The Meadows, where the first Edinburgh derby was played.
Heart of Midlothian F.C.|
Hearts 1–0 Hibernian|
(25 December 1875)
Hearts 2–1 Hibernian|
2017–18 Scottish Premiership
(9 May 2018)
Tynecastle Park (Hearts)|
Easter Road (Hibernian)
Competitive matches: 318|
All matches: 643
Competitive matches: Hearts (140)|
All matches: Hearts (282)
Competitive matches: John Robertson, Hearts (27)|
All matches: Bobby Walker, Hearts (33)
The Edinburgh derby is an informal title given to any football match played between Scottish clubs Heart of Midlothian (Hearts) and Hibernian (Hibs), the two professional clubs based in Edinburgh, Scotland. The two clubs have a fierce rivalry that dates back to the clubs being founded in the mid-1870s, which makes it one of the longest running rivalries in world football. The first match between the clubs was played on the Meadows on Christmas Day 1875.
The matches are normally played at either Easter Road or Tynecastle. It has been regularly played in the top level of the Scottish football league system, although derbies were played in the second tier during the 2014–15 season. The teams sometimes also play against one another in cup tournaments, such as the Scottish Cup and Scottish League Cup. The clubs have met twice in Scottish Cup Finals, in 1896 and 2012, both of which were won by Hearts.
Hearts and Hibs were both formed during the mid-1870s. The first ever match between the clubs was played at East Meadows on 25 December 1875, with Hearts winning 1–0. Hibs won the first Scottish Cup tie between the clubs, in 1877–78. The matches that established the two clubs as the principal sides in Edinburgh was the five game struggle for the EFA Cup later that season, which Hearts won 3–2 after four previous attempts ended in draws. Hibs beat Hearts on the way to their first national trophy, the 1886–87 Scottish Cup. Hibs also had wins of 3–0, 5–2 and 7–1 against Hearts in other competitions.
Hibs had major financial problems and briefly ceased playing during the early 1890s. In the meantime, Hearts had become founder members of the Scottish Football League in 1890–91. Hibs soon resumed operations and Hearts won 10–2 in a friendly match at Easter Road which marked their return. Hibs joined the Scottish Football League in 1893–94 and were promoted to the First Division in 1895. The first league derby was played on 28 September 1895, Hearts winning 4–3 at Tynecastle.
The clubs contested the 1896 Scottish Cup Final, which Hearts won 3–1 at Logie Green in Edinburgh. It is the only time a Scottish Cup Final has been played outside Glasgow. The derby was played regularly in the league until 1930–31, when Hibs were relegated from Division One, although matches in other competitions continued. Hibs regained top division status in 1933–34, but all league football was suspended from 1939–40 to 1945–46 due to the Second World War.
The record crowd for an Edinburgh derby was 65,860 on 2 January 1950 when Hearts won 2–1 at Easter Road. This was also the biggest crowd for any Scottish game played outside Glasgow. The post-war period was a golden age for football in Edinburgh, as Hibs won three league championships with their Famous Five forward line, while Hearts won several major trophies in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
Hibs enjoyed a sustained period of success in the fixture in the late 1960s and most of the 1970s. Their record victory against Hearts, 7–0 at Tynecastle on 1 January 1973, was achieved during this period. Hibs then had their longest unbeaten streak in the fixture, 12 games from 1974 to 1978. Scottish league football was restructured from the 1975–76 season to create smaller divisions, resulting in the teams playing each other four times a season in the league, but it also increased the risk of the clubs being relegated. Hearts were a yo-yo club in the late 1970s and early 1980s, while Hibs were also relegated in 1979–80. This meant that there were few derbies until Hearts returned to the Premier Division in 1983–84.
Hearts then took the upper hand in the derby, setting the record for consecutive derbies without a loss, a 22-game streak straddling the 1980s and 1990s. During this period, Hearts owner Wallace Mercer attempted to force through a merger of the two clubs by acquiring a majority shareholding in Hibs. This effort failed after protest groups set up by Hibs fans persuaded some shareholders not to sell to Mercer and new investment in Hibs was provided by Tom Farmer.
The clubs met in a 2005–06 Scottish Cup semi-final, in the knowledge that victory would lead to a final against Gretna, who were a Second Division club. Hearts won the semi-final against Hibs by 4–0 and went on to win the competition on a penalty shootout in the final. Hibs gained some revenge by winning a 2006–07 Scottish League Cup quarter-final against Hearts 1–0, and went on to win the competition.
