E. B. Ford
Edmund Brisco "Henry" Ford
Edmund Brisco Ford
23 April 1901
|Died||2 January 1988 (aged 86)|
|Alma mater||University of Oxford, (Wadham College)|
Weldon Memorial Prize (1959)
|Influences||Julian Huxley, F.A. Dixey, R.A. Fisher, G.D. Hale Carpenter|
|Influenced||Philip MacDonald Sheppard, Paul Brakefield, E.R. Creed, J.R.G. Turner, K.G. McWhirter, Bernard Kettlewell|
Edmund Brisco "Henry" Ford  (23 April 1901 – 2 January 1988) was a British ecological geneticist. He was a leader among those British biologists who investigated the role of natural selection in nature. As a schoolboy Ford became interested in lepidoptera, the group of insects which includes butterflies and moths. He went on to study the genetics of natural populations, and invented the field of ecological genetics. Ford was awarded the Royal Society's Darwin Medal in 1954.
Ford was born in Dalton-in-Furness, near Ulverston, in Lancashire, England, in 1901. He was the only child of Harold Dodsworth Ford (1864–1943), a classics teacher turned Anglican clergyman, and his wife (and second cousin) Gertrude Emma Bennett. His paternal grandfather, Dr Henry Edmund Ford (1821–1909), was a professor of music at Carlisle and the organist of Carlisle Cathedral from 1842 to 1902. Ford read zoology at Wadham College, Oxford, (where his father had also studied), graduating B.A. in 1924, M.A. 1927, and taking a D.Sc in 1943.
Career and research
Ford's career was based entirely at the University of Oxford. The biologist Arthur Cain said Ford took a degree in classics before turning to zoology. Ford read zoology at Oxford, and was taught genetics by Julian Huxley. "The lecturer whose interests most closely reflected mine was Julian Huxley. I owe him a great debt, especially for inspiration... Even though Huxley was... only at Oxford from 1919 to 1925, he was the most powerful voice in developing the selectionist attitude there... I met Ray Lankester through E.B. Poulton. He was already an old man... but talked to me a good deal of Charles Darwin and Pasteur, both of whom he knew."
Ford was appointed University Demonstrator in Zoology in 1927 and Lecturer at University College, Oxford, in 1933. Specialising in genetics, he was appointed University Reader in Genetics in 1939 and was the Director of the Genetics Laboratory, 1952–1969, and Professor of Ecological Genetics 1963–1969. Ford was one of the first scientists to be elected a Fellow of All Souls College since the seventeenth century.
Ford had a long working relationship with R.A. Fisher. By the time Ford had developed his formal definition of genetic polymorphism, Fisher had got accustomed to high selection values in nature. He was most impressed by the fact that polymorphism concealed powerful selective forces (Ford gave human blood groups as an example). Like Fisher, he continued the natural selection versus genetic drift debate with Sewall Wright, whom Ford believed put too much emphasis on genetic drift. It was as a result of Ford's work, as well as his own, that Dobzhansky changed the emphasis in the third edition of his famous text from drift to selection.
Ford was an experimental naturalist who wanted to test evolution in nature. He virtually invented the field of research known as ecological genetics. His work on the wild populations of butterflies and moths was the first to show that the predictions made by R.A. Fisher were correct. He was the first to describe and define genetic polymorphism, and predicted that human blood group polymorphisms might be maintained in the population by providing some protection against disease. Six years after this prediction it was found to be so, and furthermore, heterozygous advantage was decisively established by a study of AB x AB crosses. His magnum opus was Ecological Genetics, which ran to four editions and was widely influential. He laid much of the groundwork for subsequent studies in this field, and was invited as a consultant to help set up similar research groups in several other countries.
Amongst Ford's many publications, perhaps the most popularly successful was the first book in the New Naturalist series, Butterflies. Ford also went on in 1955 to write Moths in the same series, one of only a few to have authored more than one book in the series.
Ford became Professor, and then Emeritus Professor of Ecological Genetics, University of Oxford. He was a Fellow of All Souls College, and Honorary Fellow of Wadham College. He was elected FRS in 1946, and awarded the Darwin Medal in 1954.
E.B. Ford worked for many years on genetic polymorphism. Polymorphism in natural populations is frequent; the key feature is the occurrence together of two or more discontinuous forms of a species in some kind of balance. So long as the proportions of each form is above mutation rate, then selection must be the cause. As early as 1930 Fisher had discussed a situation where, with alleles at a single locus, the heterozygote is more viable than either homozygote. That is a typical genetic mechanism for causing this type of polymorphism. The work involves a synthesis of field observations, taxonomy, and laboratory genetics.
