|Born||1956/1957 (age 60–61)
|Alma mater||School of Oriental and African Studies|
|Occupation||Writer, journalist, film director, human rights activist.|
|Parent(s)||Nayantara Sahgal (mother)|
|Relatives||Vijayalakshmi Pandit (grandmother);
Jawaharlal Nehru (great uncle)
Gita Sahgal (Kashmiri: गीता सहगल (Devanagari), گیتا سہگل (Nastaleeq)), born 1956/1957 (age 60–61) in Bombay, India, is a writer and journalist on issues of feminism, fundamentalism, and racism, a director of prize-winning documentary films, and a women's rights and human rights activist.
She has been a co-founder and active member of women's organisations. She has also been head of Amnesty International's Gender Unit, and has opposed the oppression of women in particular by religious fundamentalists.
In February 2010 she was suspended by Amnesty as head of its Gender Unit after she was quoted by The Sunday Times criticising Amnesty for its high-profile associations with Moazzam Begg, director of the campaign group CAGE (formerly Cageprisoners), that represents men detained at Guantanamo under extrajudicial conditions. She referred to him as "Britain's most famous supporter of the Taliban". Amnesty responded that she was suspended "for not raising these issues internally." Speaking in her support were the writer Salman Rushdie, the journalist Christopher Hitchens and others, who also criticised Amnesty for this affiliation. Begg disputed her claims of his jihadi connections and said that he did not consider anyone a terrorist who had not been convicted of terrorism.
Sahgal left Amnesty International on 9 April 2010.
- 1 Early life and education
- 2 Career
- 3 Amnesty International controversy
- 4 Select writings
- 5 Notes
- 6 External links
Early life and education
Gita Sahgal was born in India, the daughter of the novelist Nayantara Sahgal. She was raised as a Hindu, and says she is now an atheist. She is a great-niece of former Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, and the granddaughter of his sister Vijayalakshmi Pandit. Schooled first in India, she moved to England in 1972, where she attended and graduated from the School of Oriental and African Studies in London. She returned to India in 1977, and began working in the civil rights movement. She moved back to England in 1983.
In 1989 she co-founded and has participated with Women against Fundamentalism. It has criticised Great Britain for protecting only Christianity and its by blasphemy laws. She believes this exclusion of protection for immigrant religions contributes to the growth of sectarianism and immigrants' turning towards religious fundamentalism.
Commenting on the use of rape in wars, Sahgal said in 2004 that such assaults are not typically a means of taking women as "spoils of war" or meeting sexual needs. She said rape is used intentionally as a way to disrupt the conquered society and to increase the territory of the conquering ethnic group via impregnating the conquered women.
Prostitution and peacekeeping efforts
Sahgal spoke out in 2004 regarding the increase of prostitution and sex abuse associated with humanitarian intervention forces. She observed: "The issue with the UN is that peacekeeping operations unfortunately seem to be doing the same thing that other militaries do. Even the guardians have to be guarded."
Invasion of Iraq; Views on Guantanamo Bay
Sahgal, who was against the United States and allies' invasion of Iraq, also condemned the extrajudicial detention and torture of Muslim men at Guantanamo Bay. She told Moazzam Begg, a British citizen and former Guantanamo Bay detainee, that she was "horrified and appalled" by the treatment he and other detainees received.
Writing and film producer
Among her various writings, in 1992, she contributed to and co-edited Refusing Holy Orders: Women and Fundamentalism in Britain with Nira Yuval-Davis.
In 2002 she produced Tying the Knot. The film was commissioned by the U.K.'s Foreign and Commonwealth Office's Community Liaison Unit, set up to handle the problem of British victims of forced marriage who have been, or may be, taken abroad to marry against their will. Sahgal said she was not opposed to arranged marriages unless the persons involved were abducted or subjected to physical or emotional abuse.
Saghal also made Unprovoked, a film about the case of Kiranjit Ahluwalia, for Despatches, one of British TV’s main investigative documentary programs. Ahluwalia is a Punjabi woman brought to the UK by arranged marriage who was repeatedly abused by her husband. To survive, she killed him, setting him on fire while he was drunk and asleep. She was acquitted of murder charges on the grounds of self defence.
