Cup and ring mark
Cup and ring marks or cup marks are a form of prehistoric art found in the Atlantic seaboard of Europe (Ireland, Wales, Northern England, Scotland, France (Brittany), Portugal, and Spain (Galicia) – and in Mediterranean Europe – Italy (in Alpine valleys and Sardinia) and Greece (Thessaly and Irakleia (Cyclades)), as well as in Scandinavia (Denmark, Sweden, Norway and Finland) and in Switzerland (at Caschenna in Grisons). Two studies published in 2019 found that the population which built Britain's Stonehenge descended predominantly from Fertile Crescent, South Slavic, Anatolian, and Aegean farmers (see also Neolithic Agricultural Revolution), and while female lineages were varied, male lineages belonged almost exclusively to Eastern European and Mediterranean males of I2a genetic lineage.
Similar forms are also found throughout the world including Australia, Gabon, Greece, Hawaii, India (Daraki-Chattan), Israel, Mexico, Mozambique and the Americas. The oldest known forms are found from the Fertile Crescent to India.
They consist of a concave depression, no more than a few centimetres across, pecked into a rock surface and often surrounded by concentric circles also etched into the stone. Sometimes a linear channel called a gutter leads out from the middle. The decoration occurs as a petroglyph on natural boulders and outcrops and also as an element of megalithic art on purposely worked megaliths such as the slab cists of the Food Vessel culture, some stone circles and passage graves such as the clava tombs and on the capstones at Newgrange.
The site of Atlit Yam, abandoned circa 6300 BCE and now under Israel's Mediterranean Sea coast south of Haifa, features cup marks engraved into megalithic stones, some of which are set upright to form a semi-circle which has been referred to as resembling the UK's Stonehenge but smaller, with ceremonially buried bodies at the site, and potential alignments to the solstice, and/or to other stars, still being hypothesized as the site was only discovered in 2009 and undersea sites are difficult and expensive to explore. Further inland, dating to at least 3000 BCE (exposed) and estimated up to 4000 BCE (unexcavated layer, under the layer which is exposed), is Rujm el-Hiri, a cairn (tumulus) type of megalith, consisting of concentric circles (as cup marks also are concentric circles, but much smaller than Rogem Hiri) estimated to contain 40,000,000 kg of stones moved by humans, with an opening in the outer circle which aligns to the summer solstice (just as sites throughout Eurasia also align to solstices) and which has a burial chamber in the center, with thousands of dolmens nearby, a "dolmen" being a 3rd and younger type of megalith found elsewhere in Eurasia, the oldest of which, thus far, are found in the UK, but date only to the 3rd millennium BCE in Israel.
The cup marks are still present in other proto-Canaanite sites as recently as the Chalcolithic Age, for example at several sites in and around modern-day Modiin dated to the fourth millennium BCE and the third millennium BCE, and in the City of David, Old Jerusalem. Tel Gezer has more up-ended megaliths dating to only 1550 BCE which are aligned to Earth's north and south physical poles, but Tel Gezer's cupmarks have only recently been surveyed (2012) and do not appear to have been dated (as to whether they were made before, concurrent to or after the 1550 BCE megaliths) yet; however, excavations at Gezer are ongoing as of 2014.
Numerous cup-marked stones have been found in quite all the alpine valleys, comprising Val Camonica (Italy), associated with rock drawings. Regarding western alps (Piedmont), the best known are distributed along the Chisone, Susa and Viù valleys; also the La Bessa site is to be cited. Strictly referring to cup-and-rings, it is possible to cite in the western Alps only the Novalesa stone, in the Cenischia Valley, near the Italian-French border. Found in 1988, it shows 4 concentric circles, with a central cup-mark; all around a network of 20 cup-marks and channels.
Sardinia is rich in cup-and-rings stones: the best known is the Perda Pintà (the "painted stone", which is carved, not painted) or Stele di Boeli, at Mamoiada: an impressive stela or menhir 2,67 m high with various concentric circles patterns crossed by engraved channels and central cup-marks.
Similar patterns are known in Galicia, which has given them the name of 'Galician style'. These types, the cup-and-ring, cup-and-ring with gutter and the gapped concentric circles motifs are shared between this part of Iberia and the British Isles, manifesting, together with other cultural expressions like megaliths or Bronze Age culture, a cultural link along the coasts of Atlantic Europe.
