Detransition: Revision history

11 December 2020

• curprev 20:5720:57, 11 December 2020‎ Monkbot talk contribs‎ m 50,649 bytes −366‎ Task 18 (cosmetic): eval 86 templates: del empty params (3×); hyphenate params (52×); del |ref=harv (20×); Tag: AWB

5 December 2020

• curprev 10:4810:48, 5 December 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 51,015 bytes +9‎ Undid revision 992408464 by 92.40.187.182 (talk) not clear sources say this explicitly, harassment is mentioned in first person but not who is doing it Tag: Undo
• curprev 03:1403:14, 5 December 2020‎ 92.40.187.182 talk‎ 51,006 bytes −9‎ removed qualifier as reference supports claim Tags: Reverted Mobile edit Mobile app edit iOS app edit

3 December 2020

• curprev 12:1012:10, 3 December 2020‎ Thincat talk contribs‎ 51,015 bytes +664‎ outcome

16 October 2020

• curprev 23:5823:58, 16 October 2020‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 50,351 bytes −62‎ Alter: chapter-url, url. URLs might have been internationalized/anonymized. | You can use this bot yourself. Report bugs here. | Suggested by AManWithNoPlan | All pages linked from cached copy of User:AManWithNoPlan/sandbox2 | via #UCB_webform_linked 1390/11719

5 October 2020

• curprev 18:0718:07, 5 October 2020‎ Genericusername57 talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes −273‎ Undid revision 982012024 by 79.138.84.68 (talk) this is incorrect: the 2015 NCTE survey specifically excluded responses from people who did not identify as transgender and/or wish to transition at the time of the survey Tag: Undo
• curprev 17:5817:58, 5 October 2020‎ 79.138.84.68 talk‎ 50,686 bytes +273‎ Undid revision 981847375 by Equivamp (talk) The statement of "some" is misleading as it implies the minority. Either it must be clarified that it is the majority, or be removed from the lead and placed along with the data pertaining to that topic. I have reverted to my previous edit, but have now added a disclaimer to the citation informing that the data is lacking. Tag: Reverted

4 October 2020

• curprev 19:1819:18, 4 October 2020‎ Equivamp talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes −219‎ Undid revision 981839398 by 79.138.84.68 (talk) Misinterpreting that survey data Tags: Undo Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit
• curprev 18:2318:23, 4 October 2020‎ 79.138.84.68 talk‎ 50,632 bytes +219‎ No edit summary Tag: Reverted

21 September 2020

• curprev 17:5617:56, 21 September 2020‎ Aircorn talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes +266‎ Undid revision 979598035 by 2A02:AA12:E202:8C80:A5B2:B5F4:ED91:35F3 (talk)Its a quote from the source Tag: Undo
• curprev 17:0217:02, 21 September 2020‎ 2a02:aa12:e202:8c80:a5b2:b5f4:ed91:35f3 talk‎ 50,147 bytes −266‎ Misinformation removed from citation: "Only very few trans- kids still want to transition by the time they are adults. Instead, they generally turn out to be regular gay or lesbian folks. The exact number varies by study, but roughly 60–90% of trans- kids turn out no longer to be trans by adulthood." Tags: Reverted Visual edit: Switched

16 September 2020

• curprev 05:2705:27, 16 September 2020‎ WhoAteMyButter talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes −9‎ Reverting edit(s) by Proof you can edit (talk) to rev. 978443398 by Flyer22 Frozen: non-constructive (RW 15) Tags: RW Undo
• curprev 05:2505:25, 16 September 2020‎ Proof you can edit talk contribs‎ 50,422 bytes +9‎ →‎Further reading Tags: Reverted Mobile edit Mobile web edit

14 September 2020

• curprev 23:3523:35, 14 September 2020‎ Flyer22 Frozen talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes +1,183‎ Undid revision 978417047 by Rab V (talk) Where is this "per talk"? I see no consensus for this removal. And per talk, some of this content is simply social information. Tag: Undo
• curprev 19:5819:58, 14 September 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 49,230 bytes −1,183‎ per talk