Amnesty International controversy
Saghal's public criticism
Sahgal joined the staff of Amnesty International in 2002, and the following year became head of its gender unit. She came to wide public attention in February 2010, after she was quoted by The Sunday Times in an article about Amnesty and suspended by the organization. She had criticised Amnesty for its high-profile associations with Moazzam Begg, the director of Cageprisoners, representing men in extrajudicial detention. "To be appearing on platforms with Britain’s most famous supporter of the Taliban Begg, whom we treat as a human rights defender, is a gross error of judgment," she said. Sahgal argued that by associating with Begg and Cageprisoners, Amnesty was risking its reputation on human rights. "As a former Guantanamo detainee, it was legitimate to hear his experiences, but as a supporter of the Taliban it was absolutely wrong to legitimise him as a partner,” Sahgal said. She said she repeatedly brought the matter up with Amnesty for two years, to no avail. A few hours after the article was published, Saghal was suspended from her position. Amnesty's Senior Director of Law and Policy, Widney Brown, later said Sahgal raised concerns about Begg and Cageprisoners to her personally for the first time a few days before sharing them with the Sunday Times.
Sahgal issued a statement saying she felt that Amnesty was risking its reputation by associating with and thereby politically legitimising Begg, because Cageprisoners "actively promotes Islamic Right ideas and individuals". She said the issue was not about Begg's "freedom of opinion, nor about his right to propound his views: he already exercises these rights fully as he should. The issue is ... the importance of the human rights movement maintaining an objective distance from groups and ideas that are committed to systematic discrimination and fundamentally undermine the universality of human rights." The controversy prompted responses by politicians, the writer Salman Rushdie, and journalist Christopher Hitchens, among others who criticised Amnesty's association with Begg.
After her suspension and the controversy, Saghal was interviewed by numerous media and attracted international supporters. She was interviewed on National Public Radio (NPR) on 27 February, where she discussed the activities of Cageprisoners and why she deemed it inappropriate for Amnesty to associate with Begg. She said that Cageprisoners' Asim Qureshi spoke supporting global jihad at a Hizb ut-Tahrir rally. She noted that a best seller at Begg's bookshop was a book by Abdullah Azzam, a mentor of Osama bin Laden and a founder of the terrorist organization Lashkar-e-Taiba.
In a separate interview for the Indian Daily News & Analysis, Saghal said that, as Quereshi affirmed Begg's support for global jihad on a BBC World Service programme, "these things could have been stated in his [Begg's] introduction" with Amnesty. She said that Begg's bookshop had published The Army of Madinah, which she characterised as a jihad manual by Dhiren Barot.
Amnesty responded on its website with a statement by its interim Secretary General, Claudio Cordone:
[Sahgal] was suspended ... for not raising these issues internally... [Begg] speaks about his own views ..., not Amnesty International's... Sometimes the people whose rights we defend may not share each others views–but they all have human rights, and all human rights are worth defending.
Responding to a petition supporting Sahgal from Sunila Abeysekera (a veteran Sri Lankan human rights campaigner), Amrita Chhachhi (a senior lecturer in women's and gender studies at the Institute of Social Studies in The Hague), and Sara Hossain (a Bangladesh Supreme Court advocate), Cordone wrote:
Begg and others in his group Cageprisoners also hold other views which they have clearly stated, for example on ... the role of jihad in self-defense. Are such views antithetical to human rights? Our answer is no, even if we may disagree with them.
Abeysekera, Chhachhi, and Hossain called Cordone's assertion "shocking".
Widney Brown of Amnesty also spoke on the NPR program with Saghal. She said the books sold at his bookstore did not mean that he was not "a legitimate voice on Guantanamo Bay abuses". Responding to the interviewer's observation that Amnesty had sponsored Begg's lecture tours in Europe, she said that because Begg was one of the first detainees released, he was considered important for dispelling Guantanamo Bay's secrecy. Brown said that, as a British citizen, Begg has "an incredibly effective voice in talking to governments in Europe about the importance of" their accepting Guantanamo detainees. She praised Saghal's work, saying:
There's no question about it. Gita is incredibly intelligent, very strong analysis .... She's done great work for us. And I think the real tragedy of this particular circumstance is by going public in this particular way knowing that we were addressing her issue means that she's maybe undermining her own work in fact.