Precisely dating megalithic art is difficult: even if the megalithic monument can be dated, the art may be a later addition. The Hunterheugh Crags cup and ring marks near Alnwick in Northumberland have recently been demonstrated to date back into the Early Neolithic era through their stratigraphic relationship with other, datable features. Some cup marks have been found in Iron Age contexts but these may represent re-used stones.
Where they are etched onto natural, flat stone it has been observed that they seem to incorporate the natural surface of the rock. Those at Hunterheugh are mostly connected to one another by gutters that can channel rainwater from one to the next, down the sloping top of the stone. It has been suggested by archaeologist Clive Waddington that the initial Early Neolithic impetus to create the marks was forgotten and that the practice fell into abeyance until a second phase of creation continued the basic tradition but with less precision and more variability in design. The markers of this second phase moved the art from natural stones to megaliths as its symbolism was reinterpreted by Later Neolithic and Early Bronze Age people.
Their purpose is unknown although some may be connected with natural stone outcrops exploited by Neolithic peoples to make polished stone axes. A religious purpose has been suggested. Alexander Thom suggested in a BBC television documentary, Cracking the Stone Age Code, in 1970, "I have an idea, entirely nebulous at the moment, that the cup and ring markings were a method of recording, of writing, and that they may indicate, once we can read them, what a particular stone was for. We have seen the cup and ring markings on the stone at Temple Wood, and that's on the main stone but we can't interpret them ...yet." He created diagrams and carried out analysis of over 50 of the cup and ring markings from which he determined a length he termed the Megalithic Inch (MI).
This whole idea has been ignored almost completely apart from a critical analysis carried out by Alan Davis in the 1980s, who tested Thom's hypothesis on cup and ring sites in England by examining the separations of neighbouring cupmark centres. He found some weak evidence for the "Megalithic Inch" but it was not statistically significant, and he suggested "strongest indications...towards the use of a quantum close in value to 5 MI at certain sites" and that "the apparent quantum seems strongly associated with ringed cups." Davis made an initial effort to build on Thom's start, and to answer the question he posed: "Why should a man spend hours – or rather days – cutting cups in a random fashion on a rock? It would indeed be a breakthrough if someone could crack the code of the cups."
Subsequently, Davis investigated the idea that the prehistoric carvers used an elementary method of diameter-construction in laying out the carvings. This investigation (incorporating both Scottish and English sites) suggested a possible explanation for many of the characteristic shapes of carved rings, and also produced evidence in the ring diameters for the use of a unit of measurement close to Thom's MI (and 5 MI) that was of high statistical significance. The evidence is consistent with the use of rough measures such as hand- and finger-widths (rather than the formal, accurate system proposed by Thom), but the important conclusion is that a similar design ritual, apparently involving a consistent measurement system of some kind, was in use over a wide geographical area.
Sites with cup and ring marks include:
- Ecclesall Wood, Sheffield, South Yorkshire
- Baildon Moor, Bradford, West Yorkshire
- Chatton Sandyford cairn and Fowberry petroglyphs in Northumberland
- Rombalds Moor including Ilkley Moor
- Gardom's Edge in Derbyshire
- Bachwen portal dolmen in Gwynedd
- Anderton, Lancashire
- Dalladies long barrow, Kincardineshire
- Street House cairn in Cleveland
- Dalgarven Mill, North Ayrshire
- Ballochmyle cup and ring marks, Mauchline, East Ayrshire
- Brodick, Isle of Arran
- Blackshaw Hill, North Ayrshire
- Kilmartin, Argyll
- Tomnaverie stone circle, Aberdeenshire
- Balblair, Beauly, nr. Inverness
- Tongue Croft, near Borgue, Dumfries and Galloway
- Kilpatrick Hills Strathclyde
- Kilpatrick Hills
- Clava Cairns, Culloden
- Craigmaddie Muir by the Alud Wives Lifts near Milngavie
- Reyfad Stones (Reyfad), Boho, County Fermanagh
- Eston Hills, Cleveland
- Weetwood Moor, Northumberland
- Lordenshaws, Northumberland
- Great Langdale, Cumbria
- Grasmere, Cumbria
- Dun Borve, Isle of Harris, Western Isles
- Juniper Green, Edinburgh, Scotland
Work at Drumirril in County Monaghan has uncovered Neolithic and early Bronze Age occupation evidence around the rock carvings there and this dating is generally accepted for most of the art. Another particularly rich source of cup-marked boulders is the Derrynablaha townland on the Iveragh peninsula in County Kerry.
