|Part of Governors Island|
|New York County, New York, USA|
|Owner||Public - National Park Service|
United States of America
|NRHP reference #||74001268|
|Added to NRHP||27 March 1974|
|Designated NYCL||19 September 1967|
|Built||1794, 1806, 1833|
|Built by||U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Jonathan Williams|
|Materials||Sandstone, Granite, Brick|
Fort Jay, a coastal star fort and the name of the former Army post, is located on Governors Island in New York Harbor. Fort Jay is the oldest defensive structure on the island, and was named for John Jay, a member of the Federalist Party, New York governor, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Secretary of State, and one of the "founding fathers" of the United States. It was built in 1794 to defend Upper New York Bay, but has served other purposes. From 1806 to 1904 it was named Fort Columbus, presumably for explorer Christopher Columbus. The National Park Service administers Fort Jay together with Castle Williams as the Governors Island National Monument.
On Governors Island (called Nutten Island from 1664 to 1784, based on Dutch Noten Eylandt for "Nut Island"), Fort Jay is situated on the location of earthworks originally built to defend New York City during the American Revolution. General Israel Putnam constructed the first earthen fortification on this site starting in April 1776, and armed it with eight cannons for the defense of New York Harbor. Additional guns were later emplaced, and on 12 July 1776 the Nutten Island batteries engaged HMS Phoenix and HMS Rose. The American cannons inflicted enough damage to make the British commanders cautious of entering the East River, which later contributed to the success of General George Washington's 29–30 August retreat from Brooklyn into Manhattan after the defeat in the Battle of Brooklyn. The Americans abandoned the earthworks that September, resulting in the eventual British occupation of New York City. The British Army improved the existing earthworks and used the island as a British Royal Navy hospital until they departed on 25 November 1783. At that time Governors Island was conveyed to the State of New York.
In the years following the end of British occupation of New York in 1783, the works deteriorated. A decade later in 1794, the State of New York began to finance improvements to the earthworks, then in ruins. The fort was reconstructed as a square with four corner bastions, and was named after the Federalist New York governor John Jay. By 1797 Congress appropriated $30,117 for continued construction. Eventually, to allow for continued federal funding and upkeep of the works, the state conveyed Governors Island and the works at Fort Jay to the federal government in February 1800 for one dollar.
In 1806 the earthworks were replaced by granite and brick walls and the footprint of the fort enlarged to designs by Major Jonathan Williams, chief engineer for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, superintendent of the United States Military Academy, and supervisor of fortifications in New York Harbor. The fort was rebuilt and enlarged as part of what became known as the Second System of US seacoast fortifications. Williams replaced the earthworks with sandstone and granite walls and an arrow-shaped ravelin, all surrounded by a dry moat. The moat was in turn surrounded by a sloped grassy area or glacis that was once was cleared of trees, providing a clear field of fire toward any advancing enemy forces. The slope was also designed to retard or stop cannon shot from warships. The overall result is still evident in the fort's star-shaped design and its position on the highest point on the island. Construction of the walls and gate of the existing fort were completed in 1808. Later, small wood and brick barracks buildings were constructed in the enclosed square space.
The fortification was initially named Fort Jay for John Jay, a member of the Federalist Party, New York governor, Supreme Court Justice, Secretary of State and one of the "founding fathers" of the United States. Jay, as George Washington's Secretary of State, negotiated an unpopular but essential treaty, the Jay Treaty, addressing unresolved issues with Great Britain in the years after the Revolutionary War. With the election of Thomas Jefferson as President in 1800 there was a shift of power from the Federalists, of which Jay was a prominent member, to the Democratic-Republican Party. Jefferson's party objected to the negotiations of John Jay with Britain, which resulted in the Jay Treaty of 1794, which resolved outstanding issues from the American Revolution. Following the 1806 rebuilding, and with the change in presidential administrations and the recent transfer to the federal government, the fort was renamed Fort Columbus, presumably for Christopher Columbus, a name it retained until 1904.
As the fort was being enlarged and strengthened, the fortification and Army post were renamed “Fort Columbus” at some time between 15 December 1806 and 21 July 1807, presumably for 15th-century explorer Christopher Columbus. Edmund Banks Smith, an Episcopal priest, Army chaplain and author of an early history of Governors Island in 1913 opined that this change was “supposed to have been due to Jay’s temporary unpopularity with the Republican party, which was not satisfied with the Jay Treaty with England”. Whether or not this was in fact the case has yet to be substantiated, as no orders or documentation for this change have been found. The fort retained the name “Columbus” throughout the remainder of the 19th century, finally reclaiming the name “Fort Jay” in 1904.