Amnesty's international secretariat Policy Director, Anne Fitzgerald, when asked if she thought Begg was a human rights advocate, said: “It’s something you’d have to speak to him about. I don’t have the information to answer that.”
In April 2010, Amnesty circulated a statement internally, saying:
Due to irreconcilable differences of view over policy between Gita Sahgal and Amnesty International regarding Amnesty International’s relationship with Moazzam Begg and Cageprisoners, it has been agreed that Gita will leave Amnesty International on 9 April 2010.
Begg said of the Taliban: “We need to be engaging with those people who we find most unpalatable. I don’t consider anybody a terrorist until they have been charged and convicted of terrorism.”
Amnesty ... has done its reputation incalculable damage by allying itself with Moazzam Begg and his group Cageprisoners, and holding them up as human rights advocates. It looks very much as if Amnesty's leadership is suffering from a kind of moral bankruptcy, and has lost the ability to distinguish right from wrong. It has greatly compounded its error by suspending the redoubtable Gita Sahgal for the crime of going public with her concerns. Gita Sahgal is a woman of immense integrity and distinction.... It is people like Gita Sahgal who are the true voices of the human rights movement; Amnesty and Begg have revealed, by their statements and actions, that they deserve our contempt.
Denis MacShane, a Member of the British Parliament and former Labour government minister, wrote to Amnesty protesting its suspension of Gita Sahgal: "one of its most respected researchers because she rightly called into question Amnesty’s endorsement of Mozzam Begg whose views on the Taliban and on Islamist jihad stand in total contradiction of everything Amnesty has fought for." He called "Kafkaesque" the fact that Amnesty—"the very organisation meant to defend human rights"—would threaten the career of Sahgal for her having exposed "an ideology that denies human rights".
Writing in The National Post, writer Christopher Hitchens said "It's well-nigh incredible that Amnesty should give a platform to people who are shady on this question and absolutely disgraceful that it should suspend a renowned employee who gave voice to her deep and sincere misgivings," writing in The Independent, journalist and human rights activist Joan Smith said "Amnesty's mistake is simple and egregious", and writing in The Spectator journalist Martin Bright said: "It is Gita Sahgal who should be the darling of the human rights establishment, not Moazzam Begg," and columnist Melanie Phillips wrote "her real crime has been to expose the extraordinary sympathy by white 'liberals', committed to 'human rights', for Islamic jihadists—who are committed to the extinction of human rights." The Times (not connected to The Sunday Times) wrote: "In an extraordinary inversion of its traditional role, Amnesty has stifled its own still small voice of conscience," and journalist Nick Cohen wrote in The Observer "Amnesty is living in the make-believe world ... where it thinks that liberals are free to form alliances with defenders of clerical fascists who want to do everything in their power to suppress liberals, most notably liberal-minded Muslims." Antara Dev Sen wrote in Daily News and Analysis: "It was a gutsy stand, given the dread of political correctness that cripples our thought and makes us bend over backwards till we almost topple over. ... Suspending Sahgal was an illiberal knee-jerk response unbecoming of this cherished human rights organisation." Farrukh Dhondy wrote in her support, in The Asian Age, as did The Herald (Scotland), columnist and author Mona Charen in Australia's The Daily Advertiser, commentator Jonathan Power in Dubai's Khaleej Times, journalist and author Terry Glavin in the National Post, columnist Rod Liddle in The Spectator, columnist Jay Nordlinger in National Review, and David Aaronovitch in a column in The Times entitled "How Amnesty Chose the Wrong Poster-boy". Feminist historian Urvashi Butalia also spoke up in her support. Douglas Murray wrote in The Telegraph that "Amnesty is longer an organisation worth listening to, let alone supporting", and The Wall Street Journal wrote: "it's a pity that a group that was born to give voice to the victims of oppression should now devote itself to sanitizing the oppressors".
