Electronic body music
|Electronic body music|
|Other names||Industrial dance, Aggrepo|
|Cultural origins||Early 1980s, Western Europe (Germany, Belgium, Netherlands)|
Electronic body music (acronymized to EBM) is a genre of electronic music that developed in the early 1980s in Western Europe as an outgrowth of both punk and industrial music cultures. It combines sequenced repetitive basslines, programmed dance music rhythms, and mostly undistorted vocals and commandlike shouts with confrontational or provocative themes.
The evolution of the genre reflected "a general shift towards more song-oriented structures in industrial as to a general turn towards the dancefloor by many musicians and genres in the era of post-punk." It was considered a part of the European new wave and post-punk movement and the first style that blended synthesized sounds with an ecstatic style of dancing (e.g. pogo).
EBM gained a stable following in the second half of the 1980s. Around that period, a youth-cultural scene emerged from EBM whose followers describe themselves as EBM-heads or (in North America) as rivetheads.
The term electronic body music was first used by Ralf Hütter of the German electronic band Kraftwerk in an interview with British music newspaper Sounds in November 1977. In June 1978 Hütter reused the phrase in an interview with WSKU radio (Kent, Ohio) to explain the more physical character of the Kraftwerk album The Man-Machine. Although the term originated in the late 1970s, it was not until the 1980s when it reappeared and started to come into popular use.
EBM stands for 'electronic body music', a term which only really came into use when the Brits and Belgians stepped into the 'sequencer business' with bands like Nitzer Ebb and Front 242. There you could find that sound again, where it was catchily picked up and labelled. In our days all these terms didn't exist, not 'industrial' nor 'post-punk'. [...] To us it was sequencer music, that was what we did.— Jurgen Engler of Die Krupps
In 1981, DAF from Germany employed the term "Körpermusik" (body music) to describe their danceable electronic punk sound. The term was later used by Belgian band Front 242 in 1984 to describe the music of their EP of that year called No Comment.
Described as an outgrowth of "electronically generated punk [music] intertwined with industrial sounds," EBM has been characterized as a composite of programmed drum beats, repetitive basslines, and clear or slightly distorted vocals, instructional shouts or growls complemented with reverberation and echo effects. Typical EBM rhythms rely on the 4/4 beat of disco or rock-oriented backbeats, (featuring kick drum, snare and hi-hat) and some minor syncopation.
Environmental samples, e.g. hammer blow, machine and alert sounds, are often used to create a "factory ambiance". Other samples include political speeches and excerpts from science fiction movies, cf. Front 242 – Funkahdafi.
EBM evolved from a combination of post-punk, industrial and post-industrial music sources, including The Normal, Suicide, DAF, Die Krupps, Killing Joke, Cabaret Voltaire, Throbbing Gristle and Test Dept. but also krautrock and Berlin school artists such as Kraftwerk and Tangerine Dream (who had used electronic bass sequences as a basic feature in their productions).
The song “Warm Leatherette” (The Normal, 1978) stands at the beginning of an important development, the electrified version of Punk that had been picked up and transformed in Düsseldorf by bands like Die Krupps, DAF and Liaisons Dangereuses, music that might be called proto-EBM at least. […] The role of sequencers, synthesizer and drum machine sounds for the creative process itself and its results are another interesting point concerning EBM. The use of these instruments contributed obviously to the formation of danceable grooves and sound textures that attracted a wider audience.— Timor Kaul, German musicologist and cultural historian
Other influences include the synth-pop music of The Human League and Fad Gadget; and the krautrock-inspired dance hit “I Feel Love” by Giorgio Moroder and Donna Summer. Daniel Bressanutti (Front 242), who helped establish the term EBM, named the soundscapes of Tangerine Dream and Klaus Schulze as additional influences along Kraftwerk, Throbbing Gristle, the sequencer-based Eurodisco of Giorgio Moroder, and the punk movement.
Emerging in the early 1980s in Germany and Belgium, bands such as DAF, Die Krupps, Liaisons Dangereuses, and Front 242 started to blend danceable rhythms and repetitive sequencer lines. At the time the genre arose, style-defining synthesizers included Korg MS-20, Roland SH-101, ARP Odyssey, Emulator II, along with several Oberheim and Yamaha models.