Fort Columbus played an important role in the military life of New York City as the largest army post defending the city. The fortification, in concert with Fort Wood on Liberty Island, Fort Gibson on Ellis Island, Castle Clinton at the Battery in Lower Manhattan, and two other fortifications on Governors Island, South Battery and Castle Williams, provided protection for the city and Upper New York Bay. This system of coastal fortifications is credited with discouraging the British from taking any naval action against the city during the War of 1812, who preferred easier targets in the Great Lakes, the Chesapeake Bay (resulting in the burning of Washington, DC), and the Gulf of Mexico below New Orleans.
19th century and the Civil War
In subsequent years, beginning in the 1820s, Fort Richmond, Fort Hamilton, and Fort Lafayette at the Narrows of New York Harbor reduced the need for the Upper Harbor forts, and in time, the Army transferred most properties in Upper New York Bay to other federal agencies or sold them to the state of New York. Fort Columbus, however, possessed 68 acres (280,000 m2), a sufficient land mass for a modest garrison at a reasonable proximity (1,000 yards) from Manhattan, making it the most practical of the Second System forts for the Army to retain and continue to garrison.
Personnel stationed at Fort Columbus began to record meteorological observations in the 1820s.
As the closest major army post to the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York, Fort Columbus for many years served as a first posting or a major departure point for newly graduated cadets shipping to army posts along the Atlantic or Pacific coasts. Many future generals in the Civil War were posted to or passed through Fort Columbus as young junior officers. They included Abner Doubleday, Ulysses S. Grant, Robert E. Lee, Joseph E. Johnston, John Bell Hood, Theophilus H. Holmes, Thomas Jackson, Henry Wager Halleck, James B. McPherson, John G. Barnard and others.
In the 1830s, the protective value of Fort Columbus diminished with the advance of weapons technology, but other uses evolved for the army post. The Army renovated the fortification beginning in 1833 with the construction of four barracks that remain to the present day, replacing wooden barracks. The barracks were built as the fortification's importance in protecting New York was diminished by the construction of the new forts at The Narrows of New York Harbor. The Greek Revival style barracks, unified by two-story Tuscan porticos first served as officers' and enlisted men's housing for the permanent garrison. That same year the Ordnance Department established the New York Arsenal as a separate installation, adjacent to but not part of Fort Columbus, as a major depot taking delivery of contracted manufactured arms and weapons and distributing both contract and federally manufactured weapons to army posts across the nation. In 1836, the South Battery became the Army School of Music Practice, training young boys to become company drummers and fife players and regimental musicians.
During the American Civil War, the armament of the fort was upgraded with nearly fifty 10-inch (254 mm) and 15-inch (381 mm) Rodman guns. In October 1942, three 10-inch and one 15-inch guns were retained at the fort's east entrance gate and north overlook to Lower Manhattan as ornaments, while the remainder were scrapped for the war effort during World War II.
Twice, in December 1860 and April 1861, the Army "secretly" dispatched troops and provisions from Fort Columbus to relieve the besieged garrison at Fort Sumter in Charleston, South Carolina. Outgoing President James Buchanan initiated the first effort, but a battery garrisoned by cadets from The Citadel, The Military College of South Carolina fired on the Army-chartered New York-based steamship Star of the West on 9 January 1861 as it entered Charleston Harbor. The incident provoked a crisis, prompting other southern states began to more seriously consider secession from the Union. The second effort, which marked the beginning of the Civil War, also failed when it prompted South Carolina forces to fire on Fort Sumter early in the morning of 9 April 1861.
In the early years of the Civil War, the north barracks were used to hold Confederate officers taken as prisoners of war pending transfer to other Union prisons such as Camp Johnson in Ohio, Fort Delaware or Fort Warren in Boston Harbor. Fort Columbus and Castle Williams also served as a temporary prisoner of war camp and confinement hospital for Confederate prisoners during the war. Major General William H. C. Whiting (CSA) died of dysentery in February 1865 in the post hospital shortly after his surrender at the Battle of Fort Fisher, North Carolina. He was the highest ranking Confederate officer to die as a prisoner of war.
Division and departmental headquarters
In the years after the American Civil War, New York Arsenal served as a major center for disposing of surplus and excess cannons and munitions for war memorials in national cemeteries and for municipalities, scrap, or sale to foreign governments.
