Debits and credits
|Part of a series on|
In double entry bookkeeping, debits and credits (abbreviated Dr and Cr, respectively) are entries made in account ledgers to record changes in value resulting from business transactions. Generally speaking (in T-Account terms), if cash is spent in a business transaction, the cash account is credited (that is, an entry is made on the right side of the T-Account's ledger), and conversely, when cash is obtained in a business transaction, it is described as a debit (that is, an entry is made on the left side of the T-Account's ledger). Debits and Credits can occur in any account. For simplicity it is often best to view Debits as positive numbers and Credits as negative numbers. When all the debits and credits that are transacted in each account are added up the resulting account total could be a net Debit (positive number) or a net Credit (negative number). If the total of the account is in a net Debit position (positive), it is generally classified in the Asset section of the balance sheet, whereas accounts that total to a net Credit (negative) are shown in the liability section of the balance sheet. Accounts that relate to the company's profit (example: Sales, Cost of Sales, Expenses) are totaled to yield company earnings and are classified in the Equity section of the balance sheet. When recording incoming cash (revenue) a Debit will be made to Cash or equivalent Assets and a Credit will be made on the revenue account in the income statement. If a company has a positive Net Income, the Retained Earnings will receive a Credit when closing out the Income Statement for the year, while a Net Loss will result in a Debit to the Retained Earnings. A net Credit (negative) balance in Retained Earnings in the Equity Section demonstrates that the company has been profitable over time, whereas a Debit (positive) balance in the Equity section, would demonstrate that the company has been unprofitable. In most companies the following accounts end-up in Credit positions: accounts payable, share capital, loans payable; while Debit accounts typically include Equipment, Inventory, Accounts Receivable. Debits (positive numbers) must equal Credits (negatives) in each transaction; individual transactions may require multiple debit and credit entries.
For the company as a whole, the net position of every account (debit or credit) is shown in the trial balance report. The trial balance report must add to zero; otherwise an error has occurred.
- 1 History
- 2 Aspects of transactions
- 3 Commercial understanding
- 4 Terminology
- 5 The five accounting elements
- 6 Principle
- 7 T-accounts
- 8 Contra account
- 9 Accounts classification
- 10 References
- 11 External links
The first known recorded use of the terms is Venetian Luca Pacioli's 1494 work, Summa de Arithmetica, Geometria, Proportioni et Proportionalita (translated: Everything That Is Known About Arithmetic, Geometry, Proportions and Proportionality). Pacioli devoted one section of his book to documenting and describing the double-entry bookkeeping system in use during the Renaissance by Venetian merchants, traders and bankers. This system is still the fundamental system in use by modern bookkeepers. Indian merchants had developed a double-entry bookkeeping system, called bahi-khata, predating Pacioli's work by at least many centuries, and which was likely a direct precursor of the European adaptation.
It is sometimes said that, in its original Latin, Pacioli's Summa used the Latin words debere (to owe) and credere (to entrust) to describe the two sides of a closed accounting transaction. Assets were owed to the owner and the owners' equity was entrusted to the company. At the time negative numbers were not in use. When his work was translated, the Latin words debere and credere became the English debit and credit. Under this theory, the abbreviations Dr (for debit) and Cr (for credit) derive directly from the original Latin. However, Sherman casts doubt on this idea because Pacioli uses Per (Latin for "through") for the debtor and A (Latin for "to") for the creditor in the Journal entries. Sherman goes on to say that the earliest text he found that actually uses "Dr." as an abbreviation in this context was an English text, the third edition (1633) of Ralph Handson's book Analysis or Resolution of Merchant Accompts and that Handson uses Dr. as an abbreviation for the English word "debtor." (Sherman could not locate a first edition, but speculates that it too used Dr. for debtor.) The words actually used by Pacioli for the left and right sides of the Ledger are "in dare" and "in havere" (give and receive). Geijsbeek the translator suggests in the preface:
'if we today would abolish the use of the words debit and credit in the ledger and substitute the ancient terms of "shall give" and "shall have" or "shall receive", the personification of accounts in the proper way would not be difficult and, with it, bookkeeping would become more intelligent to the proprietor, the layman and the student.'
