Lorenzo Milani

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Don milani)
Jump to: navigation, search

Lorenzo Milani Comparetti (27 May 1923 – 26 June 1967) was an Italian Roman Catholic priest. He is best known as an educator of poor children and an advocate of conscientious objection.


Lorenzo Milani was born in Florence in 1923 to a rich middle-class family (see the excellent biography by Neera Fallaci, 1993). His father, Albano Milani, and his mother, Alice Weiss, were staunch secularists. Alice Weiss was Jewish and a cousin of Edoardo Weiss, one of Sigmund Freud's earliest disciples and the founder of the Italian Psychoanalytic Association. Milani's paternal grandfather was Domenico Comparetti, a leading nineteenth-century philologist, and it is no accident that, as an educationist, Milani was a firm believer in the importance of learning how to use words effectively.[1]

In June 1943, after a period of study at the Brera Academy, Milani converted to Roman Catholicism. A chance conversation with Don Raffaele Bensi, who later became his spiritual director, appears to have played an important part in this. Milani's was a conversion both from agnosticism to religious faith and from well-off complacency to solidarity with the poor and despised. Ordained a priest in 1947, he was sent to assist Don Daniele Pugi, the old parish priest of San Donato in Calenzano, where he set up his first "school of the people" (scuola popolare) (see the excellent study on this period by Domenico Simeone,1996), open to children from both believing and non-believing families. This scandalized conservative Catholic circles. After Pugi's death in 1954, Milani was sent "into exile" at Barbiana, a small, remote village in the Mugello region.[1]

At Barbiana, despite both clerical and lay opposition, Milani continued his radical educational activities. In the spring of 1958, he published his first book, Pastoral Experiences (Esperienze pastorali). In December the Holy Office, despite failing to find in it any errors of doctrine or breaches of ecclesiastical discipline (see Corzo, 2011, often referred to as Corzo Toral, on the theological underpinnings of Milani's writings), ordered its withdrawal from circulation[1] as "inopportune".[2] Milani never publicly vented his anger against the Church since he believed in obedience to it (Gesualdi, 2011), even though he would have expected its support for his actions dictated by his conscience (see parallels with Socrates in Centro Formazione e Ricerca Don Milani e Scuola di Barbiana,2008). In 1965, Milani was put on trial for advocating conscientious objection in his "Letter to Military Chaplains" ("Lettera ai cappellani militari" see Burtchaell, 1988).[3] The right to say No' is emphasised throughout this letter and the one to the judges (Grech and Mayo, 2014). The text is relevant for a contemporary anti-militaristic pedagogy (Batini, Mayo, Surian, 2014; Grech and Mayo, 2014; Mayo, 2013, 2015).

Working with his pupils, Milani produced Letter to a Teacher (Lettera a una professoressa), denouncing the inequalities of a class-based educational system that advantaged the children of the rich over those of the poor.[4] Translated into about forty languages, Letter to a Teacher is a pedagogical classic that continues to shock and inspire. It captures most of the themes that became prominent in the Sociology of Education. Another more recent and annotated version in English is provided by Carmel Borg, Mario Cardona and Sandro Caruana (Borg, Cardona and Caruana,2009; 2013). It was composed by eight boys from the school of Barbiana, according to the "group writing" method inspired by the cooperative writing method promoted by Mario Lodi and influenced by Celesine Freinet. Lodi visited Barbiana and his students engaged in exchanges with those at Barbiana (see the last chapter in Batini, Mayo and Surian, 2014). The, which consisted of a year-long project coordinated by Milani, invites parallels with the work of key pedagogues such as Paulo Freire (Mayo, 2007; 2013)[5] The text served as a manifesto for the 68 movement (Starnone, 2007), testifying to Pasolini's claim that it is an indictment of not only the Italian schooling system but Italian society at large (Batini, Mayo and Surian, 2014)

In 1967, shortly after the publication of Letter to a Teacher and thirty days after his 44th birthday, Milani died in his mother's house in Florence of leukemia.[1]


Fr Milani was a prolific writer, and his "Letter to Pipetta" — a young communist partisan returning to civil life after World War II — typifies both his style and his stance on social issues:

