Gender pay gap in India
This article possibly contains original research. (July 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Gender pay gap in India refers to the difference in earnings between women and men in the paid employment and labor market. For the year 2013, the gender pay gap in India was estimated to be 24.81%. Further, while analyzing the level of female participation in the economy, this report slots India as one of the bottom 10 countries on its list. Thus, in addition to unequal pay, there is also unequal representation, because while women constitute almost half the Indian population (about 48% of the total), their representation in the work force amounts to only about one-fourth of the total. The gender pay gap is considered to be a myth by conservatives and economists, since it does not take into account the total work hours and the working industry of the individual. If an entity is to act upon the wage gap, it would result in a trade off between equality of opportunities to equality of outcomes.
- 1 History and contributing factors
- 2 Legislative protections
- 3 Statistics
- 4 Impact
- 5 See also
- 6 Notes
History and contributing factors
The female labor participation rate in India from 1901 to 1951 was between 28 and 34 percent, which is higher than the level of participation observed in 1990. This rate also varies from state to state. Regions in northern India (which have been observed to be more patriarchal) have lower participation rates for women than the states in southern India, where women have more freedom to participate in the formal economy. SEWA (the Self Employed Women's Association) recently found that the average wage of women workers was Rs. 1815 while the average wage for men was Rs. 3842.
Some of the main factors that contribute to the existing gender pay gap in India are:
The rate of female participation in the paid labor market is generally low, and is primarily concentrated in rural areas in the agricultural sector. In rural north India, it has been observed that labor is divided sharply on the basis of gender. Certain activities in agriculture have been assigned specifically to women, like drying and storing the grain, while other tasks like plowing and harvesting are only performed by men. This is a mere preference and not domination. Female labor participation in India has been observed to be higher in sectors involving personal services and care work, and is also higher in informal sectors, especially in agriculture.
While social and cultural norms vary from state to state within India, one commonality that has been observed is the exclusion of women from the paid labor market and status based segregation of labor. Ironically, women from higher castes faced more difficulty when they tried to obtain paid work, even if their survival depended on it.:45 In interviews conducted with widows from rural North India, they stated that if attempts were made to seek gainful employment outside their homes, they would be forced to give up their property rights and made to leave the villages they live in, indicating that paid work was not a feasible option even to sustain themselves due to the existing social norms.:49 Because childcare is viewed primarily as a woman's job, women often take part-time jobs or take time off during their careers to care for their families. When women return to work after a break, they are paid lower wages than their male colleagues. Women employed full-time ordinarily already earned 34% less than men, but when compared to part-time working women, the pay gap further increased as they earned almost 42% less than men.:13 Additionally, even if women do not have children, it has been observed that they still face pay discrimination as they are viewed as potential mothers, who may require a break from work in the near future.
Education and training
The literacy rate for women in India is far lower than the rate for men, and it has been observed that many girls drop out of school and fail to fully complete their education.:76 Investment in education and training has also been strongly in favor of men as they are brought up with the expectation of being bread earners, and hence this investment is considered necessary for their success, while women are instead viewed as "future homemakers" for whom education may not be as essential.:325
According to the Human Development Report 1995, women spend about two-thirds of their working time on unpaid work, while men spend only one-fourth of their time towards unpaid labor. It has been estimated in India that women on average work twenty-one more hours than men during each week. Agriculture currently accounts for over two-thirds of the current employment in India, but most of the work women contribute to this sector is not accounted for or officially documented. This again does not take into consideration the total population of men and women in the workforce.
India has been a permanent member of the ILO Governing Body from 1922. In September 1958, India ratified the C100 Equal Remuneration Convention, 1951 (No. 100), which addressed the issue of equal pay between men and women for work of equal value. This convention requires all member states to direct their national laws and policies towards guaranteeing equal remuneration to all workers, regardless of gender. In an attempt to ensure compliance with this convention and in response to the Report by the Committee on status of women in India, the government enacted the Equal Remuneration Act.
Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
In 1976, the Equal Remuneration Act was passed with the aim of providing equal remuneration to men and women workers and to prevent discrimination on the basis of gender in all matters relating to employment and employment opportunities. This legislation not only provides women with a right to demand equal pay, but any inequality with respect to recruitment processes, job training, promotions, and transfers within the organization can also be challenged under this Act. However, its scope does not extend to situations where: (i) a woman is attempting to comply with the requirements of laws giving women special treatment; and (ii) a woman is being accorded special treatment on account of the birth of a child, or the terms and conditions relating to retirement, marriage or death. Companies and individual employers can both be held accountable to maintain the standards prescribed under this Act. In various cases, the Supreme Court of India has also held that discrimination on the basis of gender only arises when men and women perform the same work or work of a similar nature. However, it clarified that a flexible approach is required to be taken while deciding which kinds of work may be similar by considering the duties actually performed as a part of the job, and not the duties potentially capable of being performed.
As part of its Directive Principles of State Policy, the Constitution of India through Article 39 envisages that all states ideally direct their policy towards securing equal pay for equal work for both men and women, and also ensuring that men and women have the right to an adequate means of livelihood. While these Directive Principles are not enforceable by any court of law, they are crucial to the governance of the country and a state is duty bound to consider them while enacting laws.
While “equal pay for equal work” is not expressly a constitutional right, it has been read into the Constitution through the interpretation of Articles 14, 15 and 16 – which guarantee equality before the law, protection against discrimination and equality of opportunity in matters of public employment. The Supreme Court of India has also declared this to be a constitutional goal, available to every individual and capable of being attained through the enforcement of their fundamental rights set out in Articles 14 through 16. In a popular Supreme Court decision, the conditions of employment of the air-hostesses of Air India was challenged. The terms of employment required the mandatory retirement of females: (i) upon attaining the age of 33; (ii) if they were married within four years of service; or (iii) upon their first pregnancy. The court however struck down these provisions and held them to be arbitrary and discriminatory as it violated Articles 14, 15 and 16 of the Constitution.