Sahgal's mother, Nehru's niece novelist Nayantara Sahgal, said she was proud of Gita:
for her very correct and courageous stand. Gita had been taking up the matter for a couple of years now, but after not having received a response she decided to go public—which was a very brave thing to do.... Amnesty has been supporting Begg, legitimising him, making him a partner and sponsoring his tour of Europe. They should at least have checked his credentials. It simply gives them a bad reputation.
The Observer wrote in April 2010 that Amnesty had faced few sticker periods since it was founded in 1961, and Oliver Kamm wrote in The Times that "Disastrously for itself and those who depend on its support, Amnesty is no longer the friend of liberty".
Leaked extracts from an internal 10 February 2010 memo by Amnesty's Asia-Pacific director Sam Zarifi, which echoed some of the concerns raised by Sahgal, were published by The Sunday Times. In the memo he said Amnesty made a mistake in not making it clearer they did not support Begg's views. Zarifi said Amnesty "did not always sufficiently distinguish between the rights of detainees to be free from torture, and the validity of their views", adding that the organisation "did not always clarify that while we champion the rights of all—including terrorism suspects, and more important, victims of terrorism—we do not champion their views”. In a subsequent letter to The Sunday Times, Zarifi said he agreed with Amnesty's actions with regard to Sahgal.
In response to Zarifi's objections, Amnesty changed their minds about hiring Begg. Widney Brown said: "Sam's view was that, no, he was not the right person for [our South Asia campaigns]. He raised the concern, and he was heard."
British journalist for Press TV, the Iranian-based English language news channel, and Cageprisoners patron, Yvonne Ridley, said Begg was being "demonised", and that he was "a great supporter of women and a promoter of their rights".
Andy Worthington, critic of Guantanamo Bay detention camp, and friend of Moazzam Begg, also cited Islamophobia, and then defended Begg. He said, "I know from personal experience that Moazzam Begg is no extremist. We have met on numerous occasions, have had several long discussions, and have shared platforms together at many events."
- Refusing holy orders: women and fundamentalism in Britain, co-editor with Nira Yuval-Davis, and contributor, Virago Press (1992), WLUML (2002), ISBN 1-85381-219-6
- Looking at class: film, television and the working class in Britain, Sheila Rowbotham, Huw Beynon, "Chapter: Struggle Not Submission", Rivers Oram Press, 2001, ISBN 1-85489-121-9
- Feminist postcolonial theory: a reader, Reina Lewis, Sara Mills, Chapter: "The Uses of Fundamentalism", with Nira Yuval-Davis, Taylor & Francis, 2003, ISBN 0-415-94275-6
- The situated politics of belonging, Nira Yuval-Davis, Kalpana Kannabirān, Ulrike Vieten, "Chapter: Legislating Utopia? Violence Against Women: Identities and Interventions," SAGE, 2006, ISBN Ch1412921015
- Shah, Neelima (19 February 2010). "It's Very Human To Disagree; She feels the rip of Amnesty International's barbs for speaking up; Neelima Shah on Gita Sahgal". Outlook. Retrieved 21 February 2010.
- Mark Townsend (25 April 2010). "Gita Sahgal's dispute with Amnesty International puts human rights group in the dock | World news". The Observer. London. Retrieved 27 April 2010.
- Hasan Suroor (9 February 2010). "Suroor, Hasan, "Amnesty in row over "collaborating" with pro-jehadis", The Hindu, 9 February 2010. Retrieved 16 February 2010". The Hindu. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- Guttenplan, D.D.; Margaronis, Maria. "Who Speaks for Human Rights?". The Nation. Retrieved 12 March 2016.
- The situated politics of belonging – Google Books. Books.google.com. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- Nair, Malini (21 February 2010). "A fundamental question for human rights groups". Daily News & Review. Retrieved 1 March 2010.
- "Women Against Fundamentalisms | Variant 16". Variant.org.uk. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- Amit Roy (10 February 2010). "The Telegraph – Calcutta (Kolkata) | Amnesty suspends Nehru kin". The Telegraph. Calcutta. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- Sahgal, Gita (13 May 2010). "Gita Sahgal: A Statement". Retrieved 30 September 2015.
