Flogging a dead horse

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
A man sitting on a dead horse in Sheboygan, Wisconsin. The idiom comes from the fact that flogging a horse in this condition (dead or dying) would not cause it to move or anything otherwise worthwhile to happen.

Flogging a dead horse (alternatively beating a dead horse; or beating a dead dog in some parts of the Anglophone world) is an idiom that means a particular effort is a waste of time as there will be no outcome, such as in the example of flogging a dead horse, which will not cause it to feel pain or anything else.

According to the Oxford English Dictionary,[1] the first recorded use of the expression in its modern sense was by the English politician and orator John Bright in reference to the Reform Act of 1867, which called for more democratic representation in Parliament. Trying to rouse Parliament from its apathy on the issue, he said in a speech, would be like trying to "flog a dead horse" to make it pull a load. The Oxford English Dictionary cites usage in The Globe in 1872 as the earliest verifiable use of "flogging a dead horse", where someone is said to have "rehearsed that [...] lively operation known as flogging a dead horse".[2]

However Jay Dillon[citation needed] has discovered an earlier instance attributed to that same John Bright thirteen years prior: speaking in Commons on suffragette protests, March 28, 1859, Lord Elcho remarked that Bright had not been "satisfied with the results of his winter campaign" and that "a saying was attributed to him [Bright] that he [had] found he was 'flogging a dead horse.'"[3]

Earlier meaning[edit]

Some scholars claim that the phrase originated in 17th-century slang, when a horse was a symbol of hard work, while paying for that work in advance meant the chances of a horses work being done, rather than simply keeping the payment, could be represented by a dead horse (expecting work from a horse that you had already killed).

In a seventeenth century quote from a collection of documents owned by the late Earl of Oxford, Edward Harley,

Sir Humphry Foster had lost the greatest part of his estate, and then, playing, as it is said, for a dead horse, did, by happy fortune, recover it again.[4]

Mr Foster, apparently, played for, or sought out, the dead horse, which meant payment for work without working, and regained a fortune by finding it.

Many sailors were paid in advance for their first month's work. In his book Old England and New Zealand, author Alfred Simmons gives detailed explanation and background of the "Flogging the Dead Horse" ceremony performed on board ship by a ship's crew at the end of the first month of their voyage and the resumption of their wages.[5] The sailors would get paid in advance of leaving the harbour, whereupon they would spend their money, and embark the ship with nothing. This situation allowed them to exclaim the horse, the symbol of hard work, without money for motivation, was dead. However, once a month had passed, the sailors would have reached the Horse latitudes, and payment would be due again.

One of the earliest synonyms may be found in an ancient Greek play by Sophocles, Antigone,

Nay, allow the claim of the dead; stab not the fallen; what prowess is it to slay the slain anew?[6]

Further reading[edit]

  • Isil, Olivia A. (1996). When a Loose Cannon Flogs a Dead Horse There's the Devil to Pay: Seafaring Words in Everyday Speech. International Marine. ISBN 0-07-032877-3.

References[edit]

  1. ^ flog a dead horse. Oxford English Dictionary. Oxford University Press.
  2. ^ "Unknown". The Globe. 1872-08-01.
  3. ^ Hansard (28 March 1859). "Second Reading". UK Parliament. Archived from the original on 8 February 2019. Retrieved 8 February 2019.
  4. ^ Park, Thomas (1810). The Harleian Miscellany, or, A collection of scarce, curious, and entertaining pamphlets and tracts, as well in manuscript as in print, found in the late Earl of Oxfords library, interspersed with historical, political, and critical notes. p. 364. Nick, Nicker Nicked, or, The Cheats of Gaming Discovered, printed 1669, "Sir Humphry Foster had lost the greatest part of his estate, and then, playing, as it is said, for a dead horse, did, by happy fortune, recover it again, then gave over, and wisely too."
  5. ^ Simmons, Alfred (2012-06-10). Old England and New Zealand. Forgotten Books. p. 113. ASIN B008GDXKRS.
  6. ^ Sophocles translated by RCJebb. "Antigone". Wikisource. Retrieved 8 February 2019.

External links[edit]