The two clubs met in the 2012 Scottish Cup Final. The match was played at Hampden Park in Glasgow, despite some fans proposing that it should be moved to Murrayfield Stadium, the largest venue in Edinburgh. Hearts won a one-sided final by 5–1, having also won all three league derbies in the 2011–12 Scottish Premier League. Hibs gained some revenge for this defeat six months later by knocking Hearts out of the 2012–13 Scottish Cup, winning 1–0 in a fourth round tie at Easter Road. It also ended a run of 12 games without a win for Hibs in the derby.
Both clubs were relegated to the second tier after finishing in the bottom two positions of the 2013–14 Scottish Premiership. This meant that the city of Edinburgh was left without representation in the top tier of the Scottish league system for the first time in its history. Hearts won the 2014–15 Scottish Championship and earned an immediate promotion back to the top tier. Hibs won promotion in 2016–17, which meant that top-flight league derbies were resumed in 2017–18. Meanwhile, the teams were drawn together in the Scottish Cup in three consecutive seasons: 2015–16, 2016–17 and 2017–18. Hibs won the first two ties after replays and went on to win the 2015–16 competition, while Hearts won the third tie.
Local competitions and other Edinburgh clubs
In the late 19th and early 20th century, the clubs often met each other ten times in a single season due to the plethora of local competitions, such as the East of Scotland Shield, Rosebery Charity Cup, Wilson Cup, and the Dunedin Cup. These competitions also involved the other clubs in Edinburgh and the surrounding area. Hearts and Hibs were the most frequent winners of these competitions. The East of Scotland Shield is the only one of the local competitions that is contested by Hearts and Hibs today, albeit by young reserve teams. The Shield is contested by a one-off match and gate takings are given to the Edinburgh Football Association.
St Bernard's, Leith Athletic, the original Edinburgh City and Meadowbank Thistle all represented the city of Edinburgh in the Scottish Football League. As Hibs did not enter the league until the 1893–94 season, the first league derby was actually played between Hearts and Leith Athletic on 24 October 1891 (Hearts winning 3–1). The first league derby between Hearts and Hibs was played at Tynecastle on 28 September 1895, with Hearts winning 4–3.
Edinburgh City and Spartans entered the Lowland Football League, which offers the possibility of promotion to the Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL), when it was formed in 2013. Edinburgh City gained promotion to the SPFL in 2016, but have not yet played either Hearts or Hibs in a SPFL match.
In 1985, an Edinburgh select team composing of players from Hearts, Hibs and Meadowbank Thistle played Bayern Munich in a "Festival Cup" challenge match at Tynecastle. The Festival Cup was reintroduced in 2003, to tie in with the annual Edinburgh Festival. The local media speculated that clubs from cities twinned with Edinburgh, including Bayern Munich and Dynamo Kiev, would be invited to participate in an annual Edinburgh tournament. Eventually, the clubs settled for playing a single derby match on the last Saturday before the start of the 2003–04 Scottish Premier League season. The SPL did not help the launch of the Festival Cup by scheduling a league derby match two weeks after the Festival Cup match, also at Easter Road. Hearts won the first Festival Cup match 1–0 with a goal by Andy Webster.
The clubs then had difficulty scheduling the 2004–05 match, partly due to the clubs arranging other friendly matches. The Festival Cup match was eventually played at Tynecastle on 4 September 2004. Both teams were well below full strength because several players were training with their national teams. Playing the game in September also meant that the game was played after the start of the 2004–05 Scottish Premier League season and after the end of the Festival. Hearts won the second and to date last Festival Cup match 3–1. The Hearts goals were scored by Craig Sives, Mark de Vries and Dennis Wyness, while Stephen Dobbie scored a penalty kick for Hibs. The match was not in played in 2005 as Hearts had a protracted search for a new head coach. It was not resurrected in 2006 and has not been contested since.
New Year derby
An Edinburgh derby match has traditionally been played at New Year, as both 1 January and 2 January are bank holidays in Scotland. The New Year derby match has sometimes not taken place in recent years, due to scheduling policy. Of the 94 Edinburgh derbies played at New Year, Hibs hold a slight lead of 32 wins to 30 wins by Hearts.
During the 1940 New Year's Day match, Easter Road was covered with a thick fog that would normally cause a football match to be abandoned. Due to the match being played during wartime, and it being broadcast widely by the BBC for the entertainment of soldiers stationed overseas, the War Office ordered play to go ahead to avoid alerting the Luftwaffe to the bad weather conditions. Commentator Bob Kingsley could not see the pitch either and had to improvise. Using a series of runners to tell him if there were any goals scored, he created his own version of the match. This was later described in The Scotsman as "Fawlty Towers ahead of itself" and created into a BBC Radio Four play by Scottish playwright, Andrew Dallmeyer.
