Federalism in the Philippines
Federalism in the Philippines (Filipino: Pederalismo sa Pilipinas) is a proposed form of government in the country.
|This article is part of a series on the
politics and government of
The concept of a federal government for the Philippines was proposed as early as the Philippine Revolution with Filipino revolutionaries Emilio Aguinaldo and Apolinario Mabini suggesting dividing the islands into three federal states.
One of the first proponents of federalism in the Philippines in the 21st century is University of the Philippines professor Jose Abueva who argued that a federal form of government is necessary to more efficiently cater to the needs of the country despite its diversity. The primary goals of a constitutional amendment is to increase decentralization, greater local power and access to resources most especially among regions outside Metro Manila which has long been dubbed as rather imperial.
Aside from Abueva, senator Aquilino Pimentel, Jr. is a prominent supporter of federalism who, since 2001, has advocated for federalism. He sees the proposed system as a key component in alleviating the Mindanao crisis and appeasing Moro insurgents. According to Pimentel, even though federalism was never intended to appease any followers of any specific ideology of religion, it will also hasten economic development, since resource and financial mobilization is upon each state's or province's discretion without significant constraint from the central government.
However, in 2009, after Senate and House resolutions supporting charter change were released, an estimated 13,000 to 15,000 people gathered in Makati to protest against these executive department-deriving proposals for constitutional reform. This was due to speculations that Philippine president Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo would use such amendments to extend her hold in office. In addition, Pulse Asia published in the same year their survey regarding public support for the proposed charter change; the survey reported that four out of ten Filipino adults, or 42% of all respondents, opposed the amendment, with 25% still undecided and 33% in favor. Pulse Asia furthered that from 2006 to 2009 there was no significant change of sentiment against the charter change proposal, although indecision increased by 6%.
In late 2014, then-Davao City mayor Rodrigo Duterte launched a nationwide campaign calling for a charter change for federalism. During his visit to Cebu City in October of the same year, Duterte stated that federalism will facilitate better delivery of services to the people. He also saw the current system as "antiquated" where distribution of public funds is disproportionately biased towards Manila. Aside from the economic aspect, federalism is also seen as the best means to address problems in Mindanao which suffers the most from ethno-religious conflicts. Duterte added that the current unitary form of government has not worked well given the ethnic diversity in the country. In spite of initially rejecting several calls for his candidacy for the 2016 presidential elections, he cited his organizational reforms if he were to become president. Parallel to his campaign for federalism, Duterte planned to privatize tax collection and abolish the Congress to make way for a unicameral legislature, contrary to the originally proposed Joint Resolution No. 10.
Movements for federalism further intensified from when the draft of the Bangsamoro Basic Law was submitted by Philippine president Benigno Aquino III to the 16th Congress on September 10, 2014. From approval, this law establishes the Bangsamoro as an autonomous region with its own parliamentary government and police force. Approval of the Bangsamoro structure would provide federalism proponents and supporters added confidence to clamor for the national government to enact reforms towards a more decentralized system for the rest of the country.
In May 2016, President-elect Rodrigo Duterte stated that a plebiscite on the proposed replacement of the unitary state with a federal one will be held in two years. On December 7, 2016, Duterte signed Executive Order No. 10 creating a consultative committee to review the 1987 Constitution.
Joint Resolution No. 10
The resolution may require the revision of 14 of the 18 Articles of the 1987 Philippine Constitution and the addition of two new articles. It sought to adopt a federal and presidential form of government with a bicameral legislature. This proposed resolution was backed by 12 senators of the Philippines: Aquilino Pimentel Jr., Edgardo Angara, Rodolfo Biazon, Pia Cayetano, Juan Ponce Enrile, Francis Escudero, Jinggoy Estrada, Gregorio Honasan, Panfilo Lacson, Francis Pangilinan, Ramon Revilla Jr., and Manuel Villar
In 2008, senator Aquilino Pimentel, Jr. proposed Joint Resolution No. 10, which would revise the current 1987 constitution and have created eleven autonomous regions out of the Philippine Republic, establishing eleven centers of finance and development in the archipelago.