While legislation like the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 and the Factories Act, 1948 do not directly address the issue of equal pay for equal work, they provide certain additional benefits a woman can claim. The Maternity Benefit Act applies to all establishments with more than ten employees. However, in states where the Employees’ State Insurance Act applies, employers no longer have any liability under the Maternity Benefit Act. Under this Act, a pregnant woman worker is entitled to 12 weeks of fully paid maternity leave, and six weeks in case of miscarriage or termination of pregnancy. Pregnant women also have the right to not perform physically arduous work, which may affect their pregnancy, and no deductions can be made from their wages because of this. Additionally, as per the Factories Act, employers are required to provide childcare for children under 6 years old at all worksites that employ over 30 women.
The gender pay gap varies across Indian states, and is the highest in the following states:
|State||Women's earnings as a percentage of men's earnings|
|Rajasthan and Kerala||44%|
Uttarakhand on the other hand is the state with the lowest percentage of gender pay gap, with females earning only 9% less than men. Punjab and Uttar Pradesh are also states with a lower gender pay gap, following with 10% and 15%, respectively.
The gender pay gap in India increases with an increase in educational qualifications. While comparing men and women who had only completed high-school level education, it was observed that women earned 10.34% less than men. Women who had gone to college for four to five years or who had received advanced degrees earned around 30% less than their male counterparts. With an increase in the level of education, where women had obtained a Master's degree of a Ph.D equivalent, it was observed that the gender pay gap ranged between 44% to 46%.
Research suggests that when countries are able to raise the female labor participation rate, this stands to benefit the entire economy. Apart from potential GDP growth, equal employment opportunities for women could also result in increased growth and profitability in the private sector. In countries where the population is aging quickly, an increase in the female labor participation rate would help offset the negative effects of a declining workforce. It is also important to note that women in India perform 9.8 times the amount of labor in the unpaid sector either through household duties or care work. If this work was measured and valued, it was estimated by McKinsey that it would contribute 0.3 trillion dollars to India's total economic output.
- Equal pay for equal work
- Gender discrimination in India
- Gender inequality in India
- Gender pay gap
- Indian labor law
- Labor in India
- Social issues in India
- Women in India
- Dutta, Puja (2005). "Accounting for Wage Inequality in India" (PDF). The Indian Journal of Labour Economics.
- "Gender Pay Gap in the Formal Sector: 2006 - 2013(September, 2013)". Wage Indicator Data Report.
- "Eleventh Five Year Plan (2007-2012) Planning Commission, Government of India".
- Esteve-Volart, Berta (2004). "Gender Discrimination and Growth: Theory and Evidence from India (January, 2004)" (PDF). London School of Economics.
- Staff Discussion Note, IMF (September 2013). "Women, Work, and the Economy: Macroeconomic Gains from Gender Equity" (PDF). International Monetary Fund.
- Martha C. Nussbaum, Jonathan Glover, Martha Chen (1995). "Women, Culture, and Development: A Study of Human Capabilities". Clarendon Press.
- Dewan, Sabina (2014). "Closing the Gender wage gap in Indian Agriculture" (PDF). JustJobs Network.
- Anil Kumar Mishra, Tauffiqu Ahamad, Jitendra Kumar Pandey, (December 2014). "The Status of Women Workers in the Unorganized Sector" (PDF). Newman International Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, Volume 1, Issue 12. pp. 72–79.
- Leeja Anand, Biju Varkkey, Rupa Korde, (September 2012). "Gender Pay Gap in the Formal Sector: Preliminary Evidence from Paycheck India Data". WageIndicator Data Report.
- Rustagi, Preet (2005). "Understanding Gender Inequalities in Wages and Incomes in India" (PDF). The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, Vol. 48, No. 2.
- "The Invisible Heart— Care and the Global Economy" (PDF).
- "C100 - Equal Remuneration Convention, 1951 (No. 100), Article 1".
- "Equal Pay for Equal Work in India - A Socio-legal Imperative" (PDF).
- "Section 4 and 5, Equal Remuneration Act, 1976" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on April 21, 2015.
- "Section 15, Equal Remuneration Act, 1976" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on April 21, 2015.
- "Section 11, Equal Remuneration Act, 1976" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on April 21, 2015.
- "Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co. Ltd. v. Audrey D' Costa & Another". (1987) 2 SCC 469.
- Devi, Kovuru (January 1, 2000). Women's Equality in India: A Myth Or Reality?. pp. 49–50. ISBN 81-7141-563-6.
- "The Constitution of India, Articles 14 - 16" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2014-09-09.
- Union of India v. Dineshan K.K.,. (2008) 1 SCC 586.
- Air India vs. Nargesh Mirza,. AIR 1981 SC 1829.
- "Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (Act No. 53 of 1961), Section 2" (PDF).
- Papola, T.S. "An Assessment of the Labour Statistics System in India, 2014" (PDF). International Labour Organization.
- "The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (Act No. 53 of 1961), Section 4 and 6" (PDF).
- "The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (Act No. 53 of 1961), Sections 4 and 13" (PDF).
- "The Factories Act, 1948 (Act No. 63 of 1948), Section 48".
- "Investing in Women's Employment" (PDF). International Finance Corporation, World Bank Group. 2013.
- "The Power of Parity: Advancing Women's Equality in India". McKinsey Global Institute. November 2015.