- Kerbaj, Richard (7 February 2010). "Amnesty International is 'damaged' by Taliban link; An official at the human rights charity deplores its work with a 'jihadist'". The Sunday Times. London. Retrieved 2 March 2010.
- Bird, Steve (13 April 2010). "Gita Sahgal, who criticised Amnesty's 'pro-jihadi' links, leaves job". The Times. London. Retrieved 12 April 2010.
- "Amnesty suspends Nehru kin Gita Sahgal – NewsofAP.com – Andhra Pradesh News, Andhra News ,Andhra Pradesh, Telugu News". NewsofAP.com. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- Hasan Suroor (9 February 2010). "The Hindu : News / International : Amnesty in row over "collaborating" with pro-jehadis". The Hindu. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- ""Who Are SBS?", Southall Black Sisters. Retrieved 28 February 2010". Southallblacksisters.org.uk. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- Smith-Spark, Laura (8 December 2004). "In Depth | How did rape become a weapon of war?". BBC News. Retrieved 4 March 2010.
- "Sex charges haunt UN forces; In places like Congo and Kosovo, peacekeepers have been accused of abusing the people they're protecting," Christian Science Monitor, 26 November 2004. Retrieved 16 February 2010
- "The right-on are wrong to champion so-called victims". The Herald (Scotland). 11 February 2010. Retrieved 2 March 2010.
- ""Team", Centre for Secular Space. Retrieved 12 March 2015". www.centreforsecularspace.org. Retrieved 12 March 2015.[permanent dead link]
- ""Gita Sahgal", National Secular Society. Retrieved 12 March 2015". www.secularism.org.uk. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
- "Video on 'forced marriages' sent to schools," BBC News, 11 March 2002. Retrieved 21 February 2010
- Ruchir Joshi (10 June 2007). "'Unprovoked'-A historic moment swallowed by the box office". The Telegraph. Calcutta. Retrieved 16 February 2010.
- Gupta, Rahila, "Double standards on human rights; Where does Amnesty International stand on women's rights after suspending Gita Sahgal for criticising links with Moazzam Begg?," The Guardian, 9 February 2010. Retrieved 11 February 2010
- Aaronovitch, David (9 February 2010). "How Amnesty chose the wrong poster-boy; Collaboration with Moazzam Begg, an extremist who has supported jihadi movements, looks like a serious mistake". The Times. London. Retrieved 2 March 2010.
- ""Amnesty chief suspended after attacking group's links to 'Britain's most famous Taliban supporter'", Daily Mail, 9 February 2010. Retrieved 10 February 2010". Daily Mail. London. 9 February 2010. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- "Bright, Martin, "Gita Sahgal: A Statement", ''Spectator'', 7 February 2010. Retrieved 10 February 2010". The Spectator. 7 February 2010. Archived from the original on 16 March 2010. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- "Joan Smith: Amnesty shouldn't support men like Moazzam Begg; A prisoner of conscience can turn into an apologist for extremism," The Independent, 11 February 2010. Retrieved 11 February 2010
- "Is Amnesty International Supporting a Jihadist?". All Things Considered. NPR. 27 February 2010. Retrieved 28 February 2010.
- Chakraberty, Sumit, "Gita Sahgal talks about human wrongs", Daily News & Analysis, 21 February 2010. Retrieved 28 February 2010.
- "Dangerous liaisons". Daily News and Analysis. 18 April 2010. Retrieved 27 April 2010.
- ""Amnesty International on its work with Moazzam Begg and Cageprisoners," 11 February 2010. Retrieved 11 February 2010". Amnestyusa.org. 11 February 2010. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- Hasan Suroor (2 April 2010). "The Hindu : News / International : Row over support for "defensive jihad''". The Hindu. Retrieved 8 April 2010.
- "Top Human Rights Group Blasted for 'Defensive Jihad' Comments". CNSNews.com. Retrieved 8 April 2010.