13 September 2020

• curprev 10:1310:13, 13 September 2020‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 50,413 bytes +15‎ Add: s2cid. | You can use this bot yourself. Report bugs here. | Suggested by Grimes2 | Category:Articles requiring reliable medical sources | via #UCB_Category

29 August 2020

• curprev 03:4403:44, 29 August 2020‎ Jclemens talk contribs‎ 50,398 bytes +34‎ →‎Individual accounts: link to Heyer's article, within which there are more sources and definitely room for updating

26 August 2020

• curprev 18:3518:35, 26 August 2020‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 50,364 bytes +146‎ Add: journal, s2cid. | You can use this bot yourself. Report bugs here. | Suggested by Equivamp | via #UCB_webform
• curprev 03:1303:13, 26 August 2020‎ Crossroads talk contribs‎ 50,218 bytes −27‎ →‎Cultural and political impact: clear enough
• curprev 02:1402:14, 26 August 2020‎ Flyer22 Frozen talk contribs‎ m 50,245 bytes −2‎ Comment: The stigma that detransitioners face is addressed in the "Cultural and political impact" section. Should be briefly summarized in the lead. And as for academic sources on that, one can add the Simon and Schuster "The End of Gender: Debunking the Myths about Sex and Identity in Our Society" source by Debra Soh for information on that. I might add it.

25 August 2020

• curprev 23:1323:13, 25 August 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 50,247 bytes −95‎ line is vague (what is meant by experience controversy) and not directly supported in body of article
• curprev 18:3718:37, 25 August 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 50,342 bytes −2,330‎ →‎Occurrence: Don't blanked revert; if your argument is that these are usable for cultural commentary, they certainly don't belong in the occurrence section.
• curprev 15:5315:53, 25 August 2020‎ Crossroads talk contribs‎ 52,672 bytes +3,809‎ Reverted to revision 974787366 by Aircorn: Revert. There is as yet no consensus for these removals or for purging Herzog, Singal, etc. from the article. See the portions of WP:MEDRS which Wikipedia:Biomedical information talks about - society and culture content, such as talking about attacks on social media, does not need review article sourcing. You already tried purging Singal before. Discuss on the talk page. (TW) Tag: Undo
• curprev 03:0203:02, 25 August 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 48,863 bytes −682‎ rm. per general consensus on talk; low-quality source from non-expert on this topic. Profile is trivia.
• curprev 02:5702:57, 25 August 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 49,545 bytes −785‎ The Stranger definitely doesn't pass WP:MEDRS; we shouldn't cite them for stuff like this when we have better sources.
• curprev 02:5202:52, 25 August 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 50,330 bytes −525‎ This one is being used for WP:MEDRS-sensitive claims and clearly doesn't pass, either.
• curprev 02:5002:50, 25 August 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 50,855 bytes −1,817‎ these, at least, don't look like peer-reviewed journals or WP:MEDRS-compliant sources to me; modern Newsweek in particular is a low-quality source and absolutely cannot be used for controversial medical claims.
• curprev 01:1001:10, 25 August 2020‎ Aircorn talk contribs‎ 52,672 bytes +2,588‎ Restore two deletions. Sources were from peer reveiwed journals. Considering the lack of such sources in these articles removing them requires more justification than given in the edit summary.

24 August 2020

• curprev 06:1406:14, 24 August 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 50,084 bytes −1‎ →‎Occurrence
• curprev 06:1406:14, 24 August 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 50,085 bytes −2,260‎ →‎Occurrence: per WP:MEDRS
• curprev 06:1306:13, 24 August 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 52,345 bytes −120‎ →‎Occurrence: unsourced
• curprev 06:1306:13, 24 August 2020‎ Rab V talk contribs‎ 52,465 bytes −326‎ →‎Occurrence: vague, by who and are they notable
• curprev 02:4802:48, 24 August 2020‎ MentalHealthResearch talk contribs‎ 52,791 bytes +120‎ Added a study from the Amsterdam clinic about surgical regret. Tag: Visual edit

12 August 2020

• curprev 00:5000:50, 12 August 2020‎ Comrade GC talk contribs‎ 52,671 bytes −4‎ →‎Individual accounts: Removing redlink.