As Jackson has noted, "debtor" need not be a person, but can be an abstract operator (cf. "divisor" in math):
"...it became the practice to extend the meanings of the terms ... beyond their original personal connotation and apply them to inanimate objects and abstract conceptions..."
Aspects of transactions
To determine whether one must debit or credit a specific account we use either the accounting equation approach which consists of five accounting rules or the classical approach based on three rules (for Real accounts, Personal accounts, and Nominal accounts) to determine whether to debit or to credit an account.
- Real accounts are the assets of a firm, which may be tangible (machinery, buildings etc.) or intangible (goodwill, patents etc.)
- Personal accounts relate to individuals, companies, creditors, banks etc.
- Nominal accounts relate to expenses, losses, incomes or gains.
Whether a debit increases or decreases an account depends on what kind of account it is. The basic principle is that the account receiving benefit is debited and giving benefit is credited. For instance, an increase in an asset account is a debit. An increase in a liability or an equity account is a credit.
The rules in classical approach is known as golden rules of accounting. The rules are the following for each type of account:
- Real accounts: Debit whatever comes in and, credit whatever goes out.
- Personal accounts: Receiver's account is debited, and giver's account is credited.
- Nominal accounts: All expenses and losses are debited and, all incomes and gains are credited.
The complete accounting equation based on modern approach is very easy to remember if you focus on Assets, Expenses, Costs, Dividends (highlighted in chart). All those account types increase with debits or left side entries. Conversely, a decrease to any of those accounts is a credit or right side entry. On the other hand, increases in revenue, liability or equity accounts are credits or right side entries, and decreases are left side entries or debits.
|Kind of account||Debit||Credit|
Debits and credits occur simultaneously in every financial transaction in double-entry bookkeeping. In the accounting equation, Assets = Liabilities + Equity, so, if an asset account increases (a debit (left)), then either another asset account must decrease (a credit (right)), or a liability or equity account must increase (a credit (right)). Note also that in the extended equation, revenues increase equity and expenses, costs & dividends decrease equity, so their difference is the impact on the equation.
For example, if a company provides a service to a customer who does not pay immediately, the company records an increase in assets, Accounts Receivable with a debit entry, and an increase in Revenue, with a credit entry. When the company receives the cash from the customer, two accounts again change on the company side, the cash account is debited (increased) and the Accounts Receivable account is now decreased (credited). When the cash is deposited to the bank account, two things also change, on the bank side: the bank records an increase in its cash account (debit) and records an increase in its liability to the customer by recording a credit in the customer's account (which is not cash). Note that, technically, the deposit is not a decrease in the cash (asset) of the company and should not be recorded as such. It is just a transfer to a proper bank account of record in the company's books, not affecting the ledger.
To make it more clear, the bank views the transaction from a different perspective but follows the same rules: the bank's vault cash (asset) increases, which is a debit; the increase in the customer's account balance (liability from the bank's perspective) is a credit. A customer's periodic bank statement generally shows transactions from the bank's perspective, with cash deposits characterized as credits (liabilities) and withdrawals as debits (reductions in liabilities) in depositor's accounts. In the company's books the exact opposite entries should be recorded to account for the same cash. This concept is important since this is why so many people misunderstand what debit/credit really means.
In summary, debits are simply transaction entries on the left-hand side of ledger accounts, and credits are entries on the right-hand side.
When setting up the accounting for a new business, a number of accounts are established to record all business transactions that are expected to occur. Typical accounts that relate to almost every business are: Cash, Accounts Receivable, Inventory, Accounts Payable and Retained Earnings. Each account can be broken down further, to provide additional detail as necessary. For example: Accounts Receivable can be broken down to show each customer that owes the company money. In simplistic terms, if Bob, Dave, and Roger owe the company money, the Accounts Receivable account will contain a separate account for Bob, and Dave and Roger. All 3 of these accounts would be added together and shown as a single number (i.e. total 'Accounts Receivable' - balance owed) on the balance sheet. All accounts for a company are grouped together and summarized on the balance sheet in 3 sections which are: Assets, Liabilities and Equity.
