Cynic (band)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

OriginMiami, Florida, U.S.
Years active
  • 1987–1994
  • 2006–present
Past members

Cynic is an American progressive metal band formed in Miami, Florida in 1987 and later re-formed in Los Angeles, California in 2007, where the sole surviving member, Paul Masvidal remains to this day. Cynic incorporates elements of progressive rock, alternative, and metal.[1][2][3][4] Their first album, Focus, released on September 14, 1993, is widely regarded as a landmark release of the progressive metal genre. Cynic disbanded in 1994, but they reunited in 2006 and released their second album on November 17, 2008.[5] Traced in Air was released through French label Season of Mist,[6] followed up by an EP titled Re-Traced on May 18, 2010 and an EP titled Carbon-Based Anatomy on November 11, 2011. Their third studio album, Kindly Bent to Free Us, was released on February 14, 2014. In December 2017, after two years of an uncertain future,[7][8] founding member Sean Reinert confirmed his split from Cynic.[9] Reinert died at the age of 48 on January 24, 2020.[10] Longtime Cynic bass player, Sean Malone, died at the age of 50 eleven months later, leaving Masvidal as the only remaining original core member.[11]


Demo era (1987–1991)[edit]

Cynic was formed by guitarist and frontman Paul Masvidal and drummer Sean Reinert in 1987.[12] In 1988, the band made their first recording, simply called the '88 Demo. After the demo, Paul Masvidal took over vocal duties, while continuing to play guitar. The band also added a second guitarist, Jason Gobel. Another demo followed in 1989, titled Reflections of a Dying World. 1989 also brought the addition of bassist Tony Choy. In 1990, the group went to the studio to record their third demo, plainly titled '90 Demo. In 1991, Cynic signed with Roadrunner Records and recorded their fourth and final demo, known as Demo 1991.

Recording Focus (1993)[edit]

The recording of Cynic's full-length debut album Focus did not begin immediately after the band signed a new contract with Roadrunner Records.[13][14] Paul Masvidal and Sean Reinert had played on Death's 1991 album Human and were obligated to take part in the supporting tour of Europe.[citation needed] During this tour, Death ran into serious financial trouble, which resulted in Masvidal and Reinert's gear being confiscated for six months by a UK promoter. During this time, the band parted with bassist Tony Choy (who joined Atheist). Choy was replaced by Sean Malone. The band planned to record Focus in August 1992, but the day they were to begin recording, Hurricane Andrew struck Florida and destroyed both Gobel's home and the band's rehearsal space, leading to months of delay. The band used this time as an opportunity to write new material, much of which is featured on Focus. Tony Teegarden was eventually brought in to do the death growls, but all the vocoder vocals were recorded by Masvidal.[15]

Focus was released internationally September 14, 1993.[16]

Cynic toured extensively worldwide throughout 1993[17][18] and 1994, including the Dynamo Open Air Festival in May 1994.

Asked in a 2012 interview on[19] about Focus material, Masvidal says:

Sometimes you just burn out on material and we have toured Focus quite a bit. It does have a history and it obviously had an impact as an album, but at some point you do have to move on. With another album under our belts we'll have enough material to really give people a whole body of new material to focus on instead of the past. But I enjoy Focus and to me it does seem like a record that represented something for us that was really honest. And I think it was a solid album, so it's cool that it got some recognition.

— Paul Masvidal

First disbandment (1994−2006)[edit]

Musical and personal differences halted work on a second studio album, as the group disbanded, with most of its members turning to side projects.

Gobel, Masvidal, and Reinert, with bassist Chris Kringel and vocalist/keyboardist Aruna Abrams, formed the short-lived Portal in 1994. The band's music featured slower tempos and very few distorted guitars compared to Cynic, but still had a complex, layered sound. A total of 10 tracks were recorded as pre-production demos, which were never officially released until 2012, where it was released as The Portal Tapes under the Cynic name.[20][21] Masvidal and Reinert released an album with a more recent project, the indie act Æon Spoke, on SPV Records[22] and Kringel also played with them, touring the UK in 2005. The members of Cynic loosely reunited (playing with Bill Bruford, Steve Hackett, and Jim Matheos on various tracks) on Gordian Knot's second album, Emergent.