Archetypical songs are Verschwende deine Jugend, Alle gegen alle and Der Mussolini by DAF; Wahre Arbeit, wahrer Lohn, Goldfinger and Für einen Augenblick by Die Krupps; Etre assis ou danser, Los niños del parque and Avant-après mars by Liaisons Dangereuses, and Body to Body, U-Men and He Runs Too Fast for Us by Front 242.
Front 242 characterized their approach as somewhere between Throbbing Gristle and Kraftwerk. Nitzer Ebb and Portion Control, influenced by DAF and Cabaret Voltaire, followed soon after. Groups from this era often applied socialist realist aesthetics, with ironic intent. Other prominent artists were Pankow, Vomito Negro, Borghesia, The Neon Judgement, à;GRUMH..., A Split-Second, The Klinik, and Signal Aout 42.
In the second half of the 1980s, the genre became popular in Canada (Front Line Assembly) and the U.S. (Ministry, Revolting Cocks, Schnitt Acht) as well as in Sweden (Inside Treatment, Pouppée Fabrikk, Cat Rapes Dog) and Japan (2nd Communication, DRP). North American bands started to use EBM-typical bass sequences and combined them with the roughness of (hardcore) punk and thrash metal (cf. industrial metal). Nine Inch Nails continued the cross-pollination between EBM and rock music resulting in the album Pretty Hate Machine (1989).
Meanwhile, EBM became successful in the underground club scene, particularly in Europe. In this period the most important labels were the Belgian Play It Again Sam and Antler-Subway, the German Zoth Ommog, the North American Wax Trax! and the Swedish Energy Rekords. Notable acts at that time included And One, Armageddon Dildos, Bigod 20, Insekt, Scapa Flow, Orange Sector, Paranoid, and Electro Assassin.
Between the early and mid-1990s, many EBM artists ceased activities or changed their musical direction, incorporating more elements of rock, heavy metal and electronica. The album 06:21:03:11 Up Evil by Front 242 initiated the end of the EBM era of the 1980s. Nitzer Ebb, one of the most important purveyors of the genre, turned into an alternative rock band. Without the strength of its figureheads, electronic body music as a discernable music style faded by the mid-1990s.
In the late 1990s and after the millennium, Belgian, Swedish and German artists such as Ionic Vision, Tyske Ludder, and Spetsnaz had reactivated the style. Based on this revival, Sweden and East Germany then became the centre of the movement spawning a variety of newcomers such as Dupont, Proceed, and Sequenz-E. Primarily as a counteracting force against the expanding futurepop scene, these artists followed a neo-traditionalistic path, often referred to as "old school EBM".
Simultaneously, a number of European techno producers started incorporating elements of EBM into their sound. This tendency grew in parallel with the emerging electroclash scene and, as that scene started to decline, artists partly associated with it, such as The Hacker, DJ Hell, Green Velvet, Black Strobe, and David Carretta, moved towards this techno/EBM crossover style.
There has been increasing convergence between this scene and the old school EBM scene. Some artists have remixed each other. Most notably, Terence Fixmer joined with Nitzer Ebb's Douglas McCarthy to form Fixmer/McCarthy.
EBM follows the transgressive approach of punk and industrial music (e.g. "demystification of symbols") and the use of provocative extreme imagery is common (e.g. Nazi paraphernalia; reminiscent of punk's use of the swastika). Appropriating totalitarian, Socialist and Fascist references, symbols, and signifiers has been a recurring topic of debate between fans and outsiders to the genre alike due to its stylistical ambiguity that stems from industrial music's contrarian nature. In one instance, military-themed band Laibach "ma[de] no attempt to subvert this image [so] it has the aura of authenticity" so "[m]any Laibach fans began to revel in the evils of the band and to take their stage act at face value."
Bon and Doug were heavily influenced by DAF, Test Dept. and Einstürzende Neubauten. Hand in hand with the music was the image which unashamedly borrowed a lot from German and Soviet imagery. We all loved the sharp and striking design images of Russian and German '30s and '40s posters and artwork. Obviously we faced a lot of questions and objections about the ‚Neo-Nazi‘ image. But really we were just using the images to get people to sit up and listen. ‚Iconoclastic minimalism‘ was one phrase that was used to describe Nitzer Ebb at the time.— Chris Piper, manager of Nitzer Ebb
The military style of EBM has a "part-human part-machine" gestalt typical of transhumanist or cyberpunk movements. EBM asserts a hyper-masculine image of "triumphalism, combat postures, and paranoia," and is known for its "tough-guy" or machismo attitudes displayed by both men and women. According to Gabi Delgado-López of Deutsch Amerikanische Freundschaft, the duo who adopted an aesthetic of black leather and military paraphernalia in the early 1980s was inspired by the male homosexual sado-masochistic scene and is not meant to represent "machismo ideology" but part of a "role."