Dear Pipetta, Every time we meet you tell me that if every priest were like me, then… You say so because you and I have always understood each other, even though you don’t care about being excommunicated, and even though you’d love to make mincemeat of my fellow priests. You say that we understood each other because I said you were right the thousands of times you had thousands of reasons for being right. But, tell me, Pipetta, did you really understand me? You do realise, don’t you, that it’s just a coincidence that I’m here struggling with you against the rich. It’s not what St. Paul would have done. And that coincidence is there because what happened on the 18th of April [trans note: 1948 when the Christian Democrats defeated the Communist Party in the elections and won an outright majority in Parliament] was also a defeat for the reasons that made you right as well as for those that made you wrong. And it’s only because I was unlucky enough to be on the winning side that… . I make an effort, Pipetta, to feel bad about injustice with you. But just between the two of us, believe me, it nauseates me to have to do so. Why should I have cared about your hardship? If your side had won, Pipetta, I wouldn’t have stayed with you. You’ve no bread? Why should I care as long as my conscience is clear about not having more than you? Why should I care about only wanting to speak to you about the other Bread that you haven’t asked me for any more since the time you turned up to partake of it with your mother after you got back from imprisonment. Everything passes, Pipetta. The Bread of God is on the other side for those who die on the rich man’s doorstep covered in sores. This is all that my Lord has asked me to tell you. The problem is that history has turned against me – the 18th of April ruined everything - and that victory has become my great defeat. Now that the rich have beat you with my help, I have to say you’re right – I’ve got to come out and fight the rich by your side. But, Pipetta, that’s no reason for telling me I’m the only priest who’s all right. You think you’re saying something that makes me feel good, but you’re only rubbing salt into my wound. And if history hadn’t turned against me... if on the 18th … you would never have seen me coming down there to fight the rich. You’re right; of course you’re right – between you and the rich man you’ll always be the poor man, and in the right. Even when you’re wrong enough to take up arms, I’ll say you’re right.

But what you’re making me say to you is of so little worth. This just thing you’ve made me say, Pipetta my brother, is so inadequate for opening the gates of Paradise for you, when for every hardship of yours I suffer two hardships, when for every defeat of yours I suffer two defeats. Let me tell you right now, Pipetta, that when that day comes I’m not going to say “You’re right” like I’m saying now. That day, at last, I’ll be able to open my mouth again and let forth the only cry of victory worthy of a priest of Christ: “Pipetta, you’re wrong. Blessed are the poor for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven”. The day when, together, we break down the gates of some grand estate, and, together, we make a home for the poor man in the rich man’s palace, remember, Pipetta, don’t trust me because that day I will betray you. That day I won’t stay with you there. I’ll go back to your damp, stinking little house to pray for you before my crucified Lord. (Don Lorenzo Milani, 1950).


In a review (15/11/08) of the Maltese-language book Lorenzo Milani, l-Edukazzjoni u l-Gustizzja Socjali[6] by Carmel Borg and Mario Cardona, Malta Labour Party MP Helena Dalli wrote: "Milani's ideas were considered dangerously radical and his bishop sent him into a sort of internal exile to a small mountain village north of Florence called Barbiana, thought too remote for him to cause problems. He started a full-time school there for children who had been failed or abandoned by the traditional education system. Eventually, hundreds of pupils of all ages were attracted to his teaching methods. Artists, farmers, scientists, artisans and professionals were invited to give hands-on explanations of their activities. Pupils were also made to read and evaluate national and international news. The aim was to educate them to analyze events critically so as to face life without fear and to solve problems with determination and awareness."

A recent documentary film from RAI describes the characteristics of Lorenzo Milani's educational project and its impact on Italian society. The film presents interviews with former students of the school at Barbiana and other involved persons. (The film is available with English text).[7]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b c d Don Lorenzo Milani: Biografia (In Italian)
  2. ^ Bruzzesi, Lanfranco. "Don Lorenzo Milani" (in Italian)
  3. ^ A Soldier Too Has a Conscience — The Trial of Don Milani. Translated by Gerry Blaylock.
  4. ^ Letter to a Teacher. Translated by Nora Rossi and Tom Cole.
  5. ^ It was described enthusiastically by leading Italian intellectual icon of the 60s and early 70s, Pier Paolo Pasolini as a "wind of vitality" and the one book which more than any other captured his imagination in a long time (Batini, Mayo & Surian 2014). /cont_biography.html Don Lorenzo Milani: A brief biography Archived June 25, 2011, at the Wayback Machine.
  6. ^ Borg, Carmel and Cardona, Mario (2008). Lorenzo Milani, l-Edukazzjoni u l-Gustizzja Socjali. Malta: Media Centre. ISBN 978-99909-2-114-4. The book is dedicated "...to those children who left school without basic skills — and to those teachers who believe that through their work they can make a difference in the lives of children".
  7. ^ Don Lorenzo Milani: An Obedient Archived July 28, 2009, at the Wayback Machine.

