Ground-level power supply
Ground-level power supply, also known as surface current collection and Alimentation par le Sol (APS, which literally means feeding via the ground), is a modern method of third-rail electrical pick-up for street trams. It was invented for the Bordeaux tramway (Tramway de Bordeaux), which was constructed from 2000 and opened in 2003. Until 2011, this was the only place it was used, with proposals to install it elsewhere. Reims has adopted this technology for its new Reims Tramway (Tramway de Reims), which was opened in 2011, as have Angers (Tramway d'Angers) and Dubai (Al Sufouh Tram).
Ground-level power supply is used, primarily for aesthetic reasons, as an alternative to overhead lines. It is different from the conduit current collection system which was one of the first ways of supplying power to a tram system by burying a third and fourth rail in an underground conduit (‘vault’) between the running rails. Conduit current collection was used in historic tram systems in Washington, Manhattan, Paris, Berlin, Marseilles, Vienna, Budapest and London. It fell into disuse because overhead wires proved much less expensive and troublesome for street railways and because in Manhattan, Paris, Washington and West Berlin all trams were replaced by buses for reasons unrelated to the power supply issue. In Prague on the Charles Bridge (Karlův most) a system invented by František Křižík was used, similar to today's APS.
APS uses a third rail placed between the running rails, divided electrically into ten-metre rail segments with three-metre neutral sections between. Each tram has two power collection shoes, next to which are antennas that send radio signals to energise the power rail segments as the tram passes over them. At any one time, two consecutive segments under the tram will be live.
Use in Bordeaux
Modern ground-level current collection was pioneered by the Bordeaux tramway in France. The public had assumed that the new system would use a traditional conduit system, like that of the Bordeaux trams which ran prior to 1958 and objected when they learned that it was not considered safe and that overhead wires were to be used instead. Facing complaints both from the public and the French Ministry of Culture, planners developed APS as a modern way of replicating the conduit system.
Before use in Bordeaux, APS was tested and proved viable on a short section of reserved-track in the French city of Marseille tramway. Nevertheless, Bordeaux has experienced problems, with APS being so temperamental that, at one stage, the Mayor issued an ultimatum that if reliability could not be guaranteed, it would have to be replaced with overhead wires. Although things have improved, in October 2005 it was announced that 1 km of APS tramway was to be converted to overhead wires.
Problems have included water-logging, when the water does not drain quickly enough after heavy rain.
In other cities
In July 2006, it was announced that two new French tram systems would be using APS over part of their networks. These are Tramway d'Angers and Tramway de Reims, with both systems opening in 2011. A couple of months later, it was announced that Orléans would use APS on a section of its second tram line. The under-construction Al Sufouh Tramway in Dubai will use APS.
Other cities to propose the use of APS include:
- Nice, France (abandoned in favour of nickel metal hydride batteries)
- TRAMMET, Barcelona, Spain
- Western Suburb Line, Beijing
- Gestione Servizio tramviario (GEST), Florence, Italy
- Tramway de Marseille Marseille, France
- Santa Teresa Tram, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
- Al Sufouh Tramway, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
- Tramway de Tours, Tours, France
- Tranvía Cuatro Ríos de Cuenca, Cuenca, Ecuador
- Transport Light Rail, Sydney, Australia
- Kai Tak Tramway, Hong Kong - proposal by opponents of the Environmentally Friendly Linkage System monorail system to use APS instead.
The predecessors of APS (known as Stud contact systems) were developed around 1900, and used by several tramway companies in Paris and in England. Associated with these systems were the inventors Dolter and Diatto.
There were two main differences from APS:
- Power was supplied not from rails but from studs, set in the road at intervals
- Switching in of the contacts was done by strong electromagnets beneath each car. Each contact contained a fuse, which would be blown by an earthed safety shoe on the rear of the tram should the contact not have switched out. This proved to be unsatisfactory because the strong currents melted down the switch contacts, resulting in contacts frequently remaining 'live'.
Another system of ground-level power supply was used by Budapest trams from 1887. Overhead lines were considered an eyesore, so builder Siemens developed the following system: on the inner side of one rail, a powered third rail was hidden underground in a half-covered ditch, with a narrow slit opening upwards, through which a trolley pole reached downward from the trams. The Budapest system was generally safe and water-protected. However, there was no defence against snow and ice, dirt filled up the ditches and trolley poles suffered intense wear. Overhead wire replaced the "Budapest system" everywhere by the 1920s.
Conduit current collection has the power supply carried in a channel under the roadway, between and underneath the running rails, much in the same fashion as the cable for cable cars.
Stream is an acronym that stood for "Sistema di TRasporto Elettrico ad Attrazione Magnetica" ("System of Electric Transport by Magnetic Attraction"). The channel made of composite material was thus insulating the vehicle equipped with a special shoe on the passing magnetic channel raised the band allowing contact with the copper strip and then the electrical connection.
- Post, Robert C. (2007). Urban Mass Transit: The Life Story of a Technology. Greenwood Press. pp. 45–47. ISBN 0-313-33916-3.
- "Third-rail trams across the Garonne". Railway Gazette International. 2004-02-01. Retrieved 2008-05-02.
- "Reims and Angers choose APS". Railway Gazette International. 1 August 2006.
- "Angers tram opens". Railway Gazette International. 29 June 2011.
- "Al Safouh tram project consortium selected". Railway Gazette International. 2008-04-29. Retrieved 2008-05-02.
- "El Consistorio planea un tranvía sin catenaria por la Diagonal". El País. 2008-09-09. Retrieved 2008-10-19.
- "Tours selects Citadis and APS". Railway Gazette International. 2010-09-14.
- Tram Power - A New Method (LRTA)
- Bordeaux: Fronting the French tramway revolution (LRTA)
- More information, images and some sound clips from Bordeaux.
- Official site of the town of Trieste on the Stream
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Alimentation par le sol.|