Derivatives and alternative terms
Electro-industrial is an outgrowth of the EBM and industrial music that developed in the mid-1980s. While EBM has minimal structures and a clean production, electro-industrial draws on deep, complex and layered sounds, incorporating elements of ambient industrial. Electro-industrial was pioneered by Skinny Puppy, Numb and Mentallo & The Fixer. In the early 1990s, the style spawned the dark electro genre and, in the end of the decade, a strongly techno- and hard-trance-inspired style called "hellektro" or "aggrotech."
Since the mid-1980s, the term industrial dance has been used to describe the music of Cabaret Voltaire (early 1980s), early Die Krupps, Portion Control, The Neon Judgement, Clock DVA, Nitzer Ebb, KMFDM, Skinny Puppy, Front Line Assembly, Front 242, Ministry, Nine Inch Nails, Manufacture, Yeht Mae, My Life with the Thrill Kill Kult, Leæther Strip or early Spahn Ranch. In March 1989, Spin Magazine presented a two-paged special report about the industrial dance movement in Canada and the U.S.
- Sicko, Dan (2010). Techno Rebels: The Renegades of Electronic Funk. Wayne State University. ISBN 9780814337127. Retrieved 10 August 2020.
- Various Artists: Liner-Notes of the compilation ‚Music from Belgium‘. Techno Drome International/ZYX Records, 1988.
"This record will show you the roots of Belgian electronic music. Young musicians who don’t want to ride on the New Beat wave. They want to do 100% Aggrepo for your body mechanic!"
- Nancy Kilpatrick. The Goth Bible: A Compendium for the Darkly Inclined. New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 2004, ISBN 0-312-30696-2.
- Hillegonda C Rietveld (1998) This Is Our House: House Music, Cultural Spaces and Technologies Aldershot: Ashgate. ISBN 978-1-85742-242-9
- Keunen, Gert (2002). Pop!: een halve eeuw beweging. Lannoo Uitgeverij, ISBN 9789020948714, p. 206. Quote: "[W]as de zogenaamde electronic body music, een Belgische postpunkvariant[.]"
- B, Daniel (24 May 2012). "A Beginner's Guide to EBM". FACT. Retrieved 11 May 2019.
- Ulrich Adelt: Krautrock. German Music in the Seventies. University of Michigan Press, 2016, ISBN 0-472-05319-1, p. 181.
- Horn, David (2017). Bloomsbury Encyclopedia of Popular Music of the World, Volume 11. Bloomsbury. ISBN 9781501326103.
- Albiez, Sean (2017). "Electronic Body Music". In Horn, David; Shepherd, John; Prato, Paolo (eds.). Bloomsbury Encyclopedia of Popular Music of the World, Volume 11. Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 222–223. ISBN 9781501326103.
- Eva Fischer: Audio-visuelle Tendenzen. Entwicklungen in der Visualisierung elektronischer Musik und in der Clubkultur. Universität Wien, 2009, p. 18.
- Timor Kaul: Some Thoughts on EBM as a transitional genre., Academia.edu, 2016, p. 1.
- Timor Kaul: Electronic Body Music. In: Thomas Hecken, Marcus S. Kleiner: Handbook Popculture. J.B. Metzler Verlag 2017, ISBN 3-476-02677-9, p. 102–104.
- Renaat Vandepapeliere: R & S Records Belgium, Localizer 1.0, Die Gestalten Verlag 1995, ISBN 3-931-12600-5
- Dan Sicko, Techno Rebels: The Renegades of Electronic Funk, Billboard Books, 1999, p. 142.
- Martin Pesch, Markus Weisbeck: History of Techno and House music. In: Techno Style. Musik, Grafik, Mode und Partykultur der Techno-Bewegung. Edition Olms, Hombrechtikon / Zürich 1996, ISBN 3-283-00290-8, p. 11.
