Frontier Crimes Regulation
|Frontier Crimes Regulation, 1901|
|A Regulation further to provide for the suppression of crime in certain frontier districts|
|Citation||Regulation No. III of 1901|
|Territorial extent||Federally Administered Tribal Areas|
|Date repealed||May 28th, 2018|
|The Frontier Crimes (Amendment) Regulation, 2011 (August 27th, 2011)|
|FATA Interim Governance Regulation, 2018|
|Tribal Areas Rewaj Act, Thirty-first Amendment to the Constitution of Pakistan|
The Frontier Crimes Regulations (FCR) were a special set of laws of Pakistan which were applicable to the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) of northwestern Pakistan. They were enacted by the British Empire in the nineteenth century and continue to remain in effect in modern Pakistan. They were extended to the Gilgit Agency in Jammu and Kashmir in 1901 and to Baltistan in 1947, remaining in effect till the 1970s.
The law stated that three basic rights are not applicable to the residents of FATA – appeal, wakeel and daleel (the right to request a change to a conviction in any court, the right to legal representation and the right to present reasoned evidence, respectively).
Following the passing of the Thirty-first Amendment to the Constitution of Pakistan being passed by both Houses of Parliament and the Provincial Assembly of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, President Mamnoon Hussain abolished the FCR and replaced it with the FATA Interim Governance Regulation, 2018, which lays out the future for FATA being merged with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and places FATA under presidential rule.
The Murderous Outrages Regulation was enacted in British India (which includes modern Pakistan) in 1867 to give the government additional powers to prosecute serious crimes such as murder. It was re-enacted in 1873 with minor modifications, and again in 1877 as the "Ghazi Act" for its use in the Pashtun-inhabited frontier districts.[not in citation given] The 1893 unilateral demarcation of the Durand Line by the British as the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan, which divided Pashtun tribes across the border, caused further animosity among the Pashtun.
The regulation was found to be inadequate to contain Pashtun opposition to British and government rule. So new acts have been added to it from time to time. The regulation took their present form primarily through the Frontier Crimes Regulation of 1901. In 1947, the then Dominion of Pakistan added the clause that residents can be arrested without specifying the crime.
The FCR permits collective punishment of family or tribe members for crimes of individuals. It permits punishment to be meted out by unelected tribal jirgas and denies the accused the right to trial by judiciary. Tribal chiefs can also be held responsible for handing over suspects charged by the federal government without specifying an offence. Failure to comply can make the tribal chiefs liable for punishment. Human rights activists and the superior judiciary have argued that the regulation violates basic human rights.
The regulation denies those convicted of an offence by a tribal jirga the right to appeal their conviction in any court. It gives the federal government the right to seize private property in FATA and to convict an individual without due process. It lets the government restrict the entry of a FATA tribe member into a settled district in the rest of Pakistan. The discriminatory provisions of the regulation, both substantive as well as procedural - e.g. selection of jirga members (section 2), trial procedure in civil/criminal matters (sections 8 & 11), demolition of and restriction of construction of hamlet, village or tower in the North-West Frontier Province (section 31), method of arrest/ detention (section 38 & 39) security for good behaviour (sections 40, 42), imposition/collection of fine (sections 22-27), etc. are in violation of the Constitution of Pakistan. The FCR denies tribal residents: the right to be dealt with in accordance with the law; the security of person; safeguards to arrest and detention; protection against double jeopardy or self- incrimination; the inviolability of the dignity of man; prohibition of torture for the purpose of extracting evidence; protection of property rights; and the equality of citizens.
Other articles of the Constitution of Pakistan, such as Article 247, ensure that FATA residents cannot overturn the FCR.
In August 2011, President Asif Ali Zardari enacted a presidential order to amend the FCR. Widely viewed as the most substantive changes in the 110-year history of the regulation, the reforms included new time limits on the amount of time local administration officials can wait before informing that they have taken someone prisoner. In addition, the 2011 amendments placed new restrictions on the collective responsibility clause in the regulation. Among others, changes included:
- Protection of women, children below 16 and all people above 65 from collective responsibility arrest
- Prohibition against arresting an entire tribe under collective responsibility
- Time limits for disposing of cases
- Provision for a more independent appeals process
- Appellate authority power to review decisions
- Strengthening of the FATA Tribunal
- Power to transfer cases from political agent to assistant political agent
- Concept of bail
- Jail inspections
- Voluntary reference to a council of elders and Qaumi Jirga (people's assembly)
- Inclusion of local customs and traditions (Rewaj)
- Fines on communities in case of murder
- Forfeiture of public salary for involvement in crime
- Arrest by authorities other than political agent
- Checks on arbitrary power to arrest
- Punishment and compensation for false prosecutions
- No deprivation of property rights without compensation
- Audit of political agent funds
If implemented in true letter and spirit of the law, these changes could have had a significant impact on the civil and human rights of citizens in Pakistan's tribal areas. However, the changes have been widely criticized and the political administration accused of lacking the will to implement and enforce the FCR as revised in 2011.
Current status in Pakistan
According to the FCR despite the presence of elected tribal representatives, the Parliament of Pakistan can play no role in the affairs of FATA.
Article 247 of the Pakistani Constitution provides that no Act of Parliament applies to FATA, unless the President of Pakistan consents. Only the President is authorized to amend laws and promulgate ordinances for the tribal areas. The elected representatives thus have no say in administration of FATA. It also repeals the jurisdiction of Pakistan's courts over FATA. By inference, this also limits the application of fundamental rights to FATA.
Article 247 and the Federal Crimes Regulation have been condemned by several jurists. Late Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Justice Alvin Robert Cornelius, said that the FCR is "obnoxious to all recognised modern principles governing the dispensation of justice" in the case of Sumunder vs State (PLD 1954 FC 228).)
FATA merger with KP
The National Assembly of Pakistan on Thursday, 24th May 2018, passed a historical constitutional amendment seeking the much-awaited merger of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (Fata) with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) with a 229-1 vote in favour.
This revolts the effect of FCR in FATA, rendering it liable to laws and regulations passed by the KP assembly and operating under the constitution of Pakistan.
- Sökefeld, Martin (2017), "'Not Part of Kashmir, but of the Kashmir Dispute': The Political Predicaments of Gilgit-Baltistan", in Chitralekha Zutshi, Kashmir: History, Politics, Representation, Cambridge University Press, p. 145, note 11, ISBN 978-1-108-22612-7
- "Frontier crimes regulation: Centuries-old law will take time to 'reform'". The Express Tribune. 2011-12-02.
- "Tribespeople freed of FCR as president signs FATA governance regulation". Geo TV. Karachi, Pakistan. 2018-05-28. Retrieved 2018-05-28.
- "Analysis: Pakistan's tribal frontiers". BBC News. 2001-12-14. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "Welcome to FATA". Federally Administered Tribal Areas. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "Justice Denied". Newsline. 2004-12-06. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "Spiralling into Chaos". Newsline. 2004-03-15. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "The Last Refuge". Newsline. 2003-11-10. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "Dark Justice". Newsline. 2002-08-14. Retrieved 2011-12-10.
- "Frontier Crimes Regulation 1901 as Amended in 2011". fatareforms.org. Retrieved 5 June 2014.
- Chaudhry, G.M. "Summary of 2011 Amendments to the Frontier Crimes Regulation". fatareforms.org. Retrieved 5 June 2014.
- Pakistan: New Government Announces Major Reforms In Tribal Areas, Radio Free Europe, April 3, 2008