All accounts must first be classified as one of the five types of accounts (accounting elements) ( asset, liability, equity, income and expense). To determine how to classify an account into one of the five elements, the definitions of the five account types must be fully understood. The definition of an asset according to IFRS is as follows, "An asset is a resource controlled by the entity as a result of past events from which future economic benefits are expected to flow to the entity". In simplistic terms, this means that Assets are accounts viewed as having a future value to the company (i.e. cash, accounts receivable, equipment, computers). Liabilities, conversely, would include items that are obligations of the company (i.e. loans, accounts payable, mortgages, debts).
The Equity section of the balance sheet typically shows the value of any outstanding shares that have been issued by the company as well as its earnings. All Income and expense accounts are summarize in the Equity Section in one line on the balance sheet called Retained Earnings. This account, in general, reflects the cumulative profit (retained earnings) or loss (retained deficit) of the company.
The Profit and Loss Statement is an expansion of the Retained Earnings Account. It breaks-out all the Income and expense accounts that were summarized in Retained Earnings. The Profit and Loss report is important in that it shows the detail of sales, cost of sales, expenses and ultimately the profit of the company. Most companies rely heavily on the profit and loss report and review it regularly to enable strategic decision making.
The words debit and credit can sometimes be confusing because they depend on the point of view from which a transaction is observed. In accounting terms, assets are recorded on the left-hand side (debit) of asset accounts, because they are typically shown on the left-hand side of the accounting equation (A=L+SE). Likewise, an increase in liabilities and shareholder's equity are recorded on the right-hand side (credit) of those accounts, thus they also maintain the balance of the accounting equation. In other words, if "assets are increased with left-hand entries, the accounting equation is balanced only if increases in liabilities and shareholder’s equity are recorded on the opposite or right-hand side. Conversely, decreases in assets are recorded on the right-hand side of asset accounts, and decreases in liabilities and equities are recorded on the left-hand side". Similar is the case with revenues and expenses, what increases shareholder's equity is recorded as credit because they are in the right side of equation and vice versa. Typically, when reviewing the financial statements of a business, Assets are Debits and Liabilities and Equity are Credits. For example, when two companies transact with one another say Company A buys something from Company B then Company A will record a decrease in cash (a Credit), and Company B will record an increase in cash (a Debit). The same transaction is recorded from two different perspectives.
This use of the terms can be counter-intuitive to people unfamiliar with bookkeeping concepts, who may always view a credit as an increase and a debit as a decrease. This is because most people typically only see bank accounts and billing statements (e.g., from a utility). A depositor's bank account is actually a Liability to the bank, because the bank holds money which legally belongs to the depositor, so that the bank owes the money to the depositor. Thus, when the customer deposits money into the account, the bank credits the account (increases the bank's liability). At the same time, the bank adds the money to its own cash holdings account. Since the latter account is an Asset, the increase is a debit. But the customer typically does not see this side of the transaction.
On the other hand, when a utility customer pays a bill or the utility corrects an overcharge, the customer's account is credited. This is because the customer's account is one of the utility's accounts receivable, which are Assets to the utility because they represent money the utility can expect to receive from the customer in the future. Credits actually decrease Assets (the utility is now owed less money). If the credit is due to a bill payment, then the utility will add the money to its own cash account, which is a debit because the account is another Asset. Again, the customer views the credit as an increase in the customer's own money and does not see the other side of the transaction.
The simplest most effective way to understand Debits and Credits is by actually recording them as positive and negative numbers directly on the balance sheet. If you receive $100 cash, put $100 (debit/Positive) next to the Cash account. If you spend $100 cash, put -$100 (credit/Negative) next to the cash account. The next step would be to balance that transaction with the opposite sign so that your balance sheet adds to zero. The way of doing these placements are simply a matter of understanding where the money came from and where it goes in the specific account types (like Liability and net assets account). So if $100 Cash came in and you Debited/Positive next to the Cash Account, then the next step is to determine where the -$100 is classified. If you got it as a loan then the -$100 would be recorded next to the Loan Account. If you received the $100 because you sold something then the $-100 would be recorded next to the Retained Earnings Account. If everything is viewed in terms of the balance sheet, at a very high level, then picking the accounts to make your balance sheet add to zero is the picture.
