Florence Jaffray Harriman
|Florence Jaffray Harriman|
|United States Minister to Norway|
|President||Franklin D. Roosevelt|
|Preceded by||Anthony J. Drexel Biddle, Jr.|
|Succeeded by||Anthony J. Drexel Biddle, Jr.|
July 21, 1870|
New York City, New York
|Died||August 31, 1967
|Spouse(s)||J. Borden Harriman|
|Profession||Suffragist and social reformer|
Florence Jaffray "Daisy" Harriman (July 21, 1870 – August 31, 1967) was an American socialite, suffragist, social reformer, organizer, and diplomat. “She led one of the suffrage parades down Fifth Avenue, worked on campaigns on child labor and safe milk and, as minister to Norway in World War II, organized evacuation efforts while hiding in a forest from the Nazi invasion.” In her ninety-second year, U.S. President John F. Kennedy honored her by awarding her the first “Citation of Merit for Distinguished Service.” She often found herself in the middle of historic events. As she stated, “I think nobody can deny that I have always had through sheer luck a box seat at the America of my times.”
Harriman was born Florence Jaffray Hurst on July 21, 1870 in New York City to shipping magnate F.W.J. Hurst and his wife Caroline. When she was three years old, her mother, then 29, died. She and her two sisters (Caroline Elise and Ethel) were raised in and around New York City by her father and maternal grandparents, Mr. and Mrs. Edward Somerville Jaffray. At age six, she watched her first political torchlight parade, part of the 1876 presidential campaign. "She later told of leaning over the bannister of her home at 615 Fifth Avenue, to hear visitors such as John Hay, President James A. Garfield, and President Chester A. Arthur."
She was known throughout her life as “Daisy.”
In 1889, at age nineteen, she married J. Borden Harriman, a New York banker (and an elder cousin of future cabinet secretary, New York Governor and diplomat W. Averell Harriman). The list of attendees at their wedding included past and future president Grover Cleveland, railroad tycoons Cornelius Vanderbilt and Edward Harriman, John Jacob Astor IV, and J. P. Morgan. They had one child, Ethel M.B. Harriman, born on December 11, 1897. Ethel worked on Broadway and in Hollywood, as an actress and writer (as Ethel Russell or Ethel Borden).
For many years, Harriman led the life of a young society matron interested in charitable and civic activities. Her life revolved around Mount Kisco, New York (where their estate overlooked the Hudson River), Fifth Avenue in New York City, and Newport, Rhode Island.
In 1903, she co-founded with Ava Lowle Willing (then-Mrs. John Jacob Astor IV) and Helen Hay Whitney (Mrs. Payne Whitney) the Colony Club, New York City’s first club exclusively for women. However, instead of restricting her social and civic activities to the wealthy or to members of her husband’s political party (the Republican Party), she reached out to others. For example, in 1908, she led efforts by the New York chapter of the National Women's Committee to expose harsh working conditions in New York City's factories, foundries and hotels. She explained, "Should not the woman who spends the money which the employees help to provide take a special interest in their welfare, especially in that of the women wage earners?" In 1909, she created waves when, as the “wife of a banker,” she “entertained one hundred members of the International Brotherhood of Stationary Firemen at her summer home.” In 1906, Republican Governor Charles Evans Hughes appointed her as a member of the Board of Managers of New York State Reformatory for Women at Bedford, New York.
As Harriman would later explain in her book “From Pinafores to Politics,” her leadership and organizing skills became increasingly directed toward the disenfranchised and impoverished. She was active in the women's suffrage movement in support of extending the vote to women, reportedly leading a parade of suffragists down Fifth Avenue. She also crusaded against unhealthy conditions in New York's tenements. Franklin D. Roosevelt later described her as "the woman who was most responsible for helping to provide milk for dependent poor children in the great city of New York."
In 1912, Harriman’s active support for the presidential campaign of then-New Jersey Governor Woodrow Wilson led to national publicity and leadership roles. She was elected as the first president of the “Women’s National Wilson and Marshall Association,” and organized mass meetings, and mass mailings, in support of his campaign.