"1986/87: New bands like Nitzer Ebb, The Klinik and Vomito Negro appear on the scene and gain a large audience of mainly young males."
- Kate Stevens: Freak Nation. A Field Guide to 101 of the Most Odd, Extreme, and Outrageous American Subcultures, Adams Media, 2010, ISBN 1-440-50646-9, p. 108.
- "Kraftwerk and 'The Cold Wave' in Sounds 26.11.77".
- (2007-11-25) Klein, MJ WSKU Radio (Kent - Ohio) - Ralf Hütter - 19/06/1978 Archived 2008-03-10 at the Wayback Machine kraftwerk.technopop.com.br (retrieved on 2008-01-28)
- Esch, Rudi (2016). Electri_City: The Düsseldorf School of Electronic Music. Omnibus Press. ISBN 9781783237760. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- "YouTube". www.youtube.com. Archived from the original on 2015-06-21. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- Uncle Dave Lewis. D.A.F. bio at AllMusic. Retrieved October 7, 2008.
- "Front 242 – No Comment (1984, Vinyl) - Discogs". Discogs.
- (2004-06-20) Monsoon, Jon EBM - A revolution in progress Archived 2004-07-21 at the Wayback Machine iAfrica.com (retrieved on 2007-08-03)
- Ernie Rideout, interview with Front 242, Keyboard Presents the Best of the '80s, Backbeat, 2008, p. 57.
- Oerter, Rolf (2005). Spezielle Musikpsychologie. Hogrefe Publishing Group. ISBN 9783801705817, p. 443. Quote: "Punk mit elektronischen Elementen und industriellen Gerauschen gemischt -, die sich Mitte der 80er Jahre insbesondere in den Benelux-Ländern zur Electronic Body Music (EBM) erweiterte (zu den bekannten Gruppen zählen Front 242 und Nitzer Ebb)"
- Judith Platz: Electronic Body Music (EBM). In: Axel Schmidt, Klaus Neumann-Braun: Die Welt der Gothics. Spielräume düster konnotierter Transzendenz. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, Dezember 2004, ISBN 3-531-14353-0, p. 271.
"Am ehesten lässt sich der Vokaleinsatz als Sprechgesang bezeichnen: Die Worte und Textzeilen werden deutlich gesprochen oder geschrien. Neben der tiefen, männlichen Hauptstimme, die meist trotz möglicher Echo-Effekte oder leichter Verzerrung gut verständlich ist, kommt oft noch ein so genannter ‚Shouter‘ zum Einsatz."
- S. Alexander Reed: Assimilate. A Critical History of Industrial Music. Oxford University Press, Oxford 2013, ISBN 978-0-19-983260-6, p. 165.
"Rhythmically, EBM is based around an incessant quarter-note kick drum pattern, often with a backbeat snare. Drum machine hi-hats fill in the rhythmic gaps, but percussive ornamentation varies from artist to artist. […] Drum sounds were often samples of drums, car crashes, door slamming or environmental percussion."
- Nike Breyer: Görl meets Beuys, TAZ, November 2003.
- Kaul, Timor (2016). Some Thoughts on EBM as a transitional genre. Academia.edu. p. 2.
- Ulrich Adelt: Krautrock. German Music in the Seventies. University of Michigan Press, 2016, ISBN 0-472-05319-1, p. 135.
"Moroder first experimented with krautrock-oriented synthesizer sounds on his solo album ‚Einzelgänger‘ (1975), an artistic and commercial failure. It is remarkable that he not only felt the necessity to experiment with synthesizer sounds reminiscent of Berlin School artists like Tangerine Dream and Klaus Schulze but that these experiments would help him to develop a unique German Disco sound with Summer’s 1977 hit ‚I Feel Love‘."
- Reynolds, Simon (1991). "Disturbing Sounds to Unruffle the New Age". The New York Times. Retrieved 29 July 2018.
- Judith Platz: Electronic Body Music (EBM). In: Axel Schmidt, Klaus Neumann-Braun: Die Welt der Gothics. Spielräume düster konnotierter Transzendenz. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, Dezember 2004, ISBN 3-531-14353-0, p. 270.
"Seinen Ursprung hat das Genre Anfang der 1980er-Jahre in Deutschland und Belgien."