At the end of any financial period (say at the end of the quarter or the year), the net debit or credit amount is referred to as the accounts balance. If the sum of the debit side is greater than the sum of the credit side, then the account has a "debit balance". If the sum of the credit side is greater, then the account has a "credit balance". If debits and credits equal each, then we have a "zero balance". Accounts with a net Debit balance are generally shown as Assets, while accounts with a net Credit balance are generally shown as Liabilities. The equity section and retained earnings account, basically reference your profit or loss. Therefore, that account can be positive or negative (depending on if you made money). When you add Assets, Liabilities and Equity together (using positive numbers to represent Debits and negative numbers to represent Credits) the sum should be Zero.
Debit cards and credit cards
Debit cards and credit cards are creative terms used by the banking industry to market and identify each card. From the cardholder's point of view, a credit card account normally contains a credit balance, a debit card account normally contains a debit balance. A debit card is used to make a purchase with one's own money. A credit card is used to make a purchase by borrowing money.
From the bank's point of view, when a debit card is used to pay a merchant, the payment causes a decrease in the amount of money the bank owes to the cardholder. From the bank's point of view, your debit card account is the bank's liability. A decrease to the bank's liability account is a debit. From the bank's point of view, when a credit card is used to pay a merchant, the payment causes an increase in the amount of money the bank is owed by the cardholder. From the bank's point of view, your credit card account is the bank's asset. An increase to the bank's asset account is a debit. Hence, using a debit card or credit card causes a debit to the cardholder's account in either situation when viewed from the bank's perspective.
General ledger is the term for the comprehensive collection of T-accounts (it is so called because there was a pre-printed vertical line in the middle of each ledger page and a horizontal line at the top of each ledger page, like a large letter T). Before the advent of computerised accounting, manual accounting procedure used a book (known as a ledger) for each T-account. The collection of all these books was called the general ledger. The chart of accounts is the table of contents of the general ledger. Totaling of all debits and credits in the general ledger at the end of a financial period is known as trial balance.
"Day Books" or journals are used to list every single transaction that took place during the day, and the list is totalled at the end of the day. These daybooks are not part of the double-entry bookkeeping system. The information recorded in these daybooks is then transferred to the general ledgers. Modern computer software now allows for the instant update of each ledger account – for example, when recording a cash receipt in a cash receipts journal a debit is posted to a cash ledger account with a corresponding credit in the ledger account for which the cash was received. Not every single transaction need be entered into a T-account. Usually only the sum of the book transactions (a batch total) for the day is entered in the general ledger.
The five accounting elements
There are five fundamental elements within accounting. These elements are as follows: Assets, Liabilities, Equity (or Capital), Income (or Revenue) and Expenses. The five accounting elements are all affected in either a positive or negative way. A credit transaction does not always dictate a positive value or increase in a transaction and similarly, a debit does not always indicate a negative value or decrease in a transaction. An asset account is often referred to as a "debit account" due to the account's standard increasing attribute on the debit side. When an asset (e.g. an espresso machine) has been acquired in a business, the transaction will affect the debit side of that asset account illustrated below:
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
The "X" in the debit column denotes the increasing effect of a transaction on the asset account balance (total debits less total credits), because a debit to an asset account is an increase. The asset account above has been added to by a debit value X, i.e. the balance has increased by £X or $X. Likewise, in the liability account below, the X in the credit column denotes the increasing effect on the liability account balance (total credits less total debits), because a credit to a liability account is an increase.
All "mini-ledgers" in this section show standard increasing attributes for the five elements of accounting.
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
Summary table of standard increasing and decreasing attributes for the accounting elements:
Attributes of accounting elements per real, personal, and nominal accounts
Real accounts are assets. Personal accounts are liabilities and owners' equity and represent people and entities that have invested in the business. Nominal accounts are revenue, expenses, gains, and losses. Accountants close nominal accounts at the end of each accounting period. This method is used in the United Kingdom, where it is simply known as the Traditional approach.
Transactions are recorded by a debit to one account and a credit to another account using these three "golden rules of accounting":
- Real account: Debit what comes in and credit what goes out
- Personal account: Debit who receives and Credit who gives.
