Gerhart Eisler on 1977 GDR stamp
20 February 1897|
Leipzig, German Empire
21 March 1968 (aged 71)|
Yerevan, Armenia, USSR
|Citizenship||East German (later life)|
|Political party||Austrian German Communist Party (KPDÖ), Communist Party of Germany (KPD), Communist International|
1. Hede Tune Massing|
2. Elli Tune
3. Hilde Vogel-Rothstein
|Parent(s)||Marie Fischer, Rudolf Eisler|
|Relatives||Hanns Eisler, Ruth Fischer|
Gerhart Eisler (20 February 1897 – 21 March 1968) was a German politician. Along with his sister Ruth Fischer, he was a very early member of the Austrian German Communist Party (KPDÖ) and then a prominent member of the Communist Party of Germany during the Weimar Republic.
Life and career
Eisler was born in Leipzig, the son of Marie Edith Fischer and Rudolf Eisler, a professor of philosophy at Leipzig but of Austrian nationality. His father was Jewish and his mother was Lutheran.
His brother was the leftist composer Hanns Eisler and his sister was Communist activist Ruth Fischer. In November 1918, Eisler returned from the front of World War I and joined the Austrian Communist Party under the influence of his older sister. In 1919, he married Hede Massing (1900–1981). In 1920, he followed his sister to Berlin, where in January 1921 he became associate editor of the Die Rote Fahne. It was Germany's leading left-wing newspaper.
He left Hede in 1923 for her sister Elli Tune. Elli left him with their baby daughter Natasha in 1933, when she could no longer cope with the demands the Comintern made on him. In 1937 he met Hilde Vogel-Rothstein and they married in Queens, New York City in 1942. His first wife Hede and her third husband Paul Massing both spied for the Soviet Union in the USA and they all kept in touch. Hede Massing later turned towards the FBI and testified against Alger Hiss in his second trial.
Hede Massing saw Eisler on his return to the Soviet Union: "Gerhart… was involved in the Wittdorf affair, a political maneuver to dethrone Ernst Thälmann, who was supported by Stalin…. Gerhart was, after a time, in complete isolation in Moscow, forbidden to read German papers in order to get Germany out of his system, and then sent as Comintern representative to China where, according to many reports, he achieved great success through his ruthless policy. He stepped back into Stalin's favor." 
From 1929 to 1931 he was a liaison between the Communist International and the Communist Parties in China and then from 1933 to 1936 to the United States. Time reported in 1947 that he had made a trip to China in the late 1920s during which he earned the name "the executioner" for "purging the party of spies and dissidents".
Eisler was charged in two trials in 1947 first with refusing to answer the HUAC, then of violating U.S. laws by misrepresenting his Communist Party affiliation on his immigration application. He was sentenced to one and three years in prison, but was soon released on bail. Newsweek described him in its February 23, 1948, issue as the "number one Red agent".
In 1948, Lee Pressman of New York and Joseph Forer of Washington, DC, represented Eisler along with Charles A. Doyle of the Gas, Coke and Chemical Workers Union; Irving Potash, vice president of the Fur and Leather Workers Union; Ferdinand C. Smith, secretary of the National Maritime Union; and John Williamson, labor secretary of the CPUSA). On May 5, 1948, Pressman and Forer received a preliminary injunction so their defendants might have hearings with examiners unconnected with the investigations and prosecutions by examiners of the Immigration and Naturalization Service.
When his last legal appeal had failed he jumped bail and secretly boarded the Polish liner MS Batory bound for London in May 1949. He was discovered by the crew only after the ship was at sea.
Once in England, he was dragged off the ship by his hands and feet, but the authorities allowed him to leave for the German Democratic Republic where Eisler became chief of East German radio. His wife was arrested after his escape and deported, but later joined him in East Germany. After his death during an official visit in Yerevan, Armenia, several schools and streets in the German Democratic Republic were named in his honor. His cremation urn was placed at the Zentralfriedhof Friedrichsfelde in Berlin. Files from the UK National Archives released on 4 March 2008 included information about Gerhart Eisler. The MI5 summary states:
Eisler, who was supposed by many to be the covert leader and director of the Communist Party in America during and after the Second World War, became the centre of a diplomatic incident in 1949 when, having stowed away on a Polish ship out of New York, he was forcibly removed and arrested in Southampton. This file documents the Security Service's involvement in the case. The earliest traces of Eisler in the file (KV 2/2773, 1936–1949) date from 1936, when Comintern efforts to secure a false American passport in the name of Edwards were reported. In 1947 information obtained from Eisler's former wife, Hedwiga Messing, suggested that Eisler had used this cover name in New York in 1934.
An allegation from former Communist Louis F. Budenz that Lillian Hellman hosted a dinner party for Eisler the night before he stowed away on the Batory was instrumental in labeling her an active Communist and in the subsequent dismissal of John F. Melby from the U.S. State Department in 1953.
- The Lesson of Germany: A Guide to Her History (1945)
- Eisler Hits Back: A Reply to Rankin Men (1946)
- Five Men on a Hunger Strike (1949)
- "Foreign Ideas" in Fighting Words (1949)
- Wir reden hier nicht von Napoleon: Wir reden von Ihnen! (1971)
- Auf der Hauptstraße der Weltgeschichte (1981)
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Gerhart Eisler.|
- Bentley, Eric (1971). Thirty Years of Treason. New York: Viking Press. pp. 57–109.
- Singer, Kurt D. (1953). "The men in the Trojan horse".
- "Woman with a Past", Time, 19 December 1949
- Hede Massing, This Deception: KBG Targets America (1951) pages 81-82
- "The Man from Moscow", Time, 17 February 1947
- "Eisler, 4 Others Win New Hearings: Goldsborough Enjoins Their Deportation Pending Compliance With 1946 Law". New York Times. 6 May 1948. p. 18. Retrieved 18 March 2017.
- Robert P. Newman, The Cold War Romance of Lillian Hellman and John Melby, (University of North Carolina Press, 1989), pp. 136-38, 188, 198, 201, 311
- Eisler, Gerhart; Norden, Albert; Schreiner, Albert (1945). The Lesson of Germany: A Guide to Her History. International Publishers. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- Eisler, Gerhart (1946). Eisler Hits Back: A Reply to Rankin Men. German American. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- Five Men on a Hunger Strike. Civil Rights Congress. 1949. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- Eisler, Gerhart (1949). "Foreign Ideas". Fighting Words. Daily Worker. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- Notowicz, Nathan; Eisler, Hanns; Eisler, Gerhart (1971). Wir reden hier nicht von Napoleon: Wir reden von Ihnen!. Neue Musik. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- Eisler, Gerhart (1981). "Foreign Ideas". Auf der Hauptstraße der Weltgeschichte. Dietz. Retrieved 26 July 2017.
- State Department passport brief, A115–A116
- Investigation of Un-American Propaganda Activities in the United States, hearings of 6 February 1947, U.S. Congress, House of Representatives, House Un-American Activities Committee, 80th Cong., 1st sess., 14–19.
- "The Brain", Time, Monday, 28 October 1946
- Schebera, Jürgen (1998). Hans Eisler, Eine Biographie in Texten, Bildern und Dokumenten. Mainz: Schott. Retrieved 26 July 2017.