- "Amnesty International Comes Out of the Closet – Endorses "Defensive" Jihad – Andy McCarthy – The Corner on National Review Online". Corner.nationalreview.com. 3 April 2010. Retrieved 8 April 2010.
- Salman Rushdie's statement on Amnesty International, The Sunday Times, 21 February 2010
- "Amnesty has no morals, says Rushdie", The Times of India, 22 February 2010. Retrieved 28 February 2010.
- MacShane, Member of British Parliament, Denis (10 February 2010). "Letter To Amnesty International from". Retrieved 17 February 2010.
- Phillips, Melanie (14 February 2010). "The human wrongs industry spits out one of its own". The Spectator. Archived from the original on 17 February 2010. Retrieved 23 February 2010.
- Smith, Joan "Joan Smith: Amnesty shouldn't support men like Moazzam Begg; A prisoner of conscience can turn into an apologist for extremism", The Independent, 11 February 2010. Retrieved 17 February 2010
- Hitchens, Christopher, "Christopher Hitchens: Amnesty International's suspension of conscience", The National Post, 17 February 2010. Retrieved 17 February 2010
- Bright, Martin, "Amnesty International, Moazzam Begg and the Bravery of Gita Sahgal", The Spectator, 7 February 2010 Archived 11 February 2010 at the Wayback Machine.
- "Misalliance; Amnesty has lent spurious legitimacy to extremists who spurn its values," The Times, 12 February 2010. Retrieved 17 February 2010
- Cohen, Nick, "We abhor torture – but that requires paying a price; Spineless judges, third-rate politicians and Amnesty prefer an easy life to fighting for liberty," The Observer, 14 February 2010, 17 February 2010
- Sen, Antara Dev (25 February 2010). "Amnesty's illiberal knee-jerk response". Daily News and Analysis. Retrieved 10 October 2015.
- "No amnesty for dissent," The Asian Age, 20 February 2010. Retrieved 21 February 2010
- Charen, Mona, "Amnesty International betrays its own mission", The Daily Advertiser, 1 March 2010. Retrieved 2 March 2010
- Power, Jonathan, "Amnesty International Off the Piste", Khaleej Times, 28 February 2010. Retrieved 28 February 2010
- Liddle, Rod "Why give money to charity when they shaft what they purport to defend?", The Spectator, 8 February 2010. Retrieved 2 March 2010
- "Glavin, Terry, "Terry Glavin: Amnesty International doubles down on appeasement; This has been going on for far too long. Now it's gone too far," ''National Post'', 8 February 2010, 2 March 2010". National Post. Retrieved 18 March 2010.[permanent dead link]
- Murray, Douglas (14 April 2010). "If you support Amnesty International – STOP – Telegraph Blogs". The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 27 April 2010.
- "Amnesty International and Jihad". The Wall Street Journal. 14 April 2010. Retrieved 27 April 2010.
- "Roy, Esha, "Ties with Taliban supporter a damage to Amnesty reputation, says Nehru kin", ''Indian Express'', 17 February 2010. Retrieved 15 February 2010". The Indian Express. 17 February 2010. Retrieved 18 March 2010.
- Human rights for All website.
- World Wide Outcry To Make Amnesty International See Reason and Make Amends, Human Rights for All, 22 March 2010
- Kerbaj, Richard (14 February 2010). "Second Amnesty chief attacks Islamist links". The Times. Archived from the original on 10 May 2011. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
- Suroor, Hasan, "Another Amnesty official questions its links with jihadi group ," The Hindu, 15 February 2010. Retrieved 15 February 2010
- "Amnesty misconception". The Sunday Times. 21 February 2010. Archived from the original on 4 June 2011. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
- "'An antidote to Fox': Iran launches English TV channel – Report of Glasgow attack says event staged by Britain to discredit Muslims"
- "Milestones Remembered: Yvonne Ridley". Cageprisoners. 28 March 2010. Retrieved 27 April 2010.
- Victoria Brittain, Dangerous game: a reply to Gita Sahgal and her supporters, openDemocracy.net, 30 June 2010
- Defending Moazzam Begg and Amnesty International, Andy Worthington, 10 February 2010