- Nominal account: Debit all expenses & losses and Credit all incomes & gains
|Personal (owner's equity)||Decrease||Increase|
Each transaction that takes place within the business will consist of at least one debit to a specific account and at least one credit to another specific account. A debit to one account can be balanced by more than one credit to other accounts, and vice versa. For all transactions, the total debits must be equal to the total credits and therefore balance.
The general accounting equation is as follows:
- Assets = Equity + Liabilities,
- A = E + L.
The equation thus becomes A – L – E = 0 (zero). When the total debts equals the total credits for each account, then the equation balances.
The extended accounting equation is as follows:
- Assets + Expenses = Equity/Capital + Liabilities + Income,
- A + Ex = E + L + I.
In this form, increases to the amount of accounts on the left-hand side of the equation are recorded as debits, and decreases as credits. Conversely for accounts on the right-hand side, increases to the amount of accounts are recorded as credits to the account, and decreases as debits.
This can also be rewritten in the equivalent form:
- Assets = Liabilities + Equity/Capital + (Income − Expenses),
- A = L + E + (I − Ex),
where the relationship of the Income and Expenses accounts to Equity and profit is a bit clearer. Here Income and Expenses are regarded as temporary or nominal accounts which pertain only to the current accounting period whereas Asset, Liability, and Equity accounts are permanent or real accounts pertaining to the lifetime of the business. The temporary accounts are closed to the Equity account at the end of the accounting period to record profit/loss for the period. Both sides of these equations must be equal (balance).
Each transaction is recorded in a ledger or "T" account, e.g. a ledger account named "Bank" that can be changed with either a debit or credit transaction.
In accounting it is acceptable to draw-up a ledger account in the following manner for representation purposes:
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
Accounts pertaining to the five accounting elements
Accounts are created/opened when the need arises for whatever purpose or situation the entity may have. For example, if your business is an airline company they will have to purchase airplanes, therefore even if an account is not listed below, a bookkeeper or accountant can create an account for a specific item, such as an asset account for airplanes. In order to understand how to classify an account into one of the five elements, a good understanding of the definitions of these accounts is required. Below are examples of some of the more common accounts that pertain to the five accounting elements:
Asset accounts are economic resources which benefit the business/entity and will continue to do so. They are Cash, bank, accounts receivable, inventory, land, buildings/plant, machinery, furniture, equipment, supplies, vehicles, trademarks and patents, goodwill, prepaid expenses, prepaid insurance, debtors (people who owe us money, due within one year), VAT input etc.
Two types of basic asset classification:
- Current assets: Assets which operate in a financial year or assets that can be used up, or converted within one year or less is called current assets. For example, Cash, bank, accounts receivable, inventory (people who owe us money, due within one year), prepaid expenses, prepaid insurance, VAT input and many more.
- Non-current assets: Assets that are not recorded in transactions or hold for more than one year or in an accounting period is called Non-current assets. For example, land, buildings/plant, machinery, furniture, equipment, vehicles, trademarks and patents, goodwill etc.
Liability accounts record debts or future obligations a business or entity owes to others. When one institution borrows from another for a period of time, the ledger of the borrowing institution categorises the argument under liability accounts.
The basic classifications of liability accounts are:
- Current liability, when money only may be owed for the current accounting period or periodical. Examples include accounts payable, salaries and wages payable, income taxes, bank overdrafts, accrued expenses, sales taxes, advance payments (unearned revenue), debt and accrued interest on debt, customer deposits, VAT output, etc.
- Long-term liability, when money may be owed for more than one year. Examples include trust accounts, debenture, mortgage loans and more.
Income accounts record all increases in Equity other than that contributed by the owner/s of the business/entity. Services rendered, sales, interest income, membership fees, rent income, interest from investment, recurring receivables,donation etc.
Expense accounts record all decreases in the owners' equity which occur from using the assets or increasing liabilities in delivering goods or services to a customer - the costs of doing business. Telephone, water, electricity, repairs, salaries, wages, depreciation, bad debts, stationery, entertainment, honorarium, rent, fuel, utility, interest etc.