Reunion (2006−2007)[edit]

In September 2006, Paul Masvidal announced that Cynic was reuniting to perform during spring/summer of 2007. During June/July/August 2007, they played 15 shows across Europe, predominantly at major metal/rock festivals. The setlist consisted of songs from Focus, Portal's demo, a cover of Mahavishnu Orchestra's "Meeting of the Spirits," and a new song, "Evolutionary Sleeper."

The reunion line-up featured founding members Masvidal on guitar/vocals and Reinert on drums. Gobel, the longtime guitarist who played on Focus, could not participate due to family and work commitments, and David "Mavis" Senescu was brought aboard as a replacement. Malone, who played bass on Focus, was unavailable due to teaching and work commitments, and Chris Kringel, who played bass on the 1993 European tour, was brought in as a replacement. All death growls were handled by pre-recordings of Teegarden. All keyboards were covered by Masvidal and Senescu using guitar synths.

In early 2008, the band announced plans to complete a second studio album. Malone rejoined the lineup and Dutch guitarist Tymon Kruidenier of Exivious was added, the latter contributing death growls.

Traced in Air and Re-Traced (2008−2011)[edit]

Traced in Air was released internationally November 17, 2008 on Season of Mist, followed by Robin Zielhorst being added as touring bassist.[23]

The band played at the Wacken Open Air festival.[24] The Traced in Air tour cycle began in Autumn 2008 with direct support slots for Opeth on their European tour.

Starting in February 2009, Cynic toured North America with Meshuggah and The Faceless, and beginning April 15, 2009 Cynic toured North America in support of DragonForce.

During the 2010 tour in support of Between the Buried and Me, along with Scale the Summit and the Devin Townsend Project, the band performed live "an experiment" titled "Wheels Within Wheels."[25] Shortly after unveiling this new work, the band announced a new EP coming soon on their MySpace blog. Masvidal revealed in an interview the plans for the coming EP:[26]

'Re-Traced' is an experiment for us – an opportunity to turn four songs from 'Traced in Air' inside out and to share something new ... In our exploration, we've created music that is part 'sci-fi prog folk,' part psychedelic rock, part minimalist restraint. These interpretations feel channeled from another galaxy ... For the most part, the tunes reference some of our favourite musical forms and in our own curious way (electronic/ambient, jazz/fusion, drum n' bass, experimental, shoegaze). There is no vocoder, no traditionally busy Cynic riffs that are some of our most signature sounds, but the music retains its song structure, integral melodic sense, harmony and lyrical inspiration.

— Paul Masvidal

Later blogs on MySpace revealed that the new EP would be titled Re-Traced.

In May 2010, Cynic announced plans for their first US headlining tour.[27] Titled "Re-Traced / Re-Focused Live", the tour found Cynic performing their debut album Focus in its entirety, among other tracks. The tour was co-sponsored by Decibel Magazine as its inaugural "Hall of Fame" tour series. It kicked off on July 22, 2010 in Los Angeles with Intronaut and Dysrhythmia as supporting bands. The tour ended on August 13, 2010. The final show of the tour took place in Fort Lauderdale, Florida; it was the first time in 16 years the band returned to their hometown to perform.[28]

In December 2010, the band announced that bassist Robin Zielhorst and guitarist Tymon Kruidenier were no longer in Cynic due to logistical and various other reasons. In the same announcement, Masvidal and Reinert set the approximate release schedule for Cynic's next album, stating that "the new Cynic release should be coming in late 2011 on the Season of Mist label", and, in addition, "[t]hey are also working towards a remixed re-release of their classic recording 'Focus.'"[29]

Carbon-Based Anatomy and Kindly Bent to Free Us (2011−2014)[edit]

Cynic's website announced that the band was working on a new album and the "first baby steps into this gigantic process are being taken right now, creating little embryos of songs that will turn into fully fledged Cynic tunes over the course of the following months."[30]

On September 6, 2011, Cynic announced a new EP titled Carbon-Based Anatomy would be released on November 11, 2011 in Europe, and November 15, 2011 in the United States. The artwork was designed by Robert Venosa, the artist behind the cover artworks of Focus, Traced in Air and Re-Traced, shortly before his death. All bass parts on Carbon-Based Anatomy were recorded by Sean Malone, who had also previously recorded the bass parts to Focus and Traced in Air.