Upon taking office, Wilson appointed Harriman as a member of the first U.S. Commission on Industrial Relations, which Congress had authorized the previous year. After 154 days of testimony, the Commission could not agree on the causes and solutions to labor-management difficulties. Harriman and Commissioner John R. Commons refused to sign the caustic report written by Commission Chair Frank P. Walsh. As Commons and Harriman wrote in their separate report (joined by a narrow majority of Commissioners), the Walsh report mistakenly focused on individual “scapegoats rather than on the system that produces the demand for scapegoats."
Her husband became seriously ill in February 1913, shortly before Wilson took office. After President Wilson's appointment, Washington, D.C. became their primary residence. While serving on the Commission on Industrial Relations, she also continued to serve in New York on the Bedford Reformatory board.
World War I and the Mexican Civil War
Harriman, her husband and daughter found themselves in the middle of Europe as World War I erupted in the summer of 1914. Hoping that the healing waters in the Bohemian spa in Karlsbad would benefit her husband, Harriman brought her family to Europe in June 1914. After meeting with leading British and French officials while relations between the European powers deteriorated, they traveled through France to Karlsbad (then a part of Austria-Hungary), and were there when Austria-Hungary attacked Serbia in late July. After leaving Karlsbad on the last train crossing the frontier through Germany to France, they eventually returned to New York on an armed British vessel, the RMS Adriatic. Her husband's health continued to deteriorate, and he died on December 1, 1914. His prolonged illness, the resulting lack of income, and the expense of maintaining several homes had consumed nearly all of his net worth. Harriman never remarried.
The following year, Harriman found herself near the front lines of another war - the battle along the south side of the Rio Grande near Brownsville, Texas, between supporters of rebel Pancho Villa and the armies of Mexican leader Venustiano Carranza. During a break in hearings on working conditions for farmworkers that she conducted in Dallas in March 1915, she accepted an offer to visit the Rio Grande area, where the United States was attempting to remain neutral as Mexican factions battled each other along the river. After watching the battle for Matamoros, Tamaulipas from Brownsville, she began to tend to the wounded and visited the smoking battlefields, before returning to Washington.
Harriman increased her charitable and political activity. She turned her Mount Kisco home into a tuberculosis sanitarium. During the period of American neutrality, she became a cofounder of the Committee of Mercy, which was created to help the women and children and other European noncombatants made destitute by the war. In May 1916 she was recruited by Eleanor Roosevelt to lead a contingent of "Independent Patriotic Women of America" in a preparedness parade. After the United States declared war on Germany, she organized the American Red Cross Women's Motor Corps of the District of Columbia, and directed the Women's Motor Corps in France. From 1917 to 1919, she served as chair of the U.S. National Defense Advisory Commission's Committee on Women in Industry.
1919 to 1937
Harriman participated in the Versailles Peace Conference, and upon her return was an advocate for American participation in the League of Nations, and worked on behalf of world peace organizations.
While the Wilson Administration ended in 1921, Harriman’s Democratic activism did not. Syndicated columnist William Hard described her as "a candle for the party in its darkest days." She began serving as member of the Democratic National Committee in 1920 (a position she would hold until the 1950s) and in 1922 became the founder and first president of the Woman's National Democratic Club. Her first book, “From Pinafores to Politics,” was published in 1923. She was often in the company of another widowed fixture of 1920s Washington, Montana U.S. Senator Thomas J. Walsh. She resided in a large home known as "Uplands," on a hill off Foxhall Road northwest of Georgetown.
Time Magazine would report in 1934 that her “Sunday night salons have long been a Washington institution.” She would invite up to 32 guests with diverse viewpoints, then referee a thorough off-the-record discussion of a single controversial issue. She enforced two ground rules: no one was ever to grow angry, and no one was to repeat what had been said.
Harriman reportedly “lost most of her fortune during the Depression,” and “had to eke out her income by interior decorating and real estate” (while sharing her Washington home with well-paying guests). One such cohabitant in the first year of the Roosevelt Administration was the first woman cabinet member, Secretary of Labor Frances Perkins.