Quick Services business purchases a computer for £500, on credit, from ABC Computers. Recognize the following transaction for Quick Services in a ledger account (T-account):
Quick Services has acquired a new computer which is classified as an asset within the business. According to the accrual basis of accounting, even though the computer has been purchased on credit, the computer is already the property of Quick Services and must be recognised as such. Therefore, the equipment account of Quick Services increases and is debited:
As the transaction for the new computer is made on credit, the payable "ABC Computers" has not yet been paid. As a result, a liability is created within the entity's records. Therefore, to balance the accounting equation the corresponding liability account is credited:
|Payable ABC Computers (Liability)|
The above example can be written in journal form:
|ABC Computers (Payable)||500|
The journal entry "ABC Computers" is indented to indicate that this is the credit transaction. It is accepted accounting practice to indent credit transactions recorded within a journal.
In the accounting equation form:
- A = E + L,
- 500 = 0 + 500 (the accounting equation is therefore balanced).
- A business pays rent with cash: You increase rent (expense) by recording a debit transaction, and decrease cash (asset) by recording a credit transaction.
- A business receives cash for a sale: You increase cash (asset) by recording a debit transaction, and increase sales (income) by recording a credit transaction.
- A business buys equipment with cash: You increase equipment (asset) by recording a debit transaction, and decrease cash (asset) by recording a credit transaction.
- A business borrows with a cash loan: You increase cash (asset) by recording a debit transaction, and increase loan (liability) by recording a credit transaction.
- A business pays salaries with cash: You increase salary (expenses) by recording a debit transaction, and decrease cash (asset) by recording a credit transaction.
- The totals show the net effect on the accounting equation and the double-entry principle, where the transactions are balanced.
|Account||Debit (Dr)||Credit (Cr)|
The process of using debits and credits creates a ledger format that resembles the letter "T". The term "T-account" is accounting jargon for a "ledger account" and is often used when discussing bookkeeping. The reason that a ledger account is often referred to as a T-account is due to the way the account is physically drawn on paper (representing a "T"). The left column of the "T" is for Debit (Dr) transactions, while the right column is for Credit (Cr) transactions.
|Debits (Dr)||Credits (Cr)|
All accounts also can be debited or credited depending on what transaction has taken place e.g., when a vehicle is purchased using cash, the asset account "Vehicles" is debited as the vehicle account increases, and simultaneously the asset account "Bank or Cash" is credited due to the payment for the vehicle using cash. Some balance sheet items have corresponding contra accounts, with negative balances, that offset them. Examples are accumulated depreciation against equipment, and allowance for bad debts (also known as allowance for doubtful accounts) against accounts receivable. United States GAAP utilizes the term contra for specific accounts only and doesn't recognize the second half of a transaction as a contra, thus the term is restricted to accounts that are related. For example, sales returns and allowance and sales discounts are contra revenues with respect to sales, as the balance of each contra (a debit) is the opposite of sales (a credit). To understand the actual value of sales, one must net the contras against sales, which gives rise to the term net sales (meaning net of the contras).
A more specific definition in common use is an account with a balance that is the opposite of the normal balance (Dr/Cr) for that section of the general ledger. An example is an office coffee fund: Expense "Coffee" (Dr) may be immediately followed by "Coffee - employee contributions" (Cr). Such an account is used for clarity rather than being a necessary part of GAAP (generally accepted accounting principles).
Each of the following accounts is either an Asset (A), Contra Account (CA), Liability (L), Shareholders’ Equity (SE), Revenue (Rev), Expense (Exp) or Dividend (Div) account.
Account transactions can be recorded as a debit to one account and a credit to another account using the modern or traditional approaches in accounting following are their normal balances:
|Cost of goods sold||Exp||Dr|
|Allowance for doubtful accounts||CA (A/R)||Cr|
|Accumulated depreciation||CA (A)||Cr|
|Investment in shares||A||Dr|
- "Debit Credit Rules". Accounting Explained. AccountingExplained.com. Retrieved 4 August 2011.
- "Making sense of Debits and Credits in Accounting". Archived from the original on 10 July 2013. Retrieved 5 May 2013.
- "Peachtree For Dummies, 2nd Ed" (PDF). Retrieved 6 February 2011.
- Jane Gleeson-White (2012). Double Entry: How the Merchants of Venice Created Modern Finance. W. W. Norton. ISBN 978-0-393-08968-4.
- Nigam, B. M. Lall (1986). Bahi-Khata: The Pre-Pacioli Indian Double-entry System of Bookkeeping. Abacus, September 1986. Retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-6281.1986.tb00132.x/abstract.
