Four boxes of liberty
Concepts and phrases evolve and are applied in new ways. The "four boxes" meme always includes the ballot, jury and cartridge (or ammo) boxes. Additional boxes, when specified, have sometimes been the bandbox, soapbox, moving box, or lunch box. The meme in various forms has been used in arguments about tariff abolition, the rights of African Americans, women's suffrage, environmentalism and gun control.
Stephen Decatur Miller may have originated the concept during a speech at Stateburg, South Carolina in September 1830. He said "There are three and only three ways to reform our Congressional legislation, familiarly called, the ballot box, the jury box and the cartridge box". This became his campaign slogan in his successful bid for the Senate on a platform advocating the abolition of tariffs. An 1849 edition of the Family Favorite and Temperance Journal extended the concept: "Four boxes govern the world:—cartridge box, ballot box, jury box, and band box". The bandbox, originally designed to hold collar bands, was used to carry the elaborate women's hats of the time as well as many other personal items. The quip was reproduced in the 25 December 1869 edition of the Spirit of the Times newspaper and in the 1881 Treasury of wisdom, wit and humor, odd comparisons and proverbs.
William F. Butler, an African American leader, used the concept in a speech he delivered in November 1867 in Lexington, Kentucky, saying: "First we had the cartridge box, now we want the ballot box, and soon we will get the jury box". Butler was referring to the fact that African Americans had fought in the Unionist forces in the American Civil War, but were still facing opposition to being treated as full citizens.
A version that is close to the modern forms was introduced by Frederick Douglass, an escaped slave who became an influential public figure in the Union States and Great Britain before the Civil War, and had a long and distinguished career after the war. In a speech delivered on 15 November 1867, Douglass said "A man's rights rest in three boxes. The ballot box, jury box and the cartridge box. Let no man be kept from the ballot box because of his color. Let no woman be kept from the ballot box because of her sex". In Douglass's autobiography the Life and Times of Frederick Douglass, published in 1892, he described his conviction that a freedman should become more than just a freedman, and should become a citizen. He repeated that "the liberties of the American people were dependent upon the ballot-box, the jury-box, and the cartridge-box; that without these no class of people could live and flourish in this country..."
The Altamont Enterprise revived the old saw of the cartridge box, ballot box and bandbox in 1909 when reporting a discussion between the newspaper editor Horace Greeley and the early campaigner for women's rights, Elizabeth Cody Stanton. Greeley proposed that the bullet box and ballot box went together, and asked Stanton if she would be prepared to fight if she had the vote. Stanton retorted that she would fight as he did, with her pen. The article went on to describe the case of Abigail Hopper Gibbons, who as a landowner and taxpayer was sent an official form asking her to give reasons why she was not eligible for jury duty. She replied, "I know of none". However, at this time women were barred from the jury box, the ballot box and the cartridge box.
Some women rejected the feminist position. The anti-suffragette Emily Bissell saw involvement in the boxes of liberty as inappropriate for women. She wrote "The vote is part of man's work. Ballot-box, cartridge box, jury box, sentry box all go together in his part of life. Women cannot step in and take the responsibilities and duties of voting without assuming his place very largely".
The moving box represents the right of migration, contrasted with the other boxes in phrases such as "fight or flight" and “Exit, Voice, and Loyalty”, Albert O. Hirschman's book about one’s two (peaceful) options when suffering dissatisfaction in a group. Migration is a major theme of American history, most famously in the arrival of freedom-seeking colonists from Europe, the pioneers (including the Mormon pioneers) moving west, and The Great Migration of southern blacks, first to the North and then to the West. In “Shouting Fire”, Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz generally prioritizes the freedom of speech, but states, “To the Jew, however, the right to emigrate has always been of transcendent importance... The 'wandering Jew' has escaped persecution by moving from country to country....” Internal migration in the US remains significant to the present day, with Americans seeking states with more suitable legal, economic, and cultural environments.
In a commentary on Leonard Levy's book Origins of the Bill of Rights (1999), Brian C. Kalt of the Michigan State University College of Law argues that the meme simply expresses the intent of the United States Bill of Rights to enshrine and protect the popular sovereignty. It succinctly defines the four methods by which the people can stand up for their rights. Taking a less positive view of the meme, in April 2010 the Anti-Defamation League noted that it is frequently used by anti-government extremists to justify violence to gain their ends on the grounds that all else has failed, and cites a typical comment on the Pat Dollard Web Site: "we've tried the soap box & the ballot box to no avail. Maybe it's time to start thinking INSIDE the box - the bullet box".
In their book For the People: What the Constitution Really Says About Your Rights, Akhil Reed Amar and Alan Hirsch introduce a variation on the theme. Discussing the American Constitution, they assert that the ideal of citizenship generates four "boxes" of rights. The first three are the familiar ballot box, jury box and cartridge box. To these, with some reservations, they add the lunch box: the idea of a social safety net that supports basic physical and educational needs.
