Erhard Seminars Training
|Type||Privately-held corporation (defunct)|
|Headquarters||San Francisco, California, United States|
|Werner Erhard, founder|
Erhard Seminars Training (marketed as est, though often encountered as EST or Est) was an organization, founded by Werner Erhard in 1971, that offered a two-weekend (6-day, 60-hour) course known officially as "The est Standard Training". The seminar aimed to "transform one's ability to experience living so that the situations one had been trying to change or had been putting up with clear up just in the process of life itself". An est website claims that the training "brought to the forefront the ideas of transformation, personal responsibility, accountability, and possibility".
Est seminars operated from late 1971 to late 1984, and spawned a number of books from 1976 to 2011. Est has been featured in a number of films and television shows, including the critically acclaimed spy-series The Americans, broadcast from 2013 to 2018. Est represented an outgrowth of the Human Potential Movement of the 1960s through to the 1970s.
As est grew, so did criticism of it. In 1977, the film Semi-Tough, which parodied the then-popular course, was released. Various critics accused est of mind control or of forming an authoritarian army; some labeled it a cult.
The last est training took place in December 1984 in San Francisco. The seminars gave way to a "gentler" course offered by Werner Erhard and Associates and dubbed "The Forum", which began in January 1985.
The est Standard Training program consisted of two weekend-long workshops with evening sessions on the intervening weekdays. Workshops generally involved about 200 participants and were initially led by Erhard and later by people trained by him. Ronald Heifetz, founder of the Center for Public Leadership at Harvard University, called est "an important experience in which two hundred people go through a powerful curriculum over two weekends and have a learning experience that seemed to change many of their lives." Trainers confronted participants one-on-one and challenged them to be themselves rather than to play a role that had been imposed on them by the past.
Jonathan D. Moreno observed that "participants might have been surprised how both physically and emotionally challenging and how philosophical the training was." He writes that the critical part of the training was freeing oneself from the past, which was accomplished by "experiencing" one's recurrent patterns and problems and choosing to change them. The word experience meant to bring into full awareness the repetition of old, burdensome behaviors. The seminar sought to enable participants to shift the state of mind around which their lives were organized, from attempts to get satisfaction or to survive, to actually being satisfied and experiencing themselves as whole and complete in the present moment.
Participants agreed to follow the ground rules, which included not wearing watches, not speaking until called upon, not talking to their neighbors, and not eating or leaving their seats to go to the bathroom except during breaks separated by many hours. Participants who were on medication were exempt from these rules, and had to sit in the back row, so that they would not interfere with the other participants. These classroom agreements provided a rigorous setting whereby people's ordinary ways to escape confronting their experience of themselves were eliminated.[page needed] Moreno describes the est training as a form of "Socratic interrogation...relying on the power of the shared cathartic experience that Aristotle observed." Erhard challenged participants to be themselves instead of playing a role that had been imposed on them and aimed to press people beyond their point of view, into a perspective from which they could observe their own positionality. As Robert Kiyosaki writes, "During the training, it became glaringly clear that most of our personal problems begin with our not keeping our agreements, not being true to our words, saying one thing and doing another. That first full day on the simple class agreements was painfully enlightening. It became obvious that much of human misery is a function of broken agreements – not keeping your word, or someone else not keeping theirs."
Sessions lasted from 9:00 a.m. to midnight, or to the early hours of the morning, with one meal-break. Participants had to hand over wristwatches and were not allowed to take notes, or to speak unless called upon, in which case they waited for a microphone to be brought to them.[page needed] The second day of the workshop featured the "danger process".: 384 As a way of observing and confronting their own perspective and point of view, groups of participants were brought onto the stage and confronted. They were asked to "imagine that they were afraid of everyone else and then that everyone else was afraid of them": 384 and to re-examine their reflex patterns of living that kept their lives from working. This was followed by interactions on the third and fourth days, covering topics such as reality and the nature of the mind, looking at the possibility that "what is, is and what ain't, ain't," and that "true enlightenment is knowing you are a machine": 384 and culminating in a realization that people do not need to be stuck with their automatic ways of being but can instead be free to choose their ways of being in how they live their lives. Participants were told they were perfect the way they were and were asked to indicate by a show of hands if they "had gotten it".[page needed]
I considered the training to be a brilliantly conceived Zen koan, effectively tricking the mind into seeing itself, and in thus seeing, to be simultaneously aware of who was doing the seeing, a transcendent level of consciousness, a place spacious and undefined, distinct from the tired old story that our minds continuously tell us about who we are, and with which we ordinarily identify.