- Release Magazine: Die Krupps - Too Much History
- Esch, Rudi (2015). Electri_City: The Düsseldorf School of Electronic Music. Suhrkamp. pp. 275–347. ISBN 9783518464649.
- S. Alexander Reed: Assimilate. A Critical History of Industrial Music. Oxford University Press, Oxford 2013, ISBN 978-0-19-983260-6, p. 153.
- Raggett, Ned. That Total Age review at AllMusic. Retrieved October 7, 2008.
- Raggett, Ned. Die Kleinen und die Bösen review at AllMusic. Retrieved October 7, 2008.
- Andi Harriman: Italian EBM progenitors Pankow, August 23, 2017.
- Huey, Steve. Neon Judgement: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Huey, Steve. à;GRUMH: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Huey, Steve. A Split Second: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- "Signal-Aout 42". Discogs. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- Ankeny, Jason. Front Line Assembly: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- "... this album probably owes more to Front 242 than anything." Esher, Alan. Twitch review at AllMusic. Retrieved March 11, 2009.
- Jeffries, David. Revolting Cocks: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Henderson, Alex. Subhuman Minds: Overview at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Huey, Steve. Nine Inch Nails: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Ankeny, Jason. And One: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- McDonald, Steven. Homicidal Dolls: Overview at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Bush, John. Bigod 20: Biography at AllMusic. Retrieved May 19, 2010.
- Insekt. Retrieved 15 December 2014.
- "Scapa Flow". Discogs. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- "Orange Sector". Discogs. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- "Paranoid". Discogs. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- "Electro ssassin". Discogs. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
- Shuker, Roy (2017). "Gothic Rock". In Horn, David; Shepherd, John; Prato, Paolo (eds.). Bloomsbury Encyclopedia of Popular Music of the World, Volume 11. Bloomsbury. p. 341. ISBN 9781501326103.
- Daniela Vorndran: Spetsnaz, Reflections of Darkness: A Dark Music webzine, March 6, 2006.
- Theakston, Rob (2002-11-26). "Electronicbody-Housemusic > Overview". allmusic. Retrieved 2010-05-19.
- Kellman, Andy (2004-06-01). "Chemical Sweet Girl > Overview". allmusic. Retrieved 2010-05-19.
- "Music | CD Reviews". Gothtronic. Retrieved 2010-05-19.
- Bennett A, Guerra P (2018). DIY Cultures and Underground Music Scenes, Routledge, ISBN 9781351850322. Quote: "[T]he dark symbolism of industrial music, the typically crude appearance associated with the punk era and, above all, underground collages and drawings oriented towards alternative contemporary art. While very particular aesthetic principles may be shared in some extreme subgenres such as power electronics or old-school noise, following the path of industrial music and its demystification of symbols (Obodda, 2002), the aesthetic judgements embraced by labels and listeners often demonstrate the rejection of imagery that is considered unoriginal."
- Kingsepp, Eva (2011). "Nazi Symbolism in Black Metal/National Socialist Black Metal," Stockholm University, Faculty of Humanities, Department of Journalism, Media and Communication (JMK). (English). urn:nbn:se:su:diva-68780
- Rammstein on Fire: New Perspectives on the Music and Performances edited by John T. Littlejohn and Michael T. Putnam ISBN 978-0-7864-7463-9 (2013, McFarland
- Timor Kaul: Some Thoughts on EBM as a transitional genre., Academia.edu, 2016, p. 4.
- Reed, S. Alexander (2013). Assimilate: A Critical History of Industrial Music. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199832606. OCLC 1147729910 – via the Internet Archive.. Principal quote: "Regarding the emergence of the dance-driven EBM from the industrial scene, a;GRUMPH...'s Jacques Meurrens says, "In , the people who liked industrial and the people who liked EBM were mostly the same crowd," but even by the time, audiences were starting to form subgenre-based expectations."
- Albinsson, Stefan (2008). Interview with Chris Piper. Nitzer Ebb Network New Jersey / USA.
- Reynolds, Simon (1990). Blissed Out: The Raptures of Rock. Serpent's Tail. ISBN 1-85242-199-1.
- Martina O, Ernst W (2008). Performativität und Performance: Geschlecht in Musik, Theater und MedienKunst, LIT Verlag Münster, ISBN 9783825806606, p. 124.