Results and records
Hearts have the better record in derbies, with 140 wins to 84 wins by Hibs in 318 matches played in the three main Scottish competitions. There have been 643 Edinburgh derbies to date, meaning that about half of all derbies have been played in other competitions and friendlies. Including these other fixtures, Hearts have won 282 derbies and Hibs have won 204. During the 2017–18 season, Hearts manager Craig Levein claimed that Hearts winning was the "natural order" of the fixture.
Since the creation of the Scottish Premier Division in 1975 and the introduction of four league games between clubs in a Scottish season, neither club has managed to win all four league derbies in a season. Hearts have achieved three wins and a draw five times, in 1985–86, 1989–90, 1990–91, 1996–97 and 2006–07. Hibs' best record in a league season is also 3 wins and a draw, in 1975–76. Hearts won all three derbies in the 2011–12 Scottish Premier League, but a fourth league fixture was not possible as the clubs were not in the same section of the league after the split.
Scottish Cup results
League Cup results
Single game records
Hibs recorded the biggest margin of victory in a competitive match with a 7–0 victory at Tynecastle on 1 January 1973. The biggest win in other matches was a 10–2 Hearts victory in a friendly match on 12 August 1893. The largest number of goals scored in a competitive match was when Hearts won 8–3 in a league match on 21 September 1935. Hearts hold the record margin in the Scottish Cup with a 5–0 victory on 1 February 1955, and the record margin in the Scottish League Cup with a 6–1 victory on 11 August 1956.
John Robertson scored 27 goals against Hibs in competitive games. Robertson was nicknamed "The Hammer of Hibs" due to his prolific goal record in derbies. Both Bobby Walker (33) and Tommy Walker (29) scored more goals in derbies than Robertson, when games in local competitions are considered.
Gordon Smith is the top goalscorer in Edinburgh derbies for Hibs, with 15 goals. Smith played for Hearts and Dundee later in his career and became the only player to have won the Scottish league championship with three different clubs. James McGhee scored at least 24 goals for Hibs in the early years of the fixture. The real figure is probably higher as he played in a lot of games where only the result is known and not all the scorers were recorded.
Barney Battles, Jr. scored 11 goals in less than a month versus Hibs in 1929; five in the 8–2 Dunedin Cup final victory on 17 April 1929, two in the 5–1 Wilson Cup Final victory on 30 April 1929 and four in the 5–1 Rosebery Charity Cup Final victory on 11 May 1929.
Players with both clubs
This is a list of players who played at least one competitive first team fixture for both clubs. Only four players have scored for both Hearts and Hibs in Edinburgh derbies – Ralph Callachan, Alan Gordon, Darren Jackson and Gordon Smith.
|Name||Period at Hibs||Period at Hearts||Notes|
|Thomson Allan||1963–1971||1979–1980||Allan was selected by Scotland for the 1974 FIFA World Cup while he was with Dundee.|
|Bobby Atherton||1897–1903||1897||Atherton captained Hibs when they won the 1901–02 Scottish Cup.|
|Bannon was selected by Scotland for the 1986 FIFA World Cup while he was with Dundee United.|
|Ralph Callachan||1978–1986||1971–1977||Callachan represented both Hearts and Hibs in Scottish Cup Finals, 1976 with Hearts and 1979 with Hibs. Both finals were lost by the Edinburgh club.|
|Gordon Durie||1984–1986||2000–2001||Durie was selected by Scotland for the 1990 FIFA World Cup while he was with Chelsea and the 1998 FIFA World Cup while he was with Rangers.|
|Gordon, who scored twice in Hibs' 7–0 win at Tynecastle against Hearts, also played for both sides in the Dundee derby.|
|Paul Hartley||1998–2000||2003–2007||Hartley scored a hat-trick for Hearts against Hibs in the 2005–06 Scottish Cup semi-final.|
|Darren Jackson||1992–1997||1999–2001||Jackson was selected by Scotland for the 1998 FIFA World Cup while he was with Celtic.|
|Hugh Shaw||1918–1926||1927–1930||Shaw managed the Hibs side that won three league championships in the late 1940s and early 1950s.|
|Gordon Smith||1941–1959||1959–1961||One of Hibs' Famous Five, Smith won the Scottish League with three different clubs, none of which were either half of the Old Firm.|
|Robert Walls||early 1930s||late 1920s|
|Andy Watson||1987–1989||1983–1987||Watson later became assistant manager of Hibs while Alex McLeish was manager.|
|Willie Waugh||1936||1928–1939||Waugh was loaned to Hibs by Hearts.|
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 4 May 2008. Retrieved 3 June 2008.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 13 February 2008. Retrieved 24 January 2008.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 4 May 2008. Retrieved 15 October 2007.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 1 April 2007. Retrieved 10 March 2007.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 6 March 2007. Retrieved 10 March 2007.