20 July 2020

• curprev 15:4915:49, 20 July 2020‎ Equivamp talk contribs‎ 52,675 bytes 0‎ This seems better suited to the other section

15 July 2020

• curprev 19:4519:45, 15 July 2020‎ Crossroads talk contribs‎ 52,675 bytes +680‎ You're cutting The Atlantic now? See WP:RSP, it's in green. Also see WP:BIASEDSOURCES: "reliable sources are not required to be neutral, unbiased, or objective. Sometimes non-neutral sources are the best possible sources for supporting information about the different viewpoints held on a subject." Tag: Undo
• curprev 18:0918:09, 15 July 2020‎ Aquillion talk contribs‎ 51,995 bytes −680‎ rm. pop-culture pieces by non-expert; already citing many better sources.

21 June 2020

• curprev 21:2721:27, 21 June 2020‎ Genericusername57 talk contribs‎ 52,675 bytes −31‎ Reverted 1 edit by 71.89.235.209 (talk): Rv unsourced (TW) Tag: Undo
• curprev 21:0821:08, 21 June 2020‎ 71.89.235.209 talk‎ 52,706 bytes +31‎ No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit

13 June 2020

• curprev 11:4211:42, 13 June 2020‎ Bondegezou talk contribs‎ 52,675 bytes −3,024‎ Reverting: that was not a minor edit; material is covered on other articles and doesn't fit here Tag: Undo
• curprev 09:1709:17, 13 June 2020‎ Abdulla Elattar talk contribs‎ m 55,699 bytes +3,024‎ I introduced the subtopic of common misconception relating to Transgender people. The primary rationale for this is that the page does not have the topic. Tag: Visual edit

12 June 2020

• curprev 13:5013:50, 12 June 2020‎ Jmenashe talk contribs‎ 52,675 bytes +218‎ Statistic is presented in source material without reference to originating expert(s), research, or scholarly works.

11 June 2020

• curprev 21:1921:19, 11 June 2020‎ 108.31.146.220 talk‎ 52,457 bytes +92‎ →‎Occurrence: Rephrased sentence a bit
• curprev 21:1421:14, 11 June 2020‎ 108.31.146.220 talk‎ 52,365 bytes −9‎ Changed my wording of "pre-adolescent" to "young" - the children were as young as 5. Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 18:5418:54, 11 June 2020‎ 108.31.146.220 talk‎ 52,374 bytes +31‎ See talk page "Correction 6/11/20" Tag: Visual edit

6 June 2020

• curprev 10:4810:48, 6 June 2020‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 52,343 bytes −322‎ Alter: url, chapter-url. Add: s2cid. Removed or converted URL. Removed accessdate with no specified URL. | You can use this bot yourself. Report bugs here. | Activated by AManWithNoPlan | All pages linked from User:AManWithNoPlan/sandbox2 | via #UCB_webform_linked

14 May 2020

• curprev 05:3805:38, 14 May 2020‎ WanderingWanda talk contribs‎ 52,665 bytes +13‎ potential compromise wording

13 May 2020

• curprev 20:3420:34, 13 May 2020‎ ZoeB talk contribs‎ 52,652 bytes +292‎ I can see Caspian was a trustee for the Beaumont Trust. I can't find any evidence online of the Beaumont Trust doing anything, nor of Caspian having any qualifications specific to counseling trans people. (Surely hypnosis and taking an *intro* to dream analysis don't qualify?) Contrast with e.g. the hundreds if not thousands of people who talked online about how much Russell Reid helped them. I can't find a single reference to someone actually talking to Caspian, besides the press.
• curprev 16:5116:51, 13 May 2020‎ Genericusername57 talk contribs‎ 52,360 bytes −249‎ Caspian was a trustee for the Beaumont Trust from 2001 to 2018, and used to work with Transhealth (Richard Curtis' practice); the BBC, the Times of London, and the Guardian all describe him as a specialist in transgender-related care.
• curprev 16:3616:36, 13 May 2020‎ ZoeB talk contribs‎ 52,609 bytes +62‎ OK, cite properly, even if it does look a bit overkill