Melanism in the peppered moth
The entomologist Michael Majerus discussed criticisms that had been made of Kettlewell's experimental methods in his 1998 book Melanism: Evolution in Action. This book was misrepresented in reviews, and the story was picked up by creationist campaigners. In her controversial book Of Moths and Men, Judith Hooper (2002) gave a critical account of Ford's supervision and relationship with Kettlewell, and implied that the work was fraudulent or at least incompetent. Careful studies of Kettlewell's surviving papers by Rudge (2005) and Young (2004) found Hooper's suggestion of fraud to be unjustified, and that "Hooper does not provide one shred of evidence to support this serious allegation". Majerus himself described Of Moths and Men as "littered with errors, misrepresentations, misinterpretations and falsehoods". He concludes
- "If you wade through the 200+ papers written about melanism in the peppered moth, it is difficult to come to any conclusion other than that natural selection through the agent of differential bird predation is largely responsible for the rise and fall of carbonaria".
Kettlewell and Helen Spurway, then the graduate student (and later the wife) of J.B.S. Haldane, were known to have shocked Ford by catching live moths as they flitted around a light, popping them in their mouths, and eating them whole. Haldane, who did not like Ford, was of the opinion that Ford and Kettlewell had attempted to capitalise on the supposed evolutionary adaptation of the main two variants of the peppered moth, for which Haldane, as early as 1924, had predicted the statistical probability of rate of change from light to melanic forms as an example of classic Mendelian genetics. In 1961, Haldane and Spurway talked to Canadian lepidopterist Gary Botting about the peppered moth and the unlikelihood of Ford and Kettlewell obtaining results that approximated Haldane's 1924 statistical calculations so closely. Botting already regarded the case of the peppered moth as tantamount to belief in Lamarckian evolution, and was of the opinion that some genetic mechanism other than bird predation was at work.
- Clarke B 1995. Edmund Brisco Ford. Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London.
- Creed R (ed) 1971. Ecological genetics and evolution: Essays in honour of E.B.Ford. Blackwell, Oxford. [an outstanding volume]
- Hooper, Judith 2002. Of moths and men. Norton.
- Huxley, Julian (1954). "Morphism and evolution". Heredity. 9: 1–52. doi:10.1038/hdy.1955.1.
- Kettlewell B. [H.B.D.] 1973. The Evolution of Melanism. Oxford. (jointly dedicated to Ford and the Nuffield Foundation)
- Marren P. 1995. The New Naturalists. HarperCollins: London
- Vane-Wright R.I. and Ackery P.R. 1984. The biology of butterflies. Symposia of the Royal Entomological Society of London no 11.
- Teän, Isles of Scilly: the site of Ford's Common Blue (Polyommatus icarus) population study.
Works by Ford
- Ford E.B. (1931, 8th ed 1965). Mendelism and evolution. Methuen, London.
- Carpenter, G.D. Hale and E.B. Ford (1933) Mimicry. Methuen, London.
- Ford E.B. (1938, 2nd ed 1950). The study of heredity. Butterworth, London. 2nd edn: Oxford University Press.
- Ford E.B. (1940). Polymorphism and taxonomy. In Huxley J. The new systematics. Oxford.
- Ford E.B. (1942, 7th edn 1973). Genetics for medical students Chapman and Hall, London.
- Ford E.B. (1945, 3rd edn 1977). Butterflies. New Naturalist No. 1 Collins, London.
- Ford E.B. (1951). British butterflies. Penguin Books, London.
- Ford E.B. (1954, 3rd edn 1972). Moths. New Naturalist No. 30 Collins, London.
- Ford E.B. (1964, 4th edn 1975). Ecological genetics. Chapman and Hall, London.
- Ford E.B. (1965). Genetic polymorphism. All Souls Studies, Faber & Faber, London.
- Ford E.B. (1976). Genetics and adaptation. Institute of Biology studies, Edward Arnold, London.
- Ford E.B. (1979). Understanding genetics. Faber and Faber, London.
- Ford E.B. (1980). Some recollections pertaining to the evolutionary synthesis. In Mayr E. and Provine W.B. (eds) The evolutionary synthesis: perspectives on the unification of biology. Harvard 1980; 1998. [effectively, this is an intellectual autobiography]
- Ford E.B. (1981). Taking genetics into the countryside. Weidenfeld & Nicolson, London.
- Ford E.B. and J.S. Haywood (1984). Church treasures of the Oxford district. Alan Sutton, Gloucester.