Participants' reported results
Many participants reported experiencing powerful results through their participation in the est training, characterised by Eliezer Sobel as perceived "dramatic transformations in their relationships with their families, with their work and personal vision, or most important, with the recognition who they truly were in the core of their beings".[need quotation to verify] One study of "a large sample of est alumni who had completed the training at least 3 months before revealed that "the large majority felt the experience had been positive (88%), and considered themselves better off for having taken the training (80%)".
Werner Erhard reported having a personal transformation, and created the est training to allow others to have the same experience. The first est course was held at a Jack Tar Hotel in San Francisco, California, in October 1971. Within a year, trainings were being held in New York City and other major cities in the United States followed soon after. They were carried out by Werner Erhard, who had recently resigned from Mind Dynamics.
Beginning in July 1974 the est training was delivered at the U.S. Penitentiary at Lompoc, California, with the approval of the Federal Bureau of Prisons. Initial est training in Lompoc involved participation of 12–15 federal prisoners and outside community members within the walls of the maximum security prison and was personally conducted by Werner Erhard.
By 1979, est had expanded to Europe and other parts of the world. In 1980 the first est training in Israel was offered in Tel Aviv. The est training presented several concepts to these new attendees, most notably the concept of spiritual transformation and taking responsibility for one's life. The actual teaching, called "the technology of transformation," emphasizes the value of integrity. As est grew, so did criticism. It was accused of mind control and labeled a cult by some critics who said that it exploited its followers by recruiting and offering numerous "graduate seminars."
In 1983 in the United States, a participant named Jack Slee collapsed during a portion of the seminar known as "the danger process" and died at the hospital to which he had been transported. A court subsequently found that the est training was not the cause of death. A jury later ruled that Erhard and his company had been negligent, but did not give Slee's estate a monetary award.[page needed]
According to a 1991 report by the Los Angeles Times, est had been the target of a smear campaign by the Church of Scientology. This campaign had spanned several years, with examples being found in documents seized by the FBI in 1977. This smear campaign involved hiring personal investigators to spy on Erhard, recruiting Scientologists to covertly enroll in and disrupt est courses, and compiling information from disgruntled former est participants which could be used to discredit est. Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard (who died in 1986) believed that Erhard had copied Scientology. Erhard disputed this, saying that est was essentially different despite some similarities.
In their 1992 book Perspectives on the New Age James R. Lewis and J. Gordon Melton said that similarities between est and Mind Dynamics were "striking", as both used "authoritarian trainers who enforce numerous rules," require applause after participants "share" in front of the group, and de-emphasize reason in favor of "feeling and action." The authors also described graduates of est as "fiercely loyal," and said that it recruited heavily, reducing marketing expenses to virtually zero. The last est training was held in December 1984 in San Francisco.
It was replaced by a gentler course called "The Forum," which began in January 1985. "est, Inc." evolved into "est, an Educational Corporation," and eventually into Werner Erhard and Associates. In 1991 the business was sold to the employees who formed a new company called Landmark Education with Erhard's brother, Harry Rosenberg, becoming the CEO. Landmark Education was structured as a for-profit, employee-owned company; it operates as Landmark Worldwide with a consulting division called Vanto Group.
In W. W. Bartley III's biography of Werner Erhard, Werner Erhard: The Transformation of a Man, the Founding of est (1978), Erhard describes his explorations of Zen Buddhism. Bartley quotes Erhard as acknowledging Zen as the essential contribution that "created the space [for est]".
Of all the disciplines that I studied, practiced, learned, Zen was the essential one. It was not so much an influence on me, rather it created space. It allowed those things that were there to be there. It gave some form to my experience. And it built up in me the critical mass from which was kindled the experience that produced est.
- 1971 – Erhard Seminars Training Inc, first est Training held in San Francisco, California
- 1973 – The Foundation for the Realization of Man – incorporated as a non-profit foundation in California (subsequently the name of the foundation was changed to the est Foundation in 1976, and in 1981 to the Werner Erhard Foundation)
- 1975 – est, an educational corporation.