Paul Masvidal describes this new EP as:

...both a philosophical as well as a musical journey, one that begins in the Amazon jungle on the lips of a shamanic wisewoman (as portrayed by Amy Correia) and ends in outerspace.[31]

On October 10, 2011, Cynic uploaded one song from the new EP titled "Carbon-Based Anatomy" and announced that Brandon Giffin and Max Phelps would be playing live with the band. Brandon Giffin is a former bassist for The Faceless and Max Phelps will play the second guitar and provide backing vocals. The band completed a North American and European tour in support of the EP in November and December 2011.[32]

Commenting on a musical shift from metal elements in an interview on,[19] Masvidal says:

I think every record kind of develops its own thing based on a process and I don't really know what it's gonna sound like until we're really doing it. I think Cynic was always outside the box and never a traditional metal band to begin with, so we're probably going further in a direction that'll sound more like Cynic and less than anything else familiar. Really, it's too soon to say right now – the material exists, but not as a production. They're just little songs, so – we'll see. (laughs)

— Paul Masvidal

In March 2012, Cynic released via Season of Mist an album of demos that were produced as a follow-up to Focus back in 1995, entitled The Portal Tapes.

On December 12, 2012, Cynic announced through their official website that Masvidal, Reinert and Sean Malone were entering the studio in "trio mode" to record their fifth release.[33] They revealed the title of their third studio album and its cover on November 10, 2013, on their official Facebook page. The album, Kindly Bent to Free Us, was released on February 14, 2014.[34]

In May 2014, Paul Masvidal and Sean Reinert publicly revealed their homosexuality,[35] a move that was broadly supported by the heavy metal community.[36]

Breakup rumors, new music, and deaths (2015−2020)[edit]

On September 10, 2015, Sean Reinert announced the disbandment of Cynic due to artistic and personal differences.[7] Later that day, however, Masvidal claimed that there was no disbandment, and that Reinert did not consult with the other bandmates on the issue. He also announced that the band would continue in "one way or another."[8] On September 18, 2015, it was confirmed that Cynic would perform without Reinert, and would recruit Trioscapes drummer Matt Lynch to fulfill a festival commitment, Germany's Euroblast Festival on October 3 as scheduled.[37]

In 2017 Century Media released Uroboric Forms - The Complete Demo Collection 1988-1991.

On December 9, 2017, Reinert announced his split with Cynic, and stated "A settlement has been reached between Paul and I... I am at peace with the arrangement."[9]

On January 15, 2018, Cynic digitally released "Humanoid", their first song in four years, and first one with Matt Lynch on drums instead of Sean Reinert.[38] Loudersound listed Cynic on the 4th of July special amongst the Ten Great American Prog Rock Bands[39].

Reinert died on January 24, 2020.[10] Hank Shteamer of Rolling Stone magazine wrote a tribute[40] to Reinert shortly after his passing commemorating his contributions to Death and Cynic.

Malone died on December 9, 2020.[11] On September 3, 2021, Paul Masvidal revealed that Malone died by suicide, as well as announced the release of a new version of "Integral" featuring a bass track recorded by Malone as tribute.[41]

Ascension Codes (2021−present)[edit]

On September 15, 2021, Cynic announced a new album titled Ascension Codes. A track from the album, "Mythical Serpents", was also released.[42] The album was released on November 26, 2021. It was elected by Metal Hammer as the 3rd best progressive metal album of 2021.[43] The song "Mythical Serpents" was elected by Loudwire as the 9th best metal song of 2021.[44]

Musical style[edit]

Cynic's first recordings feature a more punk rock, thrash metal, and hardcore punk sound, but in the 1990s their sound changed towards a highly complex, experimental and extremely technical form of progressive metal, while still retaining their death metal roots. Their 1990 demo displays a hyper-technical form of death/thrash, and the following 1991 Roadrunner demo bears a notable resemblance to Death and jazz-death metal pioneers Atheist, featuring two songs from Focus in cruder, more brutal form. Many influences from jazz and jazz-rock fusion[2] can be heard on their debut album Focus. Focus has both "growls" and "robotic" vocals,[2] using a vocoder. The offshoot Portal later released a demo recording that continues even further in the direction of progressive space rock, refining and softening up their sound.

Cynic's 2008 album Traced in Air melded together the styles and influences heard on 1993's Focus with the more progressive-oriented Portal approach. The result had Cynic put less emphasis on its extreme metal elements, with new guttural vocalist Tymon Kruidenier playing a smaller role than Tony Teegarden did on Focus. Additionally, Paul Masvidal all but abandoned his vocoder robotic vocals, opting instead for a more natural singing voice, with a subtler—although noticeable—vocoder layer that increases an octave his voice.