Within the joint resolution are certain proposals such as election of senators based on states, senators representing overseas voters and the state governor and vice-governor as one team. The Judicial and Bar Council which screens nominees to the judiciary would be abolished. Geographic locations of the three branches of the government would also be reconsidered. In the proposal, the legislative department would be transferred to what would become the State of Central Visayas while the judicial department would be moved somewhere within the State of Northern Luzon. The executive department would remain within the federal administrative region of Metro Manila. In May 2016, Aquilino 'Nene' Pimentel Jr., stated in an interview with Teodoro Locsin Jr. and Tina Monzon-Palma that a North Mindanao state may be separated into two distinct states, namely, Northwest Mindanao and Northeast Mindanao.
While Pimentel Jr.'s earlier proposal for a Federal Philippines was to include the area currently governed by the Cordillera Administrative Region to the Northern Luzon state, Pimentel mentioned on August 2017 two possible setups for the Cordilleras under a federal government at the North Luzon Federalism Summit: An autonomous Cordillera region within the Northern Luzon state or the region as a separate federal state from Northern Luzon due to the existence of a long-standing autonomy movement in the region and a provision in the current Constitution for giving the Cordilleras autonomy. He also made the same pronouncements during a live interview with journalist Karen Davila. After the abolition of the Negros Island Region on August 9, 2017, there have been several regional movements driven by the Negrenses in support of the unification of the twin Negros provinces (Negros Occidental and Negros Oriental) under one federal state.
In January 2017, under a federalism forum, Pimentel clarified twenty-eight points, namely:
- (1) the Cordillera will have its own federal state;
- (2) the boundaries of Northern Luzon state still needs to be clarified as the state includes two distinct regions;
- (3) Masbate will be included in the Central Visayas state;
- (4) the Northern Mindanao state shall include the entire Zamboanga region, the entire North Mindanao region including Bukidnon, Agusan del Norte, Butuan City, Dinagat Islands, and Surigao del Norte;
- (5) the Southern Mindanao state shall include the entire Soccsksargen region, the entire Davao region, Agusan del Sur, and Surigao del Sur; /(6) Minparom (Mindoro, Palawan, Romblon, and Marinduque) shall be classified as a Visayan state and not a Luzon state as it is geographically part of the Visayas, which Pimentel says is "contrary to the beliefs of Imperial Manila";
- (7) the Bangsamoro state is the most important as it is vital to peace in Mindanao and Minparom;
(8) Shariah law can only be applied in the Bangsamoro state if the two parties are Muslims, but if one or both parties are non-Muslims, national law will always apply;
- (9) Scarborough Shoal/Bajo de Masinloc shall be part of Central Luzon state through Zambales;
- (10) the Philippine territories in the Spratly Islands shall be part of Minparom state through the municipality of Kalayaan, Palawan;
- (11) if the bicameral Congress is retained, then the members of the House of Representatives will voted the same way as its is today;
- (12) if the bicameral Congress is retained, the members of the Senate shall be voted, not nationally anymore, but per state, where each state shall have six Senate seats, the Federal Capital (Metro Manila) will have six Senate seats, and the overseas Filipino population will have nine Senate seats, for a total of at least 87 Senate seats, which provides proper representation to all states;
- (13) the Supreme Court shall be mandated to have a decision on a case within 2 years from its filing;
- (14) the Court of Appeals, Sandiganbayan, and other appellate courts shall be mandated to have a decision on a case within 1.8 years from its filing;
- (15) the RTC shall be mandated to have a decision on a case within 1.6 years from its filing;
- (16) the City and Municipal courts shall be mandated to have a decision on a case within 1 year from its filing;
- (17) each federal state shall have a Federal Governor and Federal Vice Governor; (18) each federal state shall have a Federal State Legislature, whose members members shall be representatives from every province, highly urbanized cities, and sectoral groups;
- (19) warlordism and political dynasties shall be prohibited by the Constitution itself;
- (20) federal states shall have 80% of their respective state's revenues, while the federal government will only have 20%;
- (21) an Equalization Fund shall be created by the Constitution so that federal states that are in dire need of additional fund can be helped by the federal government;
- (22) there will be a unified educational system, but the indigenous peoples and Muslims shall be allowed to input certain educational resources into their educational system to better serve their peoples;
- (23) the Federal Executive Department will hold office in the Federal Administrative Region of Metro Manila;
- (24) the Federal Legislature will hold office in the Federal State of Central Visayas;
- (25) the Federal Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court will hold office in the Federal State of Northern Mindanao;
- (26) secession will not be enhanced under the federal form of government as it is a crime under the Constitution;
- (27) the Bangsamoro state shall be divided into two autonomous regions, namely, mainland Muslim Mindanao and Sulu archipelago, as the two Muslim areas are distinct from each other in terms of culture; and
- (28) the Philippines will include its claim in Sabah under the federal form of government. Pimentel, however, did not clarify that the Philippines can only claim the eastern half of Sabah.