- 1977 – The first est training outside of the United States, in London.
- 1977 – The Hunger Project was established
- 1979 – The first est training in India
- 1980 – The first est training in Israel
- 1980 – The Breakthrough Foundation was established (Youth at Risk)
- 1981 – First of ten annual physicist conferences sponsored by the est Foundation
- 1981 – est became Werner Erhard and Associates
- 1984 – The last training was held under the name of est
- EST and The Forum in popular culture
- Getting It: The Psychology of est
- Human Potential Movement
- Large-group awareness training
- List of large-group awareness training organizations
- Outrageous Betrayal
- Bartley, William Warren, Werner Erhard: the Transformation of a Man: the Founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p.164.
Fenwick, Sheridan (1976). Getting it: The Psychology of Est. Philadelphia: Lippincott. p. 44. ISBN 9780397011704. Retrieved 13 January 2021.
[...] printed on the first mailing I received after sending in my deposit:'The purpose of the est training is to transform your ability to experience living so that the situations you have been trying to change or have been putting up with clear up just in the process of life itself.'
Compare: Rushkoff, Douglas (2011). Life Inc: How the World Became a Corporation and How to Take it Back. Random House. p. 140. ISBN 9781446467787. Retrieved 2017-02-05.
'The purpose of the EST training,' we were told when I took it as a college student in the early '80s, 'is to transform your ability to experience living so that the situations you have been trying to change or have been putting up with clear up just in the process of life itself.'
"Welcome to Your est Reunion". erhardseminarstraining.com. 2019 . Retrieved 17 August 2020.
Werner Erhard and the est Training brought to the forefront the ideas of transformation, personal responsibility, accountability, and possibility – and over the next decade, over a million people 'Got it'. The est Training was as much a sign of the times as bell bottoms, peace rallies and space travel.
Hirsch, Deborah (March 3, 2018). "David Wayne Reed gives his characters and his audience a hand in Help Yourself". Pitch Magazine. Archived from the original on March 3, 2018.
Reed's show-slash-seminar takes its inspiration from the human-potential movement that spanned a couple of decades. Erhard Seminars Training (est), which began running weekend workshops in the 1970s and later evolved into Landmark Education — 'Create a future of your own design,' Landmark's website reads — may be the best-known. Today's est site claims: 'Werner Erhard and the est Training brought to the forefront the ideas of transformation, personal responsibility, accountability, and possibility ... and over a million people "Got it."' [..] Reed gets it with his farcical take on those inhabiting that world, and with his rendition of those seminars' goals, lingo, leaders and aftereffects.
Greil, Arthur L.; Rudy, David R. (2017) . "On the Margins of the Sacred". In Robbins, Thomas; Anthony, Dick (eds.). In Gods We Trust: New Patterns of Religious Pluralism in America (2 ed.). Abingdon: Routledge. ISBN 9781351513067. Retrieved 13 January 2021.
Organizations generally associated with the human potential movement, such as Silva Mind Control, est, Lifespring, Transformational Technologies, etc., are easily conceptualized as quasi-religions. Although it is now defunct and its founder, Werner Erhard, has moved on to other projects, such as the Forum and Transformational Technologies, est remains one of the best known of the human potential groups. [...] Like other organizations within the human potential movement, est understands 'itself to be communicating epistemological, psychological, and psychosomatic facts about human existence [...]' [...].
Haldeman, Peter (28 November 2015). "The Return of Werner Erhard, Father of Self-Help". Fashion. The New York Times. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
The criticism intensified as EST grew.
- Semi-Tough (1977), IMDb Trivia - "The reenactment of the EST meeting with Bert Convy was exactly what Werner Earhart used to open his program with calling everyone "Assholes" right from the beginning of the seminar."
Haldeman, Peter (28 November 2015). "The Return of Werner Erhard, Father of Self-Help". Fashion. The New York Times. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
The criticism intensified as EST grew. It was labeled a cult that practiced mind control (verbal abuse, sleep deprivation), a racket that exploited its followers (heavy recruiting, endless "graduate seminars").
Tipton, Steven M. (2014) . "EST and Ethics: Rule-egoism in Middle Class Culture". Getting Saved from the Sixties: Moral Meaning in Conversion and Cultural Change. Eugene, Oregon: Wipf and Stock Publishers. p. 215. ISBN 9781625646996. Retrieved 25 November 2020.