- Attias, Bernardo; Anna Gavanas; Hillegonda Rietveld (2013). DJ Culture in the Mix: Power, Technology, and Social Change in Electronic Dance Music. A&C Black. p. 286. ISBN 978-1-62356-437-7. Retrieved August 6, 2020.
- Marras, Amerigo (1999). ECO-TEC: Architecture of the In-Between -. Princeton Architectural Press. pp. 54. ISBN 1568981597.
- Tony Fletcher: Let's Go - Lollapalooza '93, SPIN magazine, July 1993, p. 44.
- Gail Priest (2009). Experimental Music: Audio Explorations in Australia. University of New South Wales Press. p. 48. ISBN 978-1-921410-07-9.
- Holly George-Warren / Patricia Romanowski / Jon Pareles: The Rolling Stone Encyclopedia of Rock & Roll, Fireside, 2001, ISBN 0-7432-0120-5, p. 140.
- Knowles, Christopher (2010). The Secret History of Rock 'n' Roll. Viva Editions. p. 236. ISBN 9781573444057 – via the Internet Archive.
- David Nobahkt: Suicide: No Compromise SAF Publishing Ltd., 2004, ISBN 0-946719-71-3, p. 166.
- The Wire, Volume 269-274, C. Parker, 2006, p. 32.
- Rudy von Bitter Rucker / R. U. Sirius / Queen Mu: Mondo 2000: A User's Guide to the New Edge, HarperPerennial, 1992, ISBN 0-06-096928-8
- Tony Fletcher (February 1992). "Hard-boiled Ebb – Interview with Nitzer Ebb". Spin. pp. 16–17. Retrieved October 24, 2017.
- Christian Zingales: Electronica Giunti Gruppo Editoriale, 2002, ISBN 88-09-02523-7, p. 59.
- Eddy, Chuck (July 1992). "KMFDM, Money, Wax Trax!". Spins. Spin Magazine. Vol. 8, no. 4. p. 71. Retrieved August 21, 2018 – via Google Books.
- Amy Sciarretto: Wax Trax! / TVT Offers KMFDM's Final Statement with „Adios“, CMJ New Music Report, 5. April 1999, p. 1.
- Amy Sciarretto: Review of the album „MDFMK“ by MDFMK, CMJ New Music Report, 14. February 2000, p. 22
- David Jarman: Review of the album „Flavour of the Weak“ by Front Line Assembly, CMJ New Music Monthly, April 1998, p. 50.
- David Jarman: Review of the album „Implode“ by Front Line Assembly, CMJ New Music Monthly, August 1999, p. 44.
- Vladimir Bogdanov / Chris Woodstra / Stephen Thomas Erlewine: All Music Guide to Electronica: The Definitive Guide to Electronic Music, Backbeat Books, 2001, ISBN 0-87930-628-9, p. 198.
- Macdonald - Heidi (May 1998). "Front 242 - Mut@ge.Mix@ge". CMJ (57). ISSN 1074-6978.
- Jim DeRogatis (2003). Milk it!: Collected Musings on the Alternative Music Explosion of the 90s. Da Capo Press. p. 95. ISBN 0-306-81271-1.
Big Black's relentless noise guitars, jackhammer rhythms and lyrical tales of America's underbelly continue to inspire cutting-edge bands such as Helmet, Tar and, the Jesus Lizard", as well as industrial dance groups such as Nine Inch Nails and Ministry.
- Eddy, Chuck (June 1998). "Metal Machine Music". Spin Magazine. Vol. 14, no. 6. p. 139. ISSN 0886-3032.
- Taylor, Steve (2006). The A to X of Alternative Music. Continuum International Publishing Group. p. 165. ISBN 0826482171.
- Leland, John (March 1989). "A Dilettante's Guide to Industrial Dance Music". Singles. Spin Magazine. Vol. 4, no. 12. p. 78. Retrieved August 21, 2018 – via Google Books.
- Jacks, Kelso (November 1999). "Recordnews". CMJ. Vol. 60, no. 643. p. 10. ISSN 0890-0795.
- Industrial Dance : Significant Albums, Artists and Songs, Most Viewed : AllMusic
- David Jarman: Review of the album „Beat Noir“ by Spahn Ranch, CMJ New Music Monthly, January 1999, p. 51.