An open air Rock Art site in the Swiss Alps is situated at Carschenna, Rethic Alps (in Grisons, Switzerland), where Latin derived languages mingle with German. The first engraved rocks were discovered in 1965, during the building of an iron electricity framework. Carschenna engravings are mainly characterized by cup-marks with from 1 to 9 concentric circles. Spirals, sun-like figures, riding scenes, and schematic horses are also present.
- Great dolmen of Dwasieden
- Dalgarven Mill
- European Megalithic Culture
- Prehistoric art
- Rock Drawings in Valcamonica
- Brace, Selina; Diekmann, Yoan; Booth, Thomas J.; van Dorp, Lucy; Faltyskova, Zuzana; Rohland, Nadin; Mallick, Swapan; Olalde, Iñigo; Ferry, Matthew; Michel, Megan; Oppenheimer, Jonas; Broomandkhoshbacht, Nasreen; Stewardson, Kristin; Martiniano, Rui; Walsh, Susan; Kayser, Manfred; Charlton, Sophy; Hellenthal, Garrett; Armit, Ian; Schulting, Rick; Craig, Oliver E.; Sheridan, Alison; Parker Pearson, Mike; Stringer, Chris; Reich, David; Thomas, Mark G.; Barnes, Ian (May 2019). "Ancient genomes indicate population replacement in Early Neolithic Britain". Nature Ecology & Evolution. 3 (5): 765–771. doi:10.1038/s41559-019-0871-9. PMC 6520225. PMID 30988490.
- Sánchez-Quinto, Federico; Malmström, Helena; Fraser, Magdalena; Girdland-Flink, Linus; Svensson, Emma M.; Simões, Luciana G.; George, Robert; Hollfelder, Nina; Burenhult, Göran; Noble, Gordon; Britton, Kate; Talamo, Sahra; Curtis, Neil; Brzobohata, Hana; Sumberova, Radka; Götherström, Anders; Storå, Jan; Jakobsson, Mattias (7 May 2019). "Megalithic tombs in western and northern Neolithic Europe were linked to a kindred society". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 116 (19): 9469–9474. doi:10.1073/pnas.1818037116. PMC 6511028. PMID 30988179.
- "East McDonnel Ranges". debandrandall.blogspot.co.uk. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- Alpert, Barbara Olins (1962). "Cupoles, Circles and Mandalas". Anthropologie. 33 (3): 171–178. JSTOR 26295871.
- Francis Scott Elliot, George (1915). Prehistoric Man and his story. Seeley, Service. p. 398.
- Callahan, Kevin L. (2004). "Pica, Geophagy and Rock Art in the Eastern United States" in The Rock-Art of Eastern North America: Capturing Images and Insight. University of Alabama Press. pp. 65–74. ISBN 9780817350963. Retrieved 20 February 2020.
- Ferg, Alan (1979). "The Petroglyphs of Tumamoc Hill". Kiva - the Tumamoc Hill Survey: An Intensive Study of a Cerro de Trincheras in Tucson, Arizona. 45 (1/2): 95–118. JSTOR 30247666.
- Marchant, Jo (25 November 2009). "Deep Secrets: Atlit-Yam, Israel". New Scientist. Reed Business Information Ltd. (2736): 40, 41. ISSN 0262-4079.
- Jerusalem Post: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:ObSB-SsFQLEJ:www.jpost.com/Local-Israel/Around-Israel/Israels-Atlantis[permanent dead link]
- Israel Antiquities Authority: http://www.antiquities.org.il/article_Item_eng.asp?sec_id=14&subj_id=139
- Oldest archaeological org in Israel: http://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.aspx?id=1164&mag_id=115
- "Dolmens - prehistoric megalith tombs". www.biblewalks.com. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- van den Brink, Edwin (2 Dec 2007). "Modi'in, Horbat Hadat and Be'erit (A)". Hadashot Arkheologiyot. 119.