Ford never married, had no children, and was considered decidedly eccentric, although his eccentricity was said to be more prominent when he knew he had an audience; he was also fond of slightly surrealist practical joking. He could be markedly generous to his friends: it was "an open secret" that he made a handsome contribution to the grant of £350000 given by the Nuffield Foundation for the establishment of a Unit of Medical Genetics at the University of Liverpool; this greatly boosted the research of Cyril Clarke and Philip Sheppard.
Non-academic information on his life is hard to come by, mostly consisting of scattered remarks made by colleagues. He campaigned strenuously against the admission of female Fellows to All Souls College. Miriam Rothschild, an outstanding zoologist, was one of the few women with whom Ford was on good terms. Rothschild and Ford campaigned for the legalisation of male homosexuality in Britain. Ford was on good terms with Theodosius Dobzhansky, who did ground-breaking work on ecological genetics with Drosophila species: they exchanged letters and visits.
Ford has a memoir written by Bryan Clarke published in the Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society, but there are few other sources on his life.
- Clarke, Bryan Campbell (1995). "Edmund Brisco Ford. 23 April 1901 – 2 January 1988". Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society. London: Royal Society. 41: 146–168. doi:10.1098/rsbm.1995.0010. JSTOR 770139.
- Musical Opinion and Music Trade Review, vol. 33, 1909, p. 189
- A Directory and Local Guide or Hand Book to Carlisle and Immediate Vicinity, Hudson Scott, 1858, p. 22
- The Musician, vol. 15, Hatch Music Co., 1915, p. 133
- Cathedral Organists Past and Present, John Ebenezer West, Novello, 1921, p. 15
- The Succession of Organists of the Chapel Royal and the Cathedrals of England and Wales from C. 1538: Also of the Organists of the Collegiate Churches of Westminster and Windsor, Certain Academic Choral Foundations, and the Cathedrals of Armagh and Dublin, Watkins Shaw, Clarendon Press, 1991, p. 57
- Alumni Oxonienses, 1715-1886, Later Series, E-K, Joseph Foster, Parker & Co., p. 476
- The Annual Obituary 1988, ed. Patricia Burgess, St James Press, 1988, p. 14
- Cain A.J. and Provine W.B. 1992. In Berry R.J. et al. (eds) Genes in ecology. Blackwell, Oxford.
- Ford E.B. 1980. Some recollections pertaining to the evolutionary synthesis. In Mayr E. and Provine W.B. (eds) The evolutionary synthesis: perspectives on the unification of biology. Harvard 1980; 2nd ed 1998, p336-8. [effectively, this is an intellectual autobiography]
- Papers co-written with R.A. Fisher are available on the University of Adelaide's website at "The R.A. Fisher Digital Archive". Archived from the original on 13 December 2005. Retrieved 9 September 2007.
- Ford E.B. 1940. Polymorphism and taxonomy. In Huxley J. The new systematics. Oxford.
- Dobzhansky T. 1951. Genetics and the Origin of Species. 3rd ed, Columbia University Press N.Y.
- Ford E.B. 1942. Genetics for medical students. Methuen, London.
- Ford, E.B. (1949). "Polymorphism". Biological Reviews. 20 (2): 73. doi:10.1111/j.1469-185x.1945.tb00315.x.
- Chung, C.S.; Morton, N.E. (1961). "Selection at the ABO locus". Am J Hum Genet. 13: 9–27. PMC 1932110. PMID 13693519.
- Ford E.B. 1964, 4th edn 1975. Ecological genetics. Chapman and Hall, London.
- Ford E.B. 1945, 3rd ed 1977. Butterflies. New Naturalist No. 1 Collins, London.
- Ford E.B. 1955, 3rd edn 1972. Moths. New Naturalist No. 30 HarperCollins, London.
- Huxley, J.S. (1955). "Morphism and evolution". Heredity. 9: 1–52. doi:10.1038/hdy.1955.1.
- Majerus M.E.N. 2004. The Peppered moth: decline of a Darwinian disciple. Archived 24 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine (.doc download)
- Rudge, D.W. (2005). "Did Kettlewell commit fraud? Re-examining the evidence" (PDF). Public Understanding of Science. 14 (3): 249–268. doi:10.1177/0963662505052890. PMID 16240545.
- Young M. 2003. Moonshine: why the peppered moth remains an icon of evolution.
- Hooper, p. 42
- "Preface," in Heather and Gary Botting,The Orwellian World of Jehovah's Witnesses (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1984
- Tihemme Gagnon, "Introduction," Streaking! The Collected Poems of Gary Botting (Miami: Strategic, 2013
- see for instance the "stone coffin" stunt reported from independent sources in Hooper (page 80) and Clarke (page 168)
- Obituary Professor E.B. Ford--Theory and practice in genetics. The Times January 23, 1988
- Marren P. 1995. The New Naturalists. HarperCollins, London.