- "Sat 28 Sep 1895 Division 1 Hearts 4 Hibernian 3". www.londonhearts.com. Retrieved 3 August 2012.
- Halliday, Stephen (31 March 2006). "Logie Green: the final Edinburgh didn't want". The Scotsman. Johnston Press. Retrieved 2 August 2012.
- "Hearts heading for a home record". BBC Sport. BBC. 27 July 2007. Retrieved 4 August 2012.
- Murray, Scott (3 May 2001). "Merger memories". guardian.co.uk. Guardian News and Media Limited. Retrieved 3 August 2012.
- "Farmer content with Hibs backseat". BBC Sport. BBC. 26 October 2006. Retrieved 3 August 2012.
- "Capital stars relish prospect of Scottish Cup final". BBC Sport. BBC. 16 April 2012. Retrieved 16 April 2012.
- "Fans at fever pitch for cup showdown". The Scotsman. Johnston Publishing. Retrieved 16 April 2012.
- Moffat, Colin (2 December 2012). "Hibernian 1–0 Hearts". BBC Sport. BBC. Retrieved 2 December 2012.
- Magowan, Alistair (26 May 2014). "Scottish Championship 'will be more exciting than Premiership'". BBC Sport. BBC. Retrieved 26 May 2014.
- "Scottish Cup: Hearts to host Hibernian in fifth round". BBC Sport. BBC. 11 January 2016. Retrieved 26 May 2016.
- "Scottish Cup fifth-round draw: Holders Hibs could face Hearts in cup". BBC Sport. BBC. 22 January 2017. Retrieved 25 January 2017.
- "Scottish Cup: Derbies in fourth round, Celtic v Brechin, Fraserburgh v Rangers". BBC Sport. BBC. 20 November 2017. Retrieved 21 November 2017.
- "Hibernian 1–0 Hearts: Jason Cummings settles stormy Scottish Cup replay". Sky Sports. 17 February 2016. Retrieved 26 May 2016.
- Wilson, Richard (22 February 2017). "Hibernian 3–1 Heart of Midlothian". BBC Sport. BBC. Retrieved 22 February 2017.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 27 May 2007.
- "Celtic beat Forfar to maintain pressure on Glasgow City". BBC Sport. BBC. 2 September 2012. Retrieved 2 September 2012.
Hibs stay in third on goal difference after their 4–0 defeat of Spartans in the Edinburgh derby.
- McLauchlin, Brian (14 May 2016). "East Stirlingshire 0–1 Edinburgh City". BBC Sport. BBC. Retrieved 28 May 2016.
- "Smith penalty save keeps the Festival Cup in Edinburgh". The Herald. Herald & Times Group. 14 August 1985. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Cup dream has sadly runneth dry". sport.scotsman.com. Johnston Publishing. 2 September 2004. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Festival cup for capital". sport.scotsman.com. Johnston Publishing. 27 March 2003. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Hearts' festival party". sport.scotsman.com. Johnston Publishing. 3 August 2003. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Festival Cup set to flop". BBC Sport. BBC. 28 July 2003. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Hearts win Festival Cup". BBC Sport. BBC. 4 September 2004. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Festival Cup doomed by pre-season squeeze". sport.scotsman.com. Johnston Publishing. 3 August 2006. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- McInnes, Andy (15 June 2007). "HEARTS AND HIBS FANS ANGRY OVER NE'ERDAY DERBY". Scottish Daily Express. Northern and Shell Media Publications. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Hearts Hibs New Year Derbies". www.londonhearts.com. London Hearts Supporters' club. Retrieved 3 January 2014.
- Murray, Scott (30 December 2011). "The Joy of Six: new year football fixtures". The Guardian. Retrieved 24 February 2015.
- McBurnie, John (1 January 2014). "Classic match: Hibs v Hearts, New Year's Day 1940". The Scotsman. Retrieved 24 February 2015.