Accused by critics of being an authoritarian army, the est organization is, in fact, a boot camp for bureaucracy. Hierarchical, tightly rule-governed, and meritocratic, it trains its young volunteers and staff to answer phones, write memos, keep records, promote and stage public events, and deal smoothly with clients.
Lewis, James R. (2014). "Erhard Seminars Training (est)/The Forum". Cults: A Reference and Guide. Approaches to New Religions (3 ed.). London: Routledge. p. 129. ISBN 9781317545132. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
While not a church or religion, est is included here because it has often been accused of being a cult.
Whippman, Ruth (2016). "Personal Journey? Its Not All About You". The Pursuit of Happiness: Why are we driving ourselves crazy and how can we stop?. London: Hutchinson. ISBN 9781473519602. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
The Landmark Forum is the direct successor to the notorious 1970s programme est [...]. In the 1980s, Erhard reinvented his course in a gentler, more corporate incarnation as The Forum, which later became the Landmark Forum.
Kyle, Richard G. (1993). The Religious Fringe: A History of Alternative Religions in America. InterVarsity Press. p. 319. ISBN 9780830817665. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
In 1985, Erhard changed the name of est to 'the Forum.' The Forum is not substantially different from est . Ruth Tucker says that the changes made by Erhard are largely cosmetic, for the philosophy of the Forum is essentially that of est.
- Leadership Can Be Taught: A Bold Approach for a Complex World, by Sharon Daloz Parks, published 2005 by Harvard Business School Press; pp. 157– 158
- Jonathan D, Moreno (October 2014). Impromptu Man: J.L. Moreno and the Origins of Psychodrama, Encounter Culture, and the Social Network. Bellevue Literary Press. ISBN 978-1-934137-84-0.
- Werner Erhard: The Transformation of a Man, the Founding of est, by William Warren Bartley, III; New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p. 199.
- Cults: Faith, Healing, and Coercion, by Marc Galanter; New York: Oxford University Press, 2nd ed., 1999, p. 75
- Bartley, William Warren III (December 12, 1988). Werner Erhard: The Transformation of a Man, The Founding of est. Clarkson Potter. ISBN 0-517-53502-5.
- Bartley, William Warren III (December 12, 1988). Werner Erhard: The Transformation of a Man, The Founding of est. Clarkson Potter. p. 233. ISBN 0-517-53502-5.
The training provides a format in which siege is mounted on the Mind. It is intended to identify and bring under examination presuppositions and entrenched positionality. It aims to press one beyond one's point of view, at least momentarily, into a perspective from which one observes one's own positionality.
- Kiyosaki, Robert; Kiyosaki, Emi (January 2009). Rich Brother Rich Sister. Vanguard Press. ISBN 978-1-59315-493-6.
- Ruys, Chris. "Can you unchain your mind through est or TM?". No. January 23, 1977. Sun Times (Chicago).
- Kay Holzinger (2001). "Erhard Seminars Training (est) and The Forum". In James R. Lewis (ed.). Odd gods: new religions & the cult controversy. Prometheus Books. ISBN 978-1-57392-842-7.
- McGurk, William S. (1977). "Was ist est?". Contemporary Psychology. 22 (6): 459–460. doi:10.1037/016030.
- Sobel, Eliezer (1998). "This is It: est, 20 Years Later". Quest Magazine (Summer).
Asghar, Rob (29 October 2014). "The 'Mindfulness' Craze: Headaches To Come". forbes.com. Retrieved 18 February 2021.
Mindfulness may well be the est of our generation. Four decades ago, the est movement promised dramatic 'transformation' for its practitioners. Many of them swear even today that it delivered on its promises. But est has also gone down in history as a controversial mess. Consider the words of the new-agey guru Eliezer Sobel in Psychology Today a few years ago, defending est on the 40th anniversary of its founding: "[...] no naysayer could talk them out of the very real value they experienced in their lives as a result of participating in est, whether it was dramatic transformations in their relationships with their families, with their work and personal vision, or most important, with the recognition of who they truly were in the core of their beings."