As a member of the Democratic National Committee, Harriman was also a District of Columbia delegate to the Party’s conventions. In 1932, when the Convention nominated Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harriman did not support him. According to Time, she “she unfortunately held out for Newton D. Baker or Melvin Traylor.” In her own words, this would cause "the triumphant members of the Roosevelt-before-the-Convention inner clique" to have "a little grey mark against me." However, “after Roosevelt's nomination she hastened to repair her mistake,” and became one of Roosevelt’s strongest supporters at the 1936 Convention.
Diplomacy and World War II
Early in his second term, Roosevelt scrambled many of his diplomatic assignments. Norway, the fourth nation to grant woman suffrage (after New Zealand, Australia and Finland), was considered "an obvious post for a woman diplomat." Thus, in 1937, Harriman was appointed as the United States’ Minister to Norway. (Her precise title was “Envoy Extraordinary and Minister Plenipotentiary” for Norway.) At the time of her appointment, she could hardly have known that this role would soon require her to draw on her experience in helping refugees in the previous World War. Consequently, increasing tension in Europe and the imminent death of Turkish reformer Atatürk, compelled her to advise Secretary of State Hull to install Ismet Inonu as President of Turkey to assure a protectionist ally in the region.
In 1940, Germany invaded Norway with little warning, causing Harriman and the rest of the American legation in Norway to join certain members of the Norwegian royal family and other refugees seeking protection hundreds of kilometers away in Sweden. In the chaos and bombardment, America suffered its first military casualty when Captain Robert M. Losey, a U.S. military attaché assisting the evacuation while observing the war, was killed in a Luftwaffe attack on Dombås. The rest of the American legation ultimately arrived safely in Sweden. Harriman is credited with arranging for the safety of other Americans and several members of the Norwegian royal family -- Crown Princess Märtha and her children Ragnhild, Astrid and Harald.
She returned to the Nordic countries to complete the evacuation of current and future U.S. citizens through Finland on the United States Army transport USAT American Legion in August 1940. In January 1941, she officially left her position, became a vice-chair of the Committee to Defend America by Aiding the Allies, and testified in the House Foreign Affairs Committee in favor of the Lend-Lease Act. Her service in Norway, and the harrowing escape, became the subject of her next book, “Mission to the North,” published in 1941. In July 1942, King Haakon VII of Norway (then in exile) conferred upon Harriman the Grand Cross of the Order of St. Olav.
After the United States entered World War II, Harriman continued to write on causes important to her, and wrote the foreword to the English-language edition of one of the first publications on the Holocaust and Auschwitz Concentration Camp, “Oswiecim, Camp of Death,” published in March 1944 before the camp's liberation by Soviet troops. And despite her decades of involvement in the Democratic Party, she joined a bipartisan (but unsuccessful) effort to persuade Roosevelt’s Republican opponent in the 1940 election, Wendell Willkie, to run for Governor of New York in 1942.
She served as the 3rd Vice President of the Board of Directors of the National Conference On Citizenship in 1960.
Voting rights in the District of Columbia
Harriman lived in the District of Columbia at the time of every presidential election since the adoption of the Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution in 1920, but the District received no electoral votes for most of her life, so she effectively could not vote in presidential elections for several decades.
In 1955, at age 84, Harriman led a parade through the capital to protest "taxation without representation" in the District of Columbia. That year, she wrote in a New York Times letter to the editor that "the time has come for another Boston tea party" to end the disenfranchisement of the District's residents.
The adoption of the Twenty-third Amendment to the United States Constitution in 1961 gave three electoral votes to the District, so in 1964, at age 94, Harriman cast her first vote in a presidential election - for Lyndon Johnson.
In 1956, Life Magazine reported that, even at age 86, she continued to host dinners for twenty-two guests nearly every Sunday night.
The Citation of Merit
Harriman received a Citation of Merit for Distinguished Service, presented by President Kennedy on April 18, 1963 (when she was 92 years old). It states: “In her illustrious career in public service, Mrs. Harriman has made singular and lasting contributions to the cause of peace and freedom. . . . In all of her endeavors, Mrs. Harriman has exemplified the spirit of selflessness, courage and service to the Nation, reflecting the highest credit on herself and on this country. She has, indeed, earned the esteem and admiration of her countrymen and the enduring gratitude of this Republic.”