Noting the journey from metal to the progressives, The New York Times proclaimed in a positive review of Traced in Air that:

"Cynic should be understood not so much alongside any metal bands but along with the radical harmonic progressives in the last 45 years of pop and jazz: composers like Milton Nascimento, The Beach Boys or Pat Metheny."[45]

In 2009, Chris Dick of Decibel Magazine inducted Cynic into the Decibel Hall of Fame[46] with nothing but praises:

"Cynic weren't emulators. The aggression was there. But the mindset contrasted vastly. In fact, more was owed to crossover heroes Ludichrist and thrash metal mavericks Voivod than to any band from the Sunshine State. They were innovators. Post-Andrew, Masvidal and company developed wider and deeper tastes, seamlessly stitching in new influences like jazz fusion, progressive rock and shoegaze to create new, imaginative shapes..."


The three main members in the first three Cynic studio albums, from left to right: Sean Reinert, Paul Masvidal, and Sean Malone


  • Paul Masvidal – guitars, guitar synthesizer (1987–1994, 2006–present), lead vocals, vocoder (1988–1994, 2006–present), unclean vocals (1988–1993)
  • Matt Lynch – drums (2015–present)
  • Dave Mackay – bass synthesizer, keyboards (2021–present)


  • Roopam Garg (Dark) - guitars (2021–present)
  • Plini - guitars (2021–present)
  • Max Phelps – guitars, backing vocals (2011–2015, 2021)


  • Esteban "Steve" Rincon – lead vocals (1987)
  • Russell Mofsky – guitars (1987)
  • Mark Van Erp – bass (1987–1989)
  • Sean Reinert – drums (1987–1994, 2006–2015, died 2020)
  • Jason Gobel – guitars, keyboards (1988–1994)
  • Tony Choy – bass (1989–1993)
  • Sean Malone – bass (1993, 2008, 2011–2020, died 2020)
  • Chris Kringel – bass (1994, 2006–2007)
  • Tymon Kruidenier – guitar, unclean vocals, guitar synthesizer (2008–2010)
  • Robin Zielhorst – bass (2008–2010)

Former session

  • Dana Cosley – keyboards, harsh vocals (live) (1994)
  • Tony Teegarden – keyboards, harsh vocals (studio and live) (1993–1994, 2006–2007)
  • Brandon Giffin – bass (live) (2011–2014)



Studio albums



  • Humanoid (2018)

Compilation albums

  • Uroboric Forms - The Complete Demo Recordings (2017)