Galanter, Marc (1999) . "Altered Consciousness". Cults: Faith, Healing, and Coercion (2 ed.). New York: Oxford University Press. p. 75. ISBN 9780198028765. Retrieved 18 February 2021.
The whole thing ["getting it"] is treated as a joke, discomforting the new converts. [...] Nonetheless, one study of a large sample of est alumni who had completed the training at least three months before revealed that the large majority felt the experience had been positive (88%), and considered themselves better off for having taken the training (80%).
- Bartley, William Warren, Werner Erhard: the transformation of a man: the founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p. 165.
- "Hotel to hospital: Farewell to S.F. era". San Francisco Chronicle. Oct 31, 2009.
- Woodward, Mark (1982). "The est Training in Prisons: A Basis for the Transformation of Corrections?". Baltimore Law Journal. Archived from the original on November 13, 2013.
- "est in Prison" by Earl Babbie, published in American Journal of Correction, Dec 1977
- Rogin, Neal (7 June 1978). "Getting 'It' in Prison – The First est Training at the Federal Correctional Institution at Lompoc, California in 1974". Internet Archive.
- Despair and deliverance: private salvation in contemporary Israel by Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi page 121
- The Herald Sun; March 1, 2008; http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,23298425-664,00.html
- Haldeman, Peter (2015-11-28). "The Return of Werner Erhard, Father of Self-help". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved November 6, 2017.
- Ragland, Jr., Gerald F. (1984). "Complaint in Trespass for Wrongful Death – Demand for Jury Trial". Civil Action No. N 84 497 JAC (United States District Court for the District of Connecticut).
- Welkos, Robert W. (December 29, 1991). "Founder of est Targeted in Campaign by Scientologists : Religion: Competition for customers is said to be the motive behind effort to discredit Werner Erhard". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved December 2, 2019.
- Melton, J. Gordon; Lewis, James R. (1992). Perspectives on the New Age. SUNY Press. pp. 129–132. ISBN 0-7914-1213-X.
- McClure, Laura (July–August 2009). "The Landmark Forum: 42 Hours, $500, 65 Breakdowns". Mother Jones. Archived from the original on October 18, 2010. Retrieved October 13, 2010.
- Bass, Alison (March 3, 1999). "Soul Training: A Retooled Version of the Controversial est Movement – Seekers of Many Stripes Set Out on a Path of Self-examination". The Boston Globe. Retrieved October 11, 2010.
- Bartley, William Warren, Werner Erhard: the Transformation of a Man: the Founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p. 121, 146-7.
- Bartley, William Warren, Werner Erhard: the transformation of a man: the founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p. 118.
- Bartley, William Warren, Werner Erhard: the transformation of a man: the founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, p. 121.
- Bartley, William Warren; Werner Erhard: The Transformation of a Man, The Founding of est. New York: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc. 1978. ISBN 0-517-53502-5, pp. 144–148.
- Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin (July 1, 1992). Despair and Deliverance: Private Salvation in Contemporary Israel. State University of New York Press.
- "» History of the est Training". erhardseminarstraining.com.
- Bartley, III, William Warren: Werner Erhard The Transformation of a Man: The Founding of est, New York, New York, USA: Clarkson N. Potter, Inc (1978) ISBN 0-517-53502-5.
- Bry, Adelaide: est: 60 Hours That Transform Your Life, Harper Collins (1976) ISBN 978-0-06-010562-4
- Fenwick, Sheridan: Getting It: The Psychology of est, J. B. Lippincott Company. (1976) ISBN 0-397-01170-9
- Hargrove, Robert: est: Making Life Work, Delacorte (1976) ISBN 978-0-440-19556-6
- Kettle, James: The est Experience, Zebra Books (1976) ISBN 978-0-89083-168-7
- Marks, Pat R.: est: The Movement and the Man, Playboy Press (1976) ASIN B004BI5A3E
- Moreno, M.D., Ph.D., Jonathan D. Impromptu Man: J. L. Moreno and the Origins of Psychodrama, Encounter Culture, and the Social Network. Bellevue Literary Press (2014) ISBN 1-934137-84-7
- Pressman, Steven: Outrageous Betrayal: The Dark Journey of Werner Erhard from est to Exile
- Rhinehart, Luke: The Book of est, Holt, Rinehart and Winston (1976) ISBN 978-0-557-30615-2