Harriman died in Washington, D.C., on August 31, 1967. Her daughter died on July 4, 1953, at age 55. Her granddaughter, Phyllis Russell Marcy Darling, of Eugene, Oregon, died on December 18, 2007, at age 88. Her grandson, Charles Howland Russell, of Carmel Valley, California, died on May 13, 1981, at age 60.
- Harriman, Florence Jaffray Hurst, Examples of Welfare Work in the Cotton Industry: Conditions and Progress : New England and the South, New York: Woman's Dept., National Civic Federation (1910)
- Harriman, Mrs. J. Borden, From Pinafores to Politics, New York: H. Holt and Company (1923)
- Harriman, Florence Jaffray, Mission to the North, Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott (1941)
- Harriman, Florence Jaffray Hurst, Norway Does Not Yield; The Story of the First Year, New York: American Friends of German Freedom (1941)
- Zarembina, Natalia, and Harriman, Florence Jaffray Hurst, Oswiecim, Camp of Death (Underground Report), New York, N.Y.: "Poland fights," Polish Labor Group (1944)
- Harriman, Florence Jaffray Hurst, The Reminiscences of Mrs. Florence Jaffray Harriman (1972)
- Christopher Gray, “New York Streetscapes: Former Colony Club at 120 Madison Avenue,” The New York Times, 2003-09-28.
- John F. Kennedy, "Remarks Upon Presenting a Presidential Citation of Merit to Mrs. Florence Harriman," April 19, 1963, reprinted at "The American Presidency Project" website, last accessed 2010-07-31.
- “Crusader for Rights; Florence Jaffray Harriman,” The New York Times, 1963-04-19.
- "The Wedding Of Miss Hurst and Mr. Harriman at St. Thomas's". New York Times. November 14, 1889. Retrieved 2010-10-29.
Two of the most popular of the younger members of the hunting set, Miss Florence Jaffray Hurst, daughter of F.W.J. Hurst and granddaughter of E.S. Jaffray, and J. Borden Harriman, son of Oliver Harriman, were wedded yesterday ...
- "Funeral of Mrs. Hurst," New York Times, 1873-08-15.
- Judith A. Leavitt, “American Women Managers and Administrators: A Selective Biographical Dictionary of Twentieth-Century Leaders in Business, Education, and Government,” 102-03 (1985) ISBN 0-313-23748-4.
- Jane Eads, "Lady Democrats Fete Spry Daisy Harriman," Morgantown (WV) Dominion-News, 1958-01-22 at p. 5.
- "Mrs. J. Borden Harriman, Ex-Envoy, Dies at 97. Served in Norway at Time of Nazi Invasion in 1940 Given First Citation of Merit by Kennedy in April, 1963". New York Times. September 1, 1967. Retrieved 2010-10-29.
Mrs. J. Borden Harriman, Minister to Norway at the beginning of World War II and an early crusader for social rights, died at her Georgetown home here today. She was 97 years old.
- “Florence Jaffray Hurst Harriman: A Register of Her Papers in the Library of Congress,” Library of Congress 2002.
- “New Harriman Deal,” Time, 1934-01-22.
- Mrs. J. Borden Harriman, “From Pinafores to Politics,” (Henry Holt & Co., 1923) ASIN B00085GSYO (available in the National American Woman Suffrage Association Collection, Library of Congress and accessed 2010-07-31).
- Broadway Database entry for Ethel Borden and Internet Movie Database entry for Ethel Borden. Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; name "ethel" defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- ”Florence J. Harriman,” Encyclopædia Britannica, referenced 2008-03-01.
- James Trager, "Park Avenue: Street of Dreams" p. 160 (Athenaeum 1990)ISBN 0689120249.
- "Women in Secret Crusade for Labor," New York Times, 1908-05-06.
- "Women in Society to Help Labor," New York Times, 1908-03-07 at p. 3.
- “Banker’s Wife Dines Labor Delegates,” The New York Times, 1909-08-19.