  1. ^ Ratliff, B. Progressive Metal, With a Virtuosic Accompaniment, The New York Times, Feb. 2010, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  2. ^ a b c Christina Henriques (January 26, 1994). "Faded Glory - Page 1 - Music - Miami". Miami New Times. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  3. ^ [1] Archived November 11, 2013, at the Wayback Machine
  4. ^ Photograph: Oliver Faig (December 16, 2008). "Music: The best (and worst) of 2008 - Music - Time Out New York". Archived from the original on March 24, 2009. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  5. ^ "Cynic's 'Traced in Air' Pushed Back To November". Archived from the original on December 29, 2008. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  6. ^ Harris, Chris (May 9, 2008). "DragonForce Frontman Not As Impressed As 'Guitar Hero' Fans; Plus Deftones, All That Remains And More News That Rules, In Metal File - Music, Celebrity, Artist News". MTV. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  7. ^ a b "Cynic Calls It Quits... Again". September 10, 2015. Retrieved September 10, 2015.
  8. ^ a b "Cynic 'Will Continue One Way Or Another,' Says Paul Masvidal". September 10, 2015. Retrieved September 10, 2015.
  9. ^ a b "Cynic To Continue Without Drummer Sean Reinert". December 10, 2017. Retrieved December 10, 2017.
  10. ^ a b "Death & Cynic Metal Drummer Sean Reinert Dead at 48". TMZ. January 25, 2020. Retrieved January 25, 2020.
  11. ^ a b "Cynic Bassist Sean Malone Dead At 50". Blabbermouth. December 9, 2020. Retrieved December 10, 2020.
  12. ^ Masvidal, Paul (March 31, 2010). "Metta Mind Journal with Cynic's Paul Masvidal: Hair Identity and Being Yourself". Metalsucks. Retrieved August 30, 2015.
  13. ^ Cynic page at Roadrunner Records, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  14. ^ Opening the Crypts: Cynic, Roadrunner records, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  15. ^ Wagner 2010, p. 174
  16. ^ Wagner 2010, p. 180
  17. ^ Cynic US tour dates at Cynical Sphere Archived July 8, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  18. ^ Cynic European tour dates at Cynical Sphere Archived July 8, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  19. ^ a b Schetter, Michael (January 5, 2012). "Interview with Paul Masvidal of Cynic - Prog Sphere – A Different View of Progressive Music". Retrieved February 18, 2014.
  20. ^ Portal page at Cynical Sphere Archived September 4, 2009, at the Wayback Machine, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  21. ^ "The Portal Tapes - Cynic". Season of Mist. Retrieved October 9, 2021.
  22. ^ Æon Spoke page at SPV Records Archived July 27, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, (retrieved March 25, 2011)
  23. ^ "Cynical Sphere". Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  24. ^ "W:O:A - Wacken Open Air : INTRO". Archived from the original on September 27, 2007. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  25. ^ "Cynic - Wheels Within Wheels (Live at Club Soda)". YouTube. Archived from the original on December 21, 2021. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  26. ^ "Masvidal statement on". Archived from the original on February 1, 2013. Retrieved July 17, 2011.
  27. ^ Dick, C. Decibel & Cynic Announce Hall of Fame Tour!,, May 19. 2010 (retrieved on January 30, 2011)
  28. ^ Cynic To Tour North America With Intronaut, Dysrhythmia,, May 19, 2010 (retrieved on January 30, 2011)
  29. ^ Cynic online - news Archived July 8, 2012, at,, (retrieved on January 30, 2011)
  30. ^ Cynic Online - news Archived July 8, 2012, at,, (retrieved on January 30, 2011)
  31. ^ "Musician Paul Masvidal on Carbon-Based Anatomy". Metal Sucks. September 6, 2011. Retrieved September 6, 2011.
  32. ^ Tour, Archived January 21, 2013, at, (retrieved January 5, 2012)
  33. ^ Cynic Online - news Archived June 15, 2013, at,, (retrieved on May 3, 2013)
  34. ^ "Cynic - Tijdlijnfoto's". Facebook. Retrieved February 18, 2014.
  35. ^ Brown, August (May 8, 2014). "Cynic's Paul Masvidal, Sean Reinert are Out and Ready to be Loud". The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved June 5, 2017.
  36. ^ Pasbani, Robert (May 9, 2004). "The 11 Most Shocking Reactions To Cynic Members Coming Out As Gay". Metal Injection. Retrieved June 5, 2017.
  37. ^ "Cynic Confirm Appearance at Euroblast FestivalL". September 18, 2015.
  38. ^ "Cynic Returns With First New Song in Four Years, 'Humanoid'". January 15, 2018. Retrieved January 15, 2018.
  39. ^ Ewing, Jerry (July 4, 2018). "Ten great American prog rock bands". Prog Magazine. Retrieved April 24, 2020.
  40. ^ Shteamer, Hank (January 26, 2020). "'One Foot in and One Foot Out': Remembering Death-Metal Drum Trailblazer Sean Reinert". Rolling Stone. Retrieved April 24, 2020.
  41. ^ Childers, Chad (September 3, 2021). "Cynic Reveal Sean Malone's Cause of Death, Release Tribute Song". Loudwire. Retrieved September 3, 2021.
  42. ^ "Cynic Announce New Album, Ascension Codes, Share First Single, "Mythical Serpents"". MetalSucks. September 15, 2021. Retrieved September 18, 2021.
  43. ^ Hobson, Robson (December 12, 2021). "Top 10 prog metal albums of 2021". Metal Hammer. Future plc. Retrieved January 2, 2022.
  44. ^ Al-Sharif, Rabab; DiVita, Joe; Hartmann, Graham; Richardson, Jake; Trapp, Philip; Summan, Yasmine (December 6, 2021). "The 35 Best Metal Songs of 2021". Loudwire. Townsquare Media. Retrieved January 2, 2022.
  45. ^ Ratliff, B. Critic's Choice: New CDs, The New York Times, November 30, 2008, (retrieved January 30, 2011)
  46. ^ "Cynic - "Focus"". Decibel Magazine. October 1, 2009. Retrieved April 24, 2020.


External links[edit]