In January 2018, Pimentel suggested the inclusion of the Malaysian-administered territory of Sabah as a Philippine federal state in itself to assert the Philippine claim over the disputed territory in a way "acceptable under international laws".
In February 2018, under a new federalism forum, Pimentel noted that new information have been funneled in regarding federalism in the Philippines and the actual want and need of the people in a federal form of government. In the forum, he clarified and revised six points from his initial forum back in January 2017, namely: (1) the proposed Northern Mindanao state may be divided into the Northwest Mindanao state (the entire Zamboanga region, Misamis Occidental, Lanao del Norte, Iligan City, Misamis Oriental, Cagayan de Oro city, and Camiguin) and the Northeast Mindanao state (Bukidnon, Agusan del Norte, Agusan de Sur, Butuan City, Dinagat Islands, Surigao del Norte, and Surigao del Sur); (2) If the Northern Mindanao state is divided into two states, Agusan del Sur and Surigao del Sur will shift into the Northeast Mindanao state from the initially-proposed Southern Mindanao state; (3) The president and the vice president shall continue to be elected through a nation-wide election, but they must be elected in tandem; (4) the qualifications for president, vice president, and members of Congress shall be the same with the current Constitution, but with the addition that the candidates must at least have a bachelor's degree from a college/university recognized by the government; (5) the term of the elected president and vice president shall be six years without reelection; and (6) a former president is not eligible to run for the presidency anymore as the new Constitution shall limit the term of a president into one term only.
House Concurrent Resolution No. 15
Rep. Monico O. Puentevella on May 7, 2008, filed House Concurrent Resolution No. 15 which supported Senate Resolution No. 10 backed by 16 senators. Unlike the Nene Pimentel Senate Resolution, Puentevella included the option of holding a constitutional convention, but excluded the People's Initiative mode. Prospero Nograles, a self-proclaimed advocate of federalism, on May 1, 2008, announced: "This federal system of government is close to my heart as a Mindanaoan leader and I'm sure most of the leaders in Mindanao will agree that we have long clamored for it. Senate Resolution 10 is a pleasant surprise because the Senate has a long history of opposing any move to amend the Constitution." The joint Senate resolution called for the creation of 11 federal states in the country, by convening of Congress “into a constituent assembly for the purpose of revising the Constitution to establish a federal system of government.”
In 2017, House Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez's vision for a federal Philippines called for 14 states: 7 in Luzon, 2 in Visayas and 5 in Mindanao. He also proposed that the capital of the Philippines under a federal government should be somewhere in Negros island saying that it would be accessible to all people from the three island groups while he added that the state's territory does not have to be contiguous. Alvarez has hinted that the new capital may be established between the towns of Kabankalan, Negros Occidental and Mabinay, Negros Oriental. Indigenous groups are in favor of the proposal, but are wary of the possibility of a 'no term limit' for politicians, which is a grave scandal in many Filipino indigenous societies, especially in the Cordilleras. In February 2018, Alvarez reiterated that he shall input an indigenous state in the Cordilleras in Luzon and an indigenous state in Mindanao, whatever federal set-up is approved by the President.
|Proposed states by House Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez (2017)|
2018 House Sub-Committee 1 proposal
The Sub-Committee 1 of the House of Representatives Committee on Constitutional Amendments proposed that a federal Philippines would comprise five states. Each states to be led by a premiere as its executive head will have a State Assembly according to the proposal. The proposal has been hit by massive criticism due to general lumping and a lack of representation. According to the proposal, politicians will have 'more than' two consecutive terms, making them eligible to run for office with no term limit.
|Proposed states and capitals
House of Representatives Committee on Constitutional Amendments
League of Provinces proposal
In February 2018, the League of Provinces of the Philippines (LPP), whose members are the 81 provincial governors, gave its support to the country's shift to federalism, but stated that the 81 existing provinces should be converted into “independent states”, instead of regional lumping.