- “‘Enter Politics:’ Mrs. J. Borden Harriman’s Message to American Women.” New York Herald, 1912-08-12, p. 2.
- Florence J. Harriman, "Fighting Tuberculosis in our Crowded Tenements," New York Times Magazine, 1912-10-13.
- President Franklin D. Roosevelt, "Radio Address at the White House Conference on Children in a Democracy, Washington, D.C.," January 19, 1940, reprinted at The American Presidency Project website, last accessed 2010-07-29.
- Jo Freeman, "The Rise of Political Woman in the Election of 1912" (2003).
- "Walsh Would Have Government Seize All Collosal Fortunes," Atlanta Constitution, 1915-08-24 at p. 12.
- "Final Report of the Commission on Industrial Relations: Report of Commissioners John R. Commons and Florence J. Harriman," 169 (1916).
- Bruce Kaufman, The Global Evolution of Industrial Relations: 86 (2004) ISBN 92-2-114153-5.
- "J. Borden Harriman, Ex-Banker, is Dead," New York Times, 1914-12-02.
- "J Borden Harriman Dying in Mt. Kisco," The New York Times, 1914-10-08.
- "Farm Women Work Hard: Mrs. J. Borden Harriman Investigates Conditions in the Southwest," New York Times, 1915-03-20.
- Ida Clyde Clarke, “American Women and the World War,” (D. Appleton & Co. 1918).
- Edward J. Renehan, Jr., "The Lion's Pride: Theodore Roosevelt and His Family in Peace and War," pp. 118-19 (Oxford U. Press: 1999).
- William Hard, "Men and Affairs," Charleston (WV) Daily Mail, 1930-07-21 at p. 6.
- Laton McCartney, "The Teapot Dome Scandal: How Big Oil Bought the Harding White House and Tried to Steal the Country," p. 189 (2008), ISBN 1-4000-6316-7.
- "Florence Jaffray Harriman, "Mission to the North" (Lippincott 1941) ISBN 978-1-135-46324-3.
- Sigrid Arne (Associated Press), "Daisy Harriman is 70, But Don't Let That Fool You," Gallup (NM) Independent, 1941-03-12 at p. 5.
- ”To Oslo,” Time, 1937-04-12.
- U.S. Department of State, Alphabetical List of Chiefs of Mission and Principal Officials, 1778-2005, accessed 2008-07-23.
- J. Michael Cleverley, "'The First American Official Killed In This War,'" Foreign Service Journal, December 2003 at 66; “'Daisy' Harriman Outruns Bombs,” Life, 1940-05-14, at p. 32.
- Norway.org - the official site in the United States: A New Princess in Town, 9/28/2005
- " SS American Legion," in Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships; "'American Legion' Docks with Royal and Plebeian Refugees," Life, 1940-09-09 at 30.
- "Committee Wants Action: Letter to President Signed by 2,000 Urges Firm Stand," San Antonio Express, 1941-05-27, at p. 4.
- "U.S. Envoys Call Lend Bill Vital," Oakland Tribune, 1941-01-26 at p. 1.
- "Norway's King Gives Honor to U.S. Minister," Wisconsin State Journal, 1942-07-31 at p. 8.
- Oswiecim, Camp of Death," pp. 5-6 (English edition) (Poland Fights: NY 1944) (available in the Internet Archive:Open Source Books and accessed 2008-09-25).
- Ellsworth Barnard, “Wendell Willkie: Fighter for Freedom” 330-31 (U. Mass. Press 1971) ISBN 0-87023-088-3.
- ”Talking it Over: Pre-Convention Differences Bring Family Opinions to Attention,” Syracuse Herald-Journal, 1952-06-19 at 40.
- Associated Press,"'Daisy' Harriman Dies: Democratic Party Legend," Meriden (CT) Journal, 1967-09-01 at p. 3.
- "Earned Place in Politics: Important Role of the Hostess," Life Magazine, 1956-12-24 at p. 55.
- "Obituary of Phyllis Darling". The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR). 2008-01-07. Retrieved 2008-11-18.