Time Magazine reported that the meme was used in September 1976 by a keynote speaker at a convention of the American Independent Party, a coalition of right-wing forces. Although delegates disagreed on some issues, including the extent to which the U.S. should be active in foreign affairs, all agreed with the meme. During a March 1991 dinner event organized by the Green River Cattlemen's Association in Wyoming, James G. Watt said, "If the troubles from environmentalists cannot be solved in the jury box or at the ballot box, perhaps the cartridge box should be used." The phrase has been attributed to Ed Howdershelt, who self-publishes science fiction novels on the Internet. Larry McDonald, a politician from Georgia and former president of the John Birch Society has also been quoted, omitting the caution to use bullets as the last resort: "We have four boxes with which to defend our freedom: the soap box, the ballot box, the jury box, and the cartridge box". The term is used in newspaper articles, and has been used in a petition to the Supreme Court of California. "Four boxes" and derivatives have been used in the name of various websites that espouse patriotism and the right to bear arms. The "United States Militia", a pro-gun lobby, promotes the concept, as do various other conservative organizations such as the Florida based Liberty Club of Duval County. The meme has been quoted on many other pro-gun websites. The Four Boxes is even the subject of a poem.
- Dawkins, Richard (1989), The Selfish Gene (2 ed.), Oxford University Press, p. 192, ISBN 0-19-286092-5
- The Family favorite and temperance journal. 1. 1849. p. 99. Retrieved 27 September 2010.
- "CONSERVATIVES: Conclave in Chicago". Time Magazine. Sep 6, 1976. Retrieved 2010-09-26.
- Akhil Reed Amar, Alan Hirsch (1999). For the People: What the Constitution Really Says About Your Rights. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 0-684-87102-5.
- Elisabeth Muhlenfeld (1992). Mary Boykin Chesnut: A Biography. LSU Press. p. 18. ISBN 0-8071-1804-4.
- Robin Van Auken; Louis E Hunsinger (2003). Williamsport: Boomtown on the Susquehanna. Arcadia Publishing. p. 57. ISBN 0-7385-2438-7.
- "Four Boxes" (PDF). Altamont Enterprise. January 3, 1909. Retrieved 28 September 2010.
- Brian C. Kalt, Michigan State University College of Law (2000). "The People's Forest and Levy's Trees: Popular Sovereignty and the Origins of the Bill of Rights". Constitutional Commentary. 17 (1): 119. SSRN 692765.
- Catherine Lynn (1980). Wallpaper in America: from the seventeenth century to World War I. W. W. Norton & Company. p. 292. ISBN 0-393-01448-7.
- "Many Things Wise and Otherwise" (PDF). Spirit of the Times. 1869-12-25. Retrieved 28 September 2010.
- Wooléver, Adam (Compiled and arranged) (1881). Treasury of wisdom, wit and humor, odd comparisons and proverbs. Philadelphia: E. Claxton & Company. p. 42. Retrieved 27 September 2010.
- Paul Cimbala (2010). The Great Task Remaining Before Us: Reconstruction as America's Continuing Civil War. Fordham Univ Press. p. 66. ISBN 0-8232-3203-4. Retrieved 2010-10-04.
- Frederick Douglass (1892). "Life and Times of Frederick Douglass, Written by Himself". DE WOLFE & FISKE CO. Retrieved 2010-09-27.
- Simplulo (libertarian) (October 4, 2008). "The Five Boxes of Liberty". Retrieved 2010-09-27.
- Marjorie Spruill Wheeler (1995). Votes for women!: the woman suffrage movement in Tennessee, the South, and the nation. Univ. of Tennessee Press. p. 106. ISBN 0-87049-837-1.
- Alan M. Dershowitz (2002). Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age. Little, Brown. p. 38. ISBN 9780316181419.
- "Violent Voices: Anti-Government Extremism Takes on New Intensity" (PDF). Anti-Defamation League. April 2010. Retrieved 2010-09-26.
- Cass R Sunstein (Sep 28, 1998). "Originalism for Liberals". The New Republic. Retrieved 2010-09-27.
- Raymond Booth Eby; John D. Echeverria (1995). Let the people judge: wise use and the private property rights movement. Island Press. p. 24. ISBN 1-55963-276-3.
- Jamie L. Carson; Gregory Koger; Matthew J. Lebo; Everett Young (2010). "The Electoral Costs of Party Loyalty in Congress". American Journal of Political Science. 54 (3): 598–616. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5907.2010.00449.x.
- Mike Nevin. "A Father's Advice (Part II)" (PDF). The Journal. SAN FRANCISCO POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION. Retrieved 2010-09-29.[dead link]
- Peter J. Mancus (February 2005). "PETITION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS AND MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES" (PDF). Retrieved 2010-09-29.
- "About". fourboxesonline.com. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "On Liberty". Boxes Of Liberty. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "Four Boxes". blogspot.com. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "FiveBoxes". fiveboxes.com. Retrieved 2011-12-22.
- "Welcome to the UnitedStatesMilitia.com community !". Jelsoft Enterprises. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "Issues and Positions". Liberty Club of Duval County. Retrieved 2010-09-27.
- James Robinson. "The Four Boxes of Freedom". The Florida Jury Power Association. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "Gun related one-liners". Data 1 Systems. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "Slogans, Quotes & Bumper Stickers". InLibertyAndFreedom.com. Retrieved 2010-09-25.
- "On Firearms and Militia". Campaign For Liberty. 09/04/10. Retrieved 2010-09-25. Check date values in:
- Loree. "The Four Boxes". Retrieved 2010-09-25.