and stabbed by home intruders. Bonnie barely survives, but her husband does not.
The investigation into who could do such a thing, and for what purpose, takes an unexpected twist when Bonnie's son Chris Pritchard becomes a prime suspect in the case. Police theorize that it is possible Chris provided two friends from school, Henderson and Upchurch, with a detailed map to the Von Stein family's home, resulting in his mother and stepfather being assaulted while Chris was away at college and his sister Angela asleep in her own bedroom at home.
The savagery of the crime and the absurdity of the charge leads Bonnie to hire attorney Bill Osteen to represent Chris, in as much as she finds it impossible that he could have played a role in her husband's murder. The more police investigate, however, the more Osteen tries to prepare Bonnie that her son may indeed be involved. And that even Angela may know more than she has been telling.
- Blythe Danner as Bonnie Von Stein
- Matt McGrath as Chris Pritchard
- Ed Asner as Bill Osteen
- Gwyneth Paltrow as Angela Pritchard
- Denis Arndt as Leith Von Stein
- Neal McDonough as Henderson
- Travis Fine as Upchurch
- Adam Baldwin as Detective Taylor
- Dennis Farina as Tom Brereton
- William Forsythe as Chief Crone
- Miguel Ferrer as Louis Young
- Louise Latham as Polly Bates
- G.D. Spradlin as George Bates
Although the film brought much attention to the murder of Von Stein, devotees of the role-playing game Dungeons & Dragons have criticized it for unfairly placing blame of the murders upon the game. The three perpetrating friends were supposedly fanatics. The film unethically featured the actual Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st-edition rulebook (which by then was a multi-million best-seller) but with a piece of artwork visibly pasted into the pages of the book (depicting an orc with a dagger and backpack similar to the ones in the murder depicted), implying that it had caused the murders.
- McGinniss misspells the name "Neil," but it is spelled correctly in Jerry Bledsoe's book Blood Games.
- The Attacks on Role-Playing Games Archived 2007-08-05 at the Wayback Machine, by Paul Cardwell, Jr., originally published in Skeptical Inquirer, 18:2, 1994 (157-165).
- Cruel Doubt on The Escapist's FAQ