Finkbeiner test

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Finkbeiner test is a checklist proposed by journalist Christie Aschwanden to help journalists avoid gender bias in media articles about women in science. To pass the test, an article about a female scientist must not mention:

  • That she is a woman
  • Her husband's job
  • Her child care arrangements
  • How she nurtures her underlings
  • How she was taken aback by the competitiveness in her field
  • How she's such a role model for other women
  • How she's the "first woman to..."[1]

Aschwanden formulated the test in an article in Double X Science, an online science magazine for women, on 5 March 2013.[2] She did so in response to what she considered was a type of media coverage of women scientists that:

"treats its subject's sex as her most defining detail. She's not just a great scientist, she's a woman! And if she’s also a wife and a mother, those roles get emphasized too."

Aschwanden created the test in the spirit of the Bechdel test, which is used to indicate gender bias in fiction. She named the test after fellow journalist Ann Finkbeiner, who had written a story[3] for the science blog The Last Word on Nothing about her decision not to write about the subject of her latest article, an astronomer, "as a woman".[1] Susan Gelman, Professor of Psychology at the University of Michigan, has applauded the move to report on female scientists without emphasising their gender, but questions whether the Finkbeiner test should seek to eliminate all references to personal life, suggesting that the move should be towards asking male scientists about personal issues too.[4] This view is shared by other writers.[5]

The test was mentioned in the media criticism of the New York Times's obituary of rocket scientist Yvonne Brill. That obituary, published on 30 March 2013, by Douglas Martin, began with the words: "She made a mean beef stroganoff, followed her husband from job to job and took eight years off from work to raise three children".[6] A few hours after publication the New York Times revised the obituary to address some of the criticisms; the revised version begins "She was a brilliant rocket scientist who followed her husband from job to job...".[6][7] Another New York Times article, on Jennifer Doudna, published on 11 May 2015,[8] drew similar criticism with reference to the Finkbeiner test.[9] A Globe and Mail article on astrophysicist Victoria Kaspi,[10] published on 16 February 2016, drew the same criticism.[11]

The 'Reversed Finkbeiner' approach is an exercise in which students are asked to write an article about a male scientist that would fail the Finkbeiner test if it were about a woman.[12][13]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b Brainard, Curtis (22 March 2013). "‘The Finkbeiner Test’ Seven rules to avoid gratuitous gender profiles of female scientists". Columbia Journalism Review. Retrieved 31 March 2013. 
  2. ^ Aschwanden, Christie (5 March 2013). "The Finkbeiner Test: What matters in stories about women scientists?". Double X Science. Retrieved 31 March 2013. 
  3. ^ Finkbeiner, Ann (1 March 2013). "What I’m not going to do: Do media have to talk about family matters?". Double X Science. Retrieved 31 March 2013.  Originally posted at: "What I’m Not Going to Do". The Last Word On Nothing. 17 January 2013. Retrieved 2 April 2013. 
  4. ^ "Sexism In Science | Common Reader". Common Reader. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  5. ^ "Asking Questions and the "Finkbeiner Test"". Uncertain Principles. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  6. ^ a b Gonzalez, Robert T. (31 March 2013). "The New York Times fails miserably in its obituary for rocket scientist Yvonne Brill". io9. Retrieved 31 March 2013. 
  7. ^ "NewsDiffs | Diffing: Yvonne Brill, a Pioneering Rocket Scientist, Dies at 88". www.newsdiffs.org. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  8. ^ Pollack, Andrew (11 May 2015). "Jennifer Doudna, A Pioneer Who Helped Simplify Genome Editing". New York Times. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  9. ^ "Problems With How We Talk About Female Scientists «  Berman Institute Bioethics Bulletin". bioethicsbulletin.org. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  10. ^ Semeniuk, Ivan (16 February 2016). "McGill astrophysicist is first woman to win Canada's top science award". The Globe and Mail. 
  11. ^ Shanahan, Marie-Claire (18 February 2016). "Two stories, same scientist: Gender and coverage of the Herzberg medal". Boundary Vision. 
  12. ^ "The Reversed Finkbeiner Test". www.futurescienceleaders.com. Retrieved 14 October 2015. 
  13. ^ "Finkbeiner posts: round 2". genegeek. Retrieved 14 October 2015.