In April 25, 2018, the consultative committee (Con-Com), created by President Rodrigo Duterte to propose revisions to the 1987 Constitution, agreed that the starting point for the federalism discussions will be the establishment of 17 federated regions and the National Capital Region, the proposed federal capital region. The 17 federated regions will be Ilocos, Cordillera, Cagayan Valley, Central Luzon, Calabarzon, Bicol, Mimaropa, Eastern Visayas, Central Visayas, Negros, Panay, Caraga, Northern Mindanao, Davao, Soccsksargen, Muslim Mindanao, and Zamboanga.
- "The debate on federalism". New Straits Times. 28 May 2016. Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- Brillantes, A. B.; Moscare, D. (2002). "Decentralization and federalism in the Philippines: Lessons from the global community" (PDF).
- Abueva, J. V. "Towards a Federal Republic of the Philippines: Liberating the country from the stifling, centralized, colonial control of "Imperial Manila"" (PDF).
- Abueva, J V. (2005). "Some advantages of federalism and parliamentary government for the Philippines" (PDF).
- "Thousands march in Makati vs. charter change". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "42% of Pinoys oppose charter change". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "Duterte wants cha-cha for federalism". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "Duterte says gov't system antiquated, opens federalism summit today". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "Argument for federalism: Manila steals funds". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "Duterte visits Dumaguete City to promote federalism". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "Duterte eyes abolition of Congress if elected president in 2016". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "PNoy personally submits draft Bangsamoro law to Congress leaders". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- "FAQs about the Bangsamoro Basic Law". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- Inquirer, Philippine Daily. "Duterte: Polls on federalism in 2 yrs".
- Macas, T. (9 December 2016). "Duterte signs EO creating committee to review 1987 Constitution". GMA News. Retrieved 17 May 2017.
- "Federalism gets majority backing in Senate". Retrieved 17 April 2015.
- Joint Resolution to Convene the Congress into a Constituent Assembly for the Purpose of Revising the Constitution to Establish a Federal System of Government (PDF), Senate of the Republic of the Philippines, April 23, 2008, retrieved 2008-06-27
- Eleven senators endorse federal system of govt.
- "Federalism in the Philippines?". Pilipino Express. December 16, 2014. Retrieved April 5, 2016.
- In a surprise move, senators give qualified yes to charter debate.
- Guieb, Danica (August 21, 2016). "'Autonomy can co-exist with federalism'". Sun.Star.
- Bayoran, Gilbert P. (August 18, 2017). "Negros pushed as 'federal state'". The Philippine Star.
- Gomez, Carla P. (August 15, 2017). "Cueva pushes for 1-Negros federal state". The Visayan Daily Star.
- "House resolution supports change in form of government".
- News, ABS-CBN. "House, Senate begin cha-cha talks next week".
- Arguilas, Carolyn (28 March 2017). "Alvarez' federal Philippines: 14 states, Negros as seat of central gov't". MindaNews. Retrieved 18 January 2018.
- Colcol, Erwin (16 January 2018). "Proposed federal charter divides PHL into 5 states". GMA News. Retrieved 18 January 2018.
- Calayag, Keith (January 16, 2018). "Scrapping of JBC eyed under federalism". Sun.star Manila. Retrieved January 17, 2017.
Castro, who chairs the technical working group on the judiciary, said that among the proposals is the creation of an appellate court in each of the proposed states, namely: Manila, Luzon, Visayas, Bangsamoro and Mindanao.
- Manalastas, Jestre (16 January 2018). "PH with 5 states eyed under federal system". Journal Online. Retrieved 17 January 2018.
- Esguerra, Christian (16 February 2018). "Group wants 81 states under federalism". ABS-CBN News. Retrieved 20 March 2018.
- Press release: Pimentel files resolution on federal system, Senate of the Philippines, 14th Congress, April 23, 2008, retrieved 2008-04-25
- Aquilino Q. Pimentel, Jr.; Egardo Angara; Rdudolfo Biazon; Pia "Compañera" Cayetano; Juan Ponce Enrile; Francis "Chiz" Escudero; Jinggoy Estrada; Gregario Honasan; Panfilo lacson; Francis Pangilinan; Ramon "Bong" Revilla; Manuel "Manny" Vilar (23 April 2008), Joint Resolution No. 10: A Joint Resolution to convene Congress into a Constituent Assembly for the purpose of revising the constitution to establish a federal system of government (PDF), Senate of the Philippines, retrieved 2008-05-13