In 1878, as part of a servicewide cost-cutting effort, the United States Army relocated many of its administrative functions from rented quarters in large urban centers to neighboring army posts. In New York City, nearly all army functions in the city were relocated to Governors Island, making Fort Columbus the headquarters for the Division of the Atlantic and later the Department of the East. Both commands then included almost all army activities east of the Mississippi River. The prestige of a command at Fort Columbus as a premier posting ranked second only to high-ranking army positions in Washington, D.C. and many commanders went on to become Commanding General of the United States Army. Its departmental commanders from the 1880s to the 1900s included Winfield Scott Hancock, Wesley Merritt, Oliver O. Howard, Nelson Miles, Arthur MacArthur, and other combat commanders in the Civil War, the Indian Wars, and the Spanish–American War.
Fort Jay and Governors Island drew the attention of President Theodore Roosevelt's Secretary of War, Elihu Root, a former New York City lawyer. Root sought to enhance the island army post to better serve the army's needs and fend off efforts by the City of New York to close the post and reclaim the island as a city park. Root instigated the expansion of the island from its original 60 acres to 170 acres with landfill from the newly constructed New York City Subway. Root also commissioned the New York architectural firm of McKim, Mead and White to develop a master plan for the island which would demolish all the existing buildings on the island except for the three original fortifications on the island and a newly constructed chapel. The retention of the fortifications indicated Root's interest in retaining the historical structures, as some of the army decision makers he supervised were trying to accomplish their demolition.
In one of his departing acts as Secretary of War in February 1904, he restored the original name of Fort Jay to the fortification and the army post that had evolved around it. The glacis south of the fort continued to be used as a parade ground and in the 1920s also served as a polo field. In the 1930s, the Army employed the Works Progress Administration (WPA) to turn the glacis surrounding the fort into a nine-hole golf course, which was Manhattan's only golf course until it was demolished in 1996.
Another 1930s WPA project was the complete conversion of the barracks in Fort Jay to family housing. Each company barracks was transformed into four townhouse-style apartments that served junior officers as family housing. As a further concession to the automobile, eight two-car garages were constructed inside the fort behind the barracks to serve the fort's residents.
During World War II Fort Jay was the headquarters of First Army and the Eastern Defense Command (EDC), responsible for all Army units and defense coordination in the northeastern United States, and in the east coast states from Maine through Florida. US Army forces in Newfoundland and, from April 1942, Bermuda were also included in the EDC.
End of military career
In 1964 the U.S. Army announced the closure of Fort Jay as the First Army headquarters and the relocation of the headquarters to Fort Meade, Maryland. In 1966 the United States Coast Guard (USCG) assumed control of Governors Island and continued to use Fort Jay to house junior officers and civilian staff until the USCG closed its Governors Island base in 1996.
In 2001, Fort Jay and Castle Williams were proclaimed part of the Governors Island National Monument, administered by the National Park Service. Fort Jay was recognized as being one of the finest remaining examples of the Second System of American military fortifications. Since 2003, both fortifications have been open to the public on a summer seasonal basis as they undergo stabilization.
- List of New York City Designated Landmarks in Manhattan on Islands
- National Register of Historic Places listings in Manhattan on islands
- National Park Service (2009-03-13). "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service.
- Smith 1913, p. 112.
- Wade, Arthur P. (2011). Artillerists and Engineers: The Beginnings of American Seacoast Fortifications 1794-1815. Mclean, Virginia: CDSG Press. pp. 120, 141. ISBN 978-0-9748167-2-2.
- "Fort Jay Governors Island National Monument" (PDF). National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior. 2005. Retrieved 10 April 2016. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- Smith 1913, p. 106.
- Smith 1913, p. 158-159.
- Conn, pp. 29, 33-39
- Conn, Stetson; Engelman, Rose C.; Fairchild, Byron (2000) . Guarding the United States and its Outposts. United States Army in World War II. Washington, D.C.: Center of Military History, United States Army.
- Smith, Edmund Banks (1913), Governors Island: Its Military History Under Three Flags, 1637–1913 (1st ed.), New York: Edmund Banks Smith, p. 178
- Smith, Edmund Banks (1923), Governors Island: Its Military History Under Three Flags, 1637–1922 (2nd ed.), New York: Valentine's Manual, p. 243
- Glen, Susan L.; Shaver, Michael B. (2006), Images of America: Governors Island, Mount Pleasant, SC: Arcadia, ISBN 978-0-7385-3895-2
- "Governors Island". National Historic Landmark summary listing. National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior. 2007-09-11.
- Hightower, Barbara; Higgins, Blanche (1983), Governors Island: National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination (PDF), Washington, D.C.: National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, p. 47
- "Governors Island--Accompanying 76 photos, from 1982" (PDF). National Register of Historic Places Inventory. National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior. 1983.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Fort Jay.|