- "Hearts vs. Hibernian Head To Head Stats". Soccerbase. Retrieved 21 January 2018.
- "Hibernian". www.londonhearts.com. Retrieved 21 January 2018.
- "Hibernian 2-0 Hearts: Neil Lennon - 'If that means natural order, I'll take it'". BBC Sport. BBC. 9 March 2018. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
- Campbell, Andy (18 March 2012). "Hearts 2–0 Hibernian". BBC Sport. BBC. Retrieved 18 March 2012.
- "Hearts vs Hibs by era". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 30 September 2007. Retrieved 10 March 2007.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 19 July 2008. Retrieved 23 January 2009.
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 4 September 2008. Retrieved 23 January 2009.
- "Thomson Allan – Hearts Career – from 24 Feb 1979 to 19 Sep 1979". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Eamonn Bannon – Hearts Career – from 09 Oct 1976 to 14 Dec 1994". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Roy Barry – Hearts Career – from 12 Aug 1961 to 26 Sep 1966". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Ian Black – Hearts Career – from 07 Jul 2009 to 13 Nov 2010". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Jim Brown – Hearts Career – from 04 Jan 1969 to 14 May 1979". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Ralph Callachan – Hearts Career – from 13 Apr 1974 to 05 Feb 1977". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Ian Crawford – Hearts Career – from 15 Sep 1954 to 29 Mar 1961". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Gordon Durie – Hearts Career – from 01 Oct 2000 to 22 Apr 2001". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Peter Flucker – Hearts Career – from 02 Nov 1929 to 12 Apr 1930". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Alan Gordon – Hearts Career – from 21 Oct 1961 to 14 Apr 1969". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Brian Hamilton – Hearts Career – from 08 Jan 1995 to 16 Dec 1995". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Willie Hamilton – Hearts Career – from 01 Sep 1962 to 22 Feb 1969". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Paul Hartley – Hearts Career – from 16 Jul 2003 to 20 Jan 2007". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Darren Jackson – Hearts Career – from 03 Apr 1999 to 22 Oct 2000". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Willie Jamieson – Hearts Career – from 03 Dec 1994 to 11 Nov 1995". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Hibernian: James Keatings and Fraser Fyvie sign two-year deals". BBC Sport. BBC. 1 June 2015. Retrieved 1 June 2015.
- "Peter Kerr – Hearts Career – from 07 May 1924 to 12 Oct 1929". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Davie Laing – Hearts Career – from 16 Nov 1946 to 04 Sep 1954". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Peter Marinello – Hearts Career – from 31 Oct 1981 to 19 Mar 1983". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "HIBERNIAN : 1946/47 – 2011/12". www.neilbrown.newcastlefans.com. Retrieved 22 September 2012.
- "Gordon Marshall – Hearts Career – from 19 Sep 1956 to 11 May 1963". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Maybury Joins Hibernian". www.hibernianfc.co.uk. Hibernian FC. 10 August 2012. Retrieved 10 August 2012.
- Parks, Gordon (30 June 2013). "New Hibs signing Fraser Mullen has no problem pulling on a green and white shirt despite breaking his ankle at Easter Road". Sunday Mail. Trinity Mirror. Retrieved 30 June 2013.
- "Willie Reid". National Football Teams. Benjamin Strack-Zimmerman.
- "Harry Rennie – Hearts Career – from 15 Aug 1898 to 07 May 1900". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Hibernian: Former Hearts defender Faycal Rherras signs on loan". BBC Sport. BBC. 20 January 2018. Retrieved 20 January 2018.
- "Malcolm Robertson – Hearts Career – from 19 Mar 1977 to 25 Oct 1980". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Chris Shevlane – Hearts Career – from 27 Apr 1962 to 08 Apr 1967". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Gordon Smith (1) – Hearts Career – from 22 Aug 1959 to 08 Apr 1961". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Jim Souness – Hearts Career – from 17 Jan 1953 to 24 Sep 1955". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Michael Stewart – Hearts Career – from 31 Jul 2004 to 24 Apr 2010". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Lawrie Tierney – Hearts Career – from 03 Aug 1977 to 13 Oct 1979". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Robert Walls – Hearts Career – from 01 Dec 1928 to 29 Dec 1928". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Andy Watson – Hearts Career – from 29 Dec 1984 to 03 Aug 1987". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- "Willie Waugh – Hearts Career – from 07 Nov 1936 to 02 Aug 1941". Londonhearts.com. Retrieved 2011-01-10.
- A tale of one city: Edinburgh – These Football Times (2015)