- "עיריית מודיעין מכבים רעות, גבעת התיתורה". www.modiin.muni.il. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- Mitchell, Eric; Jason M. Zan; Cameron S. Coyle; Adam R. Dodd (31 Dec 2012). "Tel Gezer, Regional Survey". Hadashot Arkheologiyot. 124.
- "Home - Tel Gezer Project". www.telgezer.com. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "Western Alps rock art records". www.rupestre.net. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "Archivio Online - arte rupestre ed etnografia delle Alpi piemontesi (a cura del Gruppo Ricerche Cultura Montana)". www.rupestre.net. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "Rock art and cup marks of Bessa". bessa.it. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "Archivio Online - arte rupestre ed etnografia delle Alpi piemontesi (a cura del Gruppo Ricerche Cultura Montana)". www.rupestre.net. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- A rock record in the western Alps, TRACCE Online Rock Art Bulletin 12, 2000
- it:Stele di Boeli
- "The strange case of snow-circles and cup-and-rings". rupestre.net. 24 April 2012. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "R. Bradley et al., Rock art and the prehistoric Landscape of Galicia..." (PDF). csic.es. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- "M. Stewart, Strath Tay in the Second Millennium BC. A Field Survey" (PDF). ahds.ac.uk. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- The Spectator, p. 608. 1970. Retrieved 28 April 2011.
- Systematics: The Journal of the Institute for the comparative study of History, Philosophy and the Sciences, Vol. 6, Number 3, Coombe Spring Press., December 1968
- Alan Davis in Clive Ruggles (13 February 2003). Records in Stone: Papers in Memory of Alexander Thom. Cambridge University Press. pp. 392–422. ISBN 978-0-521-53130-6. Retrieved 30 April 2011.
- MacKie, E. W.; Davis, A. (1989). "New light on neolithic rock carvings: the petroglyphs at Greenland (Auchentorlie), Dunbartonshire". Glasgow Archaeological Journal. 15 (15): 125–155. doi:10.3366/gas.19126.96.36.199.
- ZINDEL C., 1970. Incisioni rupestri a Carschenna, in Valcamonica Symposium, 1968, pp. 135-142, Capo di Ponte.
- "Rock Art in the Alps – The engraved rocks of Carschenna". www.rupestre.net. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
- Beckensall, Stan and Laurie, Tim. 1998. Prehistoric Rock Art of County Durham, Swaledale and Wensleydale. County Durham Books. ISBN 1-897585-45-4
- Beckensall, Stan. 2001. Prehistoric Rock Art in Northumberland. Tempus Publishing. ISBN 0-7524-1945-5
- Beckensall, Stan. 2002. Prehistoric Rock Art in Cumbria. Tempus Publishing. ISBN 0-7524-2526-9
- Butter, Rachel. 1999. Kilmartin. Kilmartin House Trust. ISBN 0-9533674-0-1
- Hadingham, Evan. 1974. Ancient Carvings in Britain; A Mystery. Garnstone Press. ISBN 0-85511-391-X
- Morris, Ronald W.B. 1977. The Prehistoric Rock Art of Argyll. Dolphin Press. ISBN 0-85642-043-3
- Papanikolaou Stelios. 600 Written Rocks. Channels of primeval knowledge Larissa <<ella>> Second Revised Edition 2005 email@example.com ISBN 960-8439-21-3
- Schwegler Urs, Die Felszeichnungen von Carschenna, Gemeinde Sils im Domleschg, Helvetia Archaeologica, Bd. 28, Heft 111/112, 1997, ISSN 0018-0173, S. 76–126.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Cup marks.|
- British Rock Art Collection
- Era – England's Rock Art (Currently only covers Northumberland and County Durham)
- Rockart – Web Access to Rock Art: the Beckensall Archive of Northumberland Rock Art – University of Newcastle upon Tyne
- El Laberinto Atlántico - Galician Rock Art
- BBC Archive - Chronicle | Cracking the Stone Age Code
- The strange case of snow-circles and cup-and-rings