Further reading[edit]

Batini, F, Mayo, P and Surian, A (2014), Lorenzo Milani, The School of Barbiana and the Struggle for Social Justice, New York, Vienna,Berne, Oxford, Frankfurt, Hamburg: Peter Lang.

Borg, C Cardona, M and Caruana, S (2013) Social Class, language and Power. 'Letter to a Teacher', Lorenzo Milani and the School of Barbiana. Rotterdam, Boston and Taipei: Sense.

Borg, C, Cardona, M and Caruana, S (2009), Letter to a Teacher. Lorenzo Milani’s Contribution to Education for Critical Citizenship, Malta: Agenda

Burtchaell, J.T. (Ed.) (1988), A Just War no Longer Exists. The Teaching and Trial of Don Lorenzo Milani, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press.

Centro Formazione e Ricerca Don Lorenzo Milani e Scuola di Barbiana (2008) Socrate e Don Lorenzo(Socrates and Don Lorenzo), Vicchio (Florence): Centro Formazione e Ricerca Don Lorenzo Milani e Scuola di Barbiana.

Corzo, J.L (2011) „Alla Scuola della Parola. Analisi teologico -spirituale degli scritti di don Lorenzo Milani‟ (For the School of the Word. A theological-spiritual analysis of Lorenzo Milani‟s writings), in R. Sani and D. Simeone (Eds.), Don Lorenzo Milani e la Scuola della Parola. Analisi storica e prospettive pedagogiche (Don Lorenzo Milani and the School of the Word. Historical Analysis and Pedagogical Perspectives), Macerata: Edizioni Università di Macerata (eum).

Fallaci, Neera (1993), Vita del Prete Lorenzo Milani. Dalla parte dell’ultimo(Life of the Priest Lorenzo Milani. On the side of those who are last), Milan: Biblioteca Universale Rizzoli.

Gesualdi, M (Ed.)(2011), L’obbedienza nella Chiesa(Obedience in the Church), Florence: Liberia Editrice Fiorentina

Grech, M and Mayo, P ( 2014) "What Catholic educators can learn from the radical Christianity and critical pedagogy of Don Lorenzo Milani," International Studies in Catholic Education, Vol. 6 No.1, pp. 33–45.

Martinelli, E, (2007).Don Lorenzo Milani. Dall’motivo occasionale al motive profondo(Don Lorenzo Milani. From the occasional motive to the profound motive), Florence: Società Editrice Fiorentina

Mayo, P (2007) "Critical approaches to education in the work of Lorenzo Milani and Paulo Freire", Studies in Philosophy and Education, Vol. 26, No. 6, pp. 525–544. Reproduced in Mayo, P (2013) Echoes from Freire for a Critically Engaged Pedagogy, New York and London: Bloomsbury Academic.

Mayo, P (2013) "Lorenzo Milani in Our Times" Policy Futures in Education Vol. 11 No. 5, pp. 515–522.

Mayo, P (2015) "Italian signposts for a sociologically and critically engaged pedagogy. Don Lorenzo Milani (1923-1967) and the schools of San Donato and Barbiana revisited," British Journal of Sociology of Education, Vol. 36, No. 6, pp. 853–870.

Simeone, D. (1996), Verso la Scuola di Barbiana. L’esperienza pastorale educativa di don Lorenzo Milani a S. Donato di Calenzano(Towards the School of Barbiana. The Pastoral Experience of Don Lorenzo Milani at San Donato di Calenzano), San Pietro in Cariano (Verona): Il Segno dei Gabrielli Editori.

Starnone,D (2007), "A Barbiana Scoppio` il '68' " (The ‟68 movement started at Barbiana) in Gesualdi, M. (Ed.), Scuola di Barbiana. Lettera a Une Professoressa. Quarnt’ anni dopo(School of Barbiana. Letter to a Teacher. 40 years later), Florence:Libreria Editrice Fiorentina