- "Basic Accounting Concepts 2 – Debits and Credits". Retrieved 6 February 2011.
- "Wheres's the "R" in Debit?" by W. Richard Sherman published in The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol. 13, No. 2 (Fall 1986), pp. 137-143.
- Analysis or Resolution of Merchant Accompts 3e at WorldCat
- "For each one of all the entries that you have made in the Journal you will have to make two in the Ledger. That is, one in the debit (in dare) and one in the credit (in havere). In the Journal the debtor is indicated by per, the creditor by a, as we have said...The debitor entry must be at the left, the creditor one at the right." Geijsbeek, John B (1914). Ancient Double-entry Bookkeeping. Retrieved 31 July 2016. A facsimile of the original Italian is given on the facing page to the translation.
- Geijsbeek, John B (1914). Ancient Double-entry Bookkeeping. p. 15. Retrieved 31 July 2016.
- Jackson, J.G.C., "The History of Methods of Exposition of Double-Entry Bookkeeping in England." Studies in the History of Accounting, A. C. Littleton and Basil S. Yamey (eds.). Homewood, III.: Richard D. Irwin, 1956. p. 295
- Pieters, A. Dempsey, H. N. (2009). Introduction to financial accounting (7th ed.). Durban: Lexisnexis. ISBN 978-0-409-10580-3.
- Accountancy: Higher Secondary First Year (PDF) (First ed.). Tamil Nadu Textbooks Corporation. 2004. pp. 28–34. Retrieved 12 July 2011.
- A. Chowdry. Fundamentals of Accounting and Financial Analysis. Pearson Education India. pp. 44+. ISBN 978-81-317-0202-4.
- IFRS for SMEs. 1st Floor, 30 Cannon Street, London EC4M 6XH, United Kingdom: IASB (International Accounting Standards Board). 2009. p. 14. ISBN 978-0-409-04813-1.
- David L. Kolitz; A. B. Quinn; Gavin McAllister (2009). Concepts-Based Introduction to Financial Accounting. Juta and Company Ltd. pp. 86–89. ISBN 978-0-7021-7749-1.
- Difference between Credit Card and Debit Card Archived 23 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine. Diffbetween.org (2012-02-08). Retrieved on 2012-05-04.
- "Accounting made easy 4 – Debits and Credits". Retrieved 13 March 2011.
- "Account Types or Kinds of Accounts :: Personal, Real, Nominal". Retrieved 8 April 2011.
- Financial Accounting 5th Ed., p. 47, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser, Willet, Pearson/PrenticeHall, 2006.
- Financial Accounting 5th Ed., p. 14–15, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser, Willet, Pearson/PrenticeHall, 2006.
- Financial Accounting 5th Ed., p. 145, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser, Willet, Pearson/PrenticeHall, 2006.
- Financial Accounting, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser Willet, pp. 13, 44, Pearson/PrenticeHall 2006.
- Maire Loughran (24 April 2012). Intermediate Accounting For Dummies. John Wiley & Sons. p. 86. ISBN 978-1-118-17682-5.
- Financial Accounting, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser Willet, pp. 14, 45, Pearson/PrenticeHall 2006.
- Financial Accounting, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser Willet, pp. 14, 46, Pearson/PrenticeHall 2006.
- Financial Accounting, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser Willet, p. 14, Pearson/PrenticeHAll 2006.
- Financial Accounting, Horngren, Harrison, Bamber, Best, Fraser Willet, p. 15, Pearson/PrenticeHall 2006.
- Weygandt, Jerry J. (2009). Financial Accounting. John Wiley and Sons. p. 53. ISBN 978-0-470-47715-1.
- Cusimano, David. "Accounting Abbreviations – Helping You Understand Accounting Jargon". Loughborough. Retrieved 18 August 2011.
- "Normal balances in the accounting double entry system". The Accounting Adventurista. Retrieved 3 March 2014.
- "Contra account definition". Accounting Coach. Retrieved 3 March 2014.
- "Q&A: What is a contra expense account?". Accounting Coach. Retrieved 3 March 2014.
|Look up debit or credit in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.|